Catalytic site forms and controls in ATP synthase catalysis

A suggested minimal scheme for substrate binding by and interconversion of three forms of the catalytic sites of the ATP synthase is presented. Each binding change, that drives simultaneous interchange of the three catalytic site forms, requires a 120 degrees rotation of the gamma with respect to the beta subunits. The binding of substrate(s) at two catalytic sites is regarded as sufficing for near maximal catalytic rates to be attained. Although three sites do not need to be filled for rapid catalysis, during rapid bisite catalysis some enzyme may be transiently present with three sites filled. Forms with preferential binding for ADP and P(i) or for ATP are considered to arise from the transition state and participate in other steps of the catalysis. Intermediate forms and steps that may be involved are evaluated. Experimental evidence for energy-dependent steps and for control of coupling to proton translocation and transition state forms are reviewed. Impact of relevant past data on present understanding of catalytic events is considered. In synthesis a key step is suggested in which proton translocation begins to deform an open site so as to increase the affinity for ADP and P(i), that then bind and pass through the transition state, and yield tightly bound ATP in one binding change. ADP binding appears to be a key parameter controlling rotation during synthesis. In hydrolysis ATP binding to a loose site likely precedes any proton translocation, with proton movement occurring as the tight site form develops. Aspects needing further study are noted. Characteristics of the related MgADP inhibition of the F(1) ATPases that have undermined many observations are summarized, and relations of three-site filling to catalysis are assessed.     

Rotary movements within the ATP synthase do not constitute an obligatory element of the catalytic mechanism

After a brief history of the proposals for the mechanism of the ATP synthase, the main experimental arguments for a rotational mechanism of catalysis are analyzed and on the basis of this analysis it is concluded that no evidence has been provided for rotation as an obligatory element of the catalytic mechanism. On the other hand, the experimental evidence in favor of a two-sites catalytic mechanism, derived from various approaches and not compatible with a three-sites rotary mechanism, appear to be very solid. Finally a brief characterization of the various nucleotide binding sites is provided and a suggestion is made how the enzyme has evolutionarily developed from a rotating machine into an asymmetrical device for energy conservation.     

F1 ATPase from the thermophilic bacterium PS3 (TF1) shows ATP modulation of oxygen exchange

The ATPase from the ATP synthase of the thermophilic bacterium PS3 (TF1), unlike F1 ATPase from other sources, does not retain bound ATP, ADP, and Pi at a catalytic site under conditions for single-site catalysis [Yohda, M., & Yoshida, M. (1987) J. Biochem. 102, 875-883]. This raised a question as to whether catalysis by TF1 involved alternating participation of catalytic sites. The possibility remained, however, that there might be transient but catalytically significant retention of bound reactants at catalytic sites when the medium ATP concentration was relatively low. To test for this, the extent of water oxygen incorporation into Pi formed by ATP hydrolysis was measured at various ATP concentrations. During ATP hydrolysis at both 45 and 60 degrees C, the extent of water oxygen incorporation into the Pi formed increased markedly as the ATP concentration was lowered to the micromolar range, with greater modulation observed at 60 degrees C. Most of the product Pi formed arose by a single catalytic pathway, but measurable amounts of Pi were formed by a pathway with high oxygen exchange. This may result from the presence of some poorly active enzyme. The results are consistent with sequential participation of three catalytic sites on the TF1 as predicted by the binding change mechanism.     

Catalytic site occupancy during ATP hydrolysis by MF1-ATPase. Evidence for alternating high affinity sites during steady-state turnover

