An evaluation of the mouse sperm morphology test and other sperm tests in nonhuman mammals. A report of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Gene-Tox Program

The literature on the mouse sperm morphology test and on other sperm tests in nonhuman mammals was reviewed (a) to evaluate the relationship of these tests to chemically induced spermatogenic dysfunction, germ-cell mutagenicity, and carcinogenicity, and (b) to make an interspecies comparison to chemicals. A total of 71 papers were reviewed. The mouse sperm morphology test was used to assess the effects of 154 of the 182 chemical agents covered. 4 other murine sperm tests were also used: the induction of acrosomal abnormalities (4 agents), reduction in sperm counts, (6 agents), motility (5 agents), and F1 sperm morphology (7 agents)). In addition, sperm tests for the spermatogenic effects of 35 agents were done in 9 nonmurine mammalian species; these included analyses for sperm count, motility, and morphology, using a large variety of study designs. For the mouse sperm morphology test, 41 agents were judged by the reviewing committee to be positive inducers of sperm-head shape abnormalities, 103 were negative, and 10 were inconclusive. To evaluate the relationship between changes in sperm morphology and germ cell mutagenicity, the effects of 41 agents on mouse sperm shape were compared to available data from 3 different mammalian germ-cell mutational tests (specific locus, heritable translocation, and dominant lethal). The mouse sperm morphology test was found to be highly sensitive to germ-cell mutagens; 100% of the known mutagens were correctly identified as positives in the sperm morphology test. Data are insufficient at present to access the rate of false positives. Although it is biologically unclear why one might expect changes in sperm morphology to be related to carcinogenesis, we found that (a) a positive response in the mouse sperm morphology test is highly specific for carcinogenic potential (100% for the agents surveyed), and (b) overall, only 50% of carcinogens were positive in the test (i.e., sensitivity approximately equal to 50%). Since many carcinogens do not produce abnormally shaped sperm even at lethal doses, negative findings with the sperm test cannot be used to classify agents as noncarcinogens. We conclude that the mouse sperm morphology test has potential use for identifying chemicals that induce spermatogenic dysfunction and perhaps heritable mutations. Insufficient numbers of chemicals agents have been studied by the other sperm tests to permit similar comparisons. A comparison of 25 chemicals tested with sperm counts, motility, and morphology in at least 2 species (including man, mouse and 9 other mammals) demonstrated good agreement in response among species. With further study, interspecies comparisons of chemically induced sperm changes may be useful for predicting and evaluating human effects.     

ENU mutagenesis in the mouse electrophoretic specific-locus test, 1. Dose-response relationship of electrophoretically-detected mutations arising from mouse spermatogonia treated with ethylnitrosourea

The mouse electrophoretic specific-locus test for induced germ-cell mutations, was used to determine the response of spermatogonial stem cells to a series of doses of the germ cell mutagen N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU). Male DBA/2J and C57B1/6J mice were treated with doses of 50, 100, 200 or 250 mg/kg ENU and their progeny screened for electrophoretically-detectable mutations at 32 separate loci. As expected, increasing doses of ENU led to increasing mutant frequencies. The differences in mutant frequencies between treated DBA/2J and C57B1/6J males were not statistically significant.     

Ethylene dibromide: negative results with the mouse dominant lethal assay and the electrophoretic specific-locus test.

Ethylene dibromide (1,2-dibromoethane; EDB) was tested for the induction of dominant lethal and electrophoretically-detectable specific-locus mutations in the germ cells of DBA/2J male mice. Males were treated with a single intraperitoneal injection of 100 mg/kg EDB and mated to two C57BL/6J females. In the dominant lethal assay, matings were carried out to measure the effect of EDB on meiotic and postmeiotic stages; germ cells representing spermatogonial stem cells were analyzed in the electrophoretic specific-locus test. Neither of these germ cell tests produced any evidence that EDB is a germ cell mutagen. It appears from these data and those reported in the literature that EDB, a genotoxic carcinogen that affects male fertility in some mammalian species, is not mutagenic in the germ cells of the male mouse.     

