Diversity loss, recruitment limitation, and ecosystem functioning: lessons learned from a removal experiment

A five-year removal experiment in which plant functional group diversity was manipulated found strong limitation of ecosystem functioning caused by the differing abilities of remaining functional groups to recruit into space left unoccupied by the plants removed. We manipulated functional group diversity and composition by removing all possible combinations of zero, one, or two plant functional groups (forbs, C₃ graminoids, and C₄ graminoids), as well as randomly chosen biomass at levels corresponding to the functional group removals, from a prairie grassland community. Although random biomass removal treatments showed no significant effect of removing biomass in general on ecosystem functions measured ( P >0.05), the loss of particular functional groups led to significant differences in above- ( P <0.001) and belowground ( P <0.001) biomass, rooting-zone ( P =0.001) and leached ( P =0.01) nitrogen, nitrogen mineralization ( P <0.001), and community drought resistance ( P =0.002). Many of these differences stemmed from the marked difference in the ways remaining functional groups responded to the experimental removals. Strong recruitment limitation of C₄ graminoids resulted in large areas of open ground, high nutrient leaching, and high community drought resistance in plots containing just this functional group. In contrast, rhizomatous C₃ graminoids quickly colonized space and used soil resources made available by the removal of other groups, leading to lower soil nitrate in plots containing C₃ graminoids. These effects of recruitment limitation on ecosystem functioning illustrate possible effects of diversity loss not captured by synthetic experiments in which diversity gradients are created by adding high densities of seeds to bare soil.     

Distribution of C3 and C4 grasses along an altitudinal gradient in Central Argentina

The distribution pattern of C₃ and C₄ grasses was studied in eight sites located between 350 m and 2100 m along an altitudinal gradient in Central Argentina. Of 139 taxa fifty-nine are C₃ and eighty C₄. Species of the C₃ tribes (Stipeae, Poeae, Meliceae, Aveneae, Bromeae and Triticeae) and C₃ Paniceae species increase in number at higher elevations; only one C₃ species was found below 650 m. C₄ Aristideae, Pappophoreae, Eragrostideae, Cynodonteae, Andropogoneae and Paniceae increase at lower altitudes. The floristic crossover point is at about 1500 m; the ground cover cross-over point is at about 1000 m. Analysis of the relationships between % C₄ species along the gradient and nine climatic and environmental variables showed the highest correlation with July mean temperature, but all temperature variables show highly significant correlations with % C₄. Correlation with annual rainfall is lower but also significant. These results are consistent with previous research showing the relative importance of C₄ grasses as temperature increases. C₃ species make a high contribution to relative grass coverage below the C₃/C₄ floristic crossover point but are rare below 1000 m.     

Seasonal differences in photosynthesis between the C3 and C4 subspecies of Alloteropsis semialata are offset by frost and drought

The regional abundance of C₄ grasses is strongly controlled by temperature, however, the role of precipitation is less clear. Progress in elucidating the direct effects of photosynthetic pathway on these climate relationships is hindered by the significant genetic divergence between major C₃ and C₄ grass lineages. We addressed this problem by examining seasonal climate responses of photosynthesis in Alloteropsis semialata , a unique grass species with both C₃ and C₄ subspecies. Experimental manipulation of rainfall in a common garden in South Africa tested the hypotheses that: (1) photosynthesis is greater in the C₄ than C₃ subspecies under high summer temperatures, but this pattern is reversed at low winter temperatures; and (2) the photosynthetic advantage of C₄ plants is enhanced during drought events. Measurements of leaf gas exchange over 2 years showed a significant photosynthetic advantage for the C₄ subspecies under irrigated conditions from spring through autumn. However, the C₄ leaves were killed by winter frost, while photosynthesis continued in the C₃ plants. Unexpectedly, the C₄ subspecies also lost its photosynthetic advantage during natural drought events, despite greater water-use efficiency under irrigated conditions. This study highlights previously unrecognized roles for climatic extremes in determining the ecological success of C₃ and C₄ grasses.     

