Evolution of the monocot gynoecium: evidence from comparative morphology and development in Tofieldia, Japonolirion, Petrosavia and Narthecium

We present new comparative morphological and developmental data on gynoecia of three genera of early-divergent monocots: Tofieldia (Tofieldiaceae, Alismatales), Petrosavia and Japonolirion (Petrosaviaceae, Petrosaviales) and one lilioid monocot: Narthecium (Nartheciaceae, Dioscoreales). Our data show significant differences between the genera examined, and are congruent with the splitting of former Nartheciaceae sensu Tamura (1998) into families Tofieldiaceae, Petrosaviaceae NB-cosistent with later and Nartheciacae (APG II 2003). Our investigation confirms the presence of at least partial carpel fusion in all taxa examined. Previous data indicating apocarpy in Japonolirion, some Petrosavia and Tofieldia could be due to late postgenital carpel fusion in these plants. Syncarpy also characterises other early-divergent monocot lineages such as Acoraceae and Araceae. It is most parsimonious to regard syncarpy as a primitive condition for monocots, but an alternative scenario suggests that apocarpy is plesiomorphic among monocots, involving multiple origins of syncarpy. The latter hypothesis is supported by significant differences between gynoecia of early-divergent monocots, including different modes of carpel fusion.     

Embryology of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Japonolirion</Emphasis> (Petrosaviaceae,Petrosaviales): a comparison with other monocots

Japonolirion osense, the sole species of the genus, endemic to Japan, which is placed together with Petrosavia in the Petrosaviaceae and the order Petrosaviales, is still poorly known with respect to systematic characters. Here I present an embryological study of the anther, ovule, and seed of J. osense. Japonolirion is characterized by a glandular anther tapetum, simultaneous cytokinesis in the microspore mother cell, two-celled mature pollen grains, anatropous and crassinucellate ovules, a two-cell-layered nucellar cap formed early in ovule development, antipodal cells hypertrophied in post-fertilization stages, the ab initio cellular mode of endosperm formation, and exotegmic seeds. Comparisons with the basal monocots Acorus (Acorales) and Araceae (Alismatales), and with the more derived monocots Nartheciaceae (Dioscoreales) and Velloziaceae/Triuridaceae (Pandanales), showed that Japonolirion is clearly distinct from those basal and more derived monocots, supporting a distinct position for Petrosaviaceae or Petrosaviales within the monocots. Extensive comparisons further suggest that the two-cell-layered nucellar cap, whose cells are rich in cytoplasm at the time of fertilization in Japonolirion and thus obviously function as the obturator, is likely to be a common characteristic of the basal monocots and may even be a link with the magnoliids.     

Recircumscription of the monocotyledonous family Petrosaviaceae to include Japonolirion

Most systematists have favored placing Petrosaviaceae close to the Triuridaceae (formerly positioned within Alismatidae) by focusing on the mycoheterotrophic habit and nearly free carpels of Petrosaviaceae. Others have favored a position near the melanthioid lilies, perhaps serving as a linking-family to the Triuridaceae. We discuss the results of recently published, independent, and combined DNA sequence analyses that indicate a strongly supported sister relationship betweenPetrosavia (Petrosaviaceae) andJaponolirion (Japonoliriaceae). Molecular data show no connection of these genera to the Alismatales (including Tofieldiaceae), the Melanthiaceae s. str., the Liliales, or the Triuridaceae (now in Pandanales), although there are morphological similarities to each of these groups. A relationship to the Pandanales has been indicated in some molecular analyses, but this is not supported by bootstrap/jackknife analyses or by most morphological characters. BothPetrosavia andJaponolirion are native to high-evelation habitats and have bracteate racemes, pedicellate flowers, six persistent tepals, septal nectaries, three nearly distinct carpels, simultaneous microsporogenesis, monosulcate pollen, and follicular fruits. Outside of the Alismatales, no other monocotyledons share this combination of features. We therefore suggest that the Petrosaviaceae be re-circumscribed to includeJaponolirion. If the family's isolated position among the monocot orders continues to be found in phylogenetic studies, then recognition of the already published order Petrosaviales would be appropriate.     

