Changes in the Microbiology of Vacuum-packaged Beef

The development of the microbial flora on meat stored in vacuum-bags at 0–2° for up to 9 weeks was studied. Although the proportion of lactic acid bacteria increased relative to the aerobic spoilage organisms, the numbers of the latter continued to increase throughout storage. The initial contamination of the meat before vacuum-packaging was important; meat with a very low initial number had lower numbers of bacteria throughout storage for up to 9 weeks and steaks cut from such meat which had been stored always had 1–2 days' additional aerobic shelf life at 4°. Spoilage of these steaks was due either to slime formation and off-odour associated with high counts of presumptive Pseudomonas spp., or by discoloration and souring (lactic acid bacteria). Extract release volume and pH measurements performed on the vacuum-packaged primal joints were only of value in determining the onset of aerobic spoilage when large numbers of Gram negative organisms were present, whereas the titrimetric method of spoilage evaluation of the vacuum-packaged meat showed a correlation with spoilage due to lactic organisms.     

A substrate-mediated assay of bacterial proton efflux/influx to predict the degree of spoilage of beef mince stored at chill temperatures

A method was developed to predict spoilage of minced meat at chill temperatures, based on the difference in proton efflux from and influx into bacterial cells. This difference depends on the number of organisms present, the available glucose in the meat sample and the ability of the organisms to metabolize amino acids. The proton efflux/influx of a meat filtrate containing bacteria was measured at 25°C with a pH/ion meter in the presence of peptone with or without glucose. There was a noticeable rate of change of mV h_-1 of the meat filtrate prior to the organoleptic detection of spoilage which may be used semi-predictively to determine the remaining shelf-life of meat at different storage temperatures. The method could be investigated further, encompassing type and relative numbers of organisms, incubation temperature, meat type and composition (i.e. available glucose) to produce a spoilage prediction model. The method does not require sophisticated equipment, only a standard pH/ion meter, is cheap, needing only peptone and glucose, is relatively simple, and takes less than 2 h to perform.     

Growth at sub-zero temperatures of black spot fungi from meat

Glycerol can prevent both freezing and desiccation of micro-organisms growing at sub-zero temperatures. On media containing glycerol, at concentrations readily tolerated by the organisms at ambient temperatures, three species of fungi isolated from black spot spoilt meat failed to grow at temperatures much below -5°C. This would, therefore, seem to be the minimum possible growth temperature of these organisms. Although the fungi could grow on frozen media, their rates of growth were such that, on frozen meat, several months would be required for colonies to become barely visible. It therefore seems that significant black spot spoilage will only develop on frozen meat if it is held at temperatures within 2–3° below the freezing point for prolonged periods, or if the meat surface reaches higher temperatures with surface drying inhibiting bacterial growth. There has been little study during the last 50 years of mould spoilage of meat, although it is still of importance in the international trade in frozen meats. Because moulds grow relatively slowly, they only spoil meat if the storage conditions prevent bacterial growth, but there are few firm data on the time and temperature requirements for visible mould growth to develop in the absence of bacterial spoilage. Such data are necessary if the causes of particular outbreaks of fungal spoilage are to be assessed correctly.     

Glucose, the key substrate in the microbiological changes occurring in meat and certain meat products

The literature dealing with the role of glucose in the microbiological changes of meat and certain meat products is reviewed. Discussion is centered on two aspects. First, glucose plays a part in the selection of the dominant spoilage organisms, Pseudomonas fragi, Ps. lundensis, and Ps. fluorescens, on red meat stored aerobically under chill (2-7 degrees C) conditions. It is concluded that the pseudomonads flourish because they convert glucose to the less commonly used substrate, gluconate. The latter serves as an extracellular energy store. With its depletion, the pseudomonads utilize amino acids, thereby producing the characteristic off-odors of spoiled meat. Storage of meat in a modified atmosphere (viz., 20% CO2:80% O2) selects Gram-positive flora (lactobacilli and Brochothrix thermosphacta) which impart a "cheesy odor" through acid production from glucose and volatile fatty acids from amino acids. The first mentioned organisms produce the same off-odors in "acid" meat (pH 5.5) from which oxygen is excluded. So too does the less acid-tolerant Br. thermosphacta in less acid meat (pH greater than 5.8), especially if trace amounts of O2 are present. Such meat may be colonized by Shewanella putrefaciens also, with green discoloration resulting from the release of H2S from amino acids. The addition of glucose and NO2- to, and the exclusion of oxygen from, comminuted meat selects a flora dominated by Lactobacillus spp. and staphylococci such as Staphylococcus carnosus. Second, sulfite, the preservative of British-style sausages, has a sparing action on glucose. As a consequence of its curtailed breakdown there is only a meager acid drift with storage even though a fermentative flora of lactobacilli and Br. thermosphacta is selected. Yeasts also contribute to the microbial association in sausages; members of four of the six commonly occurring genera bind sulfite through acetaldehyde production. Glucose appears to be essential for acetaldehyde synthesis. The role of glucose in spoilage and the conditions which select particular groups of spoilage organisms are considered in the context of chemical probes and/or instrumental methods for routine assessment of the "freshness" of meat and meat products.     

