Analysis of neonatally induced tolerance of H-2 alloantigens

Neonatal inoculation of mice with semi-allogeneic lymphohematopoietic cells produces a state of highly specific allograft tolerance. Phenotypically, by both in vivo and in vitro criteria, antigen-reactive cells specific for the tolerated antigens appear to be clonally deleted from intact, tolerant mice. However, a series of adoptive transfer experiments using mice rendered tolerant of variousH-2 alloantigens revealed that tolerance of Ia (class II) antigens is maintained by a different mechanism than tolerance of K/D (class I) antigens. Long-term acceptance of Ia-disparate grafts by recipients of Ia-tolerant lymphoid cells suggested that an active process (rather than passive clonal deletion) mediates and maintains this type of tolerance. No comparable success was achieved when tolerance of isolated class I or entireH-2 haplotype disparity was examined, suggesting that clonal deletion might be operative in these combinations. Modest prolongation of skin-graft survival was observed in adoptive transfer recipients of lymphoid cells from donors tolerant ofI-JECSD disparity. These data are compatible with the hypothesis that the centralI region (JE) promotes tolerance induction to associated strong IA- and D-region alloantigens by activating a suppression mechanism.With the technical assistance of Phoebe Strome.     

The cellular mechanism of maintenance of neonatally induced tolerance to H-2 class I antigens

We used limiting dilution analysis protocols to investigate the mechanism by which in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) hyporeactivity is maintained in adult mice that had been neonatally tolerized to major histocompatibility complex-encoded antigens. Class I molecules, presented on donor cells having an H-2 K or D region haplotype difference from recipients, readily induce tolerogen-specific CTL hyporeactivity. All attempts to identify any in vitro effects of active suppressive cells operative in the maintenance of this hyporeactivity have been unsuccessful. We conclude that this cytotoxic deficiency is the consequence of in vivo mediated clonal inactivation of the precursors of tolerogen-specific CTL. A presentation and evaluation of the assumptions inherent in this conclusion are made. In contrast to class I molecules, class II molecules, presented on donor cells having an H-2 I region haplotype difference from recipients, are unable to induce tolerogen-specific CTL hyporeactivity, even when injected neonatally at high doses. This inability of class II molecules to induce CTL tolerance parallels the considerable difficulty of inducing helper T lymphocyte tolerance to class II molecules.     

Specific neonatally induced tolerance to Mls locus determinants

Neonatal injection of CBA/HT6T6 (H-2k, Mlsb) mice with adult, Mls-incompatible (CBA/J [H-2k, Mlsd] X CBA/HT6T6)F1 spleen cells results in the abrogation of cell proliferation and interleukin 2 (IL 2) production in bulk mixed lymphocyte cultures, when spleen cells from the inoculated mice are tested at 6 to 8 wk of age with stimulator cells expressing the Mlsd of the tolerizing inoculum. In limiting dilution assays, this tolerant state was manifested in a 25- to 550-fold (280-fold average) decrease in the frequency of precursors of Mlsd-responsive IL 2-producing T cells. Tolerance was specific in that the frequencies of precursors of IL 2-producing cells responding to Con A, allogeneic H-2d, and self-Ia were not affected. The observed low frequency of Mls-responsive cells was due neither to extensive chimerism resulting in the dilution of Mlsd-responsive cells by the nonresponsive F1 cells of the inoculum, nor to the action of suppressor cells. These findings indicate that neonatal injection of Mls-incompatible spleen cells produces a state of specific tolerance by a clonal deletion or inactivation mechanism. This specific tolerance supports the view that 1) the Mls locus encodes or regulates the expression of defined alloantigenic determinants and 2) Mls-incompatible responder mice have specific receptors for Mls determinants on clonally distributed IL 2-producing responder T cells.     

Adaptive transfer of neonatally induced tolerance into normal mice

Neonatally induced tolerance in mice was adoptively transferred with living splenocytes into normal immunocompetent syngeneic adult recipients. It was also transferred passively with antisera from tolerant mice into syngeneic neonatal recipients. Immune splenocytes transferred anamnestic responsiveness rather than tolerance. No free antibody was detected by heat elution from tolerant spleen cells, but it was found in a form complexed with antigen and dissociable with acid. These results together with those reported in the accompanying paper on neonatal tolerance suggest a role for antibody in the induction and maintenance of this model of tolerance.     

Neonatal tolerance of H-2 alloantigens. I. I region modulation of tolerance potential of K and D antigens

By utilizing H-2 congenic strains of mice and appropriate recombinants, it has been possible to determine that Class I alloantigens (of K and D region genes) function poorly as tolerogens when inoculated into neonatal recipients. Alternatively, Class II alloantigens (encoded by I region genes) are excellent tolerogens. Moreover, Class I alloantigens are converted to good tolerogens when conjoined in the tolerizing inoculum with Class II alloantigens. The I subregions in which genes reside that mediate this tolerance-promoting effect are IJ and/or IE. It is suggested that elicitation of a suppressor mechanism, perhaps related to IJ region alloantigens, is responsible.     

