Novel nonviral vectors for gene delivery: Synthesis and applications

We have synthesized novel cationiclipids for gene delivery bearing an ester bond betweenthe lipid moiety and the polyamine head. We have foundthat an intramolecular rearrangement occurs duringpurification of one of the products. The rearrangementled to a cyclic lipopolyamine which was active for DNAgene transfer. The formation ofcyclization products depends on the spacer foundbetween the lipid and the polyamine. The introduction ofarginine in the linker position prevents the formation ofcyclic products. Linear as well as cyclicanalogues showed high-efficiency gene transfer whentested in vitro for luciferase gene expressionas compared to dioctadecylamidoglycyl spermineor lipofectamine and also in vivo in the Lewislung carcinoma model. The introduction of arginine in thelinker position promoted increased transfectionactivity, demonstrating that a diversity of linkers,such as short peptides or glycosides, can beintroduced into cationic lipids for targeted gene transfer.     

Evaluation of cationic assemblies constructed with amino acid based lipids for plasmid DNA delivery

We synthesized cationic lipids bearing lysine, histidine, or arginine as a cationic headgroup for use in gene transfer studies. The cationic assemblies formed from lysine- or arginine-type lipids gave unilamellar vesicles (approximately 100 nm diameter), whereas the morphology of the histidine-type lipids was tube-like. The competences of the cationic assemblies were sufficient to form lipoplexes, and the resulting lipoplexes were evaluated in terms of gene expression efficiencies with COS-7 cells. The lysine- or arginine-type lipids exhibited higher gene expression efficiencies than that of Lipofectamine2000, a conventional transgenic reagent, indicating that stable lipoplexes could be prepared between spherical cationic assemblies and plasmid DNA. The gene expression efficiency in relation to the cationic headgroup of the lipids was as follows: lysine > or = arginine > histidine. In addition, gene expression efficiency was enhanced by decreasing the length of the alkyl chain of the hydrophobic moiety. Unlike Lipofectamine2000, no reduction in transfection efficiency in the presence of fetal bovine serum was observed for the lipoplexes formed using synthetic cationic lipids. Moreover, the synthetic cationic lipids revealed remarkably low cytotoxicity compared with Lipofectamine2000. In conclusion, cationic assemblies formed from 1,5-ditetradecyl-N-lysyl-L-glutamate or 1,5-ditetradecyl-N-arginyl-L-glutamate can be used as an effective plasmid DNA delivery system.     

Optimization of cationic lipid mediated gene transfer: structure-function,physico-chemical,and cellular studies

The rationale design aimed at the enhancement of cationic lipid mediated gene transfer is discussed. These improvements are based on the straight evaluation of the structure-activity relationship and on the introduction of new structures. Much attention have been given to the supramolecular structures of the lipid/DNA complexes, to the effect of serum on gene transfer and to the intracellular trafficking of the lipoplexes. Finally new avenue using reducible cationic lipids has been discussed.     

Incorporation of oxyethylene units between hydrocarbon chain and pseudoglyceryl backbone in cationic lipid potentiates gene transfection efficiency in the presence of serum.

Four novel cationic lipids with different numbers of oxyethylene units at the linkage region between the pseudoglyceryl backbone and the hydrocarbon chains have been synthesized and used as mixtures with 1,2-dioleoyl-L-alpha-glycero-3-phosphatidyl ethanolamine (DOPE) for liposome-mediated gene transfection. Incorporation of different numbers of oxyethylene (-CH(2)CH(2)O-) units between long hydrocarbon chain at the C-1 and C-2 positions of the pseudoglyceryl skeleton improved the transfection efficiency considerably compared to the one in which the chains were connected via simple ether links. A pronounced improvement in the gene transfer efficiency was observed with the unsymmetrical cationic lipid 3 in which the long hydrocarbon at the C-1 position of the pseudoglyceryl segment is connected via two (-CH(2)CH(2)O-) units. Notably, the transfection ability of lipid 3 with DOPE in the presence of serum was significantly greater than LIPOFECTAMINE. This suggests that introduction of oxyethylene units between long hydrocarbon chains at the C-1 and C-2 positions of the pseudoglyceryl skeleton provides a novel strategy to achieve efficient gene transfer, especially in conditions where the presence of serum is critical.     

OPTIMIZATION OF CATIONIC LIPID MEDIATED GENE TRANSFER: STRUCTURE-FUNCTION,PHYSICO-CHEMICAL,AND CELLULAR STUDIES

ABSTRACT

The rationale design aimed at the enhancement of cationic lipid mediated gene transfer is discussed. These improvements are based on the straight evaluation of the structure-activity relationship and on the introduction of new structures. Much attention have been given to the supramolecular structures of the lipid/DNA complexes, to the effect of serum on gene transfer and to the intracellular trafficking of the lipoplexes. Finally new avenue using reducible cationic lipids has been discussed.     

