Effects of dominant-negative lac repressor mutations on operator specificity and protein stability

The specific binding of dominant-negative (I-d) lactose (lac) repressors to wild-type (wt) as well as mutant (Oc) lac operators has been examined to explore the sequence-specific interaction of the lac repressor with its target. Mutant lacI genes encoding substitutions in the N-terminal 60 amino acids (aa) were cloned in a derivative of plasmid pBR322. Twelve of these lacI-d missense mutations were transferred from F'lac episomes using general genetic recombination and molecular cloning, and nine lacI missense mutations were recloned from M13-lacI phages [Mott et al., Nucl. Acids Res. 12 (1984) 4139-4152]. The mutant repressors were examined for polypeptide size and stability, for binding the inducer isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG), as well as binding to wt operator. The mutant repressors' affinities for wt operator ranged from undetectable to about 1% that of wt repressor, and the mutant repressors varied in transdominance against repressor expressed from a chromosomal lacIq gene. Six of the I-d repressors were partially degraded in vivo. All repressors bound IPTG with approximately the affinity of wt repressor. Repressors having significant affinity for wt operator or with substitutions in the presumed operator recognition helix (aa 17-25) were examined in vivo for their affinities for a series of single site Oc operators. Whereas the Gly-18-, Ser-18- and Leu-18-substituted repressors showed altered specificity for position 7 of the operator [Ebright, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83 (1986) 303-307], the His-18 repressor did not affect specificity. This result may be related to the greater side-chain length of histidine compared to the other amino acid substitutions.     

Symmetric lac operator derivatives: effects of half-operator sequence and spacing on repressor affinity

We have analyzed lac repressor binding in vivo and in vitro to several symmetric lac operator sequences. Two features of the operator appear to be important for repressor binding: sequence, both of the operator and of its extended regions, and the spacing of the operator halves. Host mutations that alter DNA superhelical density (topA, gyrB) did not change the relative affinity of cloned symmetric operator sequences for repressor. Analysis by dimethylsulfate methylation and DNaseI digestion of repressor-operator complexes indicated that repressor makes symmetric contacts with the symmetric operator, in contrast to its contacts with the two halves of the natural operator.     

Specificities of three tight-binding Lac repressors.

Tight binding mutants of Lac repressor exhibit complex repression phenomena. In this work, in vivo Lac operator binding of three such mutants of E. coli Lac repressor (X86: ser 61-leu, l12: pro 3-tyr and the double mutant l12X86: pro 3-tyr, ser 61-leu) was analyzed. Repression of beta-galactosidase synthesis controlled by ideal lac operator and its 27 symmetric operator variants containing each possible base-pair at each single half-operator position in the presence of the tight-binding Lac repressor mutants was determined. The average increase of repression with all operator variants was about 3 fold with the X86 mutant. It was about 4 fold with the l12 mutant and about 2 fold with the double mutant l12X86 as compared to wildtype Lac repressor. The X86 mutant showed the same increase of affinity to all operator variants, whereas the l12 and l12X86 mutants exhibited lower repression with some variants than with most others. These results suggest that the X86 mutant has gained no additional specificity. In contrast the l12 mutant and the l12X86 mutant exhibit a relaxed specificity for certain base pairs in positions 1 and 3 of lac operator. This suggests that the extreme N-terminus of Lac repressor may interact with the inner base-pairs in the minor groove.     

In vivo interaction of Escherichia coli lac repressor N-terminal fragments with the lac operator

Escherichia coli lac repressor is a tetrameric protein composed of 360 amino acid subunits. Considerable attention has focused on its N-terminal region which is isolated by cleavage with proteases yielding N-terminal fragments of 51 to 59 amino acid residues. Because these short peptide fragments bind operator DNA, they have been extensively examined in nuclear magnetic resonance structural studies. Longer N-terminal peptide fragments that bind DNA cannot be obtained enzymatically. To extend structural studies and simultaneously verify proper folding in vivo, the DNA sequence encoding longer N-terminal fragments were cloned into a vector system with the coliphage T7 RNA polymerase/promoter. In addition to the wild-type lacI gene sequence, single amino acid substitutions were generated at positions 3 (Pro3----Tyr) and 61 (Ser61----Leu) as well as the double substitution in a 64 amino acid N-terminal fragment. These mutations were chosen because they increase the DNA binding affinity of the intact lac repressor by a factor of 10(2) to 10(4). The expression of these lac repressor fragments in the cell was verified by radioimmunoassays. Both wild-type and mutant lac repressor N termini bound operator DNA as judged by reduced beta-galactosidase synthesis and methylation protection in vivo. These observations also resolve a contradiction in the literature as to the location of the operator-specific, inducer-dependent DNA binding domain.     

