Coping with DNA double strand breaks

The repair of DNA double strand breaks (dsb) is important for maintaining the physical and genetic integrity of the genome. Moreover, in humans it is associated with the prevention of diseases such as immune deficiencies and cancer. This review briefly explores the fundamental strategies for repairing dsb, examines how cells maximize the fidelity of dsb repair in the cell cycle and discusses the requirements for dsb repair in the context of chromatin.     

Electron microscopic visualization of DNA single strand breaks

DNA single strand breaks (ssb) have been induced in FLC/C cells in culture. They have been visualized in the electron microscope after decoration with biotin-avidin-ferritin complexes and spreading as monomolecular mixed films. This allowed one to determine the average number of decorated ssbs per unit of DNA length applying straight-forward and simple evaluation methods. This method has been used to investigate the DNA alterations by benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P) on FLC/C culture cells. Thus a B[a]P-DNA damage curve can be constructed as a regression with a correlation coefficient of r = 0.97, while its isomer benzo[e]pyrene (B[e]P) known to have only low mutagenicity under the same experimental conditions is virtually without effect. The method has further informational potential regarding damage distribution and repair of DNA.     

Eumelanin causes DNA strand breaks and kills cells

Synthetic eumelanin prepared by autooxidation of D,L-DOPA causes DNA strand breaks, as determined by alkaline elution after cell lysis with detergent and proteolysis, in B16CL4 mouse melanoma cells. The melanin is toxic to the cells in the range of doses that causes strand breaks. When the melanin was incubated with the cells at 37 degrees C in tissue culture medium, it was maximally effective after 15 to 20 min at causing strand breaks in the DNA. The extent of damage is concentration dependent, but the effect plateaus at 1 mg/ml. The nature of the interaction of the cellular DNA with melanin is consistent with strand breaks, not DNA-DNA crosslinks. The strand break damage is repaired, even in the continued presence of melanin, but repair is more rapid if the cells are washed and the melanin is removed. The form of the melanin is important for obtaining the effect. Sonication for 3 min abrogates the effect to a considerable extent, and repeated cycles of sonication can completely destroy the activity. Lost activity returns slowly with storage at 4 degrees C. Melanin is more effective at damaging DNA in a protein-free medium. It is also DNA-damaging at 4 degrees C, but less so than at 37 degrees C. Preliminary studies indicate that the strand breaks caused by melanin are additive with those caused by ionizing radiation. The extent of DNA strand breaks and alkali-labile sites caused by several other melanins was also determined. Some melanins did not cause frank strand breaks, but were active in causing alkali-labile sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Chromosomal aberrations induced by double strand DNA breaks

It has been suggested that introduction of double strand DNA breaks (DSBs) into mammalian chromosomes can lead to gross chromosomal rearrangements through improper DNA repair. To study this phenomenon, we employed a model system in which a double strand DNA break can be produced in human cells in vivo at a predetermined location. The ensuing chromosomal changes flanking the breakage site can then be cloned and characterized. In this system, the recognition site for the I-SceI endonuclease, whose 18 bp recognition sequence is not normally found in the human genome, is placed between a strong constitutive promoter and the Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) gene, which serves as a negative selectable marker. We found that the most common mutation following aberrant DSB repair was an interstitial deletion; these deletions typically showed features of non-homologous end joining (NHEJ), such as microhomologies and insertions of direct or inverted repeat sequences. We also detected more complex rearrangements, including large insertions from adjacent or distant genomic regions. The insertion events that involved distant genomic regions typically represented transcribed sequences, and included both L1 LINE elements and sequences known to be involved in genomic rearrangements. This type of aberrant repair could potentially lead to gene inactivation via deletion of coding or regulatory sequences, or production of oncogenic fusion genes via insertion of coding sequences.     