Strategies for Savanna Restoration in the Southern Great Plains: Effects of Fire and Herbicides

Woody plant encroachment has degraded grassland and savanna ecosystems worldwide by decreasing herbaceous production and diversity, and altering these physiognomies toward woodlands. This study evaluated the long-term efficacy of fire and herbicide restoration strategies used in the southern Great Plains to reduce Honey mesquite ( Prosopis glandulosa ) dominance, restore a grassland/savanna physiognomy, and increase herbaceous production and diversity. Three treatments were evaluated: high-intensity winter fire, aerial spray of clopyralid + triclopyr (C + T), and aerial spray of clopyralid and were compared to untreated mesquite woodland (control). Post-treatment mesquite stand physiognomy was different between fire (low mortality, high basal sprouting), C + T (high mortality, high basal sprouting of surviving plants), and clopyralid (moderate mortality, low basal sprouting of surviving plants) treatments. From 6 to 8 years post-treatment, herbaceous production was increased in C + T and clopyralid treatments but not in the fire treatment. Mesquite regrowth in the fire treatment exerted a competitive influence that limited herbaceous production. Herbaceous functional group diversity was increased in fire and C + T treatments due to a decrease in C₃ perennial grass dominance and an increase in C₄ perennial grasses and/or C₃ forbs. Treatments that maintained mesquite overstory (control and clopyralid) had lower herbaceous diversity due to C₃ perennial grass dominance and lower C₄ perennial grass cover. The clopyralid treatment demonstrated greatest potential for long-term restoration of southern Great Plains savanna by reducing mesquite canopy cover to historic levels, limiting mesquite basal regrowth and increasing grass production.     

Dominance not richness determines invasibility of tallgrass prairie

Many recent studies suggest that more diverse communities are more resistant to invasion. Community characteristics that most strongly influence invasion are uncertain, however, due to covariation of diversity with competition and crowding. We examined separately the effects of species richness and dominance on invasion by an exotic legume, Melilotus officinalis , in intact, native Kansas grassland. We manipulated dominance of C₄ grasses by reducing their abundance (i.e. ramet densities) by ∼25 and 50%. In addition, richness was reduced by removing species that were mainly rare and uncommon as might be expected with environmental changes such as drought and fragmentation. In both years of the study (2001–2002), invasibility, measured as peak establishment of Melilotus , was not affected by a 3-fold reduction in species richness, nor was there an interaction between loss of species and reduced dominance on invasion. In contrast, reductions in abundance of the dominants significantly reduced invasibility of the grassland plots in both years. Because the abundance of dominants was highly correlated with measures of competition (i.e. ratio of dominant biomass to total biomass) and crowding (total stem densities), this pattern was opposite to that expected if competition were indeed limiting invasion. Rather, invasion appeared to be facilitated by the dominant species, most likely because reduced dominance increased environmental stress. Our results suggest that dominance is the key community characteristic determining invasibility, because highly competitive and space-filling species can either enhance or reduce susceptibility to invasion depending on whether dominants create a more competitive environment or alleviate stressful conditions.     

Effects of temperature and fertilization on nitrogen cycling and community composition of an urban lawn

We examined the influence of temperature and management practices on the nitrogen (N) cycling of turfgrass, the largest irrigated crop in the United States. We measured nitrous oxide (N₂O) fluxes, and plant and soil N content and isotopic composition with a manipulative experiment of temperature and fertilizer application. Infrared lamps were used to increase surface temperature by 3.5±1.3 °C on average and control and heated plots were split into high and low fertilizer treatments. The N₂O fluxes increased following fertilizer application and were also directly related to soil moisture. There was a positive effect of warming on N₂O fluxes. Soils in the heated plots were enriched in nitrogen isotope ratio ( δ ¹⁵N) relative to control plots, consistent with greater gaseous losses of N. For all treatments, C₄ plant C/N ratio was negatively correlated with plant δ ¹⁵N, suggesting that low leaf N was associated with the use of isotopically depleted N sources such as mineralized organic matter. A significant and unexpected result was a large, rapid increase in the proportion of C₄ plants in the heated plots relative to control plots, as measured by the carbon isotope ratio ( δ ¹³C) of total harvested aboveground biomass. The C₄ plant biomass was dominated by crabgrass, a common weed in C₃ fescue lawns. Our results suggest that an increase in temperature caused by climate change as well as the urban heat island effect may result in increases in N₂O emissions from fertilized urban lawns. In addition, warming may exacerbate weed invasions, which may require more intensive management, e.g. herbicide application, to manage species composition.     

