Effects of denervation and direct electrical stimulation upon acetylcholine receptors and acetylcholinesterase accumulation in developing latissimus dorsi muscle of the chick

The effects of denervation and of direct electrical stimulation of denervated muscle upon the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) clusters and acetylcholinesterase (AChE) spots in the fast avian muscle posterior latissimus dorsi have been investigated. Denervation at day 2 after hatching leads to a disappearance of the junctional AChR clusters and to a marked decrease of AChE spots. Direct electrical stimulation of denervated muscle allows the maintenance of AChR clusters and partly prevents the loss of AChE spots. When AChR cluster and post-synaptic AChE have disappeared in a denervated muscle, muscle activity induced by direct stimulation is unable to induce their accumulation.     

Denervation disperses acetylcholine receptor clusters at the neuromuscular junction in Xenopus cultures

The effect of denervation on acetylcholine receptor (AChR) cluster distribution on cultured Xenopus muscle cells has been examined in order to study the role of intact nerve in the maintenance of clusters at the nerve-muscle junction during development. AChRs on the muscle cell were labeled with tetramethyl rhodamine-conjugated alpha-bungarotoxin and sequential changes in AChR cluster distribution were examined with a fluorescence microscope using an image intensifier. Denervation was carried out by exposing the nerve cell body to a focused laser light of a high intensity. After this procedure the neurites originating from the cell quickly disintegrated and large AChR clusters associated with nerve divided into smaller clusters. Individual clusters subsequently decreased in size and finally disappeared. In about 30% of the cases new AChR clusters appeared at the extrajunctional region after denervation. These observations indicate that intact nerves are necessary for the maintenance of receptor localization at the nerve-muscle junction and that nerve-induced accumulation is seemingly reversible during the early period of synapse formation. We tested the idea that receptor clusters were lost due to diffusion of receptors in the muscle membrane after denervation. However, the rate of receptor cluster dispersal after denervation was much slower than that predicted by the diffusion model, suggesting that diffusion of receptors is not a rate-limiting step. Furthermore, we found that receptor clusters at the junction stabilize during days in culture. Thus, 80-90% of receptor clusters at the nerve-muscle junction disappeared at 7 hr after denervation in 1-day cocultures, while about 50% of receptor clusters remained after denervation in 3-day cocultures.     

Metabolic stabilization of acetylcholine receptors in vertebrate neuromuscular junction by muscle activity

The effects of muscle activity on the growth of synaptic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) accumulations and on the metabolic AChR stability were investigated in rat skeletal muscle. Ectopic end plates induced surgically in adult soleus muscle were denervated early during development when junctional AChR number and stability were still low and, subsequently, muscles were either left inactive or they were kept active by chronic exogenous stimulation. AChR numbers per ectopic AChR cluster and AChR stabilities were estimated from the radioactivity and its decay with time, respectively, of end plate sites whose AChRs had been labeled with 125I-alpha-bungarotoxin (alpha-butx). The results show that the metabolic stability of the AChRs in ectopic clusters is reversibly increased by muscle activity even when innervation is eliminated very early in development. 1 d of stimulation is sufficient to stabilize the AChRs in ectopic AChR clusters. Muscle stimulation also produced an increase in the number of AChRs at early denervated end plates. Activity-induced cluster growth occurs mainly by an increase in area rather than in AChR density, and for at least 10 d after denervation is comparable to that in normally developing ectopic end plates. The possible involvement of AChR stabilization in end plate growth is discussed.     

Regulation of turnover and number of acetylcholine receptors at neuromuscular junctions

The number and metabolic stability of acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) at neuromuscular junctions of rat tibialis anterior (TA) and soleus (SOL) muscles were examined after denervation, paralysis by continuous application of tetrodotoxin to the nerve, or denervation and direct stimulation of the muscle through implanted electrodes. After 18 days of denervation AChR half-life declined from about 10 days to 2.3 days (TA) or 3.6 days (SOL) and after 18 days of nerve conduction block to 3.1 days (TA). In contrast, the total number of AChRs per endplate was unaffected by these treatments. Denervation for 33 days had no further effect on AChR half-life but reduced the total number of AChRs to about 54% (SOL) or 38% (TA) of normal. Direct stimulation of the 33-day denervated SOL from day 18 restored normal AChR stability and counteracted muscle atrophy but had no effect on the decline in AChR number. The results indicate that motoneurons control the stability of junctional AChRs through evoked muscle activity and the number of junctional AChRs through trophic factors.     

