Notch and the amyloid precursor protein are cleaved by similar gamma-secretase(s)

Gamma-secretase is an intramembrane-cleaving protease whose substrates include Notch and the amyloid precursor protein (APP). On the basis of initial genetic and pharmacologic data, the gamma-secretase activity responsible for cleavage of both proteins appears to be identical. However, apparent differences in the cleavage site and in sequence specificity raise questions about the degree of similarity between Notch and APP gamma-like proteolysis. In an effort to resolve this issue directly, we established an in vitro gamma-secretase activity assay that cleaves both APP- and Notch-based substrates, C100Flag and N100Flag. Analysis with specific gamma-secretase inhibitors, dominant-negative gamma-secretase preparations, and antibody co-immunoprecipitations all demonstrated identical cleavage of these substrates. Most importantly, we found that these substrates prevented cleavage of each other, indicating that the same gamma-secretase complex can cleave either protein. Finally, we provide evidence that both substrates are cut at two distinct regions in the transmembrane domain. These data resolve some of the apparent conflicts and strongly indicate that Notch and APP are proteolyzed by the same enzyme(s).     

Nicastrin functions as a gamma-secretase-substrate receptor

gamma-secretase catalyzes the intramembrane cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (APP) and Notch after their extracellular domains are shed by site-specific proteolysis. Nicastrin is an essential glycoprotein component of the gamma-secretase complex but has no known function. We now show that the ectodomain of nicastrin binds the new amino terminus that is generated upon proteolysis of the extracellular APP and Notch domains, thereby recruiting the APP and Notch substrates into the gamma-secretase complex. Chemical- or antibody-mediated blocking of the free amino terminus, addition of purified nicastrin ectodomain, or mutations in the ectodomain markedly reduce the binding and cleavage of substrate by gamma-secretase. These results indicate that nicastrin is a receptor for the amino-terminal stubs that are generated by ectodomain shedding of type I transmembrane proteins. Our data are consistent with a model where nicastrin presents these substrates to gamma-secretase and thereby facilitates their cleavage via intramembrane proteolysis.     

Mutations at the P1' position of Notch1 decrease intracellular domain stability rather than cleavage by gamma-secretase

Gamma-secretase is a unique protease which cleaves within the transmembrane domain of several substrate proteins. Among gamma-secretase substrates are members of the Notch family of receptors and the amyloid precursor protein. In this study we used a cell-free Notch-cleavage assay and specific gamma-secretase inhibitors to study the cleavage of Notch by gamma-secretase. Using this assay, we found that, in contrast to previous reports, the presence of valine at the P1(') position of Notch1 is not required for gamma-secretase cleavage. Our results suggest that the presence of valine at the N-terminus of the Notch intracellular domain cleavage product is important for its stability. Thus it appears that Notch cleavage is very similar to APP cleavage with respect to the lack of sequence specificity.     

A sensitive and quantitative assay for measuring cleavage of presenilin substrates.

The presenilin (PS) proteins are components of the gamma-secretase activity, which is central in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. Here we present a novel cell-based reporter gene assay for the quantification of PS-controlled gamma-secretase cleavage of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor protein (APP). We show that this assay offers several advantages, including increased sensitivity and specificity, improved quantification of cleavage, and simultaneous detection of all gamma-secretase cleavages in APP. Furthermore, the APP assay can be used in parallel with a similar assay that records gamma-secretase cleavage of a Notch receptor. The use of these assays to analyze the effects of two known gamma-secretase inhibitors and postulated PS active site mutants on APP and Notch processing demonstrated that inhibitors and mutants that differently affect Notch and APP cleavage can be identified rapidly. The possibility in using these assays for high throughput screening of candidate gamma-secretase inhibitors for APP and Notch in parallel opens up new vistas to systematically search for novel inhibitors that selectively block APP cleavage while not affecting Notch signaling.     

Are presenilins intramembrane-cleaving proteases? Implications for the molecular mechanism of Alzheimer's disease.

The amyloid-beta protein (Abeta) is strongly implicated in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer's disease. The final step in the production of Abeta from the amyloid precursor protein (APP) is proteolysis by the unidentified gamma-secretases. This cleavage event is unusual in that it apparently occurs within the transmembrane region of the substrate. Studies with substrate-based inhibitors together with molecular modeling and mutagenesis of the gamma-secretase cleavage site of APP suggest that gamma-secretases are aspartyl proteases that catalyze a novel intramembranous proteolysis. This proteolysis requires the presenilins, proteins with eight transmembrane domains that are mutated in most cases of autosomal dominant familial Alzheimer's disease. Two conserved transmembrane aspartates in presenilins are essential for gamma-secretase activity, suggesting that presenilins themselves are gamma-secretases. Moreover, presenilins also mediate the apparently intramembranous cleavage of the Notch receptor, an event critical for Notch signaling and embryonic development. Thus, if presenilins are gamma-secretases, then they are also likely the proteases that cleave Notch within its transmembrane domain. Another protease, S2P, involved in the processing of the sterol regulatory element binding protein, is also a multipass integral membrane protein which cleaves within or very close to the transmembrane region of its substrate. Thus, presenilins and S2P appear to be members of a new type of polytopic protease with an intramembranous active site.     