Molecular phylogeny of monocotyledons inferred from combined analysis of plastid<Emphasis Type="Italic"> matK</Emphasis> and<Emphasis Type="Italic"> rbcL</Emphasis> gene sequences

Using matK and rbcL sequences (3,269 bp in total) from 113 genera of 45 families, we conducted a combined analysis to contribute to the understanding of major evolutionary relationships in the monocotyledons. Trees resulting from the parsimony analysis are similar to those generated by earlier single or multiple gene analyses, but their strict consensus tree provides much better resolution of relationships among major clades. We find that Acorus (Acorales) is a sister group to the rest of the monocots, which receives 100% bootstrap support. A clade comprising Alismatales is diverged as the next branch, followed successively by Petrosaviaceae, the Dioscoreales–Pandanales clade, Liliales, Asparagales and commelinoids. All of these clades are strongly supported (with more than 90% bootstrap support). The sister-group relationship is also strongly supported between Alismatales and the remaining monocots (except for Acorus) (100%), between Petrosaviaceae and the remaining monocots (except for Acorus and Alismatales) (100%), between the clade comprising Dioscoreales and Pandanales and the clade comprising Liliales, Asparagales and commelinoids (87%), and between Liliales and the Asparagales–commelinoids clade (89%). Only the sister-group relationship between Asparagales and commelinoids is weakly supported (68%). Results also support the inclusion of Petrosaviaceae in its own order Petrosaviales, Nartheciaceae in Dioscoreales and Hanguanaceae in Commelinales.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available in the online version of this article at http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10265-003-0133-3     

单子叶植物高级分类阶元系统演化: matK、rbcL和18S rDNA序列的证据

基于两个叶绿体基因（matK和rbcL）和一个核糖体基因（18S rDNA）的序列分析,对代表了基部被子植物和单子叶植物主要谱系分支的86科126属151种被子植物（单子叶植物58科86属101种）进行了系统演化关系分析。研究结果表明由胡椒目Piperales、樟目Laurales、木兰目Magnoliales和林仙目Canellales构成的真木兰类复合群是单子叶植物的姐妹群。单子叶植物的单系性在3个序列联合分析中得到98％的强烈自展支持。联合分析鉴定出9个单子叶植物主要谱系（广义泽泻目Alismatales、薯蓣目Dioscorcales、露兜树目Pandanales、天门冬目Asparagalcs、百合目Liliales、棕榈目Arecales、禾本目Poales、姜目Zingiberales、鸭跖草目Commelinales）和6个其他被子植物主要谱系（睡莲目Nymphaeales、真双子叶植物、木兰目、樟目、胡椒目、林仙目）。在单子叶植物内,菖蒲目Acorales（菖蒲属Acorus）是单子叶植物最早分化的一个谱系,广义泽泻目（包括天南星科Araceae和岩菖蒲科Toficldiaccae）紧随其后分化出来,二者依次和其余单子叶植物类群构成姐妹群关系。无叶莲科Petrosaviaceac紧随广义的泽泻目之后分化出来,无叶莲科和剩余的单子叶植物类群形成姐妹群关系,并得到了较高的支持率。继无叶莲科之后分化的类群形成两个大的分支：一支是由露兜树目和薯蓣目构成,二者形成姐妹群关系：另一支是由天门冬目、百合目和鸭跖草类复合群组成,三者之间的关系在单个序列分析和联合分析中不稳定,需要进一步扩大取样范围来确定。在鸭跖草类复合群分支内,鸭跖草目和姜目的姐妹群关系在3个序列联合分析和2个序列联合分析的严格一致树中均得到强烈的自展支持,获得的支持率均是100％。但是,对于棕榈目和禾本目在鸭跖草类中的系统位置以及它们和鸭跖草目-姜目之间的关系,有待进一步解决。值得注意的是,无叶莲科与其他单子叶植物类群（除菖蒲目和泽泻目外）的系统关系在本文中获得较高的自展支持率,薯蓣目和天门冬目的单系性在序列联合分析中都得到了较好的自展支持,而这些在以往的研究中通常支持率较低。鉴于菖蒲科和无叶莲科独特的系统演化位置,本文支持将其分别独立成菖蒲目和无叶莲目Petrosavialcs的分类学界定。     

Significant difference in mycorrhizal specificity between an autotrophic and its sister mycoheterotrophic plant species of Petrosaviaceae