The origins and diversification of C4 grasses and savanna-adapted ungulates

C₄ grasses constitute the main component of savannas and are pervasive in other dry tropical ecosystems where they serve as the main diet for grazing animals. Among potential factors driving C₄ evolution of grasses, the interaction between grasses and grazers has not been investigated. To evaluate if increased grazing pressure may have selected for higher leaf silica production as the grasses diverged, we reconstructed the phylogeny of all 800 genera of the grass family with both molecular (combined multiplastid DNA regions) and morphological characters. Using molecular clocks, we also calculated the age and number of origins of C₄ clades and found that shifts from C₃ to C₄ photosynthesis occurred at least 12 times starting 30.9 million years ago and found evidence that the most severe drop in atmospheric carbon dioxide in the late Oligocene (between 33 and 30 million years ago) matches the first origin of C₄ photosynthesis in Chloridoideae. By combining fossil and phylogenetic data for ungulates and implementing a randomization procedure, our results showed that the appearance of C₄ grass clades and ungulate adaptations to C₄-dominated habitats match significantly in time. An increase of leaf epidermal density of silica bodies was found to correspond to postulated shifts in diversification rates in the late Miocene [24 significant shifts in diversification ( P <0.05) were detected between 23 and 3.7 million years ago]. For aristidoid and chloridoid grasses, increased grazing pressure may have selected for a higher leaf epidermal silica production in the late Miocene.     

Native species richness buffers invader impact in undisturbed but not disturbed grassland assemblages

Many systems are prone to both exotic plant invasion and frequent natural disturbances. Native species richness can buffer the effects of invasion or disturbance when imposed in isolation, but it is largely unknown whether richness provides substantial resistance against invader impact in the face of disturbance. We experimentally examined how disturbance (drought/burning) influenced the impact of three exotic invaders (Centaurea stoebe, Linaria dalmatica, or Potentilla recta) on native abundance across a gradient of species richness, using previously constructed grassland assemblages. We found that invaders had higher cover in experimentally disturbed plots than in undisturbed plots across all levels of native species richness. Although exotic species varied in cover, all three invaders had significant impacts on native cover in disturbed plots. Regardless of disturbance, however, invader cover diminished with increasing richness. Invader impacts on native cover also diminished at higher richness levels, but only in undisturbed plots. In disturbed plots, invaders strongly impacted native cover across all richness levels, as disturbance favoured invaders over native species. By examining these ecological processes concurrently, we found that disturbance exacerbated invader impacts on native abundance. Although diversity provided a buffering effect against invader impact without disturbance, the combination of invasion and disturbance markedly depressed native abundance, even in high richness assemblages.     

Plant diversity increases resistance to invasion in the absence of covarying extrinsic factors

Biological invasion is a widespread, but poorly understood phenomenon. Elton's hypothesis, supported by theory, experiment, and anecdotal evidence, suggests that an important determinant of invasion success is resident biodiversity, arguing that high diversity increases the competitive environment of communities and makes them more difficult to invade. Observational studies of plant invasions, however, find little support for this hypothesis and argue strongly against it. Lack of control of extrinsic factors (e.g., disturbance, climate, or soil fertility) that covary with biodiversity and invasion in observational studies makes it difficult to determine if their findings truly refute Elton's hypothesis. We examined performance of Crepis tectorum (an invasive, annual composite weed) in experimental prairie grassland plots and greenhouse plant assemblages in which resident species richness was directly manipulated. Under these conditions, unlike observational studies, no covarying extrinsic factors could interfere with interpreting results. We found a strong inverse association between resident diversity and invader performance as predicted by Elton's hypothesis. Higher resident diversity increased crowding, decreased available light, and decreased available nutrients all of which increased the competitive environment of diverse plant assemblages and reduced C. tectorum success. Examination of individual resident species impacts on C. tectorum performance demonstrated that this diversity effect was not due to the sampling effect. These results suggest that both Elton's hypothesis and its competitive mechanism may operate in nature, but covarying extrinsic factors may obscure the negative impact of diversity on invader success.     

