The α-Helix 4 Residue, Asn135, Is Involved in the Oligomerization of Cry1Ac1 and Cry1Ab5 Bacillus thuringiensis Toxins

The insecticidal Cry toxins produced by the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis are comprised of three structural domains. Domain I, a seven-helix bundle, is thought to penetrate the insect epithelial cell plasma membrane through a hairpin composed of α-helices 4 and 5, followed by the oligomerization of four hairpin monomers. The α-helix 4 has been proposed to line the lumen of the pore, whereas some residues in α-helix 5 have been shown to be responsible for oligomerization. Mutation of the Cry1Ac1 α-helix 4 amino acid Asn135 to Gln resulted in the loss of toxicity to Manduca sexta, yet binding was still observed. In this study, the equivalent mutation was made in the Cry1Ab5 toxin, and the properties of both wild-type and mutant toxin counterparts were analyzed. Both mutants appeared to bind to M. sexta membrane vesicles, but they were not able to form pores. The ability of both N135Q mutants to oligomerize was also disrupted, providing the first evidence that a residue in α-helix 4 can contribute to toxin oligomerization.     

Structural and functional studies of alpha-helix 5 region from Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab delta-endotoxin

The crystal insecticidal proteins from Bacillus thuringiensis are modular proteins comprised of three domains connected by single linkers. Domain I is a seven alpha-helix bundle, which has been involved in membrane insertion and pore formation activity. Site-directed mutagenesis has contributed to identify regions that might play an important role in the structure of the pore-forming domain within the membrane. There are several evidences that support that the hairpin alpha4-alpha5 inserts into the membrane in an antiparallel manner, while other helices lie on the membrane surface. We hypothesized that highly conserved residues of alpha5 could play an important role in toxin insertion, oligomerization and/or pore formation. A total of 15 Cry1Ab mutants located in six conserved residues of Cry1Ab, Y153, Y161, H168, R173, W182 and G183, were isolated. Eleven mutants were located within helix alpha5, one mutant was located in the loop alpha4-alpha5 and three mutants, W182P, W182I and G183C, were located in the loop alpha5-alpha6. Their effect on binding, K(+) permeability and toxicity against Manduca sexta larvae was analyzed and compared. The results provide direct evidence that some residues located within alpha5 have an important role in stability of the toxin within the insect gut, while some others also have an important role in pore formation. The results also provide evidence that conserved residues within helix alpha5 are not involved in oligomer formation since mutations in these residues are able to make pores in vitro.     

Role of alpha-helix seven of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab delta-endotoxin in membrane insertion, structural stability, and ion channel activity

Domain I of the Cry1Ab insecticidal toxic protein has seven alpha-helices and is considered to be involved in the ion channel activity. While other alpha-helices, particularly alpha-4 and alpha-5, have been extensively explored, the remaining alpha-helices have been slightly studied. Site-directed mutagenesis was used to generate mutations throughout sequences encoding the alpha-helix 7 to test its role in ion channel function. Every amino acid residue in alpha-helix 7 was mutated to alanine. Most resultant proteins, e.g., D225A, W226A, Y229A, N230A, R233A, R234A, D242A, and F247A yielded no protoxin or were sensitive to degradation by trypsin or Manduca sexta midgut juice. Other mutant proteins, R224A, R228A, and E235A, were resistant to degradation to the above proteases but were 8, 30, and 12 times less toxic to M. sexta, respectively, than the wild-type Cry1Ab. Circular dichroism spectroscopy indicated a very small change in the R228A spectrum, while R224A and E235A display the same spectrum as the wild-type protein. These three mutant proteins showed little differences from Cry1Ab when analyzed by saturation binding and competition binding kinetics with (125)I-labeled toxin or by surface plasmon resonance to M. sexta brush border membrane vesicles. More conservative amino acid substitutions were introduced into alpha-helix 7 residues: R228K, F232Y, E235Q, and F247Y. In comparison with wild-type Cry1Ab, mutant proteins R228K, F232Y, E235A, and E235Q selectively discriminate between K+ and Rb+, while R224A and R228A had reduced inhibition of short-circuit current for both ions, when analyzed by voltage clamping of M. sexta midguts.     

Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab mutants affecting oligomer formation are non-toxic to Manduca sexta larvae

Pore-forming toxins are biological weapons produced by a variety of living organisms, particularly bacteria but also by insects, reptiles, and invertebrates. These proteins affect the cell membrane of their target, disrupting permeability and leading eventually to cell death. The pore-forming toxins typically transform from soluble, monomeric proteins to oligomers that form transmembrane channels. The Cry toxins produced by Bacillus thuringiensis are widely used as insecticides. These proteins have been recognized as pore-forming toxins, and their primary action is to lyse midgut epithelial cells in their target insect. To exert their toxic effect, a prepore oligomeric intermediate is formed leading finally to membrane-inserted oligomeric pores. To understand the role of Cry oligomeric pre-pore formation in the insecticidal activity we isolated point mutations that affected toxin oligomerization but not their binding with the cadherin-like, Bt-R(1) receptor. We show the helix alpha-3 in domain I contains sequences that could form coiled-coil structures important for oligomerization. Some single point mutants in this helix bound Bt-R(1) receptors with similar affinity as the wild-type toxin, but were affected in oligomerization and were severally impaired in pore formation and toxicity against Manduca sexta larvae. These data indicate the pre-pore oligomer and the toxin pore formation play a major role in the intoxication process of Cry1Ab toxin in insect larvae.     

Role of interdomain salt bridges in the pore-forming ability of the Bacillus thuringiensis toxins Cry1Aa and Cry1Ac

The four salt bridges (Asp(222)-Arg(281), Arg(233)-Glu(288), Arg(234)-Glu(274), and Asp(242)-Arg(265)) linking domains I and II in Cry1Aa were abolished individually in alpha-helix 7 mutants D222A, R233A, R234A, and D242A. Two additional mutants targeting the fourth salt bridge (R265A) and the double mutant (D242A/R265A) were rapidly degraded during trypsin activation. Mutations were also introduced in the corresponding Cry1Ac salt bridge (D242E, D242K, D242N, and D242P), but only D242N and D242P could be produced. All toxins tested, except D242A, were shown by light-scattering experiments to permeabilize Manduca sexta larval midgut brush border membrane vesicles. The three active Cry1Aa mutants at pH 10.5, as well as D222A at pH 7.5, demonstrated a faster rate of pore formation than Cry1Aa, suggesting that increases in molecular flexibility due to the removal of a salt bridge facilitated toxin insertion into the membrane. However, all mutants were considerably less toxic to M. sexta larvae than to the respective parental toxins, suggesting that increased flexibility made the toxins more susceptible to proteolysis in the insect midgut. Interdomain salt bridges, especially the Asp(242)-Arg(265) bridge, therefore contribute greatly to the stability of the protein in the larval midgut, whereas their role in intrinsic pore-forming ability is relatively less important.     

Domains II and III of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab toxin remain exposed to the solvent after insertion of part of domain I into the membrane

Bacillus thuringiensis produces insecticidal proteins named Cry toxins, that are used commercially for the control of economical important insect pests. These are pore-forming toxins that interact with different receptors in the insect gut, forming pores in the apical membrane causing cell burst and insect death. Elucidation of the structure of the membrane-inserted toxin is important to fully understand its mechanism of action. One hypothesis proposed that the hairpin of α-helices 4-5 of domain I inserts into the phospholipid bilayer, whereas the rest of helices of domain I are spread on the membrane surface in an umbrella-like conformation. However, a second hypothesis proposed that the three domains of the Cry toxin insert into the bilayer without major conformational changes. In this work we constructed single Cys Cry1Ab mutants that remain active against Manduca sexta larvae and labeled them with different fluorescent probes that have different responses to solvent polarity. Different soluble quenchers as well as a membrane-bound quencher were used to compare the properties of the soluble and brush border membrane-inserted forms of Cry1Ab toxin. The fluorescence and quenching analysis presented here, revealed that domains II and III of the toxin remain in the surface of the membrane and only a discrete region of domain I is inserted into the lipid bilayer, supporting the umbrella model of toxin insertion.     

