Inability of interferon to protect virus-infected cells against lysis by natural killer (NK) cells correlates with NK cell-mediated antiviral effects in vivo

Murine cytomegalovirus (MCMV) is a natural killer (NK) cell-sensitive virus, whereas lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) is an NK cell-resistant virus. Selective depletion of NK cell activity by injection of mice with anti-asialo GM1 antibody enhanced synthesis of MCMV but not that of LCMV when mice were simultaneously infected with the two viruses. This suggests that the NK cell-mediated antiviral effects may depend on target cell susceptibility to NK cell-mediated lysis rather than the ability of a virus to induce a specialized antiviral NK cell. In support of this concept, activated NK cells isolated from either MCMV- or LCMV-infected mice had similar patterns of killing against all targets tested. Mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEF) infected with MCMV were less sensitive to lysis by activated NK cells than either uninfected or LCMV-infected MEF. However, when MEF were pretreated with IFN, activated NK cell-mediated lysis against MCMV-infected MEF was undiminished and was much higher (up to fourfold) than that against uninfected MEF, whose sensitivity to lysis was almost totally abolished by IFN pretreatment. LCMV-infected MEF were also protected by IFN against activated NK cell-mediated lysis. During infection, the virus-induced IFN may protect uninfected and LCMV-infected cells from IFN-activated, NK cell-mediated lysis, but MCMV-infected cells may remain sensitive to lysis. This could explain how NK cells play a role in resistance to MCMV but not LCMV.     

Purification and target cell range of in vivo elicited blast natural killer cells

Blast natural killer (NK) cells were elicited in the spleens of mice by treatments with the interferon inducers lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) or polyinosinic-polycytidylic acid (poly I:C). The blast-NK cells, separated on the basis of size by centrifugal elutriation, were compared with blast cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) generated during infection with LCMV. In vivo treatments with antibody to asialo GM1 (AGM1) blocked the appearance of blast-NK cells but not blast-CTL. Antibody and complement depletion experiments indicated that the blast-NK cells were AGM1+, NK 1.2+/-, Lyt-5+/-, Thy+/-, Qa-5/NK 1.1+, Lyt-2-, B23.1-, and J11d-. Blast-NK cells could be unequivocally distinguished from blast-CTL, because the blast-CTL were completely sensitive to treatments with anti-Lyt-2 and complement, whereas the blast-NK cells were completely resistant. The blast-NK cells were purified from populations of large-size cells by antibody and complement treatments that depleted the co-eluting monocyte/macrophages and polymorphonuclear leukocytes. The population resulting after separation from dead cells over Percoll gradients represented approximately 1% of the total spleen cells, contained greater than 60% large granular lymphocytes and mediated greater than 15% killing of YAC-1 target cells in a 4-hr 51Cr release assay at an effector to target cell ratio of 1:1. The purified blast-NK cells lysed a broad range of target cells at relatively low effector to target cell ratios. The order of sensitivity of the target cells was YAC-1 much greater than K562 approximately equal to L-929 much greater than P815, consistent with that reported for NK cell-mediated lysis. The ability of the blast-NK cells to mediate lysis of NK cells also was examined. The purified NK cells mediated significant levels of lysis against the NK-like cloned line, NK1B6B10, in a 51Cr release assay. Furthermore, the purified blast-NK cells mediated lysis of bound blast-NK cells in a single-cell agarose assay. These results indicate that highly purified blast-NK cells are exceptionally efficient at mediating lysis and suggest that NK cells may act to negatively regulate the proliferation of NK cells by lysing other NK cells.     

Elevated natural killer cell-mediated cytotoxicity, plasma interferon, and tumor cell rejection in mice persistently infected with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus

To assess the effects of chronic virus infection on NK cells, the related phenomena of interferon (IFN) production, NK cell activation, and resistance to tumor implants were studied in mice persistently infected with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV). NK cells from these LCMV-carrier mice displayed augmented killing of the NK-sensitive YAC-1 target cell. They did not lyse the more resistant targets L-929 and P815, whereas NK cells from acutely infected mice efficiently lysed all three cell types. The plasma from LCMV-carrier mice contained an antiviral substance identified as IFN type I, based on species specificity, virus nonspecificity, resistance to pH 2, and sensitivity to antibody to type I IFN. IFN titers in plasma from LCMV-carrier mice were 32 to 64 U/ml, about 20-fold less than those in acutely infected mice. Both the IFN and NK cell levels continuously remained elevated in the LCMV carrier mice up to at least 6 months of age. IFN is known to activate NK cells and to induce their blastogenesis in vivo. As determined by centrifugal elutriation, large NK blast-size cells were isolated from the spleens of acutely infected mice, but not from either normal or LCMV-carrier mice, suggesting augmented NK cell-mediated lysis in the absence of enhanced proliferation. Poly inosinic-cytidylic acid induced high levels of NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity and blastogenesis in both control and LCMV-carrier mice, but IFN was induced to lower levels in carriers as compared with controls. Coincidental with augmented NK cell activity, the LCMV-carrier mice rejected intravenously injected 125IUdR-labeled tumor cells more efficiently than did normal mice. Thus, LCMV carrier mice have low levels of type I IFN, moderately augmented NK cell activity lasting for at least 6 months, and increased resistance to tumor cell implants. This indicates that augmented NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity can be maintained in vivo over prolonged periods of time in the presence of chronic low-level IFN stimulation.     

Effect of altered membrane structure on NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity. II. Conversion of NK-resistant tumor cells into NK-sensitive targets upon fusion with liposomes containing NK-sensitive membranes

There is a large body of evidence that supports the notion that NK cells exert important immune surveillance functions in vivo, against a variety of virus-infected and neoplastic cells. However, certain targets are not susceptible to lysis by NK cells. The exact mechanism by which resistance or sensitivity is conferred on target cells is not known. We investigated whether the selectivity to NK lysis is a property of the membrane of the target cell. This was examined by the application of a recently developed method which is aimed at changing the membrane structure of the target cell by cell-liposome fusion. Our studies demonstrate that NK-resistant tumor cells acquired sensitivity to lysis by NK cells after fusion with reconstituted vesicles which contained membrane components derived from NK-sensitive target cells. The fusion required the presence of Sendai virus envelope glycoproteins and exogenous lipids (soybean lecithin and cholesterol) for maximal efficiency. This finding was demonstrated in both the human system (with U937 and Raji as NK-sensitive and -resistant cell lines, respectively) and the rat/murine system (with YAC-1 as NK-sensitive target and P815 and YAC-asc as NK-resistant targets). Both the 51Cr-release assay and the single cell assay showed lysis of the modified target cells in a 3-hr incubation period. The magnitude of the cytotoxic activity was found to depend on the concentration of reconstituted vesicles used in the fusion step. The effect seen was specific because target cells were not lysed when fused with vesicles which contained membrane constituents derived from either NK-resistant targets or NK-sensitive targets from another species (human vs mouse). The resistance of modified target cells to lysis by xenogeneic NK cells was not due to failure of membrane fusion, as detected by immunofluorescence, or to failure to form conjugates. These results demonstrate the feasibility of converting a resistant NK target to a sensitive target by cell-liposome fusion. Furthermore, the data indicate that susceptibility to lysis by NK cells is a property of the membrane composition of the target cell. The significance of these findings is discussed.     

Antiviral effect of lymphokine-activated killer cells: characterization of effector cells mediating prophylaxis

Lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells generated by cultivation of C57BL/6 mouse spleen cells in the presence of recombinant interleukin-2 were transferred into natural killer (NK) cell-deficient suckling mouse recipients. These mice were then challenged with either murine cytomegalovirus (MCMV) or lymphocytic choriomeningitis (LCMV) and sacrificed 3 days later. No interleukin 2 infusions were given. Mice receiving as few as 5 x 10(5) LAK cells had several 100-fold decreases in spleen MCMV titers as compared with untreated mice. This treatment had no effect on spleen LCMV titers. The LAK cell cultures contained 10 to 17% NK 1.1+, 50 to 55% Lyt-2+, and 33 to 50% immunoglobulin D+ cells. Double fluorescence labeling and in vitro cytotoxicity assays with fluorescence-activated cell sorting revealed at least two mutually exclusive killer cell populations. NK 1.1+ LAK cells resembled freshly isolated activated NK cells with regard to target cell range (YAC-1 cell killing greater than L-929, P815, and EL-4 cell killing), large granular lymphocyte (LGL) morphology, and decreased ability to lyse interferon (IFN)-treated target cells. Lyt-2+ LAK cells lysed the targets mentioned above but at lower levels and without the differences in susceptibility mentioned above. These Lyt-2+ LAK cells also had a decreased ability to lyse IFN-treated targets, in contrast to classic cytotoxic T lymphocytes, which lyse IFN-treated targets far more efficiently than untreated targets. Purified populations of LAK cells obtained by fluorescence-activated cell sorting were used in the antiviral protection model. The results showed that protection against MCMV could be mediated by NK 1.1+, NK 1.1-, Lyt-2+, Lyt-2-, and IgD- populations but not by IgD+ cells. The five protective populations all had in common the LGL phenotype and cytotoxic activity in vitro. The IgD+ population did not contain LGLs, lyse target cells in vitro, or mediate an antiviral effect in vivo. These results suggest that LAK cells may be therapeutically useful against certain virus infections (MCMV) but not others (LCMV) and that despite their heterogeneity in antigenic phenotype and cytotoxic activity, their pattern of antiviral activity in vivo resembles that of NK cells, which protect against MCMV but not LCMV.     

