Mu Element-Generated Gene Conversions in Maize Attenuate the Dominant Knotted Phenotype

The knotted1 gene was first defined by dominant mutations that affect leaf morphology. The original allele, Kn1-O, results from a 17-kb tandem duplication. Mutator (Mu) insertions near the junction of the two repeats suppress the leaf phenotype to different degrees depending on the position of the insertion. The Mu insertions also increase the frequency of recombination at Kn1-O to create derivative alleles in which the Mu element and one copy of the repeat are lost. These derivatives are normal in appearance. Here we describe two derivatives that retained the tandem duplication but gained insertions of 1.7 and 3 kb in length in place of the Mu element. In each case, the inserted DNA is a sequence that normally flanks the distal repeat unit. Thus, each derivative consists of a tandem duplication in which the repeat unit has been extended at its distal end by the length of the new insertion. The 1.7-kb insertion dampens the phenotype, as did the original Mu insertion, whereas the 3-kb insertion completely suppresses the knotted phenotype. We propose that gene conversion, stimulated by the double-strand break of the Mu excision, gave rise to these derivatives.     

Gnarley1 is a dominant mutation in the knox4 homeobox gene affecting cell shape and identity.

Maize leaves have a stereotypical pattern of cell types organized into discrete domains. These domains are altered by mutations in knotted1 (kn1) and knox (for kn1-like homeobox) genes. Gnarley (Gn1) is a dominant maize mutant that exhibits many of the phenotypic characteristics of the kn1 family of mutants. Gn1 is unique because it changes parameters of cell growth in the basal-most region of the leaf, the sheath, resulting in dramatically altered sheath morphology. The strongly expressive allele Gn1-R also gives rise to a floral phenotype in which ectopic carpels form. Introgression studies showed that the severity of the Gn1-conferred phenotype is strongly influenced by genetic background. Gn1 maps to knox4, and knox4 is ectopically expressed in plants with the Gn1-conferred phenotype. Immunolocalization experiments showed that the KNOX protein accumulates at the base of Gn1 leaves in a pattern that is spatially and temporally correlated with appearance of the mutant phenotype. We further demonstrate that Gn1 is knox4 by correlating loss of the mutant phenotype with insertion of a Mutator transposon into knox4.     

Site-selected transposon mutagenesis at the hcf106 locus in maize.

The High chlorophyll fluorescence106 (Hcf106) gene in maize is required for chloroplast membrane biogenesis, and the hcf106-mum1 allele is caused by the insertion of a Robertson's Mutator Mu1 element into the promoter of the gene. Seedlings homozygous for hcf106-mum1 are pale green and die 3 weeks after germination, but only in the presence of Mutator activity conferred by active, autonomous Mu regulatory transposons elsewhere in the genome. When Mutator activity is lost, the mutant phenotype is suppressed, and homozygous plants have an almost wild-type phenotype. To isolate derivative alleles at the hcf106 locus that no longer require Mutator activity for phenotypic expression, we have developed a method for site-selected transposon mutagenesis in maize. This procedure, first described for Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila, involves using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to screen pools of individuals for insertions and deletions in genes of known sequence. Pools of seedlings segregating for the progenitor allele hcf106-mum1 were screened by PCR for insertions and deletions associated with Robertson's Mutator. In a 360-bp target region, two new insertions and one deletion were identified in only 700 Mu-active gametes screened. One of the insertions was in the progenitor hcf106-mum1 allele and the other was in the wild-type allele, but all three new alleles were found to have break-points at the same nucleotide in the first intron. Unlike the hcf-106-mum1 progenitor allele, the deletion and one of the insertions conferred pale green seedling lethal phenotypes in the absence of mutator activity. However, the second insertion had a weak, viable phenotype under these conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

A Tandem Duplication Causes the Kn1-O Allele of Knotted, a Dominant Morphological Mutant of Maize

Molecular and genetic techniques are used to define Kn1-O, a mutation which interferes with the normal differentiation of vascular tissue in leaves. Sequences associated with a previously cloned allele, Kn1-2F11, were used as hybridization probes in a Southern analysis of Kn1-O. By this analysis, Kn1-O lacks the Ds2 transposable element that causes Kn1-2F11 but instead is associated with a sequence duplication. Sequence and restriction analysis of genomic clones show that the duplication consists of a tandem array of two 17-kb repeats. Analysis of Kn1-O derivatives indicates that the duplication itself conditions the mutant phenotype; a severely knotted line, Kn1-Ox, has gained a repeat unit to form a triplication, whereas normal derivatives have either lost a repeat unit or sustained insertions that disrupt the tandem duplication. These insertions map near the central junction of the tandem duplication, suggesting that the mutant phenotype results from the novel juxtaposition of sequences. We discuss models that relate the tandem duplication of sequences to altered gene expression.     

