Evolutionarily stable stalk to spore ratio in cellular slime molds and the law of equalization in net incomes

The evolutionarily stable stalk ratio (ESSR) in the cellular slime molds is studied when the fruiting body is formed by multiple clones of various size. The survival probability of a spore cell is assumed to depend on the stalk ratio and the fruiting body size. ESSR is obtained as the non-co-operative equilibrium (Nash solution) that maximizes the fitness of each clone. The following two predictions are obtained: (1) the number of spore cells produced by each clone forming a fruiting body tends to be equalized, even if a variation in clone size exists. As a result, the larger clones do not necessarily enjoy higher fitness than the smaller ones. (2) The stalk ratio and the overall fitness of the fruiting body decrease as the genetic diversity in the fruiting body increases. A condition for the stalk to spore ratio to be invariant of overall fruiting body size is also investigated. Finally, "the law of equalization in net incomes" is proposed, extending result (1) into the broader range of resource allocation problems.     

Altruism, cheating, and anticheater adaptations in cellular slime molds

Cellular slime molds (CSMs) possess a remarkable life cycle that encompasses an extreme act of altruism. CSM cells live as individual amoebae until starved, then aggregate and ultimately transform themselves into a multicellular fruiting body. This fruiting body consists of stalk cells (altruists that eventually die) and spores (the beneficiaries of this sacrifice). Altruistic systems such as this are vulnerable to cheaters, which are individuals unrelated to the altruists that obtain the benefits provided by them without reciprocating. Here, we investigate two forces that can maintain CSM altruism despite cheating: kin selection and anticheater adaptations. First, we present new kinship-based models based on CSM developmental biology to evaluate the efficacy of kin selection. These models show that stalk-making genotypes can still be maintained when aggregations are initiated by multiple "founder" spores, provided that spores of stalkless fruiting bodies have low rates of dispersal and dispersal success is a concave function of stalk height. Second, we review proposals that several features of CSM development, such as the chemical suppression of the redifferentiation of prestalk cells into prespores, act as anticheater adaptations.     

Species recognition in social amoebae

Aggregative multicellularity requires the ability of cells to recognise conspecifics. Social amoebae are among the best studied of such organisms, but the mechanism and evolutionary background of species recognition remained to be investigated. Here we show that heterologous expression of a single Dictyostelium purpureum gene is sufficient for D. discoideum cells to efficiently make chimaeric fruiting bodies with D. purpureum cells. This gene forms a bidirectional pair with another gene on the D. purpureum genome, and they are both highly polymorphic among independent wild isolates of the same mating group that do not form chimaeric fruiting bodies with each other. These paired genes are both structurally similar to D. discoideum tgrB1/C1 pair, which is responsible for clonal discrimination within that species, suggesting that these tgr genes constitute the species recognition system that has attained a level of precision capable of discriminating between clones within a species. Analysis of the available genome sequences of social amoebae revealed that such gene pairs exist only within the clade composed of species that produce precursors of sterile stalk cells (prestalk cells), suggesting concurrent evolution of a precise allorecognition system and a new ‘worker’ cell-type dedicated to transporting and supporting the reproductive cells.     

How social evolution theory impacts our understanding of development in the social amoeba Dictyostelium

Dictyostelium discoideum has been very useful for elucidating principles of development over the last 50 years, but a key attribute means there is a lot to be learned from a very different intellectual tradition: social evolution. Because Dictyostelium arrives at multicellularity by aggregation instead of through a single-cell bottleneck, the multicellular body could be made up of genetically distinct cells. If they are genetically distinct, natural selection will result in conflict over which cells become fertile spores and which become dead stalk cells. Evidence for this conflict includes unequal representation of two genetically different clones in spores of a chimera, the poison-like differentiation inducing factor (DIF) system that appears to involve some cells forcing others to become stalk, and reduced functionality in migrating chimeras. Understanding how selection operates on chimeras of genetically distinct clones is crucial for a comprehensive view of Dictyostelium multicellularity. In nature, Dictyostelium fruiting bodies are often clonal, or nearly so, meaning development will often be very cooperative. Relatedness levels tell us what benefits must be present for sociality to evolve. Therefore it is important to measure relatedness in nature, show that it has an impact on cooperation in the laboratory, and investigate genes that Dictyostelium uses to discriminate between relatives and non-relatives. Clearly, there is a promising future for research at the interface of development and social evolution in this fascinating group.     

