EVIDENCE FOR THE REPAIR OF OZONE-INDUCED MEMBRANE INJURY

The increase in [¹⁴C]-2-deoxy-D-glucose uptake by leaf discs 24 hr after fumigation was used as a measure of ozone injury to pinto bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris). This method showed that the primary leaves were most affected by ozone when plants were 10 to 12 days old, which coincided with the time of maximum leaf necrosis. However, 8-day-old plants, which had no visible leaf injury, still showed a higher uptake rate than controls, indicating that injury occurred at the cellular level. In these younger plants, uptake was shown to return to normal over a 5 day period. Moreover, the rate of this “repair” was retarded by cold or continuous darkness, enhanced by continuous light, and very markedly increased by glucose applied to the leaves. The timing of the glucose application was not critical, nor did H₂O or mannitol have an effect. The results suggest that ozone injury at the cellular level can be repaired by energy-dependent processes so that necrosis of the leaf tissue does not occur. These experiments also show that conditions and treatments after ozone exposure can alter the degree of ozone injury.     

Water translocation in Kalanchoë daigremontiana during periods of drought

Abstract. Kalanchoë daigremontiana strongly reduced daily water loss within 6 d of drought using CAM to restrict transpiration and net CO₂ uptake to the dark period.
Water translocation from old to young leaves of the plant was an additional mechanism which reduced the negative effects of drought on the water relations of young leaves. Excision of old leaves after 7–9 d of drought resulted in a decrease in the water content of young leaves. This was observed despite a decrease in transpirational water loss from young leaves. Water content in young leaves increased slightly in plants with all their leaves in place.
The dry weight of young leaves clearly increased during the experimental period when old leaves were present, but it remained relatively constant in plants without old leaves. Obviously, in addition to water, solutes were transported from old to young leaves of the plant via the phloem. Xylem tension was higher in young compared to old leaves; thus, water translocation could have occurred via xylem elements.
Since transport of organic matter in the phloem is also linked to water flow, phloem transport additionally may contribute effectively to the balance of the water budget in young leaves.     

Photosynthesis in ozone-exposed duckweed (Lemna gibba)

The photosynthetic light saturation curve in duckweed was lowered by 20–25% after ozone exposure (300 nmol mol⁻¹, 1 h). The light flux and oxygen concentration during ozone-exposure had no effect on reduction of net photosynthesis. Net photosynthesis and photorespiration were both depressed by about 40% after exposure for 1 h to 360 nmol mol⁻¹ ozone. We could not find any change in dark respiration after ozone exposure below 300 nmol mol⁻¹. When the concentration of ozone was doubled from 150 nmol mol⁻¹ to 300 nmol mol⁻¹, the uptake of ozone in duckweed changed from 100 nmol m⁻² s⁻¹ to 170 nmol m⁻² s⁻¹. We found no differences in fluorescence (pattern) between ozone treated plants and the control plants during a period of 150 min after ozone treatment, but there was an increase in synthesis of the Dl-protein and a significant reduction in degradation after ozone treatment (300 nmol mol⁻¹, 1 h). These results, together with fluorescence measurements, indicate that photochemical electron transport was not responsible for the ozone-induced reduction in net photosynthesis.     

Monitoring chilling injury: A comparison of chlorophyll fluorescence measurements, post-chilling growth and visible symptoms of injury in Zea mays

Changes in chlorophyll fluorescence emission from maize ( Zea mays L. cv. Northern Belle) seedlings chilled at 1.5°C in the dark for 3–30 h were compared with the ability of plants to resume growth in the immediate post-chilling period and with the development of visible symptoms of injury to the leaves. During chilling, the maximal rate of increase of the induced chlorophyll fluorescence rise. F_R, was measured on secondary leaf tissue. F_R decreased exponentially, at approximately the same rate in plants grown and chilled in hydroponic pots, in leaves detached from similar plants and in plants that were removed from the hydroponic pots and laid on wet filter paper adjacent to the detached leaves. The half-fall time for F_R in the 3 treatments was 7.8 ± 1.3 h, 8.6 ± 0.6 h and 8.8 ± 1.0 h, respectively. Following seedling removal from 1.5°C and return to 25/15°C, relative growth rates were determined from daily measurements of plant fresh weight gain. Compared with non-chilled seedlings, plants chilled for 3 h and longer showed depressed rates of growth. Inhibition of growth in the immediate post-chilling period (0–27 h) was linearly related to the duration of the chilling period and had a high positive correlation with the decrease in chlorophyll fluorescence (linearly related to log F_R) sustained during the chilling exposure. Visible symptoms of chilling injury developed during the post-chilling period on seedlings chilled for longer than 3 h. The decrease in log F_R during chilling was also linearly correlated with the severity of visual symptoms of chilling injury expressed in the post-chilling period. It is concluded that the extent of chilling injury in maize can be rapidly and non-destructively assessed from measurements of chlorophyll fluorescence.     

