Bioethics for clinicians: 12. Ethical dilemmas that arise in the care of pregnant women: rethinking "maternal-fetal conflicts".

When a pregnant woman makes a decision or acts in a manner that may be detrimental to the health and well-being of her fetus, her physician may be faced with an ethical dilemma. Is the physician''s primary duty to respect the woman''s autonomy, or to promote behaviour that may be in the best interest of the fetus? The controversial concept of "fetal rights" or the "fetus as a patient" contributes to the notion that the pregnant woman and her fetus are potential adversaries. However, Canadian law has upheld women''s right to life, liberty and security of the person and has not recognized fetal rights. If a woman is competent and refuses medical advice, her decision must be respected even if the physician believes that her fetus will suffer as a result. Coercion of the woman is not permissible no matter what appears to be in the best interest of the fetus.     

Labour: when to worry.

To ensure an optimum result in pregnancy it is essential that the physician be alert in the antenatal period to recognize those women and their babies who are at risk during labour. Premature labour, with its attendant risk of respiratory distress syndrome in the newborn, continues to be an important factor in perinatal morbidity and mortality. Early recognition of predisposing factors and the judicious use of myometrial inhibiting agents have helped to reduce the incidence of fetal prematurity in these cases. A long interval between rupture of the membranes and delivery continues to be a danger to both mother and fetus. Delivery is recommended when gestation is beyond 36 weeks or when there are signs of incipient infection, and once labour has begun antibiotics should be used prophylactically. Failure of labour to progress should be recognized and managed aggressively in its early stages. Amniotomy and oxytocin infusion have reduced considerably the incidence of prolonged labour and its risks to both mother and fetus. The role of intrapartum monitoring of the fetal heart rate, measurement of the pH in the fetus''s scalp blood and assessment of amniotic fluid is discussed, as is the monitoring of maternal well-being.     

Correlations between pregnancy pathology, study of the placenta, antenatal echography and examination of the product of conception in a series of 175 congenital malformations

In order to verify the hypothesis that during pregnancy in a woman without peculiar history, signs could be discovered when the fetus is malformed we have reviewed the files of 175 women who had a malformed child and of 300 controls. All of these women had at least one clinical examination and one ultrasonographic examination during pregnancy. Two clinical symptoms were more often discovered in the mother of the malformed fetus (p less than 0.001): decrease of fetal movements and small for date fetus. The placenta is never abnormal in the mother with normal fetus. Placenta is abnormal in 31% of the mother with malformed fetus but the abnormalities are not specific. Ultrasonographic examinations allowed more often the discovery of a malformation when hydramnios (p less than 0.001) or fetal hypotrophy (p less than 0.01) or an anomaly of the morphology of the fetus is discovered. Accuracy of prenatal diagnostic is considered for the different categories of congenital malformations.     

双胎妊娠一胎宫内死亡18 例临床分析

目的:探讨双胎妊娠中一胎宫内死亡的原因、对母亲和存活胎儿的影响及临床处理方法。方法:对2001年1月至2011年10月分娩的双胎妊娠之一胎宫内死亡的18例产妇临床资料进行回顾性分析。结果:双胎妊娠一胎宫内死胎的发生率占双胎的1.08%,其中单绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胎(monochorionic-diamniotic twin,MCDA)11例(61.11%),双绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胎(dichorionic-diamniotic twin,DCDA)7例(38.89%)。胎儿死因:胎盘脐带因素3例(16.67%),胎儿畸形1例(5.56%),妊娠并发症3例(16.67%),双胎输血综合征(twin-twin transfusion syndrome,TTTs)3例(16.67%),宫内感染3例(16.67%),不明原因5例(27.78%)。另一胎选择剖宫产者13例,阴道分娩3例。双胎一胎死亡后对母体的凝血功能影响不大(P>0.05)。结论:单绒毛膜双胎较双绒毛膜双胎母儿结局存在差别;双胎一胎宫内死亡对母体及存活儿有一定影响。对于孕周小,胎儿尚不成熟的病例,可严密监测存活胎儿宫内情况,行期待治疗延长孕龄至足月再分娩。     

