Determinative properties of muscle lineages in ascidian embryos

Blastomeres removed from early cleavage stage ascidian embryos and reared to 'maturity' as partial embryos often elaborate tissue-specific features typical of their constituent cell lineages. We used this property to study recent corrections of the ascidian larval muscle lineage and to compare the ways in which different lineages give rise to muscle. Our evaluation of muscle differentiation was based on histochemical localization and quantitative radiometric measurement of a muscle-specific acetylcholinesterase activity, and the development of myofilaments and myofibrils as observed by electron microscopy. Although the posterior-vegetal blastomeres (B4.1 pair) of the 8-cell embryo have long been believed to be the sole precursors of larval muscle, recent studies using horseradish peroxidase to mark cell lineages have shown that small numbers of muscle cells originate from the anterior-vegetal (A4.1) and posterior-animal (b4.2) blastomeres of this stage. Fully differentiated muscle expression in isolated partial embryos of A4.1-derived cells requires an association with cells from other lineages whereas muscle from B4.1 blastomeres develops autonomously. Clear differences also occurred in the time acetylcholinesterase activity was first detected in partial embryos from these two sources. Isolated b4.2 cells failed to show any muscle development even in combination with anterior-animal cells (a4.2) and are presumably even more dependent on normal cell interactions and associations. Others have noted an additional distinction between the different sources of muscle: muscle cells from non-B4.1 lineages occur exclusively in the distal part of the tail, while the B4.1 descendants contribute those cells in the proximal and middle regions. During the course of ascidian larval evolution tail muscle probably had two origins: the primary lineage (B4.1) whose fate was set rigidly at early cleavage stages and secondarily evolved lineages which arose later by recruitment of cells from other tissues resulting in increased tail length. In contrast to the B4.1 lineage, muscle development in the secondary lineages is controlled less rigidly by processes that depend on cell interactions.     

Developmental autonomy of muscle fine structure in muscle lineage cells of ascidian embryos

We have observed ultrastructural features of muscle differentiation in the muscle lineage cells of cleavage-arrested whole embryos and partial embryos of ascidians. Whole embryos of Ciona intestinalis and Ascidia ceratodes were cleavage-arrested with cytochalasin B at the 8-cell stage and reared to an age equivalent to several hours after hatching; these embryos formed extensive myofilaments which were often further organized into myofibrils of different sizes and densities in the peripheral cytoplasm of the two muscle lineage blastomeres (B4.1 pair). Developing myofibrils in cleavage-arrested embryos resembled the muscle elements observed in normal hatched larvae, but were less uniformly organized. A similar development of myofilaments and myofibrils occurred in the muscle lineage cells of multicellular partial embryos reared to "hatching" age. These partial embryos resulted from the isolated muscle lineage pair (B4.1) of blastomeres of the 8-cell stage (Ciona and Ascidia), and from a muscle lineage blastomere pair (B5.2) isolated at the 16-cell stage (Ascidia). Muscle lineage cells in the partial embryos were readily identified by the dense aggregates of mitochondria in their cytoplasm. Taken together, these results from the two kinds of partial embryo effectively eliminate inductive interactions with embryonic tissues other than mesodermal as a necessary factor in the onset of self-differentiation in muscle lineage cells. The relative complexity of muscle phenotype expressed in cleavage-arrested and partial embryos attests to an unusually strong developmental autonomy in the ascidian muscle lineages. This autonomy lends further support to the theory that a localized and segregated egg cytoplasmic determinant is responsible for larval muscle development in ascidian embryos.     

