The effect of inoculation with Azospirillum brasilense on growth and nitrogen utilization by wheat plants

Azospirillium brasilense is a rhizosphere bacteria that has been reported to improve yield when inoculated on wheat plants. However, the mechanisms through which this effect is induced is still unclear. In the present work, we have studied the effects of inoculating a highly efficient A. brasilense strain on wheat plant grown in 5 kg pots with soil in a greenhouse, under three N regimes (0, 3 or 16 mM NO₃ ^–, 50 ml/pot once or twice-a -week), and in disinfected or non-disinfected soil. At the booting stage, the inoculated roots in both soils showed a similar colonization by Azospirillum sp. that was not affected by N addition. The plants grown in the disinfected soil showed a higher biomass, N content and N concentration than those in the non-disinfected soil, and in both soils the inoculation stimulated plant growth, N accumulation, and N and NO₃ ^– concentration in the tissues.At maturity, the inoculated plants showed a higher biomass, grain yield and N content than the uninoculated ones in both soils, and a higher grain protein concentration than the uninoculated. It is concluded that in the present experiments, A. brasilenseincreased plant growth by stimulating nitrogen uptake by the roots.     

Nutrition of sorghum plants fertilized with nitrogen or inoculated withAzospirillum brasilense

Summary Sorghum plants were inoculated withAzospirillum brasilense or received an N-amended nutrient solution. Azospirillum inoculation increased plant dry weight and nitrogen assimilation by 25%. Most plant growth responses to Azospirillum were comparable to application of 2.0 mM N. Increased scavenging of nutrients, altered root permeability or nitrogen fixation are possible explanations for these effects.This work was supported by the United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service (CRIS No. 5102-20170-001) in collaboration with the University of California, Berkeley. Requests for reqrints to G. J. Bethlenfalvay.     

Use ofAzospirillum brasilense as biofertilizer in intensive wheat cropping

Summary Three field experiments were conducted on ten cultivars of winterwheat and four cultivars of springwheat to estimate the growth promoting effect ofAzospirillum brasilense under varying nitrogen doses. Independent of cultivar selection or nitrogen dose a highly significant yield increase could be observed in winterwheat: strains S631 and SpBr14 increased the average grain yield with 9.14% and 14.82% respectively. When the yield components were studied a coinciding increase in ear density could be demonstrated of resp. 10.57% and 13.55%. Less significant results were obtained with springwheat although in one experiment strain SpBr14 significantly increased grain yield. As with winterwheat tillering of the plant was markedly affected by inoculation with both strains. In a companion greenhouse experiment it was found that inoculation with Azospirillum can cause a decrease in the root mass of wheatplants except when strain SpBr14 is used. Therefore it is suggested that the presence of a higher tillering together with an undisturbed nutrient uptake capacity can result in yield increases after inoculation withAzospirillum brasilense.     

15N-Determined effect of inoculation with N2 fixing bacteria on nitrogen assimilation in Western Canadian wheats

