A Role for Auxin in Triggering Lamina Outgrowth of Unifacial Leaves

A common morphological feature of typical angiosperms is the patterning of lateral organs along primary axes of asymmetry—a proximodistal, a mediolateral, and an adaxial–abaxial axis. Angiosperm leaves usually have distinct adaxial–abaxial identity, which is required for the development of a flat shape. By contrast, many unifacial leaves, consisting of only the abaxial side, show a flattened morphology. This implicates a unique mechanism that allows leaf flattening independent of adaxial–abaxial identity. In this study, we report a role for auxin in outgrowth of unifacial leaves. In two closely related unifacial-leaved species of Juncaceae, Juncus prismatocarpus with flattened leaves, and Juncus wallichianus with transversally radialized leaves, the auxin-responsive gene GLYCOSIDE HYDROLASE3 displayed spatially different expression patterns within leaf primordia. Treatment of J. prismatocarpus seedlings with exogenous auxin or auxin transport inhibitors, which disturb endogenous auxin distribution, eliminated leaf flatness, resulting in a transversally radialized morphology. These treatments did not affect the radialized morphology of leaves of J. wallichianus. Moreover, elimination of leaf flatness by these treatments accompanied dysregulated expression of genetic factors needed to specify the leaf central-marginal polarity in J. prismatocarpus. The findings imply that lamina outgrowth of unifacial leaves relies on proper placement of auxin, which might induce initial leaf flattening and subsequently act to specify leaf polarity, promoting further flattening growth of leaves.

Lamina outgrowth of unifacial leaves, which lack adaxial identity, relies on proper localization of auxin, which might induce initial leaf flattening and subsequently act to specify leaf polarity, promoting further flattening growth of leaves.     

Evolutionary and developmental studies of unifacial leaves in monocots: Juncus as a model system

An important objective in evolutionary developmental biology is to understand the molecular genetic mechanisms that have given rise to morphological diversity. Leaves in angiosperms generally develop as a flattened structure with clear adaxial–abaxial polarity. In monocots, however, a unifacial leaf has evolved in a number of divergent species, in which leaf blades consist of only the abaxial identity. The mechanism of unifacial leaf development has long been a matter of debate for comparative morphologists. However, the underlying molecular genetic mechanism remains unknown. Unifacial leaves would be useful materials for developmental studies of leaf-polarity specification. Moreover, these leaves offer unique opportunities to investigate important phenomena in evolutionary biology, such as repeated evolution or convergent evolution of similar morphological traits. Here we describe the potential of unifacial leaves for evolutionary developmental studies and present our recent approaches to understanding the mechanisms of unifacial leaf development and evolution using Juncus as a model system.     

Developmental events leading to peltate leaf structure in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Tropaeolum majus</Emphasis> (Tropaeolaceae) are associated with expression domain changes of a YABBY gene

Peltate leaf architecture has evolved from conventional bifacial leaves many times in flowering plant evolution. Characteristics of peltate leaves, such as the differentiation of a cross zone and of a radially symmetric, margin-less petiole, have also been observed in mutants of genes responsible for adaxial-abaxial polarity establishment. This suggests that altered regulation of such genes provided a mechanism for the evolution of peltate leaf structure. Here, we show that evolution of leaf peltation in Tropaeolum majus, a species distantly related to Arabidopsis thaliana, was associated with altered expression of Tropaeolum majus FILAMENTOUS FLOWER (TmFIL), a gene conferring abaxial identity. In situ hybridization indicates that adaxial and abaxial domains are established in early leaf primordia as in species with bifacial leaves. Upon initiation of the cross zone by fusion of the blade margins, localized expansion of TmFIL to the upper leaf side could be seen, indicating a local loss of adaxial leaf identity. The observed changes in expression are consistent with a role of TmFIL in radialization of the petiole and circularization of the leaf blade margin by the cross zone. In addition, expression was observed in segment primordia and during expansion of the bifacial blade, suggesting additional roles for TmFIL in leaf development.     

