Recent advances in nano-carrier immobilized enzymes and their applications

Enzymes have been widely used because of their catalytic properties, and immobilization is a promising technique to improve their catalytic activity and stability. Due to their large specific surface areas, exceptional chemical, mechanical, thermal and cost effective characteristics, nanomaterials should be ideal carriers for the immobilization of enzymes. Enzymes immobilized on nano-carriers are more robust and stable, and can be recycled and reused. This review focuses on the nanomaterial immobilized enzymes and their applications. The introduction addresses the advantages of immobilized enzymes and the features of enzyme immobilization nanocarriers. The next section covers carbonaceous nanomaterials used in enzymes immobilization, with subsections on carbon nanotube, graphene, graphene oxide and reduced graphene oxide. The third section treats metallic nanomaterials for enzymes immobilization, with subsections on metal (gold), metal oxide (titanium dioxide, zinc oxide) and metal hydroxide (layered double hydroxide) nanomaterials. Then, the next section summarizes the applications of nanomaterial immobilized enzymes. A concluding section discusses the challenges and prospects of nanomaterial immobilized enzymes.     

Novel sol-gel immobilization of horseradish peroxidase employing a detergentless micro-emulsion system

A novel sol-gel immobilization method employing a detergentless micro-emulsion system that consisted ofn-hexane/iso-propanol/water was developed and used to immobilize a horseradish peroxidase (HRP). Micro-sized gel powder containing enzymes was generated in the ternary solution without drying and grinding steps or the addition of detergent, therefore, the method described in this study is a simple and straightforward process for the manufacture of gel powder. The gel powder made in this study was able to retain 84% of its initial enzyme activity, which is higher than gel powders produced through other immobilization methods. Furthermore, the HRP immobilized using this method, was able to maintain its activity at or above 95% of its initial activity for 48h, whereas the enzyme activities of free HRP and HRP that was immobilized using the other sol-gel method decreased dramatically. In addition, even when in the presence of excess hydrogen peroxide, the enzyme immobilized using the novel sol-gel method described here was more stable than enzymes immobilized using the other method.     

Reversible immobilization of invertase on Cu-chelated polyvinylimidazole-grafted iron oxide nanoparticles

Polyvinylimidazole (PVI)-grafted iron oxide nanoparticles (PVIgMNP) were prepared by grafting of telomere of PVI on the iron oxide nanoparticles. Different metal ions (Cu²⁺, Zn²⁺, Cr²⁺, Ni²⁺) ions were chelated on polyvinylimidazole-grafted iron oxide nanoparticles, and then the metal-chelated magnetic particles were used in the adsorption of invertase. The maximum invertase immobilization capacity of the PVIgMNP–Cu²⁺ beads was observed to be 142.856 mg/g (invertase/PVIgMNP) at pH 5.0. The values of the maximum reaction rate (V _max) and Michaelis–Menten constant (Km) were determined for the free and immobilized enzymes. The enzyme adsorption–desorption studies, pH effect on the adsorption efficiency, affinity of different metal ions, the kinetic parameters and storage stability of free and immobilized enzymes were evaluated.     

Affinity precipitation and site-specific immobilization of proteins carrying polyhistidine tails

Proteins carrying genetically attached polyhistidine tails have been purified using affinity precipitation with metal chelates. DNA fragments encoding four or five histidine residues have been genetically fused to the oligomeric enzymes lactate dehydrogenase (Bacillus stearothermophilus), beta-glucoronidase (Escherichia coli), and galactose dehydrogenase (Pseudomonas fluorescens) as well as to the monomeric protein A (Staphylococcus aureus). The chimeric genes were subsequently expressed in E. coli. The engineered enzymes were successfully purified from crude protein solutions using ethylene glycolbis (beta-aminoethyl) tetraacetic acid (EGTA) charged with Zn(2+) as precipitant, whereas protein A, carrying only one attached histidine tail, did not precipitate. However, all of the engineered proteins could be purified on immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) columns loaded with Zn(2+). The potential of using the same histidine tails for site-specific immobilization of proteins was also investigated. The enzymes were all catalytically active when immobilized on IMAC gels. For instance, immobilized lactate dehydrogenase, carrying tails composed of four histidine residues, displaced 83% of the soluble enzyme activity. (c) 1996 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Control of protein immobilization: coupling immobilization and site-directed mutagenesis to improve biocatalyst or biosensor performance