Induction of specific-locus and dominant lethal mutations in male mice by ifosfamide (Holoxan)

Ifosfamide induced dominant lethal mutations in spermatozoa of mice at doses of 200 and 300 mg/kg and in spermatids and spermatocytes at 600 mg/kg. The highest dose also induced specific-locus mutations in post-spermatogonial germ-cell stages of mice but not in spermatogonial stem cells. The nature of the induced mutations suggests they are intergenic. The spermatogenic specificity of ifosfamide in mouse germ cells is similar to that of the structurally related cytostatic drugs cyclophosphamide and trofosfamide. Due to the post-spermatogonial germ cell specificity of ifosfamide, the genetic risk is limited to a few weeks after exposure.     

Clastogenic effects of acrylamide in mouse bone marrow cells

Acrylamide, known to induce dominant-lethal mutations (Shelby et al., 1986; Smith et al., 1986) and heritable translocations (Shelby et al., 1987) in rodent germ cells, was hitherto a questionable clastogen in rodent bone marrow (Shiraishi, 1978). Therefore, it was tested for chromosomal aberrations in mouse bone marrow cells, spermatogonia and by the micronucleus test. The intraperitoneally injected doses ranged from 50 to 150 mg/kg. In the chromosomal bone marrow test and the micronucleus assay positive results were obtained with acrylamide, and in the latter test the effect increased linearly with dose. Chromosomal aberrations were not induced in differentiating spermatogonia by the acute acrylamide treatment. Cisplatin was used as a positive control and gave the expected positive response in all 3 tests. The present results demonstrate that acrylamide is no exception among clastogens. It breaks chromosomes not only in mammalian germ cells but also in somatic cells.     

Activity of germ-cell mutagens and nonmutagens in the rat spermatocyte UDS assay

The ability of 13 chemicals of known germ-cell mutagenicity to induce unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) in rat spermatocytes was examined. At selected times following i.p. injection of test compounds, spermatocytes were isolated from Fischer 344 rats by enzymatic digestion of the seminiferous tubules and cultured for 24 h in the presence of [3H]thymidine. 7 compounds, methyl methanesulfonate, triethylenemelamine, cyclophosphamide, methylnitrosourea, ethylnitrosourea, procarbazine, and dibromochloropropane produced positive UDS responses in spermatocytes. These chemicals are also positive for specific locus mutations, heritable translocations, or dominant lethal mutations when administered to male rodents. Mitomycin C, which produces DNA interstrand crosslinks and induces heritable mutations and translocations in male germ cells, failed to stimulate UDS in rat spermatocytes. Germ-cell nonmutagens N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, dimethylnitrosamine, 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide, and ethylene dibromide were negative in the rat spermatocyte UDS assay. Correlation of these results with those of other assays for heritable mutations in germ cells indicates that the in vivo/in vitro spermatocyte DNA repair assay is useful in predicting the mutagenic potential of chemicals in male germ cells.     

Genetic toxicology of 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropane (DBCP)

1,2-Dibromo-3-chloropropane (DBCP) is a nematocide, which has been used extensively as a soil fumigant in agriculture. Since sterility was found among male workers involved in the manufacture of DBCP, great concern has been focused on the genetic hazards of DBCP. DBCP gave positive results in many tests such as microbial, in vitro cytogenetics, and Drosophila studies. In mammalian test systems, DBCP caused chromosomal aberrations in the bone marrow cells and dominant-lethal mutations in germ cells in rats. In mice, there were no signs of DBCP-induced heritable mutation in germ cells, although point mutations were detected in somatic cells. The occurrence of Y-chromosomal non-disjunction was indicated in DBCP-exposed male workers by an increased number of sperm containing 2 Y-chromosomes.     