The transmembrane domain region of nicastrin mediates direct interactions with APH-1 and the gamma-secretase complex

Nicastrin (NCT) is a type I integral membrane protein that is one of the four essential components of the gamma-secretase complex, a protein assembly that catalyzes the intramembranous cleavage of the amyloid precursor protein and Notch. Other gamma-secretase components include presenilin-1 (PS1), APH-1, and PEN-2, all of which span the membrane multiple times. The mechanism by which NCT associates with the gamma-secretase complex and regulates its activity is unclear. To avoid the misfolding phenotype often associated with introducing deletions or mutations into heavily glycosylated and disulfide-bonded proteins such as NCT, we produced chimeras between human (hNCT) and Caenorhabditis elegans NCT (ceNCT). Although ceNCT did not associate with human gamma-secretase components, all of the ceNCT/hNCT chimeras interacted with gamma-secretase components from human, C. elegans, or both, indicating that they folded correctly. A region at the C-terminal end of hNCT, encompassing the last 50 residues of its ectodomain, the transmembrane domain, and the cytoplasmic domain was important for mediating interactions with human PS1, APH-1, and PEN-2. This finding is consistent with the fact that the bulk of the gamma-secretase complex proteins resides within the membrane, with relatively small extramembranous domains. Finally, hNCT associated with hAPH-1 in the absence of PS, consistent with NCT and APH-1 forming a subcomplex prior to association with PS1 and PEN-2 and indicating that the interactions between NCT with PS1 may be indirect or stabilized by the presence of APH-1.     

Regulated intramembrane proteolysis of the p75 neurotrophin receptor modulates its association with the TrkA receptor

The generation of biologically active proteins by regulated intramembrane proteolysis is a highly conserved mechanism in cell signaling. Presenilin-dependent gamma-secretase activity is responsible for the intramembrane proteolysis of selected type I membrane proteins, including beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP) and Notch. A small fraction of intracellular domains derived from both APP and Notch translocates to and appears to function in the nucleus, suggesting a generic role for gamma-secretase cleavage in nuclear signaling. Here we show that the p75 neurotrophin receptor (p75NTR) undergoes presenilin-dependent intramembrane proteolysis to yield the soluble p75-intracellular domain. The p75NTR is a multifunctional type I membrane protein that promotes neurotrophin-induced neuronal survival and differentiation by forming a heteromeric co-receptor complex with the Trk receptors. Mass spectrometric analysis revealed that gamma-secretase-mediated cleavage of p75NTR occurs at a position located in the middle of the transmembrane (TM) domain, which is reminiscent of the amyloid beta-peptide 40 (Abeta40) cleavage of APP and is topologically distinct from the major TM cleavage site of Notch 1. Size exclusion chromatography and co-immunoprecipitation analyses revealed that TrkA forms a molecular complex together with either full-length p75 or membrane-tethered C-terminal fragments. The p75-ICD was not recruited into the TrkA-containing high molecular weight complex, indicating that gamma-secretase-mediated removal of the p75 TM domain may perturb the interaction with TrkA. Independent of the possible nuclear function, our studies suggest that gamma-secretase-mediated p75NTR proteolysis plays a role in the formation/disassembly of the p75-TrkA receptor complex by regulating the availability of the p75 TM domain that is required for this interaction.     

gamma-Secretase, evidence for multiple proteolytic activities and influence of membrane positioning of substrate on generation of amyloid beta peptides of varying length

gamma-Secretase activity is the final cleavage event that releases the amyloid beta peptide (Abeta) from the beta-secretase cleaved carboxyl-terminal fragment of the amyloid beta protein precursor (APP). No protease responsible for this highly unusual, purportedly intramembranous, cleavage has been definitively identified. We examined the substrate specificity of gamma-secretase by mutating various residues within or adjacent to the transmembrane domain of the APP and then analyzing Abeta production from cells transfected with these mutant APPs by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and mass spectrometry. Abeta production was also analyzed from a subset of transmembrane domain APP mutants that showed dramatic shifts in gamma-secretase cleavage in the presence or absence of pepstatin, an inhibitor of gamma-secretase activity. These studies demonstrate that gamma-secretase's cleavage specificity is primarily determined by location of the gamma-secretase cleavage site of APP with respect to the membrane, and that gamma-secretase activity is due to the action of multiple proteases exhibiting both a pepstatin- sensitive activity and a pepstatin-insensitive activity. Given that gamma-secretase is a major therapeutic target in Alzheimer's disease these studies provide important information with respect to the mechanism of Abeta production that will direct efforts to isolate the gamma-secretases and potentially to develop effective therapeutic inhibitors of pathologically relevant gamma-secretase activities.     

