Complete DNA sequences of the plastid genomes of two parasitic flowering plant species, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cuscuta reflexa</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cuscuta gronovii</Emphasis>

Background  

The holoparasitic plant genus Cuscuta comprises species with photosynthetic capacity and functional chloroplasts as well as achlorophyllous and intermediate forms with restricted photosynthetic activity and degenerated chloroplasts. Previous data indicated significant differences with respect to the plastid genome coding capacity in different Cuscuta species that could correlate with their photosynthetic activity. In order to shed light on the molecular changes accompanying the parasitic lifestyle, we sequenced the plastid chromosomes of the two species Cuscuta reflexa and Cuscuta gronovii. Both species are capable of performing photosynthesis, albeit with varying efficiencies. Together with the plastid genome of Epifagus virginiana, an achlorophyllous parasitic plant whose plastid genome has been sequenced, these species represent a series of progression towards total dependency on the host plant, ranging from reduced levels of photosynthesis in C. reflexa to a restricted photosynthetic activity and degenerated chloroplasts in C. gronovii to an achlorophyllous state in E. virginiana.     

Diversity and evolution of pollen-ovule production in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cuscuta</Emphasis> (dodders,Convolvulaceae) in relation to floral morphology

Cuscuta (dodder, Convolvulaceae) is a genus of about 200 species of obligate stem parasites with subcosmopolitan distribution. The diversity of pollen and ovule production was surveyed in 128 species and ten varieties. Taxa were assigned to Cruden’s mating system categories based on their pollen-ovule ratios. Variation and correlations among floral characters were analyzed using regression and ANOVA, while the mating system categories were subjected to a linear discriminant and canonical variates analysis to assess their cohesiveness. Our data strongly suggest that most Cuscuta species possess a wide range of mixed-mating systems. Whereas four ovules develop in each flower, pollen production varies over three orders of magnitude. Several Cuscuta taxa are highly outcrossing, but no species could be identified that are exclusively selfing. The transition from the one-style flowers of subg. Monogynella to the two-style flowers of subgenera Cuscuta and Grammica, and from simultaneous to sequential maturation of the two stigmas in the latter subgenus, has decreased the role of herkogamy as a facilitator of outcrossing. These evolutionary changes are associated with an increase of species richness in subgenus Cuscuta, and especially in subgenus Grammica. Morphological features were not individually found to have a strong correlation to the mating system, but in general, larger corollas and stigmas were associated with greater pollen-ovule ratios. Cuscuta presents some puzzling results when considered in light of the sex allocation theory, as only some infrageneric lineages demonstrate the predicted pollen size-number tradeoff, while Cuscuta gracillima complex (in subgenus Grammica) displays an unexpected negative relationship between pollen size and style length. The relationship between host range and mating system is discussed, prompting further research into the co-evolution of pollination systems and life history traits between parasites and their host species.     

Morphological and plant hormonal changes during parasitization by Cuscuta japonica on Momordica charantia

The holostemparasitic plant Cuscuta parasitizes various plants and sucks nutrients from the host stem. We used Cuscuta japonica as the parasite and Momordica charantia as the host plant, and described their interaction. The parasitized Momordica stems started swelling as a hypertrophic response within 3 days after parasitization. Concurrently, the Cuscuta stem grew rapidly and developed bigger scale leaves than usual. Parasitized Momordica stems reduced photosynthetic activity. Histological observation revealed no programmed cell death but an increased number of vascular bundles in the Momordica stem, especially near the Cuscuta hyphae. The defensive response of Momordica mainly involved the SA pathway. Drastic increase of tZ- and DZ-type cytokinins in Momordica stems would play an important role for hypertrophy. Cuscuta had higher cZ endogenously and our results imply that each subtype of CK might play different roles during parasitization process. Comprehensive plant hormone analysis provides new insights into plant interaction studies.     

Canopy ergodicity: can a single leaf represent an entire plant canopy?