Growth of Bacteria on Meat at Room Temperatures

The development of spoilage flora and the growth of individual psychrotrophs and pathogens on meat held at 20 or 30°C were studied. Under aerobic conditions psychrotrophic pseudomonads accounted for 60% of the spoilage flora at 20°C, but <20% at 30°C where they were displaced by species of Acinetobacter and Enterobacteriaceae which included both mesophilic and psychrotrophic strains. Mesophiles dominated the anaerobic spoilage flora at 30°C when clostridia were the major species, but at 20° the flora contained mesophiles and psychrotrophs in similar proportions and was dominated by Enterobacteriaceae. These results were largely predictable from the growth rate data for individual organisms.
Interactions between species occurred more frequently at 20°C than at 30°C. When pathogenic species were grown at 20 or 30°Cin competition with equal numbers of psychrotrophic spoilage organisms, no interactions were observed. When pathogens were grown in competition with high numbers of psychrotrophs, only Lactobacillus growing anaerobically inhibited Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli , but other pathogens were inhibited to varying degrees depending on the competing species and the incubation conditions. In general, the degree of inhibition was greater at 20 than at 30°C and facultative organisms were more susceptible under anaerobic than aerobic conditions. It appears that the cumulative stresses of low pH, suboptimal temperatures and competition with large numbers of saprophytic organisms can inhibit many of the pathogens likely to be present on meat. The organisms least affected by the conditions on meat surfaces, Salmonella and Esch. coli , are likely to be the main hazards on meat of normal pH held at room temperatures.     

Assessment of the Stability of Pasteurized Comminuted Meat Products

S ummary . Data on the occurrence of spores in raw meat materials and in pasteurized meat products are presented. A survey of sporeforming organisms, isolated mainly from spoilt pasteurized meat products, is given. The preparation of a mixed spore suspension and its application to assess the various factors which influence the stability of pasteurized vacuum packed comminuted meat products are described. The incorporation of glucono-delta-lactone into meat mixes containing nitrite may improve the stability of the pasteurized products considerably, because it adjusts the pH value to an effective level.     

Spoilage of vacuum-packaged dark, firm, dry meat at chill temperatures.

The flora of vacuum-packaged dark, firm, dry meat included thred organisms not usually found on vacuum-packaged meat, Yersinia enterocolitica, Enterobacter liquefaciens, and Alteromonas putrefaciens. Y. enterocolitica did not affect the meat quality. Production of spoilage odors by E. liquefaciens could be prevented by addition of glucose or citrate to the meat. Greening of meat could be prevented by addition of glucose or citrate to the meat. Greening of meat by A. putrefaciens was not prevented by addition of glucose, as the organism degraded cysteine with the release of H2S even when glucose was present. To prevent greening, growth of A. putrefaciens must be inhibited by reducing the meat pH to less than 6.0.     

Spoilage of vacuum-packaged dark, firm, dry meat at chill temperatures.

The flora of vacuum-packaged dark, firm, dry meat included thred organisms not usually found on vacuum-packaged meat, Yersinia enterocolitica, Enterobacter liquefaciens, and Alteromonas putrefaciens. Y. enterocolitica did not affect the meat quality. Production of spoilage odors by E. liquefaciens could be prevented by addition of glucose or citrate to the meat. Greening of meat could be prevented by addition of glucose or citrate to the meat. Greening of meat by A. putrefaciens was not prevented by addition of glucose, as the organism degraded cysteine with the release of H2S even when glucose was present. To prevent greening, growth of A. putrefaciens must be inhibited by reducing the meat pH to less than 6.0.     

