Model systems of invertebrate allorecognition

Nearly all colonial marine invertebrates are capable of allorecognition--the ability to distinguish between self and genetically distinct members of the same species. When two or more colonies grow into contact, they either reject each other and compete for the contested space or fuse and form a single, chimeric colony. The specificity of this response is conferred by genetic systems that restrict fusion to self and close kin. Two selective pressures, intraspecific spatial competition between whole colonies and competition between stem cells for access to the germline in fused chimeras, are thought to drive the evolution of extensive polymorphism at invertebrate allorecognition loci. After decades of study, genes controlling allorecognition have been identified in two model systems, the protochordate Botryllus schlosseri and the cnidarian Hydractinia symbiolongicarpus. In both species, allorecognition specificity is determined by highly polymorphic cell-surface molecules, encoded by the fuhc and fester genes in Botryllus, and by the alr1 and alr2 genes in Hydractinia. Here we review allorecognition phenomena in both systems, summarizing recent molecular advances, comparing and contrasting the life history traits that shape the evolution of these distinct allorecognition systems, and highlighting questions that remain open in the field.     

Pattern of settlement and natural chimerism in the colonial urochordate Botryllus schlosseri

Colonies of the cosmopolitan urochordate Botryllus schlosseri that share one or both alleles at a single allorecognition locus (Fu/HC) and come into tissue contacts, may fuse and form a mixed entity, a chimera. Botryllus populations worldwide exhibit unprecedented extensive polymorphism at this locus, a result that restricts fusions to kin encounters. This study aims to compare spatiotemporal configurations in source and introduced B. schlosseri populations, residing on natural and man-made substrata, respectively. By using four microsatellite loci, we tested genetic consanguinity of colonies settled naturally along spatial vectors on both, natural (native populations) and man-made (introduced) substrates. Four populations were studied. Results revealed that B. schlosseri colonies, on both substrate types, assemble in groups of relatives that share similar microsatellite profiles. We suggest that this pattern of settlement promotes the formation of chimeras, which evoke conflicting interactions: cooperation between different somatic cell lines that constitute the colonial soma and competition between germ cells that inhabit the chimera gonads. Under natural conditions, the chimera may allow genetic flexibility that depends on joint genomic fitness of its partners. This is probably one of the life history characteristics that led to the worldwide distribution success of this species.     

Tunic cell populations during fusion events in the colonial ascidian Didemnum vexillum (Tunicata)

We documented changes in the abundance and distribution patterns of tunic cells involved in the allorecognition response of the colonial aplousobranch Didemnum vexillum, whose zooids do not share a common vascular system. A histological examination of the fusion zone of isogeneic (CIAs) and allogeneic (CAAs) fused colony assays revealed that tunic cuticles were rapidly regenerated. The underlying tunic matrix fused readily in all assays and controls. We identified four different types of tunic cells. Phagocytic cells represented the most abundant cell type in allogeneic fusions, followed by morula cells. These cells were more abundant at the immediate fusion junction than at 120 μm or 240 μm from the junction, most likely because they mediate the allorecognition reaction. Elongated filopodial cells also were present, although only at very low abundances, and a layer of bladder cells was located immediately below the cuticle. Our results provide quantitative evidence for the involvement of tunic cells in the allorecognition response of a highly invasive ascidian.     

The ontogeny of allorecognition in a colonial hydroid and the fate of early established chimeras

Colonies of the marine hydroid, Hydractinia, are able to discriminate between their own tissues and those belonging to unrelated conspecifics. We have studied the ontogeny of this allorecognition system by a series of allogeneic transplantations along a developmental gradient, including two-cell-stage embryos, 8 h morulae, planula larvae and metamorphosed polyps. Allograft acceptance of incompatible tissue was observed in all embryonic and larval stages, whereas metamorphosed polyps rejected incompatible transplanted allografts. Most of the chimeras established at the two-cell-stage, although composed of two allogeneic, incompatible entities with mismatching allorecognition loci, developed normally and remained stable through metamorphosis. The results of post metamorphic transplantation assays among the chimeras and the naive ramets, suggested that both incompatible genotypes were still represented in the chimera despite the onset of alloimmune maturation. The naive colonies always rejected each other. Chimeras established from later embryonic and larval stages did not develop into adult chimeric entities, but rather separated immediately post metamorphosis. We thus show that (1) allorecognition in this species matures during metamorphosis and (2) genetically incompatible entities may coexist in one immunologically mature, chimeric soma, provided that they were grafted early enough in ontogeny.     