The effects of O3 fumigation during leaf development on photosynthesis of wheat and pea: An in vivo analysis

Previous studies have shown that short exposure of plants to high doses of ozone decreases subsequent photosynthesis; initially by reducing carboxylation capacity. This study tests the hypothesis that this is also the primary cause of loss of photosynthetic capacity in leaves affected by development under a low level of ozone. Triticum aestivum and Pisum sativum plants were exposed from germination to ozone in air (80 nmol mol^-1 for 7 hours per day, for 18 days. Leaves that had completed lamina expansion at this time were free of visible injury and light absorptance was unaffected. However, some significant changes in photosynthetic gas exchange were evident. Photosynthetic CO2 uptake at light saturation was decreased significantly by 35% in T. aestivum but was unchanged in P. sativum. The reduction in photosynthesis of T. aestivum was accompanied by a 31% decline in the maximum velocity of carboxylation measured in vivo. Decreased stomatal conductance did not contribute to this reduction of photosynthesis because there was no significant change in the stomatal limitation to CO2. Processes directly dependent upon photochemical reactions; that is, the quantum yield of CO2 uptake and capacity for regeneration of ribulose 1,5-bisphosphate were not affected by O3 fumigation in either species. This suggests that for wheat, the quantitative cause of decreased photosynthetic rate in vivo is a decrease in the quantity of active ribulose-1,5- bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase.     

Assessment of Atmospheric ozone levels in Israel through foliar injury to Bel-W3 tobacco plants

Summary Nicotiana tabacum L. Bel-W3, which is highly sensitive to ozone, was grown in two glass chambers and exposed to the ambient air at the periphery of Tel-Aviv, during winter, spring, summer and autumn 1978. During the exposure time, atmospheric ozone was continuously measured by a chemiluminescent monitor. Throughout the experiments, plants' height was measured and the number of leaves was determined three times weekly. The extent of injury to the tobacco plants was measured by the percentage of injured plants, the percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured. Necrotic lesions, typical for ozone injury, appeared on the mature leaves of the exposed tobacco plants in three out of four exposures. Appearance of incipient injury and the extent of injury differed among the experiments and depended not only on exposure duration and on ozone concentrations, but also on the exposure conditions. The percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured, increased with the duration of exposure and with rising cumulative ozone concentrations.This work was partially supported by the Chief Scientist's Office—Israeli Ministry of Health—Contract No. 550     

Ascorbate in the leaf apoplast is a factor mediating ozone resistance in Plantago major

The role of ascorbate in mediating ozone resistance was examined in Plantago major L. Seedlings of eleven populations which exhibited differential resistance to ozone were fumigated in controlled environment chambers with charcoal/Purafil®-filtered air (CFA) or CFA plus 15 nmol·mol^–1 ozone overnight rising to a maximum between 12:00–16:00 hours of 75 nmol·mol^–1 for 14 d. Measurements of ascorbate content were made on apoplastic and symplastic extracts. Populations differed in their constitutive level of ascorbate in youngest fully expanded leaves, and regression analysis revealed a significant correlation between ascorbate content in ozone-treated leaves and the ozone resistance of the populations. The relationship was stronger using apoplastic ascorbate levels than with corresponding symplastic measurements. The ascorbate content of the youngest fully expanded leaf of an ozone sensitive population was increased by foliar application of ascorbate. No significant difference in stomatal conductance was found between control and ascorbate-treated plants. Following spraying, plants were fumigated with 400 nmol·mol^–1 ozone for 7 h. In control plants, ozone exposure resulted in extensive visible leaf damage (20–70 % at the end of the fumigation period) and decreased rates of CO₂ assimilation (–57 %). However, ascorbate treatment prevented the appearance of visible injury, and ameliorated the decline in photosynthesis induced by ozone (–26 %). Modelled data estimating the extent of protection afforded by apoplastic ascorbate against ozone supported the experimental observations. The results suggested that although apoplastic ascorbate plays an important role, other factors must also contribute to the mediation of ozone resistance in P. major.     