Summary A two-year field study was undertaken using¹⁵N isotope techniques to differentiate between stimulation of N uptake and N₂ fixation in Western Canadian cultivars of spring wheat (Triticum aestivum L. emend Thell) and durum (T. turgidum L. emend Bowden) in response to inoculation with N₂-fixing bacteria. Bacterial inoculation either had no effect or lowered the % N derived from the fertilizer and the fertilizer use efficiency. Despite the depression of fertilizer uptake, inoculants did not alter the relative uptake from soil and fertilizer-N pools indicating that bacterial inoculation did not alter rooting patterns. Nitrogen-15 isotope dilution indicated that N₂ fixation did occur. In 1984, % plant N derived from the atmosphere (% Ndfa) due to inoculation with Bacillus C-11-25 averaged 23.9% while that withAzospirillum brasilense ATCC 29729 (Cd) averaged 15.5%. In 1985, higher soil N levels reduced these values by approximately one-half. Cultivar x inoculant interactions, while significant, were not consistent across years. However, these interactions did not affect cultivars ‘Cadet’ and ‘Rescue’. In agreement with previous results, ‘Cadet’ performed well with all inoculants in both years while ‘Rescue’ performed poorly. Among 1984 treatments, the N increament in inoculated plants was positively correlated with % Ndfa but no such correlation existed in 1985. N₂ fixation averaged over all cultivars and strains was 17.9 and 6.7 kg N fixed ha⁻¹ in 1984 and 1985, respectively. Highest rates of N₂ fixation were estimated at 52.4 kg N ha⁻¹ for ‘Cadet’ in 1984 and 31.3 kg N ha⁻¹ for ‘Owens’ in 1985, both inoculated with Bacillus C-11-25, an isolate from southern Alberta soils. Inoculation with either ofAzospirillum brasilense strain Cd (ATCC29729) or 245 did not result in as consistent or as high N₂ fixation, suggesting that these wheats had not evolved genetic compatability with this exogenous microorganism. These agronomically significant amounts of N₂ fixation occurred under optimally controlled experimental conditions in the field. It is yet to be determined if N₂ fixation would occur in response to bacterial inoculation under dryland conditions commonly occurring in Western Canada. Contribution from Agriculture Canada Research Station, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada.     

Relationships between cell membrane stability, exudate content and infectivity of Bradyrhizobium japonicum strain 639 to boron starved soybean plants

The influence of boron starvation on the root exudates content in soybean seedlings (Glycine max. L. Merr.) and the effect of exudates pretreatment on the pre-infection processes in symbiotic system Br. japonicum strain 636 and soybean were investigated. Root cell membrane stability of boron starved soybean plants (-B) decreased compared to the control. The concentrations of all analyzed metabolites (reducing sugars, free amino acids, organic acids, soluble phenols and total flavonoids) from root exudates of -B plants were lower than the control concentrations. Analysis of polyphenols after HPLC chromatography of root exudates showed significant difference of peak numbers between chromatograms of exudates obtained from boron starved and from control plants. Bacterial culture treatment with root exudates from -B plants showed decreased growth, chemotaxis and attachment ability toward the host root compared to the control exudate treatments. These changes were accompanied by decreased nodulation and acetylene reduction activity of boron starved soybean plants.     

Endophytic Establishment of Diazotrophic Bacteria in Auxin-Induced Tumors of Cereal Crops

Gramineous crops such as wheat (triticum oestivum), maize (zea mays), and rice (oryza sativa) develop tumorous structures (para-nodules) along primary and secondary roots when treated with low concentrations of various auxins. Rice forms additional tumors along its hypocotyle. Histologically, auxin-induced tumors appear as cancerous grown out root meristems and thus are comparable in origin and structure to stem nodules of the legume sesbania rostrata. Auxin-affected root meristems do not recover and develop further to large nodule-like organs. Introduced diazotrophs (Azospirillum spp., Azorhizobium caulinodans, Rhizobium spp.) potentially inhabit tissues of both stem and root tumors with the central meristem as a major colonization niche. Evidence is given that infecting bacteria follow a ‘crack entry’ invasion at sites where developing tumors have emerged through the root cortex and epidermis. Bacteria are shown to establish with high cell numbers inside intercellular spaces of cortical and meristematic tissues. Plant-cell infection of tumor cells takes place with bacteria found inside the cell-cytoplasm surrounded by membrane-like structures. Once inhabiting induced tumor tissues introduced diazotrophs colonize endophytically with high cell numbers. Mutant, ammonium-excreting and thus ecologically disadvantaged A. brasilense is shown to survive inside para-nodulating maize and rice plants with a dense population. Micro-aerobic nitrogenase activities of tumor inhabiting diazotrophic bacteria (A. brasilense, Azotobacter vinelandii, A. caulonidans) are in general highly increased when compared with untreated control plants. Additionally, bacterial nitrogenase activity is less sensitive to an increased oxygen tension in the root environment. The host plants benefit from the enhanced nitrogen fixation in their para-nodulating roots. Highest rates of incorporation of fixed nitrogen into host plant material is reported for para-nodule inhabiting ammonium excreting A. brasilense strain C3. The host plant potentially stimulates the nitrogenase activity of endophytically colonizing diazotrophs by providing energy in the form of a suitable carbon source. In conclusion, it is demonstrated that gramineous plants are potentially capable of developing an endophytical diazotrophic symbiosis through para-nodule formation.     