Use of dithiodiglycolic acid as a tether for cationic lipids decreases the cytotoxicity and increases transgene expression of plasmid DNA in vitro.

Two major barriers that limit cationic lipids in gene delivery are low transfection efficiency and toxicity. In the present studies, we used dithiodiglycolic acid as a new tether for the polar and hydrophobic domains of a cationic lipid, cholesteryl hemidithiodiglycolyl tris(aminoethyl)amine (CHDTAEA). We compared the transfection activity and toxicity of CHDTAEA with its nondisulfide analogue and cholesteryl N-(dimethylaminoethyl) carbamate (DC-Chol). The liposomes of CHDTAEA had more than 2 orders of magnitude greater transfection activity than DC-Chol in CHO cells and 7 times greater transfection activity in SKnSH cells. CHDTAEA also demonstrated much less toxicity than the other two lipids. Dithiodiglycolic acid may act as an excellent linker in the application of cationic lipid syntheses.     

Efficient gene transfection by bisguanylated diacetylene lipid formulations

We have previously shown that cationic cholesterol derivatives bearing guanidinium groups were efficient vectors for gene transfer. To further evaluate the potentiality of this novel class of cationic lipids, we undertook to study the transfection efficiency of guanidinium-based lipids with other hydrophobic moieties. Specifically, we synthesized a reagent where two guanidinium groups are linked to a diacetylene lipid which may provide the lipoplexes with favorable structural features. We report here that the cationic lipid bisguanidinium-diacetylene (BGDA) is highly efficient for in vitro gene transfection when formulated with dioleoylphosphatidyl ethanolamine (DOPE). We also show that liposomes composed of BGDA, DOPE, and a neutral diacetylene colipid, hydroxyethylenediacetylene (HEDA), are efficient for transfection. Thus, diacetylene-based lipids provide a novel scaffold for gene transfection and will be particularly useful for gaining new insights into the structure-activity relationships of the lipid/DNA complexes as they offer a means to study the effects of polymerizable domains.     

Synthesis and in vitro evaluation of glutamide-containing cationic lipids for gene delivery

A novel series of cationic amphiphiles based on dialkyl glutamides with cationic pyridinium head group were synthesized as potential gene delivery agents. Four cationic lipids with glutamide as linker and varying chain lengths were tested for their transfection efficiency in three cell lines. The DNA-lipid complexes were characterized for their ability to bind to DNA, protection from nuclease digestion, size, zeta-potential, and toxicity. All four lipids demonstrated efficient transfection in MCF-7, COS, and HeLa cells, and the reporter gene expression was much higher with DOPE as the helper lipid in the formulation when compared to cholesterol. Among these 14-carbon lipids, lipid 2 has shown the highest transfection efficiency, complete protection of DNA from nuclease digestion, and low toxicity. Interestingly, lipid 2 has also shown remarkable enhancement in transfection in the presence of serum.     

Influence of minor backbone structural variations in modulating the in vitro gene transfer efficacies of α-tocopherol based cationic transfection lipids

Toward probing the influence of backbone structural variation in cationic lipid mediated gene delivery of α-tocopherol based lipids, two novel α-tocopherol based lipids 1 and 2 have been designed and synthesized. The only structural difference between the cationic amphiphiles 1 and 2 is the backbone structure, where lipid 1 has a non-glycerol backbone and lipid 2 has a glycerol backbone. The lipids 1 and 2 showed contrasting transfection efficiencies: lipid 1 showed high gene transfer efficacy in multiple cultured animals cell lines, whereas lipid 2 is transfection incompetent. In summary, the present findings demonstrate that in the case of α-tocopherol based lipids even minor structural variations like backbone can profoundly influence size, DNA binding characteristics, cellular uptake, and consequently gene delivery efficacies.     

Structure-activity investigation on the gene transfection properties of cardiolipin mimicking gemini lipid analogues

A structure-activity relationship has been explored on the gene transfection efficiencies of cardiolipin mimicking gemini lipid analogues upon variation of length and hydrophilicity of the spacer between the cationic ammonium headgroups and lipid hydrocarbon chain lengths. All the gemini lipids were found to be highly superior in gene transfer abilities as compared to their monomeric lipid and a related commercially available formulation. Pseudoglyceryl gemini lipids bearing an oxyethylene (-CH2-(CH2-O-CH2)m-CH2-) spacer were found to be superior gene transfecting agents as compared to those bearing polymethylene (-CH2)m-) spacers. The major characteristic feature of the present set of gemini lipids is their serum compatibility, which is most often the major hurdle in liposome-mediated gene delivery.     