Acetylcholine receptor aggregation parallels the deposition of a basal lamina proteoglycan during development of the neuromuscular junction

To determine the time course of synaptic differentiation, we made successive observations on identified, nerve-contacted muscle cells developing in culture. The cultures had either been stained with fluorescent alpha-bungarotoxin, or were maintained in the presence of a fluorescent monoclonal antibody. These probes are directed at acetylcholine receptors (AChR) and a basal lamina proteoglycan, substances that show nearly congruent surface organizations at the adult neuromuscular junction. In other experiments individual muscle cells developing in culture were selected at different stages of AChR accumulation and examined in the electron microscope after serial sectioning along the entire path of nerve-muscle contact. The results indicate that the nerve-induced formation of AChR aggregates and adjacent plaques of proteoglycan is closely coupled throughout early stages of synapse formation. Developing junctional accumulations of AChR and proteoglycan appeared and grew progressively, throughout a perineural zone that extended along the muscle surface for several micrometers on either side of the nerve process. Unlike junctional AChR accumulations, which disappeared within a day of denervation, both junctional and extrajunctional proteoglycan deposits were stable in size and morphology. Junctional proteoglycan deposits appeared to correspond to discrete ultrastructural plaques of basal lamina, which were initially separated by broad expanses of lamina-free muscle surface. The extent of this basal lamina, and a corresponding thickening of the postsynaptic membrane, also increased during the accumulation of AChR and proteoglycan along the path of nerve contact. Presynaptic differentiation of synaptic vesicle clusters became detectable at the developing neuromuscular junction only after the formation of postsynaptic plaques containing both AChR and proteoglycan. It is concluded that motor nerves induce a gradual formation and growth of AChR aggregates and stable basal lamina proteoglycan deposits on the muscle surface during development of the neuromuscular junction.     

Developmental regulation of interstitial cell density in bullfrog skeletal muscle

Denervation of skeletal muscle results in striking connective tissue remodelling in junctional areas of muscle. Since extracellular matrix molecules mediate axonal growth and synaptic differentiation, it is likely that the interstitial cells and matrix molecules that accumulate near synaptic sites after denervation influence the regrowth and regeneration of synaptic connections. The experiments presented here addressed the question of whether the junctional connective tissue in developing bullfrog skeletal muscle was also specialized in its cellular and molecular composition. Denervation responses of muscle, such as extrajunctional sensitivity to acetylcholine, often reproduce the characteristics of developing muscle during synaptogenesis. In developing muscle, the distribution of interstitial cells was nonuniform during the period of muscle fibre birth and synaptogenesis. Interstitial cells were concentrated near synaptic sites as in denervated adult muscle. Unlike denervated adult muscle, there were no junctional accumulations of fibronectin or tenascin, matrix molecules produced by interstitial cells, in developing muscles. These results demonstrate that the junctional connective tissue in developing muscle is identified by a high density of interstitial cells that may play a role in the identification and formation of synaptic sites. Further, the junctional matrix environment of developing muscle is distinct from the matrix remodelling that occurs in response to denervation, suggesting that the matrix production by interstitial cells during development is regulated differently from that after denervation of the neuromuscular junction.     

Agrin and acetylcholine receptors are removed from abandoned synaptic sites at reinnervated frog neuromuscular junctions

Changes in the distribution of agrin and acetylcholine receptors (AChRs) were examined during reinnervation and following permanent denervation as a means of understanding mechanisms controlling the distribution of these molecules. Following nerve damage in the peripheral nervous system, regenerating nerve terminals preferentially return to previous synaptic sites leading to the restoration of synaptic activity. However, not all portions of original synaptic sites are reoccupied: Some of the synaptic sites are abandoned by both the nerve terminal and the Schwann cell. Abandoned synaptic sites contain agrin, AChRs, and acetylcholinesterase (AChE) without an overlying nerve terminal or Schwann cell providing a unique location to observe changes in the distribution of these synapse-specific molecules. The distribution of anti-agrin and AChR staining at abandoned synaptic sites was altered during the process of reinnervation, changing from a dense, wide distribution to a punctate, pale pattern, and finally becoming entirely absent. Agrin and AChRs were removed from abandoned synaptic sites in reinnervated frog neuromuscular junctions, while in contralateral muscles which were permanently denervated, anti-agrin and AChR staining remained at abandoned synaptic sites. Decreasing synaptic activity during reinnervation delayed the removal of agrin and AChRs from abandoned synaptic sites. Altogether, these results support the hypothesis that synaptic activity controls a cellular mechanism that directs the removal of agrin from synaptic basal lamina and the loss of agrin leads to the dispersal of AChRs. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Neurobiol 33: 999–1018, 1997     