Genotoxic evaluation of Ara-C by multiple parameters

The cytogenetic effects of the antimetabolite, cytosine arabinoside (Ara-C) are evaluated using in vivo and in vitro test systems and applying multiple parameters. The in vivo assay was carried out on 8-10-week-old inbred Swiss albino male mice using bone marrow as the somatic test system and the cells of testis as the meiotic test system. In vitro human leukocyte cultures were also employed. In vivo experimental doses were computed on surface area basis within the therapeutic dose range and injected intraperitoneally and for in vitro they were calculated on blood volume basis. Evaluation of somatic chromosome mutations included conventional screening for chromosome aberrations, variations in mitotic index and sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) by in vivo and in vitro methods besides studies on meiotic test systems using conventional screening for chromosome and sperm-head abnormalities. The quantitative data were subjected to statistical analysis by applying appropriate tests to evaluate their significance. The results of in vivo and in vitro experiments reveal the chromosome mutational activity of the compound. This is further supported by data on SCEs from both systems. However, a comparison of both demonstrated a differential mutagenic response of the drug, more in vivo than in vitro. This is also true for SCEs. Even though the mechanisms involved in causing chromosome aberrations and SCEs are different, the data on both corroborate each other on induction of chromosome mutations.     

Models and assumptions underlying genetic risk assessment

Various methods employed for estimating the genetic risks of radiation are reviewed. With the doubling-dose method, genetic damage is expressed as an increase in cases of known genetic disease. The actual doubling dose is based on figures obtained with the mouse. There have been no recent data on induced mutation frequencies. Recent results suggest that the prevalence figure for multifactorial disease may be at least one order of magnitude higher than before. Various assumptions underlying the doubling-dose concept are discussed in the light of recent findings on: (1) spontaneous mutations resulting from insertion elements, and (2) the comparability between spontaneous and induced mutations. The so-called direct method makes use of figures for induction of dominant mutations affecting the skeleton and the lens of the eye in the mouse, and of translocation induction in monkeys. Induction rates are converted to overall rates of induced dominant effects in man by applying certain assumptions. The proportionality between dose and effect is the basis for all genetic risk assessments. The possible significance of data on human lymphocytes indicating a threshold below 4 rad and the induction of repair enzymes by low radiation doses is discussed. The parallelogram approach is based on the principle that estimates can be obtained on the amount of genetic damage that cannot always be assessed directly. Thus mutations in mouse germ cells can be predicted by using mutation frequencies in cultured mammalian cells and O6-ethylguanine adducts. Measurement of haemoglobin mutations in human and mouse erythrocytes, and of HPRT-deficient mutations in lymphocytes of man and mouse should make more precise estimates of mutation frequencies in human germ cells possible. The development of a database on mutations in somatic cells of the mouse, their induction frequencies and molecular nature are considered an important priority. Used in combination with mouse germ-cell mutation frequencies, they should enable more precise risk estimates on the basis of mutations in somatic cells of man.     

Analysis of chromosomal rearrangements induced by postmeiotic mutagenesis with ethylnitrosourea in zebrafish

Mutations identified in zebrafish genetic screens allow the dissection of a wide array of problems in vertebrate biology. Most screens have examined mutations induced by treatment of spermatogonial (premeiotic) cells with the chemical mutagen N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU). Treatment of postmeiotic gametes with ENU induces specific-locus mutations at a higher rate than premeiotic regimens, suggesting that postmeiotic mutagenesis protocols could be useful in some screening strategies. Whereas there is extensive evidence that ENU induces point mutations in premeiotic cells, the range of mutations induced in postmeiotic zebrafish germ cells has been less thoroughly characterized. Here we report the identification and analysis of five mutations induced by postmeiotic ENU treatment. One mutation, snh(st1), is a translocation involving linkage group (LG) 11 and LG 14. The other four mutations, oep(st2), kny(st3), Df(LG 13)(st4), and cyc(st5), are deletions, ranging in size from less than 3 cM to greater than 20 cM. These results show that germ cell stage is an important determinant of the type of mutations induced. The induction of chromosomal rearrangements may account for the elevated frequency of specific-locus mutations observed after treatment of postmeiotic gametes with ENU.     