Inoculationin vitro of wheat seedlings and wheat straw cultures withBacillus azotofixans

Bacillus azotofixans is a recently described species capable of fixing molecular nitrogen efficiently.Ecological studies performed in monoxenic wheat cultures, both in 0.7% agar and in vermiculite-sand mixture, showed that no acetylene reduction occurred and that this bacteria did not grow when supplied only with the wheat plant root exudates. However, after glucose addition to the 0.7% agar cultures, acetylene reduction ability (ARA) was detected. Comparing ARA for media with glucose both with and without plants, it was observed that the plants supply some component leading to the increase of the nitrogenase activity, since the ARA doubled in the samples containing plants.In wheat straw cultures a fast growth of the bacteria was observed in the first 24 hours after inoculation, but no acetylene reduction was detected. After glucose addition to the media with and without straw, nitrogenase activity was detected.     

Attachment,colonization and proliferation ofAzospirillum brasilense andEnterobacter spp. on root surface of grasses

Root colonization studies, employing immunofluorescence and using locally isolated strains, showed thatEnterbacter sp. QH7 andEnterobacter agglomerans AX12 attached more readily to the roots of most plants compared withAzospirillum brasilense JM82. Heat treatment of either root or inoculum significantly decreased the adsorption of bacteria to the root surface. Kallar grass and rice root exudates sustained the growth ofA. brasilense JM82,Enterobacter sp. QH7 andE. agglomerans AX12 in Hoagland and Fahraeus medium. All the strains colonized kallar grass and rice roots in an axenic culture system. However, in studies involving mixed cultures,A. brasilense JM82 was inhibited byEnterobacter sp. QH7 in kallar grass rhizosphere and the simultaneous presence ofEnterobacter sp. QH7 andE. agglomerans AX12 suppressed the growth ofA. brasilense JM82 in rice rhizosphere. The bacterial colonization pattern changed from dispersed to aggregated within 3 days of inoculation. The colonization sites corresponded mainly to the areas where root mucigel was present. The area around the point of emergence of lateral roots usually showed maximum colonization.     

Natural occurrence of Azospirillum brasilense in strawberry plants

Azospirillum species are free-living nitrogen-fixing bacteria commonly found in soil and in association with roots of different plant species. For their capacity to stimulate growth they are known as plant growth-promoting bacteria (PGPB). In this work, we demonstrate the natural occurrence and colonization of different parts of strawberry plants by Azospirillum brasilense in the cropping area of Tucumán, Argentina. Although bacteria isolations were carried out from two strawberry cultivars, e.g., Camarosa and Pájaro, attempts were successful only with the cultivar Camarosa. Whereas different strains of Azospirillum were isolated from the root surface and inner tissues of roots and stolons of the cultivar Camarosa, we have not obtained Azospirillum isolates from the cultivar Pájaro. After microbiological and molecular characterization (ARDRA) we determined that the isolates belonged to the species A. brasilense. All isolates showed to have the capacity to fix nitrogen, to produce siderophores and indoles. Local isolates exhibited different yields of indoles production when growing in N-free NFb semisolid media supplemented or not with tryptophan (0.1 mg ml⁻¹). This is the first report on the natural occurrence of A. brasilense in strawberry plants, especially colonizing inner tissues of stolons, as well as roots. The local isolates showed three important characteristics within the PGPB group: N₂-fixation, siderophores, and indoles production.     

