Electron microscopic mapping of secondary structures in bacterial 16S and 23S ribosomal ribonucleic acid and 30S precursor ribosomal ribonucleic acid

Electron microscopy revealed reproducible secondary structure patterns within partially denatured 16S and 23S ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) from Escherichia coli. When prepared with 50% formamide-100 mM ammonium acetate, 16S rRNA included two small hairpins that appeared in over 50% of all molecules. Three open loops were observed with frequencies of less than 25%. In contrast, 23S rRNA included a terminal open loop and two additional large structures in over 75% of all molecules. These secondary structure patterns were conserved in the 16S and 23S rRNA from Pseudomonas aeruginosa. The secondary structure of the 30S precursor rRNA from the ribonclease III-deficient E. coli mutant AB105 was mapped after partial denaturation in 70% formamide-100 mM ammonium acetate. Two large open loops were superimposed on the 16S and 23S rRNA secondary structure patterns. These loops were the most frequent structures found on the precursor, and their stems coincided with ribonuclease III cleavage sites. A tentative 5'-3 orientation was determined for the secondary structure patterns of 16S and 23S rRNA from their relative locations within 30S precursor rRNA. The relation of secondary structure to ribosomal protein binding and ribonuclease III cleavage is discussed.     

Electron microscopy of the secondary structure in partially denatured rRNAs of Escherichia coli and Bacillus stearothermophilus.

Partially denatured 16S and 23S rRNAs from the thermophile Bacillus stearothermophilus show characteristic loop patterns when observed by electron microscopy. The patterns are very similar to those seen in rRNAs from Escherichia coli. At least 2 of 4 most stable interactions in 16S rRNA and 8 of 12 interactions in 23S rRNA are in common for the two species. These interactions correspond well to features of secondary structure in models inferred for rRNA from phylogenetic sequence comparisons and chemical modification studies. However, two additional large loops, enclosing large portions of the 23S rRNA, have been detected in B. stearothermophilus for the first time, and even though other loops are similar, their relative frequencies vary in the two species. Much of the variation is consistent with relative delta G degree values for putative base-paired stems at the base of different loops; but the 5'-terminal loops in 23S rRNA, for example, are unaccountably far less stable in B. stearothermophilus. Also, in general, structural features are not differentially stabilized in B. stearothermophilus; the relative stability of secondary structure in its ribosomes at elevated growth temperatures must involve interactions with ribosomal proteins or other cellular components.     

Base Pairing between U3 Small Nucleolar RNA and the 5′ End of 18S rRNA Is Required for Pre-rRNA Processing

The loop of a stem structure close to the 5' end of the 18S rRNA is complementary to the box A region of the U3 small nucleolar RNA (snoRNA). Substitution of the 18S loop nucleotides inhibited pre-rRNA cleavage at site A(1), the 5' end of the 18S rRNA, and at site A(2), located 1.9 kb away in internal transcribed spacer 1. This inhibition was largely suppressed by a compensatory mutation in U3, demonstrating functional base pairing. The U3-pre-rRNA base pairing is incompatible with the structure that forms in the mature 18S rRNA and may prevent premature folding of the pre-rRNA. In the Escherichia coli pre-rRNA the homologous region of the 16S rRNA is also sequestered, in that case by base pairing to the 5' external transcribed spacer (5' ETS). Cleavage at site A(0) in the yeast 5' ETS strictly requires base pairing between U3 and a sequence within the 5' ETS. In contrast, the U3-18S interaction is not required for A(0) cleavage. U3 therefore carries out at least two functionally distinct base pair interactions with the pre-rRNA. The nucleotide at the site of A(1) cleavage was shown to be specified by two distinct signals; one of these is the stem-loop structure within the 18S rRNA. However, in contrast to the efficiency of cleavage, the position of A(1) cleavage is not dependent on the U3-loop interaction. We conclude that the 18S stem-loop structure is recognized at least twice during pre-rRNA processing.     

Escherichia coli 16S rRNA 3''-end formation requires a distal transfer RNA sequence at a proper distance.

The 16S rRNA species in bacterial precursor rRNAs is followed by two evolutionarily conserved features: (i) a double-stranded stem formed by complementary sequences adjacent to the 5' and 3' ends of the 16S rRNA; and (ii) a 3'-transfer RNA sequence. To assess the possible role of these features, plasmid constructs with precursor-specific features deleted were tested for their capacity to form mature rRNA. Stem-forming sequences were dispensable for both 5' and 3' terminus formation; whereas an intact spacer tRNA positioned greater than 24 nucleotides downstream of the 16S RNA sequence was required for correct 3'-end maturation. These results suggest that spacer tRNA at an appropriate location helps form a conformation obligate for pre-rRNA processing, perhaps by binding to a nascent binding site in preribosomes. Thus, spacer tRNAs may be an obligate participant in ribosome formation.     