Germ line specific factors in chemical mutagenesis

Chemical mutagenesis test results have not revealed evidence of germ line specific mutagens. However, conventional assays have indicated that there are male-female differences in mutagenic response, as well as quantitative/qualitative differences in induced mutations which depend upon the particular cell stage exposed. Many factors inherent in the germ line can be speculated to influence chemical transport to, and interaction with, target cell populations to result in mutagenic outcomes. The level of uncertainty regarding the general operation of such factors, in combination with the limited availability of chemical test data designed to address comparative somatic and germ cell mutagenesis, leaves open the question of whether there are mutagens specifically affecting germ cells. This argues for a conservative approach to interpreting germ cell risk from somatic cell mutation analysis.     

Induction of specific-locus and dominant lethal mutations in male mice in the low dose range by methyl methanesulfonate (MMS)

Methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) induces specific-locus and dominant lethal mutations in spermatozoa and spermatids of mice. A dose of 15 mg/kg b.w. of MMS induces 9% dominant lethal mutations in the most sensitive germ-cell stages, corresponding to the mating intervals 5-8 and 9-12 days post treatment. A dose of 150 mg/kg b.w. of MMS in the same mating intervals induces 100% dominant lethal mutations. The sensitivity pattern for the induction of dominant lethal and specific-locus mutations is the same. In the mating interval 5-8 days a dose of 20 mg/kg b.w. of MMS induced 3.8 x 10(-5) mutations per locus per gamete. The yield of specific-locus and dominant lethal mutations in the low dose range increases proportionally with the dose. A dose given in 2, 4 or 5 fractions yields the same frequency of mutations as a single injection of the total dose. The additivity of small doses proves that the pre-mutational lesions are not or only partially repaired in these stages and that MMS is not or only partially detoxified. In addition, the frequency of dominant lethal and specific-locus mutations depends on the germ-cell stage.     

The frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations and mutation mosaics in F1 mice derived from post-spermatogonial treatment with ethylnitrosourea

The frequency of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus mutations and mutation mosaics was determined in F1 mice derived from post-spermatogonial germ-cell stage treatment with 2 X 80, 160 or 250 mg/kg ethylnitrosourea. A total of 5 dominant cataract mutations, 3 dominant cataract mutation mosaics, 1 specific-locus mutation and 9 specific-locus mutation mosaics were recovered in 15,542 screened F1 offspring. Results indicate that ethylnitrosourea treatment increases the mutation rate of dominant cataract and recessive specific-locus alleles in post-spermatogonial germ-cell stages of the mouse and that the mutations occur mainly as mosaics. Genetic confirmation of newly induced mutations occurring as mosaics is more problematical for induced recessive alleles than for induced dominant alleles and should be considered when evaluating such mutagenicity results.     

Tests for heritable genetic damage and for evidence of gonadal exposure in mammals

Tests for the induction of genetic damage in mammalian germ cells provide the data needed for human genetic risk assessment and are used as standards for judging the ability of shorter-term tests to predict genetic hazard. In this review, 15 mammalian germ-cell tests and their variants are described. These tests are of two general types: (a) those designed to detect certain classes of genetic damage (gene mutations, chromosome breakage and/or rearrangement, and chromosome mis-segregation), regardless of whether or not the endpoint scored has any significance to human health, and (b) those designed to detect phenotypes that have human health implications, while the nature of the genetic damage is not usually known. Exposure to a mutagenic agent presents no genetic hazard if the chemical or its metabolites fail to reach the reproductive cells. Tests for gonadal exposure are, therefore, important, as preliminaries or components of studies on germ-cell mutagenicity. Seven of these tests and their variants are briefly described in the second part of the paper.     