The virus-specific and allospecific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus is modified in a subpopulation of CD8(+) T cells coexpressing the inhibitory major histocompatibility complex class I receptor Ly49G2

The role of negatively signaling NK cell receptors of the Ly49 family on the specificity of the acute CD8(+) cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response was investigated in lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-infected C57BL/6 mice. Activated CD8(+) T cells coexpressing Ly49G2 expanded during LCMV infection, and T-cell receptor analyses by flow cytometry and CDR3 spectratyping revealed a unique polyclonal T-cell population in the Ly49G2(+) fraction. These cells lysed syngeneic targets infected with LCMV or coated with two of three LCMV immunodominant peptides examined. Transfection of these sensitive targets with H2D(d), a ligand for Ly49G2, inhibited lysis. This was reversed by antibody to Ly49G2, indicating effective negative signaling. LCMV characteristically induces an anti-H2(d) allospecific T-cell response that includes T-cell clones cross-reactive between allogeneic and LCMV-infected syngeneic targets. The CD8(+) Ly49G2(+) population mediated no allospecific killing, nor was any NK-like killing observed against YAC-1 cells. This study shows that CD8(+) Ly49G2(+) cells participate in the virus-induced CTL response but lyse a more restricted range of targets than the rest of the virus-induced CTL population.     

An oligosaccharide biosynthetic defect in concanavalin A-resistant Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells that enhances NK reactivity in vitro and in vivo

We have examined a concanavalin A-resistant (Con AR) Chinese hamster ovary cell (CR-7) that has a defect in the synthesis of asparagine-linked oligosaccharides and consequently an altered expression of membrane carbohydrate. The CR-7 mutant, which has a decreased ability to incorporate mannose into oligolipid and membrane glycoprotein and an increased membrane fucose, was more sensitive to natural killer (NK) cell lysis than the parental wild type (CHO-WT). Splenocytes mediating the lysis of the CR-7 line were asialo GM1+, nonadherent, IFN stimulatable, absent in the bg/bg mutant, and co-fractionated on Percoll density gradients with cells mediating lysis of the YAC-1 murine lymphoma. The increase in NK lysis correlated with enhanced binding of NK cells to the mutant determined by adsorption on tumor monolayers, cold target inhibition, and target binding analysis. A revertant of CR-7 (RCR-7), which showed wild-type levels of NK lysis, was intermediate in its ability to bind or cold target inhibit NK cells. The CR-7, CHO-WT, and RCR-7 lines were equally sensitive to hypotonic lysis and cytotoxicity by human lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells suggesting that the mutation did not nonspecifically alter membrane fragility. The NK-sensitive CR-7 line was less tumorigenic after subcutaneous injection in nude mice when compared with the parental CHO-WT or RCR-7 lines. This decreased tumorigenicity could be reversed by the i.v. injection of antiserum directed at the NK cell determinant asialo GM1. In conclusion, a ConAR tumor cell with a demonstrable oligosaccharide biosynthetic defect, exhibited enhanced NK lytic sensitivity and was poorly tumorigenic in vivo, a feature which may also be a consequence of its altered NK reactivity.     

