Conformational stability of PrP amyloid fibrils controls their smallest possible fragment size

Fibril fragmentation is considered to be an essential step in prion replication. Recent studies have revealed a strong correlation between the incubation period to prion disease and conformational stability of synthetic prions. To gain insight into the molecular mechanism that accounts for this correlation, we proposed that the conformational stability of prion fibrils controls their intrinsic fragility or the size of the smallest possible fibrillar fragments. Using amyloid fibrils produced from full-length mammalian prion protein under three growth conditions, we found a correlation between conformational stability and the smallest possible fragment sizes. Specifically, the fibrils that were conformationally less stable were found to produce shorter pieces upon fragmentation. Site-specific denaturation experiments revealed that the fibril conformational stability was controlled by the region that acquires a cross-β-sheet structure. Using atomic force microscopy imaging, we found that fibril fragmentation occurred in both directions—perpendicular to and along the fibrillar axis. Two mechanisms of fibril fragmentation were identified: (i) fragmentation caused by small heat shock proteins, including αB-crystallin, and (ii) fragmentation due to mechanical stress arising from adhesion of the fibril to a surface. This study provides new mechanistic insight into the prion replication mechanism and offers a plausible explanation for the correlation between conformational stability of synthetic prions and incubation time to prion disease.     

Nucleation of Polymorphic Amyloid Fibrils

One and the same protein can self-assemble into amyloid fibrils with different morphologies. The phenomenon of fibril polymorphism is relevant biologically because different fibril polymorphs can have different toxicity, but there is no tool for predicting which polymorph forms and under what conditions. Here, we consider the nucleation of polymorphic amyloid fibrils occurring by direct polymerization of monomeric proteins into fibrils. We treat this process within the framework of our newly developed nonstandard nucleation theory, which allows prediction of the concentration dependence of the nucleation rate for different fibril polymorphs. The results highlight that the concentration dependence of the nucleation rate is closely linked with the protein solubility and a threshold monomer concentration below which fibril formation becomes biologically irrelevant. The relation between the nucleation rate, the fibril solubility, the threshold concentration, and the binding energies of the fibril building blocks within fibrils might prove a valuable tool for designing new experiments to control the formation of particular fibril polymorphs.     

Dissection of Conformational Conversion Events during Prion Amyloid Fibril Formation Using Hydrogen Exchange and Mass Spectrometry

A molecular understanding of prion diseases requires an understanding of the mechanism of amyloid fibril formation by the prion protein. In particular, it is necessary to define the sequence of the structural events describing the conformational conversion of monomeric PrP to aggregated PrP. In this study, the sequence of the structural events in the case of amyloid fibril formation by recombinant mouse prion protein at pH 7 has been characterized by hydrogen–deuterium exchange and mass spectrometry. The observation that fibrils are substantially more stable to hydrogen–deuterium exchange than is native monomer allows both forms to be quantified during the course of the aggregation reaction. Under the aggregation conditions utilized, native monomeric protein and amyloid fibrils are the only forms of the protein detectable during the course of the fibril formation reaction, suggesting that monomer directly adds on to the fibril template. Conformational conversion is shown to occur in two steps after the binding of monomer to fibril, with helix 1 unfolding only after helices 2 and 3 transform into β-sheet. Local stability in the β-sheet core region (residues ~ 159–225) of the fibrils is shown to be sequence dependent in that it varies along the length of the core, and local stability in protein molecules that are ordered in the structurally heterogeneous sequence segment 109–132 is shown to be similar to that in the core. This new understanding of the structural events during prion protein aggregation has important bearing on our comprehension of the molecular basis of prion pathogenesis.     