H-2 I alloantigens and recall of memory cytotoxic responses

AQR mice were immunized with H-2K and H-2 I encoded alloantigens presented by (Ax6R)F₁ splenocytes. Spleen cells from these alloimmune mice were subsequently restimulated in vitro with B10.A lymphocytes and/or B10.T(6R) lymphocytes, thus presenting them with the immunizing H-2K and H-2 I alloantigens independently. When stimulated with B10.A lymphocytes, alloimmune lymphocytes develop significant cytotoxicity against the immunizing H-2K target antigens. When stimulated with a similar number of B10.T(6R) spleen cells, alloimmune lymphocytes undergo a prominant proliferative response, but develop little, if any, cytotoxicity against the immunizing H-2 K target antigens. The most efficient restimulation of cytotoxicity occurs when the alloimmune spleen cells are simultaneously restimulated by B10.A and B10.T(6R) lymphocytes. Stimulation with the immunizing H-2 I alloantigens alone is not sufficient for regeneration of detectable cytotoxic responses from alloimmune spleen populations. Stimulation with the immunizing H-2K alloantigens alone appears to be both necessary and sufficient to stimulate alloimmune cytotoxic responses. Although the immunizing H-2 I alloantigens are apparently not required to generate alloimmune cytotoxic responses, they markedly potentiate the cytotoxic responses induced by the immunizing H-2K alloantigens.     

Synthesis of surface H-2 alloantigens in murine splenocytes.

The synthesis and turnover of cell surface H-2 alloantigens were studied in murine splenocytes by the anti-H-2-bind method to separate precursor-labeled surface from intracellular molecules. Results indicate that newly synthesized H-2 antigen, labeled in either its peptide or carbohydrate portion enters a relatively small pool of intracellular H-2 antigen and then is rapidly transported to the plasma membrane which represents a larger compartment. The simplest interpretation of these findings is that H-2 antigen is synthesized and transported along a conventional secretory pathway. Pulse-chase experiments indicate that H-2 antigens are not readily chased from the plasma membrane and are not shed or internalized during short-term culture. The aforementioned observations are discussed in terms of a cellular heterogeneity.     

Similarity and difference in the mechanisms of neonatally induced tolerance and cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance in mice

The mechanisms of cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced tolerance were investigated by comparing with those of neonatally induced tolerance. When C3H/He Slc (C3H; H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were given i.v. either AKR/J Sea (AKR; H-2k, Mls-1a) or (AKR x C3H)F1 (AKC3F1; H-2k, Mls-1a/b) spleen cells and treated i.p. with CP 2 days later, a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance to AKR was induced in each case without any signs of graft-vs-host disease (GVHD). However, typical signs of GVHD were observed in the C3H mice neonatally tolerized with AKR spleen cells, but not in those tolerized with AKC3F1 spleen cells. The expression of TCR V beta 6, which is strongly correlated with the reactivity to Mls-1a Ag (of donor AKR origin), in the periphery was quite different between the two types of tolerant C3H mice. Namely, in the lymph nodes of the C3H mice tolerized with AKR spleen cells and CP, only CD4(+)-V beta 6+, but not CD8(+)-V beta 6+, T cells selectively disappeared, whereas both of them were abrogated in the lymph nodes of the C3H mice neonatally tolerized of AKR. By contrast, in the thymus of the two types of tolerant C3H mice, both CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+ single-positive thymocytes expressing TCR V beta 6 were clonally deleted, suggesting that the thymic involvement was the same in each type of tolerance. These results suggest that the preferential disappearance of the CD4(+)-V beta 6+ T cells (of host origin) and the effector T cells of GVHD (of donor origin) occurred only in the periphery of the C3H mice tolerized with AKR spleen cells plus CP and was attributable to the destruction of Ag-stimulated T cells by the CP treatment. In contrast, the intrathymic clonal deletion of immature V beta 6+ T cells was a common mechanism for both of the tolerance induction systems.     

Role of suppressor cells in neonatally induced tolerance to transplantable hepatoma 22A

It was found that adoptive transfer of T lymphocytes from tumor-tolerant ice result in the enhancement of hepatoma 22a growth. This finding suggests an activation of suppressor cells. However, this activation is detectable only in the definite period during the immunologic tolerance induction.     

Abrogation of neonatally induced permanent transplantation tolerance in mice: quantitative aspects.