Murine trophoblast can be killed by lymphokine-activated killer cells

The ability of fetal trophoblast cells in the placenta to resist cell-mediated lysis may be important for successful pregnancy. Previous studies in this laboratory demonstrated that cultured midterm mouse trophoblast cells are not susceptible to allospecific CTL generated by standard in vitro protocols, to antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity, or to naive or IFN-activated NK cells, despite expressing the requisite target structures. However, we now report that murine trophoblast can be killed, in a non-MHC-specific manner, by LAK cells. Normal mouse spleen cells cultured for 4 days in IL-2-containing lymphokine preparations characteristically killed both NK-sensitive (YAC-1) and NK-resistant (EL4, P815) target cells, and mediated significant lysis of both cultured and freshly isolated trophoblast cells (35 to 55%, E/T 100/1). Pretreatment of the LAK cells with anti-ASGM1 antibody and C markedly reduced the lysis of trophoblast and YAC-1 targets, suggesting that the responsible cells belonged to the NK lineage. The ability of IL-2-activated NK cells to kill midterm murine trophoblast cells was confirmed using a population of highly lytic NK cells generated by culturing spleen cells from severe combined immunodeficiency mice in 500 U/ml rIL-2 for 5 days. These effector cells killed YAC-1, EL4 and P815 target cells at much lower E/T ratios than was achieved with the normal splenic LAK cells, and mediated significant lysis of both freshly isolated (45 to 50%, E/T 20/1) and cultured trophoblast cells (68 to 76%, E/T 20/1). The susceptibility of trophoblast to LAK cells and IL-2-activated NK cells supports the need for suppressor mechanisms regulating IL-2 activity at the maternal-fetal interface.     

Natural killer cells vs cytotoxic T cells in the peripheral blood of virus-infected mice

The cell-mediated immune response of mice against various enveloped RNA and DNA viruses expressed by immune lymphocytes from the spleen and the peripheral blood (PBL) were compared. PBL from mice of various strains infected with vaccinia virus, vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), or lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV) were tested on histocompatible or incompatible target cells infected with the homologous virus. PBL from immune mice showed clear H-2 restriction, but additionally, they expressed high natural killing (NK) activity on YAC-1 cells. The high NK-cytolytic activity of PBL on YAC-1 differed significantly from that expressed by splenic lymphocytes. In both lymphocyte populations lysis was detected as early as 1 day after infection; NK activity decreased in the spleen after day 4 post infection, whereas that of PBL persisted at high levels for up to 10 days after infection. Treatment of mice with anti-asialo GM1 in vivo abrogated NK activity in PBL effector cells tested in vitro. These results may explain some of the difficulties to observe MHC-restricted cytotoxic T cells in PBL from humans or primates during primary infections with virus.     

Functional defects of NK cells treated with chloroquine mimic the lytic defects observed in perforin-deficient mice

NK cells are the primary effectors mediating acute rejection of incompatible bone marrow cell grafts. To reduce rejection, we evaluated the ability of chloroquine (CHQ) to prevent perforin-dependent NK cell activity. Perforin is a key cytotoxic component released from the lytic granules of activated NK cells. Generation of functional perforin requires an acidic protease activity that occurs in the secretory, lytic lysosomes. Our hypothesis was that CHQ, a lysosomotropic reagent, would raise the pH of the acidic compartment in which perforin is processed and thereby block perforin maturation and cytotoxicity. We have measured NK cytotoxicity in vivo by clearance of YAC-1 tumor cells from the lungs and by rejection of incompatible bone marrow transplants and in vitro by cytolysis of YAC-1 and Jurkat cells. The engraftment of bone marrow cells was monitored by recolonization of the spleen with hemopoietic cells from transplants of MHC class I-deficient bone marrow cells into lethally irradiated recipient mice. Transplant rejection was compared in two inbred strains of mice: 129, which apparently use perforin-dependent cytotoxicity, and C57BL/6, in which rejection can be perforin-independent. CHQ treatment reduced NK cell activity in 129 mice in which perforin is important for mediating rejection. CHQ affected the fraction of NK cell cytolysis that was Fas independent. In addition, we found that CHQ prevents perforin processing by LAK cells in vitro. These data indicate that CHQ may impair rejection of incompatible bone marrow transplants and other functions mediated by NK and cytotoxic T cells.     