Leaf adaxial-abaxial polarity specification and lamina outgrowth: evolution and development

A key innovation in leaf evolution is the acquisition of a flat lamina with adaxial-abaxial polarity, which optimizes the primary function of photosynthesis. The developmental mechanism behind leaf adaxial-abaxial polarity specification and flat lamina formation has long been of interest to biologists. Surgical and genetic studies proposed a conceptual model wherein a signal derived from the shoot apical meristem is necessary for adaxial-abaxial polarity specification, and subsequent lamina outgrowth is promoted at the juxtaposition of adaxial and abaxial identities. Several distinct regulators involved in leaf adaxial-abaxial polarity specification and lamina outgrowth have been identified. Analyses of these genes demonstrated that the mutual antagonistic interactions between adaxial and abaxial determinants establish polarity and define the boundary between two domains, along which lamina outgrowth regulators function. Evolutionary developmental studies on diverse leaf forms of angiosperms proposed that alteration to the adaxial-abaxial patterning system can be a major driving force in the generation of diverse leaf forms, as represented by 'unifacial leaves', in which leaf blades have only the abaxial identity. Interestingly, unifacial leaf blades become flattened, in spite of the lack of adaxial-abaxial juxtaposition. Modification of the adaxial-abaxial patterning system is also utilized to generate complex organ morphologies, such as stamens. In this review, we summarize recent advances in the genetic mechanisms underlying leaf adaxial-abaxial polarity specification and lamina outgrowth, with emphasis on the genetic basis of the evolution and diversification of leaves.     

Anatomical study of an aquatic mustard: Subularia aquatica (Brassicaceae)

Subularia aquatica is a small annual aquatic plant in the family Brassicaceae with unique leaf morphology. Its anatomical features were studied using light microscopy. We show that the leaves of S. aquatica are bifacial dorsiventral phyllodes, having adaxial-abaxial polarity, rather than the alternative unifacial type. This morphology is also manifested in the collaterally arranged vascular bundles, which are clearly bifacial. The roots exhibit typical anatomical features of an aquatic plant, including prominent aerenchyma. Although unique within the Brassicaceae, S. aquatica displays many of the same morphological characteristics as other Isoetid life-forms.     

PHANTASTICA regulates development of the adaxial mesophyll in Nicotiana leaves

Initiation and growth of leaf blades is oriented by an adaxial/abaxial axis aligned with the original axis of polarity in the leaf primordium. To investigate mechanisms regulating this process, we cloned the Nicotiana tabacum ortholog of PHANTASTICA (NTPHAN) and generated a series of antisense transgenics in N. sylvestris. We show that NSPHAN is expressed throughout emerging blade primordia in the wild type and becomes localized to the middle mesophyll in the expanding lamina. Antisense NSPHAN leaves show ectopic expression of NTH20, a class I KNOX gene. Juvenile transgenic leaves have normal adaxial/abaxial polarity and generate leaf blades in the normal position, but the adaxial mesophyll shows disorganized patterns of cell division, delayed maturation of palisade, and ectopic reinitiation of blade primordia along the midrib. Reversal of the phenotype with exogenous gibberellic acid suggests that NSPHAN, acting via KNOX repression, maintains determinacy in the expanding lamina and sustains the patterns of cell proliferation critical to palisade development.     

Acquisition and diversification of cladodes: leaf-like organs in the genus Asparagus

The genus Asparagus is unusual in producing axillary, determinate organs called cladodes, which may take on either a flattened or cylindrical form. Here, we investigated the evolution of cladodes to elucidate the mechanisms at play in the diversification of shoot morphology. Our observations of Asparagus asparagoides, which has leaf-like cladodes, showed that its cladodes are anatomically and developmentally similar to leaves but differ in the adaxial/abaxial polarity of the vasculature. In addition to the expression of an ortholog of KNAT1, orthologous genes that are normally expressed in leaves, asymmetric leaves1 and HD-ZIPIII, were found to be expressed in cladode primordia in a leaf-like manner. The cylindrical cladodes of Asparagus officinalis showed largely similar expression patterns but showed evidence of being genetically abaxialized. These results provide evidence that cladodes are modified axillary shoots, suggest that the co-option of preexisting gene networks involved in leaf development transferred the leaf-like form to axillary shoots, and imply that altered expression of leaf polarity genes led to the evolution of cylindrical cladodes in the A. officinalis clade.     

