Retinoic acid and its receptors in limb regeneration

The effects of retinoids on the regenerating amphibian limb are described: the mesenchymal cells of the blastema can be proximalized, posteriorized and ventralized. Ectopic limbs are also induced after retinoid treatment of regenerating tails, but not during limb development unless the limb bud is damaged. The cellular and molecular alterations induced by retinoids are reported as well as experiments which have revealed the importance of endogenous retinoids for normal limb regeneration. Various retinoic acid receptors are expressed in the regeneration blastema and the experiments which have revealed functions for individual isoforms are described. These experiments reveal that retinoids are a crucial component of the normal, regenerating limb and demonstrate the value of the regenerating limb as an experimental system for providing functional data on individual retinoic acid receptors.     

Retinoic acid in development and regeneration

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have profound effects upon the development of various embryonic systems. Here I review the effects on developing and regenerating limbs, regenerating amphibian tails and the developing central nervous system (CNS). In the regenerating amphibian limb, retinoids can proximalize, posteriorize and ventralize the axes of the blastema. In the chick limb bud retinoids can only posteriorize the tissue. In the regenerating amphibian tail retinoids can homeotically transform tail tissue into hindlimb tissue. In the developing and regenerating limb retinoic acid has been detected endogenously, confirming that this molecule plays a role in the generation of pattern and we have shown that limbs cannot develop in the absence of retinoic acid. In the developing CNS retinoic acid specifically affects the hindbrain where it causes a transformation of anterior rhombomeres into more posterior ones. Again, endogenous retinoic acid has been detected in the CNS and in the absence of retinoids the posterior hindbrain has been found to be affected. The effects of retinoids on the CNS are most likely to be mediated via theHox genes acting in the mesoderm after gastrulation. It has also been proposed that the establishment of the head-to-tail axis in the mesoderm is established by retinoic acid. These data show that retinoids play an important role in both the development and regeneration of various systems in the embryo and post-embryonically     

The relationship among retinoid structure, affinity for retinoic acid-binding protein, and ability to respecify pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb

To further our understanding of the action of retinoids on the respecification of pattern in the regenerating axolotl limb we have studied the relative potencies of a range of synthetic and natural retinoids administered locally to the blastema. Alterations in the polar end group of the retinoic acid (RA) molecule to produce esters, the alcohol, or the aldehyde abolish the ability of the molecule to respecify pattern. On the other hand, alterations of the ring or side chain to produce the synthetic retinoids arotinoid and TTNPB considerably increases the potency of the molecule to respecify pattern--TTNPB is at least 100X more potent than retinoic acid. To examine the role of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABP) in the respecification process we determined the relative binding affinities of these retinoids for CRABP. These data correlated well with the respecification series: retinoids which showed no affinity for CRABP did not respecify pattern and those which did show affinity for CRABP did respecify pattern. Furthermore the most potent retinoid, TTNPB, has a higher affinity for CRABP than RA itself. This suggests that CRABP may be playing an important role in the action of RA on pattern formation in the regenerating limb.     

Retinoid antagonists inhibit normal patterning during limb regeneration in the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum

Retinoic acid (RA) has been detected in the regenerating limb of the axolotl, and exogenous RA can proximalize, posteriorize, and ventralize blastemal cells. Thus, RA may be an endogenous regulatory factor during limb regeneration. We have investigated whether endogenous retinoids are essential for patterning during axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) limb regeneration by using retinoid antagonists that bind to specific RAR (retinoic acid receptor) or RXR (retinoid X receptor) retinoid receptor subtypes. Retinoid antagonists (Ro41-5253, Ro61-8431, LE135, and LE540) were administered to regenerating limbs using implanted silastin blocks loaded with each antagonist. The skeletal pattern of regenerated limbs treated with Ro41-5253 or Ro61-8431 differed only slightly from control limbs. Treatment with LE135 inhibited limb regeneration, while treatment with LE540 allowed relatively normal limb regeneration. When LE135 and LE540 were implanted together, regeneration was not completely inhibited and a hand-like process regenerated. These results demonstrate that interfering with retinoid receptors can modify pattern in the regenerating limb indicating that endogenous retinoids are important during patterning of the regenerating limb.     

The effect of vitamin A (retinoids) on pattern formation implies a uniformity of developmental mechanisms throughout the animal kingdom

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have a profound effect upon the development of a diverse array of animals. Here, I review these effects on Invertebrates: a colonial hydroid, a colonial ascidian, and Vertebrates: the regenerating amphibian limb, the developing chick limb bud, the regenerating amphibian tail, the anteroposterior axis of the early embryo, the developing chick embryo skin. There is a striking uniformity of effect of retinoids on pattern formation when applied to these diverse organisms. The majority react by being posteriorized in their development, although additional effects can also be seen. Several hypotheses which can explain these results are discussed along with the deduction that they lead to: retinoids may be components of a universal developmental mechanism or they may simply act in a similar way to alter a universal developmental mechanism. In either case the experimental analysis of retinoid effects on development has important implications for the evolution of developmental mechanisms.     