Consumer diversity mediates invasion dynamics at multiple trophic levels

Theory and recent experiments, mostly focused on plants, indicate that biodiversity can reduce invasion success, but diversity effects on mobile animal invasion have received little attention. We tested effects of mobile crustacean grazer diversity (species richness) on the establishment of invaders at multiple trophic levels in flow-through seagrass mesocosms. On average, increasing diversity of resident grazers reduced population growth and biomass of experimentally introduced grazers. This increase in invasion resistance was concurrent with reductions in food and habitat availability and increases in resident density, paralleling previous results with plants. In many cases, mixtures of resident species resisted invasion better than did any single resident species, arguing that interactions among residents, rather than a sampling mechanism, explained diversity effects on invasion. Higher grazer diversity also generally reduced biomass of naturally recruiting invertebrates and algae and shifted epiphytic community dominance from algae to sessile invertebrates. Exploitation competition, then, appears to contribute to the diversity effect on invasion in both plant and animal systems. Our results further suggest that resident competitive advantage may also be at work in multi-trophic level systems. Thus, negative effects of local diversity on invasion appear general, and trophically mediated processes can also strongly influence invader success and identity in multi-trophic level systems.     

How does the C4 grass Eragrostis pilosa respond to elevated carbon dioxide and infection with the parasitic angiosperm Striga hermonthica?

Eragrostis pilosa (Linn.) P Beauv., a C₄ grass native to east Africa, was grown at both ambient (350 μmol mol⁻¹ and elevated (700 μmol mol⁻¹) CO₂ in either the presence or absence of the obligate, root hemi-parasite Striga hermonthica (Del.) Benth. Biomass of infected grasses was only 50% that of uninfected grasses at both CO₂ concentrations, with stems and reproductive tissues of infected plants being most severely affected. By contrast, CO₂ concentration had no effect on growth of E. pilosa , although rates of photosynthesis were enhanced by 30–40% at elevated CO₂. Infection with S. hermonthica did not affect either rates of photosynthesis or leaf areas of E. pilosa , but did bring about an increase in root:shoot ratio, leaf nitrogen and phosphorus concentration and a decline in leaf starch concentration at both ambient and elevated CO₂. Striga hermonthica had higher rates of photosynthesis and shoot concentrations of soluble sugars at elevated CO₂, but there was no difference in biomass relative to ambient grown plants. Both infection and growth at elevated CO₂ resulted in an increase in the Δ¹³C value of leaf tissue of E. pilosa , with the CO₂ effect being greater. The proportion of host-derived carbon in parasite tissue, as determined from δ¹³C values, was 27% and 39% in ambient and elevated CO₂ grown plants, respectively. In conclusion, infection with S. hermonthica limited growth of E. pilosa , and this limitation was not removed or alleviated by growing the association at elevated CO₂.     

Regulation of nitrogen fixation by nitrite and glutamine in Derxia gummosa

Abstract Nitrogenase activity of cells of Derxia gummosa (30 h growth in cultures without combined nitrogen) was not inhibited on adding nitrate. However, on adding either azaserine or methionine sulfoximine (MSX) with nitrate to these cells, nitrogenase (C₂H₂ reduction) was inhibited because nitrite accumulated in the reaction mixtures. Nitrite inhibition of the in vivo C₂H₂ reduction had a K _i value of 16 μM. Both ammonia and glutamine inhibited N₂ fixation (C₂H₂ reduction) in intact cells and in those treated with toluene. This inhibition by ammonia was relieved by methionine sulfoximine but not by glutamine. Azaserine enhanced the inhibition of nitrogenase produced by either ammonia or glutamine, since these treatments resulted in an accumulation of glutamine.     