Leaf dimorphism in Thuja plicata and Platycladus orientalis (thujoid Cupressaceae s. str., Coniferales): the changes in morphology and anatomy from juvenile needle leaves to mature scale leaves

Thuja plicata and Platycladus orientalis initially produce only bifacial needle leaves. When the first lateral shoots develop, the leaf morphology and anatomy changes dramatically. Subsequently, only greatly reduced, bifacial scale leaves are developed. A new kind of “superimposed bifaciality” occurs with the change from juvenile needle leaves to mature scale leaves. Anatomical dorsiventrality affects not only the individual leaf, but also the complete plagiotropic lateral shoots of Thuja, which have a sun- and shade-exposed side. The upper light-exposed median leaves show adaxial leaf anatomy, contrary to the lower shaded median leaves showing abaxial leaf anatomy. Due to their mixed exposure, the lateral leaves show a lateral differentiation. At vertical lateral shoots of Platycladus, a predominant light-exposed side is absent. Thus, the anatomical dorsiventrality does not affect the complete shoot. Here the morphological abaxial side of a scale leaf becomes functionally and physiologically adaxial by reorientation of the palisade parenchyma and stomata. In juvenile needle leaves, the palisade parenchyma is located adaxial, with the majority of stomata being located abaxial. Conversely, in mature scale leaves, the palisade parenchyma is abaxial and the majority of stomata are adaxial.     

Leaf and inflorescence peduncle anatomy: a contribution to the taxonomy of Rapateaceae

The anatomy of leaves and inflorescence peduncles was studied in species of Monotrema (4), Stegolepis (1) and Saxofridericia (1), aiming to contribute to the taxonomy of Rapateaceae. The form and structure of leaf blade midrib and the form of the inflorescence peduncle are diagnostic characteristics for the studied species. Monotrema is distinguished by: epidermal and vascular bundle outer sheath cells containing phenolic compounds in both organs; leaf blade with palisade and spongy chlorenchyma, arm-parenchyma, and air canals between the vascular bundles; leaf sheath with phenolic idioblasts in the mesophyll; inflorescence peduncle with tabular epidermal cells and air canals in the cortex and pith. Such characteristics support the recognition of Monotremoideae, which includes Monotrema. Stegolepis guianensis is distinguished by thick-walled epidermal cells and a plicate chlorenchyma in both organs; leaf blade with subepidermal fiber strands in abaxial surface and a heterogeneous mesophyll; inflorescence peduncle with rounded epidermal cells, a hypodermis with slightly thick-walled cells, and a pith with isodiametric cells and vascular bundles. Saxofridericia aculeata is distinguished by papillate epidermal cells in both organs; unifacial leaf blade with subepidermal fiber strands in both surfaces and a regular chlorenchyma; leaf sheath with a hypodermis in both surfaces and fiber bundles in the mesophyll; inflorescence peduncle with an undefined cortex and a hypodermis with thick-walled cells. S. guianensis shares few characteristics with S. aculeata, supporting their placement in different tribes.     

Model for the role of auxin polar transport in patterning of the leaf adaxial–abaxial axis

Leaf adaxial–abaxial polarity refers to the two leaf faces, which have different types of cells performing distinct biological functions. In 1951, Ian Sussex reported that when an incipient leaf primordium was surgically isolated by an incision across the vegetative shoot apical meristem (SAM), a radialized structure without an adaxial domain would form. This led to the proposal that a signal, now called the Sussex signal, is transported from the SAM to emerging primordia to direct leaf adaxial–abaxial patterning. It was recently proposed that instead of the Sussex signal, polar transport of the plant hormone auxin is critical in leaf polarity formation. However, how auxin polar transport functions in the process is unknown. Through live imaging, we established a profile of auxin polar transport in and around young leaf primordia. Here we show that auxin polar transport in lateral regions of an incipient primordium forms auxin convergence points. We demonstrated that blocking auxin polar transport in the lateral regions of the incipient primordium by incisions abolished the auxin convergence points and caused abaxialized leaves to form. The lateral incisions also blocked the formation of leaf middle domain and margins and disrupted expression of the middle domain/margin‐associated marker gene WUSCHEL‐RELATED HOMEOBOX 1 (SlWOX1). Based on these results we propose that the auxin convergence points are required for the formation of leaf middle domain and margins, and the functional middle domain and margins ensure leaf adaxial–abaxial polarity. How middle domain and margins function in the process is discussed.     