Chlorophyll fluorescence assay for ozone injury in intact plants

A chlorophyll fluorescence induction (Kautsky effect) assay predicted ozone-induced injury in bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris) at least 20 hours before any visible sign of leaf necrosis. The extent of injury, which could be predicted during exposure to ozone, depended on concentration, exposure time, and leaf development stage. Much more injury occurred in light than in darkness and long exposures to lower ozone concentrations were more injurious than brief exposures to higher ones. The first detectable effect was on the photosynthetic water-splitting enzyme systems, followed by inhibition of electron transport between the photosystems. The fluorescence assay provides a simple, rapid, nondestructive method for observing effects of ozone on plants.     

Ozone-induced changes in photosynthesis and photorespiration of hybrid poplar in relation to the developmental stage of the leaves

Young poplar trees (Populus tremula Michx. x Populus alba L. clone INRA 717-1B4) were subjected to 120 ppb of ozone for 35 days in phytotronic chambers. Treated trees displayed precocious leaf senescence and visible symptoms of injury (dark brown/black upper surface stippling) exclusively observed on fully expanded leaves. In these leaves, ozone reduced parameters related to photochemistry (Chl content and maximum rate of photosynthetic electron transport) and photosynthetic CO(2) fixation [net CO(2) assimilation, Rubisco (ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase oxygenase) activity and maximum velocity of Rubisco for carboxylation]. In fully expanded leaves, the rate of photorespiration as estimated from Chl fluorescence was markedly impaired by the ozone treatment together with the activity of photorespiratory enzymes (Rubisco and glycolate oxidase). Immunoblot analysis revealed a decrease in the content of serine hydroxymethyltransferase in treated mature leaves, while the content of the H subunit of the glycine decarboxylase complex was not modified. Leaves in the early period of expansion were exempt from visible symptoms of injury and remained unaffected as regards all measured parameters. Leaves reaching full expansion under ozone exposure showed potential responses of protection (stimulation of mitochondrial respiration and transitory stomatal closure). Our data underline the major role of leaf phenology in ozone sensitivity of photosynthetic processes and reveal a marked ozone-induced inhibition of photorespiration.     

Effect of a chronic and moderate ozone pollution on the phenolic pattern of bean leaves (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Nerina): relations with visible injury and biomass production

From sowing, bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv Nerina) plants were exposed to three chronic doses of ozone for 7h.day(-1): non-filtered air (NF), non-filtered air supplied with 40nl.l(-1) ozone (NF+40) and non-filtered air supplied with 60nll(-1) ozone (NF+60). Four harvests were carried out 6, 13, 20 and 27 days after emergence. Either primary leaves, or first trifoliate leaves, or both were sampled as far as possible. For each sampled leaf, visible ozone injuries were registered, the free polyphenolic pool was analysed using HPLC and the dry matter was weighed. Visible damage on leaves was related to both exposure time and ozone concentration added. There were no adverse effects of added ozone on the biomass of primary leaves while a significant reduction of first trifoliates dry matter could be observed (NF+60 atmosphere, third and fourth harvest). Among the normally occurring phenolics, we detected a significant decrease in the accumulation of a hydroxycinnamic acid derivative as the ozone concentration increased. Nevertheless, we demonstrated that this ozone-induced modification could be sometimes distinguishable with difficulties from changes expected to be of development relevance. Beside this phenolic disbalance, we detected a de novo biosynthesis of compounds that closely depended on the level of visible ozone injury. Since their accumulation increased with leaf damage, these ozone-induced phenolics could be used to detect phytotoxic ambient levels of tropospheric ozone.     