Mutagenesis and immobilization are usually considered to be unrelated techniques with potential applications to improve protein properties. However, there are several reports showing that the use of site-directed mutagenesis to improve enzyme properties directly, but also how enzymes are immobilized on a support, can be a powerful tool to improve the properties of immobilized biomolecules for use as biosensors or biocatalysts. Standard immobilizations are not fully random processes, but the protein orientation may be difficult to alter. Initially, most efforts using this idea were addressed towards controlling the orientation of the enzyme on the immobilization support, in many cases to facilitate electron transfer from the support to the enzyme in redox biosensors. Usually, Cys residues are used to directly immobilize the protein on a support that contains disulfide groups or that is made from gold. There are also some examples using His in the target areas of the protein and using supports modified with immobilized metal chelates and other tags (e.g., using immobilized antibodies). Furthermore, site-directed mutagenesis to control immobilization is useful for improving the activity, the stability and even the selectivity of the immobilized protein, for example, via site-directed rigidification of selected areas of the protein. Initially, only Cys and disulfide supports were employed, but other supports with higher potential to give multipoint covalent attachment are being employed (e.g., glyoxyl or epoxy-disulfide supports). The advances in support design and the deeper knowledge of the mechanisms of enzyme-support interactions have permitted exploration of the possibilities of the coupled use of site-directed mutagenesis and immobilization in a new way. This paper intends to review some of the advances and possibilities that these coupled strategies permit.     

Overview on immobilization of enzymes on synthetic polymeric nanofibers fabricated by electrospinning

The arrangement and type of support has a significant impact on the efficiency of immobilized enzymes. 1-dimensional fibrous materials can be one of the most desirable supports for enzyme immobilization. This is due to their high surface area to volume ratio, internal porosity, ease of handling, and high mechanical stability, all of which allow a higher enzyme loading, release and finally lead to better catalytic efficiency. Fortunately, the enzymes can reside inside individual nanofibers to remain encapsulated and retain their three-dimensional structure. These properties can protect the enzyme's tolerance against harsh conditions such as pH variations and high temperature, and this can probably enhance the enzyme's stability. This review article will discuss the immobilization of enzymes on synthetic polymers, which are fabricated into nanofibers by electrospinning. This technique is rapidly gaining popularity as one of the most practical ways to fibricate polymer, metal oxide, and composite micro or nanofibers. As a result, there is interest in using nanofibers to immobilize enzymes. Furthermore, present research on electrospun nanofibers for enzyme immobilization is primarily limited to the lab scale and industrial scale is still challanging. The primary future research objectives of this paper is to investigate the use of electrospun nanofibers for enzyme immobilization, which includes increasing yield to transfer biological products into commercial applications.     

Site-specific immobilization of enzymes on magnetic nanoparticles and their use in organic synthesis

Magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs) are attractive materials that serve as a support for enzyme immobilization and facilitate separations by applying an external magnetic field; this could facilitate the recycling of enzymes and broaden their applications in organic synthesis. Herein, we report the methods for the immobilization of water-soluble and membrane-bound enzymes, and the activity difference between free and immobilized enzymes is discussed. Sialyltransferase (PmST1, from Pasteurella multocida ) and cytidine monophosphate (CMP)-sialic acid synthetase (CSS, from Neisseria meningitides ) were chosen as water-soluble enzymes and expressed using an intein expression system. The enzymes were site-specifically and covalently immobilized on PEGylated-N-terminal cysteine MNPs through native chemical ligation (NCL). Increasing the length of the PEG linker between the enzyme and the MNP surface increased the activity of the immobilized enzymes relative to the free parent enzymes. In addition, the use of a fluorescent acceptor tag for PmST1 affected enzyme kinetics. In contrast, sialyltransferase from Neisseria gonorrheae (NgST, a membrane-bound enzyme) was modified with a biotin-labeled cysteine at the C-terminus using NCL, and the enzyme was then assembled on streptavidin-functionalized MNPs. Using a streptavidin-biotin interaction, it was possible to immobilize NgST on a solid support under mild ligation conditions, which prevented the enzyme from high-temperature decomposition and provided an approximately 2-fold increase in activity compared to other immobilization methods on MNPs. Finally, the ganglioside GM3-derivative (sialyl-lactose derivative) was synthesized in a one-pot system by combining the use of immobilized PmST1 and CSS. The enzymes retained 50% activity after being reused ten times. Furthermore, the results obtained using the one-pot two-immobilized-enzyme system demonstrated that it can be applied to large-scale reactions with acceptable yields and purity. These features make enzyme-immobilized MNPs applicable to organic synthesis.     

Efficient immobilization technique for enhancement of cellobiose dehydrogenase activity on silica gel

In this study, cellobiose dehydrogenase (CDH) of Phanerochaete chrysosporium ATCC 32629 was immobilized on silica gel for the further application of CDH in the saccharification process of biomass. To prevent the loss of enzyme activity during enzyme immobilization, the pretreatment of CDH was performed by various pretreatment materials before immobilization. When pretreated enzymes were used in immobilization, the activities of immobilized CDH were higher than non-pretreated CDH even in same amounts of immobilized protein. The specific activity of pretreated immobilized CDH with lactose was about two times higher than that of non-pretreated immobilized CDH. Moreover, the pretreated immobilized CDH showed better reusability than non-pretreated immobilized CDH, with 67.3% of its original activity being retained after 9 reuses.     

Immobilization of lipases on hydrophobic supports: immobilization mechanism,advantages, problems,and solutions

Lipases are the most widely used enzymes in biocatalysis, and the most utilized method for enzyme immobilization is using hydrophobic supports at low ionic strength. This method allows the one step immobilization, purification, stabilization, and hyperactivation of lipases, and that is the main cause of their popularity. This review focuses on these lipase immobilization supports. First, the advantages of these supports for lipase immobilization will be presented and the likeliest immobilization mechanism (interfacial activation on the support surface) will be revised. Then, its main shortcoming will be discussed: enzyme desorption under certain conditions (such as high temperature, presence of cosolvents or detergent molecules). Methods to overcome this problem include physical or chemical crosslinking of the immobilized enzyme molecules or using heterofunctional supports. Thus, supports containing hydrophobic acyl chain plus epoxy, glutaraldehyde, ionic, vinylsulfone or glyoxyl groups have been designed. This prevents enzyme desorption and improved enzyme stability, but it may have some limitations, that will be discussed and some additional solutions will be proposed (e.g., chemical amination of the enzyme to have a full covalent enzyme-support reaction). These immobilized lipases may be subject to unfolding and refolding strategies to reactivate inactivated enzymes. Finally, these biocatalysts have been used in new strategies for enzyme coimmobilization, where the most stable enzyme could be reutilized after desorption of the least stable one after its inactivation.     

Stabilization of a multimeric beta-galactosidase from Thermus sp. strain T2 by immobilization on novel heterofunctional epoxy supports plus aldehyde-dextran cross-linking

This work exemplifies the advantages of using a battery of new heterofunctional epoxy supports to immobilize enzymes. We have compared the performance of a standard Sepabeads-epoxy support with other Sepabeads-epoxy supports partially modified with boronate, iminodiacetic, metal chelates, and ethylenediamine in the immobilization of the thermostable beta-galactosidase from Thermus sp. strain T2 as a model system. Immobilization yields depended on the support, ranging from 95% using Sepabeads-epoxy-chelate, Sepabeads-epoxy-amino, or Sepabeads-epoxy-boronic to 5% using Sepabeads-epoxy-IDA. Moreover, immobilization rates were also very different when using different supports. Remarkably, the immobilized beta-galactosidase derivatives showed very improved but different stabilities after favoring multipoint covalent attachment by long-term alkaline incubation, the enzyme immobilized on Sepabeads-epoxy-boronic being the most stable. This derivative had some subunits of the enzyme not covalently attached to the support (detected by SDS-PAGE). This is a problem if the biocatalysts were to be used in food technology. The optimization of the cross-linking with aldehyde-dextran permitted the full stabilization of the quaternary structure of the enzyme. The optimal derivative was very active in lactose hydrolysis even at 70 degrees C (over 1000 IU/g), maintaining its activity after long incubation times under these conditions and with no risk of product contamination with enzyme subunits.     

