Early cytokinin response proteins and phosphoproteins of Arabidopsis thaliana identified by proteome and phosphoproteome profiling

Cytokinins are plant hormones involved in regulation of diverse developmental and physiological processes in plants whose molecular mechanisms of action are being intensely researched. However, most rapid responses to cytokinin signals at the proteomic and phosphoproteomic levels are unknown. Early cytokinin responses were investigated through proteome-wide expression profiling based on image and mass spectrometric analysis of two-dimensionally separated proteins and phosphoproteins. The effects of 15 min treatments of 7-day-old Arabidopsis thaliana seedlings with four main cytokinins representing hydroxyisopentenyl, isopentenyl, aromatic, and urea-derived type cytokinins were compared to help elucidate their common and specific function(s) in regulating plant development. In proteome and phosphoproteome maps, significant differences were reproducibly observed for 53 and 31 protein spots, respectively. In these spots, 96 proteins were identified by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight/time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF/TOF MS), providing a snapshot of early links in cytokinin-regulated signalling circuits and cellular processes, including light signalling and photosynthesis, nitrogen metabolism, the CLAVATA pathway, and protein and gene expression regulation, in accordance with previously described cytokinin functions. Furthermore, they indicate novel links between temperature and cytokinin signalling, and an involvement of calcium ions in cytokinin signalling. Most of the differentially regulated proteins and phosphoproteins are located in chloroplasts, suggesting an as yet uncharacterized direct signalling chain responsible for cytokinin action in chloroplasts. Finally, first insights into the degree of specificity of cytokinin receptors on phosphoproteomic effects were obtained from analyses of cytokinin action in a set of cytokinin receptor double mutants.     

The interaction of cytokinin with other signals

Cytokinins are important signalling molecules in plants, and recent studies have begun to shed light on the molecular mechanisms underlying their biosynthesis and response pathways. However, from the time of their discovery, it has been clear that cytokinins interact with other signals to regulate plant growth and development. Herein the interaction of cytokinin with three other signals: light, ethylene, and auxin is discussed. The interaction between light and cytokinin signalling, highlighted by recent analysis of cytokinin signalling mutants is reviewed. A discussion of another aspect of cytokinin cross-talk, its induction of ethylene biosynthesis in etiolated Arabidopsis seedlings, and recent studies that have begun to elucidate the mechanism underlying this regulation is also presented. Finally, there is a brief review of the interaction of auxin and cytokinin, and present novel expression profiling data of Arabidopsis seedlings treated with combinations of these two hormones, which provide insight into this interaction.     

Generic signal-specific responses: cytokinin and context-dependent cellular responses

The phytohormone cytokinin triggers numerous and diverse responses during the plant life cycle via a two-component phosphorelay signalling system. Each step of the signalling cascade is supported by a gene family comprising several members. While functional redundancy is observed among family members, additional gene-specific functions encoded by cis-regulatory and coding sequence of individual family members have been described and contribute to specificity in signalling output. In addition, the cellular context of the signal-receiving cell affects the response triggered. Recent studies in Arabidopsis have demonstrated how expression of cytokinin signalling components predefines a spatiotemporal map of signalling sensitivity, which causes local signal amplification and attenuation. In summary, the specific interpretation of cytokinin signalling is affected by an orchestrated interplay of signalling genes and cellular context.     

A role for G proteins in plant hormone signalling?

The G protein signalling pathway is one of the most highly conserved mechanisms that enables cells to sense and respond to changes in their environment. Essential components of this are cell surface G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that perceive extracellular ligands, and heterotrimeric G proteins (G proteins) that transduce information from activated GPCRs to down-stream effectors such as enzymes or ion channels. It is now clear from a range of biochemical and molecular studies that some potential G protein signalling components exist in plants. The best examples of these are the seven transmembrane receptor homologue GCR1 and the G_α (GPA1) and G_β (Gβ1) subunit homologues of heterotrimeric G proteins. G protein agonists and antagonists are known to influence a variety of signalling events in plants and have been used to implicate G proteins in a range of signalling pathways that include the plant hormones gibberellin and auxin. Furthermore, antisense suppression of GCR1 expression in Arabidopsis leads to a phenotype that supports a role for this receptor in cytokinin signalling. This review considers the current evidence for and against functional G protein signalling pathways in higher plants and questions whether or not these might be involved in the action of certain plant hormones.     

Evidence for the localization of the Arabidopsis cytokinin receptors AHK3 and AHK4 in the endoplasmic reticulum

Cytokinins are hormones that are involved in various processes of plant growth and development. The model of cytokinin signalling starts with hormone perception through membrane-localized histidine kinase receptors. Although the biochemical properties and functions of these receptors have been extensively studied, there is no solid proof of their subcellular localization. Here, cell biological and biochemical evidence for the localization of functional fluorophor-tagged fusions of Arabidopsis histidine kinase 3 (AHK3) and 4 (AHK4), members of the cytokinin receptor family, in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is provided. Furthermore, membrane-bound AHK3 interacts with AHK4 in vivo. The ER localization and putative function of cytokinin receptors from the ER have major impacts on the concept of cytokinin perception and signalling, and hormonal cross-talk in plants.     