Helix 4 mutants of the Bacillus thuringiensis insecticidal toxin Cry1Aa display altered pore-forming abilities

The role played by alpha-helix 4 of the Bacillus thuringiensis toxin Cry1Aa in pore formation was investigated by individually replacing each of its charged residues with either a neutral or an oppositely charged amino acid by using site-directed mutagenesis. The majority of the resulting mutant proteins were considerably less toxic to Manduca sexta larvae than Cry1Aa. Most mutants also had a considerably reduced ability to form pores in midgut brush border membrane vesicles isolated from this insect, with the notable exception of those with alterations at amino acid position 127 (R127N and R127E), located near the N-terminal end of the helix. Introducing a negatively charged amino acid near the C-terminal end of the helix (T142D and T143D), a region normally devoid of charged residues, completely abolished pore formation. For each mutant that retained detectable pore-forming activity, reduced membrane permeability to KCl was accompanied by an approximately equivalent reduction in permeability to N-methyl-D-glucamine hydrochloride, potassium gluconate, sucrose, and raffinose and by a reduced rate of pore formation. These results indicate that the main effect of the mutations was to decrease the toxin's ability to form pores. They provide further evidence that alpha-helix 4 plays a crucial role in the mechanism of pore formation.     

Role of tryptophan residues in toxicity of Cry1Ab toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis

Bacillus thuringiensis produces insecticidal proteins (Cry protoxins) during the sporulation phase as parasporal crystals. During intoxication, the Cry protoxins must change from insoluble crystals into membrane-inserted toxins which form ionic pores. The structural changes of Cry toxins during oligomerization and insertion into the membrane are still unknown. The Cry1Ab toxin has nine tryptophan residues; seven are located in domain I, the pore-forming domain, and two are located in domain II, which is involved in receptor recognition. Eight Trp residues are highly conserved within the whole family of three-domain Cry proteins, suggesting an essential role for these residues in the structural folding and function of the toxin. In this work, we analyzed the role of Trp residues in the structure and function of Cry1Ab toxin. We replaced the Trp residues with phenylalanine or cysteine using site-directed mutagenesis. Our results show that W65 and W316 are important for insecticidal activity of the toxin since their replacement by Phe reduced the toxicity against Manduca sexta. The presence of hydrophobic residue is important at positions 117, 219, 226, and 455 since replacement by Cys affected either the crystal formation or the insecticidal activity of the toxin in contrast to replacement by Phe in these positions. Additionally, some mutants in positions 219, 316, and 455 were also affected in binding to brush border membrane vesicles (BBMV). This is the first report that studies the role of Trp residues in the activity of Cry toxins.     

Aggregation of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1A Toxins upon Binding to Target Insect Larval Midgut Vesicles

During sporulation, Bacillus thuringiensis produces crystalline inclusions comprised of a mixture of δ-endotoxins. Following ingestion by insect larvae, these inclusion proteins are solubilized, and the protoxins are converted to toxins. These bind specifically to receptors on the surfaces of midgut apical cells and are then incorporated into the membrane to form ion channels. The steps required for toxin insertion into the membrane and possible oligomerization to form a channel have been examined. When bound to vesicles from the midguts of Manduca sexta larvae, the Cry1Ac toxin was largely resistant to digestion with protease K. Only about 60 amino acids were removed from the Cry1Ac amino terminus, which included primarily helix α1. Following incubation of the Cry1Ab or Cry1Ac toxins with vesicles, the preparations were solubilized by relatively mild conditions, and the toxin antigens were analyzed by immunoblotting. In both cases, most of the toxin formed a large, antigenic aggregate of ca. 200 kDa. These toxin aggregates did not include the toxin receptor aminopeptidase N, but interactions with other vesicle components were not excluded. No oligomerization occurred when inactive toxins with mutations in amphipathic helices (α5) and known to insert into the membrane were tested. Active toxins with other mutations in this helix did form oligomers. There was one exception; a very active helix α5 mutant toxin bound very well to membranes, but no oligomers were detected. Toxins with mutations in the loop connecting helices α2 and α3, which affected the irreversible binding to vesicles, also did not oligomerize. There was a greater extent of oligomerization of the Cry1Ac toxin with vesicles from the Heliothis virescens midgut than with those from the M. sexta midgut, which correlated with observed differences in toxicity. Tight binding of virtually the entire toxin molecule to the membrane and the subsequent oligomerization are both important steps in toxicity.     