The mechanism of ATP hydrolysis by the solubilized mitochondrial ATPase (MF1) has been studied under conditions where catalytic turnover occurs at one site, uni-site catalysis (obtained when enzyme is in excess of substrate), or at two sites, bi-site catalysis (obtained when substrate is in excess of enzyme). Pulse-chase experiments support the conclusion that the sites which participate in bi-site catalysis are the same as those which participate in uni-site catalysis. Upon addition of ATP in molar excess to MF1, label that was bound under uni-site conditions dissociates at a rate equal to the rate of bi-site catalysis. Similarly, when medium ATP is removed, label that was bound under bi-site conditions dissociates at a rate equal to the rate of uni-site catalysis. Evidence that a high affinity catalytic site equivalent to the one observed under uni-site conditions participates as an intermediate in bi-site catalysis includes the demonstration of full occupancy of a catalytically competent site during steady-state turnover at nanomolar concentrations of ATP. Improved measurements of the interaction of ADP at a high affinity catalytic site have lead to the revision of several of the rate constants that define uni-site catalysis. The rate constant for unpromoted dissociation of ADP is equal to that for Pi (4 X 10(-3) s-1). The rate of binding ADP at a high affinity chaseable site (Kd = 1 nM) is equal to the rate of binding ATP (4 X 10(6) M-1 s-1). The rate of catalysis obtained when substrate binding at one site promotes product release from an adjacent site (bi-site catalysis) is up to 100,000-fold faster than unpromoted product release (uni-site catalysis).     

Reaction mechanism of the membrane-bound ATPase of submitochondrial particles from beef heart

Submitochondrial particles from beef heart, washed with dilute solutions of KCl so as to activate the latent, membrane-bound ATPase, F1, may be used to study single site catalysis by the enzyme. [gamma-32P]ATP, incubated with a molar excess of catalytic sites, a condition which favors binding of substrate in only a single catalytic site on the enzyme, is hydrolyzed via a four-step reaction mechanism. The mechanism includes binding in a high affinity catalytic site, Ka = 10(12)M-1, a hydrolytic step for which the equilibrium constant is near unity, and two product release steps in which Pi dissociates from catalytic sites about 10 times more rapidly than ADP. Catalysis by the membrane-bound ATPase also is characterized by a 10(6)-fold acceleration in the rate of net hydrolysis of [gamma-32P]ATP, bound in the high affinity catalytic site, that occurs when substrate is made available to additional catalytic sites on the enzyme. These aspects of the reaction mechanism of the ATPase of submitochondrial particles closely parallel the reaction mechanism determined for solubilized, homogeneous F1 (Grubmeyer, C., Cross, R. L., and Penefsky, H. S. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 12092-12100). The finding that removal of the enzyme from the membrane does not significantly alter the properties of single site catalysis lends support to models of ATP synthesis in oxidative phosphorylation, catalyzed by membrane-bound F1, that have been based on the study of the soluble enzyme.     

The properties of hybrid F1-ATPase enzymes suggest that a cyclical catalytic mechanism involving three catalytic sites occurs

Maximal rates of ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by F1-ATPase enzymes are known to involve strong positive catalytic site cooperativity. There are three potential catalytic nucleotide-binding sites on F1. Two important and unanswered questions are (i) whether all three potential catalytic sites must interact cooperatively to yield maximal rates of ATP hydrolysis and (ii) whether a cyclical three-site mechanism operates as suggested by several authors. We have studied these two questions here by measuring the ATPase activities of hybrid enzymes containing normal beta-, gamma-, delta-, and epsilon-subunits together with different combinations of mutant and normal alpha-subunits. The mutant alpha-subunits were derived from uncA401, uncA447, and uncA453 mutant E. coli F1-ATPase, in which positive cooperativity between catalytic sites is strongly attenuated by defined mis-sense mutations. Our data show that three normal catalytic sites are required to interact in order to achieve maximal ATPase rates and suggest that a cyclical mechanism does operate. Hybrid enzyme containing one-third mutant alpha-subunit and two-thirds normal alpha-subunits had substantial but submaximal activity, showing that cooperativity between three sites in a noncyclical fashion, or between pairs of sites, can achieve effective catalysis.     