While leaves typically emerge near shoot apices around the outer surface of a plant canopy, their relative position “moves” deeper into the canopy as additional leaves emerge. The photosynthetic capacity (A _max) of a given leaf can be expected to decline over time as its relative position (P _r) in the canopy becomes progressively deeper; this can be observed as a spatial gradient with the A _max of leaves declining distally from the shoot apex. As a consequence, we propose that the photosynthetic capacity averaged over a single leaf’s lifespan is equivalent to the average photosynthetic capacity of the entire plant canopy at a given time; in other words, there is an ergodic time to space averaging in the organization and development of plant canopies. We tested this “canopy ergodic hypothesis” in two woody (Alnus sieboldiana and Mallotus japonica) and two herbaceous (Polygonum sachalinensis and Helianthus tuberosus) species by following the photosynthetic capacity in 100 individual leaves from the time of their emergence until their death. We compared the average photosynthetic capacity of individual leaves through time (time-average) to the average photosynthetic capacity of all the leaves along a shoot at the time of emergence of the focal leaf (space-average). We found that A _max and P _r were positively correlated and that the time-averages of three plant species (Alnus, Mallotus, and Helianthus) were not significantly different from the corresponding space-averages, although the averages differed among individual plants. Polygonum, however, did show significant differences between time and space averages. Ergodicity appears to apply to the leaf–canopy relationship, at least approximately—the average photosynthetic capacity of a single leaf through time (time-average) can represent the average photosynthetic capacity of the entire canopy.     

Native Cuscuta campestris restrains exotic Mikania micrantha and enhances soil resources beneficial to natives in the invaded communities

Nutrients in exotic species and invaded communities play a key role in determining the dynamics of invaders and the invasibility of a receipt community. This study focused on the effects of the native holoparasite Cuscuta campestris (for short Cuscuta) on nutrients in the exotic invasive Mikania micrantha (for short Mikania) and stands invaded by Mikania. We conducted a set of field investigations on Mikania with Cuscuta parasitism for 1–4 years, and measured soil properties, community composition, and the growth and nutrient content of Mikania and Cuscuta in two types of sub-communities (i.e. with Mikania only, or with Mikania and Cuscuta). Cuscuta dramatically reduced the cover, biomass, and nutrients (i.e. N, P, and K content) of Mikania, significantly enhanced soil water, pH and nutrient content (i.e. organic matter, total N and P, available P and K), and greatly increased the cover and species richness of native plants. In addition, N and K of Cuscuta were positively correlated with N of Mikania, which was negatively associated with soil total N, available P and K. These findings suggest that Cuscuta may be an effective measure against Mikania and be beneficial to the restoration of invaded communities.     

Down the Slippery Slope: Plastid Genome Evolution in Convolvulaceae

Cuscuta (dodder) is the only parasitic genus found in Convolvulaceae (morning-glory family). We used long PCR approach to obtain large portions of plastid genome sequence from Cuscuta sandwichiana in order to determine the size, structure, gene content, and synteny in the plastid genome of this Cuscuta species belonging to the poorly investigated holoparasitic subgenus Grammica. These new sequences are compared with the tobacco chloroplast genome, and, where data are available, with corresponding regions from taxa in the other Cuscuta subgenera. When all known plastid genome structural rearrangements in parasitic and nonparasitic Convolvulaceae are considered in a molecular phylogenetic framework, three categories of rearrangements in Cuscuta are revealed: plesiomorphic, autapomorphic, and synapomorphic. Many of the changes in Cuscuta, previously attributed to its parasitic mode of life, are better explained either as plesiomorphic conditions within the family, i.e., conditions shared with the rest of the Convolvulaceae, or, in most cases, autapomorphies of particular Cuscuta taxa, not shared with the rest of the species in the genus. The synapomorphic rearrangements are most likely to correlate with the parasitic lifestyle, because they represent changes found in Cuscuta exclusively. However, it appears that most of the affected regions, belonging to all of these three categories, have probably no function (e.g., introns) or are of unknown function (a number of open reading frames, the function of which, if any, has yet to be discovered).[Reviewing Editor: Dr. Debashish Bhattacharya]     

Unresolved quenching mechanisms of chlorophyll fluorescence may invalidate MT saturating pulse analyses of photosynthetic electron transfer in microalgae

Chlorophyll a fluorescence is a powerful tool for estimating photosynthetic efficiency, but there are still unanswered questions that hinder the use of its full potential. The present results describe a caveat in estimation of photosynthetic performance with so‐called rapid light curves (RLCs) with pulse amplitude modulation fluorometers. RLCs of microalgae show a severe decrease in photosynthetic performance in high light, although a similar decrease cannot be seen with other methods. We show that this decrease cannot be assigned to energy‐dependent non‐photochemical quenching or photoinhibition or to the geometry of the algal sample. The measured decrease in electron transfer rate is small in the tested siphonaceuous algae and higher plants, but very notable in all planktonic species, exhibiting species‐dependent variation in extent and reversibility. We performed in‐depth analysis of the phenomenon in the diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum, in which the decrease is the most pronounced and reversible among the tested organisms. The results suggest that quenching of fluorescence by oxidized plastoquinone alone cannot explain the phenomenon, and alternative quenching mechanisms within PSII need to be considered.     