Thermodynamic origins of specificity in the lac repressor-operator interaction. Adaptability in the recognition of mutant operator sites

A system has been developed for facile generation and characterization of mutant lac operator sites, free of competing pseudo operator sequences. The interaction of lac repressor with these sites has been investigated by the nitrocellulose filter binding assay. The equilibrium binding affinity for each of three single-site changes was reduced by more than three orders of magnitude relative to the wild-type operator under standard assay conditions. The free-energy changes associated with single base-pair substitutions are not additive. We propose that adaptations in the recognition surface of the repressor involving significant trade-offs between electrostatic versus non-electrostatic interactions and between enthalpic versus entropic contributions to the binding free energy occur, in order to achieve the most stable complex with a given DNA sequence.     

Tight-binding repressors of the lac operon: selection system and in vitro analysis.

The isolation and characterization of altered repressors of the lac operon which have an increased affinity for an operator should give useful clues about the molecular basis for the very tight and specific interaction between repressor and operator. A selection system has been devised which allows the isolation of such repressor mutants. This system selects for mutant repressors which can overcome lac operator-constitutive (Oc) mutations. By using in vivo assays, 24 candidates were obtained which, compared with wild type, have an increased trans effect of their repressor on one or several Oc operators. Three of these candidates have been investigated in vitro; the affinity of their repressor for inducer was unchanged, whereas the affinity for wild-type operator was increased 15-, 86-, and 262-fold, respectively.     

Affinity purification of specific DNA fragments using a lac repressor fusion protein

A new method for purification of specific DNA sequences using a solid phase technique has been developed based on a fusion between the Escherichia coli lac repressor gene (lacI) and the staphylococcal protein A gene (spa). The fusion protein, expressed in Escherichia coli, is active both in vivo and in vitro with respect to its three functional activities (DNA binding, IPTG induction, and IgG binding). The recombinant protein can be immobilized in a one-step procedure with high yield and purity using the specific interaction between protein A and the Fc-part of immunoglobulin G. The immobilized repressor can thereafter be used for affinity purification of specific DNA fragments containing the lac operator (lacO) sequence.     

Operator DNA sequence variation enhances high affinity binding by hinge helix mutants of lactose repressor protein

The mechanism by which genetic regulatory proteins discern specific target DNA sequences remains a major area of inquiry. To explore in more detail the interplay between DNA and protein sequence, we have examined binding of variant lac operator DNA sequences to a series of mutant lactose repressor proteins (LacI). These proteins were altered in the C-terminus of the hinge region that links the N-terminal DNA binding and core sugar binding domains. Variant operators differed from the wild-type operator, O(1), in spacing and/or symmetry of the half-sites that contact the LacI N-terminal DNA binding domain. Binding of wild-type and mutant proteins was affected differentially by variations in operator sequence and symmetry. While the mutant series exhibits a 10(4)-fold range in binding affinity for O(1) operator, only a approximately 20-fold difference in affinity is observed for a completely symmetric operator, O(sym), used widely in studies of the LacI protein. Further, DNA sequence influenced allosteric response for these proteins. Binding of this LacI mutant series to other variant operator DNA sequences indicated the importance of symmetry-related bases, spacing, and the central base pair sequence in high affinity complex formation. Conformational flexibility in the DNA and other aspects of the structure influenced by the sequence may establish the binding environment for protein and determine both affinity and potential for allostery.     

Use of a ligand-screening procedure to study the interaction of S. cerevisiae alpha 2 repressor with its operator sequence.