Localization and structure of endonuclease cleavage sites involved in the processing of the rat 32S precursor to ribosomal RNA.

The initial endonuclease cleavage site in 32 S pre-rRNA (precursor to rRNA) is located within the rate rDNA sequence by S1-nuclease protection mapping of purified nucleolar 28 S rRNA and 12 S pre-rRNA. The heterogeneous 5'- and 3'-termini of these rRNA abut and map within two CTC motifs in tSi2 (internal transcribed spacer 2) located at 50-65 and 4-20 base-pairs upstream from the homogeneous 5'-end of the 28 S rRNA gene. These results show that multiple endonuclease cleavages occur at CUC sites in tSi2 to generate 28 S rRNA and 12 S pre-rRNA with heterogeneous 5'- and 3'-termini, respectively. These molecules have to be processed further to yield mature 28 S and 5.8 S rRNA. Thermal-denaturation studies revealed that the base-pairing association in the 12 S pre-rRNA:28 S rRNA complex is markedly stronger than that in the 5.8 S:28 S rRNA complex. The sequence of about one-quarter (1322 base-pairs) of the 5'-part of the rat 28 S rDNA was determined. A computer search reveals the possibility that the cleavage sites in the CUC motifs are single-stranded, flanked by strongly base-paired GC tracts, involving tSi2 and 28 S rRNA sequences. The subsequent nuclease cleavages, generating the termini of mature rRNA, seem to be directed by secondary-structure interactions between 5.8 S and 28 S rRNA segments in pre-rRNA. An analysis for base-pairing among evolutionarily conserved sequences in 32 S pre-rRNA suggests that the cleavages yielding mature 5.8 S and 28 S rRNA are directed by base-pairing between (i) the 3'-terminus of 5.8 S rRNA and the 5'-terminus of 28 S rRNA and (ii) the 5'-terminus of 5.8 S rRNA and internal sequences in domain I of 28 S rRNA. A general model for primary- and secondary-structure interactions in pre-rRNA processing is proposed, and its implications for ribosome biogenesis in eukaryotes are briefly discussed.     

Mouse rDNA: sequences and evolutionary analysis of spacer and mature RNA regions.

Two regions of mouse rDNA were sequenced. One contained the last 323 nucleotides of the external transcribed spacer and the first 595 nucleotides of 18S rRNA; the other spanned the entire internal transcribed spacer and included the 3' end of 18S rRNA, 5.8S rRNA, and the 5' end of 28S rRNA. The mature rRNA sequences are very highly conserved from yeast to mouse (unit evolutionary period, the time required for a 1% divergence of sequence, was 30 X 10(6) to 100 X 10(6) years). In 18S rRNA, at least some of the evolutionary expansion and increase in G + C content is due to a progressive accretion of discrete G + C-rich insertions. Spacer sequence comparisons between mouse and rat rRNA reveal much more extensive and frequent insertions and substitutions of G + C-rich segments. As a result, spacers conserve overall G + C richness but not sequence (UEP, 0.3 X 10(6) years) or specific base-paired stems. Although no stems analogous to those bracketing 16S and 23S rRNA in Escherichia coli pre-rRNA are evident, certain features of the spacer regions flanking eucaryotic mature rRNAs are conserved and could be involved in rRNA processing or ribosome formation. These conserved regions include some short homologous sequence patterns and closely spaced direct repeats.     

Mapping of the major early endonuclease cleavage site of the rat precursor to rRNA within the internal transcribed spacer sequence of rDNA