Regeneration, neural crest derivatives and retinoids: a new synthesis

Consideration of recent data from diverse fields of biology permits the presentation of a general theory to explain the underlying mechanism and phylogenetic distribution of vertebrate regenerative capacity. It is suggested that dermal xanthophores, which are neural crest derivatives that contain carotenoid pigments, serve as storage reservoirs for proretinoids. At trauma, carotenoids are released and are converted to retinoids. The spatial distribution of xanthophores at the amputation site determines the amount of carotenoids released, which in turn determines the number of cells which will participate in regeneration and their degree of dedifferentiation. It also influences the proliferative and morphogenetic potential of the blastema. The theory is based on several factors. (1) The pluripotency of neural crest derivatives in general and that of chromatophores in particular; (2) The storage metabolism of carotenoids, especially their convertability to retinoids; (3) The known roles of retinoids in regeneration; (4) Evidence suggesting a relationship between carotenoids and regeneration in invertebrates; and (5) Dynamic characteristics of regenerating systems. The theory is experimentally testable with currently available technology. Specific review of data concerning urodele lens regeneration illustrates the theory. Evidence from amphibian limb regeneration is also presented. Methods of evaluation of other regeneration systems are outlined.     

Retinoic acid does not induce formation of cilia on the surface of wound epithelial cells in axolotls

It has been reported that vitamin A palmitate induces the production of cilia on the epidermal cells of the regenerating axolotl limb, and the formation of crevices in the epidermal surface. The aim of the present investigation was to reexamine under well defined conditions the potential of retinoids to evoke the above described metaplastic changes. In order to achieve our purpose we administered axolotls with retinoic acid for 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 days after limb amputation. The young regenerates were inspected by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The data obtained showed that the external layer of the wound epithelium and of the stump epidermis as well was quite normal without any sign of cilia formation. In some cases, crevices were observed even in control animals.     

Effects of retinoids on regenerating limbs: comparison of retinoic acid and arotinoid at different amputation levels

Summary Retinoic acid and the synthetic retinoid, arotinoid, were compared for their efficacy in inducing proximodistal (PD) pattern duplication in regenerating axolotl limbs, after amputation through either the distal zeugopodium (lower arm or leg) or distal stylopodium (upper arm or leg). At each level of amputation, the morphology of the duplications produced was the same for both retinoids, and the mean level of proximalization was dose-dependent. Blastema formation was delayed by both retinoids and the delay was associated with regression of the limb stump. Blastemas which produced PD duplication to the stylopodial or girdle level grew out from the stump in a posterior direction. In several zeugopodial regenerates, a partially duplicated, PD-reversed zeugopodium regenerated between the stump cartilages and a completely duplicated zeugopodium distally. Arotinoid was 50 times more effective than retinoic acid in evoking duplication. The dose of arotinoid required to duplicate a stylopodium in a stylopodial regenerate was several times higher than the dose required to duplicate a zeugopodium in a zeugopodial regenerate, suggesting differences either in the sensitivity of zeugopodial and stylopodial cells to retinoid, or in the numbers of positional value specifying these segments.     

Expression and role of retinoic acid receptor alpha in lens regeneration

The role of retinoids in eye development has been well studied. Retinoids and their receptors regulate gene expression and morphogenesis of the eye. In this study, a highly specific antagonist of retinoic acid receptor (RAR)-alpha was used in an attempt to study its function in lens regeneration. It was found that this antagonist inhibited lens regeneration and lens fiber differentiation. It was also shown that RAR-alpha is expressed in the lens during the process of regeneration. These results indicate that different RAR might have unique as well as redundant effects and patterns of expression in the regenerating lens.     