A Role of Tyrosine Phosphatase in Acetylcholine Receptor Cluster Dispersal and Formation

Innervation of the skeletal muscle involves local signaling, leading to acetylcholine receptor (AChR) clustering, and global signaling, manifested by the dispersal of preexisting AChR clusters (hot spots). Receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) activation has been shown to mediate AChR clustering. In this study, the role of tyrosine phosphatase (PTPase) in the dispersal of hot spots was examined. Hot spot dispersal in cultured Xenopus muscle cells was initiated immediately upon the presentation of growth factor–coated beads that induce both AChR cluster formation and dispersal. Whereas the density of AChRs decreased with time, the fine structure of the hot spot remained relatively constant. Although AChR, rapsyn, and phosphotyrosine disappeared, a large part of the original hot spot–associated cytoskeleton remained. This suggests that the dispersal involves the removal of a key linkage between the receptor and its cytoskeletal infrastructure. The rate of hot spot dispersal is inversely related to its distance from the site of synaptic stimulation, implicating the diffusible nature of the signal. PTPase inhibitors, such as pervanadate or phenylarsine oxide, inhibited hot spot dispersal. In addition, they also affected the formation of new clusters in such a way that AChR microclusters extended beyond the boundary set by the clustering stimuli. Furthermore, by introducing a constitutively active PTPase into cultured muscle cells, hot spots were dispersed in a stimulus- independent fashion. This effect of exogenous PTPase was also blocked by pervanadate. These results implicate a role of PTPase in AChR cluster dispersal and formation. In addition to RTK activation, synaptic stimulation may also activate PTPase which acts globally to destabilize preexisting AChR hot spots and locally to facilitate AChR clustering in a spatially discrete manner by countering the action of RTKs.     

Disruption and reformation of the acetylcholine receptor clusters of cultured rat myotubes occur in two distinct stages

We have examined the redistribution of acetylcholine receptor (AChR) intramembrane particles (IMPs) when AChR clusters of cultured rat myotubes are experimentally disrupted and allowed to reform. In control myotubes, the AChR IMPs are evenly distributed within the AChR domains of cluster membrane. Shortly after addition of azide to disrupt clusters, IMPs become unevenly scattered, with some microaggregation. After longer treatment, IMPs are depleted from AChR domains with no further change in IMP distribution. Contact domains of clusters are relatively poor in IMPs both before and after cluster dispersal. Upon visualization with fluorescent alpha-bungarotoxin, some AChR in azide-treated samples appear as small, bright spots. These spots do not correspond to microaggregates seen in freeze-fracture replicas, and probably represent receptors that have been internalized. The internalization rate is insufficient to account completely for the loss of IMPs from clusters, however. During reformation of AChR clusters upon removal of azide, IMP concentration in receptor domains increases. At early stages of reformation, IMPs appear in small groups containing compact microaggregates. At later times, AChR domains enlarge and IMPs within them assume the evenly spaced distribution characteristic of control clusters. These observations suggest that the disruption of clusters is accompanied by mobilization of AChR from a fixed array, allowing AChR IMPs to diffuse away from the clusters, to form microaggregates, and to become internalized. Cluster reformation appears to be the reverse of this process. Our results are thus consistent with a two-step model for AChR clustering, in which the concentration of IMPs into a small membrane region precedes their rearrangement into evenly spaced sites.     

Induction of phosphorylation and cell surface redistribution of acetylcholine receptors by phorbol ester and carbamylcholine in cultured chick muscle cells

We have investigated the mechanisms regulating the clustering of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) on the surface of cultured embryonic chick muscle cells. Treatment of these cells with the phorbol ester 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA), a potent activator of protein kinase C, was found to cause a rapid dispersal of AChR clusters, as monitored by fluorescence microscopy of cells labeled with tetramethylrhodamine-conjugated alpha-bungarotoxin. The loss of AChR clusters was not accompanied by an appreciable change in the amount of AChR on the surface of these cells, as measured by the specific binding of [125I]Bgt. Analysis of the phosphorylation pattern of immunoprecipitable AChR subunits showed that the gamma- and delta-subunits are phosphorylated by endogenous protein kinase activity in the intact muscle cells, and that the delta-subunit displays increased phosphorylation in response to TPA. Structural analogues of TPA which do not stimulate protein kinase C have no effect on AChR surface topography or phosphorylation. Exposure of chick myotubes to the cholinergic agonist carbamylcholine was found to cause a dispersal of AChR clusters with a time course similar to that of TPA. Like TPA, carbamylcholine enhances the phosphorylation of the delta-subunit of AChR. The carbamylcholine-induced redistribution and phosphorylation of AChR is blocked by the nicotinic AChR antagonist d-tubocurarine. TPA and carbamylcholine have no effect on cell morphology during the time-course of these experiments. These findings indicate that cell surface topography of AChR may be regulated by phosphorylation of its subunits and suggest a mechanism for dispersal of AChR clusters by agonist activation.     