The endonuclease cleavage of 41 S pre-rRNA to yield 32 S and 21 S pre-rRNA constitutes a major early step in the processing of pre-rRNA in rat liver. The 5'-terminus of 32 S pre-rRNA and the 3'-terminus of 21 S pre-rRNA were precisely located within the rDNA sequence by S1 nuclease protection mapping and use of appropriate rDNA restriction fragments. The 5'-terminus of 12 S pre-rRNA, an initial product of 32 S pre-rRNA processing, was also mapped within the rDNA sequence. The 5'-termini of 32 S and 12 S pre-rRNA coincide and map within a 14-residue T-tract (non-coding strand) at 161-163 bp upstream from the 5'-end of the 5.8 S rRNA gene. The 3'-terminus of 21 S pre-rRNA maps within the same T-tract. These results show that the endonuclease cleavage occurs within a U-tract in the internal transcribed spacer 1 sequence of 41 S pre-rRNA. The homogeneity of the 5'- or 3'-termini of 32 S, 12 S and 21 S pre-rRNA indicates also that the terminal processing of these molecules, if any, is markedly slower. The coincidence in the location of 32 S and 12 S pre-rRNA 5'-termini shows further that the endonuclease cleavage of 32 S pre-rRNA precedes the removal of its 5'-terminal segment to yield 5.8 S rRNA. The absence in the whole pre-rRNA internal transcribed spacer of sequences complementary to the target U-tract suggests that the endonuclease cleavage, generating 32 S and 21 S pre-rRNA, occurs in a single-stranded loop of U-residues.     

Location of the initial cleavage sites in mouse pre-rRNA.

The locations of three cleavages that can occur in mouse 45S pre-rRNA were determined by Northern blot hybridization and S1 nuclease mapping techniques. These experiments indicate that an initial cleavage of 45S pre-rRNA can directly generate the mature 5' terminus of 18S rRNA. Initial cleavage of 45S pre-rRNA can also generate the mature 5' terminus of 5.8S rRNA, but in this case cleavage can occur at two different locations, one at the known 5' terminus of 5.8S rRNA and another 6 or 7 nucleotides upstream. This pattern of cleavage results in the formation of cytoplasmic 5.8S rRNA with heterogeneous 5' termini. Further, our results indicate that one pathway for the formation of the mature 5' terminus of 28S rRNA involves initial cleavages within spacer sequences followed by cleavages which generate the mature 5' terminus of 28S rRNA. Comparison of these different patterns of cleavage for mouse pre-rRNA with that for Escherichia coli pre-rRNA implies that there are fundamental differences in the two processing mechanisms. Further, several possible cleavage signals have been identified by comparing the cleavage sites with the primary and secondary structure of mouse rRNA (see W. E. Goldman, G. Goldberg, L. H. Bowman, D. Steinmetz, and D. Schlessinger, Mol. Cell. Biol. 3:1488-1500, 1983).     

A story: unpaired adenosine bases in ribosomal RNAs

In 1985 an analysis of the Escherichia coli 16 S rRNA covariation-based structure model revealed a strong bias for unpaired adenosines. The same analysis revealed that the majority of the G, C, and U bases were paired. These biases are (now) consistent with the high percentage of unpaired adenosine nucleotides in several structure motifs.An analysis of a larger set of bacterial comparative 16 S and 23 S rRNA structure models has substantiated this initial finding and revealed new biases in the distribution of adenosine nucleotides in loop regions. The majority of the adenosine nucleotides are unpaired, while the majority of the G, C, and U bases are paired in the covariation-based structure model. The unpaired adenosine nucleotides predominate in the middle and at the 3' end of loops, and are the second most frequent nucleotide type at the 5' end of loops (G is the most common nucleotide). There are additional biases for unpaired adenosine nucleotides at the 3' end of loops and adjacent to a G at the 5' end of the helix. The most prevalent consecutive nucleotides are GG, GA, AG, and AA. A total of 70 % of the GG sequences are within helices, while more than 70 % of the AA sequences are unpaired. Nearly 50 % of the GA sequences are unpaired, and approximately one-third of the AG sequences are within helices while another third are at the 3' loop.5' helix junction. Unpaired positions with an adenosine nucleotide in more than 50 % of the sequences at the 3' end of 16 S and 23 S rRNA loops were identified and arranged into the A-motif categories XAZ, AAZ, XAG, AAG, and AAG:U, where G or Z is paired, G:U is a base-pair, and X is not an A and Z is not a G in more than 50 % of the sequences. These sequence motifs were associated with several structural motifs, such as adenosine platforms, E and E-like loops, A:A and A:G pairings at the end of helices, G:A tandem base-pairs, GNRA tetraloop hairpins, and U-turns.     