A simple and rapid screening procedure was developed to study the interaction of the S. cerevisiae alpha 2 repressor with its operator sequence. An E. coli expression vector was constructed in which the alpha 2 coding sequence was placed under control of the lac promoter. Bacterial colonies containing this vector could be lysed and assayed directly for binding of wild-type and mutant operator sequences when grown on nitrocellulose filters. alpha 2 assayed in this way showed the same sequence specificity as determined in vivo. Pools of mutant alpha 2 repressors in which the codons for Arg185 or Ser181 in the homeodomain region were randomized were created by cassette mutagenesis. These pools of mutants were screened with the wild-type operator sequence to determine allowed amino acid substitutions at each position. Results suggest that both Arg185 and Ser181 have a role in high affinity operator binding.     

Novel method for identifying sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins.

We developed a general method for the enrichment and identification of sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins. A well-characterized protein-DNA interaction is used to isolate from crude cellular extracts or fractions thereof proteins which bind to specific DNA sequences; the method is based solely on this binding property of the proteins. The DNA sequence of interest, cloned adjacent to the lac operator DNA segment is incubated with a lac repressor-beta-galactosidase fusion protein which retains full operator and inducer binding properties. The DNA fragment bound to the lac repressor-beta-galactosidase fusion protein is precipitated by the addition of affinity-purified anti-beta-galactosidase immobilized on beads. This forms an affinity matrix for any proteins which might interact specifically with the DNA sequence cloned adjacent to the lac operator. When incubated with cellular extracts in the presence of excess competitor DNA, any protein(s) which specifically binds to the cloned DNA sequence of interest can be cleanly precipitated. When isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside is added, the lac repressor releases the bound DNA, and thus the protein-DNA complex consisting of the specific restriction fragment and any specific binding protein(s) is released, permitting the identification of the protein by standard biochemical techniques. We demonstrate the utility of this method with the lambda repressor, another well-characterized DNA-binding protein, as a model. In addition, with crude preparations of the yeast mitochondrial RNA polymerase, we identified a 70,000-molecular-weight peptide which binds specifically to the promoter region of the yeast mitochondrial 14S rRNA gene.     

lac Operator nucleosomes. 2. lac Nucleosomes can change conformation to strengthen binding by lac repressor

We have shown previously that lac repressor binds specifically and quantitatively to lac operator restriction fragments which have been complexed with histones to form artificial nucleosomes (203 base pair restriction fragment) or core particles (144 base pair restriction fragment. We describe here a quantitative method for determining the equilibrium binding affinities of repressor for these lac reconstitutes. Quantitative analysis shows that the operator-histone reconstitutes may be grouped into two affinity classes: those with an affinity for repressor close to that of naked DNA and those with an affinity 2 or more orders of magnitude less than that of naked DNA. All particles in the lac nucleosome preparations bind repressor with high affinity, but the lac core particle preparations contain particles of both high and low affinities for repressor. Formaldehyde cross-linking causes all high-affinity species to suffer a 100-fold decrease in binding affinity. In contrast, there is no effect of cross-linking on species of low affinity. Therefore, the ability of a particle to be bound tightly by repressor depends on a property of the particle which is eliminated by cross-linking. Control experiments have shown that chemical damage to the operator does not accompany cross-linking. Therefore, the property sensitive to cross-linking must be the ability of the particle to change conformation. We infer that the particles of low native affinity, like cross-linked particles, are of low affinity because of an inability to facilitate repressor binding by means of this conformational change. Dimethyl suberimidate cross-linking experiments show that histone-histone cross-linking is sufficient to preclude high-affinity binding. Thus, the necessary conformational change involves a nucleosome histone core event. We find that the ability of a particle to undergo a repressor-induced facilitating conformational change appears to depend on the position of the operator along the DNA binding path of the nucleosome core. We present a general model which proposes that nucleosomes are divided into domains which function differentially to initiate conformational changes in response to physiological stimuli.     

Degradation of the DNA-binding domain of wild-type and i-d lac repressors in Escherichia coli.