Denervation alters the size, number, and distribution of clusters of acetylcholine receptor-like molecules on frog cardiac ganglion neurons

Acetylcholine receptor (AChR)-like molecules are found in clusters on the surface of parasympathetic neurons in the frog cardiac ganglion. Electron microscopy of immunoperoxidase-stained tissue reveals that in normally innervated ganglia most of these clusters are located at synaptic sites. Denervation for 2-3 weeks results in a 64% reduction in the total surface area occupied by AChR-like clusters; this change is brought about by the combined effects of a 4-fold decrease in cluster size and a 30% increase in cluster number. Denervation also changes the distribution of AChR-like clusters: clusters, normally restricted to portions of the cell surface, are more widely distributed following denervation. Denervation of amphibian skeletal muscle for a comparable period of time has no effect on the size or the number of synaptic clusters of AChRs. These results suggest that AChRs in nerve and in muscle are regulated differently by innervation.     

Nerve disperses preexisting acetylcholine receptor clusters prior to induction of receptor accumulation in Xenopus muscle cultures

We have investigated the sequential changes of acetylcholine receptor (AChR) distribution on identified Xenopus laevis muscle cells in culture before and after innervation. AChRs on muscle cells were stained with tetramethylrhodamine-conjugated alpha-bungarotoxin and the distribution of AChR clusters was examined on a fluorescence microscope using an image intensifier. Large receptor clusters were identified on muscle cells and their fate was followed afterward. In muscle cells cultured without neural tube cells, about one-half of the identified AChR clusters survived for 2 days. In nerve-muscle cocultures, preexisting AChR clusters survived longer on non-nerve-contacted muscle cells than on muscle cells cultured without nerve. However, in nerve-contacted muscle cells the great majority of preexisting AChR clusters dispersed within 2 days. The dispersal of preexisting AChR clusters preceded receptor accumulation along the path of nerve contact by about 12-16 hr. Therefore, an accelerated dispersal of receptor clusters in innervated muscle cells is not a consequence of receptor accumulation along the nerve. The preexisting AChR clusters located near and far from the nerve contact sites dispersed along a similar time course. Protease inhibitors, trasylol and leupeptin, reduced the nerve-induced dispersal of the preexisting AChR clusters in the period before AChR accumulation at the nerve contact sites but did not do so during the period when AChRs began to accumulate at nerve-muscle contact. The significance of the dispersal of preexisting receptor clusters is discussed with regard to neuromuscular junction formation.     

A single pulse of agrin triggers a pathway that acts to cluster acetylcholine receptors

Agrin triggers signaling mechanisms of high temporal and spatial specificity to achieve phosphorylation, clustering, and stabilization of postsynaptic acetylcholine receptors (AChRs). Agrin transiently activates the kinase MuSK; MuSK activation has largely vanished when AChR clusters appear. Thus, a tyrosine kinase cascade acts downstream from MuSK, as illustrated by the agrin-evoked long-lasting activation of Src family kinases (SFKs) and their requirement for AChR cluster stabilization. We have investigated this cascade and report that pharmacological inhibition of SFKs reduces early but not later agrin-induced phosphorylation of MuSK and AChRs, while inhibition of Abl kinases reduces late phosphorylation. Interestingly, SFK inhibition applied selectively during agrin-induced AChR cluster formation caused rapid cluster dispersal later upon agrin withdrawal. We also report that a single 5-min agrin pulse, followed by extensive washing, triggered long-lasting MuSK and AChR phosphorylation and efficient AChR clustering. Following the pulse, MuSK phosphorylation increased and, beyond a certain level, caused maximal clustering. These data reveal novel temporal aspects of tyrosine kinase action in agrin signaling. First, during AChR cluster formation, SFKs initiate early phosphorylation and an AChR stabilization program that acts much later. Second, a kinase mechanism rapidly activated by agrin acts thereafter autonomously in agrin's absence to further increase MuSK phosphorylation and cluster AChRs.     