Effects of severe CO2 starvation on the photosynthetic electron transport chain in tobacco plants

Tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum) were kept in CO₂ free air for several days to investigate the effect of lack of electron acceptors on the photosynthetic electron transport chain. CO₂ starvation resulted in a dramatic decrease in photosynthetic activity. Measurements of the electron transport activity in thylakoid membranes showed that a loss of Photosystem II activity was mainly responsible for the observed decrease in photosynthetic activity. In the absence of CO₂ the plastoquinone pool and the acceptor side of Photosystem I were highly reduced in the dark as shown by far-red light effects on chlorophyll fluorescence and P700 absorption measurements. Reduction of the oxygen content of the CO₂ free air retarded photoinhibitory loss of photosynthetic activity and pigment degradation. Electron flow to oxygen seemed not to be able to counteract the stress induced by severe CO₂ starvation. The data are discussed in terms of a donation of reducing equivalents from mitochondria to chloroplasts and a reduction of the plastoquinone pool via the NAD(P)H-plastoquinone oxidoreductase during CO₂ starvation. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Piecing together the puzzle of parasitic plant plastome evolution

The importance of photosynthesis as a mode of energy production has put plastid genomes of plants under a constant purifying selection. This has shaped the characteristic features of plastid genomes across the entire spectrum of photosynthetic plants and has led to a highly uniform and conserved plastid genome with respect to structure, size, gene order, intron and editing site positions and coding capacity. Parasitic species that have dropped photosynthesis as the main energy provider share striking deviations from the plastid genome norm: multiple rearrangements within the circular chromosome, pseudogenization and gene deletions, promoter losses, intron losses as well as the extensive loss of mRNA editing competence have been reported. The collective loss of larger sets of functionally related genes like those for the plastid NADH–dehydrogenase complex and concomitant losses of RNA polymerase genes together with their target promoters point to “domino effects” where an initial loss might have triggered others. An example, which will be discussed in more detail, is the concomitant loss of the intron maturase gene matK and all introns that are supposedly subject to MatK-dependent splicing in two Cuscuta species.     

The cost of mutualism: interactions between Trollius europaeus and its pollinating parasites

Summary Photosynthetic acclimation to 5 light environments ranging from 2 to 60% full sun was determined in Alocasia macrorrhiza, a shade tolerant species from tropical forest understories, and Colocasia esculenta, a cultivated species which occurs naturally in open marshy areas. Photosynthetic capacities of both species increased nearly 3 fold with increased photon flux density (PFD). In a given environment, however, photosynthetic capacities of C. esculenta were double those of A. macrorrhiza. Stomatal limitations explained only a small part of this difference. Respiration rates and estimated biochemical capacities increased in parallel to photosynthetic capacity. No differences were observed either between species or environments in the ratio of RuBP regeneration capacity to carboxylation capacity as determined from the CO₂ dependence response of photosynthesis. Quantum yields of both species decreased only slightly with increasing growth PFD, providing little evidence for photoinhibition at high PFD. The results are discussed in terms of the mechanisms of and limitations on acclimation in these two species.     

Photosynthetic Characteristics and the Ratios of Chlorophyll, β-Carotene,and the Components of the Xanthophyll Cycle Upon a Sudden Increase in Growth Light Regime in Several Plant Species*