Petrosaviaceae is a monocotyledonous plant family that comprises two genera: the autotrophic Japonolirion and the mycoheterotrophic Petrosavia. Accordingly, this plant family provides an excellent system to examine specificity differences in mycobionts between autotrophic and closely related mycoheterotrophic plant species. We investigated mycobionts of Japonolirion osense, the sole species of the monotypic genus, from all known habitats of this species by molecular identification and detected 22 arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungal phylotypes in Archaesporales, Diversisporales, and Glomerales. In contrast, only one AM fungal phylotype in Glomerales was predominantly detected from the mycoheterotrophic Petrosavia sakuraii in a previous study. The high mycobiont diversity in J. osense and in an outgroup plant, Miscanthus sinensis (Poaceae), indicates that fungal specificity increased during the evolution of mycohetrotrophy in Petrosaviaceae. Furthermore, some AM fungal sequences of J. osense showed >99 % sequence similarity to the dominant fungal phylotype of P. sakuraii, and one of them was nested within a clade of P. sakuraii mycobionts. These results indicate that fungal partners are not necessarily shifted, but rather selected for in the course of the evolution of mycoheterotrophy. We also confirmed the Paris-type mycorrhiza in J. osense.     

Endosperm development in the Araceae (Alismatales) and evolution of developmental modes in monocots

The Araceae, a basal-most family of Alismatales that basally diverged subsequent to Acorales in monocot phylogeny, are known to have diverse modes of endosperm development: nuclear, helobial, and cellular. However, the occurrence of nuclear and helobial endosperm development has long been debated. Here, we report a (re-)investigation of endosperm development in Lysichiton, Orontium, and Symplocarpus of the Orontioideae (a basal Araceae), in which nuclear endosperm development was recorded more than 100 years ago. The results show that all three genera exhibit a cellular, rather than nuclear, endosperm development and suggest that the helobial endosperm development reported as an “unmistakable record” from Ariopsis is likely cellular. Thus the Araceae are very likely characterized by cellular endosperm development alone. An extensive comparison with other monocots in light of phylogenetic relationships demonstrates that a plesiomorphic cellular endosperm development is restricted to the three basal monocot orders Acorales, Alismatales, and Petrosaviales, in which evolutionary changes from cellular to nuclear endosperm development occurred twice as major events, once within Alismatales and once as a synapomorphy of the eight remaining monocot orders, including Dioscoreales, Liliales, Asparagales, and Poales, and that helobial endosperm development, which is known for many monocot families, evolved as homoplasy throughout the monocots.     

A SURVEY OF FLORAL ANATOMY IN ARACEAE

Flowers of 23 species representing six subfamilies of Araceae were studied by means of serial cross sections, special attention being given to vascular patterns and to taxa of supposed phylogenetic importance. Floral structure is shown to be extremely diverse with no unifying pattern common to all subfamilies. Conclusions include the following: (1) Lysichiton has a specialized gynoecial vascular pattern which differs from others encountered in the survey and which weighs against the primitive position attributed to this genus by Hutchinson. (2) Philodendron, with its multiple stylar canals, cannot have originated from subfamily Pothoideae, as Engler's phylogenetic concept would require of all Araceae; instead, it appears that several syncarpous evolutionary lines have evolved independently from extinct apocarpous members of the family. (3) In Acorus, stamens are introrse and dorsal carpellary bundles are lacking; these characters and others justify the recognition of Acorus as a separate subfamily Acoroideae. In addition, the survey revealed a peculiar deterioration of the inner ovary wall and the septa in several taxa, apparently a normal feature of floral development. Spathiphyllum solomonense Nicolson is described in an appendix.     

EVOLUTIONARY AND ECOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE OF STARCH STORAGE IN POLLEN OF THE ARACEAE

Starch content was qualitatively assessed for pollen of 79 of the 111 currently recognized genera of the family Araceae—one of three monocot families known to exhibit both starchy and starchless pollen. Although 73% of the genera investigated had exclusively starchy pollen, character correlation suggests that starchless pollen is the primitive type for the family Araceae, as well as for monocots in general. Pollen starch content is a highly conservative character at the generic level in Araceae; only a single genus (Schismatoglottis) clearly exhibits both character states. The distribution of starchy pollen among aroid genera is consistent with what have here been termed Bakers' Starch Laws. Aroid pollen below a certain critical diameter—17-25 μm—is almost invariably starchless. Larger pollen is nearly always starchy, except where insect pollinators may use pollen nutritionally. There is strong evidence that the trend from starchless to starchy pollen in Araceae is reversible, according to the constraints imposed by the aforementioned factors.     