Cysteine scanning mutagenesis of alpha4, a putative pore-lining helix of the Bacillus thuringiensis insecticidal toxin Cry1Aa

Helix alpha4 of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry toxins is thought to line the lumen of the pores they form in the midgut epithelial cells of susceptible insect larvae. To define its functional role in pore formation, most of the alpha4 amino acid residues were replaced individually by a cysteine in the Cry1Aa toxin. The toxicities and pore-forming abilities of the mutated toxins were examined, respectively, by bioassays using neonate Manduca sexta larvae and by a light-scattering assay using midgut brush border membrane vesicles isolated from M. sexta. A majority of these mutants had considerably reduced toxicities and pore-forming abilities. Most mutations causing substantial or complete loss of activity map on the hydrophilic face of the helix, while most of those having little or only relatively minor effects map on its hydrophobic face. The properties of the pores formed by mutants that retain significant activity appear similar to those of the pores formed by the wild-type toxin, suggesting that mutations resulting in a loss of activity interfere mainly with pore formation.     

Role of helix 3 in pore formation by the Bacillus thuringiensis insecticidal toxin Cry1Aa

Helix 3 of the Cry1Aa toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis possesses eight charged amino acids. These residues, with the exception of those involved in intramolecular salt bridges (E90, R93, E112, and R115), were mutated individually either to a neutral or to an oppositely charged amino acid. The mutated genes were expressed, and the resultant, trypsin-activated toxins were assessed for their toxicity to Manduca sexta larvae and their ability to permeabilize M. sexta larval midgut brush border membrane vesicles to KCl, sucrose, raffinose, potassium gluconate, and N-methyl-D-glucamine hydrochloride with a light-scattering assay based on osmotic swelling. Most mutants were considerably less toxic than Cry1Aa. Replacing either E101, E116, E118, or D120 by cysteine, glutamine, or lysine residues had only minor effects on the properties of the pores formed by the modified toxins. However, half of these mutants (E101C, E101Q, E101K, E116K, E118C, and D120K) had a significantly slower rate of pore formation than Cry1Aa. Mutations at R99 (R99C, R99E, and R99Y) resulted in an almost complete loss of pore-forming ability. These results are consistent with a model in which alpha-helix 3 plays an important role in the mechanism of pore formation without being directly involved in determining the properties of the pores.     

Polydispersity of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1 toxins in solution and its effect on receptor binding kinetics

Dynamic light scattering and surface plasmon resonance techniques were used to investigate the influence of ionic strength, buffer composition and pH on the multimerization of trypsin-activated Cry1Ac and Cry1C toxins over time and the subsequent effects of the different multimers on receptor binding models. In carbonate buffer at pH 10.5, Cry1Ac and Cry1C assumed a monomeric state. After 24 h, a complete conversion of monomeric toxin to a dimeric or trimeric form was observed only for Cry1Ac under low ionic strength condition. Cry1C and Cry1Ac in high ionic strength buffer remained monomeric. Substitution of CAPS pH 11 for carbonate buffer suppressed this Cry1Ac oligomerization effect. Once Cry1Ac toxin was in an aggregated form, increases in ionic strength failed to revert the aggregated toxin back to a monomeric form. Monomeric Cry1Ac bound to a purified 115 kDa aminopeptidase N receptor from Manduca sexta in a 2:1 molar ratio thus confirming the existence of two binding sites on this receptor. Binding rates of dimeric or higher aggregated Cry1Ac toxin forms were different from those generated using the monomeric form and could not be fitted to existing binding models. In summary, our results confirm that the M. sexta 115 kDa aminopeptidase N receptor possesses two Cry1Ac binding sites. They further suggest that although high pH and low salt conditions promote Cry1Ac aggregation, this observation cannot be applied universally to other members of the Cry family.     