Unscheduled DNA synthesis in spermatogenic cells of mice treated in vivo with the indirect alkylating agents cyclophosphamide and mitomen

Cyclophosphamide (CPA) and mitomen (DMO) are chemical mutagens that require metabolic activation to produce their biological effect. We have used an in vivo UDS assay in various meiotic and postmeiotic germ-cell stages of male mice to study DNA repair after treatment with these chemicals. EMS, a compound requiring no metabolic activation, was also used for comparative purposes.CPA and DMO induced UDS in meiotic through early-to-midspermatid stages, but no UDS was detected in late spermatids and mature sperm. While EMS produced a maximum UDS response in the germ cells immediately after treatment, CPA and DMO did not produce a maximum response until ～0.5 to 1 h after injection. This delay is attributed to the time required for CPA and DMO to be enzymatically vonverted active alkylating metabolites.Unlike the results found with EMS, mutation frequencies (dominant lethals, translocations, specific-locus mutations) following CPA treatment are not noticeably reduced in germ-cell stages in which UDS occurred. In the case of DMO, mutations are induced only in mature spermatozoa, and these germ-cell stages represent only a fraction of those in which no UDS is detected. The results with CPA and DMO thus still leave unclear the relationship between DNA repair and the differential spermatogenic response of mice to genetic damage.     

Bleomycin, unlike other male-mouse mutagens, is most effective in spermatogonia, inducing primarily deletions

Dominant-lethal tests [P.D. Sudman, J.C. Rutledge, J.B. Bishop, W.M. Generoso, Bleomycin: female-specific dominant lethal effects in mice, Mutat. Res. 296 (1992) 205-217] had suggested that Bleomycin sulfate (Blenoxane), BLM, might be a female-specific mutagen. While confirming that BLM is indeed a powerful inducer of dominant-lethal mutations in females that fails to induce such mutations in postspermatogonial stages of males, we have shown in a specific-locus test that BLM is, in fact, mutagenic in males. This mutagenicity, however, is restricted to spermatogonia (stem-cell and differentiating stages), for which the specific-locus mutation rate differed significantly (P<0.008) from the historical control rate. In treated groups, dominant mutations, also, originated only in spermatogonia. With regard to mutation frequencies, this germ-cell-stage pattern is different from that for radiation and for any other chemical studied to date, except ethylnitrosourea (ENU). However, the nature of the spermatogonial specific-locus mutations differentiates BLM from ENU as well, because BLM induced primarily (or, perhaps, exclusively) multilocus deletions. Heretofore, no chemical that induced specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia did not also induce specific-locus as well as dominant-lethal mutations in postspermatogonial stages, making the dominant lethal test, up till now, predictive of male mutagenicity in general. The BLM results now demonstrate that there are chemicals that can induce specific-locus mutations in spermatogonia without testing positive in postspermatogonial stages. Thus, BLM, while not female-specific, is unique, (a) in its germ-cell-stage specificity in males, and (b) in inducing a type of mutation (deletions) that is atypical for the responding germ-cell stages (spermatogonia).     

Somatic cell mutagenicity in Drosophila melanogaster in comparison with genetic damage in early germ-cell stages

With the intention of assessing the general performance, sensitivity and the underlying mechanisms of somatic cell mutagenicity assays in Drosophila, a study was undertaken to compare the effectiveness of 5 procarcinogens and 4 direct-acting agents in the white/white-coral eye mosaic assay (SMART) with their activity in early (premeiotic) male and female germ-cell stages, after exposure of Drosophila larvae. The outcome indicated a lack of agreement in the results from recessive lethal assays (SLRL) in comparison with the somatic mutation and recombination test (SMART). The procarcinogens 2-naphthylamine (NA), 3-methylcholanthrene (MC), 9,10-dimethylanthracene (DA) and 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA), and the direct-acting mutagens bleomycin (BM), methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) and ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS), were quite efficient in producing somatic recombination and mutations in white/white-coral larvae, as opposed to only weak effects in early germ-cell stages. 2-Acetylaminofluorene (2AAF) showed marginal effects in both germ cells and somatic tissue after exposure of female larvae, but was inactive in testis. The discrepancy in mutational response between somatic cells and premeiotic germ cells is most impressive for MMS and BM. There is sufficient evidence for attributing a good sized proportion of the encountered variation to efficient error-free DNA repair of premutational damage and to segregational elimination during meiosis of deleterious mutations: (1) The efficient point mutagen ENU was the but one agent producing high levels of viable genetic alterations in early germ cells and in somatic cells. A similar behaviour was previously described for diethylnitrosamine, which ethylates DNA in the same fashion as ENU. (2) In early germ-cell stages of mei-9L1 male larvae, MMS induced multiple mutations (putative clusters) at a low dose differing by a factor 20-40 from those needed to produce an equivalent response in repair-competent strains. This is consistent with the concept of an active excision repair in premeiotic cells. (3) In the case of EMS, next to DNA repair, germinal selection seems to restrict the realization of EMS-induced genetic damage in premeiotic cells. (4) Bleomycin-induced chromosome aberrations caused high mortality rates in males (hemizygous for an X-chromosome) but not in females. MMS and BM, agents known to show preference for chromosome aberration induction, produced 3-6-fold higher rates of somatic mutational events (SME) in female genotypes as compared with the other sex.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Ionizing radiation and genetic risks. II. Nature of radiation-induced mutations in experimental mammalian in vivo systems