Loss of the beta-catenin homologue aardvark causes ectopic stalk formation in Dictyostelium

Aardvark (Aar) is a Dictyostelium beta-catenin homologue with both cytoskeletal and signal transduction roles during development. Here, we show that loss of aar causes a novel phenotype where multiple stalks appear during late development. Ectopic stalks are preceded by misexpression of the stalk marker ST-lacZ in the surrounding tissue. This process does not involve the kinase GSK-3. Mixing experiments show that ectopic ST-lacZ expression and stalk formation are cell non-autonomous. The protein-cellulose matrix surrounding the stalk of aar mutant fruiting bodies is defective, and damage to the stalk of wild-type fruiting bodies leads to ectopic ST-lacZ expression. We postulate that poor synthesis of the stalk tube matrix allows diffusion of a stalk cell-inducing factor into the surrounding tissue.     

Ultrastructural and lectin binding changes during the formation of the animal dimple in oocytes of Discoglossus pictus (Anura)

The numbers of spores, stalk cells, and basal disk cells in fruiting bodies of Dictyostelium discoideum were estimated by direct cell counting. It was found that the ratios of differentiated cells varied with the number of cells in the fruiting body. Hence, this invalidates, in D. discoideum at least, an assumption used in many theories of differentiation that proportions do not vary with size. Simple statistical analysis showed that a semilogarithmic equation could describe the relationship of spore to stalk cell number and spore to basal disk cell number, whereas a double-logarithmic equation described the basal disk and stalk cell number relationship. Studies under different environmental conditions and with different strains suggest that the basic equations describing the relationships are conserved. However, quantitative differences in the proportioning of the cell types have been observed. Previous papers concerning the proportions of D. discoideum are reviewed, and the implications of the results, in regard to theories of differentiation, are analyzed.     

High relatedness in a social amoeba: the role of kin-discriminatory segregation

A major challenge for social theory is to explain the importance of kin discrimination for the evolution of altruism. One way to assess the importance of kin discrimination is to test its effects on increasing relatedness within groups. The social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum aggregates to form a fruiting body composed of dead stalk and live spores. Previous studies of a natural population showed that where D. discoideum occurs in the soil, multiple clones are often found in the same small soil samples. However, actual fruiting bodies usually contain only one clone. We here performed experiments to gauge the effect of kin-discriminatory segregation on increasing relatedness. We mixed co-occurring clones from this population using a relatedness level found in small soil samples. We found a lower proportion of uniclonal fruiting bodies and a lower level of relatedness compared with natural fruiting bodies. We found that the amount of relatedness increase attributable to kin-discriminatory segregation was small. These findings suggest a relatively minor influence of kin-discriminatory segregation on relatedness in D. discoideum. We discuss our results comparing with the results of previous studies, including those of wild clones and laboratory mutants. We ask why wild clones of D. discoideum exhibit a low degree of kin-discriminatory segregation, and what alternative factors might account for high relatedness in D. discoideum.     

Quantification of Social Behavior in D. discoideum Reveals Complex Fixed and Facultative Strategies

Understanding the maintenance of cooperation requires an understanding of the nature of cheaters and the strategies used to mitigate their effects. However, it is often difficult to determine how cheating or differential social success has arisen. For example, cheaters may employ different strategies (e.g., fixed and facultative), whereas other causes of unequal fitness in social situations can result in winners and losers without cheating. To address these problems, we quantified the social success of naturally occurring genotypes of Dictyostelium discoideum during the formation of chimeric fruiting bodies, consisting of dead stalk cells and viable spores. We demonstrate that an apparent competitive dominance hierarchy of spore formation in chimera is partly due to a fixed strategy where genotypes exhibit dramatically different spore allocations. However, we also find complex, variable facultative strategies, where genotypes change their allocation in chimera. By determining the magnitude and direction of these changes, we partition facultative cheating into two forms: (1) promotion of individual fitness through selfish behaviour (“self-promotion”) and (2) coercion of other genotypes to act cooperatively. Our results demonstrate and define social interactions between D. discoideum isolates, thus providing a conceptual framework for the study of the genetic mechanisms that underpin social evolution.     