A trimeric building block model for Cry toxins in vitro ion channel formation

The crystal (Cry) insecticidal toxins, or delta-endotoxins, are lethal to a wide variety of insect larvae, and are therefore very important in insect control. Toxicity has been explained by formation of transmembrane oligomeric pores or ion channels and, more recently, by the ability of the monomeric toxin to subvert cellular signaling pathways. The structure, topology, and precise role of the putative pore in toxicity are not known. However, in vitro biophysical studies suggest that helices alpha4 and alpha5 in domain I insert into the lipid bilayer as an alpha-helical hairpin. Mutagenesis studies have assigned an important role to alpha5 in maintaining oligomerization, and to alpha4 in channel formation. To detect the possible homo-oligomerizing tendencies of these two helices, we have used the evolutionary conservation data contained in sixteen Cry homologs in order to filter non-native interactions found during a global conformational search. No conserved homo-oligomer was found for alpha4, but a right handed trimeric alpha5 model was present in the simulations of all Cry sequences. We propose a model for Cry toxin oligomerization based on sequence analysis and available mutagenesis data.     

A trimeric building block model for Cry toxins in vitro ion channel formation

The crystal (Cry) insecticidal toxins, or δ-endotoxins, are lethal to a wide variety of insect larvae, and are therefore very important in insect control. Toxicity has been explained by formation of transmembrane oligomeric pores or ion channels and, more recently, by the ability of the monomeric toxin to subvert cellular signaling pathways. The structure, topology, and precise role of the putative pore in toxicity are not known. However, in vitro biophysical studies suggest that helices α4 and α5 in domain I insert into the lipid bilayer as an α-helical hairpin. Mutagenesis studies have assigned an important role to α5 in maintaining oligomerization, and to α4 in channel formation. To detect the possible homo-oligomerizing tendencies of these two helices, we have used the evolutionary conservation data contained in sixteen Cry homologs in order to filter non-native interactions found during a global conformational search. No conserved homo-oligomer was found for α4, but a right handed trimeric α5 model was present in the simulations of all Cry sequences. We propose a model for Cry toxin oligomerization based on sequence analysis and available mutagenesis data.     

Enhancement of insecticidal activity of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1A toxins by fragments of a toxin-binding cadherin correlates with oligomer formation

Cry1A toxins produced by Bacillus thuringiensis bind a cadherin receptor that mediates toxicity in different lepidopteran insect larvae. Insect cadherin receptors are modular proteins composed of three domains, the ectodomain formed by 9-12 cadherin repeats (CR), the transmembrane domain and the intracellular domain. Cry1A toxins interact with three regions of the Manduca sexta cadherin receptor that are located in CR7, CR11 and CR12 cadherin repeats. Binding of Cry1A toxin to cadherin induces oligomerization of the toxin, which is essential for membrane insertion. Also, it has been reported that cadherin fragments containing the CR12 region enhanced the insecticidal activity of Cry1Ab toxin to M. sexta and other lepidopteran larvae. Here we report that cadherin fragments corresponding to CR7 and CR11 regions also enhanced the activity of Cry1Ac and Cry1Ab toxin to M. sexta larvae, although not as efficient as the CR12 fragment. A single point mutation in the CR12 region (I1422R) affected Cry1Ac and Cry1Ab binding to the cadherin fragments and did not enhance the activity of Cry1Ab or Cry1Ac toxin in bioassays. Analysis of Cry1Ab in vitro oligomer formation in the presence of wild type and mutated cadherin fragments showed a correlation between enhancement of Cry1A toxin activity in bioassays and in vitro Cry1Ab-oligomer formation. Our data shows that formation of Cry1A toxin oligomer is in part responsible for the enhancement of Cry1A toxicity by cadherin fragments that is observed in vivo.     