Escherichia coli ATP synthase alpha subunit Arg-376: the catalytic site arginine does not participate in the hydrolysis/synthesis reaction but is required for promotion to the steady state

The three catalytic sites of the F(O)F(1) ATP synthase interact through a cooperative mechanism that is required for the promotion of catalysis. Replacement of the conserved alpha subunit Arg-376 in the Escherichia coli F(1) catalytic site with Ala or Lys resulted in turnover rates of ATP hydrolysis that were 2 x 10(3)-fold lower than that of the wild type. Mutant enzymes catalyzed hydrolysis at a single site with kinetics similar to that of the wild type; however, addition of excess ATP did not chase bound ATP, ADP, or Pi from the catalytic site, indicating that binding of ATP to the second and third sites failed to promote release of products from the first site. Direct monitoring of nucleotide binding in the alphaR376A and alphaR376K mutant F(1) by a tryptophan in place of betaTyr-331 (Weber et al. (1993) J. Biol. Chem. 268, 20126-20133) showed that the catalytic sites of the mutant enzymes, like the wild type, have different affinities and therefore, are structurally asymmetric. These results indicate that alphaArg-376, which is close to the beta- or gamma-phosphate group of bound ADP or ATP, respectively, does not make a significant contribution to the catalytic reaction, but coordination of the arginine to nucleotide filling the low-affinity sites is essential for promotion of rotational catalysis to steady-state turnover.     

Bi-site catalysis in F1-ATPase: does it exist?

The mechanism of action of F(1)F(0)-ATP synthase is controversial. Some favor a tri-site mechanism, where substrate must fill all three catalytic sites for activity, others a bi-site mechanism, where one of the three sites is always unoccupied. New approaches were applied to examine this question. First, ITP was used as hydrolysis substrate; lower binding affinities of ITP versus ATP enable more accurate assessment of sites occupancy. Second, distributions of all eight possible enzyme species (with zero, one, two or three sites filled) as fraction of total enzyme population at each ITP concentration were calculated, and compared with measured ITPase activity. Confirming data were obtained with ATP as substrate. Third, we performed a theoretical analysis of possible bi-site mechanisms. The results argue convincingly that bi-site hydrolysis activity is negligible, and may not even exist. Effectively, tri-site hydrolysis is the only mechanism. We argue that only tri-site hydrolysis drives subunit rotation. Theoretical analyses of possible bi-site mechanisms reveal serious flaws, not previously recognized. One is that, in bi-site catalysis, the predicted direction of subunit rotation is the same for both ATP synthesis and hydrolysis; a second is that infrequently occurring enzyme species are required.     

The characteristics and effect on catalysis of nucleotide binding to noncatalytic sites of chloroplast F1-ATPase.

The recent finding that the presence of ATP at non-catalytic sites of chloroplast F1-ATPase (CF1) is necessary for ATPase activity (Milgrom, Y. M., Ehler, L. L., and Boyer, P. D. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265,18725-18728) prompted more detailed studies of the effect of noncatalytic site nucleotides on catalysis. CF1 containing at noncatalytic sites less than one ADP or about two ATP was prepared by heat activation in the absence of Mg2+ and in the presence of ADP or ATP, respectively. After removal of medium nucleotides, the CF1 preparations were used for measurement of the time course of nucleotide binding from 10 to 100 microM concentrations of 3H-labeled ADP, ATP, or GTP. The presence of Mg2+ strongly promotes the tight binding of ADP and ATP at noncatalytic sites. For example, the ADP-heat-activated enzyme in presence of 1 mM Mg2+ binds ADP with a rate constant of 0.5 x 10(6) M-1 min-1 to give an enzyme with two ADP at noncatalytic sites with a Kd of about 0.1 microM. Upon exposure to Mg2+ and ATP the vacant noncatalytic site binds an ATP rapidly and, as an ADP slowly dissociates, a second ATP binds. The binding correlates with an increase in the ATPase activity. In contrast the tight binding of [3H]GTP to noncatalytic sites gives an enzyme with no ATPase activity. The three noncatalytic sites differ in their binding properties. The noncatalytic site that remains vacant after the ADP-heat-activated CF1 is exposed to Mg2+ and ADP and that can bind ATP rapidly is designated as site A; the site that fills with ATP as ADP dissociates when this enzyme is exposed to Mg2+ and ATP is called site B, and the site to which ADP remains bound is called site C. Procedures are given for attaining CF1 with ADP at sites B and C, with GTP at sites A and/or B, and with ATP at sites A, B, and/or C, and catalytic activities of such preparations are measured. For example, little or no ATPase activity is found unless ATP is at site A, but ADP can remain at site C with no effect on ATPase. Maximal GTPase activity requires ATP at site A but about one-fifth of maximal GTPase is attained when GTP is at sites A and B and ATP at site C. Noncatalytic site occupancy can thus have profound effects on the ATPase and GTPase activities of CF1.     