Among three species, Gossypium hirsutum, Rhizophora mangle, and Monstera deliciosa, which were transferred from low to high growth PFD, only small decreases in the efficiency of photochemical energy conversion were observed in those plants which exhibited an increase in photosynthetic capacity. Leaves of plants which showed no increase in photosynthetic capacity experienced a continuous decrease in photochemical efficiency, accompanied by a more pronounced loss of chlorophyll than that observed in the former group. In all species marked increases in the xanthophyll/β-carotene ratio resulted from small increases in lutein, and several-fold increases in the sum of the three components of the xanthophyll cycle, zeaxanthin, antheraxanthin, and violaxanthin. A strong increase in the level of zeaxanthin was only partially matched by a decrease of violaxanthin to zero, and was further paralleled by a decrease in β-carotene. Antiparallel changes in the sum of zeaxanthin + antheraxanthin + violaxanthin and β-carotene between morning and evening were observed in all species. These diel changes were overlaid on a net increase in β-carotene as well as total carotenoid content in those plants in which photosynthetic capacity increased. In those, however, which exhibited no photosynthetic acclimation upon transfer to high light, a decrease in both β-carotene and total carotenoid content was observed. Rhizophora mangle grown at 100 % seawater exhibited a particularly high capacity for increasing the level of zeaxanthin in response to high light.     

Impact of a parasitic plant on the zonation of two salt marsh perennials

Animal, fungal, and bacterial consumers can have dramatic effects on the structure of plant communities, often by consuming dominant competitors and indirectly increasing the abundance of inferior competitors. We investigated the role of a consumer plant, the parasite Cuscuta salina, on plant zonation in a western salt marsh. Cuscuta had a strong host species preference in experiments, disproportionally infecting Salicornia virginica, the dominant competitor in most of the marsh. In plots with Cuscuta, which infected 18% of our study area over a 3-year period, Salicornia cover decreased and the cover of Arthrocnemum increased substantially in comparison to plots without Cuscuta. Deep in the Salicornia zone, the cover of Arthrocnemum in Cuscuta-infected plots increased by 558% in 1 year relative to uninfected plots. At the ecotone, the cover of Arthrocnemum in Cuscuta-infected plots increased by only 41% during the same time interval. These data suggest that the relative benefit of a consumer to a less-preferred, subordinate competitor may be strongest where competition is the most asymmetrical as predicted by recent theoretical models. By weakening the competitive dominant, which in the absence of the parasite can create virtual monocultures, Cuscuta enhanced community diversity and altered the ecotone between Salicornia and Arthrocnemum. Cuscuta patches were highly dynamic at the ecotone between Salicornia and Arthrocnemum, and thus the changes we measured in our sample plots were likely to be representative of large portions of the marsh. Our findings emphasize the importance of trophic interactions in salt marsh structure and zonation. Received: 23 April 1997 / Accepted: 10 October 1997     

Contrasting patterns of photosynthetic acclimation and photoinhibition in two evergreen herbs from a winter deciduous forest

The relationship between the microclimate within an Oak-Hickory forest and photosynthetic characters of two resident evergreen herbs with contrasting leaf phenologies was investigated on a monthly basis for 1 full year. Heuchera americana has leaf flushes in the spring and fall, with average leaf life spans of 6–7 months. Hexastylis arifolia produces a single cohort of leaves each spring with a leaf life span of 12–13 months. We predicted that among evergreen plants inhabiting a seasonal habitat, a species for which the frequency of leaf turnover is greater than the frequency of seasonal extremes would have a greater annual range in photosynthetic capacity than a species that only produced a single flush of leaves during the year. Photosynthetic parameters, including apparent quantum yield, maximum photosynthetic capacity (P_max), temperature of maximum photosynthesis, photochemical efficiency of PSII and leaf nitrogen (N) and chlorophyll concentrations, were periodically measured under laboratory conditions in leaves sampled from natural populations of both species. Mature leaves of both species acclimated to changing understory conditions with the mean seasonal differences being significantly greater for Heuchera than for Hexastylis. Area based maximum photosynthetic rates at 25°C were approximately 250% and 100% greater in winter leaves than summer leaves for Heuchera and Hexastylis respectively. Nitrogen concentrations were highest in winter leaves. Chlorophyll concentrations were highest in summer leaves. Low P_max/N values for these species suggest preferential allocation of leaf nitrogen into non-photosynthetic pools and/or light-harvesting function at the expense of photosynthetic enzymes and electron transport components. Despite the increase in photosynthetic capacity, there was evidence of chronic winter photoinhibition in Hexastylis, but not in Heuchera. Among these ecologically similar species, there appears to be a trade-off between the frequency of leaf production and the balance of photosynthetic acclimation and photoinhibition.     