Characterization of retinoid metabolism in the developing chick limb bud

Retinoids (vitamin A derivatives) have been shown to have striking effects on developing and regenerating vertebrate limbs. In the developing chick limb, retinoic acid is a candidate morphogen that may coordinate the pattern of cellular differentiation along the anteroposterior limb axis. We describe a series of investigations of the metabolic pathway of retinoids in the chick limb bud system. To study retinoid metabolism in the bud, all-trans-[3H]retinol, all-trans-[3H]retinal and all-trans-[3H]retinoic acid were released into the posterior region of the limb anlage, the area that contains the zone of polarizing activity, a tissue possibly involved in limb pattern formation. We found that the locally applied [3H]retinol is primarily converted to [3H]retinal, [3H]retinoic acid and a yet unidentified metabolite. When [3H]retinal is locally applied, it is either oxidized to [3H]retinoic acid or reduced to [3H]retinol. In contrast, local delivery of retinoic acid to the bud yields neither retinal nor retinol nor the unknown metabolite. This flow of metabolites agrees with the biochemical pathway of retinoids that has previously been elucidated in a number of other animal systems. To find out whether metabolism takes place directly in the treated limb bud, we have compared the amount of [3H]retinoid present in each of the four limb anlagen following local treatment of the right wing bud. The data suggest that retinoid metabolism takes place mostly in the treated limb bud. This local metabolism could provide a simple mechanism to generate in a controlled fashion the biologically active all-trans-retinoic acid from its abundant biosynthetic precursor retinol. In addition, local metabolism supports the hypothesis that retinoids are local chemical mediators involved in pattern formation.     

Effects of vitamin D metabolites on axolotl limb regeneration

Vitamin D is essential for normal metabolism of phosphorus and calcium, and differentiation of skeletal elements. 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin-D₃, the biologically active metabolite, acts as an induction/proliferation switch in various cell types and promotes chondrogenesis of chick limb bud mesenchymal cells. The function of vitamin D is mediated through its nuclear receptor, the vitamin D receptor (VDR). The proliferative actions of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃ on limb bud mesenchymal cells are similar to the ones produced by retinoids, such as all- trans retinoic acid (RA) or 9- cis retinoic acid (9- cis ). The retinoids have been shown to be compounds of extreme importance in the field of limb development and regeneration. In order to examine possible roles of vitamin D metabolites on limb regeneration, the effects of 1,25(OH)₂-D₃, 24,25(OH)₂-D₃ and KH1060 (a more potent metabolite) alone or in conjunction with all- trans RA or 9- cis RA on the regenerating axolotl limb. Vitamin D affects limb morphogenesis by generating abnormalities in skeletal elements. Synergism of vitamin D with retinoic acid in affecting pattern formation is suggested by the results.     

Emerging roles for retinoids in regeneration and differentiation in normal and disease states

The vitamin A (retinol) metabolite, all-trans retinoic acid (RA), is a signaling molecule that plays key roles in the development of the body plan and induces the differentiation of many types of cells. In this review the physiological and pathophysiological roles of retinoids (retinol and related metabolites) in mature animals are discussed. Both in the developing embryo and in the adult, RA signaling via combinatorial Hox gene expression is important for cell positional memory. The genes that require RA for the maturation/differentiation of T cells are only beginning to be cataloged, but it is clear that retinoids play a major role in expression of key genes in the immune system. An exciting, recent publication in regeneration research shows that ALDH1a2 (RALDH2), which is the rate-limiting enzyme in the production of RA from retinaldehyde, is highly induced shortly after amputation in the regenerating heart, adult fin, and larval fin in zebrafish. Thus, local generation of RA presumably plays a key role in fin formation during both embryogenesis and in fin regeneration. HIV transgenic mice and human patients with HIV-associated kidney disease exhibit a profound reduction in the level of RARβ protein in the glomeruli, and HIV transgenic mice show reduced retinol dehydrogenase levels, concomitant with a greater than 3-fold reduction in endogenous RA levels in the glomeruli. Levels of endogenous retinoids (those synthesized from retinol within cells) are altered in many different diseases in the lung, kidney, and central nervous system, contributing to pathophysiology. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Retinoid and Lipid Metabolism.     

Limb Regeneration in the Fiddler Crab, Uca pugilator: Histological, Physiological and Molecular Considerations

This paper summarizes our recent work on the histological, physiologicaland molecular aspects of limb regeneration in the fiddler crabUca pugilator and new information is presented on mitotic activityin the blastema during the first days of blastemal organization.We also report for the first time the localization of vertebrategrowth factor immunoreactivity (FGF 2 and FGF 4) in the regeneratingblastema. In the first part of this paper we review recent histologicalfindings concerning the physical events that accompany autotomyof limbs and propose a new function for the autotomy membrane—thetethering of the regenerating pedal nerve to the walls of thecoxa. In the second part of the paper we review our recent findingson the identification and characterization of the Uca ecdysteroidreceptor (UpEcR, and its potential dimer partner, the retinoid-X-receptor,UpRXR). Using Uca-specific antibody probes raised in our lab,we have been able to identify specific cells in the early blastemathat express receptor proteins. The regenerating limb of thefiddler crab is responsive to both steroids and retinoids andmRNA for steroid and retinoid receptors are expressed in theregenerating limb buds during all stages of regeneration. TheDNA and deduced amino acid sequences of the ecdysteroid receptoris very similar to the sequences of insect EcRs, while the retinoidreceptor is similar to insect protein (ultraspiracle) in theDNA-binding domain, but closer to vertebrate RXRs in the ligandbinding domain     

Inhibition of trans-retinoic acid-resistant human breast cancer cell growth by retinoid X receptor-selective retinoids.