Mechanical modulation of catalytic power on F1-ATPase

The conformational fluctuation of enzymes has a crucial role in reaction acceleration. However, the contribution to catalysis enhancement of individual substates with conformations far from the average conformation remains unclear. We studied the catalytic power of the rotary molecular motor F(1)-ATPase from thermophilic Bacillus PS3 as it was stalled in transient conformations far from a stable pausing angle. The rate constants of ATP binding and hydrolysis were determined as functions of the rotary angle. Both rates exponentially increase with rotation, revealing the molecular basis of positive cooperativity among three catalytic sites: elementary reaction steps are accelerated via the mechanical rotation driven by other reactions on neighboring catalytic sites. The rate enhancement induced by ATP binding upon rotation was greater than that brought about by hydrolysis, suggesting that the ATP binding step contributes more to torque generation than does the hydrolysis step. Additionally, 9% of the ATP-driven rotary step was supported by thermal diffusion, suggesting that acceleration of the ATP docking process occurs via thermally agitated conformational fluctuations.     

Novel features of the rotary catalytic mechanism revealed in the structure of yeast F1 ATPase

The crystal structure of yeast mitochondrial F(1) ATPase contains three independent copies of the complex, two of which have similar conformations while the third differs in the position of the central stalk relative to the alpha(3)beta(3) sub-assembly. All three copies display very similar asymmetric features to those observed for the bovine enzyme, but the yeast F(1) ATPase structures provide novel information. In particular, the active site that binds ADP in bovine F(1) ATPase has an ATP analog bound and therefore this structure does not represent the ADP-inhibited form. In addition, one of the complexes binds phosphate in the nucleotide-free catalytic site, and comparison with other structures provides a picture of the movement of the phosphate group during initial binding and subsequent catalysis. The shifts in position of the central stalk between two of the three copies of yeast F(1) ATPase and when these structures are compared to those of the bovine enzyme give new insight into the conformational changes that take place during rotational catalysis.     

ATP hydrolysis in the betaTP and betaDP catalytic sites of F1-ATPase

The enzyme F1-adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) is a molecular motor that converts the chemical energy stored in the molecule adenosine triphosphate (ATP) into mechanical rotation of its gamma-subunit. During steady-state catalysis, the three catalytic sites of F1 operate in a cooperative fashion such that at every instant each site is in a different conformation corresponding to a different stage along the catalytic cycle. Notwithstanding a large amount of biochemical and, recently, structural data, we still lack an understanding of how ATP hydrolysis in F1 is coupled to mechanical motion and how the catalytic sites achieve cooperativity during rotatory catalysis. In this publication, we report combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical simulations of ATP hydrolysis in the betaTP and betaDP catalytic sites of F1-ATPase. Our simulations reveal a dramatic change in the reaction energetics from strongly endothermic in betaTP to approximately equienergetic in betaDP. The simulations identify the responsible protein residues, the arginine finger alphaR373 being the most important one. Similar to our earlier study of betaTP, we find a multicenter proton relay mechanism to be the energetically most favorable hydrolysis pathway. The results elucidate how cooperativity between catalytic sites might be achieved by this remarkable molecular motor.     

The Escherichia coli F1F0 ATP synthase displays biphasic synthesis kinetics

The F1F0 proton-translocating ATPase/synthase is the primary generator of ATP in most organisms growing aerobically. Kinetic assays of ATP synthesis have been conducted using enzymes from mitochondria and chloroplasts. However, limited data on ATP synthesis by the model Escherichia coli enzyme are available, mostly because of the lack of an efficient and reproducible assay. We have developed an optimized assay and have collected synthase kinetic data over a substrate concentration range of 2 orders of magnitude for both ADP and Pi from the synthase enzyme of E. coli. Negative and positive cooperativity of substrate binding and positive catalytic cooperativity were all observed. ATP synthesis displayed biphasic kinetics for ADP indicating that 1) the enzyme is capable of catalyzing efficient ATP synthesis when only two of three catalytic sites are occupied by ADP; and 2) occupation of the third site further activates the rate of catalysis.     