It has been shown that 28 transdominant mutant lac repressors which have lost operator DNA-binding ability in vivo and in vitro, but still bind inducer and are able to form tetramers (i-d repressors), could be divided into two groups by their capacity or incapacity to bind non-specifically to the phosphate groups of the DNA backbone. All but one of 15 analysed i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the C-terminal of residue 52 showed uneffected non-specific DNA binding. All 13 tested i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the N-terminal of residue 53 did not bind to double-stranded DNA, and 11 of these repressors derived from missense mutations in the lacI gene were endogenously degraded. The degradation in vivo only affects the amino-terminal 50-60 residues producing a mutant-specific pattern of stable repressor fragments. These fragments are tetrameric and capable of binding inducer in vivo and in vitro. The proteolytic attack presumably takes place during synthesis of the i-d repressors, since the resulting fragments are stable, both in vivo (as shown by a pulse-chase experiment) and in vitro. The proteolysis in vivo depends on the growth conditions of the bacteria and is higher in cells grown in minimal media than in rich media. Wild-type repressor is only susceptible to limited proteolysis in cells grown in minimal media but not in cells grown in rich media. The results suggest that the majority of the sequence alterations before residue 53 in missense mutant i-d lac repressor proteins affect the three-dimensional structure of the amino-terminal DNA-binding domain of the repressor protein, making it susceptible to proteolytic attack by one or several intracellular proteases.     

Resolution of the fluorescence decay of the two tryptophan residues of lac repressor using single tryptophan mutants.

We have studied the time-resolved intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the lac repressor (a symmetric tetramer containing two tryptophan residues per monomer) and two single-tryptophan mutant repressors obtained by site-directed mutagenesis, lac W201Y and lac W220Y. These mutant repressor proteins have tyrosine substituted for tryptophan at positions 201 and 220, respectively, leaving a single tryptophan residue per monomeric subunit at position 220 for the W201Y mutant and at position 201 in the W220Y mutant. It was found that the two decay rates recovered from the analysis of the wild type data do not correspond to the rates recovered from the analysis of the decays of the mutant proteins. Each of these residues in the mutant repressors displays at least two decay rates. Global analysis of the multiwavelength data from all three proteins, however, yielded results consistent with the fluorescence decay of the wild type lac repressor corresponding simply to the weighted linear combination of the decays from the mutant proteins. The effect of ligation by the antagonistic ligands, inducer and operator DNA, was similar for all three proteins. The binding of the inducer sugar resulted in a quenching of the long-lived species, while binding by the operator decreased the lifetime of the short components. Investigation of the time-resolved anisotropy of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence in these three proteins revealed that the depolarization of fluorescence resulted from a fast motion and the global tumbling of the macromolecule. Results from the simultaneous global analysis of the frequency domain data sets from the three proteins revealed anisotropic rotations for the macromolecule, consistent with the known elongated shape of the repressor tetramer. In addition, it appears that the excited-state dipole of tryptophan 220 is alighed with the long axis of the repressor.     

Sequence-specific interactions of the tight-binding I12-X86 lac repressor with non-operator DNA.

The tight-binding I12-X86 lac repressor binds to non-operator DNA in a sequence-specific fashion. Using the DNA of the E. coli I gene we have investigated these sequence-specific interactions and compared them to the operator binding of wild-type repressor. The specific, non-operator DNA interactions are sensitive to the inducer IPTG. One strong binding site in the I gene DNA was found to be one of two expected on the basis of their homology with the lac operator. The binding of I12-X86 repressor to this site was visualized using the footprinting technique, and found to be consistent with an operator-like binding configuration. The protection pattern extends into an adjacent sequence suggesting that two repressor tetramers are bound in tandem.     

Affinities of tight-binding lactose repressors for wild-type and pseudo-operators

Five tight-binding (Itb) mutants of the Escherichia coli lactose (lac) repressor have been characterized with regard to their non-specific affinity for DNA and their specific affinity for the wild-type operator and several sequence-altered (pseudo-) operators. Repressor-operator association rates were determined in the presence or absence of competitor DNA, dissociation rates of repressor from various DNA fragments were measured, and equilibrium competition for repressor binding was examined for several pseudo-operator DNAs. The mutant repressors exhibited increased non-specific affinity for DNA, and variable increases in affinity for sequence-altered operators. The known positions of amino acid substitutions for three of these Itb repressors support suggestions that residues 51 to 64 are important for operator recognition in addition to residues 1 to 50.     