Expression of epidermis-specific antigens during embryogenesis of the ascidian, Halocynthia roretzi

We have produced two monoclonal antibodies (Epi-1 and Epi-2) which specifically recognize epidermal cells and their derivative, the larval tunic, of developing embryos of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi. The antigens, examined by indirect immunofluorescence staining, first appear at the early tailbud stage and are present until at least the swimming larval stage. There were distinct and separate puromycin and actinomycin D sensitivity periods for each antigen. Aphidicolin, a specific inhibitor of DNA synthesis, prevented the appearance of each antigen when embryos were exposed to the drug continuously from cleavage stages. These results suggest that the antigens are synthesized during embryogenesis by developing epidermal cells and that several rounds of DNA replication are required for the antigen expression. Early cleavage stage embryos, including fertilized but unsegmented eggs, in which cytokinesis had been blocked with cytochalasin B expressed the antigens, and blastomeres exhibiting the antigens were always of the epidermis lineage. In partial embryos produced by four separated blastomere pairs of the 8-cell embryos, the expression of antigens was seen only in those developed from the animal blastomere pairs, which are progenitors of epidermal cells. These observations indicate that differentiation of epidermal cells in ascidian embryos takes place in a typical "mosaic" fashion.     

An evolutionary change in the muscle lineage of an anural ascidian embryo is restored by interspecific hybridization with a urodele ascidian

Anural ascidians do not develop into a conventional tailed larva with differentiated muscle cells, however, embryos of some anural ascidian species retain the ability to express acetylcholinesterase (AChE) in a vestigial muscle cell lineage. This study examines the number of AChE-positive cells that develop in the anural ascidian Molgula occulta relative to that in the closely related urodele (tailed) species, Molgula oculata. Histochemical assays showed that M. oculata embryos develop 36 to 38 AChE-positive cells, consistent with the number of tail muscle cells expressed in other urodele ascidians. In contrast, M. occulta embryos develop a mean of only 20 AChE-positive cells in their vestigial muscle lineage. Cleavage-arrested embryos of the anural species express AChE only in B-line blastomeres, showing that the vestigial muscle lineage cells are derived from the primary muscle lineage. Less than the expected number of AChE-positive B-line cells develop in cleavage-arrested anural embryos, however, implying that the allocation of primary muscle lineage cells is decreased. Eggs of the anural species can be fertilized with sperm of the urodele species resulting in the development of some larvae that contain a short tail and/or a brain melanocyte, specific features of urodele larvae. The typical urodele number of AChE-positive cells is restored in some of these hybrid embryos. Both primary and secondary muscle lineages are restored because cleavage-arrested hybrid embryos develop more AChE-positive cells in the B-line blastomeres and supernumerary AChE-positive cells in the A-line blastomeres. Hybrid embryos that develop the urodele complement of AChE-positive cells also form a tail and/or a brain melanocyte showing that restoration of muscle lineage cells is coupled to the development of other urodele features. AChE expression occurred in anural embryos with disorganized or dissociated blastomeres, indicating that AChE expression is determined autonomously. It is concluded that an evolutionary change in the allocation of larval muscle lineage cells occurs during development of the anural ascidian M. occulta which can be restored by interspecific hybridization with the urodele ascidian M. oculata.     

Developmental autonomy of presumptive notochord cells in partial embryos of an ascidian

Summary

Ultrastructural features of larval notochord cell differentiation, sheath (membrane leaflets and filaments) and vacuoles of intracellular colloid, were found in some cells of certain partial embryos of the ascidian, Ciona intestinalis. As expected from established lineage fate maps, mature quarter-embryos developing from microsurgically isolated anterior-vegetal blastomeres (A4.1 pair) at the 8-cell stage had some cells with the notochord features. Such cells, however, also occurred in quarter-embryos resulting from the posterior-vegetal blastomere pair (B4.1) and in partial embryos derived from the B5.1 cell pair isolated at the next cleavage of the B4.1 blastomeres. These findings confirm a prediction of additional notochord cell fates from a recent revision of the ascidian lineage map based on cell marking with microinjected horseradish peroxidase. Partial embryos obtained from other lineages of the 8- and 16-cell stages did not develop notochord cells.     