Interaction between alfalfa cultivars and Rhizobium strains for nitrogen Fixation

Summary Two experiments were conducted in the greenhouse to study the interaction between alfalfa cultivars (Medicago sativa L. and M. falcata L.) and strains of Rhizobium meliloti Dang. for acetylene reduction rate, plant height and dry weights of shoot, root and whole plant. Fifteen alfalfa cultivars were inoculated with 10 strains of Rhizobium in Experiment I. Variance component analysis revealed that more than 30% of the total variance was due to alfalfa cultivars for acetylene reduction rate and 26% was accounted for by Rhizobium strains. More than 36% of the total variation was attributed to the interaction between alfalfa cultivars and Rhizobium strains for this character. Twenty-five host cultivars and 11 Rhizobium strains were included in Experiment II. The results also showed that the interaction of alfalfa cultivars and Rhizobium strains contributed the largest portion of the total variation for dry weights of shoot, root and whole plant and acetylene reduction rate. The results clearly demonstrated that the non-additive effects were the major component of variation for these characters associated with nitrogen fixation in alfalfa. Therefore, an effective way of improving nitrogen fixation in alfalfa is to select for a favourable combination of specific Rhizobium strains and alfalfa cultivars.     

Strain-specific salt tolerance and chemotaxis ofAzospirillum brasilense and their associative N-fixation with finger millet in saline calcareous soil

Three salt-tolerantAzospirillum brasilense strains were isolated from the roots of finger millet grown in saline calcareous soil and characterized. The effect of various salts on growth and N₂ase activity of these strains was tested and strain STR1 was found more tolerant at higher concentrations of Cl^-, SO₄ ² and HCO₃ ^-. Bicarbonate was found to be the most toxic. The content and concentrations of root exudates of finger millet genotypes were different and chemotaxis to sugars, amino acids, organic acids and root exudates was strain specific. Under salt stress, significant interactions between strains and genotypes of finger millet resulted in different responses of N₂ase activity, endo- and exorhizospheric population, dry weight of root, shoot and grain yield.     

Chemotaxis ofAzospirillum brasilense towards compounds typical of plant root exudates

Nitrogen-fixingAzospirillum brasilense exhibits positive chemotaxis towards a large number of organic compounds (amino acids, saccharides, organic acids) typical for plant root exudates. The most effective attractants were malate, succinate, fructose and other compounds which serve as substrates forA. brasilense. Chemotactic response towards the majority of compounds was inducible, but in case of malate and succinate it was constitutive. Tactic response during the nitrogen-fixing process was essentially the same as in the presence of fixed nitrogen in the medium. Among organic compounds tested no repellents were found.     

Changes in Azospirillum brasilense motility and the effect of wheat seedling exudates

The rhizobacterium Azospirillum brasilense Sp245 swims, swarms (Swa⁺ phenotype) or, very rarely, migrates with the formation of granular macrocolonies (Gri⁺ phenotype). Our aims were (i) to identify Sp245 mutants that swarm faster than the parent strain or differ from it in the mode of spreading and (ii) to compare the mutants’ responses to wheat seedling exudates. In isotropic liquid media, the swimming speeds of all motile A. brasilense strains were not influenced by the exudates. However, the exudates significantly stimulated the swarming of Sp245. In several Sp245 mutants, the superswarming phenotype was insensitive to local colonial density and to the presence of wheat seedling exudates. An A. brasilense polar-flagellum-defective Gri⁺ mutant BK759.G gave rise to stable Swa⁺⁺ derivatives with restored flagellum production. This transition was concurrent with plasmid rearrangements and was stimulated in the presence of wheat seedling exudates. The swarming rate of the Swa⁺⁺ derivatives of BK759.G was affected by the local density of their colonies but not by the presence of the exudates.     

Lack of effect of toxic aluminium concentrations on nitrogen fixation by nodulatedStylosanthes species

Summary Effects of three solution aluminium concentrations (0, 25, and 100M) on nitrogen fixation by well-nodulated plants ofStylosanthes hamata, Stylosanthes humilis andStylosanthes scabra are reported. Plants were inoculated with Rhizobium CB756 and grown for 21 days in an aluminium-free nutrient solution at pH 5.3 before imposition of the aluminium treatments.Nitrogen fixation was measured both by the increase in total nitrogen content of the plants and acetylene reduction in roots of plants harvested at 10 and 20 days after imposition of the aluminium treatments. Solution aluminium concentrations as high as 100M, had no detrimental effect on nitrogen fixation in any species.     