Adjustment of the fetal head and adult pelvis in modern humans

In nonhuman anthropoids, the anteroposterior (AP) diameters of the fetus are greater than the transverse (TR) diameters and the AP diameters of the pelvic planes are greater than the TR diameters: during labor, therefore, the fetus moves through the birth canal without changing position or orientation. In modern humans, the fetal head at term is encephalized and the fetal chest is flattened. The maternal pelvic inlet is flattened in an AP direction, the sacral promontory and the ischial spines are prominent. As a result, AP<TR at the inlet, but AP>TR at the midpelvis and outlet. In addition, the birth canal presents a marked sacral curvature in the AP direction. The human fetus successfully negotiates the birth canal because the three crucial fetal adaptations: (1) spheroidicity of the presenting part of the fetal head, which allows it to “roll” in the pelvis; (2) mobility of the head and chest in all directions; and (3) a capacity for cranial molding, which adapts fetal head dimensions to pelvic dimensions. The result is that the human fetal head and chest can perform multiple rotational movements in order to always present the greatest fetal diameters to the greatest pelvic diameters. Monkeys show a limited degree of encephalization and suffer from narrow TR pelvic diameters without any possibility of fetal adaptations as shown by humans. Apes also show some encephalization but, because of wider TR diameters in the pelvis, they achieve an easy delivery with no need of fetal adaptations.     

ITP in pregnancy and the newborn: introduction

Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP) occurs more commonly in young women and is one of the commonest immune mediated disorders in pregnancy. It may exist as an incidental finding in an otherwise healthy pregnant woman or may be associated with symptomatic reduction in the platelet count and varying degrees of clinical hemorrhage. The condition termed incidental thrombocytopenia of pregnancy is invariably associated with a platelet count of greater than 100 x 10(9)/L and a very low incidence of fetal thrombocytopenia. Symptomatic thrombocytopenia is more commonly associated with low platelet counts in the fetus (estimated between 20%-40%). It has recently been suggested that the incidence of fetal thrombocytopenia is substantially lower than this figure. The management of ITP in pregnancy is complicated by the fact that fetal thrombocytopenia is difficult to diagnose and carries substantial risks during the delivery process with rare cases of fetal hemorrhage occurring spontaneously in utero. Unfortunately there are no laboratory studies that can be performed precisely in the mother that may predict the occurrence of fetal thrombocytopenia. Maternal management is usually directed towards treatment of maternal symptoms. Maternal treatment or response to treatment is inconsistently associated with predictable changes in the fetal platelet count. Obstetric management is aimed at reducing the risks of life threatening fetal hemorrhage occurring at the time of delivery, and fetal management is directed towards the obtaining of fetal platelet samples in order to plan an appropriate strategy for obstetrical delivery. Fetal blood samples are obtained either by a scalp vein puncture at the time of delivery or earlier in gestation by the use of the newer technique termed percutaneous umbilical blood sampling. Fetuses with platelet counts of less then 50 x 10(9)/L are generally delivered by cesarean section whereas those with counts greater than 50 x 10(9)/L are allowed to proceed with vaginal delivery assuming no obstetrical contraindications exist. The use of IVIgG therapy during pregnancy has theoretical implications on improving platelet counts in the mother in situations of severe hemorrhage, however cannot be considered to be appropriate treatment for the prevention of fetal thrombocytopenia, since the exogenous transport of IVIgG across the placenta appears to be inconsistent and unpredictable.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Prenatal diagnosis and significance of fetal infections.

Viruses like rubella, cytomegalovirus, varicella-zoster virus and parasites like Toxoplasma gondii can be transmitted from a pregnant woman to her fetus and can affect fetal development. Several factors determine the likelihood of fetal infection and the risk of consequences for the fetus, such as the timing of transmission during gestation or the immunologic status of the mother. No single diagnostic modality can be applied to all infections. Knowledge of the diagnostic methods available is essential for accurate counseling and treatment of affected pregnant women.     