Advances in upstream players of cytokinin phosphorelay: receptors and histidine phosphotransfer proteins

Cytokinins are a class of plant hormones that have been linked to numerous growth and developmental aspects in plants. The cytokinin signal is perceived by sensor histidine kinase receptors and transmitted via histidine phosphotransfer proteins (HPts) to downstream response regulators. Since their discovery, cytokinin receptors have been a focus of interest for many researchers. Ongoing research on these transmembrane receptors has greatly broadened our knowledge in terms of cytokinin–receptor interaction, receptor specificity, receptor cellular localization, and receptor functions in cytokinin related growth and developmental processes. This review focuses on the recent advances on the cytokinin receptors and HPt proteins in Arabidopsis.     

Cytokinin action in response to abiotic and biotic stresses in plants

The phytohormone cytokinin was originally discovered as a regulator of cell division. Later, it was described to be involved in regulating numerous processes in plant growth and development including meristem activity, tissue patterning, and organ size. More recently, diverse functions for cytokinin in the response to abiotic and biotic stresses have been reported. Cytokinin is required for the defence against high light stress and to protect plants from a novel type of abiotic stress caused by an altered photoperiod. Additionally, cytokinin has a role in the response to temperature, drought, osmotic, salt, and nutrient stress. Similarly, the full response to certain plant pathogens and herbivores requires a functional cytokinin signalling pathway. Conversely, different types of stress impact cytokinin homeostasis. The diverse functions of cytokinin in responses to stress and crosstalk with other hormones are described. Its emerging roles as a priming agent and as a regulator of growth‐defence trade‐offs are discussed.     

Mechanisms of cytokinin action

Cytokinins are involved in the control of numerous and important processes associated with plant growthand development. They take part in the control of cell division, chloroplast development, bud differentiation, shoot initiationand growth or leaf senescence. In contrast to the wide knowledge of cytokinin effects, the mechanisms of cytokinin actionremain largely unknown. Therefore, it is still difficult to explain how a group of molecules can control so many different biological responses. In this review, we propose some arguments in order to solve this question. In a first part, we underline that cytokinins act in concert with other signals for the control of biological responses. Therefore, the effects observed in responses to cytokinins would be not only related to cytokinins but would also be dependent on all other environmental and hormonal signals perceived by plant cells. In a second part, we present the different actors which could be involved in the signalling pathways of cytokinins. It is very likely that these different elements could be implicated in different cytokinin signalling pathways. Therefore, we propose that the diversity of the cytokinin responses could be also correlated with a diversity of cytokinin signalling pathways.     

CYTOKININ INDEPENDENT-1 regulates levels of different forms of cytokinin in Arabidopsis and mediates response to nutrient stress

The gene CYTOKININ INDEPENDENT-1 (CKI-1), previously isolated by enhancer trap screening, has been hypothesised to play a role in cytokinin perception. Alternative hypotheses suggest that it is required for the production of cytokinins or that it has no direct role in cytokinin signalling but simply interferes with the pathway when overexpressed. These hypotheses were investigated by producing transgenic Arabidopsis plants expressing CKI-1 cDNA in antisense orientation. In standard conditions, the phenotype of the plants was similar to wild type. Significantly higher amounts of the free base and riboside forms of cytokinin and lower amounts of membrane-impermeable cytokinins were found in the antisense lines. This supports the hypothesis that CKI-1 is involved in cytokinin perception and demonstrates the existence of a feedback loop altering cytokinin metabolism in response to the level of receptor abundance. An elevation in the content of free bases and ribosides of zeatin and isopentenyladenine, along with a reduction in the content of ribotide forms, suggests that a cytokinin ribotide 5'-ribonucleotidase may be a site at which CKI-1 exerts feedback control. When seed homozygous for the transgene was germinated on medium with reduced total mineral nutrient levels, the cotyledons of seedlings with reduced levels of CKI-1 failed to expand and green, and vegetative growth was inhibited. A similar phenotype was observed on low-phosphate media, suggesting that this failure resulted from an interaction between phosphate and cytokinins.     

Auxin, cytokinin and the control of shoot branching

BACKGROUND: It has been known for many decades that auxin inhibits the activation of axillary buds, and hence shoot branching, while cytokinin has the opposite effect. However, the modes of action of these two hormones in branching control is still a matter of debate, and their mechanisms of interaction are equally unresolved. SCOPE: Here we review the evidence for various hypotheses that have been put forward to explain how auxin and cytokinin influence axillary bud activity. In particular we discuss the roles of auxin and cytokinin in regulating each other's synthesis, the cell cycle, meristem function and auxin transport, each of which could affect branching. These different mechanisms have implications for the main site of hormone action, ranging from systemic action throughout the plant, to local action at the node or in the bud meristem or leaves. The alternative models have specific predictions, and our increasing understanding of the molecular basis for hormone transport and signalling, cell cycle control and meristem biology is providing new tools to enable these predictions to be tested.     