Effect of different levels of mineral nitrogen on nodulation and N2 fixation of two cultivars of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.)

An experiment was conducted under greenhouse conditions to evaluate the effect of mineral nitrogen on N₂ fixation of two cultivars of Phaseolus vulgaris L., Puebla 152 and Negro Argel. Nitrogen application was 0, 2.5, 12.5 and 25 mg N Kg^–1 of a vermiculite-sand-mixture at planting time. Shoot and root growth were elevated by nitrogen application at all growth stages. During vegetative growth (V 5) nodule dry weight and nitrogenase activity (acetylene reducing activity) per plant were reduced by nitrogen supply in both cultivars, but less in Negro Argel than in Puebla 152. At later stages nodulation in nitrogen-treated Puebla 152 did not differ from that in non-treated plants, whereas increased nodule number was found in Negro Argel at high nitrogen levels. The influence of mineral N on the total amount of nitrogen fixed in the two bean cultivars was only slightly different.     

Influence of combined nitrogen level andEucalyptus competition on dinitrogen fixation in nodulatedCasuarina

Summary Experiments were conducted to determine the effect on biological dinitrogen fixation byCasuarina of available nitrogen (N) in the substrate and competition by interplantedEucalyptus. In these experiments, combined N was applied to the plants after nodules were developed and functioning. Both environmental factors, nitrate and competition, were observed to influence biological dinitrogen fixation byCasuarina, but not yield (total dry weight). In one experiment, the proportion of nitrogen derived byCasuarina from atmospheric fixation (pNdfa) was observed to be inhibited by potassium nitrate in a linear fashion. However, substrate N did not significantly affect the weight of root nodules. Thus nodule dry weight was not highly correlated with the proportion of nitrogen fixed. In a second experiment, the presence of a non-fixing interplanted species,Eucalyptus, increased dinitrogen fixation inCasuarina.Casuarina interplanted withEucalyptus obtained a greater proportion of its nitrogen (94.75%) from fixation than didCasuarina grown alone (86.68%) suggesting that competition for substrate N influences the proportion of nitrogen fixed by this actinorhizal plant.Dedicated to the memory of Professor John G. Torrey     

Rhizospheric exudation of Eriophorum vaginatum L. — Potential link to methanogenesis

Root exudates are a direct link between primary production in higher plants and methanogenesis. The relationship has been widely studied on rice paddies, but less is known about its role in wetlands populated by naturally occurring species. This study provides information about the amount and composition of root exudates produced by a widespread mire plant, Eriophorum vaginatum L. For this purpose, E. vaginatum plants were grown in quartz sand in pots from April to October, and root exudates were collected once a month by percolation of the cultivation substrate. In June and October, a set of plants was labelled with ¹⁴CO₂ for two days and subsequently harvested for the determination of dry weight and for root exudates collected by the dipping method. The study supports earlier findings that natural wetland plants can enhance methanogenesis in their rhizosphere via active and seasonally varying exudation, but that the amount of exuded carbon (C) is many times lower than that delivered via litter formation. At both harvests in June and October, the proportion of incorporated radioactivity in shoots, roots and exudates was 92–96%, 4–8%, and 0.2%, respectively. New C was primarily fixed in the metabolically important carbohydrates, as well as acid anions that composed the main compounds of the new exudates. However, microbes seemed to rapidly metabolise the exudates into other substances like acetate. This was the dominant compound in the rhizoplane and rhizosphere, and it was the only detected substance that occurred in higher amounts outside the roots than inside them. Further studies in the field, including the quantification of gaseous end products, are necessary to complete our understanding of the carbon cycling in E. vaginatum-soil-microbe-system.     