Pseudomonas aeruginosa aspartate transcarbamoylase. Characterization of its catalytic and regulatory properties

Aspartate transcarbamoylase from Pseudomonadaceae is a class A enzyme consisting of six copies of a 36-kDa catalytic chain and six copies of a 45-kDa polypeptide of unknown function. The 45-kDa polypeptide is homologous to dihydroorotase but lacks catalytic activity. Pseudomonas aeruginosa aspartate transcarbamoylase was overexpressed in Escherichia coli. The homogeneous His-tagged protein isolated in high yield, 30 mg/liter of culture, by affinity chromatography and crystallized. Attempts to dissociate the catalytic and pseudo-dihydroorotase (pDHO) subunits or to express catalytic subunits only were unsuccessful suggesting that the pDHO subunits are required for the proper folding and assembly of the complex. As reported previously, the enzyme was inhibited by micromolar concentrations of all nucleotide triphosphates. In the absence of effectors, the aspartate saturation curves were hyperbolic but became strongly sigmoidal in the presence of low concentrations of nucleotide triphosphates. The inhibition was unusual in that only free ATP, not MgATP, inhibits the enzyme. Moreover, kinetic and binding studies with a fluorescent ATP analog suggested that ATP induces a conformational change that interferes with the binding of carbamoyl phosphate but has little effect once carbamoyl phosphate is bound. The peculiar allosteric properties suggest that the enzyme may be a potential target for novel chemotherapeutic agents designed to combat Pseudomonas infection.     

Stepping rotation of F(1)-ATPase with one, two, or three altered catalytic sites that bind ATP only slowly

F(1)-ATPase is an ATP hydrolysis-driven motor in which the gamma subunit rotates in the stator cylinder alpha(3)beta(3). To know the coordination of three catalytic beta subunits during catalysis, hybrid F(1)-ATPases, each containing one, two, or three "slow" mutant beta subunits that bind ATP very slowly, were prepared, and the rotations were observed with a single molecule level. Each hybrid made one, two, or three steps per 360 degrees revolution, respectively, at 5 microm ATP where the wild-type enzyme rotated continuously without step under the same observing conditions. The observed dwell times of the steps are explained by the slow binding rate of ATP. Except for the steps, properties of rotation, such as the torque forces exerted during rotary movement, were not significantly changed from those of the wild-type enzyme. Thus, it appears that the presence of the slow beta subunit(s) does not seriously affect other normal beta subunit(s) in the same F(1)-ATPase molecule and that the order of sequential catalytic events is faithfully maintained even when ATP binding to one or two of the catalytic sites is retarded.     

Mitochondrial F1-ATPase will bind and cleave ATP but only slowly release ADP after N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide or 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole derivatization

The ATPase from the inner mitochondrial membrane is known to be inhibited by modification of one of the three catalytic subunits with N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) or 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole. An experimental approach described in this paper shows that most of the residual ATPase activity observed after the usual DCCD or 7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazole modification is due to the presence of unmodified enzyme, although the large fraction of modified enzyme retains a weak catalytic activity. This weak catalytic activity can be stimulated by methanol or dimethyl sulfoxide. When the modified enzymes are exposed to Mg2+ and [3H]ATP, about equal amounts of [3H]ATP and [3H]ADP appear at catalytic sites. The turnover rate for these enzymes is less than 1/1000 that of the native enzyme when it is calculated from the rate at which the enzyme becomes labeled at the catalytic sites with [3H]ATP and [3H]ADP during steady state hydrolysis. In addition, a higher ATP concentration is required for steady state turnover and, after ATP binding, the principal rate-limiting step is the capacity of the derivatized enzyme to undergo the binding changes necessary for the release of ADP and Pi. When the modified enzymes are not hydrolyzing ATP, they convert to form(s) that show a distinct lag in the replacement of bound nucleotides at catalytic sites. The replacement of bound nucleotides is still promoted by MgATP, even though the enzymes have been converted to sluggish forms. Contrary to a recent suggestion based on the study of the DCCD-modified enzyme (Soong, K.S., and Wang, J.H. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 136-141), our data provide evidence for the existence of catalytic cooperatively between at least two alternating sites in the modified enzyme and are consistent with continued sequential participation of all three sites.     