Pre-Steady-State Kinetic Analysis of the Elongation of Amyloid Fibrils of β2-Microglobulin with Tryptophan Mutagenesis

Amyloid fibrils elongate seed dependently, with preformed fibrils providing a template for propagation of amyloidogenic conformation. Most seeding experiments use relatively few seed fibrils in comparison with monomers, resembling steady-state enzyme kinetics. Pre-steady-state kinetics should also be useful for characterizing the elongation process. With β₂-microglobulin (β₂-m), a protein responsible for dialysis-related amyloidosis, we measured the pre-steady-state kinetics of fibril elongation at pH 2.5, conditions under which the monomer is largely unfolded. β₂-m has Trp residues at positions 60 and 95. We used three single Trp mutants and fluorescence spectroscopy to study structural change upon fibril elongation. To focus on conformational change in monomers, we prepared seeds with a mutant without a Trp residue. At a fixed concentration of monomeric β₂-m, the apparent rate of fibril elongation increased with an increase in the concentration of seeds and then saturated, suggesting the accumulation of a rate-limiting intermediate. Importantly, saturation occurred at a seed/monomer ratio of around 10, as expressed by the concentration of the monomer. Because the number of monomers constituting the seed fibrils is much larger than 10, the results suggest that the elongation process is limited by “non-active-site binding.” Spectral analysis indicated that, upon this non-active-site binding, both Trp60 and Trp95 are exposed to the solvent, and then only Trp60 is buried upon transition to the fibrils. We propose a new model of fibril elongation in which non-active-site binding plays a major role.     

Prion Domain of Yeast Ure2 Protein Adopts a Completely Disordered Structure: A Solid-Support EPR Study

Amyloid fibril formation is associated with a range of neurodegenerative diseases in humans, including Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and prion diseases. In yeast, amyloid underlies several non-Mendelian phenotypes referred to as yeast prions. Mechanism of amyloid formation is critical for a complete understanding of the yeast prion phenomenon and human amyloid-related diseases. Ure2 protein is the basis of yeast prion [URE3]. The Ure2p prion domain is largely disordered. Residual structures, if any, in the disordered region may play an important role in the aggregation process. Studies of Ure2p prion domain are complicated by its high aggregation propensity, which results in a mixture of monomer and aggregates in solution. Previously we have developed a solid-support electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) approach to address this problem and have identified a structured state for the Alzheimer’s amyloid-β monomer. Here we use solid-support EPR to study the structure of Ure2p prion domain. EPR spectra of Ure2p prion domain with spin labels at every fifth residue from position 10 to position 75 show similar residue mobility profile for denaturing and native buffers after accounting for the effect of solution viscosity. These results suggest that Ure2p prion domain adopts a completely disordered structure in the native buffer. A completely disordered Ure2p prion domain implies that the amyloid formation of Ure2p, and likely other Q/N-rich yeast prion proteins, is primarily driven by inter-molecular interactions.     

Fibril elongation mechanisms of HET-s prion-forming domain: topological evidence for growth polarity

The prion-forming C-terminal domain of the fungal prion HET-s forms infectious amyloid fibrils at physiological pH. The conformational switch from the nonprion soluble form to the prion fibrillar form is believed to have a functional role, as HET-s in its prion form participates in a recognition process of different fungal strains. On the basis of the knowledge of the high-resolution structure of the prion forming domain HET-s(218-289) in its fibrillar form, we here present a numerical simulation of the fibril growth process, which emphasizes the role of the topological properties of the fibrillar structure. An accurate thermodynamic analysis of the way an intervening HET-s chain is recruited to the tip of the growing fibril suggests that elongation proceeds through a dock and lock mechanism. First, the chain docks onto the fibril by forming the longest β-strands. Then, the re-arrangement in the fibrillar form of all the rest of the molecule takes place. Interestingly, we also predict that one side of the HET-s fibril is more suitable for sustaining its growth with respect to the other. The resulting strong polarity of fibril growth is a consequence of the complex topology of HET-s fibrillar structure, as the central loop of the intervening chain plays a crucially different role in favoring or not the attachment of the C-terminus tail to the fibril, depending on the growth side.     