Lineage segregation and developmental autonomy in expression of functional muscle acetylcholinesterase mRNA in the ascidian embryo

Acetylcholinesterase is a histospecific marker of cell differentiation occurring only in the muscle and mesenchyme tissues of the ascidian embryo. The distribution of functional mRNA coding for this enzyme has been investigated and it is shown here that only cells of muscle and mesenchyme lineages possess such a template. Blastomeres of four cell lineage quadrants were separated microsurgically from eight-cell-stage embryos of Ciona intestinalis and raised in isolation until muscle development was well advanced. Measurement of enzyme activity in the resulting partial embryos revealed that acetylcholinesterase was limited to descendants of one blastomere pair, the B4.1 blastomeres containing muscle and mesenchyme lineages. To study the tissue distribution of acetylcholinesterase mRNA, RNA from partial embryos was translated in Xenopus laevis oocytes. When oocytes were injected with an appropriate template, they synthesized a biologically active acetylcholinesterase that could be selectively immunopurified with an antiserum to the ascidian enzyme. Under the conditions used the quantity of acetylcholinesterase mRNA was directly related to the enzyme activity in immunoprecipitates. Acetylcholinesterase mRNA was found only in B4.1 lineage partial embryos where it occurred in approximately the same amount as in whole embryos of the same age. Since there is a limited period from gastrulation until the middle tail-formation stage when functional acetylcholinesterase mRNA accumulates, the results of our mRNA distribution experiments strongly suggest that the gene for ascidian acetylcholinesterase is active only in muscle and mesenchyme tissues. The histospecific occurrence of this enzyme apparently does not involve selective, cell-specific control of translation.     

Cell lineage analysis in ascidian embryos by intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme: I. Up to the eight-cell stage

Cell lineages during development of ascidian embryos were analyzed by injection of horseradish peroxidase as a tracer enzyme into identified cells at the one-, two-, four-, and eight-cell stages of the ascidians, Halocynthia roretzi, Ciona intestinalis, and Ascidia ahodori. Identical results were obtained with eggs of the three different species examined. The first cleavage furrow coincided with the bilateral symmetry plane of the embryo. The second furrow did not always divide the embryo into anterior and posterior halves as each of the anterior and posterior cell pairs gave rise to different tissues according to their destinies, which became more definitive in the cell pairs at the eight-cell stage. Of the blastomeres constituting the eight-cell stage embryo, the a4.2 pair (the anterior animal blastomeres) differentiated into epidermis, brain, and presumably sense organ and palps. Every descendant cell of the b4.2 pair (the posterior animal blastomeres) has been thought to become epidermis; however, the horseradish peroxidase injection probe revealed that the b4.2 pair gave rise to not only epidermis but also muscle cells at the caudal tip region of the developing tailbud-stage embryos. The A4.1 pair (the anterior vegetal blastomeres) developed into endoderm, notochord, brain stem, spinal cord, and also muscle cells next the caudal tip muscle cells. From the B4.1 pair (the posterior vegetal blastomeres) originated muscle cells of the anterior and middle parts of the tail, mesenchyme, endoderm, endodermal strand, and also notochord at the caudal tip region. These results clearly demonstrate that muscle cells are derived not only from the B4.1 pair, as has hitherto been believed, but also from both the b4.2 and A4.1 pairs.     

Cell lineage analysis in ascidian embryos by intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme : II. The 16- and 32-cell stages

Cell lineages during development of ascidian embryos were analyzed by injecting horseradish peroxidase as a tracer enzyme into identified cells of the 16-cell and 32-cell stage embryos of Halocynthia roretzi. Most of the blastomeres of these embryos developed more kinds of tissues than have hitherto been reported, and therefore, the developmental fates of each blastomere are more complex. It has been thought that every blastomere of the 64-cell stage ascidian embryo gives rise to only one kind of tissues, but the finding that the several blastomeres at the 32-cell stage developed into at least three different kinds of tissues, clearly indicates that the stage at which the fates of every blastomere are determined to one tissue is later than the 64-cell stage. The results also clearly demonstrate that muscle cells are derived not only from B-line cells (B5.1, B5.2, B6.3, and B6.4) but also from A-line cells (A5.2 and A6.4) and b-line cells (b5.3 and b6.5). Based on the present analysis as well as other studies, complete cell lineages of muscle cells up to their terminal differentiation have been proposed. In addition, lineages of nervous system, notochord, and epidermis are also discussed.     