Seed-borne cucumber mosaic virus infection of subterranean clover in Western Australia

In Western Australia, infection with cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) was widespread in all three subspecies of subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum) growing in plots belonging to the Australian National Subterranean Clover Improvement Programme. Seed-borne CMV was detected in seed harvested in 1984–1986 of 18/25 cultivars from two collections of registered cultivars; seed transmission rates ranged up to 8.8%. Seed samples from CMV-inoculated plants of 11 cultivars transmitted the virus to 0.5–8.7% of seedlings. Seed transmission rates greater than 5% were obtained only with cvs Enfield, Green Range and Nangeela. CMV was not detected in seed harvested in 1975–1981 from one of the registered cultivar collections, in 17 commercial seed stocks from 1986 or in a survey of subterranean clover pastures.
Symptoms in subterranean clover naturally infected with CMV included mottle, leaflet downcurling and dwarfing but severity varied with cultivar and selection. CMV isolates from different sources varied in virulence when inoculated to subterranean clover; two (both from subterranean clover) were severe, two moderate and three (including one from subterranean clover) mild. In pot tests, CMV decreased herbage production and root growth (dry wts) of cv. Green Range by 49% and 59% respectively. In spaced-plants growing in plots, CMV decreased herbage production and root growth of cvs Green Range and Northam by 59–630 and seed production of cv. Green Range by 45%. In rows sown with infected seed, aphid spread increased infection levels to 75% in cv. Green Range and 44% in cv. Esperance and losses in herbage production of 42% and 29% respectively were recorded.
CMV isolated from subterranean clover included isolates from both serogroups.     

Differential ozone sensitivity of rice cultivars as indicated by visible injury and grain yield

Surface ozone pollution may cause reductions in rice ( Oryza sativa L.) yield. Ozone sensitivity in rice cultivars is often evaluated based on visible leaf injury at an early growth stage. However, it is not clear whether reduction in grain yield is related to visible injury. Therefore, visible damage and grain yield reduction were examined in Japanese and Asian rice cultivars exposed to ozone. In experiment 1, 3-week-old rice seedlings were exposed to ozone (min.: 20 nl·l⁻¹, max.:120 nl·l⁻¹) for 12 h in open-top chambers (OTCs). Visible leaf injury was quantified according to a leaf bronzing score. In experiment 2, rice plants were exposed to ozone in OTCs throughout the cropping season until grain harvest. Daily mean ozone concentrations were maintained at 2, 23, 28, 42, and 57 nl·l⁻¹ with a regular diurnal pattern of exposure. After harvest, grain yield was determined. Based on visible injury to the uppermost fully expanded leaf, the indica cultivar 'Kasalath' was most tolerant, and the japonica cultivar 'Kirara 397' was most sensitive to ozone. However, grain yields for both 'Kasalath' and 'Kirara 397' were significantly decreased after ozone exposure. The indica cultivar 'Jothi' suffered severe injury after ozone exposure but had no reduction in grain yield. Therefore, ozone sensitivity of rice cultivars evaluated by visible injury did not coincide with that evaluated by the reductions in grain yield. These results suggest that mechanisms that induce acute leaf injury do not relate to chronic ozone toxicity that reduces yield.     

Evidence of widespread effects of ozone on crops and (semi‐)natural vegetation in Europe (1990–2006) in relation to AOT40‐ and flux‐based risk maps