Aminoglycoside-derived cationic lipids as efficient vectors for gene transfection in vitro and in vivo

Background

Cationic lipids are at present very actively investigated for gene transfer studies and gene therapy applications. Basically, they rely on the formation of DNA/lipid aggregates via electrostatic interactions between their cationic headgroup and the negatively charged DNA. Although their structure/activity relationships are not well understood, it is generally agreed that the nature of the positive headgroup impacts on their transfection activity. Thus, we have directed our efforts toward the development of cationic lipids with novel cationic moieties. In the present work, we have explored the transfection potential of the lipophilic derivatives of the aminoglycoside kanamycin A. Indeed, aminoglycosides, which are natural polyamines known to bind to nucleic acids, provide a favorable scaffold for the synthesis of a variety of cationic lipids because of their structural features and multifunctional nature.

Methods and results

We report here the synthesis of a cationic cholesterol derivative characterized by a kanamycin A headgroup and of its polyguanidinylated derivative. The amino‐sugar‐based cationic lipid is highly efficient for gene transfection into a variety of mammalian cell lines when used either alone or as a liposomal formulation with the neutral phospholipid dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DOPE). Its polyguanidinylated derivative was also found to mediate in vitro gene transfection. In addition, colloidally stable kanamycin‐cholesterol/DOPE lipoplexes were found to be efficient for gene transfection into the mouse airways in vivo.

Conclusions

These results reveal the usefulness of cationic lipids characterized by headgroups composed of an aminoglycoside or its guanidinylated derivative for gene transfection in vitro and in vivo. Copyright © 2002 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

     

Plasmid DNA size does not affect the physicochemical properties of lipoplexes but modulates gene transfer efficiency.

Clinical applications of gene therapy mainly depend on the development of efficient gene transfer vectors. Large DNA molecules can only be transfected into cells by using synthetic vectors such as cationic lipids and polymers. The present investigation was therefore designed to explore the physicochemical properties of cationic lipid-DNA particles, with plasmids ranging from 900 to 52 500 bp. The colloidal stability of the lipoplexes formed by complexing lipopolyamine micelles with plasmid DNA of various lengths, depending on the charge ratio, resulted in the formation of three domains, respectively corresponding to negatively, neutrally and positively charged lipoplexes. Lipoplex morphology and structure were determined by the physicochemical characteristics of the DNA and of the cationic lipid. Thus, the lamellar spacing of the structure was determined by the cationic lipid and its spherical morphology by the DNA. The main result of this study was that the morphological and structural features of the lipopolyamine-DNA complexes did not depend on plasmid DNA length. On the other hand, their gene transfer capacity was affected by the size of plasmid DNA molecules which were sandwiched between the lipid bilayers. The most effective lipopolyamine-DNA complexes for gene transfer were those containing the shortest plasmid DNA.     

Transfection activity of binary mixtures of cationic o-substituted phosphatidylcholine derivatives: the hydrophobic core strongly modulates physical properties and DNA delivery efficacy

A combination of two cationic lipid derivatives having the same headgroup but tails of different chain lengths has been shown to have considerably different transfection activity than do the separate molecules. Such findings point to the importance of investigating the hydrophobic portions of cationic amphiphiles. Hence, we have synthesized a variety of cationic phosphatidylcholines with unusual hydrophobic moieties and have evaluated their transfection activity and that of their mixtures with the original molecule of this class, dioleoyl-O-ethylphosphatidylcholine (EDOPC). Four distinct relationships between transfection activity and composition of the mixture (plotted as percent of the new compound added to EDOPC) were found, namely: with a maximum or minimum; with a proportional change; or with essentially no change. Relevant physical properties of the lipoplexes were also examined; specifically, membrane fusion (by fluorescence resonance energy transfer between cationic and anionic lipids) and DNA unbinding (measured as accessibility of DNA to ethidium bromide by electrophoresis and by fluorescence resonance energy transfer between DNA and cationic lipid), both after the addition of negatively charged membrane lipids. Fusibility increased with increasing content of second cationic lipid, regardless of the transfection pattern. However, the extent of DNA unbinding after addition of negatively charged membrane lipids did correlate with extent of transfection. The phase behavior of cationic lipids per se as well as that of their mixtures with membrane lipids revealed structural differences that may account for and support the hypothesis that a membrane lipid-triggered, lamellar-->nonlamellar phase transition that facilitates DNA release is critical to efficient transfection by cationic lipids.     