A variational model for oligomer-formation process of GNNQQNY peptide from yeast prion protein Sup35

Many human neurodegenerative diseases are associated with the aggregation of insoluble amyloid-like fibrous proteins. However, the processes by which the randomly diffused monomer peptides aggregate into the highly regulated amyloid fibril structures are largely unknown. We proposed a residue-level coarse-grained variational model for the investigation of the aggregation pathway for a small assembly of amyloid proteins, the peptide GNNQQNY from yeast prion protein Sup35. By examining the free energy surface, we identified the residue-level sequential pathways for double parallel and antiparallel β-peptides, which show that the central dry polar zipper structure is the major folding core in both cases. The critical nucleus size is determined to be three peptides for the homogeneous nucleation process, whereas the zig-zag growth pattern appears most favorably for heterogeneous nucleation. Consistent with the dock-and-lock mechanism, the aggregation process of free peptides to the fibril core was found to be highly cooperative. The quantitative validation with the computational simulations and experimental data demonstrated the usefulness of the proposed model in understanding the general mechanism of the amyloid fibril system.     

Effect of salts on the structural behavior of hPrP alpha2-helix-derived analogues: the counterion perspective.

Both theoretical studies and direct experimental evidence have emphasized the importance of electrostatic interactions in the general phenomenon of spontaneous amyloid fibril formation. A number of observations have recently spurred interest in the contribution of these interactions to the conformational behavior of the prion protein. In this paper, we show how salt addition and pH change can modify the conformation of two peptide analogues derived from the human prion protein helix 2 according to a Hofmeister-series-type dependence. Employment of various sodium salts allowed us to highlight the fact that chaotropic anions favor unstructured conformation, whereas kosmotropic anions promote the formation of compact structures like alpha-helix and beta-sheet, which may ultimately facilitate fibril formation. This finding should warn people engaged in ion-based research on prion and derived peptides about cation-bound effects, which have been almost exclusively investigated to date, being easily confounded with modifications that are actually caused by anion activity, thus leading researchers into misunderstand ion-specific effects. To avoid the common complication of ion confounding, it is highly desirable that experiments be designed so that the species causing the modification can be unequivocally perceived.     

Two structurally similar fungal prions efficiently cross-seed in vivo but form distinct polymers when coexpressed

HET-s is a prion protein of the filamentous fungus Podospora anserina. An orthologue of this protein, called FgHET-s has been identified in Fusarium graminearum. The region of the FgHET-s protein corresponding to the prion forming domain of HET-s, forms amyloid fibrils in vitro. These fibrils seed HET-s(218-289) fibril formation in vitro and vice versa. The amyloid fold of HET-s(218-289) and FgHET-s(218-289) are remarkably similar although they share only 38% identity. The present work corresponds to the functional characterization of the FgHET-s(218-289) region as a prion forming domain in vivo. We show that FgHET-s(218-289) is capable of prion propagation in P. anserina and is able to substitute for the HET-s PFD in the full-length HET-s protein. In accordance with the in vitro cross-seeding experiments, we detect no species barrier between P. anserina and F. graminearum PFDs. We use the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae as a host to compare the prion performances of the two orthologous PFDs. We find that FgHET-s(218-289) leads to higher spontaneous prion formation rates and mitotic prion stability than HET-s(218-289). Then we analysed the outcome of HET-s(218-289)/FgHET-s(218-289) coexpression. In spite of the cross-seeding ability of HET-s(218-289) and FgHET-s(218-289), in vivo, homotypic polymerization is favoured over mixed fibril formation.     

Mechanism of fiber assembly: treatment of Aβ peptide aggregation with a coarse-grained united-residue force field