Changes in fetal and maternal blood levels of prolactin, cortisol, and cortisone during eutocic and dystocic childbirth

The changes in blood levels of prolactin, total and free cortisol, and cortisone were studied and compared in 51 mother-infant pairs, 30 with eutocic delivery and 21 with dystocic delivery. Regardless of the type of delivery, the newborn at term showed significantly higher prolactin and cortisone serum levels than their mothers, and significantly lower levels of free and total cortisol. In fetal distress of short duration, free cortisol levels were significantly raised in both the mother and the child, while prolactin and cortisone levels were significantly higher only in the child. In contrast to these observations, serum prolactin and cortisone levels in the mother were not altered by the occurrence of fetal distress. In the newborn at delivery there was a negative correlation between serum prolactin and the Apgar score at 1 min applied to the part of the graph between 8 and 2 Apgar scores. This study illustrates the utility of fetal prolactin measurements in evaluating the stress to which the fetus is subjected.     

Infant survival in prematurity

Reduction of neonatal mortality and the rate of stillbirth may be expected from improved management of spontaneous labor and delivery.Neither roentgenographic measurement nor the inception of fetal movement or heartbeat nor any other single test is an index of fetal maturity; all must be considered together. Prenatal care, particularly supplemented diet, will help to avoid premature delivery, or at least to prolong pregnancy; since the fetus undergoes accelerated growth during the last weeks of pregnancy, even slight extension of gestation increases the chances for survival. Analgesia in the first stage of premature labor is contraindicated. Only low spinal anesthesia and other types of conduction anesthesia should be employed for later stages. The fetal membranes should be preserved as long as possible, but premature rupture does not call for immediate termination of pregnancy. Deep episiotomy and prophylactic outlet forceps are routinely employed to hasten the second stage of premature delivery and to protect the immature fetus. Breech presentation is managed by unassisted expulsion or by forceps extraction of the head. The umbilical cord is not immediately severed on delivery; administration of oxytocic drugs after the second stage of labor, combined with gentle stripping of the cord, results in rapid transfer of increased amount of placental blood. The airways of the infant should be immediately cleared. Artificial respiration may be necessary and it must be gentle.All premature infants should receive supplementary oxygen to render breathing regular and more efficient. They should be insulated immediately in controlled temperature and humidity, and they should be handled little.     

Oxytocin and vasopressin in the rat do not readily pass from the mother to the amniotic fluid in late pregnancy

In order to see whether the mother contributes to the vasopressin or oxytocin levels of amniotic fluid, these peptides were measured under conditions (1) in which the fetus lacks vasopressin (Brattleboro strain) and (2) where high maternal oxytocin and vasopressin plasma levels were induced by means of a controlled-delivery Accurel-collodion device. No vasopressin could be demonstrated in amniotic fluid of vasopressin-deficient fetuses present in a heterozygous (i.e., vasopressin-synthetizing mother). High peptide levels on the maternal side of Wistar rats generally failed to affect the amniotic fluid levels. The increase that was occasionally seen in amniotic vasopressin was probably due to fetal release concomitant with growth retardation. Amniotic vasopressin is derived from the fetus. Since amniotic fluid oxytocin is neither derived from the mother nor from the fetal brain, other fetal sources should be considered.     

Blunt abdominal trauma in pregnancy.

Two cases are presented in which the effects of blunt trauma to a pregnant woman''s abdomen were apparently minor but resulted in fetal death. Blunt trauma may result in serious injury to the fetus or the placenta. Three-point restraint systems should be worn by pregnant women travelling in automobiles to minimize the risks to mother and fetus. Awareness of the potential for injury in these circumstances is essential to reduce the risks to the fetus.     

Fetal circulatory responses to oxygen lack.