Natural cytotoxicity against mouse hepatitis virus-infected target cells. I. Correlation of cytotoxicity with virus binding to leukocytes

Spleen cells from uninfected control mice selectively lysed BALB/c 3T3 fibroblasts infected with mouse hepatitis virus (MHV), a murine coronavirus. Lysis of infected cells occurred within 3 hr, and histocompatibility between effector and target cells was not required. This natural, cell-mediated, virus-associated cytotoxicity differed from NK cell- and T cell-mediated lysis. Spleen cells from animals infected with MHV were enriched in NK activity and were more cytotoxic to YAC-1 target cells, but did not show enhanced cytotoxicity for MHV-infected target cells. Spleen cells from beige mice, which are deficient in NK cell activity, were able to lyse MHV-infected target cells, as were spleen cells from nude mice, which are deficient in T cell activity. Lysis of MHV-infected target cells could be mediated by cells from the spleen and, to a lesser extent, by cells from the bone marrow, but not by resident peritoneal cells or thymocytes. We suggest the term "virus killer (VK) activity" for this phenomenon. VK activity of splenocytes from different mouse strains correlated with the ability of the splenocytes to bind purified radiolabeled MHV virions. MHV virions caused agglutination of spleen leukocytes from susceptible mouse strains, indicating that leukocyte agglutination or adsorption may provide a useful assay for coronaviruses such as MHV which lack hemagglutinating activity. SJL mouse splenocytes did not bind MHV and did not lyse infected targets. MHV bound relatively well to splenocytes of other mouse strains, but poorly to thymocytes and erythrocytes. Binding of MHV to leukocytes was not influenced by 6 mM EDTA or EGTA, indicating a lack of requirement for Mg++ or Ca++. VK activity was also resistant to EDTA and EGTA, in contrast to NK activity, which was sensitive to those chelating agents. VK activity was also unaffected by actinomycin D, cycloheximide, or puromycin, indicating that new protein synthesis was not required for lysis. Antibody to interferon-alpha/beta did not block lysis, nor was there substantially enhanced lysis mediated by leukocytes from mice infected with virus and thus exposed to high levels of interferon. VK activity was blocked by antibody directed against the peplomeric glycoprotein E2 of MHV. VK activity required infected target cells, because cells with adsorbed MHV virions were not lysed by splenocytes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Transfection of beta 2-microglobulin restores IFN-mediated protection from natural killer cell lysis in YAC-1 lymphoma variants

A beta 2-microglobulin (beta 2m)-deficient variant of YAC-1, A.H-2-, was transfected with a genomic beta 2m clone. Transfected cells were used to investigate the role of beta 2m in IFN-induced protection from NK cell lysis. IFN-gamma treatment of the NK-sensitive murine YAC-1 lymphoma results in reduced sensitivity to NK cell-mediated lysis in parallel with increased expression of its constitutively low MHC class I expression. It was previously shown that the A.H-2- variant had lost both these capacities, although it retained other responses to IFN-gamma. Here beta 2m transfection restored the YAC-1 phenotype with respect to an inducible expression of MHC class I molecules and a concomitant protection from NK cell lysis after treatment with IFN-gamma. In the absence of IFN-gamma the NK sensitivity of the transfectants did not differ significantly from A.H-2-. A similar protection from NK cell lysis, in parallel with enhanced MHC class I expression, was observed for in vivo-passaged beta 2m transfectants whereas no protection was found for in vivo-passaged A.H-2- cells. The present study provides evidence that the IFN-gamma-mediated protection from NK cell lysis is dependent on beta 2m expression in the YAC-1 lymphoma. Restoration of MHC class I assembly, transport, and concomitantly an IFN-gamma augmentable cell surface expression of MHC class I molecules is a possible explanation for the effect of beta 2m.     

Peptide mapping of the epitope on target cells recognized by nonspecific cytotoxic cells (NCC) from channel catfish

Nonspecific cytotoxic cells (NCC) may comprise an important effector population specific for recognition of aberrant (tumour) cells, regulation of cell interactions including antibacterial action and lysis of protozoan parasites. In the present study, peptides were synthesized based on the amino acid sequence of a novel protein (Natural Killer cell Target Antigen, NK Tag) found on the protozoan parasite Tetrahymena pyriformis and on NCC-sensitive tumour target cells. Partially purified NK Tag was obtained from Tetrahymena. It inhibited NCC lysis of a large variety of mammalian tumour target cells. Synthetic peptides composed of short 20 mer sequences obtained from the N-terminal and midregion portions of NK Tag were tested for their ability to inhibit NCC cytotoxicity. Synthetic peptide comprised of aa # 55-74 significantly inhibited NCC lysis of IM-9 target cells. A monoclonal antibody generated against an N-terminal dodecapeptide of NK Tag bound to Tetrahymena and to several mammalian NK-sensitive target cells including K562, YAC-1, U937, NC-37, EL-4, IM-9, HL-60 and MOLT-4. NK Tag sequence comparisons using Swisspro database revealed no significant homologies except in a restricted domain region of several glycolytic pathway enzymes. A supergene family relationship was indicated because of these similarities.     