Increased lymphocyte DNA strand breaks in rubber workers

OBJECTIVE: To study the effect of occupational exposure to rubber processing, smoking, and alcohol drinking on lymphocyte DNA damage. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Of 371 employees (197 men and 174 women) from a rubber factory in Guangzhou, 281 were rubber processing workers from five production sections and 90 were managerial workers. Information on occupational exposure, smoking, and drinking was collected by interviews. Blood samples were taken in the morning by venipuncture. DNA damages were measured by the Comet assay. Possible DNA-protein crosslinks were broken down by proteinase K. Tail moment, measured by Komet 4.0 image analysis software, was the measure of DNA damage. RESULTS: The rubber processing workers had larger tail moment than the managerial workers (Geometric mean, 95%CI) [1. 77microm (1.64-1.90) versus 1.52microm (1.36-1.71), P=0.04]. Both smoking [1.93microm (1.74-2.13) versus 1.59microm (1.47-1.71), P=0. 003] and alcohol drinking [2.21microm (1.87-2.62) versus 1.63microm (1.53-1.74), P<0.001] increased tail moment. Tail moment differed significantly among job categories (F=3.21, P=0.008), the largest was observed in mixers. In the non-smoking and non-drinking workers, rubber processing workers had larger tail moment than managerial workers after adjusting for age (P=0.033). General linear model analysis showed that after adjusting for each other, occupational exposure (P=0.027), smoking (P=0.012), and alcohol drinking (P=0. 013) was associated with larger tail moment, whereas age and gender had no effect. CONCLUSIONS: Occupational exposure to rubber processing, smoking, and alcohol drinking can cause DNA damage.     

Increased lymphocyte DNA strand breaks in rubber workers

Objective: To study the effect of occupational exposure to rubber processing, smoking, and alcohol drinking on lymphocyte DNA damage. Subjects and Methods: Of 371 employees (197 men and 174 women) from a rubber factory in Guangzhou, 281 were rubber processing workers from five production sections and 90 were managerial workers. Information on occupational exposure, smoking, and drinking was collected by interviews. Blood samples were taken in the morning by venipuncture. DNA damages were measured by the Comet assay. Possible DNA-protein crosslinks were broken down by proteinase K. Tail moment, measured by Komet 4.0 image analysis software, was the measure of DNA damage. Results: The rubber processing workers had larger tail moment than the managerial workers (Geometric mean, 95%CI) [1.77 μm (1.64–1.90) versus 1.52 μm (1.36–1.71), P=0.04]. Both smoking [1.93 μm (1.74–2.13) versus 1.59 μm (1.47–1.71), P=0.003] and alcohol drinking [2.21 μm (1.87–2.62) versus 1.63 μm (1.53–1.74), P<0.001] increased tail moment. Tail moment differed significantly among job categories (F=3.21, P=0.008), the largest was observed in mixers. In the non-smoking and non-drinking workers, rubber processing workers had larger tail moment than managerial workers after adjusting for age (P=0.033). General linear model analysis showed that after adjusting for each other, occupational exposure (P=0.027), smoking (P=0.012), and alcohol drinking (P=0.013) was associated with larger tail moment, whereas age and gender had no effect. Conclusions: Occupational exposure to rubber processing, smoking, and alcohol drinking can cause DNA damage.     

DNA strand breaks induced by low-energy heavy ions

The DNA unwinding method was used to estimate DNA breakage in Chinese hamster cells exposed to heavy ions with LET in the range of 750-5000 keV/micron. Comparison of the primary induced unwinding rate per dose unit for ions with various track diameters but similar LET showed a pronounced influence on the track diameter. Low-energy ions, producing thin tracks with diameters (penumbra) in the submicrometer region, were almost two orders of magnitude less efficient than more energetic ions producing tracks with diameters of several micrometers and about three orders of magnitude less efficient than X-rays. For the thin tracks, clustering of breaks was indicated by comparison of the DNA unwinding rates in two different alkaline solutions. The results indicate that the unwinding rate cannot be used as a good measurement for DNA breaks in this case. The residual unwinding remaining after 4 h of repair at 37 degrees C correlated well with the ability of the various ions to produce cell-killing.     

Methoxyamine potentiates DNA single strand breaks and double strand breaks induced by temozolomide in colon cancer cells

We have previously shown that human cancer cells deficient in DNA mismatch repair (MMR) are resistant to the chemotherapeutic methylating agent temozolomide (TMZ) and can be sensitized by the base excision repair (BER) blocking agent methoxyamine (MX) [21]. To further characterize BER-mediated repair responses to methylating agent-induced DNA damage, we have now evaluated the effect of MX on TMZ-induced DNA single strand breaks (SSB) by alkaline elution and DNA double strand breaks (DSB) by pulsed field gel electrophoresis in SW480 (O6-alkylguanine-DNA-alkyltransferase [AGT]+, MMR wild type) and HCT116 (AGT+, MMR deficient) colon cancer cells. SSB were evident in both cell lines after a 2-h exposure to equitoxic doses of temozolomide. MX significantly increased the number of TMZ-induced DNA-SSB in both cell lines. In contrast to SSB, TMZ-induced DNA-DSB were dependent on MMR status and were time-dependent. Levels of 50 kb double stranded DNA fragments in MMR proficient cells were increased after TMZ alone or in combination with O6-benzylguanine or MX, whereas, in MMR deficient HCT116 cells, only TMZ plus MX produced significant levels of DNA-DSB. Levels of AP endonuclease, XRCC1 and polymerase beta were present in both cell lines and were not significantly altered after MX and TMZ. However, cleavage of a 30-mer double strand substrate by SW480 and HCT116 crude cell extracts was inhibited by MX plus TMZ. Thus, MX potentiation of TMZ cytotoxicity may be explained by the persistence of apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites not further processed due to the presence of MX. Furthermore, in MMR-deficient, TMZ-resistant HCT116 colon cancer cells, MX potentiates TMZ cytotoxicity through formation of large DS-DNA fragmentation and subsequent apoptotic signalling.     