Embryology of Harrisonia (Cneoroideae,Rutaceae): a comparison with related genera and families

Harrisonia, a genus of three or more species distributed from tropical Africa and Southeast Asia to northern Australia, has long been considered a member of Simaroubaceae. Recent molecular analyses, however, have shown that the genus is assigned to subfamily Cneoroideae of Rutaceae, in which Cneoroideae (eight genera) are sister to the remainder of the family (‘core Rutaceae’). Here, we report embryological features of Harrisonia based on published and newly obtained data and provide morphological corroboration for the molecular affinities of the genus and Cneoroideae. We compared its embryological features with those of seven other genera of Cneoroideae and with those of the core Rutaceae and related families (Meliaceae, Simaroubaceae and Sapindaceae). Comparisons showed that Harrisonia fits within Cneoroideae through possessing campylotropous seeds with a multi‐cell‐layered endotesta. Embryological evidence, like molecular evidence, further shows that, in Cneoroideae, Harrisonia probably has affinities to a group of Bottegoa, Cedrelopsis, Cneorum and Ptaeroxylon by sharing a micropyle formed by the inner integument alone and solitary oil cells in the testa. Except for Harrisonia, Cneoroideae are still poorly understood embryologically and further investigations are needed.     

Microsporogenesis in Monocotyledons

This paper critically reviews the distribution of microsporogenesistypes in relation to recent concepts in monocot systematics.Two basic types of microsporogenesis are generally recognized:successive and simultaneous, although intermediates occur. Theseare characterized by differences in tetrad morphology, generallytetragonal or tetrahedral, although other forms occur, particularlyassociated with successive division. Successive microsporogenesisis predominant in monocotyledons, although the simultaneoustype characterizes the ‘lower’ Asparagales. Simultaneousmicrosporogenesis also occurs inJaponolirion and Petrosavia(unplaced taxa), some Araceae, Aponogeton, Thalassia andTofieldia(Alismatales), Dioscorea, Stenomeris and Tacca (Dioscoreales),and some Commelinanae: Arecaceae (Arecales), and Cyperaceae,Juncaceae and Thurniaceae (Poales). Simultaneous microsporogenesisis of phylogenetic significance within some of these groups,for example, Asparagales, Dioscoreales and Poales. An intermediatetype is recorded in Stemonaceae (Pandanales), Commelinaceae(Commelinales) and in Eriocaulaceae and Flagellariaceae (Poales).There is little direct relationship between microsporogenesistype and pollen aperture type in monocots (except for trichotomosulcateand pantoporate apertures), although trichotomosulcate aperturesin monocot pollen, and equatorial tricolpate and tricolporateapertures in eudicot pollen, are all related to simultaneousmicrosporogenesis. Copyright 1999 Annals of Botany Company Microsporogenesis, monocotyledons, pollen apertures, phylogeny, tetrads, simultaneous, successive, systematics.     

PATTERNS OF ENDOTHECIAL WALL THICKENINGS IN ARACEAE: SUBFAMILIES POTHOIDEAE AND MONSTEROIDEAE

A survey of the patterns of endothecial wall thickenings in 106 representative species from 20 genera in the Pothoideae and Monsteroideae was made using cleared anthers, sections and macerations. The wide variety of wall thickenings that is present is based on an annular-helical pattern. Variations in thickenings are related to differences in cell shape, cell orientation, intergradation between helical and annular patterns, pitch of helices, presence of branched thickenings, and various types of discontinuities in thickenings. Notable exceptions to the annular-helical pattern include Culcasia, which lacks a differentiated endothecial layer with thickenings, and Acorus, which has a peculiar stellate pattern that is unique in the family. No single pattern consistently characterizes either subfamily, although continuous helices are common in the Monsteroideae, and rare in the endothecium of Pothoideae (except Anadendrum). Monsteroideae frequently exhibit a series of slanted separate thickenings on anticlinal walls, which is absent from Pothoideae except in Heteropsis. The slanted pattern is considered a variation on a rectangular helix, involving discontinuities of thickenings on the periclinal walls. Some monsteroid genera show considerably more interspecific variation (Rhaphidophora) than others (Monstera). Endothecial thickenings constitute an anatomical character that is useful in the systematic study of Araceae; present results support other anatomical studies in identifying Culcasia and Acorus as highly divergent genera in the Pothoideae.     