Volatile compounds associated with microbial growth on normal and high pH beef stored at chill temperatures

Volatile compounds produced by Pseudomonas fragi and mixed, natural floras on beef of normal pH (5.5-5.8; glucose greater than 1500 micrograms/g) and high pH (6.3-6.8; glucose less than 10 micrograms/g) included a range of alkyl esters and a number of sulphur-containing compounds including dimethylsulphide but not hydrogen sulphide. Production of the last was a property common to the other Gram-negative organisms tested viz. Hafnia alvei, Enterobacter agglomerans, Serratia liquefaciens, Alteromonas putrefaciens and Aeromonas hydrophila, all of which produced similar off-odours and, with the exception of E. agglomerans, 'greening' on high pH meat. Serratia liquefaciens also produced greening of normal pH meat. Acetoin and diacetyl were major end products of Brochothrix thermosphacta but the related 2,3-butanediol was formed only on normal pH meat. The Enterobacteriaceae produced the same compounds but only on normal pH meat and together with Br. thermosphacta were probable sources of these compounds and of the free and esterified branched-chain alcohols detected in the naturally contaminated samples.     

Fate of low temperature and acid-adapted Yersinia enterocolitica and Listeria monocytogenes that contaminate lactic acid decontaminated meat during chill storage

Pathogens found in the environment of abattoirs may become adapted to lactic acid used to decontaminate meat. Such organisms are more acid tolerant than non-adapted parents and can contaminate meat after lactic acid decontamination (LAD). The fate of acid-adapted Yersinia enterocolitica and Listeria monocytogenes, inoculated on skin surface of pork bellies 2 h after LAD, was examined during chilled storage. LAD included dipping in 1%, 2% or 5% lactic acid solutions at 55°C for 120 s. LAD brought about sharp reductions in meat surface pH, but these recovered with time after LAD at ≈1–1·5 pH units below that of water-treated controls. Growth permitting pH at 4·8–5·2 was reached after 1% LAD in less than 0·5 d (pH 4·8–5·0), 2% LAD within 1·5 d (pH 4·9–5·1) and after 5% LAD (pH 5·0–5·2) within 4 d. During the lag on 2% LAD meat Y. enterocolitica counts decreased by 0·9 log₁₀ cfu per cm² and on 5% LAD the reduction was more than 1·4 log₁₀ cfu per cm². The reductions in L. monocytogenes were about a third of those in Y. enterocolitica . On 1% LAD the counts of both pathogens did not decrease significantly. The generation times of Y. enterocolitica and L. monocytogenes on 2–5% LAD meats were by up to twofold longer than on water-treated controls and on 1% LAD-treated meat they were similar to those on water-treated controls. Low temperature and acid-adapted L. monocytogenes and Y. enterocolitica that contaminate skin surface after hot 2–5% LAD did not cause an increased health hazard, although the number of Gram-negative spoilage organisms were drastically reduced by hot 2–5% LAD and intrinsic (lactic acid content, pH) conditions were created that may benefit the survival and the growth of acid-adapted organisms.     

Incidence and Spoilage Potential of Isolates from Vacuum-packaged Meat of High pH Value

Meat of high pH value (6·6) showing dark-cutting characteristics was vacuum-packaged and stored for up to 8 weeks at 0–2°C. 'Off'-odours were detected on opening the packages after 6 weeks of storage. Total counts at this stage were ca. 10⁷/cm² of which lactobacilli were the major component, with ca. 10⁶/cm² Gram negative organisms. Psychrotrophic Enterobacteriaceae represented a major proportion of the microflora only after the full 8 weeks of storage and were not detected previously. Aerobic storage of steaks cut from the vacuum packaged meat stored for 8 weeks resulted in a predominantly Gram negative spoilage flora.
Inoculation studies on meat of normal pH value (5·4) and appearance using representative isolates from the vacuum-packaged meat microflora indicated that most of the test organisms were capable of causing spoilage under aerobic conditions but few under vacuum-packaging when incubated at 4°C. On meat of higher pH value (6·15) many of the Gram negative isolates did not grow as well, whereas the Gram positive isolates grew better than on meat of normal pH value when held under aerobic conditions. Under vacuum-packaging all but one isolate grew as well or better on meat of high pH value than on normal meat at 4°C and objectionable odours were more marked.     