Efficient nucleic acid transduction with lipoplexes containing novel piperazine- and polyamine-conjugated cholesterol derivatives

To advance the use of cationic lipids for non-viral nucleic acid vector formulation, a panel of novel nitrogen heterocycle cholesteryl derivatives containing a biodegradable carbamate linker was synthesised. Optimally acting piperazine and cyclen compounds had nucleic acid-binding and lipoplex nanoparticle formation properties that were suitable for their use as non-viral vectors. It was found that the lipoplexes formed were capable of efficient non-toxic nucleic acid delivery to cells in culture. The chemical structure of individual cationic lipids, which is likely to influence lipoplex formation, affected efficiency of DNA or RNA transfection. The results indicated that the cyclen containing compound possessing two cholesteryl moieties resulted in efficient siRNA-mediated target gene silencing but was a poor reagent for DNA transfection.     

Synthesis and gene transfer activities of novel serum compatible cholesterol-based gemini lipids possessing oxyethylene-type spacers

Four novel cholesterol-based gemini cationic lipids differing in the length of oxyethylene-type spacers [-CH2-(CH2-O-CH2)n-CH2-] between each ammonium headgroup have been synthesized. These formed stable suspensions in aqueous media. Cationic liposomes were prepared from each of these lipids individually and as mixtures of cationic lipid and DOPE. These were used as nonviral gene delivery agents. All the cholesterol-based gemini lipids induced better transfection activity than their monomeric counterpart. Inclusion of DOPE in co-liposomal formulation of the cationic gemini lipid potentiates their gene transfer activity significantly. A major characteristic feature of these oxyethylene spacer based cholesterol gemini lipids was that serum does not inhibit the transfection activity of these gemini lipids, whereas the transfection activity of their monomeric counterpart decreased drastically in the presence of serum. One of the cholesterol-based gemini lipids 2a possessing a -CH2-CH2-O-CH2-CH2- spacer showed the highest transfection activity.     

Lipid transfer between cationic vesicles and lipid-DNA lipoplexes: Effect of serum

Differential scanning calorimetry was used to examine the lipid exchange between model lipid systems, including vesicles of the cationic lipoids ethyldimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (EDMPC), ethyldipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (EDPPC) or their complexes with DNA (lipoplexes), and the zwitterionic lipids (DMPC, DPPC). The changes of the lipid phase transition parameters (temperature, enthalpy, and cooperativity) upon consecutive temperature scans was used as an indication of lipid mixing between aggregates. A selective lipid transfer of the shorter-chain cationic lipoid EDMPC into the longer-chain aggregates was inferred. In contrast, transfer was hindered when EDMPC (but not EDPPC) was bound to DNA in the lipoplexes. These data support a simple molecular lipid exchange mechanism, but not lipid bilayer fusion. Exchange via lipid monomers is considerably more facile for the cationic ethylphosphatidylcholines than for zwitterionic phosphatidylcholines, presumably due to the higher monomer solubility of the charged lipids. With the cationic liposomes, lipid transfer was strongly promoted by the presence of serum in the dispersing medium. Serum proteins are presumed to be responsible for the accelerated transfer, since the effect was strongly reduced upon heating the serum to 80 °C. The effect of serum indicates that even though much lipoplex lipid is inaccessible due to the multilayered structure, the barrier due to buried lipid can be easily overcome. Serum did not noticeably promote the lipid exchange of zwitterionic liposomes. The phenomenon is of potential importance for the application of cationic liposomes to nonviral gene delivery, which often involves the presence of serum in vitro, and necessarily involves serum contact in vivo.     

In vitro gene transfer efficacies and serum compatibility profiles of novel mono-, di-, and tri-histidinylated cationic transfection lipids: a structure-activity investigation

Recently, we demonstrated that covalent grafting of an endosome-disrupting single histidine functionality in the headgroup region imparts high gene transfer properties to cationic amphiphiles (Kumar, V. V., et al. Gene Ther. 2003, 10, 1206-1215). However, whether covalent attachment of multiple histidine functionalities in the headgroup region are capable of further enhancing the gene transfer efficacies of cationic amphiphiles remains to be explored. To this end, herein, we report on the design, syntheses, physicochemical characterizations, in vitro gene transfer properties, and serum compatibilities of three novel nontoxic cationic transfection amphiphiles containing mono-, di-, and tri-histidine functionalities in their headgroup regions (lipids 1-3) in multiple cultured cells. Significantly, findings in both the reporter gene expression assay and the whole cell histochemical X-gal staining assay support the notion that there is no linear correlation between the in vitro transfection efficacies and the number of histidine functionalities in the polar headgroup regions for histidinylated cationic amphiphiles. The relative gene transfer efficiencies, as well as the serum compatibilities, of the present histidinylated cationic amphiphiles were found to be strikingly dependent on the medium of lipoplex formation. Most importantly, high serum compatibilities (up to 50% added serum) of the lipoplexes of lipids 1 and 3 make them promising nonviral transfection vectors for future systemic applications.     