The knowledge on fetal and neonatal circulatory physiology accumulated by basic scientists and clinicians over the years has contributed considerably to the recent decline of perinatal morbidity and mortality. This review will summarize the peculiarities of the fetal circulation, the distribution of organ blood flow during normoxemia, and that during oxygen lack caused by various experimental perturbations. Furthermore, the relation between oxygen delivery and tissue metabolism during oxygen lack as well as evidence to support a new concept will be presented along with the principal cardiovascular mechanisms involved. Finally, blood flow and oxygen delivery to the principal fetal organs will be examined and discussed in relation to organ function. The fetal circulatory response to hypoxemia and asphyxia is a centralization of blood flow in favour of the brain, heart, and adrenals and at the expense of almost all peripheral organs, particularly of the lungs, carcass, skin and scalp. This response is qualitatively similar but quantitatively different under various experimental conditions. However, at the nadir of severe acute asphyxia the circulatory centralization cannot be maintained. Then there is circulatory decentralization, and the fetus will experience severe brain damage if not expire unless immediate resuscitation occurs. Future work in this field will have to concentrate on the important questions, what factors determine this collapse of circulatory compensating mechanisms in the fetus, how does it relate to neuronal damage, and how can the fetal brain be pharmacologically protected against the adverse effects of asphyxia.     

The murine allantois: emerging paradigms in development of the mammalian umbilical cord and its relation to the fetus

The fertilized egg of the mammal gives rise to the embryo and its extraembryonic structures, all of which develop in intimate relation with each other. Yet, whilst the past several decades have witnessed a vast number of studies on the embryonic component of the conceptus, study of the extraembryonic tissues and their relation to the fetus have been largely ignored. The allantois, precursor tissue of the mature umbilical cord, is a universal feature of all placental mammals that establishes the vital vascular bridge between the fetus and its mother. The allantois differentiates into the umbilical blood vessels, which become secured onto the chorionic component of the placenta at one end and onto the fetus at the other. In this way, fetal blood is channeled through the umbilical cord for exchange with the mother. Despite the importance of this vascular bridge, little is known about how it is made. The aim of this review is to address current understanding of the biology of the allantois in the mouse and genetic control of its features and functions, and to highlight new paradigms concerning the developmental relationship between the fetus and its umbilical cord.     

Hipertiroidismo y embarazo

Association of hyperthyroidism and pregnancy is not an unusual event, and has an impact on both the mother and fetus. After delivery, it may also affect the newborn and the nursing mother. Clinical management of this situation is quite different from that required by non-pregnant hyperthyroid women and poses significant diagnostic and therapeutic challenges.This review addresses aspects related to the unique characteristics of biochemical assessment of thyroid function in pregnancy, the potential causes of hyperthyroidism in pregnancy, and the clinical and therapeutic approach in each case. Special attention is paid to pregnancy complicated with Graves’ disease and its different the maternal, fetal, neonatal, and postnatal consequences.     

Evolutionary implications of fetal and maternal microvillous surfaces in epitheliochorial placentae

According to the “parent-offspring conflict hypothesis” the rapid evolution and diversification of the mammalian placenta is driven by divergent optima of resource allocation between fetus and mother. The fetus has an interest to maximize its resource intake, while the mother has an interest to restrict the transfer of resources, and thus retain resources for subsequent pregnancies. In the epitheliochorial placenta, the contacting fetal and maternal surfaces at the feto-maternal interface are covered with microvilli, which leads to an increase of membrane surfaces available for transport processes. Because membranes are the site of active transport, the conflict hypothesis predicts that the fetal surfaces at the feto-maternal interfaces are larger than the maternal ones. We use transmission electron microscopy and a stereological method to estimate the factors by which the apical fetal and maternal membranes are enlarged by the microvilli. Ten species with an epitheliochorial placenta were studied. Focused ion beam—scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) was used to create three-dimensional models of the interdigitating microvilli of the bovine and porcine placenta. In all species, the fetal surface was larger than the maternal. This was due to a higher number of fetal microvilli and to the presence of membrane folds at the base of the fetal, but not of maternal microvilli. Our results suggest that the ultrastructural morphology of the feto-maternal interface in the epitheliochorial placenta is shaped by conflicting interests between fetus and mother and thus represent a so far neglected arena of the parent-offspring conflict.     