The growth mechanism of β-amyloid (Aβ) peptide fibrils was studied by a physics-based coarse-grained united-residue model and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. To identify the mechanism of monomer addition to an Aβ_1-40 fibril, we placed an unstructured monomer at a distance of 20 Å from a fibril template and allowed it to interact freely with the latter. The monomer was not biased towards fibril conformation by either the force field or the MD algorithm. With the use of a coarse-grained model with replica-exchange molecular dynamics, a longer timescale was accessible, making it possible to observe how the monomers probe different binding modes during their search for the fibril conformation. Although different assembly pathways were seen, they all follow a dock-lock mechanism with two distinct locking stages, consistent with experimental data on fibril elongation. Whereas these experiments have not been able to characterize the conformations populating the different stages, we have been able to describe these different stages explicitly by following free monomers as they dock onto a fibril template and to adopt the fibril conformation (i.e., we describe fibril elongation step by step at the molecular level). During the first stage of the assembly (“docking”), the monomer tries different conformations. After docking, the monomer is locked into the fibril through two different locking stages. In the first stage, the monomer forms hydrogen bonds with the fibril template along one of the strands in a two-stranded β-hairpin; in the second stage, hydrogen bonds are formed along the second strand, locking the monomer into the fibril structure. The data reveal a free-energy barrier separating the two locking stages. The importance of hydrophobic interactions and hydrogen bonds in the stability of the Aβ fibril structure was examined by carrying out additional canonical MD simulations of oligomers with different numbers of chains (4-16 chains), with the fibril structure as the initial conformation. The data confirm that the structures are stabilized largely by hydrophobic interactions and show that intermolecular hydrogen bonds are highly stable and contribute to the stability of the oligomers as well.     

Apolipoprotein C-II amyloid fibrils assemble via a reversible pathway that includes fibril breaking and rejoining

Alzheimer's and several other diseases are characterized by the misfolding and assembly of protein subunits into amyloid fibrils. Current models propose that amyloid fibril formation proceeds via the self-association of several monomers to form a nucleus, which then elongates by the addition of monomer to form mature fibrils. We have examined the concentration-dependent kinetics of apolipoprotein C-II amyloid fibril formation and correlated this with the final size distribution of the fibrils determined by sedimentation velocity experiments. In contrast to predictions of the nucleation-elongation model, the final size distribution of the fibrils was found to be relatively independent of the starting monomer concentration. To explain these results, we extended the nucleation-elongation model to include fibril breaking and rejoining as integral parts of the amyloid fibril assembly mechanism. The system was examined under conditions that affected the stability of the mature fibrils including the effect of dilution on the free pool of monomeric apolipoprotein C-II and the time-dependent recovery of fibril size following sonication. Antibody-labelling transmission electron microscopy studies provided direct evidence for spontaneous fibril breaking and rejoining. These studies establish the importance of breaking and rejoining in amyloid fibril formation and identify prospective new therapeutic targets in the assembly pathway.     

Cooperative hydrogen bonding in amyloid formation

Amyloid diseases, including Alzheimer's and prion diseases, are each associated with unbranched protein fibrils. Each fibril is made of a particular protein, yet they share common properties. One such property is nucleation-dependent fibril growth. Monomers of amyloid-forming proteins can remain in dissolved form for long periods, before rapidly assembly into fibrils. The lag before growth has been attributed to slow kinetics of formation of a nucleus, on which other molecules can deposit to form the fibril. We have explored the energetics of fibril formation, based on the known molecular structure of a fibril-forming peptide from the yeast prion, Sup35, using both classical and quantum (density functional theory) methods. We find that the energetics of fibril formation for the first three layers are cooperative using both methods. This cooperativity is consistent with the observation that formation of amyloid fibrils involves slow nucleation and faster growth.     

Defining the pathway of worm-like amyloid fibril formation by the mouse prion protein by delineation of the productive and unproductive oligomerization reactions