Reversible loss of acetylcholine receptor clusters at the developing rat neuromuscular junction

Exposure of sternomastoid muscles excised from 16-day embryonic rats to medium depleted of Ca²⁺ or containing high concentrations of KCl leads to extensive loss of aggregates of acetylcholine receptors newly formed at the motor end plate region. Upon restoration of Ca²⁺ or removal of excess KCl, receptor accumulations reappear in the central regions of about one-third of the muscle fibers. This susceptibility of junctional AChR aggregates lasts only a short while during development of the neuromuscular junction. By the time of birth, end plate receptor aggregates have become resistant to these treatments.     

Molecular regulation of postsynaptic differentiation at the neuromuscular junction

The neuromuscular junction (NMJ) is a synapse that develops between a motor neuron and a muscle fiber. A defining feature of NMJ development in vertebrates is the re-distribution of muscle acetylcholine (ACh) receptors (AChRs) following innervation, which generates high-density AChR clusters at the postsynaptic membrane and disperses aneural AChR clusters formed in muscle before innervation. This process in vivo requires MuSK, a muscle-specific receptor tyrosine kinase that triggers AChR re-distribution when activated; rapsyn, a muscle protein that binds and clusters AChRs; agrin, a nerve-secreted heparan-sulfate proteoglycan that activates MuSK; and ACh, a neurotransmitter that stimulates muscle and also disperses aneural AChR clusters. Moreover, in cultured muscle cells, several additional muscle- and nerve-derived molecules induce, mediate or participate in AChR clustering and dispersal. In this review we discuss how regulation of AChR re-distribution by multiple factors ensures aggregation of AChRs exclusively at NMJs.     

Development of rat soleus endplate membrane following denervation at birth

Rat soleus endplates develop some of their characteristic features before birth and others after birth. Specializations appearing before birth include a localized cluster of acetylcholine receptors (AChRs), an accumulation of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) in the synaptic basal lamina, and a cluster of nuclei near the endplate membrane. In contrast, postsynaptic membrane folds are elaborated during the first three weeks after birth. We denervated soleus muscles on postnatal day 1, before folds had appeared, and followed the subsequent development of endplate regions with light and electron microscopy. We found that the denervated endplates initiated fold formation on schedule and maintained their accumulations of AChRs, AChE, and endplate nuclei. However, the endplates stopped fold formation prematurely and eventually lost their rudimentary folds. At about the same time, the junctional AChR clusters were joined by ectopic patches of AChRs. The former endplate regions also became unusually elongated, possibly as a consequence of the lack of membrane folds. Apparently, endplate membranes have only a limited capacity for further development in the absence of both the nerve and muscle activity.     

Antigenic modulation of junctional acetylcholine receptor is not sufficient to account for the development of myasthenia gravis in receptor immunized mice

Myasthenia gravis (MG) is a disease thought to result from an autoimmune response against the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor of the neuromuscular junction. Although there is little doubt that the muscular weakness characteristic of MG can be attributed to an antibody-mediated reduction in the density of AChR, the mechanism responsible for this reduction remains uncertain. In the present studies we have used a mouse model of MG, termed experimental myasthenia gravis (EMG), to test the possibility that antigenic modulation of AChR may be the principle mechanism whereby this reduction in AChR density is achieved. We found that immunization of mice with AChR, on average, leads to a twofold increase in the rate of junctional AChR degradation. Because this effect occurred to the same extent in mice that developed severe paralysis and in those that gave no indication of muscular weakness, the role of antigenic modulation as a major pathologic mechanism in MG is questioned.     

A Role for Acetylcholine-Nicotinic Receptor Interactions in the Selective Increase of Rat Skeletal Muscle G4 Acetylcholinesterase Following Short-Term Denervation

The present work addresses the effects of short-term denervation on acetylcholinesterase (AChE; EC 3.1.1.7) isoenzymes in anterior gracilis muscles from adult male Sprague-Dawley rats. It examines possible relationships between AChE isoform changes and other denervation phenomena, and evaluates the importance of acetylcholine (ACh)-nicotinic receptor interactions in selectively modulating the activity of G4 AChE. Results confirm that denervation causes a specific, transient increase in G4 AChE and show that: most of the increment can be explained by the hydrophobic species of this isoenzyme; changes in AChE isoforms markedly precede the onset of spontaneous electromechanical activity (fibrillation), as well as acetylcholine receptor (AChR) proliferation; and the G4 AChE response is eliminated when AChRs are blocked by alpha-bungarotoxin treatment performed before but not after (24 h) denervation. These data point to the absence of direct causal relationships between the G4 AChE increment and fibrillation, AChR proliferation, or changes in the release of this isoform from denervated muscle. In turn, they suggest the participation of AChR activation in triggering the G4 AChE response and emphasize the possible role of ACh-AChR interactions in modulating the production of this isoenzyme in not only denervated but also innervated fast-twitch muscles.