Yield of DNA strand breaks after base oxidation of plasmid DNA

We have irradiated aerobic aqueous solutions of plasmid DNA with 137Cs gamma rays in the presence of inorganic radical scavengers including nitrite, iodide, azide, thiocyanate and bromide. These scavengers react with the strongly oxidizing hydroxyl radical (*OH) to produce less powerful oxidants. Of these scavengers, only thiocyanate and bromide result in the formation of oxidizing species [(SCN)2*- and Br2*-, respectively] which are capable of reacting with the bases in DNA. The oxidized bases were detected after incubation of the irradiated plasmid with the two E. coli DNA base excision repair endonucleases, formamidopyrimidine-DNA N-glycosylase and endonuclease III. Depending on the experimental conditions, the intermediate base radicals may ultimately form stable oxidized bases in very high yields (within an order of magnitude of the *OH yield), and possibly also single-strand breaks (SSBs) in much lower yield (between 0.1 and 1% of the total yield of base damage). By competing for (SCN)2*- with an additional species (nitrite), it was possible to estimate the second-order rate constant for the reaction of (SCN)2*- with DNA as 1.6 x 10(4) dm3 mol(-1) s(-1), and also to demonstrate a correlation between the large yield of damaged bases and the much smaller increase in the yield of SSBs over background levels due to *OH. The efficiency of transfer of damage from oxidized base to sugar is estimated as about 0.5% or 5%, depending on whether purine or pyrimidine base radicals are responsible for the base to sugar damage transfer.     

Hyperthermic potentiation of unrejoined DNA strand breaks following irradiation

Previous reports have suggested that the potentiation of cellular radiation sensitivity by hyperthermia may be due to its inhibition of the repair of single-strand breaks in DNA. Such inhibition could result in increased numbers of unrejoined breaks at long times following irradiation, lesions that are presumed to be lethal to the cell. As a test of this hypothesis, the amounts of residual strand-break damage in cells following combined hyperthermia and ionizing radiation were measured. The results show that hyperthermia does significantly enhance the relative number of unrejoined strand breaks as measured by the technique of alkaline elution and that the degree of enhancement is dependent on both the temperature and duration of the hyperthermia treatment. For example, compared to unheated cells, the proportion of unrejoined breaks measured 8 hr after irradiation was increased by a factor of 1.5 in cells that were treated for 30 min at 43 degrees C, by a factor of 6 for cells treated for 30 min at 45 degrees C, and by a factor of 4 for cells treated at 43 degrees C for 2 hr. In experiments in which the sequence of heat and irradiation were varied, a high degree of correlation was observed between the resulting level of cell killing and the relative numbers of unrejoined strand breaks. The greatest effects on both of these parameters were observed in those protocols in which the irradiation was delivered either during, just before, or just after the heat treatment.     

Genome-wide analysis of DNA replication and DNA double-strand breaks using TrAEL-seq

Faithful replication of the entire genome requires replication forks to copy large contiguous tracts of DNA, and sites of persistent replication fork stalling present a major threat to genome stability. Understanding the distribution of sites at which replication forks stall, and the ensuing fork processing events, requires genome-wide methods that profile replication fork position and the formation of recombinogenic DNA ends. Here, we describe Transferase-Activated End Ligation sequencing (TrAEL-seq), a method that captures single-stranded DNA 3′ ends genome-wide and with base pair resolution. TrAEL-seq labels both DNA breaks and replication forks, providing genome-wide maps of replication fork progression and fork stalling sites in yeast and mammalian cells. Replication maps are similar to those obtained by Okazaki fragment sequencing; however, TrAEL-seq is performed on asynchronous populations of wild-type cells without incorporation of labels, cell sorting, or biochemical purification of replication intermediates, rendering TrAEL-seq far simpler and more widely applicable than existing replication fork direction profiling methods. The specificity of TrAEL-seq for DNA 3′ ends also allows accurate detection of double-strand break sites after the initiation of DNA end resection, which we demonstrate by genome-wide mapping of meiotic double-strand break hotspots in a dmc1Δ mutant that is competent for end resection but not strand invasion. Overall, TrAEL-seq provides a flexible and robust methodology with high sensitivity and resolution for studying DNA replication and repair, which will be of significant use in determining mechanisms of genome instability.