Rapid alteration of the phosphoproteome in the moss Physcomitrella patens after cytokinin treatment

Cytokinin hormones are crucial regulators of a large number of processes in plant development. Recently, significant progress has been made toward the elucidation of the molecular details of cytokinin that has led to a model for signal transduction involving a phosphorylation cascade. However, the current knowledge of cytokinin action remains largely unknown and does not explain the different roles of this hormone. To gain further insights into this aspect of cytokinin action and the inducible phosphorelay, we have produced the first large-scale map of a phosphoproteome in the moss Physcomitrella patens. Using a protocol that we recently published (Heintz, D.; et al. Electrophoresis 2004, 25, 1149-1159) that combines IMAC, MALDI-TOF-MS, and LC-MS/MS, a total of 172 phosphopeptide sequences were obtained by a peptide de novo sequencing strategy. Specific P. patens EST and raw genomic databases were interrogated, and protein homology searches resulted in the identification of 112 proteins that were then classified into functional categories. In addition, the temporal dynamics of the phosphoproteome in response to cytokinin stimulation was studied at 2, 4, 6, and 15 min after hormone addition. We identified 13 proteins that were not previously known targets of cytokinin action. Among the responsive proteins, some were involved in metabolism, and several proteins of unknown function were also identified. We have mapped the time course of their activation in response to cytokinin and discussed their hypothetical biological significance. Deciphering these early induced phosphorylation events has shown that the cytokinin effect can be rapid (few minutes), and the duration of this effect can be variable. Also phosphorylation events can be differentially regulated. Taken together our proteomic study provides an enriched look of the multistep phosphorelay system mediating cytokinin response and suggests the existence of a multidirectional interaction between cytokinin and numerous other pathways.     

The hormonal regulation of axillary bud growth in Arabidopsis

Apically derived auxin has long been known to inhibit lateral bud growth, but since it appears not to enter the bud, it has been proposed that its inhibitory effect is mediated by a second messenger. Candidates include the plant hormones ethylene, cytokinin and abscisic acid. We have developed a new assay to study this phenomenon using the model plant Arabidopsis. The assay allows study of the effects of both apical and basal hormone applications on the growth of buds on excised nodal sections. We have shown that apical auxin can inhibit the growth of small buds, but larger buds were found to have lost competence to respond. We have used the assay with nodes from wild-type and hormone-signalling mutants to test the role of ethylene, cytokinin and abscisic acid in bud inhibition by apical auxin. Our data eliminate ethylene as a second messenger for auxin-mediated bud inhibition. Similarly, abscisic acid signalling is not to be required for auxin action, although basally applied abscisic can enhance inhibition by apical auxin and apically applied abscisic acid can reduce it. By contrast, basally applied cytokinin was found to release lateral buds from inhibition by apical auxin, while apically applied cytokinin dramatically increased the duration of inhibition. These results are consistent with cytokinin acting independently to regulate bud growth, rather than as a second messenger for auxin. However, in the absence of cytokinin-signalling mutants, a role for cytokinin as a second messenger for auxin cannot be ruled out.     

CREam of cytokinin signalling: receptor identified.

Cytokinins play a central role in the regulation of plant cell division and numerous developmental processes. Pleiotropic effects have made studies of this hormone difficult, and cytokinin signalling pathways have long remained elusive. The recent identification of CRE1 (a histidine kinase identical to AHK4 and WOL) as the cytokinin receptor of Arabidopsis thaliana is a landmark in cytokinin research. Mutations have been identified in CRE1, and the phenotype of loss-of-function mutations sheds new light on the role of cytokinins in plant development. This article describes the experimental paths leading to receptor identification and the current interpretation of its function.     

Contrasting patterns of cytokinins between years in senescing aspen leaves

Cytokinins are plant hormones that typically block or delay leaf senescence. We profiled 34 different cytokinins/cytokinin metabolites (including precursors, conjugates and degradation products) in leaves of a free‐growing mature aspen (Populus tremula) before and after the initiation of autumnal senescence over three consecutive years. The levels and profiles of individual cytokinin species, or classes/groups, varied greatly between years, despite the fact that the onset of autumn senescence was at the same time each year, and senescence was not associated with depletion of either active or total cytokinin levels. Levels of aromatic cytokinins (topolins) were low and changed little over the autumn period. Diurnal variations and weather‐dependent variations in cytokinin content were relatively limited. We also followed the expression patterns of all aspen genes implicated as having roles in cytokinin metabolism or signalling, but neither the pattern of regulation of any group of genes nor the expression of any particular gene supported the notion that decreased cytokinin signalling could explain the onset of senescence. Based on the results from this tree, we therefore suggest that cytokinin depletion is unlikely to explain the onset of autumn leaf senescence in aspen.