Accessibility and Structural Role of Histone Domains in Chromatin. Biophysical and Immunochemical Studies of Progressive Digestion with Immobilized Proteases

Abstract

The accessibility and role of histone regions in chromatin fibres were investigated using limited proteolysis with enzymes covalently bound to collagen membranes. The changes in chromatin conformation and condensation monitored by various biophysical methods, were correlated to the degradation of the histone proteins revealed by antibodies specific for histones and histone peptides.

Upon digestion with trypsin and subtilisin, chromatin undergoes successive structural transitions. The cleavage of the C-terminal domains of Hl, H2A and H2B, and of the N-terminal tail of H3 led to a decondensation of chromatin fibres, indicated by increases in electric birefringence and orientational relaxation times. It corresponds to a 15% increase in linear dimensions. The degradation of the other terminal regions of histones H3, H2A and H2B resulted in the appearance of hinge points between nucleosomes without alteration of the overall orientation of polynucleosome chains. Despite the loss of all the basic domains of HI, H3, H2A and H2B, no significant change in DNA-protein interactions occurred, suggesting that most of these protease-accessible regions interact weakly, if at all, with DNA in chromatin. Further proteolysis led to H4 degradation and other additional cleavages of Hl, H2B and H3. This caused the relaxation of no more than 8% of the total DNA but resulted in changes in the ability of chromatin to condense at high ionic strength. More extensive digestion resulted in a total unravelling of nucleosomal chains which acquired properties similar to those of Hl- depleted chromatin, although the globular part of HI was still present.

The data suggest that histone-histone interactions between HI and core histone domains play a central role in stabilizing the chromatin fibres, and cuts in H3, H2A and H2B as well as HI, seem necessary for chromatin expansion. On the contrary, H4 might be involved in the stabilization of nucleosomes only.     

Subunit structure of simian-virus-40 minichromosome.

Electron microscopic evidence indicates that Simian virus 40 (SV40) minichromosomes extracted from infected cells consist of 20 +/- 2 nucleosomes, each containing 190 -- 200 base pairs of DNA. About 50% of the nucleosomes are not close together, but connected by segments of DNA of irregular lengths which correspond to about 15% of the viral genome, irrespective of the ionic strength. Micrococcal nuclease digestion studies show that there is about 200 base pairs of DNA in the biochemical unit of SV40 chromatin. Therefore, the visible internucleosomal DNA of the SV40 minichromosome does not arise from an unfolding of a fraction of the 190 - 200 base pairs of DNA initially wound in the nucleosome. These results support the chromatin model which proposes that the same DNA length is contained in the nucleosome and the biochemical unit. Results from extensive micrococcal nuclease digestion suggest that an SV40 nucleosome consists of a 'core' containing a DNA segment of about 135 base pairs associated to a DNA fragment more susceptible to nuclease attack. The addition of histone H1 results in a striking condensation of the SV40 minichromosome, which supports the assumption that histone H1 is involved in the folding of chromatin fibers.     

Nucleosome DNA repeat length and histone complement in a fungus exhibiting condensed chromatin

Fungal chromatins are reported to exhibit unusually short nucleosomal DNA repeat lengths. To test whether this is a phylogenetic feature of fungi or rather is correlated with an apparent absence of condensed chromatin in the organisms studied, we have examined the chromatin organization and the complement of basic nuclear proteins in the fungus Entomophthora, an organism which exhibits marked chromatin condensation. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of Entomophthora chromatin revealed a nucleosomal DNA repeat length of 197 +/- 1.2 base pairs (bp). This repeat length is 20-40 bp longer than that reported for any fungus. Entomophthora nucleosomes exhibited an HI-like protein which was much less basic than the HI histones reported for higher eukaryotes but which was similar in basicity to the HI histone reported for the fungus Neurospora. However, the nucleosomal DNA repeat length of Neurospora chromatin is reported to be unusually short, whereas that of Entomophthora was found to be typical of the repeat lengths observed for chromatins of higher eukaryotes. Thus, repeat length, at least in fungi, would not appear to be directly determined by the basicity of the fungal cognate of histone HI.     