Recognition signals for mouse pre-rRNA processing

In order to identify signals for rRNA processing in eukaryotes, mouse pre-rRNA sequence features around four cleavage sites have been analyzed. No consensus sequence can be recognized when the four boundary regions are examined. Unlike mature rRNA termini, distal sequences of precursor-specific domains cannot participate in stable duplex with adjacent regions. The extensive divergence of precursor-specific sequences during evolution also applies to nucleotides adjacent to cleavage sites, with a significant exception for a conserved segment immediately downstream 5.8S rRNA. A specific role is proposed for U3 nucleolar RNA in the conversion of 32S pre-rRNA into mature 28S rRNA, through base-pairing with precursor-specific sequences at the boundaries of excised domains.     

Functional analysis of internal transcribed spacer 2 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae ribosomal DNA.

Using the previously described "tagged ribosome" (pORCS) system for in vivo mutational analysis of yeast rDNA, we show that small deletions in the 5'-terminal portion of ITS2 completely block maturation of 26 S rRNA at the level of the 29 SB precursor (5.8 S rRNA-ITS2-26 S rRNA). Various deletions in the 3'-terminal part, although severely reducing the efficiency of processing, still allow some mature 26 S rRNA to be formed. On the other hand, none of the ITS2 deletions affect the production of mature 17 S rRNA. Since all of the deletions severely disturb the recently proposed secondary structure of ITS2, these findings suggest an important role for higher order structure of ITS2 in processing. Analysis of the effect of complete or partial replacement of S. cerevisiae ITS2 with its counterpart sequences from Saccharomyces rosei or Hansenula wingei, points to helix V of the secondary structure model as an important element for correct and efficient processing. Direct mutational analysis shows that disruption of base-pairing in the middle of helix V does not detectably affect 26 S rRNA formation. In contrast, introduction of clustered point mutations at the apical end of helix V that both disrupt base-pairing and change the sequence of the loop, severely reduces processing. Since a mutant containing only point mutations in the sequence of the loop produces normal amounts of mature 26 S rRNA, we conclude that the precise (secondary and/or primary) structure at the lower end of helix V, but excluding the loop, is of crucial importance for efficient removal of ITS2.     

The 3''-terminal region of bacterial 23S ribosomal RNA: structure and homology with the 3''-terminal region of eukaryotic 28S rRNA and with chloroplast 4.5s rRNA.

The sequence of the 110 nucleotide fragment located at the 3'-end of E.coli, P.vulgaris and A.punctata 23S rRNAs has been determined. The homology between the E.coli and P.vulgaris fragments is 90%, whereas that between the E.coli and A.punctate fragments is only 60%. The three rRNA fragments have sequences compatible with a secondary structure consisting of two hairpins. Using chemical and enzymatic methods recently developed for the study of the secondary structure of RNA, we demonstrated that one of these hairpins and part of the other are actually present in the three 3'-terminal fragments in solution. This supports the existence of these two hairpins in the intact molecule. Indeed, results obtained upon limited digestion of intact 23S RNA with T1 RNase were in good agreement with the existence of these two hairpins. We observed that the primary structures of the 3'-terminal regions of yeast 26S rRNA and X.laevis 28S rRNA are both compatible with a secondary structure similar to that found at the 3'-end of bacterial 23S rRNAs. Furthermore, both tobacco and wheat chloroplast 4.5S rRNAs can also be folded in a similar way as the 3'-terminal region of bacterial 23S rRNA, the 3'-end of chloroplast 4.5S rRNAs being complementary to the 5'-end of chloroplast 23S rRNA. This strongly reinforces the hypothesis that chloroplast 4.5S rRNA originates from the 3'-end of bacterial 23S rRNA and suggests that this rRNA may be base-paired with the 5'-end of chloroplast 23S rRNA. Invariant oligonucleotides are present at identical positions in the homologous secondary structures of E.coli 23S, yeast 26S, X.laevis 28S and wheat and tobacco 4.5S rRNAs. Surprisingly, the sequences of these oligonucleotides are not all conserved in the 3'-terminal regions of A.punctata or even P.vulgaris 23S rRNAs. Results obtained upon mild methylation of E.coli 50S subunits with dimethylsulfate strongly suggest that these invariant oligonucleotides are involved in RNA tertiary structure or in RNA-protein interactions.     