Determinative mechanisms in secondary muscle lineages of ascidian embryos: development of muscle-specific features in isolated muscle progenitor cells

Muscle cells of the ascidian larva originate from three different lines of progenitor cells, the B-line, A-line and b-line. Experiments with 8-cell embryos have indicated that isolated blastomeres of the B-line (primary) muscle lineage show autonomous development of a muscle-specific enzyme, whereas blastomeres of the A-line and b-line (secondary) muscle lineage rarely develop the enzyme in isolation. In order to study the mechanisms by which different lines of progenitors are determined to give rise to muscle, blastomeres were isolated from embryos of Halocynthia roretzi at the later cleavage stages when conspicuous restriction of the developmental fate of blastomeres had already occurred. Partial embryos derived from B-line muscle-lineage cells of the 64-cell embryo (B7.4, B7.5 and B7.8) showed autonomous expression of specific features of muscle cells (acetylcholinesterase, filamentous actin and muscle-specific antigen). In contrast, b-line muscle-lineage cells, even those isolated from the 110-cell embryo (b8.17 and b8.19), did not express any muscle-specific features, even though their developmental fate was mainly restricted to generation of muscle. Isolated A-line cells from the 64-cell embryos (A7.8) did not show any features of muscle differentiation, whereas some isolated A-line cells from the 110-cell embryos (A8.16) developed all three above-mentioned features of muscle cells. This transition was shown to occur during the eighth cell cycle. These results suggest that the mechanism involved in the process of determination of the secondary-lineage muscle cells differs from that of the primary-lineage muscle cells. Interaction with cells of other lineages may be required for the determination of secondary precursors to muscle cells. The presumptive b-line and A-line muscle cells that failed to express muscle-specific features in isolation did not develop into epidermal cells. Thus, although interactions between cells may be required for muscle determination in secondary lineages, the process may represent a permissive type of induction and may differ from the processes of induction of mesoderm in amphibian embryos.     

Cell lineage analysis in ascidian embryos by intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme. III. Up to the tissue restricted stage

Cell lineages during embryogenesis of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi were analyzed up until the stage where each blastomere was fated to be only a single tissue type (i.e., the tissue restricted stage) by intracellular injection of horseradish peroxidase using the iontophoretic injection method. Initially, the developmental fates of all blastomeres of the 64-cell stage embryo were examined, and thereafter, only the fates of daughter blastomeres of those blastomeres that were not tissue restricted at the 64-cell stage were traced. The developmental fates of blastomeres were highly invariant except for two candidates for "equivalence groups" (J. Kimble, J. Sulston, and J. White (1979). In "Cell Lineage, Stem Cells and Cell Determination," pp. 59-68. Elsevier, Amsterdam/New York), in which cellular interaction is suggested to be involved in the specification of the fates. The right and left a8.25 cells gave rise to the otolith and ocellus, and the right and left b8.17 cells gave rise to the spinal cord and endodermal strand in a complementary manner. No fixed relationship existed between the position of the blastomere and its derivative. Most restrictions of cell fates occurred early in cleavage. The numbers of blastomeres which generated a single type of tissue were 44 at the 64-cell stage and 94 at the 110-cell stage. Eight pairs of blastomeres had not yet become tissue restricted by the 110-cell stage. Almost complete lineages of epidermis, nervous system, muscle, mesenchyme, notochord, and endodermal tissues were described, and a fate map was constructed for the blastula. For certain tissues, the primordial cells occupied two different regions. Supplementary investigations of the lineage of muscle cells were also performed on embryos of another species, Ciona intestinalis.     

Autonomous muscle cell differentiation in partial ascidian embryos according to the newly verified cell lineages

Recent analysis of cell lineages in ascidian embryos by the intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme has clearly demonstrated that muscle cells are derived not only from the B4.1-cell pair of the eight-cell stage embryo, as has hitherto been believed, but also from both the b4.2- and A4.1-cell pairs (H. Nishida and N. Satoh, 1983, Dev. Biol.99, 382–394). In order to reexamine the developmental autonomy in muscle lineage cells, the B4.1 pair was isolated from the eight-cell stage embryo. The progeny cells of the B4.1 pair, as well as those of the six other blastomeres, were then allowed to develop in isolation into partial embryos. Autonomous muscle cell differentiation not only in partial embryos originating from the B4.1 cells but also in those from the six other blastomeres was substantiated by (a) occurrence of localized histospecific muscle acetylcholinesterase and (b) development of myofibrils. These results support the validity of the recent cell lineage study and confirmed the self-differentiation potency of muscle lineage cells in ascidian embryos according to the newly verified cell lineages.     