Selective loss of natural killer T cells by apoptosis following infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus

Natural killer T (NKT) cells, a unique subpopulation of T cells, coexpress markers also present on NK cells and recognize the major histocompatibility complex class I-like CD1d1 molecule. We studied the effect of an acute virus infection on NKT cells. Mice were infected with the nonhepatotropic Armstrong strain of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV), and at various times postinfection, mononuclear cells from the liver, peritoneum, and spleen were isolated. It was found that within 2 to 3 days, there was a selective loss of NKT cells from the liver with an apparent rapid recovery within 8 to 14 days. There was no increase in peritoneal or splenic NKT cells, indicating that NKT cells did not traffic to these tissues. This loss of NKT cells was independent of gamma interferon (IFN-gamma) and interleukin 12 (IL-12) production, but did occur in mice treated with poly(I-C), a classical inducer of IFN-alpha/beta. The reduction in NKT cells was CD28 and fas/fasL independent and occurred via apoptosis. It was not observed in LCMV-infected DNA fragmentation factor 45-deficient mice, and an increase in active caspase 3-specific staining was found in liver NKT cells from LCMV-infected and poly(I-C)-treated mice compared to uninfected wild-type mice. Interestingly, it was also found that liver NKT cells from LCMV-infected mice were themselves infected. These results suggest that the loss of NKT cells following an acute LCMV infection could be due to the induction of IFN-alpha/beta resulting in NKT-cell apoptosis and is important for the host's immune response to LCMV.     

Studies on the mechanism of natural killer cell-mediated cytotoxicity. V. Lack of NK specificity at the level of induction of natural killer cytotoxic factors in cultures of human, murine, or rat effector cells stimulated with mycoplasma-free cell lines

We have proposed that lysis of target cells by NK cells is mediated by NK cytotoxic factors (NKCF). According to our model, for a target cell to be NK-sensitive, it must be recognized by the NK cell, it must stimulate the release of NKCF, and it must be sensitive to lysis by these factors. This report examines whether the ability to stimulate release of NKCF is a characteristic restricted to NK-sensitive tumor cells or whether it is also a property of NK-resistant target cells. Many different types of cell lines were tested for their ability to stimulate release of NKCF in the human, rat, and murine systems. It was found that mycoplasma-free NK-sensitive cell lines, resistant cell lines, and Con A could stimulate the release of NKCF. Many different types of cell lines grown in suspension or in monolayers were found to be effective stimulators, including T or B lymphoid, myeloid, and those of histiocytic origin. Cells cultured in the absence of serum stimulated NKCF release, thus ruling out the possible involvement of serum components in stimulation. NKCF was also produced by xenogeneic combinations of effector and stimulator cells, demonstrating lack of species specificity in NKCF production. Factors stimulated by NK-resistant cell lines or by Con A exhibited the same NK target specificity as supernatants stimulated by NK-sensitive tumor cells. The finding that many different NK-resistant cell lines can stimulate the release of NKCF indicates that there is no apparent NK specificity at the level of induction of NKCF release from human, rat, or murine effector cells. Therefore, the NK specificity of a target cell is determined ultimately by its sensitivity to lysis by NKCF.     

Natural killer cell activity in murine muscular dystrophy. III. NK-sensitive myoblast cells and lack of NK activity in beige/dystrophic hybrid mice