Functional domains in presenilin 1: the Tyr-288 residue controls gamma-secretase activity and endoproteolysis

Processing of the Alzheimer amyloid precursor protein (APP) into the amyloid beta-protein and the APP intracellular domain is a proteolysis event mediated by the gamma-secretase complex where presenilin (PS) proteins are key constituents. PS is subjected to an endoproteolytic cleavage, generating a stable heterodimer composed of an N-terminal and a C-terminal fragment. Here we aimed at further understanding the role of PS in endoproteolysis, in proteolytic processing of APP and Notch, and in assembly of the gamma-secretase complex. By using a truncation protocol and alanine scanning, we identified Tyr-288 in the PS1 N-terminal fragment as critical for PS-dependent intramembrane proteolysis. Further mutagenesis of the 288 site identified mutants differentially affecting endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity. The Y288F mutant was endoproteolyzed to the same extent as wild type PS but increased the amyloid beta-protein 42/40 ratio by approximately 75%. In contrast, the Y288N mutant was also endoproteolytically processed but was inactive in reconstituting gamma-secretase in PS null cells. The Y288D mutant was deficient in both endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity. All three mutant PS1 molecules were incorporated into gamma-secretase complexes and stabilized Pen-2 in PS null cells. Thus, mutations at Tyr-288 do not affect gamma-secretase complex assembly but can differentially control endoproteolysis and gamma-secretase activity.     

Proteolysis of chimeric beta-amyloid precursor proteins containing the Notch transmembrane domain yields amyloid beta-like peptides

gamma-Secretase is an unusual intramembranous protease that has been reported to cleave the beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP) near the middle of its transmembrane domain (TMD) but cleave Notch near the cytoplasmic end of its TMD. To ascertain whether the TMD sequence of the substrate determines where gamma-secretase cleaves and whether the region just before the TMD participates in recognition by the enzyme, we expressed chimeric human APP molecules containing either the TMD or pre-TMD regions of Notch or other transmembrane proteins. APP chimeras bearing either the Notch or the amyloid precursor-like protein-2 TMD released similar amounts of approximately 4-kDa amyloid beta-peptide (Abeta)-like peptides as did intact APP. Mass spectrometry revealed that the principal Abeta-like peptide ended at residue 40, indicating cleavage at the middle of the Notch TMD in the chimera. Generation of Abeta-like peptides was significantly decreased when the APP TMD was replaced by those of SREBP-1 or human epithelial growth factor receptor 3. Replacement of the APP pre-TMD region (Abeta 10-28) with that of SREBP-1 increased generation of Abeta-like peptides, while those of human epithelial growth factor receptor 3 or amyloid precursor-like protein-2 decreased it. We conclude that gamma-secretase can cleave near the middle of the Notch TMD, that Abeta-like peptides may arise during Notch processing, and that the pre-TMD sequence of the substrate influences recognition or binding by the enzyme.     

Characterization of a presenilin-mediated amyloid precursor protein carboxyl-terminal fragment gamma. Evidence for distinct mechanisms involved in gamma -secretase processing of the APP and Notch1 transmembrane domains

A variety of investigations have led to the conclusion that presenilins (PS) play a critical role in intramembranous, gamma-secretase proteolysis of selected type I membrane proteins, including Notch1 and amyloid precursor protein (APP). We now show that the generation of the S3/Notch intracellular domain and APP-carboxyl-terminal fragment gamma (CTFgamma) derivatives are dependent on PS expression and inhibited by a highly selective and potent gamma-secretase inhibitor. Unexpectedly, the APP-CTFgamma derivative is generated by processing between Leu-645 and Val-646 (of APP(695)), several amino acids carboxyl-terminal to the scissile bonds for production of amyloid beta protein peptides. Although the relationship of APP-CTFgamma to the production of amyloid beta protein peptides is not known, we conclude that in contrast to the highly selective PS-dependent processing of Notch, the PS-dependent gamma-secretase processing of APP is largely nonselective and occurs at multiple sites within the APP transmembrane domain.     