Co-occurrence in nature of different clones of the social amoeba,Dictyostelium discoideum

The social amoeba, Dictyostelium discoideum, produces a multicellular fruiting body and has become a model system for cell-cell interactions such as signalling, adhesion and development. However, unlike most multicellular organisms, it forms by aggregation of cells and, in the laboratory, forms genetic chimeras where there may be competition among clones. Here we show that chimera formation is also likely in nature, because different clones commonly co-occur on a very small scale. This suggests that D. discoideum will likely have evolved strategies for competing in chimeras, and that the function of some developmental genes will be competitive. Natural chimerism also makes D. discoideum a good model organism for the investigation of issues relating to coexistence and conflict between cells.     

Induction of fruiting bodies in a macrocyst-forming mutant of the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium mucomides

Some wild-type strains of Dictyostelium mucoroides exhibit dimorphism in development depending on culture conditions: on agar, fruiting bodies containing stalk and spore cells are formed, whereas under water, a thick-walled structure lacking spore and stalk cells (the macro-cyst) is formed. The mutant, MF-1, was derived from one of these wild-type strains. It forms macrocysts on an agar surfxe as well as under water. It was found that MF-1 could be induced to form fruiting bodies in two ways. First, when an aggregation center from the wild-type strain was grafted to an MF-1 aggregation center. MF-1 cells migrated to the center and formed a large aggregate that gave rise to many slugs that became fruiting bodies. This result, along with the observation that MF-1 aggregates have no tip, suggests that MF-1 normally produces an aggregation center that is unable to organize the aggregate to form a slug. Second, when MF-1 cells were allowed to develop on 1.2 mM ethionine (an analog of methionine), they formed aggregates with tips and developed into fruiting bodies with thick stalks instead of macrocysts. The effect of ethionine was blocked by the presence of 2.4 mM methio-nine. Two other methionine analogs were also tested, i.e., α-methylmethionine and norleucine. When cultured on the former at concentrations ranging from 1.2 to 9.6 mM, MF-1 cells still produced macrocysts; when cultured on norleucine at concentrations ranging from 2.4 to 9.6 mM, MF-1 cells aggregated into large clumps that formed numerous slugs, but these failed to continue development to fruiting bodies. In vertebrates, it is known that a major biochemical effect of ethionine is the inhibition of the methylation of nucleic acids, proteins, and phospholipids. Norleucine and a-methylmethionine inhibit methylation to a lesser extent. Thus, it can be speculated that the biological effects of ethionine on MF-1 cells may result from its interference with methylation reactions, suggesting that macrocyst formation may involve excess methylation as compared with the situation during fruiting-body development.     

A linear dominance hierarchy among clones in chimeras of the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum

Amoebae from different clones of Dictyostelium discoideum aggregate into a common slug, which migrates towards light for dispersal, then forms a fruiting body consisting of a somatic, dead stalk, holding up a head of living spores. Contributions of two clones in a chimera to spore and stalk are often unequal, with one clone taking advantage of the other's stalk contribution. To determine whether there was a hierarchy of exploitation among clones, we competed all possible pairs among seven clones and measured their relative representation in the prespore and prestalk stages and in the final spore stage. We found a clear linear hierarchy at the final spore stage, but not at earlier stages. These results suggest that there is either a single principal mechanism or additive effects for differential contribution to the spore, and that it involves more than spore/stalk competition.     