Evidence for leucine zipper motif in lactose repressor protein

Amino acid sequence homology between the carboxyl-terminal segment of the lac repressor and eukaryotic proteins containing the leucine zipper motif with associated basic DNA binding region (bZIP) has been identified. Based on the sequence comparisons, site-specific mutations have been generated at two sites predicted to participate in oligomer formation based on the three-leucine heptad repeat at positions 342, 349, and 356. Leu342----Ala, Leu349----Ala, and Leu349----Pro have been isolated and their oligomeric state and ligand binding properties evaluated. These mutant proteins do not form tetramers but exist as stable dimers with inducer binding comparable with the wild-type protein. Apparent operator affinities for lac repressor proteins with mutations in the proposed bZIP domain were significantly lower than the corresponding wild-type values. For these dimeric mutant proteins, the monomer-dimer equilibrium is linked to the apparent operator binding constant. The values for the monomer-monomer binding constant and for the intrinsic operator binding constant for the dimer cannot be resolved from measurements of the observed Kd for operator DNA. Further studies on these proteins are in progress.     

Regulated expression of nuclear genes by T3 RNA polymerase and lac repressor, using recombinant vaccinia virus vectors.

Recombinant vaccinia viruses that express the bacteriophage T3 RNA polymerase (VV-T3pol) or the Escherichia coli lac repressor (VV-lacI) under control of the early-late vaccinia promoter P7.5 were constructed. To determine whether phage polymerase and lac repressor can function in the nucleus of mammalian cells, the bacterial chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene was cloned downstream of a T3 promoter (PT3-CAT) or downstream of a T3 promoter-lac operator fusion element (PT3Olac-CAT), and these reporter gene cassettes were introduced stably into NIH 3T3 or Ltk- cells. Infection of 3T3/PT3-CAT or Ltk-/PT3-CAT cells by VV-T3pol led to rapid expression of CAT (greater than 20 ng of CAT protein per 10(6) cells). The presence of hydroxyurea (which blocks virus DNA replication) did not prevent CAT production. When 3T3/PT3Olac-CAT cells were infected with both VV-T3pol and VV-lacI (multiplicities of infection of 2.5 and 10, respectively), greater than 30-fold repression of CAT gene activity by lac repressor was observed. This could be reversed to unrepressed levels by the presence of 10 mM o-nitrophenyl-beta-D-galactoside (IPTG) in the medium. Regulated expression of the target gene was observed with cell lines that had been maintained for over 1 year (greater than 50 passages in culture), and Southern blot analysis revealed the presence of the CAT gene only in the nuclear fraction in these cells, demonstrating the stability of the target gene. These results indicate that vaccinia virus-encoded proteins can function in the mammalian nucleus and provide the basis for a genetic system in which essential vaccinia virus genes, placed in the chromosome of a cell, can be used to complement defective virus particles. This approach may prove useful for other virus systems.     

How Escherichia coli sets different basal levels in SOS operons

The recA and sfiA genes of Escherichia coli are SOS operons regulated negatively by the LexA repressor. The steady state level of expression of recA is 10-fold higher than that of sfiA, as measured by means of recA::lac and sfiA::lac operon fusions. To study the molecular basis of this difference, we have compared the expression of these two operons in strains in which the concentration of LexA repressor was normal (lexA+), zero (spr amber mutation) or higher than normal (plasmid pJL45, carrying the lexA gene linked to the lac promoter). The results indicate (i) that the recA promoter is about 4 times stronger than the sfiA promoter (as measured in the spr strains), (ii) that neither operon has a physiologically significant level of lexA-independent expression (pJL45 strains), and (iii) that the recA operator has about 2.5 times lower affinity than the sfiA operator for LexA repressor (comparison of lex+ and spr strains). Considering our previous results that the sfiA operon (high operator affinity of LexA) is derepressed very rapidly after inducing treatments and that the recA operon (low operator affinity) is repressed very rapidly when induction is stopped, we conclude that differences in operator affinity do not affect inducibility but serve only to set the basal levels of the different SOS functions.