Compositions and compositional-behavioural relationships of enzymes immobilized on porous inorganic supports via titanium(IV) species

The compositions and compositional-behavioural relationships of glucoamylase (exo-1,4-α-d-glucosidase, EC 3.2.1.3) immobilized on titanium(IV)-activated porous inorganic supports have been investigated for several transition metal activation techniques based on the metal-link/chelation method developed by our group. The highest activity (239 Ug^?1 matrix) of immobilized glucoamylase was obtained with the hydrous titanium(IV) oxide derivative of the support when this and a 15% w/v TiCl₄ solution were dried at 45°C in vacuum for 30 h. However, the immobilized enzyme preparation displayed a very unstable behaviour, as did also the preparation which was obtained by drying the mixture of support and transition metal solution at atmospheric pressure. This was mainly due to an enzyme deactivation by titanium inhibition instead of enzyme loss in substrate solution. When amination and carbonylation steps were included in the immobilization technique much more stable preparations were obtained, mainly when the support was activated by drying at 45°C with a 15% w/v TiCl₄ solution ($\text{t}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}\text{= 1495}\text{h}$) although with a lower initial activity (35.6 Ug^?1 matrix). The pure TiCl₄ support activation rather than TiCl₄/HCl solution support activation led to less stable immobilized enzyme preparations (washing and amination solvent chloroform, $\text{t}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}\text{= 365}\text{h}$; washing and amination solvent water, $\text{t}{}_{\mathrm{<mtext>1</mtext><mtext>2</mtext>}}\text{= 276}\text{h}$) than the preparation obtained with the dried titanium(IV)-activated support. This was due to loss of enzyme-titanium(IV) complex in solution, as the interactions between the titanium(IV) and the silanol groups of the porous silica are weak. However, the amination (with 1,6-diaminohexane) and carbonylation (with glutaraldehyde) steps always led to immobilized enzyme preparations with constant specific activities and protein/titanium(IV) ratio. This suggests that the spacing effect introduced by these reactions removes the titanium(IV) inhibition of glucoamylase.     

Highly efficient immobilization of glycosylated enzymes into polyurethane foams

Glycosylated enzymes, including aminoacylase from Aspergillus melleus, chloroperoxidase from Caldariomyces fumago, and phytase from Aspergillus ficuum, were covalently immobilized into polyurethane foams with very high enzyme loadings of up to 0.2 g protein per gram dry foam. The immobilization efficiency (retained activity) ranged from 100% at a low loading to 60% at high loadings. In contrast to many other immobilization methods no leaching of the enzyme from the support took place under the reaction conditions. In short, a universal method for the immobilization of enzymes from fungal sources was developed, affording a highly active, stable, and reusable biocatalyst.     

Fabrication of an organic–inorganic nanocomposite carrier for enzyme immobilization based on metal–organic coordination

An organic–inorganic nanocomposite which combined mesoporous silica SBA-15 and chitosan using a carboxyl functionalized ionic liquid as the bridging agent (SBA@CS) was successfully fabricated, and was used to immobilize porcine pancreas lipase (PPL) by physical adsorption, cross-linking and metal–organic coordination, respectively. The as-prepared carriers were characterized by scanning electron microscopy, Fourier transform infrared and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. Compared with immobilization onto the pure mesoporous silicon material SBA-15, all the batches of PPL immobilized onto organic–inorganic nanocomposites showed higher activity, improved stability and reusability as well as better resistance to pH and temperature changes. Among the immobilized PPLs, immobilization based on Co²⁺ coordination (SBA@CS-Co-PPL) produced the best enzymatic properties. The maximum immobilization efficiency and specific activity of 79.6% and 1975.8 U g⁻¹ were obtained with SBA@CS-Co, separately. More importantly, the activity of immobilized enzyme can still maintain 84.0% after 10 times of reuse. These results demonstrated that thus prepared organic–inorganic nanocomposite could be an ideal carrier for enzyme immobilization by metal–organic coordination.     