Studies on Japanese botryllid ascidians. II. A new species of the genus Botryllus from the vicinity of Shimoda

Morphology and life history of a new species of the genus Botryllus belonging to the family Botryllidae were described in detail. This ascidian was collected from the stony shore in the vicinity of Shimoda (Shizuoka prefecture, Japan). The arrangement of ovary and testis in this ascidian was the same as that in other species of the genus Botryllus, while the embryo developed in a brood pouch formed from the invagination of peribranchial epithelium, as in the other genus Botrylloides. The processes and features of the allorecognition reaction of this ascidian were observed. The reaction showed the same processes as that in the species of the genus Botrylloides. Therefore, this ascidian has both features of the two genera of the family Botryllidae, which strongly suggests the necessity of reconsidering on the classificatory criteria of botryllid ascidians.     

Natural chimerism in colonial urochordates

Natural chimeras are commonly distributed in the wild, challenging the traditional paradigm for the advantages of genetically homogenous entities, where uniclonality prevents within-organism conflicts. This essay focuses on the last two-decade studies on chimerism in the cosmopolitan urochordate Botryllus schlosseri, enlightening and focusing the idea of multichimeras as a primary tool for fending off the pervasiveness of super parasitic germ lines. Interacting Botryllus colonies may fuse or reject each other based on allelic compatibility on a single highly polymorphic gene locus. After fusion and establishment of a chimera, a second tier of allorecognition is developed, expressed as genetically controlled morphological resorption of one of the chimeric partners. This is followed by the third tier of allorecognition where somatic and germ cell lineages parasitism are developed. Studies revealed a complex network of costs and few suggested benefits for the state of chimerism in botryllid ascidians. Two life history traits (diversification of allorecognition allele repertoire, colonial programmed lifespan) were considered as selected to combat the major cost of chimeric associated germ cell parasitism. Three other ecological traits (heterosis, settlement of kin larvae in aggregates, multichimerism) have been suggested as selected to enhance the existence of chimerism in botryllid ascidians. Recent results revealing a fine-tuning of the chimerical somatic genetic components in response to changes in environmental conditions are discussed. Results further elucidate the possible existence of multichimeras, each made of several genotypes. It is proposed that natural multichimeras form more stable and vigorous entities, depicting a unique way for domesticating consortia of selfish cells that may otherwise seriously threaten survivorship of the entity.     

Allorecognition polymorphism versus parasitic stem cells

Allorecognition--the ability of an individual to distinguish between self and non-self cells and tissues--ultimately depends on the presence of highly polymorphic gene(s). Allorecognition loci are the most diverse ever described, with tens to hundreds of alleles observed in a population. An unresolved problem in population genetics lies in understanding the origins, accumulation and maintenance of this extensive polymorphism, often over millions of years and across multiple speciation events. Botryllus schlosseri, a primitive chordate, has a life history that links several components of allorecognition from disparate fields that are experimentally accessible. This review outlines these traits and discusses some of the puzzling aspects of allorecognition in Botryllus that might contribute to understanding the evolution of these extraordinary polymorphisms.     

Identification of the endostyle as a stem cell niche in a colonial chordate

Stem cell populations exist in "niches" that hold them and regulate their fate decisions. Identification and characterization of these niches is essential for understanding stem cell maintenance and tissue regeneration. Here we report on the identification of a novel stem cell niche in Botryllus schlosseri, a colonial urochordate with high stem cell-mediated developmental activities. Using in vivo cell labeling, engraftment, confocal microscopy, and time-lapse imaging, we have identified cells with stemness capabilities in the anterior ventral region of the Botryllus' endostyle. These cells proliferate and migrate to regenerating organs in developing buds and buds of chimeric partners but do not contribute to the germ line. When cells are transplanted from the endostyle region, they contribute to tissue development and induce long-term chimerism in allogeneic tissues. In contrast, cells from other Botryllus' regions do not show comparable stemness capabilities. Cumulatively, these results define the Botryllus' endostyle region as an adult somatic stem cell niche.     