Complex cooperativity of ATP hydrolysis in the F(1)-ATPase molecular motor

F(1)-ATPase catalyses ATP hydrolysis and converts the cellular chemical energy into mechanical rotation. The hydrolysis reaction in F(1)-ATPase does not follow the widely believed Michaelis-Menten mechanism. Instead, the hydrolysis mechanism behaves in an ATP-dependent manner. We develop a model for enzyme kinetics and hydrolysis cooperativity of F(1)-ATPase which involves the binding-state changes to the coupling catalytic reactions. The quantitative analysis and modeling suggest the existence of complex cooperative hydrolysis between three different catalysis sites of F(1)-ATPase. This complexity may be taken into account to resolve the arguments on the binding change mechanism in F(1)-ATPase.     

Investigation of the Methanosarcina thermophila acetate kinase mechanism by fluorescence quenching

Acetate kinase, a member of the acetate and sugar kinase/Hsc 70/actin (ASKHA) structural superfamily, catalyzes the reversible transfer of the gamma-phosphoryl group from ATP to acetate, yielding ADP and acetyl phosphate. A catalytic mechanism for the enzyme from Methanosarcina thermophila has been proposed on the basis of the crystal structure and kinetic analyses of amino acid replacement variants. The Gln43Trp variant was generated to further investigate the catalytic mechanism via changes in fluorescence. The dissociation constants for ADP.Mg2+ and ATP.Mg2+ ligands were determined for the Gln43Trp variant and double variants generated by replacing Arg241 and Arg91 with Ala and Lys. The dissociation constants and kinetic analyses indicated roles for the arginines in transition state stabilization for catalysis but not in nucleotide binding. The results also provide the first experimental evidence for domain motion and evidence that catalysis does not occur as two independent active sites of the homodimer but the active site activities are coordinated in a half-the-sites manner.     

The role of tightly bound ADP on chloroplast ATPase

Isolated chloroplast coupling factor 1 ATPase is known to retain about 1 mol of tightly bound ADP/mol of enzyme. Some experimental results have given evidence that the bound ADP is at catalytic sites, but this view has not been supported by observations of a slow replacement of the bound ADP when CaATP or MgATP is added. The experiments reported in this paper show why a slow replacement of ADP bound at a catalytic site can occur. When coupling factor 1, labeled with tightly bound [3H]ADP, is exposed to Mg2+ or Ca2+ prior to the addition of MgATP or CaATP, a pronounced lag in the onset of ATP hydrolysis is observed, and only slow replacement of the [3H]ADP occurs. Mg2+ or Ca2+ can induce inhibition very rapidly, as if an inhibited form of the enzyme results whenever the enzyme with tightly bound ADP encounters Mg2+ or Ca2+ prior to ATP. The inhibited form can be slowly reactivated by incubation with EDTA, although some irreversible loss in activity is encountered. In contrast, when MgATP or CaATP is added to enzyme depleted of Mg2+ and Ca2+ by incubation with EDTA, a rapid onset of ATP hydrolysis occurs and most of the tightly bound [3H]ADP is released within a few seconds, as expected for binding at a catalytic site. The Mg2+-induced inhibition of both the ATPase activity and the lack of replacement of tightly bound [3H] ADP can be largely prevented by incubation with Pi under conditions favoring Pi addition to the site containing the tightly bound ADP. Our and other results can be explained if enzyme catalysis is greatly hindered when MgADP or CaADP without accompanying Pi is tightly bound at one of the three catalytic sites on the enzyme in a high affinity conformation.