Mass Isolation of Muscle Lineage Blastomeres from Ascidian Embryos

The aim of this investigation was to establish an experimental system for studying the causal relationship between DNA replication and tissue-specific enzyme development in ascidian embryos. Blastomeres were dissociated from 44∽64-ceIl Halocynthia roretzi embryos and fractionated by centrifugation through a discontinuous Percoll density gradient. When cells harvested from the fraction at the bottom of the tube were division-arrested with cytochalasin B (an inhibitor of cytokinesis) soon after their isolation, more than 70% of them developed histochemically-detectable muscle-specific acetylcholinesterase (AChE) activity, suggesting that they were almost all blastomeres of muscle lineage. When these cells were arrested with aphidicolin (an inhibitor of DNA replication) and cytochalasin B immediately after their isolation, however, none of them showed AChE activity. When they were allowed to divide once and then arrested with the inhibitors, nearly 40 % of them developed AChE activity, and when they were allowed to divide twice before arrest, about 70% of them showed AChE activity.     

Evolutionary modification of cell lineage in the direct-developing sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma

The sea urchin Heliocidaris erythrogramma undergoes direct development, bypassing the usual echinoid pluteus larva. We present an analysis of cell lineage in H. erythrogramma as part of a definition of the mechanistic basis for this evolutionary change in developmental mode. Microinjection of fluoresceinated tracer dye and surface marking with vital dye are used to follow larval fates of 2-cell, 8-cell, and 16-cell blastomeres, and to examine axial specification. The animal-vegetal axis and adult dorsoventral axis are basically unmodified in H. erythrogramma. Animal cell fates are very similar to those of typically developing species; however, vegetal cell fates in H. erythrogramma are substantially altered. Radial differences exist among vegetal blastomere fates in the 8-cell embryo: dorsal vegetal blastomeres contribute proportionately more descendants to ectodermal and fewer to mesodermal fates, while ventral vegetal blastomeres have a complementary bias in fates. In addition, vegetal cell fates are more variable than in typical developers. There are no cells in H. erythrogramma with fates comparable to those of the micromeres and macromeres of typically developing echinoids. Instead, all vegetal cells in the 16-cell embryo can contribute progeny to ectoderm and gut. Alterations have thus arisen in cleavage patterns and timing of cell lineage partitioning during the evolution of direct development in H. erythrogramma.     

A conserved role for the MEK signalling pathway in neural tissue specification and posteriorisation in the invertebrate chordate,the ascidian Ciona intestinalis

Ascidians are invertebrate chordates with a larval body plan similar to that of vertebrates. The ascidian larval CNS is divided along the anteroposterior axis into sensory vesicle, neck, visceral ganglion and tail nerve cord. The anterior part of the sensory vesicle comes from the a-line animal blastomeres, whereas the remaining CNS is largely derived from the A-line vegetal blastomeres. We have analysed the role of the Ras/MEK/ERK signalling pathway in the formation of the larval CNS in the ascidian, Ciona intestinalis. We show evidence that this pathway is required, during the cleavage stages, for the acquisition of: (1) neural fates in otherwise epidermal cells (in a-line cells); and (2) the posterior identity of tail nerve cord precursors that otherwise adopt a more anterior neural character (in A-line cells). Altogether, the MEK signalling pathway appears to play evolutionary conserved roles in these processes in ascidians and vertebrates, suggesting that this may represent an ancestral chordate strategy.     