PHYLOGENY, REPRODUCTIVE ISOLATION AND KIN RECOGNITION IN THE SOCIAL AMOEBA DICTYOSTELIUM PURPUREUM

Little is known about the population structure of social microorganisms, yet such studies are particularly interesting for the ways that genetic variation impacts their social evolution. Dictyostelium , a eukaryotic microbe widely used as a developmental model, has a social fruiting stage in which some formerly independent individuals die to help others. To assess genetic variation within the social amoeba Dictyostelium purpureum , we sequenced ∼4000 base pairs of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) from 37 isolates collected in Texas, Virginia, and Japan. Our analysis showed extensive genetic variation between populations and clear evidence of phylogenetic structure. We identified three major phylogenetic groups that were more different than other accepted species pairs. Tests using pairs of clones showed that both sexual macrocyst and asexual fruiting body formation were influenced by genetic divergence. Macrocysts were less likely to form between pairs of clones from different groups than from the same group. There was also a correlation between the genetic divergence of a pair of clones and their degree of mixing within fruiting bodies. These observations suggest that cryptic species might occur within D. purpureum and, more importantly, reveal how genetic variation impacts social interactions.     

Taking the plunge. Terminal differentiation in Dictyostelium

During the last stage of Dictyostelium development a motile, cylindrical slug transforms into an immotile, stalked fruiting body and the constituent cells change from amoebae to either refractile spores or vacuolated stalk cells. Analysis of this process using genetics and simple culture techniques is becoming a powerful way of investigating a number of conserved signal transduction processes. A common pathway activating cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) triggers the maturation of spore cells and those stalk cells forming the stalk. It uses a eukaryotic version of the 'bacterial' two-component phospho-relay system to control cAMP breakdown. A second pathway, inhibiting the GSK3 protein kinase, might control the maturation of a distinct set of stalk cells at the base of the fruiting body.     

Copine A is expressed in prestalk cells and regulates slug phototaxis and thermotaxis in developing Dictyostelium

Copines are calcium-dependent membrane-binding proteins found in many eukaryotic organisms. We are studying the function of copines using the model organism, Dictyostelium discoideum. When under starvation conditions, Dictyostelium cells aggregate into mounds that become migrating slugs, which can move toward light and heat before culminating into a fruiting body. Previously, we showed that Dictyostelium cells lacking the copine A (cpnA) gene are not able to form fruiting bodies and instead arrest at the slug stage. In this study, we compared the slug behavior of cells lacking the cpnA gene to the slug behavior of wild-type cells. The slugs formed by cpnA- cells were much larger than wild-type slugs and exhibited no phototaxis and negative thermotaxis in the same conditions that wild-type slugs exhibited positive phototaxis and thermotaxis. Mixing as little as 5% wild-type cells with cpnA- cells rescued the phototaxis and thermotaxis defects, suggesting that CpnA plays a specific role in the regulation of the production and/or release of a signaling molecule. Reducing extracellular levels of ammonia also partially rescued the phototaxis and thermotaxis defects of cpnA- slugs, suggesting that CpnA may have a specific role in regulating ammonia signaling. Expressing the lacZ gene under the cpnA promoter in wild-type cells indicated cpnA is preferentially expressed in the prestalk cells found in the anterior part of the slug, which include the cells at the tip of the slug that regulate phototaxis, thermotaxis, and the initiation of culmination into fruiting bodies. Our results suggest that CpnA plays a role in the regulation of the signaling pathways, including ammonia signaling, necessary for sensing and/or orienting toward light and heat in the prestalk cells of the Dictyostelium slug.     

Stalk size and altruism investment within and among populations of the social amoeba

Reproductive division of labour is common in many societies, including those of eusocial insects, cooperatively breeding vertebrates, and most forms of multicellularity. However, conflict over what is best for the individual vs. the group can prevent an optimal division of labour from being achieved. In the social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum, cells aggregate to become multicellular and a fraction behaves altruistically, forming a dead stalk that supports the rest. Theory suggests that intra‐organismal conflict over spore–stalk cell fate can drive rapid evolutionary change in allocation traits, leading to polymorphisms within populations or rapid divergence between them. Here, we assess several proxies for stalk size and spore–stalk allocation as metrics of altruism investment among strains and across geographic regions. We observe geographic divergence in stalk height that can be partly explained by differences in multicellular size, as well as variation among strains in clonal spore–stalk allocation, suggesting within‐population variation in altruism investment. Analyses of chimeras comprised of strains from the same vs. different populations indicated genotype‐by‐genotype epistasis, where the morphology of the chimeras deviated significantly from the average morphology of the strains developed clonally. The significantly negative epistasis observed for allopatric pairings suggests that populations are diverging in their spore–stalk allocation behaviours, generating incompatibilities when they encounter one another. Our results demonstrate divergence in microbial social traits across geographically separated populations and demonstrate how quantification of genotype‐by‐genotype interactions can elucidate the trajectory of social trait evolution in nature.     