All-trans-retinoic acid (trans-RA) and other retinoids exert anticancer effects through two types of retinoid receptors, the RA receptors (RARs) and retinoid X receptors (RXRs). Previous studies demonstrated that the growth-inhibitory effects of trans-RA and related retinoids are impaired in certain estrogen-independent breast cancer cell lines due to their lower levels of RAR alpha and RARbeta. In this study, we evaluated several synthetic retinoids for their ability to induce growth inhibition and apoptosis in both trans-RA-sensitive and trans-RA-resistant breast cancer cell lines. Our results demonstrate that RXR-selective retinoids, particularly in combination with RAR-selective retinoids, could significantly induce RARbeta and inhibit the growth and induce the apoptosis of trans-RA-resistant, RAR alpha-deficient MDA-MB-231 cells but had low activity against trans-RA-sensitive ZR-75-1 cells that express high levels of RAR alpha. Using gel retardation and transient transfection assays, we found that the effects of RXR-selective retinoids on MDA-MB-231 cells were most likely mediated by RXR-nur77 heterodimers that bound to the RA response element in the RARbeta promoter and activated the RARbeta promoter in response to RXR-selective retinoids. In contrast, growth inhibition by RAR-selective retinoids in trans-RA-sensitive, RAR alpha-expressing cells most probably occurred through RXR-RAR alpha heterodimers that also bound to and activated the RARbeta promoter. In MDA-MB-231 clones stably expressing RAR alpha, both RARbeta induction and growth inhibition by RXR-selective retinoids were suppressed, while the effects of RAR-selective retinoids were enhanced. Together, our results demonstrate that activation of RXR can inhibit the growth of trans-RA-resistant MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells and suggest that low cellular RAR alpha may regulate the signaling switch from RAR-mediated to RXR-mediated growth inhibition in breast cancer cells.     

Chromatographic analysis of endogenous retinoids in tissues and serum

We present a reliable, highly sensitive, and versatile method for the simultaneous determination of endogenous polar (acidic) and apolar (retinol, retinal, and retinyl esters) retinoids in various biological matrices. Following a single liquid extraction of retinoids from tissues or plasma with isopropanol, polar retinoids are separated from apolar retinoids and neutral lipids via automated solid-phase extraction using an aminopropyl phase. After vacuum concentration to dryness and reconstitution of the residue in appropriate solvents, the obtained fractions are injected onto two different high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)-systems. Polar retinoids are analyzed on a RP18 column (2.1mm ID) using a buffered gradient composed of methanol and water and on-column-focusing large-volume injection. Apolar retinoids are separated on a normal-bore RP18 column using a nonaqueous gradient composed of acetonitrile, chloroform, and methanol. Both HPLC systems are coupled with UV detection, and retinoids are quantitated against appropriate internal standards. The method was validated with regard to recovery, precision, robustness, selectivity, and analyte stability. Using 400 microl serum or 200mg tissue, the limits of detection for all-trans-retinoic acid were 0.15ng/ml or 0.3ng/g, respectively. The corresponding values for retinol were 1.2ng/ml or 2.4ng/g, respectively. This method was successfully applied to mouse, rat, and human tissue and serum samples.     

Detection of radical species in mixtures of some retinoids with hematin by using the ESR spin-trapping technique

Radical species were detected in mixtures of some retinoids with hematin by using the ESR spin-trapping technique. The rates of radical formation were approximately proportional to the oxygen consumption during the incubation of the retinoids with hematin. HPLC analyses of the incubation mixtures of the retinoids with hematin showed that 5,6-epoxides of the retinoids were formed. The amounts of the epoxides formed were proportional to both oxygen consumption and the amounts of radicals formed. These results suggest that the 5,6-epoxidations proceed via radical intermediates.     