Unravelled nucleosomes,nucleosome beads and higher order structures of chromatin: Influence of non-histone components and histone H1

Effects of non-histone components and histone H1 on the morphology of nucleosomes and chromatin were studied by electron microscopy. Soluble rat liver ehromatin was depleted of non-histone components [NH]or non-histone components and H1 [NH and H1] by dissociation and subsequent fractionation in sucrose gradients in the presence of 300 to 350 mm or 500 mm-NaCl, respectively. In reconstitution experiments the depleted samples were mixed either with [NH] or with [NH and H1] or with purified H1. The morphology of the ionic strength-dependent condensation of the samples was monitored by electron microscopy using 0 mm to 100 mm-NaCl. Based on the appearance of the different types of fibres in very low salt (0 mm up to 10 mm-NaCl), namely the zigzag-shaped, the beads-on-a-string or the DNA-like filaments, it is possible to distinguish between nucleosomes, partially unravelled nucleosomes and unravelled nucleosomes, respectively. Only those fibres which were zigzag-shaped at low ionic strength condense at increasing ionic strength into higher order structures of compact fibres. We demonstrate the dependence of the appearance of nucleosomes and chromatin upon its composition and upon the ionic strength of the solvent.[NH] have no detectable influence upon the formation of higher order chromatin structures, but they can prevent the unravelling of nucleosomes at very low ionic strength, presumably by charge shielding.For the appearance of zigzag-shaped fibres and for the condensation into compact fibres with increasing ionic strength, H1 must be present in about native amounts. Partial removal of H1 (about 10%) promotes a change from fibres into tangles. This supports the model that an H1 polymer is stabilizing the higher order chromatin structures.Reconstitution experiments with purified H1 regenerated fibres containing all the features of [NH]-depleted chromatin. Reconstitution experiments with [NH and H1] promoted fibres compatible with control chromatin. Overloading of chromatin with H1 led to additional condensation. The detailed morphology of the reconstituted fibres showed local distortions. One possibility explaining these local distortions would be competition between “main” and “additional” binding sites for histone H1.     

Closely spaced nucleosome cores in reconstituted histone.DNA complexes and histone-H1-depleted chromatin

It has been demonstrated by digestion studies with micrococcal nuclease that reconstitution of complexes from DNA and a mixture of the four small calf thymus histones H2A, H2B, H3, and H4 leads to subunits closely spaced in a 137 +/- 7-nucleotide-pair register. Subunits isolated from the reconstituted complex contain nearly equimolar amounts of the four histones and sediment at 11.6S. On DNase I digestion both the reconstituted complex and the separated subunits gave rise to series of single-stranded DNA fragments with a 10-nucleotide periodicity. This indicates that the reconstitution leads to subunits very similar to nucleosome cores. Nucleosome cores closely spaced in a 140-nucleotide-pair register were also obtained upon removal of histone H1 from chromatin by dissociation with 0.63 M NaCl and subsequent ultracentrifugation. In reconstitution experiments with all five histones (including histone H1) our procedure did not lead to tandemly arranged nucleosomes containing about 200 nucleotide pairs of DNA. In the presence of EDTA, DNase II cleaved calf thymus nuclei and chromatin at about 200-nucleotide-pair intervals whereas in the presence of Mg2+ cleavage at intervals of approximately half this size was observed. The change in the nature of the cleavage pattern, however, was no longer found after removal of histone H1 from chromatin. This indicates that H1 influences the accessibility of DNase II cleavage sites in chromatin. This finding is discussed with respect to the influence of histone H1 on chromatin superstructure.     

Accessibility and structural role of histone domains in chromatin. biophysical and immunochemical studies of progressive digestion with immobilized proteases

The accessibility and role of histone regions in chromatin fibres were investigated using limited proteolysis with enzymes covalently bound to collagen membranes. The changes in chromatin conformation and condensation monitored by various biophysical methods, were correlated to the degradation of the histone proteins revealed by antibodies specific for histones and histone peptides. Upon digestion with trypsin and subtilisin, chromatin undergoes successive structural transitions. The cleavage of the C-terminal domains of H1, H2A and H2B, and of the N-terminal tail of H3 led to a decondensation of chromatin fibres, indicated by increases in electric birefringence and orientational relaxation times. It corresponds to a 15% increase in linear dimensions. The degradation of the other terminal regions of histones H3, H2A and H2B resulted in the appearance of hinge points between nucleosomes without alteration of the overall orientation of polynucleosome chains. Despite the loss of all the basic domains of H1, H3, H2A and H2B, no significant change in DNA-protein interactions occurred, suggesting that most of these protease-accessible regions interact weakly, if at all, with DNA in chromatin. Further proteolysis led to H4 degradation and other additional cleavages of H1, H2B and H3. This caused the relaxation of no more than 8% of the total DNA but resulted in changes in the ability of chromatin to condense at high ionic strength. More extensive digestion resulted in a total unravelling of nucleosomal chains which acquired properties similar to those of H1-depleted chromatin, although the globular part of H1 was still present. The data suggest that histone-histone interactions between H1 and core histone domains play a central role in stabilizing the chromatin fibres, and cuts in H3, H2A and H2B as well as H1, seem necessary for chromatin expansion. On the contrary, H4 might be involved in the stabilization of nucleosomes only.     