Adaxial–abaxial polarity: The developmental basis of leaf shape diversity

Leaves of flowering plants are diverse in shape. Part of this morphological diversity can be attributed to differences in spatiotemporal regulation of polarity in the upper (adaxial) and lower (abaxial) sides of developing leaves. In a leaf primordium, antagonistic interactions between polarity determinants specify the adaxial and abaxial domains in a mutually exclusive manner. The patterning of those domains is critical for leaf morphogenesis. In this review, we first summarize the gene networks regulating adaxial–abaxial polarity in conventional bifacial leaves and then discuss how patterning is modified in different leaf type categories. genesis 52:1–18, 2014. © 2013 The Authors. Genesis Published byWiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Systematic vegetative anatomy and ensiform leaf development in Xyris (Xyridaceae)

Ensiform leaf development in monocotyledons follows a broadly similar sequence in a wide range of relatively unrelated taxa, indicating a plastic developmental pattern, possibly associated with stressed environmental conditions, since Xyris species tend to grow in relatively damp but nutrient-poor environments. The bifacial leaf sheath surrounds the apex and the subadjacent primordium. A conical unifacial leaf tip 'Vorläuferspitze' is established at an early stage, followed by extension growth in the region behind it, generating a unifacial ensiform blade. Root and rhizome structure are also described in a systematic context, particularly in comparison with related taxa in Xyridaceae and other commelinoid monocotyledons, although information on these structures is relatively sparse.     

COMPARATIVE FOLIAR HISTOGENESIS IN ACORUS CALAMUS AND ITS BEARING ON THE PHYLLODE THEORY OF MONOCOTYLEDONOUS LEAVES

A comparative histogenetic investigation of the unifacial foliage leaves of Acorus calamus L. (Araceae; Pothoideae) was initiated for the purposes of: (1) re-evaluating the previous sympodial interpretation of unifacial leaf development; (2) comparing the mode of histogenesis with that of the phyllode of Acacia in a re-examination of the phyllode theory of monocotyledonous leaves; and (3) specifying the histogenetic mechanisms responsible for morphological divergence of the leaf of Acorus from dorsiventral leaves of other Araceae. Leaves in Acorus are initiated in an orthodistichous phyllotaxis from alternate positions on the bilaterally symmetrical apical meristem. During each plastochron the shoot apex proceeds through a regular rhythm of expansion and reduction related to leaf and axillary meristem initiation and regeneration. The shoot apex has a three- to four-layered tunica and subjacent corpus with a distinctive cytohistological zonation evident to varying degrees during all phases of the plastochron. Leaf initiation is by periclinal division in the second through fourth layers of the meristem. Following inception early growth of the leaf primordium is erect, involving apical and intercalary growth in length as well as marginal growth in circumference in the sheathing leaf base. Early maturation of the leaf apex into an attenuated tip marks the end of apical growth, and subsequent growth in length is largely basal and intercalary. Marked radial growth is evident early in development and initially is mediated by a very active adaxial meristem; the median flattening of this leaf is related to accentuated activity of this meristematic zone. Differentiation of the secondary midrib begins along the center of the leaf axis and proceeds in an acropetal direction. Correlated with this centralized zone of tissue specialization is the first appearance of procambium in the center of the leaf axis. Subsequent radial expansion of the flattened upper leaf zone is bidirectional, proceeding by intercalary meristematic activity at both sides of the central midrib. Procambial differentiation is continuous and acropetal, and provascular strands are initiated in pairs in both sides of the primordium from derivatives of intercalary meristems in the abaxial and adaxial wings of the leaf. Comparative investigation of foliar histogenesis in different populations of Acorus from Wisconsin and Iowa reveals different degrees of apical and adaxial meristematic activity in primordia of these two collections: leaves with marked adaxial growth exhibit delayed and reduced expression of apical growth, whereas primordia with marked apical growth show, correspondingly, reduced adaxial meristematic activity at equivalent stages of development. Such variations in leaf histogenesis are correlated with marked differences in adult leaf anatomy in the respective populations and explain the reasons for the sympodial interpretation of leaf morphogenesis in Acorus and unifacial organs of other genera by previous investigators. It is concluded that leaf development in Acorus resembles that of the Acacia phyllode, thereby confirming from a developmental viewpoint the homology of these organs. Comparison of development with leaves of other Araceae indicates that the modified form of the leaf of Acorus originates through the accentuation of adaxial and abaxial meristematic activity which is expressed only slightly in the more conventional dorsiventral leaf types in the family.     