Sieve-element plastids and evolution of monocotyledons, with emphasis on Melanthiaceae sensu lato and Aristolochiaceae-Asaroideae, a putative dicotyledon sister group

Monocotyledons are distinguishable from dicotyledons by their subtype P2 sieve-element plastids containing cuneate protein crystals, a synapomorphic character uniformly present from basal groups through Lilioids to Commelinoids. The dicotyledon generaAsarum andSaruma (Aristolochiaceae-Asaroideae) are the only other taxa with cuneate crystals, but their sieveelement plastids include an additional large polygonal crystal, as is typical of many eumagnoliids. New investigations in Melanthiaceae s.l. revealed the same pattern (polygonal plus cuneate crystals) in the sieve-element plastids ofJaponolirion osense (Japonoliriaceae/Petrosaviaceae), ofHarperocallis flava, Pleea tenuifolia, andTofleldia (all: Tofieldiaceae). InNarthecium ossifragum a large crystal, present in addition to cuneate ones, usually breaks up into several small crystals, whereas inAletris glabra andLophiola americana (Nartheciaceae) and in all of the 15 species studied and belonging to Melanthiaceae s.str. only cuneate crystals are found. Highresolution TEM pictures reveal a crystal substructure that is densely packed in both cuneate and polygonal forms, but in Tofieldiaceae the polygonal crystals stain less densely, probably as a result of the slightly wider spacing of their subunits. The small crystals ofNarthecium are “loose”; that is, much more widely spaced. Such “loose” crystals are commonly found in sieve-element plastids of Velloziaceae, present there in addition to angular crystals, and together with cuneate crystals in a few Lilioids and many taxa of Poales (Commelinoids). Ontogenetic studies of the sieve elements ofSaruma, Aristolochia, and several monocotyledons have shown that in their plastids cuneate crystals develop very early and independent from a polygonal one present in some taxa. Therefore, a conceivable particulation of polygonal into cuneate crystals is excluded. Consequently, mutations of some monocotyledons that contain a lone, large, polygonal crystal in their sieve-element plastids are explained as the result of a complex genetic block. The total result of all studies in sieve-element plastids suggests thatJaponolirion and Tofieldiaceae are the most basal monocotyledons and that Aristolochiaceae are their dicotyledon sister group.     

An analysis of flavonoid compounds in leaves of Japonolirion (Petrosaviaceae)

Japonolirion, comprising Japonolirion osense Nakai, which occurs on serpentinite at two widely separated localities in Japan, has been considered as an isolated taxon, but more recently has been proved by molecular evidence to be a sister group to an achlorophyllous, mycoheterotrophic genus, Petrosavia. In an effort to research possible characters linking these groups, we analyzed the flavonoid compounds obtained from leaves of Japonolirion using UV spectra, mass spectrometry and ¹H and ¹³C nuclear magnetic resonance, and acid hydrolysis of the original glycosides as well as direct thin layer chromatography and high performance liquid chromatography comparisons with authentic specimens. As a result, we identified seven flavonoids, of which two were major components identified as 6-C-glucosylquercetin 3-O-glucoside and isoorientin. The remaining five were minor components identified as 6-C-glucosylkaempferol 3-O-glucoside, quercetin 3-O-glucoside, quercetin 3-O-arabinoside, vicenin-2 and orientin. Both 6-C-glucosylquercetin 3-O-glucoside and 6-C-glucosylkaempferol 3-O-glucoside were recorded for the first time in nature. Because of their restricted occurrence in angiosperms, both C-glycosylflavonols and 3-O-glycosides of C-glycosylflavonols may be significant chemical markers for assessing relationships of J. osense.     

An anatomical study of anther development in Acorus L.: Phylogenetic implications

 Critical morphological synapomorphies have not been found in support of the Acoranan hypothesis, the molecular phylogenetic discovery that Acoranae are the basal monocots. The previously undetermined pattern of anther wall development in Acorus has been suggested to be one such character. Two main types of anther wall development have been recognized: 1) the “monocotyledonous” type, which characterizes both monocots and dicots, and 2) the “dicotyledonous” type, which is almost exclusively found among dicots. An anatomical study of anther wall development in Acorus was here undertaken using the electron microscope. Development of the anther wall in Acorus was found to be somewhat irregular or perhaps even intermediate between the two types although largely consistent with the “monocotyledonous” type. The presumed significance of anther wall development and other critical morphological characters to the Acoranan hypothesis in the absence of knowledge about the sister group to the monocots is evaluated. Received August 28, 2000 Accepted February 19, 2001     

Target sequence data shed new light on the infrafamilial classification of Araceae

Premise

Recent phylogenetic studies of the Araceae have confirmed the position of the duckweeds nested within the aroids, and the monophyly of a clade containing all the unisexual flowered aroids plus the bisexual-flowered Calla palustris. The main objective of the present study was to better resolve the deep phylogenetic relationships among the main lineages within the family, particularly the relationships between the eight currently recognized subfamilies. We also aimed to confirm the phylogenetic position of the enigmatic genus Calla in relation to the long-debated evolutionary transition between bisexual and unisexual flowers in the family.