TrAEL-seq provides genome-wide base pair resolution maps of exposed DNA 3’ ends; this reveals replication fork stalling and normal replication profiles in asynchronous, unlabelled wildtype cell populations, along with the sites of resected DNA breaks.     

A nervous predisposition to unrepaired DNA double strand breaks

Ataxia-telangiectasia (A–T) has for a long time stood apart from most other human neurodegenerative syndromes by the characteristic failure of cells derived from these patients to properly repair DNA damage-induced by ionizing radiation. The discovery of mutations in the ATM gene as being the underlying cause for A–T and the demonstration that the ATM protein functions as a DNA damage-responsive kinase has defined current research focusing on decoding how the cell responds to genotoxic stress. Yet, despite significant advances in delineating the cellular DNA damage response pathways coordinated by ATM, very little headway has been made toward understanding how loss of ATM leads to progressive cerebellar ataxia and whether this can be attributed to an underlying defect in DNA double strand break repair (DSBR). Since its identification, A–T has been used as the archetypal model for how a deficiency in DNA repair affects both the development and maintenance of the nervous and immune systems in humans as well as contributing to the process of tumourigenesis. However, following the growing availability and cost effectiveness of next generation sequencing technologies, the increasing recognition of novel human disorders associated with abnormal DNA repair has demonstrated that the neuropathology typified by A–T is an ‘exception’ rather than the ‘rule’. As a consequence, this throws into doubt the longstanding hypothesis that the neurodegeneration seen in A–T is due to the progressive loss of damaged neurons that have acquired toxic levels of unrepaired DNA lesions over time. Therefore, this review aims to address the question: Is defective DNA double strand break repair an underlying cause of neurodegeneration?     

RecA protein-facilitated DNA strand breaks. A mechanism for bypassing DNA structural barriers during strand exchange

RecA protein promotes an unexpectedly efficient DNA strand exchange between circular single-stranded DNA and duplex DNAs containing short (50-400-base pair) heterologous sequences at the 5' (initiating) end. The major mechanism by which this topological barrier is bypassed involves DNA strand breakage. Breakage is both strand and position specific, occurring almost exclusively in the displaced (+) strand of the duplex within a 15-base pair region of the heterology/homology junction. Breakage also requires recA protein, ATP hydrolysis, and homologous sequences 3' to the heterology. Although the location of the breaks and the observed requirements clearly indicate a major role for recA protein in this phenomenon, the molecular mechanism is not yet clear. The breakage may reflect a DNA structure and/or some form of structural stress within the DNA during recA protein-mediated DNA pairing which either exposes the DNA at this precise position to the action of a contaminating nuclease or induces a direct mechanical break. We also find that when heterology is located at the 3' end of the linear duplex, strand exchange is halted (without DNA breakage) about 500 base pairs from the homology/heterology junction.     

DNA strand breaks in mammalian tissues induced by methylarsenics

DNA damage induced by administration of dimethylarsinic acid (DMAA) to rats and mice was investigated. At 12 h after administration of DMAA, DNA single-strand breaks were induced markedly in lung. The majority of dimethylarsine, one of the main metabolites, in the expired air was excreted within 6–18 h after administration of DMAA to rats. In vitro experiments using nuclei isolated from lung of mice indicated that DNA strand breaks were caused by dimethylarsine. Furthermore, the strand breaks after exposure to dimethylarsine were reduced in the presence of catalase and/or superoxide dismutase. These results strongly suggest that the strand breaks are induced not by dimethylarsine itself but by active oxygen, e.g., O ₂ ^? and ·OH, produced both by dimethylarsine and molecular oxygen. When DNA was exposed to dimethylarsine, thiobarbituric acid (TBA)-reactive intermediates andcis-thymine glycol were produced. Dimethylarsine appears to induce DNA damage by the mechanism similar to the damage produced by ionizing radiation.     

Neighborly DISCourse: DNA double strand breaks silence transcription

Comment on: Shanbhag NM, et al. Cell 2010; 141:970-81.