Alkane composition diversity among populations of dwarf forms of Juniperus communis L.: comparison between western Europe and northern American populations

The cuticular wax composition of leaves has been analysed in three western European populations (Corsica, central Pyrenees, northern Alps) of Juniperus communis var. saxatilis Pall. (=  J. nana Willd., nom illeg.) and in one population of J. communis L. var. depressa Pursh. from North America (Sierra Nevada). Gas chromatography shows the presence of 13 alkanes in all samples ranging from C₂₃ to C₃₅ with important intraspecific polymorphism in alkane content. The dominant alkanes range from C₃₃ to C₃₅. Alkanes C₂₁ and C₂₂ were found only in Corsica and Sierra Nevada populations. Canonical discriminant analysis separated the J. communis L. var. depressa Pursh. of the population of Sierra Nevada from other populations of J. communis var. saxatilis Pall. on the basis of their higher C₃₁ content and the constant presence of C₂₁ and C₂₂ alkanes. J. communis var. saxatilis Pall. populations from the Pyrenees are close to northern Alps populations characterized by high concentrations of C₃₃, C₃₄ and C₃₅ alkanes. This paper confirms the existence of Juniperus var. saxatilis Pall. in the Pyrenees (France).  © The Linnean Society of London, Botanical Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002, 140 , 165–168.     

Photorespiration in C4 grasses remains slow under drought conditions

The CO₂-concentrating mechanism present in C₄ plants decreases the oxygenase activity of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) and, consequently, photorespiratory rates in air. Under drought conditions, the intercellular CO₂ concentration may decrease and cause photorespiration to increase. The C₄ grasses Paspalum dilatatum Poiret, Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. and Zoysia japonica Steudel were grown in soil and drought was imposed by ceasing to provide water. Net CO₂ assimilation ( A ) and stomatal conductance to water vapour decreased with leaf dehydration. Decreased carbon and increased oxygen isotope composition were also observed under drought. The response of A to CO₂ suggested that the compensation point was zero in all species irrespective of the extent of drought stress. A slight decrease of A as O₂ concentration increased above 10% provided evidence for slow photorespiratory gas exchanges. Analysis of amino acids contained in the leaves, particularly the decrease of glycine after 30 s in darkness, supported the presence of slow photorespiration rates, but these were slightly faster in Cynodon dactylon than in Paspalum dilatatum and Zoysia japonica . Although the contents of glycine and serine increased with dehydration and mechanistic modelling of C₄ photosynthesis suggested slightly increased photorespiration rates in proportion to photosynthesis, the results provide evidence that photorespiration remained slow under drought conditions.     

Inorganic soil nitrogen under grassland plant communities of different species composition and diversity

We measured aboveground plant biomass and soil inorganic nitrogen pools in a biodiversity experiment in northern Sweden, with plant species richness ranging from 1 to 12 species. In general, biomass increased and nitrate pools decreased with increasing species richness. Transgressive overyielding of mixed plant communities compared to the most productive of the corresponding monocultures occurred in communities with and without legumes. N₂-fixing legumes had a fertilizing function, while non-legumes had a N retaining function. Plant communities with only legumes had a positive correlation between biomass and soil nitrate content, whereas in plant communities without legumes they were negatively correlated. Both nitrate and ammonium soil pools in mixed non-legume communities were approximately equal to the lowest observed in the corresponding monocultures. In mixed legume/non-legume communities, no correlation was found for soil nitrate with either biomass or legume biomass as percentage of total biomass. The idea of complementarity among species in nitrogen acquisition was supported in both pure non-legume and mixed non-legume/legume communities. In the latter, however, facilitation through increased nitrogen availability and retention, was probably dominating. Our results suggest that diversity effects on biomass and soil N pools through resource use complementarity depend on the functional traits of species, especially N₂ fixation or high productivity.     