Effect of the hydrocarbon chain and polymethylene spacer lengths on gene transfection efficacies of gemini lipids based on aromatic backbone

Design, syntheses, and gene delivery efficacies of fifteen novel gemini (dimeric) and three monomeric cationic lipids anchored on an aromatic backbone have been described. Each new lipid has been used for liposome formation, and optimal formulations were used to determine the structure-activity correlation of the gene transfection efficacies of these lipids in HeLa and HT1080 cells. The results of the present investigation bring out the effect of hydrocarbon chain lengths and the length of the spacer between the headgroups on gene transfection efficiencies of the cationic gemini lipids based on aromatic backbone. The lipids bearing n-C 14H 29 hydrocarbon chain lengths have been found to be the best transfecting agents compared to their counterparts with n-C 16H 33 and n-C 12H 25 chains in HeLa cells. On the other hand, in HT1080 cells, the lipids based on n-C 12H 25 and n-C 14H 29 chains were found to be more potent transfecting agents than lipids possessing n-C 16H 33 chains. Transmission electron microscopy examination revealed the existence of spherical lipid-DNA complexes.     

Modulation of a membrane lipid lamellar-nonlamellar phase transition by cationic lipids: A measure for transfection efficiency

Synthetic cationic lipids can be used as DNA carriers and are regarded to be the most promising non-viral gene carriers. For this investigation, six novel phosphatidylcholine (PC) cationic derivatives with various hydrophobic moieties were synthesized and their transfection efficiencies for human umbilical artery endothelial cells (HUAEC) were determined. Three compounds with relatively short, myristoleoyl or myristelaidoyl 14:1 chains exhibited very high activity, exceeding by ∼ 10 times that of the reference cationic derivative dioleoyl ethylPC (EDOPC). Noteworthy, cationic lipids with 14:1 hydrocarbon chains have not been tested as DNA carriers in transfection assays previously. The other three lipids, which contained oleoyl 18:1 and longer chains, exhibited moderate to weak transfection activity. Transfection efficiency was found to correlate strongly with the effect of the cationic lipids on the lamellar-to-inverted hexagonal, L_α → H_II, phase conversion in dipalmitoleoyl phosphatidylethanolamine dispersions (DPoPE). X-ray diffraction on binary DPoPE/cationic lipid mixtures showed that the superior transfection agents eliminated the direct L_α → H_II phase transition and promoted formation of an inverted cubic phase between the L_α and H_II phases. In contrast, moderate and weak transfection agents retained the direct L_α → H_II transition but shifted to higher temperatures than that of pure DPoPE, and induced cubic phase formation at a later stage. On the basis of current models of lipid membrane fusion, promotion of a cubic phase by the high-efficiency agents may be considered as an indication that their high transfection activity results from enhanced lipoplex fusion with cellular membranes. The distinct, well-expressed correlation established between transfection efficiency of a cationic lipid and the way it modulates nonlamellar phase formation of a membrane lipid could be useful as a criterion to assess the quality of lipid carriers and for rational design of new and superior nucleotide delivery agents.     

Gene transfection efficacies of novel cationic gemini lipids possessing aromatic backbone and oxyethylene spacers

Six novel gemini cationic lipids based on aromatic backbone, bearing n-C14H 29 or n-C16H33 hydrocarbon chains, differing in the length of oxyethylene type spacers -CH2-(CH2-O-CH2)m-CH2- between each ammonium headgroups have been synthesized, where m varies from 1 to 3. Each of these lipids formed stable suspensions in aqueous media. Cationic liposomes were prepared from each of these lipids individually and as mixtures of each cationic lipid and DOPE. These were used as nonviral gene delivery agents. Transfection studies showed that among lipids bearing n-C14H29 chains, the transfection efficacies decreased with the increase in the length of the spacer, whereas in case of lipids bearing n-C 16H33 chains, the transfection efficacies increased with the increase in the length of the spacer. Lipid bearing n-C16H33 hydrocarbon chains with a [-(CH2-CH2-O-CH2-CH2-O-CH2-CH2-O-CH2-CH2)-] spacer was found to be a potent gene transfer agent and its transfection was highly serum compatible even in the presence of 50% serum conditions.