The NK-susceptibility of dystrophic mouse myoblast cells was investigated. Spleen cells from 8- to 10-week-old normal (+/+) and dystrophic (dy2J/dy2J) male C57BL/6J mice were fractionated on Percoll density gradients and the cells at each density interface were incubated with either 51Cr-labeled YAC-1 or myoblast cells in a 6 hr 51Cr-release assay. Myoblast target cells were obtained from either heterozygous (+/dy2J) or homozygous (dy2J/dy2J) muscle cultures or a transformed tetraploid myoblast line (M14D2). The data indicate that the interface between the 50 and 60% (1.060-1.075 g/ml) Percoll density fractions of spleen cells from either normal or dystrophic mice contains the largest proportion of asialo GM-1 positive and NK-1 positive cells displaying NK activity. Myoblast cells from either heterozygous (phenotypically normal) or homozygous dystrophic mice were not significantly different in susceptibility to NK-mediated lysis by Percoll enriched normal or dystrophic mouse NK cells. However, dystrophic mouse spleen cells had the highest NK activity against both myoblast targets as compared with normal mouse spleen cells. The transformed myoblast cell line, M14D2, was significantly less susceptible to NK-mediated lysis by dystrophic mouse spleen cells when compared with freshly cultured myoblast target cells. Target cell binding studies revealed that conjugate forming cells from the 50% Percoll density interface of dystrophic mouse spleen cells were approximately twofold greater than that of normal mouse spleen cells against either heterozygous or homozygous dystrophic mouse myoblast targets. Cold target inhibition studies revealed that the natural killing of dystrophic mouse myoblast cells was due to a YAC-1 reactive NK cell. Breeding experiments between C57BL/6J homozygous "beige" (bgJ/bgJ) mutant mice and dystrophic (dy2J/dy2J) mice produced beige/dystrophic hybrid mice which displayed clinical symptoms of the dystrophy process by 3 to 4 weeks of age. Spleen cells from these hybrid mice showed no significant differences in NK activity against YAC-1 target cells when compared with homozygous beige mice. Taken together, these results demonstrate the first reported evidence that murine myoblasts are susceptible to NK-mediated lysis. In addition, the data indicate that although dystrophic mouse NK cells recognize myoblast cells as targets, the NK cell studies with the beige/dystrophic hybrid mice do not indicate a direct in vivo role for NK cells in the dystrophy process.     

Enhanced natural killer (NK) cell activity and NK-sensitive thymic cells in murine muscular dystrophy

Studies have shown that there is an abnormality in the thymus of dystrophic mice with respect to age-dependent thymus weight changes and altered morphology (T. DeKretser and B. Livett, Nature (London), 263, 682, 1976). Recently, others have shown that natural killer (NK) cells can lyse cells of a large, immature, rapidly dividing cell subpopulation within the thymus of normal young (3 weeks of age) mice (M. Hansson, K. Karre, R. Kiessling, J. Roder, B. Anderson, and P. Hayry, J. Immunol., 123, 765, 1979). The NK susceptibility of dystrophic mouse thymocytes as targets was therefore studied. Spleen cells from normal (+/+) and dystrophic ($\text{dy}{}^{\mathrm{2J}}\text{dy}{}^{\mathrm{2J}}$) male C57BL/6J mice 8–10 weeks old were passed over nylon wool and the nonadherent cells were incubated with ⁵¹Cr-labeled YAC-1 lymphoma target cells or thymocytes in a ⁵¹Cr-release assay. Spleen cells from dystrophic mice killed twofold more YAC-1 target cells than did spleen cells from normal mice. Thymocytes from 3- to 4-week-old dystrophic mice were three to four times more susceptible to NK lysis by dystrophic mouse spleen cells as compared with normal mouse spleen cells. Spleen cells from dystrophic mice had the same NK activity against dystrophic and normal mouse thymocytes as targets. Normal mouse spleen cells killed three- to fourfold more dystrophic mouse thymocytes than that of normal mouse thymocytes as targets. Target cellbinding studies revealed that conjugate-forming cells from nylon nonadherent dystrophic mouse spleen cells were found to be two- to fourfold greater than for normal mouse spleen cells using YAC-1 tumor cells as targets. The number of lymphocytes bound per YAC-1 target cell ranged from 2 to 5 for dystrophic mouse spleen cells as compared with 1 to 2 for the normal control group. Using both normal and dystrophic mouse thymocytes as targets, the conjugate-forming cells from dystrophic mouse spleen cells were also found to be twofold greater than in the normal control group. Cold target inhibition studies revealed that the natural killing of dystrophic mouse thymocytes was due to a YAC-1-reactive NK cell. Effector cell depletion studies using monoclonal anti-Thy-1.2 plus complement treatment and plastic petri dish adherence also revealed that the natural killing of dystrophic mouse thymocytes was not due to either T lymphocytes or macrophages. Taken together, these results show an increase in NK-sensitive thymocyte targets in dystrophic mice, in combination with an increase in splenic NK activity.     