Light acclimation, CO2 response and long-term capacity of underwater photosynthesis in three terrestrial plant species

To characterize underwater photosynthetic performance in some terrestrial plants, we determined (i) underwater light acclimation (ii) underwater photosynthetic response to dissolved CO₂, and (iii) underwater photosynthetic capacity during prolonged submergence in three species that differ in submergence tolerance: Phalaris arundinacea, Rumex crispus (both submergence-tolerant) and Arrhenatherum elatius (submergence-intolerant). None of the species had adjusted to low irradiance after 1 week of submergence. Under non-submerged (control) conditions, only R. crispus displayed shade acclimation. Submergence increased the apparent quantum yield in this species, presumably because of the enhanced CO₂ affinity of the elongated leaves. In control plants of the grass species P. arundinacea and A. elatius, CO₂ affinities were higher than for R. crispus. The underwater photosynthetic capacity of R. crispus increased during 1 month of submergence. In P. arundinacea photosynthesis remained constant during 1 month of submergence at normal irradiance; at low irradiance a reduction in photosynthetic capacity was observed after 2 weeks, although there was no tissue degeneration. In contrast, underwater photosynthesis of the submergence-intolerant species A. elatius collapsed rapidly under both irradiances, and this was accompanied by leaf decay. To describe photosynthesis versus irradiance curves, four models were evaluated. The hyperbolic tangent produced the best goodness-of-fit, whereas the rectangular hyperbola (Michaelis-Menten model) gave relatively poor results.     

The parasitic mechanism of the holostemparasitic plant Cuscuta

Cuscuta is a stem holoparasitic plant without leaves or roots, which develops a haustorium and sucks nutrients from host plants. The genus Cuscuta comprises about 200 species, many of which can cause severe problems for certain crops. The parasitic process in Cuscuta begins in finding and attaching to a host plant and then developing a haustorium. The process does not always require any chemical signal, but does require a light signal. Finding a host involves detecting the lower red light:far-red light ratio near a potential host plant by phytochrome. A contact signal is also necessary for haustorium induction. Apparently, cytokinin increase is downstream of the light and contact signal and is critical for haustorium induction. This pathway, however, appears to be slightly different from a standard pathway. The direct connection between Cuscuta and its host involves both the xylem and phloem, and mRNA and proteins can translocate. Several features indicate that Cuscuta is a useful model plant for parasite plant research as well as plant–plant interaction research. These include the simple anatomical structure and seedling development, no chemical requirement for haustorium induction, and the wide range of host plants.     

High thermal acclimation potential of both photosynthesis and respiration in two lowland Plantago species in contrast to an alpine congeneric

Thermal acclimation of photosynthesis and respiration can enable plants to maintain near constant rates of net CO₂ exchange, despite experiencing sustained changes in daily average temperature. In this study, we investigated whether the degree of acclimation of photosynthesis and respiration of mature leaves differs among three congeneric Plantago species from contrasting habitats [two fast‐growing lowland species (Plantago major and P. lanceolata), and one slow‐growing alpine species (P. euryphylla)]. In addition to investigating some mechanisms underpinning variability in photosynthetic acclimation, we also determined whether leaf respiration in the light acclimates to the same extent as leaf respiration in darkness, and whether acclimation reestablishes the balance between leaf respiration and photosynthesis. Three growth temperatures were provided: constant 13, 20, or 27°C. Measurements were made at five temperatures (6–34°C). Little acclimation of photosynthesis and leaf respiration to growth temperature was exhibited by P. euryphylla. Moreover, leaf masses per area (LMA) were similar in 13°C‐grown and 20°C‐grown plants of the alpine species. In contrast, growth at 13°C increased LMA in the two lowland species; this was associated with increased photosynthetic capacity and rates of leaf respiration (both in darkness and in the light). Alleviation of triose phosphate limitation and increased capacity of electron transport capacity relative to carboxylation were also observed. Such changes demonstrate that the lowland species cold‐acclimated. Light reduced the short‐term temperature dependence (i.e. Q₁₀) of leaf respiration in all three species, irrespective of growth temperature. Collectively, our results highlight the tight coupling that exists between thermal acclimation of photosynthetic and leaf respiratory metabolism (both in darkness and in the light) in Plantago. If widespread among contrasting species, such coupling may enable modellers to assume levels of acclimation in one parameter (e.g. leaf respiration) where details are only known for the other (e.g. photosynthesis).     