This paper reviews data on the nature of spontaneous and radiation-induced mutations in the mouse. The data are from studies using a variety of endpoints scorable at the morphological or the biochemical level and include pre-selected as well as unselected loci at which mutations can lead to recessive or dominant phenotypes. The loci used in the morphological recessive specific-locus tests permit the recovery of a wide spectrum of induced changes. Important variables that affect the nature of radiation-induced mutations (assessed primarily using tests for viability of homozygotes) include: germ cell stage, type of irradiation and the locus. Most of the results pertain to irradiated stem cell spermatogonia. The data on morphological specific-locus mutations show that overall, more than two-thirds of the X- or gamma-ray-induced mutations are lethal when homozygous. This proportion may be lower for those that occur spontaneously, but the numbers of tested mutants are small. For spontaneous mutations, there is evidence for the occurrence of mosaics and for proviral insertions. Most or all tested induced enzyme activity variants, dominant visibles (recovered in specific-locus experiments) and dominant skeletal mutations are lethal when homozygous and this is true of 50% of dominant cataract mutations, but again, the numbers of tested mutants are small. Electrophoretic mobility variants, which are known to be due to base-pair changes, are seldom induced by irradiation. At the histocompatibility loci, no radiation-induced mutations have been recovered, presumably because deletions are incompatible with survival even in heterozygotes. All these findings are consistent with the view that in mouse germ cells, most radiation-induced mutations are DNA deletions. Some mutations (in the morphological specific-locus tests) which had previously been inferred to be deletions on the basis of genetic analyses have now been shown to be DNA deletions by molecular methods. However, the possibility cannot be excluded that at least a small proportion of induced mutations may be intragenic changes. The data on the rates of induction of recessive lethals and of dominant skeletal and dominant cataract mutations (and proportions of the latter two which are homozygous lethal) can be used to estimate the proportions of recessive lethals which are expressed as skeletal abnormalities or cataracts. These calculations show that about 10% of recessive lethals manifest themselves as skeletal and less than 0.2% as cataract mutations.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Mutagenic activity of 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine in the mouse spot test.

The base analogue 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine (AHA) was mutagenic in the spot test in (T x HT)F1 mouse embryos. Females were injected with single doses of 20 or 40 mg AHA per kg body weight on the 9th day of pregnancy. To rank the mutagenic potency of different compounds, the frequencies of genetically relevant spots induced by 1 mg/kg body weight were calculated. The observed somatic mutation frequency for 1 mg/kg AHA was lower (1.95 x 10(-3)) spots of genetic relevance) than that of mitomycin C (16 x 10(-3)), ethylnitrosourea (6.8 x 10(-3)) and cyclophosphamide (6.4 x 10(-3)) and therefore AHA was not classified as a very potent mutagen in this test system. The doubling dose to induce genetically relevant spots was calculated to be 20 mg/kg b.w. Based on these data, AHA is suggested to be a candidate to induce recessive specific-locus mutations in germ cells of mice.