Neonatal transplantation tolerance was induced in CBA (H-2k) mice by the intravenous injection of 20 million (CBAxA)F1 spleen cells to the transplantation antigens of the A mouse strain. Those mice which carried an A (H-2a) skin allograft without any sign of rejection for at least 120 days, were considered to be permanently tolerant and were selected for further experiments. Abrogation of permanent transplantation tolerance was achieved by injecting the tolerant mice with different doses (50, 100 and 200 millions, respectively) of normal syngeneic (CBA) lymphoid (spleen) cells. Dynamics of the rejection of the test skin allografts tolerated so far revealed well reproducible dose-response curves. Further groups of tolerant CBA mice were given 10, 50, 100, or 200 million "sensitized" (G + 16) CBA spleen cells: "sensitization" by A-skin allografting was performed 16 days before. The sensitized spleen cells abolished the state of tolerance more vigorously and effectively than the normal CBA spleen cells did. In a third group of experiments, the abrogating capacity of 50 million sensitized CBA spleen cells 16, 120, 240, or 360 days after sensitization was compared. The efficacy of the sensitized cells in abolishing the state of tolerance decreased continuously, but, even 360 days after sensitization a remarkably strong immunologic memory was demonstrable. The excellent quantitative correlations found between the number of the injected lymphoid cells and the dynamics of the abrogation of tolerance offer a highly promising new possibility for studying the immunological activity, the immunologic memory, etc., of the different lymphoid cell (sub)populations in performing the transplantation immune reactions.     

H-2 effects on cell-cell interactions in the response to single non-H-2 alloantigens

Individual mice were tested for their proliferative T-cell response to H-Y- and H-3-incompatible stimulator cells in secondary mixed lymphocyte culture. Responders expressing the H-2^bhaplotype were restricted in their response to stimulators presenting H-Y and H-3 in the context of H-2^b. Lymphocytes from individual B10 females proliferated in response to H-Y presented with I-A^band D^b. The ratio of I-A^b/D^b-restricted responses varied between individual responders, indicating significant qualitative variation between genetically identical responders. The majority of the proliferative response in all tested mice was restricted to the entire H-2^bhaplotype suggesting complementation of I-A^b- and D^b-region genes in presenting the H-Y antigen. Similar observations were made in the response of individual B10.LP mice to the H-3 antigen. H-3-specific, proliferating T cells were restricted to H-3 antigen presented with K^bA^band D^bwith significant variation between individuals in their preference for H-3 plus K^bA^band D^b. In contrast to the response to H-Y, the proliferative response to H-3 plus H-2^bcould be accounted for by the summation of the proliferative responses to H-3. plus K^bA^band D^b. These observations demonstrate that the proliferative response to non-H-2 H antigens in the context of I-region determinants is not a sine qua non for the T-cell response to these antigens. Further, the individual qualitative and quantitative variation observed with individual genetically identical mice has strong implications for our knowledge of intrastrain variation in immune responsiveness and the characterization of inbred strains for immune responsiveness.     

Genetic regulation of the antibody response to H-2Db alloantigens in mice

The cytotoxic antibody response to the H-2D^b alloantigen has been investigated in ten strains of the C57BL/10 background. Three types of responses could be distinguished: no detectable response, an IgM response, and an IgG response. The IgG response is influenced by the D and probably the I-A region of the H-2 complex, whereas the IgM response is dependent on the allele for the E chain. The hypothesis is proposed that regulatory T cells, which recognize the antigen in context of self MHC molecules, determine the outcome of an anti-H-2D^b immunization in which the I-E molecule restricts the IgM response and the I-A molecule restricts the IgG response; the D molecule is probably responsible for activation of suppressor T cells which suppress only the IgG response.     

Serological detection of H-2K- and H-2D-gene products. I. Principal difference between T and B lymphocytes in expression of H-2D-encoded alloantigens

Using the fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS II), we have analyzed the expression of H-2K- and H-2D-gene products on the membrane of various cellular components of the murine immune system. Using this serological technique we show a basic difference between T and B lymphocytes. Whereas all cellular components analyzed--hydrocortisone-resistant thymocytes, splenic T and B lymphocytes, macrophages and bone-marrow cells--expressed H-2K-subregion-encoded alloantigens at a high density, it seems that the high density expression of H-2D-encoded alloantigens is restricted mainly to B cells and to macrophages. Hydrocortisone-resistant thymocytes, splenic T lymphocytes and bone-marrow cells, on the other hand, showed significant expression of the H-2D alloantigens only at low membrane density. These results, then, provide evidence for the existence of an imbalance in serologically detectable expression of H-2K- and H-2D-region-gene products on the cell membrane of various cells comprising the murine immune system.     

Isolation and analysis of H-2 and Ia alloantigens from wild mouse strains.

Immunoprecipitation and SDS-PAGE analysis were used to examine H-2 and Ia antigens from mouse strains with wild-derived MHC haplotypes. Antisera raised against the wild-derived strains contained anti-H-2 and anti-Ia antibodies which precipitated antigen molecules readily distinguishable by a single assay procedure. The antibodies to wild strains were cross-reactive with standard laboratory haplotypes. Evidence supporting the similar genetic organization of wild and standard haplotypes was found, including isolation of separate H-2K and H-2D molecules from a wild-derived strain, and isolation of two separate Ia molecules from a wild-derived strain.