Muscle cell differentiation in ascidian embryos analysed with a tissue-specific monoclonal antibody

Utilizing a muscle-specific monoclonal antibody (Mu-2) as a probe, we analysed developmental mechanisms involved in muscle cell differentiation in ascidian embryos. The antigen recognized by Mu-2 was a single polypeptide with a relative molecular mass of about 220 X 10(3). It first appeared at the early tailbud stage and continued to be expressed until the swimming larva stage. There were distinct and separate puromycin and actinomycin D sensitivity periods during the occurrence of the antigen, suggesting the new synthesis of the polypeptide by developing muscle cells. Embryos that had been permanently arrested with aphidicolin in the early cleavage stages up to the 32-cell stage did not express the antigen. DNA replications may be required for the antigen expression. Embryos that had been arrested with cytochalasin B in the 8-cell and later stages developed the antigen, and the number and position of the arrested blastomeres exhibiting the differentiation marker almost corresponded to those of the B4.1-line muscle lineage. Furthermore, in quarter embryos developed from each blastomere pair isolated from the 8-cell embryo, all the B4.1 as well as a part of b4.2 partial embryos expressed the antigen, while the a4.2 and A4.1 partial embryos did not show the antigen expression. These results may provide further support for the existence of cytoplasmic determinants for muscle cell differentiation in this mosaic egg.     

Studies on the Cytoplasmic Determinant for Muscle Cell Differentiation in Ascidian Embryos: An Attempt at Transplantation of the Myoplasm

The 8-cell stage embryos of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi which had been prevented from undergoing further divisions by continuous treatment with cytochalasin B could develop histospecific muscle acetylcholinesterase in two blastomeres (B4.1 and B4.1 cells). If the cytoplasm of a B4.1 or B4.1 cell was transplanted by microinjection into either an A4.1 or A4.1 cell of recipient embryos and the transplanted embryos were permanently cleavage-arrested with cytochalasin B, a few eventually developed AChE in three blastomeres instead of in just the two blastomeres found in cleavage-arrested control embryos. Judging from the relative positions of the blastomeres, the third AChE-producing cells appeared to be the A4.1 or A4.1 cells injected with the cytoplasm of B4.1 or B4.1. Although the success rate was considerably low, this result might indicate the presence in the cytoplasm of a determinant for the muscle-specific enzyme development.     

Allocation of cells in mouse blastocyst is not determined by the order of cleavage of the first two blastomeres

The second cleavage of the mouse embryo is asynchronous. Some recent investigators have proposed that the sequence of division of blastomeres in two-cell embryos may predict the ultimate location of the descendants of these blastomeres within the blastocyst. To verify this model, we tracked the cells derived from two-cell stage blastomeres using tetramethylrhodamine-conjugated dextran as a lineage tracer. In the first variant of the experiment, we labeled one of two blastomeres in two-cell embryos and subsequently recorded which blastomere cleaved first. In the second variant of the experiment, fluorescent dextran was injected at the three-cell stage into the blastomere that had not yet cleaved. Subsequently, the fate of the progeny of labeled and unlabeled blastomeres was followed up to the blastocyst stage. Our results suggest that allocation of cells into the embryonic and abembryonic parts of the blastocyst is not determined by the order of cleavage of the first two blastomeres.     

Cell lineage of zebrafish blastomeres. I. Cleavage pattern and cytoplasmic bridges between cells

Patterns of cleavage and cytoplasmic connections between blastomeres in the embryo of the zebrafish, Brachydanio rerio have been described. The cell division pattern is often very regular; in many embryos a blastomere's lineage may be ascertained from its position in the cluster through the 64-cell stage. At the 5th cleavage, however, significant variability in pattern is observed, and alternative patterns of the 5th cleavage are described. The early cleavages are partial, incompletely separating blastomeres from the giant yolk cell. The tracer fluorescein-dextran (FD) was injected into blastomeres to learn the extent of the cytoplasmic bridging. It was observed that until the 10th cleavage, blastomeres located along the blastoderm margin maintain cytoplasmic bridges to the yolk cell. Beginning with the 5th cleavage, FD injected into a nonmarginal blastomere either remains confined to the injected cell, or if the injection was early in the cell cycle, the tracer spreads to the cell's sibling, through a bridge persisting from the previous cleavage. On the other hand, injected Lucifer yellow spreads, presumably via gap junctions, widely among blastomeres in a pattern unrelated to lineage.