Considerations for in vitro retinoid experiments: importance of protein interaction

Retinoids, natural and synthetic substances structurally related to vitamin A, are important modulators of cell proliferation and differentiation, and have proven activity in cancer therapy. Experiments to reveal the mechanism of action of retinoids are routinely performed in in vitro models. As retinoids are relatively hydrophobic and unstable, we hypothesized that the composition of culture media is of critical importance for the stability and bioavailability of these compounds. Various culture media were incubated with all-trans-, 13-cis- and 9-cis-retinoic acid (RA). Without fetal calf serum (FCS) or bovine serum albumin (BSA) in the medium, the concentration of these retinoids was found to decrease to considerably low levels. This excessive loss of retinoids was due to absorption to culture plates, reaction tubes and pipet tips. Binding of retinoids to BSA was demonstrated to have attenuating effects on uptake and metabolism of all-trans-RA, as studied in oral keratinocytes and head and neck cancer cells, indicating that a balance exists between the bioavailability and the aspecific loss of retinoids. In this study we demonstrate that the type of culture medium and especially the presence of protein in the medium is of paramount importance to perform reproducible experiments with retinoids.     

Osteoblastic activity and estrogenic response in the regenerating scale of goldfish, a good model of osteogenesis

Osteogenesis in the teleost was morphologically observed using regenerating scales of goldfish. Histological observations indicated that osteoblasts around the regenerating scales on days 7 to 10 were greater in size and number than those at other stages. Therefore, further experiments were carried out to examine the activity of osteoblasts in the regenerating period. To quantify their osteoblastic activities, scales on the left side of the body were taken, and the regenerating scales were then used to measure the activities of alkaline phosphatase (ALP), a marker of osteoblasts, on days 7, 10, and 15. The ontogenic scales on the right side of the body were also collected and used to measure ALP activity on the same days. Osteoblasts at all stages of regenerating scales were more active than those in the remaining ontogenic scales. The regenerating scales on day 10 had the highest activity. Furthermore, we found that estrogen receptor (ER) mRNA was expressed in the regenerating scales because estrogen participates in osteoblastic growth and differentiation in mammals. Therefore, using a scale culture system reported previously, the estrogenic response was examined in the ontogenic and regenerating scales on day 10. The reactivity was much higher in regenerating scales, although estrogen treatment significantly activated the osteoblastic activities in both scales. We are the first to demonstrate that ER is expressed in regenerating scales and that estrogen participates in osteogenesis as it does in mammalian bone. Our findings strongly suggest that regenerating scales can be used as a model of osteogenesis in vertebrates.     

Distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud: analysis with monoclonal antibody

Retinoic acid induces anteroposterior duplicate formation in developing chick limb bud, and it may be a natural morphogen involved in limb pattern formation. Retinoic acid is produced from retinol locally in the limb bud via retinal, and thus, to elucidate the distribution of these retinoids in the limb bud seems to be important for the understanding of the morphogen formation. We produced a monoclonal antibody against the retinoids with BSA-RA (bovine serum albumin-retinoic acid) conjugate for antigen, and investigated the distribution of retinoids in the chick limb bud. The antibody predominantly bound to retinoic acid, but weakly to retinol and retinal. Retinoids appeared in the limb bud at stage 18 and were distributed through stages 20-24, when the pattern formation in distal mesoderm was in progress. Initially they were found evenly in the whole mesoderm, but disappeared gradually from core mesoderm and remained only in the region of peripheral mesoderm at stage 24. At stage 26, retinoids were detected only in ectoderm. These results support the idea that the retinoids actually play roles in limb pattern formation and suggest that the retinoids in the peripheral mesoderm are important for pattern formation. Further, the role of retinoids in epidermis development at later limb bud stages is also suggested.     

Pulse radiolysis study of the interaction of retinoids with peroxyl radicals

Vitamin A (retinol) and its derivatives-retinal and retinoic acid-are known for their ability to inhibit lipid peroxidation. Antioxidant actions of retinoids have been attributed to chain-breaking by scavenging of peroxyl radicals. Based on chemical analysis of retinoic acid degradation products formed during microsomal lipid peroxidation, it was previously suggested that retinoids interact with peroxyl radicals forming free carbon-centered radical adducts. However, it can be argued that such a mode of antioxidant action of retinoids is not sufficient to fully explain their effectiveness at inhibiting lipid peroxidation, which in many systems is comparable to, or even exceeds, that of alpha-tocopherol. In order to elucidate the mechanism of interaction of retinoids with peroxyl radicals, (trichloromethyl)peroxyl radical was generated by pulse radiolysis, and its interactions with retinoids solubilized in Triton X-100 micelles were followed by kinetic absorption spectroscopy. All retinoids--retinol, retinal, and retinoic acid--interacted with the peroxyl radical, and at least two transient products were detected. One of these products, absorbing at 590 nm, was identified as retinoid cation radical. Therefore, we postulate that, apart from formation of radical adducts, retinoids may also scavenge peroxyl radicals by electron transfer.