Tam3 produces a suppressible allele of the DAG locus of Antirrhinum majus similar to Mu-suppressible alleles of maize

Tam3 from Antirrhinum majus belongs to the Ac/Ds family of transposable elements. An allele of the DAG locus of Antirrhinum ( dag ::Tam3), which is required for chloroplast development and leaf palisade differentiation, has been generated by Tam3 insertion into the untranslated leader sequence of the gene. This allele gives rise to a cold-sensitive phenotype, where mutant tissue containing wild-type revertant somatic sectors is observed in the leaves of plants grown at 15°C, while leaves of plants grown at 25°C appear near wild-type. The temperature sensitivity of dag ::Tam3 results from expression of the DAG locus responding to the activity of the transposable element, the transposition of which is very sensitive to growing temperature. Genetic suppression of Tam3 transposition, using the STABILISER locus, also results in suppression of the dag mutant phenotype. dag ::Tam3 represents a Tam3-suppressible allele similar to those described for Mu transposons in maize. Suppression of the dag mutant phenotype in response to element inactivation appears to result from use of an alternative promoter at the 3' end of the Tam3 element. The production of suppressible alleles by an Ac-like element is discussed in relation to the mutagenic potential of plant transposons in producing complex genetic diversity.     

Mutant characters of knotted maize leaves are determined in the innermost tissue layers

Knotted (Kn1), a dominant mutation in maize, perturbs normal leaf development. Mutant leaves have localized regions of extra growth called knots and, in addition to the normal ligule, ectopic fringes of ligule are found on the leaf blade. Previous clonal analysis showed that the epidermal genotype was immaterial in knot formation. To establish which inner leaf layer was required for formation of knots and ectopic ligule we used a closely linked albino mutation to mark X-ray-induced clonal sectors of wild type (kn) tissue in Kn1 plants. The sectors examined frequently changed in composition of layers in the leaf both transversely and longitudinally. We present results that show that both mutant characters are determined in the middle mesophyll-bundle sheath (MMBS) layer. We show that a lateral vein can produce a knot when only half the MMBS layer around the lateral vein contains the mutant gene. We also show that the ectopic ligule in Kn1 has contributions from both the adaxial epidermal and adaxial mesophyll layer.     

Cloning Knotted, the dominant morphological mutant in maize using Ds2 as a transposon tag

The Kn1-2F11 mutation causes protrusions or knots along the lateral veins of the first few leaves of the maize plant. The phenotype is visible when an unlinked gene, presumably Ac, is present in the genome. The mutation is closely linked to a genetically unstable Adh1 mutation that resulted from the insertion of a Ds2 element (Döring et al., 1984; Chen et al., 1986). Using a unique sequence from the Ds2 element as a hybridization probe, a genomic restriction fragment that cosegregated with the knotted phenotype was cloned. It carries the Kn1-2F11 locus by the following criteria. (i) Cosegregation of the fragment is tightly linked to the phenotype. (ii) Somatic and germinal excision produce a fragment which is the expected size of a revertant fragment; progeny containing the revertant size fragment are normal. (iii) The sequences that hybridize to this fragment are significantly altered in the chromosome containing the original knotted mutation, Kn1-O, (iv) The cloned fragment does not hybridize to a chromosome that contains a deletion of Kn1-O.     

Shoot meristem size is dependent on inbred background and presence of the maize homeobox gene, knotted1

The knotted1 (kn1) gene of maize is expressed in meristems and is absent from leaves, including the site of leaf initiation within the meristem. Recessive mutations of kn1 have been described that limit the capacity to make branches and result in extra carpels. Dominant mutations suggest that kn1 function plays a role in maintaining cells in an undifferentiated state. We took advantage of a Ds-induced dominant allele in order to screen for additional recessive alleles resulting from mobilization of the Ds element. Analysis of one such allele revealed a novel embryonic shoot phenotype in which the shoot initiated zero to few organs after the cotyledon was made, resulting in plants that arrested as seedlings. We refer to this phenotype as a limited shoot. The limited shoot phenotype reflected loss of kn1 function, but its penetrance was background dependent. We examined meristem size and found that plants lacking kn1 function had shorter meristems than non-mutant siblings. Furthermore, meristems of restrictive inbreds were significantly shorter than meristems of permissive inbreds, implying a correlation between meristem height and kn1 gene function in the embryo. Analysis of limited shoot plants during embryogenesis indicated a role for kn1 in shoot meristem maintenance. We discuss a model for kn1 in maintenance of the morphogenetic zone of the shoot apical meristem.     

Cloning of the y1 Locus of Maize,a Gene Involved in the Biosynthesis of Carotenoids

The y1 gene is one of the genes responsible for the production of [beta]-carotene in the endosperm and leaves of maize. We have cloned a Robertson's Mutator-tagged allele of the y1 gene (y1-mum) by using a Mu3 element as a hybridization probe. We substantiate that the cloned sequence is a portion of the y1 gene by molecular analyses of a revertant of a putative Mutator-induced y1 allele and the incidence of insertions within the cloned y1 sequence from several independently derived Mutator-induced y1 mutant stocks. The y1-mum sequence was used to isolate the standard Y1 allele, which conditions the presence of [beta]-carotene in the endosperm of the maize kernel.     