Aggregation reactions of proteins leading to amyloid fibril formation are often characterized by early transient accumulation of a heterogeneous population of soluble oligomers differing in size and structure. Delineating the kinetic roles of the different oligomeric forms in fibril formation has been a major challenge. The aggregation of the mouse prion protein to form worm-like amyloid fibrils at low pH is known to proceed via a β-rich oligomer ensemble, which is shown here to be comprised of two subpopulations of oligomers that differ in size and internal structure. The relative populations of the two oligomers can be tuned by varying the concentration of NaCl present. By demonstrating that the apparent rate constant for the formation of fibrils is dependent linearly on the concentration of the larger oligomer and is independent of the concentration of the smaller oligomer, we show that the larger oligomer is a productive intermediate that accumulates on the direct pathway of aggregation from monomer to worm-like fibrils. The smaller oligomer is shown to be populated off the pathway of the larger oligomer and, hence, is not directly productive for fibril formation. The relative populations of the two oligomers can also be tuned by single-amino acid residue changes in the sequence of the protein. The different protein variants yield worm-like fibrils of different lengths, and the apparent rate of formation of the fibrils by the mutant variants is also shown to be dependent on the concentration of the larger but not of the smaller oligomer formed.     

Tetramer dissociation and monomer partial unfolding precedes protofibril formation in amyloidogenic transthyretin variants

Amyloid fibril formation and deposition is a common feature of a wide range of fatal diseases including spongiform encephalopathies, Alzheimer's disease, and familial amyloidotic polyneuropathies (FAP), among many others. In certain forms of FAP, the amyloid fibrils are mostly constituted by variants of transthyretin (TTR), a homotetrameric plasma protein. Recently, we showed that transthyretin in solution may undergo dissociation to a non-native monomer, even under close to physiological conditions of temperature, pH, ionic strength, and protein concentration. We also showed that this non-native monomer is a compact structure, does not behave as a molten globule, and may lead to the formation of partially unfolded monomeric species and high molecular mass soluble aggregates (Quintas, A., Saraiva, M. J. M., and Brito, R. M. M. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 32943-32949). Here, based on aging experiments of tetrameric TTR and chemically induced protein unfolding experiments of the non-native monomeric forms, we show that tetramer dissociation and partial unfolding of the monomer precedes amyloid fibril formation. We also show that TTR variants with the least thermodynamically stable non-native monomer produce the largest amount of partially unfolded monomeric species and soluble aggregates under conditions that are close to physiological. Additionally, the soluble aggregates formed by the amyloidogenic TTR variants showed morphological and thioflavin-T fluorescence properties characteristic of amyloid. These results allowed us to conclude that amyloid fibril formation by some TTR variants might be triggered by tetramer dissociation to a compact non-native monomer with low conformational stability, which originates partially unfolded monomeric species with a high tendency for ordered aggregation into amyloid fibrils. Thus, partial unfolding and conformational fluctuations of molecular species with marginal thermodynamic stability may play a crucial role on amyloid formation in vivo.     

Differentiation of subnucleus-sized oligomers and nucleation-competent assemblies of the Aβ peptide

A significant feature of Alzheimer’s disease is the formation of amyloid deposits in the brain consisting mainly of misfolded derivatives of proteolytic cleavage products of the amyloid precursor protein amyloid-β (Aβ) peptide. While high-resolution structures already exist for both the monomer and the amyloid fibril of the Aβ peptide, the mechanism of amyloid formation itself still defies precise characterization. In this study, low and high molecular weight oligomers (LMWOs and HMWOs) were identified by sedimentation velocity analysis, and for the first time, the temporal evolution of oligomer size distributions was correlated with the kinetics of amyloid formation as determined by thioflavin T-binding studies. LMWOs of subnucleus size contain fewer than seven monomer units and exist alongside a heterogeneous group of HMWOs with 20–160 monomer units that represent potential centers of nucleus formation due to high local monomer concentrations. These HMWOs already have slightly increased β-strand content and appear structurally similar regardless of size, as shown by examination with a range of fluorescent dyes. Once fibril nuclei are formed, the monomer concentration begins to decrease, followed by a decrease in oligomer concentration, starting with LMWOs, which are the least stable species. The observed behavior classifies the two LMWOs as off pathway. In contrast, we consider HMWOs to be on-pathway, prefibrillar intermediates, representing structures in which nucleated conformational conversion is facilitated by high local concentrations. Aβ40 and Aβ42 M35^ox take much longer to form nuclei and enter the growth phase than Aβ42 under identical reaction conditions, presumably because both the size and the concentration of HMWOs formed are much smaller.     