Effects of allogeneic contact on life-history traits of the colonial ascidian Botryllus schlosseri in Monterey Bay

The formation of chimeric colonies following allogeneic contact between benthic invertebrates may strongly affect colony fitness. Here we show that, in a field population of the colonial ascidian Botryllus schlosseri in Monterey Bay, California, more than 20% of all colonies occur in allogeneic contact with conspecifics. We experimentally assessed the effects of allogeneic contact on the following life-history traits under natural field conditions: growth, age and size at first reproduction, and egg production (fecundity). When compared with isolated colonies, and in some cohorts also with colonies that rejected allogeneic neighbors, colonies that fused with neighbors incurred reduced fitness in terms of most life-history traits measured. We propose that one of the benefits of precise allorecognition is that, in fused colonies, it limits the unit of selection to chimeric individuals composed of closely related kin.     

The importance of life-history stage and individual variation in the allorecognition system of a marine sponge

In marine invertebrates with complex life cycles, it may often be the case that trade-offs and behaviors differ between adult and larval stages. In this study, I examined the effects of life-history stage on allorecognition system function in the sponge, Haliclona sp. For sedentary marine invertebrates, allorecognition systems allow individuals to distinguish between genetically similar and distinct tissue they may encounter and are thought to reduce costly tissue fusion with individuals other than self or kin. Although it was found that sessile adults fused preferentially with self-tissue and exhibited a functioning allorecognition system, free-swimming larvae fused equally with sibling and non-sibling larvae resulting in swimming chimeras capable of successful metamorphosis, suggesting a stage-activated allorecognition system. In addition, adult sponges differed significantly in the propensity of their larvae to fuse suggesting variation in parental strategies. Analysis of larval swimming behavior indicated that larvae aggregate and are capable of increasing their encounters with other larvae and perhaps their probability of fusing in nature. The pursuit of fusion at this motile stage, along with evidence of a functioning adult allorecognition system, suggests that larvae may not express a recognition system, or that factors other than relatedness such as benefits to larval or adult chimeras, are involved in larval fusion and a stage-activated allorecognition system. In addition, this study demonstrates the presence of variation among individuals in the allorecognition system's ontogeny in the sponge Haliclona sp.     

Studies on Japanese Botryllid Ascidians. III. A new species of the genus Botryllus with a vivid colony color from the vicinity of Shimoda

The morphology and life history of a new species of the genus Botryllus belonging to the family Botryllidae are described in detail. This ascidian was collected from the stony shore in the cove near Shimoda Marine Research Center, University of Tsukuba (Shimoda, Shizuoka Prefecture, Japan). The ascidian colony was easily distinguished from colonies of other botryllids because it was very thin and bright pink in color. The arrangement of ovary and testis in this ascidian was the same as that in other species of the genus Botryllus. This ascidian was prolific, with 1-5 embryos on each side of a zooid, and the embryos of this ascidian developed in the peribranchial cavity without any brooding organs as in Botryllus scalaris. We observed the processes and features of the allorecognition reaction in colony specificity and found that allorejection occurred after fusion of the vascular system between two incompatible colonies. This manner of allorejection is also shown in B. scalaris and Botryllus delicatus; however, the reaction speed of allorejection is faster than that of B. delicatus and similar to that of B. scalaris. These results indicate that this ascidian might be closely related to B. scalaris.     

Germ cell parasitism as an ecological and evolutionary puzzle: hitchhiking with positively selected genotypes

The phenomenon of intraspecific germ cell parasitism may reveal a theoretical puzzle to the concept of Darwinian selection. In natural chimeras of the colonial protochordate Botryllus schlosseri , parasitic germ lines hitchhike with positively selected allogeneic soma, passing throughout successive generations without being visible to natural selection forces. This may cause the possible development of super-parasitic entities, specialized in allogeneic invasion and germ cell parasitism. Three evolutionary selected mechanisms (diversification of fusibility allele repertoire, the establishment of multichimeric entities, induction of programmed life spans) reduce opportunities for parasitic forms to hitchhike to a high frequency with selected genotypes, and may shape, on the other hand, more benign germ cell parasitic forms that share overlapping future expectations with their hosts. These benign forms are expected to contribute cells for somatic functions, forming entities with fitness that depends on joint genomic fitness of the partners. Population-level feedback thus may stabilize chimeric entities, shaping the evolution of chimerism.     