Volatile compounds associated with microbial growth on normal and high pH beef stored at chill temperatures

Volatile compounds produced by Pseudomonas fragi and mixed, natural floras on beef of normal pH (5–5–5–8; glucose < 1500 μg/g) and high pH (6–3–6–8; glucose < 10 μg/g) included a range of alkyl esters and a number of sulphur-containing compounds including dimethylsulphide but not hydrogen sulphide. Production of the last was a property common to the other Gram-negative organisms tested viz. Hafnia alvei, Enterobacter agglomerans, Serratia liquefaciens, Alteromonas putrefaciens and Aeromonas hydrophila , all of which produced similar off-odours and, with the exception of E. agglomerans , 'greening'on high pH meat. Serratia liquefaciens also produced greening of normal pH meat. Acetoin and diacetyl were major end products of Brochothrix thermosphacta but the related 2,3-butanediol was formed only on normal pH meat. The Enterobacteriaceae produced the same compounds but only on normal pH meat and together with Br. thermosphacta were probable sources of these compounds and of the free and esterified branched-chain alcohols detected in the naturally contaminated samples.     

Fate of Bacteria in Chicken Meat During Freeze-Dehydration, Rehydration, and Storage

Total plate counts were determined on boneless cooked, cubed chicken meat obtained from a commercial processor. Survival of the natural flora was determined after the meat was freeze-dehydrated and rehydrated at room temperature for 30 min and 50, 85, and 100 C for 10 min. Total counts of bacteria in the rehydrated samples were determined during storage of the meat at 4, 22, and 37 C until spoilage odor was detectable. Meat samples were inoculated with Staphylococcus aureus, then dried, rehydrated, and stored at the same temperatures. Numbers of surviving organisms in the inoculated samples were determined with use of both selective and nonselective media. Representative genera surviving the various rehydration treatments were determined. Approximately 32% of the bacteria in the meat survived during dehydration and rehydration at room temperature. Many numbers and types of vegetative bacteria also survived rehydration at 50 C. When meat was rehydrated at 85 or 100 C, the initial count was less than one per gram. The only organisms isolated from samples rehydrated at 85 or 100 C were of the genus Bacillus. S. aureus in inoculated samples survived dehydration and rehydration at 60 C. Storage of all rehydrated samples at 4 C gave a good shelf life (18 or more days). The study indicates that freeze-dehydrated meat should be produced with adequate microbiological control and that such meat should be rehydrated in very hot water.     

Role of Broiler Carcasses and Processing Plant Air in Contamination of Modified-Atmosphere-Packaged Broiler Products with Psychrotrophic Lactic Acid Bacteria

Some psychrotrophic lactic acid bacteria (LAB) are specific meat spoilage organisms in modified-atmosphere-packaged (MAP), cold-stored meat products. To determine if incoming broilers or the production plant environment is a source of spoilage LAB, a total of 86, 122, and 447 LAB isolates from broiler carcasses, production plant air, and MAP broiler products, respectively, were characterized using a library of HindIII restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) patterns of the 16 and 23S rRNA genes as operational taxonomic units in numerical analyses. Six hundred thirteen LAB isolates from the total of 655 clustered in 29 groups considered to be species specific. Sixty-four percent of product isolates clustered either with Carnobacterium divergens or with Carnobacterium maltaromaticum type strains. The third major product-associated cluster (17% of isolates) was formed by unknown LAB. Representative strains from these three clusters were analyzed for the phylogeny of their 16S rRNA genes. This analysis verified that the two largest RFLP clusters consisted of carnobacteria and showed that the unknown LAB group consisted of Lactococcus spp. No product-associated LAB were detected in broiler carcasses sampled at the beginning of slaughter, whereas carnobacteria and lactococci, along with some other specific meat spoilage LAB, were recovered from processing plant air at many sites. This study reveals that incoming broiler chickens are not major sources of psychrotrophic spoilage LAB, whereas the detection of these organisms from the air of the processing environment highlights the role of processing facilities as sources of LAB contamination.     