Elongation of Mouse Prion Protein Amyloid-Like Fibrils: Effect of Temperature and Denaturant Concentration

Prion protein is known to have the ability to adopt a pathogenic conformation, which seems to be the basis for protein-only infectivity. The infectivity is based on self-replication of this pathogenic prion structure. One of possible mechanisms for such replication is the elongation of amyloid-like fibrils.We measured elongation kinetics and thermodynamics of mouse prion amyloid-like fibrils at different guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl) concentrations. Our data show that both increases in temperature and GuHCl concentration help unfold monomeric protein and thus accelerate elongation. Once the monomers are unfolded, further increases in temperature raise the rate of elongation, whereas the addition of GuHCl decreases it.We demonstrated a possible way to determine different activation energies of amyloid-like fibril elongation by using folded and unfolded protein molecules. This approach separates thermodynamic data for fibril-assisted monomer unfolding and for refolding and formation of amyloid-like structure.     

Role of elongation and secondary pathways in S6 amyloid fibril growth

The concerted action of a large number of individual molecular level events in the formation and growth of fibrillar protein structures creates a significant challenge for differentiating between the relative contributions of different self-assembly steps to the overall kinetics of this process. The characterization of the individual steps is, however, an important requirement for achieving a quantitative understanding of this general phenomenon which underlies many crucial functional and pathological pathways in living systems. In this study, we have applied a kinetic modeling approach to interpret experimental data obtained for the aggregation of a selection of site-directed mutants of the protein S6 from Thermus thermophilus. By studying a range of concentrations of both the seed structures, used to initiate the reaction, and of the soluble monomer, which is consumed during the growth reaction, we are able to separate unambiguously secondary pathways from primary nucleation and fibril elongation. In particular, our results show that the characteristic autocatalytic nature of the growth process originates from secondary processes rather than primary nucleation events, and enables us to derive a scaling law which relates the initial seed concentration to the onset of the growth phase.     

A beta fibrillogenesis: kinetic parameters for fibril formation from congo red binding

Using Scatchard analysis, we have formulated as a function of time and pH the relationship between the binding of Congo red to Alzheimer's beta-amyloid and the aggregation number (i.e., monomer concentration within fibrils) as defined by nucleation-dependent self-assembly. This provides a basis on which to determine the kinetic parameters for fibril formation from the observed concentration of bound Congo red.     

Structural origin of polymorphism of Alzheimer's amyloid β-fibrils

Formation of senile plaques containing amyloid fibrils of Aβ (amyloid β-peptide) is a pathological hallmark of Alzheimer's disease. Unlike globular proteins, which fold into unique structures, the fibrils of Aβ and other amyloid proteins often contain multiple polymorphs. Polymorphism of amyloid fibrils leads to different toxicity in amyloid diseases and may be the basis for prion strains, but the structural origin for fibril polymorphism is still elusive. In the present study we investigate the structural origin of two major fibril polymorphs of Aβ40: an untwisted polymorph formed under agitated conditions and a twisted polymorph formed under quiescent conditions. Using electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, we studied the inter-strand side-chain interactions at 14 spin-labelled positions in the Aβ40 sequence. The results of the present study show that the agitated fibrils have stronger inter-strand spin-spin interactions at most of the residue positions investigated. The two hydrophobic regions at residues 17-20 and 31-36 have the strongest interactions in agitated fibrils. Distance estimates on the basis of the spin exchange frequencies suggest that inter-strand distances at residues 17, 20, 32, 34 and 36?in agitated fibrils are approximately 0.2?? (1??=0.1?nm) closer than in quiescent fibrils. We propose that the strength of inter-strand side-chain interactions determines the degree of β-sheet twist, which then leads to the different association patterns between different cross β-units and thus distinct fibril morphologies. Therefore the inter-strand side-chain interaction may be a structural origin for fibril polymorphism in Aβ and other amyloid proteins.