Allorecognition and xenorecognition in reef corals: a decade of interactions

Xenorecognition phenomena in coral reefs are expressed by a striking array of morphological and cytological responses. Corals encountering conspecifics further elicit additional repertoires of effector mechanisms, specific to allogeneic challenges. Both inducible sets of antagonistic machineries of allo- and xenoresponses are highly specific. In many cases, they are predictable, reproducible, and reveal the hallmark of coral tissue capacity to distinguish between self and non-self. This essay summarizes a decade (1992 –2002) of published results on reef coral immune features. While studies on xenorecognition uncovered the existence of established, non-transitive hierarchies and the importance of antibacterial/cytotoxic compounds secreted by corals, allorecognition assays disclosed the presence of specific and complex non-transitive hierarchies dictated by the expression of a variety of effector mechanisms (‘tailored’ against different conspecifics), the existence of gradual maturation of alloresponses (important in the formation of natural chimeras), the debatable issue of allorecognition memory, and the appearance of delayed, second sets of alloresponses. A critical evaluation of historecognition reveals that expressed responses in different coral systems are phenotypically matched with counterpart outcomes recorded in the mammalian immune systems. Histocompatibility in corals, as in vertebrates, relies on recognition elements (not yet disclosed on the molecular level) as well as on effector mechanisms.     

The hydroid Hydractinia: a versatile, informative cnidarian representative

The Cnidaria represent the most ancient eumetazoan phylum. Members of this group possess typical animal cells and tissues such as sensory cells, nerve cells, muscle cells and epithelia. Due to their unique phylogenetic position, cnidarians have traditionally been used as a reference group in various comparative studies. We propose the colonial marine hydroid, Hydractinia, as a convenient, versatile platform for basic and applied research in developmental biology, reproduction, immunology, environmental studies and more. In addition to being a typical cnidarian representative, Hydractinia offers many practical and theoretical advantages: studies that are feasible in Hydra like regeneration, pattern regulation, and cell renewal from stem cells, can be supplemented by genetic analyses and classical embryology in Hydractinia. Metamorphosis of the planula larva of Hydractinia can be used as a model for cell activation and communication and the presence of a genetically controlled allorecognition system makes it a suitable model for comparative immunology. Most importantly, Hydractinia may be manipulated at most aspects of its (short) life cycle. It has already been the subject of many studies in various disciplines, some of which are discussed in this essay.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes show HLA-C-restricted recognition of EBV-bearing cells and allorecognition of HLA class I molecules presenting self-peptides.

Human CTL have been isolated that show self-restricted recognition of autologous lymphoblastoid cell lines and allorecognition. The lymphoblastoid cell line ligand most likely used a peptide that is expressed in EBV-bearing cells when the virus enters the lytic cycle. This peptide is presented to CD8+ CTL by HLA-Cw7 molecules. The allogeneic ligand recognized on non-EBV-infected cells is composed of a class I glycoprotein and a naturally selected self-peptide. In previous studies we demonstrated that this ligand is determined by two MHC-linked genes: one gene encodes the allogeneic class I molecule whereas the other controls the self-peptide. Despite the use of different peptides and different class I molecules, seemingly equivalent structures are formed that enable these two ligands to function as antigenic mimics of each other. CTL with the same patterns of dual specificity could be isolated from four unrelated donors, indicating that HLA-Cw7 is frequently involved in self-restricted recognition of EBV-harboring cells. Such CTL could help not only to contain lytic virus during a primary infection but also may be maintained life-long to eliminate cells in which reactivated virus appears.     

Primary and secondary immunocompetence in mixed allogeneic chimeras

Targeted disruption of T cell costimulatory pathways, particularly CD28 and CD40, has allowed for the development of minimally myeloablative strategies for the induction of mixed allogeneic chimerism and donor-specific tolerance across full MHC barriers. In this study we analyze in depth the ability of mixed allogeneic chimeras in two strain combinations to mount effective host-restricted and donor-restricted antiviral CD4 and CD8 responses, as well as the impact of development of mixed chimerism on the maintenance of pre-existing memory populations. While antiviral CD8 responses in mixed chimeras following acute viral infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus Armstrong or vaccinia virus are largely host-restricted, donor-restricted CD8 responses as well as host- and donor-restricted CD4 responses are also readily detected, and virus is promptly cleared. We further demonstrate that selection of donor-restricted T cells in mixed chimeras is principally mediated by bone marrow-derived cells in the thymus. Conversely, we find that mixed chimeras exhibit a deficit in their ability to deal with a chronic lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus clone 13 infection. Encouragingly, pre-existing memory populations are largely unaffected by the development of high level mixed chimerism and maintain the ability to control viral rechallenge. Our results suggest that while pre-existing T cell memory and primary immunocompetence to acute infection are preserved in mixed allogeneic chimeras, MHC class I and/or class II tissue matching may be required to fully preserve immunocompetence in dealing with chronic viral infections.     