Acclimation to low ultraviolet-B radiation increases photosystem I abundance and cyclic electron transfer with enhanced photosynthesis and growth in the cyanobacterium Nostoc sphaeroides

Ultraviolet-B radiation is known to harm most photosynthetic organisms with the exception of several studies of photosynthetic eukaryotes in which UV-B showed positive effects. In this study, we investigated the effect of acclimation to low UV-B radiation on growth and photosynthesis of the cyanobacterium Nostoc sphaeroides. Exposure to 0.08 W m⁻² UV-B plus low visible light for 14 d significantly increased the growth rate and biomass production by 16% and 30%, respectively, compared with those under visible light alone. The UV-B acclimated cells showed an approximately 50% increase in photosynthetic efficiency (α) and photosynthetic capacity (P_max), a higher PSI/PSII fluorescence ratio, an increase in PSI content and consequently enhanced cyclic electron flow, relative to those of non-acclimated cells. Both the primary quinone-type acceptor and plastoquinone pool re-oxidation were up-regulated in the UV-B acclimated cells. In parallel, the UV-B acclimated colonies maintained a higher rate of D1 protein synthesis following exposure to elevated intensity of UV-B or visible light, thus functionally mitigating photoinhibition. The present data provide novel insight into photosynthetic acclimation to low UV-B radiation and suggest that UV-B may act as a positive ecological factor for the productivity of some photosynthetic prokaryotes, especially during twilight periods or in shaded environments.     

The non-photochemical reduction of plastoquinone in leaves

Although it is generally assumed that the plastoquinone pool of thylakoid membranes in leaves of higher plants is rapidly oxidized upon darkening, this is often not the case. A multiflash kinetic fluorimeter was used to monitor the redox state of the plastoquinone pool in leaves. It was found that in many species of plants, particularly those using the NAD-malic enzyme C₄ system of photosynthesis, the pool actually became more reduced following a light to dark transition. In some Amaranthus species, plastoquinone remained reduced in the dark for several hours. Far red light, which preferentially drives Photosystem I turnover, could effectively oxidize the plastoquinone pool. Plastoquinone was re-reduced in the dark within a few seconds when far red illumination was removed. The underlying mechanism of the dark reduction of the plastoquinone pool is still uncertain but may involve chlororespiratory activity.Abbreviations apparent F_o observed fluorescence yield after dark adaptation - F_m maximum fluorescence when all Q_A is fully reduced - F_o minimum fluorescence yield when Q_A is fully oxidized and non-photochemical quenching is fully relaxed - F_s steady state fluorescence yield - PPFD photosynthetic photon flux density - PQ plastoquinone - Q_A primary quinone acceptor of the Photosystem II reaction center - Q_B secondary quinone acceptor to the Photosystem II reaction center - F F_m minus F_s     

EVOLUTION OF C3 AND C4 PLANTS ALONG AN ENVIRONMENTAL MOISTURE GRADIENT: PATTERNS OF PHOTOSYNTHETIC DIFFERENTIATION IN HAWAIIAN SCAEVOLA AND EUPHORBIA SPECIES

The endemic Hawaiian species of Scaevola and Euphorbia grow in a wide variety of native habitats and exhibit a wide range of variation in photosynthetic responses. Light-saturated photosynthetic capacities range from 12.0 to 24.7 μmol CO₂ m^−-2 s^−-1 in the Scaevola species and from 18.2 to 51.4 μmol CO₂ m^−-2 s^−-1 in the Euphorbia species. Within each genus, differences in light-saturated photosynthetic capacity are paralleled by differences in mesophyll and leaf conductances to CO₂. Within each habitat, the C₄ Euphorbia species exhibits a significantly higher photosynthetic capacity and a significantly higher mesophyll conductance than the corresponding C₃ Scaevola species. These differences are greatest in the dry scrub habitat and least in the wet forest habitat. One photosynthetic characteristic that exhibits little variation among the species within each genus, yet that exhibits a consistently large difference between the species within each habitat, is photosynthetic water-use efficiency. The C₄ Euphorbia species possess water-use efficiencies that are 2–3½ times as high as those of the C₃ Scaevola species, regardless of whether these species are native to very dry or very wet habitats. At present, the ecological significance of this large inherent difference in photosynthetic water-use efficiency is unknown. Indeed, it appears that neither photosynthetic pathway has imposed any major inherent constraints on the ability of the Scaevola and Euphorbia species to diversify into a wide variety of habitats.