Evidence for intermolecular interaction as a necessary step for pore-formation activity and toxicity of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry1Ab toxin

Based on the observation of large conductance states formed by Bacillus thuringiensis Cry toxins in synthetic planar lipid bilayers and the estimation of a pore size of 10-20 A, it has been proposed that the pore could be formed by an oligomer containing four to six Cry toxin monomers. However, there is a lack of information regarding the insertion of Cry toxins into the membrane and oligomer formation. Here we provide direct evidence showing that the intermolecular interaction between Cry1Ab toxin monomers is a necessary step for pore formation and toxicity. Two Cry1Ab mutant proteins affected in different steps of their mode of action (F371A in receptor binding and H168F in pore formation) were affected in toxicity against Manduca sexta larvae. Binding analysis showed that F371A protein bound more efficiently to M. sexta brush border membrane vesicles when mixed with H168F in a one to one ratio. These mutant proteins also recovered pore-formation activity, measured with a fluorescent dye with isolated brush border membrane vesicles, and toxicity against M. sexta larvae when mixed, showing that monomers affected in different steps of their mode of action can form functional hetero-oligomers.     

Functional characterizations of residues Arg-158 and Tyr-170 of the mosquito-larvicidal Bacillus thuringiensis Cry4Ba

The insecticidal activity of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) Cry toxins involves toxin stabilization, oligomerization, passage across the peritrophic membrane (PM), binding to midgut receptors and pore-formation. The residues Arg-158 and Tyr-170 have been shown to be crucial for the toxicity of Bt Cry4Ba. We characterized the biological function of these residues. In mosquito larvae, the mutants R158A/E/Q (R158) could hardly penetrate the PM due to a significantly reduced ability to alter PM permeability; the mutant Y170A, however, could pass through the PM, but degraded in the space between the PM and the midgut epithelium. Further characterization by oligomerization demonstrated that Arg-158 mutants failed to form correctly sized high-molecular weight oligomers. This is the first report that Arg-158 plays a role in the formation of Cry4Ba oligomers, which are essential for toxin passage across the PM. Tyr-170, meanwhile, is involved in toxin stabilization in the toxic mechanism of Cry4Ba in mosquito larvae. [BMB Reports 2014; 47(10): 546-551]     

Pore formation activity of Cry1Ab toxin from Bacillus thuringiensis in an improved membrane vesicle preparation from Manduca sexta midgut cell microvilli

The pore formation activity of Cry1Ab toxin is analyzed in an improved membrane preparation from apical microvilli structures of Manduca sexta midgut epithelium cells (MEC). A novel methodology is described to isolate MEC and brush border membrane vesicles (BBMV) from purified microvilli structures. The specific enrichment of apical membrane enzyme markers aminopeptidase (APN) and alkaline phosphatase (APh) were 35- and 22-fold, respectively, as compared to the whole midgut cell homogenate. Ligand-blot and Western-blot experiments showed that Cry1A specific receptors were also enriched. The pore formation activity of Cry1Ab toxin was fourfold higher in the microvilli membrane fraction that showed low intrinsic K+ channels and higher APN and APh activities than in the basal-lateral membrane fraction harboring high intrinsic K+ channels. These data suggest that basal-lateral membrane was separated from apical membrane.This procedure should allow more precise studies of the interaction of Cry toxins with their target membranes, avoiding unspecific interaction with other cellular membranes, as well as the study of the pore formation activity induced by Cry toxins in the absence of endogenous channels from M. sexta midgut cells.     

All domains of Cry1A toxins insert into insect brush border membranes

A critical step in understanding the mode of action of insecticidal crystal toxins from Bacillus thuringiensis is their partitioning into membranes and, in particular, the insertion of the toxin into insect brush border membranes. The Umbrella and Penknife models predict that only alpha-helix 5 of domain I along with adjacent helices alpha-4 or alpha-6 insert into the brush border membranes because of their hydrophobic nature. By employing fluorescent-labeled cysteine mutations, we observe that all three domains of the toxin insert into the insect membrane. Using proteinase K protection assays, steady state fluorescence quenching measurements, and blue shift analysis of acrylodan-labeled cysteine mutants, we show that regions beyond those proposed by the two models insert into the membrane. Based on our studies, the only extended region that does not partition into the membrane is that of alpha-helix 1. Bioassays and voltage clamping studies show that all mutations examined, except certain domain II mutations in loop 2 (e.g. F371C and G374C), which disrupt membrane partitioning, retain their ability to form ion channels and toxicity in Manduca sexta larvae. This study confirms our earlier hypothesis that insertion of crystal toxin does not occur as separate helices alone, but virtually the entire molecule inserts as one or more units of the whole molecule.