Vascular endothelium does not activate CD4+ direct allorecognition in graft rejection

Expression of MHC class II by donor-derived APCs has been shown to be important for allograft rejection. It remains controversial, however, whether nonhemopoietic cells, such as vascular endothelium, possess Ag-presenting capacity to activate alloreactive CD4(+) T lymphocytes. This issue is important in transplantation, because, unlike hemopoietic APCs, allogeneic vascular endothelium remains present for the life of the organ. In this study we report that cytokine-activated vascular endothelial cells are poor APCs for allogeneic CD4(+) T lymphocytes in vitro and in vivo despite surface expression of MHC class II. Our in vitro observations were extended to an in vivo model of allograft rejection. We have separated the allostimulatory capacity of endothelium from that of hemopoietic APCs by using bone marrow chimeras. Hearts that express MHC class II on hemopoietic APCs are acutely rejected in a mean of 7 days regardless of the expression of MHC class II on graft endothelium. Alternatively, hearts that lack MHC class II on hemopoietic APCs are acutely rejected at a significantly delayed tempo regardless of the expression of MHC class II on graft endothelium. Our data suggest that vascular endothelium does not play an important role in CD4(+) direct allorecognition and thus does not contribute to the vigor of acute rejection.     

Growth and long-term somatic and germline chimerism following fusion of juvenile Botryllus schlosseri

The colonial ascidian Botryllus schlosseri undergoes a histocompatibility reaction that can result in vascular fusion of distinct genotypes, creating a chimera. Chimerism has both potential benefits, such as an immediate increase in size that may enhance growth rates, and costs. For the latter, the presence of multiple genotypes in a chimera can lead to competition between genetically distinct stem cell lineages, resulting in complete replacement of somatic and germline tissues by a single genotype. Although fusion can occur at any point after metamorphosis, previous studies have focused on chimeras created from sexually mature adults, where no benefit to chimerism has been documented. Here we focus on the costs and benefits of fusion between juveniles, characterizing growth rates and patterns of somatic and germline chimerism after natural and controlled fusion events. We also compared outcomes between low- and high-density growth conditions, the latter more likely representative of what occurs in natural populations. We found that growth rates were density-dependent, and that only chimeras grew under high-density conditions. We also observed a positional component to a post-fusion event called resorption, indicating that extrinsic factors were important in this process. Patterns of germline and somatic chimerism and dominance in chimeras made from fused juveniles were equivalent to those after fusion of sexually mature adults, and there were no age-related differences in these processes. Finally, by using genetic markers that could retrospectively assign genotypes, we also found that the majority of individual testes in a chimera were clonally derived.     

EVIDENCE FOR SELECTION ON A CHORDATE HISTOCOMPATIBILITY LOCUS

Allorecognition is the ability of an organism to differentiate self or close relatives from unrelated individuals. The best known applications of allorecognition are the prevention of inbreeding in hermaphroditic species (e.g., the self‐incompatibility [SI] systems in plants), the vertebrate immune response to foreign antigens mediated by MHC loci, and somatic fusion, where two genetically independent individuals physically join to become a chimera. In the few model systems where the loci governing allorecognition outcomes have been identified, the corresponding proteins have exhibited exceptional polymorphism. But information about the evolution of this polymorphism outside MHC is limited. We address this subject in the ascidian Botryllus schlosseri, where allorecognition outcomes are determined by a single locus, called FuHC (Fusion/HistoCompatibility). Molecular variation in FuHC is distributed almost entirely within populations, with very little evidence for differentiation among different populations. Mutation plays a larger role than recombination in the creation of FuHC polymorphism. A selection statistic, neutrality tests, and distribution of variation within and among different populations all provide evidence for selection acting on FuHC, but are not in agreement as to whether the selection is balancing or directional.