Covalent immobilization of enzymes within micro-aqueous organic media

Traditional covalent immobilization of enzymes was mostly operated within water phase. However, most of enzymes are flexible when they are in water environment, and the covalent reactions generally lead to complete or partial activity losing due to the protein conformational changes.This paper examined enzyme covalent immobilization operated in micro-aqueous organic media, to display the differences between two environments of immobilization within water and micro-aqueous organic solvent by activity and stability determination of the resulting immobilized enzymes. Catalase, trypsin, horseradish peroxidase, laccase and glucose oxidase have been employed as model enzymes. Results showed the thermal, pH and reusable stabilities of the micro-aqueous organic covalently immobilized enzymes were improved when compared with the immobilized enzymes within water. Micro-aqueous covalent immobilization showed a remarkable advantage in remaining the enzymes catalytic activity for all the five enzymes compared with the traditional water phase immobilization. And the optimum pH values for both immobilization within water and micro-aqueous organic media shifted slightly.     

Stabilization of thymidine phosphorylase from Escherichia coli by immobilization and post immobilization techniques

Homodimeric thymidine phosphorylase from Escherichia coli (TP, E.C. 2.4.2.4) was immobilized on solid support with the aim to have a stable and recyclable biocatalyst for nucleoside synthesis. Immobilization by ionic adsorption on amine-functionalized agarose and Sepabeads^® resulted in a very high activity recovery (>85%). To prevent undesirable leakage of immobilized enzyme away from the support, the ionic preparations were cross-linked with aldehyde dextran (MW 20 kDa) and the influence of the dextran oxidation degree on the resulting biocatalyst activity was evaluated. Although in all cases the percentage of expressed activity after immobilization drastically decreased (≤25%), this procedure allowed to obtain an active catalyst which resulted up to 6-fold and 3-fold more stable than the soluble (non immobilized) enzyme and the just adsorbed (non cross-linked) counterpart, respectively, at pH 10 and 37 °C. No release of the enzyme from the support could be observed. Covalent immobilization on aldehyde or epoxy supports was generally detrimental for enzyme activity. Optimal TP preparation, achieved by immobilization onto Sepabeads^® coated with polyethyleneimine and cross-linked, was successfully used for the one-pot synthesis of 5-fluoro-2′-deoxyuridine starting from 2′-deoxyuridine or thymidine (20 mM) and 5-fluorouracil (10 mM). In both cases, the reaction proceeded at the same rate (3 μmol min⁻¹) affording 62% conversion in 1 h.     

One-step enzyme extraction and immobilization for biocatalysis applications

An extraction/immobilization method for HIs(6) -tagged enzymes for use in synthesis applications is presented. By modifying silica oxide beads to be able to accommodate metal ions, the enzyme was tethered to the beads after adsorption of Co(II). The beads were successfully used for direct extraction of C. antarctica lipase B (CalB) from a periplasmic preparation with a minimum of 58% activity yield, creating a quick one-step extraction-immobilization protocol. This method, named HisSi Immobilization, was evaluated with five different enzymes [Candida antarctica lipase B (CalB), Bacillus subtilis lipase A (BslA), Bacillus subtilis esterase (BS2), Pseudomonas fluorescence esterase (PFE), and Solanum tuberosum epoxide hydrolase 1 (StEH1)]. Immobilized CalB was effectively employed in organic solvent (cyclohexane and acetonitrile) in a transacylation reaction and in aqueous buffer for ester hydrolysis. For the remaining enzymes some activity in organic solvent could be shown, whereas the non-immobilized enzymes were found inactive. The protocol presented in this work provides a facile immobilization method by utilization of the common His(6) -tag, offering specific and defined means of binding a protein in a specific location, which is applicable for a wide range of enzymes.     