Maternal phenylketonuria. Review with emphasis on pathogenesis

Maternal phenylketonuria (PKU) refers to fetal damage from PKU in the pregnant woman. The progeny from such pregnancies are almost always microcephalic and mentally subnormal and have an increased frequency of congenital heart disease and low birth weight. Treatment with a phenylalanine-restricted diet, if begun before conception, seems to protect the fetus. The degree of protection is much less if dietary treatment is delayed until the pregnancy is in progress. The origin of fetal damage in maternal PKU is not known. Due to placental concentration of amino acids, the fetus is exposed to a higher concentration of phenylalanine than that in the mother, but it is not certain that phenylalanine is the toxic agent. Animal models made hyperphenylalaninemic by the administration of phenylalanine, often accompanied by a phenylalanine hydroxylase inhibitor, do not reproduce the full maternal PKU syndrome; but fetuses and newborns from these models have had reduced growth of the body and brain, and offspring later may show evidence of impaired learning ability.     

Developing ways of reducing allograft immunogenicity.

Heavy alcohol consumption by the mother during pregnancy has long been suspected of being a risk factor for abnormalities in the fetus or infant. Only during the last decade have these assumptions been supported by scientific studies. A clustering of fetal defects observed in some cases has been labelled the fetal alcohol syndrome. The syndrome involves prenatal and postnatal growth retardation, central nervous system involvement and craniofacial abnormalities, some of which are characteristic of the syndrome. Fetal alcohol syndrome is relatively rare, affecting from 1 in 300 to 1 in 2000 infants; approximately 450 cases have been reported since the syndrome was identified. Despite this rarity, however, heavy alcohol consumption is an important risk factor during pregnancy. A review of the current literature indicates that in animals alcohol in high doses is embryotoxic and teratogenic, the heavy drinking is not uncommon before and during pregnancy and that the fetal alcohol syndrome and other effects on the fetus associated with alcohol abuse appear with significant frequency among mothers who drink heavily. Heavy alcohol consumption is a perinatal risk factor that not only can be detected by the physician, but also can be reduced in concerned, cooperative patients. Thus, awareness of this problem gives health care personnel an opportunity to help in the prevention of abnormal outcomes of pregnancy.     

Disposition of methadone in the ovine maternal-fetal unit

The distribution of methadone between mother and fetus after a single dose and at steady state was determined using the chronic pregnant ewe preparation. Chronic indwelling catheters were placed in the maternal aorta and vena cava, umbilical vein and fetal aorta. Following a single i.v. dose (0.5 mg/kg) to the mother, methadone was rapidly distributed to the fetus, with peak concentration in the umbilical vein occurring within two min. An umbilical venous-arterial gradient existed for 10–15 min after drug administration, indicating uptake of methadone by fetal tissues. Methadone concentration in the fetus was 2–5 times lower than those in the mother even in the post-distribution phase. The terminal half-life of methadone in 4 animals was 57±7.6 (S.E.) min in the mother, and 58.5±10.0 (S.E.) min in the fetus. When methadone was infused at a constant rate to the mother (0.01 mg/kg/min), steady state was achieved in both mother and fetus by 4–5 hrs. In 5 animals, maternal steady state was found to be 203±18.8 (S.E.) ng/ml, and fetal steady state was found to be 29.7±2.9 (S.E.) ng/ml. These studies show that methadone is rapidly distributed to the fetus, but fetal concentration remain lower than maternal concentration at all times.     

Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura in pregnancy and neonatal period

In pregnancy and neonatal period both mother and child are endangered by bleeding complications due to maternal idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura. Obstetrical and perinatal management therefore must aim at increasing maternal and fetal platelet count. In our paper six patients in nine pregnancies are reported. Two of them (five pregnancies) were treated with corticosteroids, four of the patients were successfully treated with i.v. immunoglobulins (IgG). Longterm steroid application and splenectomy during pregnancy may be hazardous for mother and fetus. IgG i.v. administration in contrast offers a new and safe way to control maternal and fetal platelet counts during pregnancy, delivery and the neonatal period.