Use of the polymerase chain reaction and 16S rRNA sequences for the rapid detection of Brochothrix spp. in foods

Oligonucleotide primers were designed against rRNA sequences to give a DNA-based PCR assay for the rapid identification/detection of Brochothrix spp. The PCR products could be confirmed by hybridization to an internal oligonucleotide probe. The method successfully and sensitively detected/identified these organisms in pure cultures but was of limited value as a detection method because the detection sensitivity, in relation to conventional plate counts, varied and the assay sensitivity was reduced in the presence of staphylococci. Furthermore, sensitivity was also lost when the assay was applied directly to meat samples. However, a separation step using a lectin (from Agaricus bisporus ) immobilized on magnetic beads prior to the PCR assay, allowed the direct detection of low numbers (> 10 cfu g^-1) of Brochothrix in meat samples within a working day.     

Heat Inactivation of In Vivo- and In Vitro-Grown Mycobacteria in Meat Products

Heat inactivation of mycobacteria from lesions and from culture was compared in meat products. In vivo-grown organisms were more easily heat inactivated than were in vitro-grown organisms.     

Conditions affecting growth and enterotoxin production by Staphylococcus aureus on temperature-abused chicken meat

Growth of Staphylococcus aureus at 15°C, with and without addition of representative spoilage bacteria, was studied in cooked, whole chicken meat and chicken broth. In the absence of competitors, the organism grew better in broth culture than on whole meat, but multiplied more slowly in broth when other organisms were present, even from twice the previous level of inoculum. The presence of competitors had no marked effect on the growth of Staph. aureus on whole meat. Enterotoxin A was not produced at 15°C on either whole meat or in broth, and occurred at 20°C only in pure culture. At 30° and 37°C, toxin was produced whether or not competitors were present. Toxin production by Staph. aureus appeared to be influenced more by growth temperature than by bacterial competition.     

Locating nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis in a fermented meat system

S.C. STRINGER, C.E.R. DODD, M.R.A. MORGAN AND W.M. WAITES. 1995. Antibody-linked probes were used to locate nisin in a fermented meat system. Free nisin or nisin bound to susceptible cells or food components was not detected. Colonies of nisin-producing Lactococcus lactis were stained at all times during growth. The position of nisin-producing L. lactis colonies was noted and compared with the location of spoilage organisms or the distribution of areas with a fermented meat appearance. No relationship between the distribution of starter culture and the location of spoilage organisms or areas of fermentation was observed. In addition to the presence of L. lactis , a rapidly fermentable sugar was also required to obtain a fermented appearance and to reduce the levels of spoilage organisms.     

The Use of Streptococcus faecalis as an Indicator of the Hygienic Condition of Meat Preserves and the Possibility of Interference by Aerococcus viridans

Summary: Few arguments may be put forward in favour of the use of Escherichia coli as an indicator of the hygienic condition of preserved meat products. In products of this type E. coli occurs only rarely. The proposal, which is supported by logical considerations and practical experience, to replace this organism by Streptococcus faecalis as an indicator of possible faecal contamination is strongly upheld by the authors. However, it is necessary to stress that the ubiquitous micro-organism, Aerococcus viridans , occurs frequently in preserved meat products and, as it strongly resembles Strep. faecalis , may cause difficulties in the hygienic evaluation of such foods. The morphological and biological characteristics found suitable for differentiating these two organisms are described. Results supporting the view that Aerococcus, Pediococcus and Gaffkya be considered as distinct genera are also given.     

The Behaviour of a Food Poisoning Strain of Clostridium welchii in Beef

S ummary : An inoculum of 10⁵ spores of Clostridium welchii F2985/50 in meat survived steaming at 100° for 5 h, the number being reduced sevenfold for every hour of steaming. They also survived for at least 6 months in frozen meat stored at -5° and -20°, whereas vegetative cells died more rapidly at -5° than at -20°. In beef stored for 13 days at 1°, 5°, 10° and 15° there was no multiplication but a slow destruction of vegetative cells, but there was little change in the spore count. Slow multiplication occurred at 20° but at 25° and 37° growth was rapid. Only about 3% of the spores germinated without prior heat shock, so the majority failed to germinate in raw meat stored at any temperature, but did so once the meat had been heated. In meat which had been heated and allowed to cool almost all of the spores had lost their heat resistance.
It was found that the minimal growth temperature was related to pH and medium, so that meat with a pH higher than that used in these experiments (pH 5°7–5°8) would probably have a lower minimal growth temperature for these organisms and would thus be more susceptible to spoilage.