Uptake and utilization of n-octacosane and n-nonacosane by Arthrobacter nicotianae KCC B35

Arthrobacter nicotianae KCC B35 isolated from blue-green mats densely covering oil sediments along the Arabian Gulf coast grew well on C₁₀ to C₄₀ n -alkanes as sole sources of carbon and energy. Growth on C₂₀ to C₄₀ alkanes was even better than on C₁₀ to C₁₈ alkanes. Biomass samples incubated for 6 h with n -octacosane (C₂₈) or n -nonacosane (C₂₉) accumulated these compounds as the predominant constituent alkanes of the cell hydrocarbon fractions. The even chain hexadecane C₁₆ and the odd chain pentadecane C₁₅ were the second dominant constituent alkanes in C₂₈ and C₂₉ incubated cells, respectively. n -Hexadecane-incubated cells accumulated in their lipids higher proportions of C₁₆-fatty acids than control cells not incubated with hydrocarbons. On the other hand, C₂₈ and C₂₉-incubated cells did not contain any fatty acids with the equivalent chain lengths, but the fatty acid patterns of the cell lipids suggest that there should have been mid-chain oxidation of these very long chain alkanes. This activity qualifies A. nicotianae KCC B35 to be used in cocktails for bioremediating environments polluted with heavy oil sediments.     

Effect of plant species richness on invasibility of experimental plant communities

Invasion of unsown species to artificially created assemblages of grassland species was investigated in a 3-year field experiment. In the experiment, assemblages varying in species richness (1, 2, 4, 8, and 16 species) and functional group richness (1–4, grasses, legumes, rosette forbs, and creeping forbs) were grown in control and fertilized plots, without any attempt to prevent the invasion of unsown species or to weed them. The relationship between species and functional group diversity and above-ground biomass was positive for sown species in all study years (2003, 2004 and 2005). In the latter 2 years, weed invader biomass decreased significantly with increasing biomass of sown species and their functional group richness, but not with number of species. However, no suppressive effect of species or functional group richness beyond that by increased biomass of residents was found. In fact, slight but significant positive partial effect of species richness was found, suggesting that the negative effect of the same amount of resident biomass on invaders is stronger when the biomass is composed of fewer species. The negative relationship between the number of functional groups of residents and invader biomass suggested that better coverage of functional trait space could be a mechanism promoting the resistance to invasion. In Addition, species composition of invaders were significantly related to initial composition of sown residents.     

Effect of H2 evolution on 15N2 fixation, C2H2 reduction and relative efficiency of leguminous symbionts

The (C₂H₄+ H_2(C2H₂))/¹⁵N₂ ratios of 15 clover- Rhizobium symbionts. soybean, and black medick symbionts were measured. Relative efficiency based on the C2H4 production and on ¹⁵N₂ incorporation were compared, and in most symbionts there was little difference between the two measures of relative efficiency. Total measurable electron flux through nitrogenase during acetylene reduction and ¹⁵N₂ incorporation were nearly equal for most symbionts studied. The relative efficiency and the (C₂H₄+ H_2(C2H₂))/¹⁵N₂ ratio showed an inverse correlation. Use of this ratio appears preferable to use of the ratio of C2H2 reduction/N₂ reduction. Some evolution of H₂ was observed in the presence of C₂H₂.     

Induction of acetoacetate decarboxylase in Clostridium acetobutylicum

Abstract Factors that may initiate the biosynthesis of acetoacetate decarboxylase were investigated in resting cells of Clostridium acetobutylicum . Linear acids from C₁ to C₄ were inducers, whereas branched acids and linear acids from C₅ to C₇ were not inducers of acetoacetate decarboxylase biosynthesis. Induction of acetoacetate decarboxylase was maximal at pH 4.8 in the presence of acid concentrations comparable with those found during fermentation. In growth conditions repression of acetoacetate decarboxylase biosynthesis was found. This fact explains that acetone production by Clostridium acetobutylicum occurs when growth slows down.