gamma-Secretase substrate selectivity can be modulated directly via interaction with a nucleotide-binding site

gamma-Secretase is an unusual protease with an intramembrane catalytic site that cleaves many type I membrane proteins, including the amyloid beta-protein (Abeta) precursor (APP) and the Notch receptor. Genetic and biochemical studies have identified four membrane proteins as components of gamma-secretase: heterodimeric presenilin composed of its N- and C-terminal fragments, nicastrin, Aph-1, and Pen-2. Here we demonstrated that certain compounds, including protein kinase inhibitors and their derivatives, act directly on purified gamma-secretase to selectively block cleavage of APP- but not Notch-based substrates. Moreover, ATP activated the generation of the APP intracellular domain and Abeta, but not the generation of the Notch intracellular domain by the purified protease complex, and was a direct competitor of the APP-selective inhibitors, as were other nucleotides. In accord, purified gamma-secretase bound specifically to an ATP-linked resin. Finally, a photoactivable ATP analog specifically labeled presenilin 1-C-terminal fragments in purified gamma-secretase preparations; the labeling was blocked by ATP itself and APP-selective gamma-secretase inhibitors. We concluded that a nucleotide-binding site exists within gamma-secretase, and certain compounds that bind to this site can specifically modulate the generation of Abeta while sparing Notch. Drugs targeting the gamma-secretase nucleotide-binding site represent an attractive strategy for safely treating Alzheimer disease.     

The cytoplasmic sequence of E-cadherin promotes non-amyloidogenic degradation of A beta precursors

The presenilin (PS)/gamma-secretase system promotes production of the A beta (A beta) peptides by mediating cleavage of amyloid precursor protein (APP) at the gamma-sites. This system is also involved in the processing of type-I transmembrane proteins, including APP, cadherins and Notch1 receptors, at the epsilon-cleavage site, resulting in the production of peptides containing the intracellular domains (ICDs) of the cleaved proteins. Emerging evidence shows that these peptides have important biological functions, raising the possibility that their inhibition by gamma-secretase inhibitors may be detrimental to the cell. Here, we show that peptide E-Cad/CTF2, produced by the PS1/gamma-secretase processing of E-cadherin, promotes the lysosomal/endosomal degradation of the transmembrane APP derivatives, C99 and C83, and inhibits production of the APP ICD (AICD). In addition, E-Cad/CTF2 decreases accumulation of total secreted A beta. These data suggest a novel method to promote the non-amyloidogenic degradation of A beta precursors and to inhibit A beta production.     

Overexpression of human CRB1 or related isoforms, CRB2 and CRB3, does not regulate the human presenilin complex in culture cells

The presenilin proteins (PS1 and PS2) with their partners (NCT, Aph1, and Pen2) are the major components of the high molecular weight gamma-secretase complex which facilitates the intramembraneous cleavage of various type 1 transmembrane proteins, including the amyloid-beta precursor protein (APP) and the Notch receptor. Additional gamma-secretase complex components may be involved in regulation of its activity and specificity. A recent investigation indicated that the Crumbs protein is a negative regulator of Notch signaling and may act by repressing gamma/epsilon-secretase activity in Drosophila [Herranz, H., Stamataki, E., Feiguin, F., and Milan, M. (2006) EMBO Rep. 7, 297-302]. To address this question, we investigated potential functional interactions between the human Crumbs homologues (CRB1, CRB2, and CRB3) and presenilin complexes which mediate gamma/epsilon-secretase cleavage of APP and Notch. We found no evidence for direct interaction between CRB1, CRB2, or CRB3 and presenilin complex components. Furthermore, overexpression of human CRB1 and related isoforms, CRB2 and CRB3, had no effect on the levels of presenilin complex components, on NCT maturation or on PS endoproteolysis, and did not alter Abeta AICD or NICD production. These results suggest that, in mammalian cells at least, Crumbs is unlikely to be a significant direct modulator of presenilin-dependent gamma/epsilon-secretase activity.     