Methods

Nuclear DNA sequence data were generated for 128 species across 111 genera (78%) of Araceae using target sequence capture and the Angiosperms 353 universal probe set.

Results

The phylogenomic data confirmed the monophyly of the eight Araceae subfamilies, but the phylogenetic position of subfamily Lasioideae remains uncertain. The genus Calla is included in subfamily Aroideae, which has also been expanded to include Zamioculcadoideae. The tribe Aglaonemateae is newly defined to include the genera Aglaonema and Boycea.

Conclusions

Our results strongly suggest that new research on African genera (Callopsis, Nephthytis, and Anubias) and Calla will be important for understanding the early evolution of the Aroideae. Also of particular interest are the phylogenetic positions of the isolated genera Montrichardia, Zantedeschia, and Anchomanes, which remain only moderately supported here.     

Plastid phylogenomics and molecular evolution of Alismatales

Past phylogenetic studies of the monocot order Alismatales left several higher‐order relationships unresolved. We addressed these uncertainties using a nearly complete genus‐level sampling of whole plastid genomes (gene sets representing 83 protein‐coding and ribosomal genes) from members of the core alismatid families, Tofieldiaceae and additional taxa (Araceae and other angiosperms). Parsimony and likelihood analyses inferred generally highly congruent phylogenetic relationships within the order, and several alternative likelihood partitioning schemes had little impact on patterns of clade support. All families with multiple genera were resolved as monophyletic, and we inferred strong bootstrap support for most inter‐ and intrafamilial relationships. The precise placement of Tofieldiaceae in the order was not well supported. Although most analyses inferred Tofieldiaceae to be the sister‐group of the rest of the order, one likelihood analysis indicated a contrasting Araceae‐sister arrangement. Acorus (Acorales) was not supported as a member of the order. We also investigated the molecular evolution of plastid NADH dehydrogenase, a large enzymatic complex that may play a role in photooxidative stress responses. Ancestral‐state reconstructions support four convergent losses of a functional NADH dehydrogenase complex in Alismatales, including a single loss in Tofieldiaceae.     

Embryology of Abeliophyllum (Oleaceae) and its phylogenetic relationships

Abeliophyllum, a monotypic endemic genus of Oleaceae, resembles Forsythia in various morphological characters, but its phylogenetic position is disputed and no embryological study of the genus has been carried out. We investigated more than 40 embryological characters of Abeliophyllum, compared them with previous information on Oleaceae, and discusses its phylogenetic relationships. Abeliophyllum is similar to other genera of Oleaceae in many embryological features, having some distinct features such as the mode of anther wall formation, formation of a nucellar cap, and formation of obturator and hypostase. The basic type of anther wall development and formation of a nucellar cap have not previously been reported in Oleaceae. In addition, differentiation of the obturator and formation of hypostase are not reported in the previously investigated genera of the family. Compared with close relatives, the seed coat structure of Abeliophyllum resembles Forsythia more than Fontanesia and supports existing molecular data which place Abeliophyllum as the sister group of Forsythia.     

Contribution of pollen and tapetal characters to the systematics of Triuridaceae

 Pollen and tapetal characters in the mycoheterotrophic monocot family Triuridaceae are here compared with those of their putative relatives, including the lilioid order Pandanales (Pandanaceae, Cyclanthaceae, Velloziaceae and Stemonaceae), with which Triuridaceae have recently been associated following analyses of molecular data. Triuridaceae have small, inaperturate (functionally monoaperturate) pollen grains with the exine reduced to gemmae which have distinctive protruberances or spines. Microsporogenesis is of the successive type. Some genera have a plasmodial tapetum. Orbicules are absent. These characters are compatible with a relationship with Pandanaceae, but a relationship with Alismatales, as suggested by earlier authors, cannot be excluded. Received June 18, 2002; accepted July 22, 2002 Published online: November 22, 2002 Address of the authors: Carol A. Furness (e-mail: c.furness@rbgkew.org.uk), Paula J. Rudall and Alison Eastman, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, Richmond, Surrey, TW9 3AB, UK.