Structural studies on site-directed mutants of domain 3 of Xenopus laevis oocyte 5 S ribosomal RNA

Base substitutions have been introduced into the highly conserved sequences of loops D and E within domain 3 of Xenopus laevis oocyte 5 S rRNA. The effects of these mutations on the solution structure of this 5 S rRNA have been studied by means of probing with nucleases, and with chemical reagents under native and semi-denaturing conditions. The data obtained with these mutants support the graphic model of Xenopus oocyte 5 S rRNA proposed by Westhof et al. In particular, our results rule out the existence of long-range base-pairing interactions between loop C and either loop D or loop E. The data also confirm that loops D and E in the wild-type 5 S RNA adopt unusual secondary structures and illustrate the importance of nucleotide sequence in the formation of intrinsic local loop conformations via non-canonical base-pairs and specific base-phosphate contacts. Consistent with this conclusion is our observation that the domain 3 fragment of Xenopus oocyte 5 S rRNA adopts the same conformation as the corresponding region in the full-length 5 S rRNA.     

Nucleotide sequence of a Euglena gracilis chloroplast gene coding for the 16S rRNA: homologies to E. coli and Zea mays chloroplast 16S rRNA

The nucleotide sequence of 16S rDNA from Euglena gracilis chloroplasts has been determined representing the first complete sequence of an algal chloroplast rRNA gene. The structural part of the 16S rRNA gene has 1491 nucleotides according to a comparative analysis of our sequencing results with the published 5'- and 3'-terminal "T1-oligonucleotides" from 16S rRNA from E. gracilis. Alignment with 16S rDNA from Zea mays chloroplasts and E. coli reveals 80 to 72% sequence homology, respectively. Two deletions of 9 and 23 nucleotides are found which are identical in size and position with deletions observed in 16S rDNA of maize and tobacco chloroplasts and which seem to be characteristic for all chloroplast rRNA species. We also find insertions and deletions in E. gracilis not seen in 16S rDNA of higher plant chloroplasts. The 16S rRNA sequence of E. gracilis chloroplasts can be folded by base pairing according to the general 16S rRNA secondary structure model.     

U17/snR30 is a ubiquitous snoRNA with two conserved sequence motifs essential for 18S rRNA production

Saccharomyces cerevisiae snR30 is an essential box H/ACA small nucleolar RNA (snoRNA) required for the processing of 18S rRNA. Here, we show that the previously characterized human, reptilian, amphibian, and fish U17 snoRNAs represent the vertebrate homologues of yeast snR30. We also demonstrate that U17/snR30 is present in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe and the unicellular ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila. Evolutionary comparison revealed that the 3'-terminal hairpins of U17/snR30 snoRNAs contain two highly conserved sequence motifs, the m1 (AUAUUCCUA) and m2 (AAACCAU) elements. Mutation analysis of yeast snR30 demonstrated that the m1 and m2 elements are essential for early cleavages of the 35S pre-rRNA and, consequently, for the production of mature 18S rRNA. The m1 and m2 motifs occupy the opposite strands of an internal loop structure, and they are located invariantly 7 nucleotides upstream from the ACA box of U17/snR30 snoRNAs. U17/snR30 is the first identified box H/ACA snoRNA that possesses an evolutionarily conserved role in the nucleolytic processing of eukaryotic pre-rRNA.     

Intermolecular hybridization of 5S rRNA with 18S rRNA: identification of a 5'-terminally-located nucleotide sequence in mouse 5S rRNA which base-pairs with two specific complementary sequences in 18S rRNA.

Eukaryotic 5S rRNA hybridizes specifically with 18S rRNA in vitro to form a stable intermolecular RNA:RNA hybrid. We have used 5S rRNA/18S rRNA fragment hybridization studies coupled with ribonuclease digestion and primer extension/chain termination analysis of 5S rRNA:18S rRNA hybrids to more completely map those mouse 5S rRNA and 18S rRNA sequences responsible for duplex formation. Fragment hybridization analysis has defined a 5'-terminal region of 5S rRNA (nucleotides 6-27) which base-pairs with two independent sequences in 18S rRNA designated Regions 1 (nucleotides 1157-1180) and 2 (nucleotides 1324-1339). Ribonuclease digestion of isolated 5S rRNA:18S rRNA hybrids with both single-strand- and double-strand-specific nucleases supports the involvement of this 5'-terminal 5S rRNA sequence in 18S rRNA hybridization. Primer extension/chain termination analysis of isolated 5S rRNA:18S rRNA hybrids confirms the base-pairing of 5S rRNA to the designated Regions 1 and 2 of 18S rRNA. Using these results, 5S rRNA:18S rRNA intermolecular hybrid structures are proposed. Comparative sequence analysis revealed the conservation of these hybrid structures in higher eukaryotes and the same but smaller core hybrid structures in lower eukaryotes and prokaryotes. This suggests that the 5S rRNA:16S/18S rRNA hybrids have been conserved in evolution for ribosome function.