Influence of histone acetylation on the solubility, H1 content and DNase I sensitivity of newly assembled chromatin.

In a previous report [Annunziato, A.T. and Seale, R.L. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258:12675] a novel intermediate in chromatin assembly was described (detected by labeling new DNA in the presence of the deacetylase inhibitor sodium butyrate), which retained approximately 50% of the heightened sensitivity of newly replicated chromatin to DNaseI. It is now reported that nucleosomes replicated in butyrate are considerably more soluble in the presence of magnesium, relative to chromatin replicated under control conditions, and that this heightened magnesium-solubility is reflected in a concomitant increase in the preferential solubility of nucleosomes containing newly synthesized core histones. This differential solubility was accompanied by a 5- to 6-fold depletion of histone H1, and was completely abolished by the selective removal of H1 from isolated nuclei. The removal of H1 also markedly reduced the preferential DNaseI sensitivity of chromatin replicated in butyrate. Further, when mononucleosomes of control and (acetylated) nascent chromatin were compared, no differences in DNaseI sensitivity were detected. These results provide evidence that the interactions between newly assembled nucleosomes and histone H1 are altered when histone deacetylation is inhibited during chromatin replication, and suggest a mechanism for the control of H1 deposition during nucleosome assembly in vivo.     

Histone variant Htz1 promotes histone H3 acetylation to enhance nucleotide excision repair in Htz1 nucleosomes

Nucleotide excision repair (NER) is critical for maintaining genome integrity. How chromatin dynamics are regulated to facilitate this process in chromatin is still under exploration. We show here that a histone H2A variant, Htz1 (H2A.Z), in nucleosomes has a positive function in promoting efficient NER in yeast. Htz1 inherently enhances the occupancy of the histone acetyltransferase Gcn5 on chromatin to promote histone H3 acetylation after UV irradiation. Consequently, this results in an increased binding of a NER protein, Rad14, to damaged DNA. Cells without Htz1 show increased UV sensitivity and defective removal of UV-induced DNA damage in the Htz1-bearing nucleosomes at the repressed MFA2 promoter, but not in the HMRa locus where Htz1 is normally absent. Thus, the effect of Htz1 on NER is specifically relevant to its presence in chromatin within a damaged region. The chromatin accessibility to micrococcal nuclease in the MFA2 promoter is unaffected by HTZ1 deletion. Acetylation on previously identified lysines of Htz1 plays little role in NER or cell survival after UV. In summary, we have identified a novel aspect of chromatin that regulates efficient NER, and we provide a model for how Htz1 influences NER in Htz1 nucleosomes.     

Electron microscopic and biochemical evidence that chromatin structure is a repeating unit

Electron microscopic and biochemical studies demonstrate that the fundamental structure of chromatin depleted of lysine-rich histones is composed of a flexible chain of spherical particles (nucleosomes), about 125 Å in diameter, connected by DNA filaments. Such a chromatin preparation can be separated by centrifugation into two fractions which differ in the spacing of the nucleosomes. In one fraction almost all of the DNA is condensed in nucleosomes, while the other fraction contains long stretches of free DNA connecting regions where the nucleosomes are closely packed. The isolated nucleosomes contain about 200 base pairs of DNA and the four histones F2a₁, F2a₂, and F2b, and F3 in an overall histone/DNA ratio of 0.97. In such a structure the DNA is compacted slightly more than five times from its extended length. The same basic structure can be visualized in chromatin spilling out of lysed nuclei. However, in this latter case the nucleosomes are very closely packed, suggesting that histone F1 is involved in the superpacking of DNA in chromosomes and nuclei. The chromatin fiber appears to be a self-assembling structure, since the nucleosomal arrangement can be reconstituted in vitro from DNA and the four histones F2a₁, F2a₂, F2b and F3 only, irrespective of their cellular origin.     