Striga seed-germination activity of root exudates and compounds present in stems of Striga host and nonhost (trap crop) plants is reduced due to root colonization by arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi

Root colonization by arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi reduces stimulation of seed germination of the plant parasite Striga (Orobanchaceae). This reduction can affect not only host plants for Striga, resulting in a lower parasite incidence, but also false hosts or trap crops, which induce suicidal Striga seed germination, thereby diminishing their effectiveness. In order to better understand these AM-induced effects, we tested the influence of root colonization by different AM fungi on the seed-germination activity of root exudates of the Striga hermonthica nonhost plants cowpea and cotton on S. hermonthica. We also tested the effect of AM fungi on the seed-germination activity of the Striga gesnerioides host plant cowpea on S. gesnerioides. Moreover, we studied whether mycorrhization affects the transport of seed-germination activity to above-ground plant parts. Mycorrhization not only resulted in a lower seed germination of S. gesnerioides in the presence of root exudates of the S. gesnerioides host cowpea but also seed germination of S. hermonthica was also lower in the presence of root exudates of the S. hermonthica nonhosts cowpea and cotton. Downregulation of the Striga seed-germination activity occurs not only in root exudates upon root colonization by different AM fungi but also in the compounds produced by stems. The lowered seed-germination activity does not appear to depend on the presence of seed germination inhibitors in the root exudates of mycorrhizal plants. The implication for Striga control in the field is discussed.     

Ecophysiological aspects of growth and nitrogen fixation inAzospirillum spp.

The nitrogenase activity ofAzospirillum spp. is efficiently regulated by environmental factors. InA. brasilense andA. lipoferum a rapid switch off of nitrogenase activity occurs after the addition of ammonium chloride. As in photosynthetic bacteria, a covalent modification of nitrogenase reductase (Fe-protein) is involved. InA. amazonense, a non-covalent mechanism causes only a partial inhibition of nitrogenase activity after ammonium chloride is added. In anaerobic conditions, nitrogenase reductase is also switched off by a covalent modification inA. brasilense andA. lipoferum. Short-time exposure ofAzospirillum to increased oxygen levels causes a partially reversible inhibition of nitrogenase activity, but no covalent modification is involved.Azospirillum spp. show variations in their oxygen tolerance. High levels of carotenoids confer a slightly improved oxygen tolerance. Certain amino acids (e. g. glutamate, aspartate, histidine and serine) affect growth and nitrogen fixation differently inAzospirillum spp. Amino acids may influence growth and nitrogen fixation ofAzospirillum in the association with plants.Azospirillum brasilense andA. halopraeferens are the more osmotolerant species. They utilize most amino acids poorly and accumulate glycine betaine, which also occurs in osmotically stressed grasses as a compatible solute to counteract osmotic stress. Nitrogen fixation is stimulated by glycine betaine and choline. Efficient iron acquisition is a prerequisite for competitive and aerotoleran growth and for high nitrogenase activity.Azospirillum halopraeferens andA. amazonense assimilate iron reasonably well, whereas growth of someA. brasilense andA. lipoferum strains is severely inhibited by iron limitation and by competition with foreign microbial iron chelators. However, growth of certain iron-limitedA. brasilense strains is stimulated by the phytosiderophore mugineic acid. Thus, various plant-derived substances may stimulate growth and nitrogen fixation ofAzospirillum.     

Colonization of wheat by Azospirillum brasilense Cd is impaired by saline stress

The effect of saline stress on the colonization of wheat was analyzed by using Azospirillum brasilense Cd carrying the fusion of the reporter gene lacZ (β-galactosidase) with the N₂ fixation gene promoter nifA. Colonization was also studied by inducing para-nodules on wheat roots using 2,4-D, establishing that these structures acted as bacterium protected niches. Bacteria grown under standard conditions were distributed along the whole root system, except the elongation zone, and colonized the para-nodules. Bacteria experiencing saline stress were mainly localized at the root tips and the lateral roots. In 2,4-D treated plants, most of the bacteria were present around the basal surface of the modified lateral root structures. Using the MPN method, there were not statistical differences between the numbers of control and stressed bacteria. As this method estimates endophytic colonization in contrast with the one using X-gal, which emphasizes colonization on the root surface, both procedures demonstrated to be necessary, concluding that salt treatment reduced surface colonization (X-gal) but not colonization inside the root. The bacterial counts made on inoculated wheat roots indicated higher numbers of both control and stressed bacteria in roots treated with 2,4-D compared with untreated roots. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.