Multi-point enzyme immobilization,surface chemistry,and novel platforms: a paradigm shift in biocatalyst design

Engineering enzymes with improved catalytic properties in non-natural environments have been concerned with their diverse industrial and biotechnological applications. Immobilization represents a promising but straightforward route, and immobilized biocatalysts often display higher activities and stabilities compared to free enzymes. Owing to their unique physicochemical characteristics, including the high-specific surface area, exceptional chemical, electrical, and mechanical properties, efficient enzyme loading, and multivalent functionalization, nano-based materials are postulated as suitable carriers for biomolecules or enzyme immobilization. Enzymes immobilized on nanomaterial-based supports are more robust, stable, and recoverable than their pristine counterparts, and are even used for continuous catalytic processes. Furthermore, the unique intrinsic properties of nanomaterials, particularly nanoparticles, also confer the immobilized enzymes to be used for their broader applications. Herein, an effort has been made to present novel potentialities of multi-point enzyme immobilization in the current biotechnological sector. Various nano-based platforms for enzyme/biomolecule immobilization are discussed in the second part of the review. In summary, recent developments in the use of nanomaterials as new carriers to construct robust nano-biocatalytic systems are reviewed, and future trends are pointed out in this article.     

Use of chemically modified PMMA microspheres for enzyme immobilization

Modified poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) microspheres, about 7microm in diameter, carrying aldehyde groups on their surfaces were synthesized and used as the support for enzyme immobilization. The immobilizing behavior as well as the properties of immobilized enzyme was studied. The amount of bound enzyme can be extended to 76.8mg g(-1) support, which is relatively much higher than other supports. The kinetic investigation derived from three typical models shows that the practical process is more complicated than the ideal condition, with one or more interactions being involved in the immobilization process. The K(m) value is actually larger and V(max) is smaller in the immobilized form than those in the free form. The increased resistance of the immobilized enzyme against the changes of temperature indicates that immobilizing enzyme onto the modified microspheres is useful for enzyme immobilization.     

Substituted polymethylglutamate membrane for immobilization of urease

Poly-γ-methyl-l-glutamate (PMG) was modified and used for enzyme immobilization. Trichloroethyl ester (TCE) and three kinds of amino groups (ethylenediamine, ED; 1,8-diamino-4-amino-methyloctane, TA; polyethyleneimine, PEI) were introduced into the pendant group of PMG. A membrane was prepared from these polymers for enzyme immobilization. Urease was immobilized on each membrane using glutaraldehyde or water-soluble carbodiimide. Urease was very stable when it was immobilized with water-soluble carbodiimide on the membrane having PEI in the pendant group. The characteristics of immobilized urease were also discussed.     

Preparation and application of poly(N,N-dimethylacrylamide-co-acrylamide) and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-acrylamide)/kappa-Carrageenan hydrogels for immobilization of lipase

In the present of this study, two novel polymeric matrixes that are poly(N,N-dimethylacrylamide-co-acrylamide) and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide-co-acrylamide)/kappa-Carrageenan was synthesized and applied for immobilization of lipase. For the immobilization of enzyme, two different immobilization procedures have been carried out via covalently binding and entrapment methods. On the free and immobilized enzymes activities, optimum pH, temperature, storage and thermal stability was investigated. The optimum temperature for free, covalently immobilized and entrapped enzymes was found to be 30, 35 and 30 degrees C, respectively. Optimum pH for both free and immobilized enzymes was also observed at pH 8. Maximum reaction rate (Vmax) and Michaelis-Menten constant (Km) were determined for free and immobilized lipases. Furthermore, the reuse numbers of immobilized enzymes also studied. It was observed that after 40th use in 5 days, the retained activities for covalently immobilized and entrapped lipases were found as 39% and 22%, respectively. Storage and thermal stability of enzyme was also increased by as a result of immobilization procedures.