Involvement of the glucose-regulated protein 94 (Dd-GRP94) in starvation response of Dictyostelium discoideum cells

Upon deprivation of nutrients, Dictyostelium discoideum Ax-2 cells arrest proliferation and initiate a metamorphosed developmental program including induction of altered gene expressions which are necessary for differentiation. In Ax-2 cells, we found out a member of Hsp90 family usually contained in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Dd-GRP94 (Dictyostelium discoideum glucose-regulated protein 94). In general, GRP94 are induced either by glucose-depletion or by depletion of Ca(2+) in intracellular Ca(2+) stores. Unexpectedly, however, the expression of Dd-grp94 was greatly reduced within 60 min of starvation. Dd-grp94-overexpressing cells (GRP94(OE) cells) collected without forming distinct aggregation streams, and never formed normal fruiting bodies. Also, prespore differentiation as well as maturation into spores and stalk cells were particularly impaired in the GRP94(OE) cells. Thus Dd-GRP94 seems to be crucial in late differentiation as well as in starvation response.     

Monoclonal antibodies specific for stalk differentiation in Dictyostelium discoideum

We have produced two monoclonal antibodies specific to the stalk cells of Dictyostelium discoideum fruiting bodies. Both monoclonal antibodies react with high molecular weight proteins previously found to be stalk-specific by two-dimensional gel analysis. One antibody (JAb 1) is specific for a single protein of apparent molecular weight 310 000 which first appears when overt stalk differentiation begins at 20 h. The other monoclonal antibody (JAb 2) is also stalk-specific, though earlier in development it binds to proteins extracted from both prestalk and prespore cells of the migrating slug. It reacts with two proteins in stalks, one of apparent molecular weight 430 000 which is first detected during tip formation at 12 h and a lower molecular weight protein (310 000) detected from 20 h. Although several markers are available for the investigation of prespore/spore differentiation there is a distinct lack of suitable prestalk/stalk markers. The monoclonal antibodies described here are highly specific stalk markers and should prove useful in the study of cell proportioning and terminal differentiation.     

Developmental commitment in Dictyostelium discoideum

Upon starvation, Dictyostelium discoideum cells halt cell proliferation, aggregate into multicellular organisms, form migrating slugs, and undergo morphogenesis into fruiting bodies while differentiating into dormant spores and dead stalk cells. At almost any developmental stage cells can be forced to dedifferentiate when they are dispersed and diluted into nutrient broth. However, migrating slugs can traverse lawns of bacteria for days without dedifferentiating, ignoring abundant nutrients and continuing development. We now show that developing Dictyostelium cells revert to the growth phase only when bacteria are supplied during the first 4 to 6 h of development but that after this time, cells continue to develop regardless of the presence of food. We postulate that the cells' inability to revert to the growth phase after 6 h represents a commitment to development. We show that the onset of commitment correlates with the cells' loss of phagocytic function. By examining mutant strains, we also show that commitment requires extracellular cyclic AMP (cAMP) signaling. Moreover, cAMP pulses are sufficient to induce both commitment and the loss of phagocytosis in starving cells, whereas starvation alone is insufficient. Finally, we show that the inhibition of development by food prior to commitment is independent of contact between the cells and the bacteria and that small soluble molecules, probably amino acids, inhibit development during the first few hours and subsequently the cells become unable to react to the molecules and commit to development. We propose that commitment serves as a checkpoint that ensures the completion of cooperative aggregation of developing Dictyostelium cells once it has begun, dampening the response to nutritional cues that might inappropriately block development.