Structural analysis of the dissected ensiform leaves and shoot morphology of Marathrum foeniculaceum (Podostemaceae)

Foliage leaves of Marathrum foeniculaceum Humb. & Bonpl. (Podostemaceae–Podostemoideae) resemble pinnate compound leaves at first sight. But the similarity is deceptive, since studies of the leaf structure reveal the ensiform (sword-like) shape of the blade. The ribbon-shaped central rachis-like portion represents the parallel-veined ensiform blade that extends in the median plane direction. Pinnae, typically developing from the leaf margin of the blade in transverse position relative to the mother shoot axis, do not occur here, but instead, bi-pinnate-like appendages arise alternately at the adaxial and abaxial edge of the ensiform blade. The pinnate-like structures are accessory structures. These project only from one side (“front side”) of the ensiform blade. The appendages produce repeatedly forked threads that end in pubescent filaments. The trichomes are of the Zeylanidium olivaceum type. The occurrence of similar structures in species of Marathrum and the related genera Apinagia and Mourera are discussed.     

Shoot apex,leaf development and unifacial tip inAgave wightii drumm. et prain (agavaceae)

The shoot apex has one tunica layer enclosing a mass of corpus which is differentiated cytohistologically into central mother cell zone, flank zone, rib zone and a ‘cambium-like’ zone. Occurrence of ‘cambium-like’ zone during minimal phase is considered as an expression of nodal region. Agave wightii shows spirodistichous arrangement of leaves which have an expanded photosynthetic surface with a reduced unifacial tip. Leaves are initiated by periclinal divisions in the second layer. Vertical growth in the leaves is by subapical initials and lateral growth is by marginal and submarginal initials in their early stages of development. The unifacial tip is formed by the extension of adaxial meristematic activity. The derivatives thus formed are pushed to the abaxial side of the primordiuj. Hence the unifacial part of the leaf is regarded as equivalent to a phyllode.     

The Knotted leaf blade is a mosaic of blade,sheath, and auricle identities

The dominant Knotted-1 mutations in maize alter development of the leaf blade. Sporadic patches of localized growth, or knots, and fringes of ectopic ligule occur along lateral veins of mutant leaf blades. In addition, bundle sheaths do not completely encircle lateral veins on mutant leaf blades. We have compared mutant leaf blades with wild-type leaves to determine the precise nature of the perturbed regions. Our analysis includes characterization of epidermal cell shapes, localization of photosynthetic proteins and histology of the leaf. We show that mutant leaf blades are a mosaic of leaf organ components. Affected regions of mutant leaf blades resemble either sheath or auricle tissue in both external and internal features. This conversion of blade cells represents an acropetal shift of more basal parts of the leaf blade region and correlates with previously identified ectopic expression of the Knotted-1 protein in the leaf blade. We propose that inappropriate expression of Kn1 interferes with the process of establishment of cell identities, resulting in early termination of the normal blade development program or precocious expression of the sheath and auricle development programs. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.