The core histone tail domains contribute to sequence-dependent nucleosome positioning

The precise positioning of nucleosomes plays a critical role in the regulation of gene expression by modulating the DNA binding activity of trans-acting factors. However, molecular determinants responsible for positioning are not well understood. We examined whether the removal of the core histone tail domains from nucleosomes reconstituted with specific DNA fragments led to alteration of translational positions. Remarkably, we find that removal of tail domains from a nucleosome assembled on a DNA fragment containing a Xenopus borealis somatic-type 5S RNA gene results in repositioning of nucleosomes along the DNA, including two related major translational positions that move about 20 bp further upstream with respect to the 5S gene. In a nucleosome reconstituted with a DNA fragment containing the promoter of a Drosophila alcohol dehydrogenase gene, several translational positions shifted by about 10 bp along the DNA upon tail removal. However, the positions of nucleosomes assembled with a DNA fragment known to have one of the highest binding affinities for core histone proteins in the mouse genome were not altered by removal of core histone tail domains. Our data support the notion that the basic tail domains bind to nucleosomal DNA and influence the selection of the translational position of nucleosomes and that once tails are removed movement between translational positions occurs in a facile manner on some sequences. However, the effect of the N-terminal tails on the positioning and movement of a nucleosome appears to be dependent on the DNA sequence such that the contribution of the tails can be masked by very high affinity DNA sequences. Our results suggest a mechanism whereby sequence-dependent nucleosome positioning can be specifically altered by regulated changes in histone tail-DNA interactions in chromatin.     

Histone phosphorylation in native chromatin induces local structural changes as probed by electric birefringence

In order to understand how the phosphorylation of histones affects the chromatin structure, we used electron microscopy, sedimentation velocity, circular dichroism and electric birefringence to monitor the salt-induced filament reversible solenoid transition of phosphorylated and native chromatin. Phosphorylation in vitro of chicken erythrocyte chromatin by cyclic-AMP-dependent protein kinase from porcine heart led to the modification of the histones H3 and H5 only, which were modified at a level of one phosphate and about three phosphate groups per molecule, respectively. In contrast to circular dichroism and sedimentation studies, which tend to suggest that phosphorylation of H3 and H5 does not affect chromatin structure, electron microscopy reveals that phosphorylation causes a relaxation of structure at low ionic strength. Electric birefringence and relaxation time measurements clearly prove that local structural changes are induced in chromatin: we observe a decrease of the steady-state birefringence with the appearance of a negative contribution in the signal and a marked increase of the flexibility of fibres. The component with the negative birefringence presents very short relaxation times, like those exhibited by small DNA fragments or individual nucleosomes. Two possibilities are then suggested. First, the conformational change is consistent with what would be expected from the presence of DNA segments loosely associated with the core histone H3. That the length of such segments could correspond to about one to two base-pairs per nucleosome strongly suggests that phosphorylation induces changes affecting some specific H3-DNA interactions only. This result could corroborate previous observations indicating that the N-terminal region of H3, where the site of phosphorylation is located, plays a decisive role in maintaining the superstructure of chromatin. Second, phosphorylation could introduce hinge points between each nucleosome. In this case, the negative birefringence results from partial orientation of the swinging nucleosomes. A possible mode of action of phosphorylation might be to weaken structural restraints imposed by histone H3, thus facilitating further condensation of chromatin.     

Polylysine titration of rat liver chromatin fractions after DNase II digestion.

The concentration of free phosphate groups is measured in rat liver chromatin after DNase II digestion using polylysine titration. The unsheared chromatin completely precipitates at lysine/DNA phosphate ratios of 0.5 to 0.6. Digestion of the chromatin reduces the lysine/DNA phosphate ratio of complete precipitation by about 0.2 units suggesting the removal of free phosphate groups. The two chromatin fractions: MgC12 insoluble (template-inactive) and Mg12 soluble (template-active) chromatins precipitate at about the same lysine/DNA phosphate ratio. Some 15% of the MgC12 soluble chromatin remains in solution at any polylysine concentration. The removal of histone H 1 FROM THE MgC12 insoluble chromatin increases the lysine/DNA phosphate ratio by about 0.2 units suggesting that 20% of the DNA phosphate groups in nucleosomes are masked by histone H 1.     

The distribution of histone H1 subfractions in chromatin subunits.

Rat liver chromatin was digested with micrococcal nuclease to various extents and fractionated into nucleosomes, di and trimers of nucleosomes on an isokinetic sucrose gradient. In conditions under which degradation of linker DNA within the particles was limited, the electrophoretic analysis of the histone content showed that the overall content of H1 histone increased from nucleosomes to higher order oligomers. Moreover, the histone H1 subfractions were found unevenly distributed among the chromatin subunits, one of them, H1--3 showing most variation. A more regular distribution of these subfractions was found in subunits obtained from a more extended digestion level of chromatin. It is suggested that the H1 subfractions differ in the protection they confer upon DNA.