Records of effects of ambient ozone pollution on vegetation have been compiled for Europe for the years 1990–2006. Sources include scientific papers, conference proceedings, reports to research funders, records of confirmed ozone injury symptoms and an international biomonitoring experiment coordinated by the ICP Vegetation. The latter involved ozone‐sensitive (NC‐S) and ozone‐resistant (NC‐R) biotypes of white clover (Trifolium repens L.) grown according to a common protocol and monitored for ozone injury and biomass differences in 17 European countries, from 1996 to 2006. Effects were separated into visible injury or growth/yield reduction. Of the 644 records of visible injury, 39% were for crops (27 species), 38.1% were for (semi‐) natural vegetation (95 species) and 22.9% were for shrubs (49 species). Owing to inconsistencies in reporting effort from year to year it was not possible to determine geographical or temporal trends in the data. Nevertheless, this study has shown effects in ambient air in 18 European countries from Sweden in the north to Greece in the south. These effects data were superimposed on AOT40 (accumulated ozone concentrations over 40 ppb) and POD3_gen (modelled accumulated stomatal flux over a threshold of 3 nmol m^?2 s^?1) maps generated by the EMEP Eulerian model (50 km × 50 km grid) that were parameterized for a generic crop based on wheat and NC‐S/NC‐R white clover. Many effects were found in areas where the AOT40 (crops) was below the critical level of 3 ppm h. In contrast, the majority of effects were detected in grid squares where POD3_gen (crops) were in the mid‐high range (>12 mmol m^?2). Overall, maps based on POD3_gen provided better fit to the effects data than those based on AOT40, with the POD3_gen model for clover fitting the clover effects data better than that for a generic crop.     

Does elevated ozone have differing effects in flowering and deblossomed strawberry?

Fruiting and deblossomed plants of strawberry ( Fragaria × ananassa ) were exposed to 92 ppb ozone or filtered air in open-top chambers for 69 d. Flower and fruit production, relative growth rate of leaf area, leaf gas exchange and plant biomass were investigated. Ozone caused an initial acceleration in inflorescence production, which was followed by a reduction in inflorescence production, fruit set, and, later, individual fruit weight, although total fruit yield was not affected before the end of the fumigation period. Ozone accelerated leaf senescence and had a greater negative effect on the rate of photosynthesis in older than in younger leaves in fruiting and deblossomed plants, but the response of net photosynthesis to ozone did not differ between the two groups of plants. Relative growth rate of leaf area was the first parameter to be reduced by ozone fumigation, with the effect being significant in fruiting, but not in deblossomed, plants. Final above-ground biomass was also significantly decreased by ozone in fruiting plants, but not in deblossomed plants. Root and crown biomass were not significantly affected by ozone fumigation in either fruiting or deblossomed plants.     

Internal filters: Prospects for UV-acclimation in higher plants

Wavelength-selective absorption of solar radiation within plant leaves allows penetration of visible radiation (400–700 nm) to the chloroplasts, while removing much of the damaging ultraviolet-B (UV-B, 280–320 nm) radiation. Flavonoids are important in this wavelength-selective absorption. Induction of flavonoid synthesis by solar radiation, and specifically by UV-B radiation, is discussed as this relates to the potential acclimation of plants to enhanced solar UV-B radiation that would result from stratospheric ozone reduction.     

OZONE SENSITIVITY OF LEAVES: RELATIONSHIP TO LEAF WATER CONTENT,GAS TRANSFER RESISTANCE,AND ANATOMICAL CHARACTERISTICS

Relative water content, resistance to gas transfer, stomatal spacing, and other characteristics of primary bean leaves were studied in relation to ozone sensitivity and injury. Cells of primary bean leaves are maximally sensitive to ozone exposure 9–10 days after germination under our experimental conditions. The stage of maximum sensitivity was not correlated with changes in stomatal number or resistance on either adaxial or abaxial leaf surfaces. It was deduced that bean leaf sensitivity was a function of more internal circumstances, and gas exchange was never the limiting factor through the developmental period studied. Changes in resistance were not significantly altered by ozone levels that produced no visible injury. After exposure to high ozone doses, a decrease in adaxial resistance occurred apparently as a result of palisade and epidermal cell lysis. Normally most gas exchange occurs through the adaxial surface. A 10 % decrease in relative water content accompanying a 60-min ozone exposure of 0.55 ppm could not be explained physiologically on the basis of cell injury as no visible leaf injury occurred.     