Ectopic expression of maize knotted1 results in the cytokinin-autotrophic growth of cultured tobacco tissues

The ectopic expression of knotted homologues has cytokinin-like effects on plant morphology. The functional relationship between knotted and cytokinins was investigated in cultures of leaf tissue established from tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Havana 425) plants transformed with the maize knotted1 (kn1) gene regulated by cauliflower mosaic virus 35S RNA expression signals. In contrast to leaf tissues of untransformed plants, leaf tissues of kn1 transformants were capable of sustained, cytokinin-autotrophic growth on auxin-containing medium and resembled the tobacco cytokinin-autotrophic mutants Hl-1 and Hl-2. The concentration of 18 cytokinins was measured in cultures initiated from leaves of three independent kn1 transformants and the Hl-1 and Hl-2 mutants. Although cytokinin contents were variable, the content of several cytokinins in Kn1, Hl-1 and Hl-2 tissue lines was at least 10-fold higher than that of wild-type tobacco tissues and in the range reported for other cytokinin-autotrophic tobacco tissues. These results suggest that the cytokinin-autotrophic growth of Kn1 lines could result from elevated steady-state levels of cytokinins. Received: 7 July 1999 / Accepted: 10 November 1999     

KNAT1 induces lobed leaves with ectopic meristems when overexpressed in Arabidopsis.

Plant development depends on the activity of apical meristems, which are groups of indeterminate cells whose derivatives elaborate the organs of the mature plant. Studies of knotted1 (kn1) and related gene family members have determined potential roles for homeobox genes in the function of shoot meristems. The Arabidopsis kn1-like gene, KNAT1, is expressed in the shoot apical meristem and not in determinate organs. Here, we show that ectopic expression of KNAT1 in Arabidopsis transforms simple leaves into lobed leaves. The lobes initiate in the position of serrations yet have features of leaves, such as stipules, which form in the sinus, the region at the base of two lobes. Ectopic meristems also arise in the sinus region close to veins. Identity of the meristem, that is, vegetative or floral, depends on whether the meristem develops on a rosette or cauline leaf, respectively. Using in situ hybridization, we analyzed the expression of KNAT1 and another kn1-like homeobox gene, SHOOT MERISTEMLESS, in cauliflower mosaic virus 35S::KNAT1 transformants. KNAT1 expression is strong in vasculature, possibly explaining the proximity of the ectopic meristems to veins. After leaf cells have formed a layered meristem, SHOOT MERISTEMLESS expression begins in only a subset of these cells, demonstrating that KNAT1 is sufficient to induce meristems in the leaf. The shootlike features of the lobed leaves are consistent with the normal domain of KNAT1's expression and further suggest that kn1-related genes may have played a role in the evolution of leaf diversity.     

Genetic Analysis of Rough Sheath1 Developmental Mutants of Maize

Maize Rough sheath1 (Rs1) mutants are dominant and cause a proliferation of sheath-like tissue at the base of the blade and throughout the ligular region. They also cause ligule displacement, a chaotic pattern of vasculature and abnormal cellular structure of vascular bundles. The affected region of Rs1-O leaves displays genetic and morphological attributes of both sheath and auricle, suggesting an overlap of these genetic programs. The rs1 locus maps approximately 26 map units distal to opaque2 (o2) on chromosome 7S, defining a new distal-most locus on the genetic map. Three mutant alleles, Rs1-O, Rs1-1025 and Rs1-Z, all display similar phenotypes. The mutations are completely dominant and the Rs1-O phenotype is not affected by dosage of the chromosome arm carrying the rs1(+) allele, indicating that these alleles are neomorphic. Analysis of genetic mosaics showed that the Rs1-O phenotype is non-cell-autonomous, suggesting that intercellular signals convey the phenotype. Rs1 mutant phenotypes are affected by modifiers present in particular genetic backgrounds. An enhancer of Rs1-O was identified; segregation data imply a single recessive gene, ers1. Rs1 mutants were also found to enhance the expression of unlinked rs2 and Rs4 mutants, suggesting that these mutations affect similar developmental processes. We discuss the phenotypic and genetic similarities between Rs1 and Knotted1 (Kn1) mutants that led to the identification of rs1 as a kn1-like homeobox gene (unpublished data).     

Over-expression of tobacco knotted1-type class1 homeobox genes alters various leaf morphology

We compared the phenotypes of transgenic tobacco plants over-expressing various knotted1-type class1 homeobox genes. All transformants showed abnormal leaf morphology, with the degree of abnormality depending upon the Nicotiana tabacum homeobox (NTH) gene that was over-expressed. Tobacco plants over-expressing NTH1 or NTH9 showed a relatively weak phenotype, while NTH15 and NTH20 over-expressing plants exhibited severe alterations, with occasional ectopic shoot formation on the leaves. Plants over-expressing NTH22 had a relatively severe phenotype, but did not form any ectopic shoots. These results indicate that all of the NTH genes can influence leaf development from the shoot apical meristem, but that the effect varies with the gene. Based on phylogenetic analysis of the NTH genes and comparison of the phenotypes of plants over-expressing them, we suggest that the kn1-type class1 family can be divided into two subgroups, and that the differences in their ability to induce the abnormal phenotype corresponds to the structures of their conserved domains.