Enhanced lysis of herpes simplex virus type 1-infected mouse cell lines by NC and NK effectors

Spontaneously cytotoxic murine lymphocytes lysed certain cell types infected by herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) better than uninfected cells. The levels of virus-directed lysis varied widely from target to target, and we found that differences in virus-directed lytic efficiency could be attributed both to the characteristics of HSV-1 replication in the different targets and to the subgroup of natural effector cells which mediated lysis. Although HSV-1 adsorbed to the surface of all the target cells, those in which the virus replicated more efficiently were lysed to a greater extent. As targets, we used cell lines that, when uninfected, were spontaneously lysed by NK cells (YAC-1) or by NC cells (WEHI-164). We also used a fibroblastoid cell line (M50) and a monocytic tumor line (PU51R), which were not spontaneously killed. Using complement-mediated elimination of Qa-5-positive or asialo-GM1-positive NK cells to distinguish NK from NC activity, we found that NK cells lysed HSV-1-infected YAC cells better than uninfected cells, and an NC-like activity selectively lysed HSV-1-infected WEHI cells. In addition, we showed that both NK and NC cytotoxicities contributed to the lysis against the HSV-1-infected fibroblastoid line, M50, but the infected PU51R cells were killed by only NK effectors. These findings were consistent with the results of experiments performed to define the role of interferon in induction of virus-augmented cytolysis. Increased lysis of YAC-HSV and PU51R-HSV was entirely due to interferon activation and was completely abolished by performing the 51Cr-release assay in the presence of anti-interferon serum. Because NC activity was not augmented by interferon, virus-enhanced NC lysis of M50-HSV and WEHI-HSV was not due to this nonspecific mechanism. Together, our data show that HSV-1 infection of NK/NC targets induces increased cytotoxicity, but the effector cell responsible for lysis is determined by the uninfected target, or by an interaction between the virus and target cell, rather than by a viral determinant alone.     

Tumorigenicity of persistently infected tumors in nude mice is a function of both virus and host cell type.

Although BHK-21 cells persistently infected with wild-type vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) are sensitive to natural killer (NK) cells and do not form tumors in athymic nude mice, BHK-21 cells persistently infected with a previously isolated mutant virus (VSV-P) are resistant to NK cells and form tumors in nude mice. We used this VSV-P mutant to persistently infect HeLa cells and mouse tumor cell lines. A mouse mastocytoma line (P815) persistently infected with VSV-P was similar to BHK-21 cells in that it was resistant to NK cell lysis and formed tumors in nude mice. However, neither HeLa cells nor mouse myeloma lines persistently infected with VSV-P were resistant to NK cell lysis in vitro, and neither formed tumors in nude mice. Rejection by nude mice of HeLa cells and mouse myeloma cell lines persistently infected with VSV-P could be ablated by rabbit antiserum to asialo-GM1, implicating NK cells in the in vivo rejection of these persistently infected tumors. These results suggest that NK cell recognition and killing of virus-infected cells in vivo and in vitro depend upon genetic contributions from both the virus and the host cell.     

Differences in target cell DNA fragmentation induced by mouse cytotoxic T lymphocytes and natural killer cells

Fragmentation of YAC-1 target cell DNA during cytolysis mediated by mouse natural killer (NK) cells and cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) was compared. Cleavage of nuclear chromatin was always an extensive and early event in CTL-mediated cytolysis, whereas with NK cell-mediated killing the degree of DNA fragmentation showed an unexpected relationship to the effector:target (E:T) ratio. At low NK:YAC-1 ratios, DNA fragmentation and 51Cr release were equivalent and increased proportionately until a ratio of about 50:1 was reached; at higher ratios, 51Cr release increased as expected but DNA fragmentation decreased dramatically. Comparison of time course data at E:T ratios producing similar rates of 51Cr release showed that the target cell DNA fragmentation observed in NK killing was not nearly as rapid nor as extensive as that observed with CTL effectors. These results suggest that NK cells induce target cell injury via two different mechanisms. One mechanism would involve lysis mediated by cell-to-cell contact, while the other may induce DNA fragmentation via a soluble mediator. In support of this notion, cell-free culture supernatants containing NK cytotoxic factor (NKCF) induced DNA fragmentation in YAC-1 cells. The DNA fragments induced by NK cells and NKCF-containing supernatants consisted of oligonucleosomes indistinguishable from those induced by CTL. The results presented here show distinct differences in target cell DNA fragmentation induced by CTL and NK cells, and suggest that these two effectors use different mechanisms to achieve the same end. CTL seem to induce DNA fragmentation in their targets by direct signaling, whereas NK cells may do so by means of a soluble factor.