Electron spin resonance evidence for the formation of free radicals in plants exposed to ozone

Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy was used to demonstrate that free radicals are formed in O₃-fumigated plant leaves prior to the formation of visible leaf injury. ESR signals with a g-value of 2.0037 to 2.0043, were observed in pea ( Pisum sativum L. cv. Feltham first) and bean ( Phaseolus vulgaris L. cv. Pinto) plants that had been fumigated for 4 h with 70–300 nl l⁻¹ of ozone after they had been treated with the spin-trap N- t -butyl-α-phenylnitrone (PBN). The size of the ESR signals increased with the concentration of ozone used but the nature of the trapped radicals could not be identified. However, further experiments using an inhibitor of ethylene biosynthesis, arninoethoxyvinyl glycine (AVG), showed that the reaction between ozone and ethylene is the cause for ozone toxicity.     

Pre-activating wounding response in tobacco prior to high-level ozone exposure prevents necrotic injury

In tobacco, both wounding and treatment with jasmonates prior to exposure of the tissue to high concentrations of ozone (250 to 500 p.p.b.) produce a dramatic decrease in ozone injury. A systemic pattern of increased ozone tolerance developed within 3–6 h after wounding and also after local application of jasmonates. Ozone treatment of transgenie (NahG) tobacco plants showed that the inability of these plants to accumulate salicylic acid is also accompanied by increased ozone tolerance. Expression of mRNA encoding the anti-oxidant enzyme ascorbate peroxidase is upregulated by ozone challenge, wounding and by methyl jasmonate exposure within 3–4 h, while levels of carbonic anhydrase mRNA are simultaneously depressed following ozone exposure and methyl jasmonate treatment. The pattern of these results shows that the response to ozone challenge in tobacco involves signalling mechanisms similar to those induced in plants by other environmental stresses that generate reactive oxygen species.     

Use of Bel-W3 Tobacco as indicator plant for atmospheric ozone during different seasons in the coastal zone of Israel

Bel-W3 Tobacco, which is highly sensitive to ozone, was grown in two glass chambers and exposed to the ambient air at the periphery of Tel-Aviv, during winter, spring, summer and autumn 1978. During the exposure time, atmospheric ozone was continuously measured by a chemiluminescent monitor. Throughout the experiments, plants' height was measured and the number of leaves was determined three times weekly. The extent of injury to the tobacco plants was measured by the percentage of injured plants, the percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured. Necrotic lesions, typical for ozone injury, appeared on the mature leaves of the exposed tobacco plants in three out of four exposures. Appearance of incipient injury differed among the experiments and depended not only on exposure duration and on ozone concentrations, but also on the exposure conditions (like light intensity, temperature and humidity), which considerably influenced the appearance of the injury. The percentage of injured leaves and the percentage of leaves' area injured, increased with the duration of exposure and with rising cumulative ozone concentrations.Presented at the Eighth International Congress of Biometeorology 9–14 September 1979, Shefayim, Israel.     

Survival and recovery of perennial forage grasses under prolonged Mediterranean drought: II. Water status, solute accumulation, abscisic acid concentration and accumulation of dehydrin transcripts in bases of immature leaves

Effects of ozone on spring wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Satu) were studied in an open-top chamber experiment during two growing seasons (1992–1993) at Jokioinen in south-west Finland. The wheat was exposed to filtered air (CF), non-filtered air (NF), non-filtered air+35 nl l⁻¹ ozone for 8 h d⁻¹ (NF⁺) and ambient air (AA). Each treatment was replicated five times. Two wk after anthesis, after 4 wk of ozone treatment (NF⁺, 45 nl l⁻¹ 1000–1800 hours, seasonal mean) the net CO₂ uptake of wheat flag leaves was decreased by c . 40% relative to CF and NF treatments, both initial and total activity of Rubisco and the quantity of protein-bound SH groups were decreased significantly. Added ozone also significantly accelerated flag leaf senescence recorded as a decrease in chloroplast size. The effect was significant 2 wk after anthesis, and senescence was complete after 4 wk. In the CF and NF treatments senescence was complete 5 wk after anthesis. The significant effect of ozone on the chloroplasts and net CO₂ uptake 2 wk after anthesis did not affect the grain filling rate. However, since the grain filling period was shorter for ozone fumigated plants, kernels were smaller. The decrease in 1000-grain weight explained most of the yield reduction in the plants under NF⁺ treatment. The results indicate that wheat plants are well buffered against substantial decrease in source activity, and that shortened flag leaf duration is the major factor causing ozone-induced yield loss.