Presenilin clinical mutations can affect gamma-secretase activity by different mechanisms

Mutations in human presenilin (PS) genes cause aggressive forms of familial Alzheimer's disease. Presenilins are polytopic proteins that harbour the catalytic site of the gamma-secretase complex and cleave many type I transmembrane proteins including beta-amyloid precursor protein (APP), Notch and syndecan 3. Contradictory results have been published concerning whether PS mutations cause 'abnormal' gain or (partial) loss of function of gamma-secretase. To avoid the possibility that wild-type PS confounds the interpretation of the results, we used presenilin-deficient cells to analyse the effects of different clinical mutations on APP, Notch, syndecan 3 and N-cadherin substrate processing, and on gamma-secretase complex formation. A loss in APP and Notch substrate processing at epsilon and S3 cleavage sites was observed with all presenilin mutants, whereas APP processing at the gamma site was affected in variable ways. PS1-Delta9 and PS1-L166P mutations caused a reduction in beta-amyloid peptide Abeta40 production whereas PS1-G384A mutant significantly increased Abeta42. Interestingly PS2, a close homologue of PS1, appeared to be a less efficient producer of Abeta than PS1. Finally, subtle differences in gamma-secretase complex assembly were observed. Overall, our results indicate that the different mutations in PS affect gamma-secretase structure or function in multiple ways.     

Notch1 competes with the amyloid precursor protein for gamma-secretase and down-regulates presenilin-1 gene expression

Presenilin 1 (PS1) is a critical component of the gamma-secretase complex, which is involved in the cleavage of several substrates including the amyloid precursor protein (APP) and Notch1. Based on the fact that APP and Notch are processed by the same gamma-secretase, we postulated that APP and Notch compete for the enzyme activity. In this report, we examined the interactions between APP, Notch, and PS1 using the direct gamma-secretase substrates, Notch 1 Delta extracellular domain (N1DeltaEC) and APP carboxyl-terminal fragment of 99 amino acids, and measured the effects on amyloid-beta protein production and Notch signaling, respectively. Additionally, we tested the hypothesis that downstream effects on PS1 expression may coexist with the competition phenomenon. We observed significant competition between Notch and APP for gamma-secretase activity; transfection with either of two direct substrates of gamma-secretase led to a reduction in the gamma-cleaved products, Notch intracellular domain or amyloid-beta protein. In addition, however, we found that activation of the Notch signaling pathway, by either N1 Delta EC or Notch intracellular domain, induced down-regulation of PS1 gene expression. This finding suggests that Notch activation directly engages gamma-secretase and subsequently leads to diminished PS1 expression, suggesting a complex set of feedback interactions following Notch activation.     

Generation and characterization of mutant cell lines defective in gamma-secretase processing of Notch and amyloid precursor protein

Several type I integral membrane proteins, such as the Notch receptor or the amyloid precursor protein, are cleaved in their intramembrane domain by a gamma-secretase enzyme, which is carried within a multiprotein complex. These cleavages generate molecules that are involved in intracellular or extracellular signaling. At least four transmembrane proteins belong to the gamma-secretase complex: presenilin, nicastrin, Aph-1, and Pen-2. It is still unclear whether these proteins are the only components of the complex and whether a unique complex is involved in the different gamma-secretase cleavage events. We have set up a genetic screen based on the permanent acquisition or loss of an antibiotic resistance depending on the presence of an active gamma-secretase able to cleave a Notch-derived substrate. We selected clones deficient in gamma-secretase activity using this screen on mammalian cells after random mutagenesis. We further analyzed two of these clones and identified previously undescribed mutations in the nicastrin gene. The first mutation abolishes nicastrin production, and the second mutation, a point mutation in the ectodomain, abolishes nicastrin maturation. In both cases, gamma-secretase activity on Notch and APP is impaired.     

Low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein (LRP) interacts with presenilin 1 and is a competitive substrate of the amyloid precursor protein (APP) for gamma-secretase

Presenilin 1 (PS1) is a critical component of the gamma-secretase complex, which is involved in the cleavage of several substrates including the amyloid precursor protein (APP) and the Notch receptor. Recently, the low density receptor-related protein (LRP) has been shown to be cleaved by a gamma-secretase-like activity. We postulated that LRP may interact with PS1 and tested its role as a competitive substrate for gamma-secretase. In this report we show that LRP colocalizes and interacts with endogenous PS1 using coimmunoprecipitation and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy. In addition, we found that gamma-secretase active site inhibitors do not disrupt the interaction between LRP and PS1, suggesting that the substrate associates with a gamma-secretase docking site located in close proximity to PS1. This is analogous to APP-gamma-secretase interactions. Finally, we show that LRP competes with APP for gamma-secretase activity. Overexpression of a truncated LRP construct consisting of the C terminus, the transmembrane domain, and a short extracellular portion leads to a reduction in the levels of the Abeta40, Abeta42, and p3 peptides without changing the total level of APP expression. In addition, transfection with the beta-chain of LRP causes an increase in uncleaved APP C-terminal fragments and a concomitant decrease in the signaling effects of the APP intracellular domain. In conclusion, LRP is a PS1 interactor and can compete with APP for gamma-secretase enzymatic activity.