Differential effects of culture media on normal and foreign differentiation pathways followed by chick embryo neuroretinal cells in vitro

Three different culture media, Ham's F-12, medium 199, and Eagle's minimal essential medium (MEM), were compared with respect to the expression of neuronal (choline acetyl transferase activity: CAT) and glial (hydrocortisone-induced glutamine synthetase activity; GSase) markers of normal differentiation in cultures of 9-day chick embryo neuroretinal cells, and also with respect to the accumulation of a lens marker (delta crystallin) during so-called 'transdifferentiation' in these cultures. MEM allows transient expression of both CAT and GSase activities in early cultures, but also permits extensive delta crystallin accumulation at later stages. F-12 medium gives somewhat higher levels of CAT and GSase activities, the former being noticeably prolonged as compared with parallel MEM cultures; delta crystallin accumulation, however, is largely inhibited in F-12 cultures. By contrast, medium 199 permits only low levels of CAT and GSase activities, perhaps because the neuronal cells are distributed individually over the glial cell sheet in 199 cultures, rather than forming aggregates as in MEM or F-12 cultures. Medium 199 also blocks delta crystallin accumulation. The results of medium changeover between 'transdifferentiation'-permissive (MEM) and non-permissive (199, F-12) conditions suggest: (a) that potential lens precursor cells (whatever their nature) survive in F-12 medium for prolonged periods without extensive expression of the lens phenotype; (b) that such precursor cells become committed to subsequent differentiation as lens cells between 10 and 20 days of culture in permissive MEM medium (as judged by the accumulation of delta crystallin following transfer into F-12); and (c) that medium 199 can block expression of the lens phenotype even in cells already committed (by the above criteria) to lens differentiation, as for instance after 30 days of preculture in MEM.     

Differential effects of culture media on normal and foreign differentiation pathways followed by chick embryo neuroretinal cells in vitro

Abstract. Three different culture media, Ham's F-12, medium 199, and Eagle's minimal essential medium (MEM), were compared with respect to the expression of neuronal (choline acetyl transferase activity: CAT) and glial (hydrocortisone-induced glutamine synthetase activity; GSase) markers of normal differentiation in cultures of 9-day chick embryo neuroretinal cells, and also with respect to the accumulation of a lens marker (δ crystallin) during so-called 'transdifferentiation' in these cultures.
MEM allows transient expression of both CAT and GSase activities in early cultures, but also permits extensive δ crystallin accumulation at later stages. F-12 medium gives somewhat higher levels of CAT and GSase activities, the former being noticeably prolonged as compared with parallel MEM cultures; δ crystallin accumulation, however, is largely inhibited in F-12 cultures. By contrast, medium 199 permits only low levels of CAT and GSase activities, perhaps because the neuronal cells are distributed individually over the glial cell sheet in 199 cultures, rather than forming aggregates as in MEM or F–12 cultures. Medium 199 also blocks δ crystallin accumulation.
The results of medium changeover between 'transdifferentiation'-permissive (MEM) and non-permissive (199, F-12) conditions suggest: (a) that potential lens precursor cells (whatever their nature) survive in F-12 medium for prolonged periods without extensive expression of the lens phenotype; (b) that such precursor cells become committed to subsequent differentiation as lens cells between 10 and 20 days of culture in permissive MEM medium (as judged by the accumulation of δ crystallin following transfer into F-12); and (c) that medium 199 can block expression of the lens phenotype even in cells already committed (by the above criteria) to lens differentiation, as for instance after 30 days of preculture in MEM.     

Expression of Neuronal Specificities in "Transdifferentiating" Cultures of Neural Retina

Cells dissociated from the neural retina of embryonic chick differentiate into lens and pigment cells, when cultured in vitro. Using 3.5-day-old and 8.5-day-old chick embryos, we examined whether neuronal specificities would be expressed in such transdifferentiating cultures of neural retinal cells. The synthesis of acetylcholine and γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and the activity of choline acetyl transferase (CAT) was searched for in these cultures. The synthesis of an appreciable amount of these two putative neurotransmitters was detected in cultures of 3.5-day-old embryonic retinas by about 15 days. The activity of CAT was maximum in 7-day cultures of the 3.5-day-old materials and in 2-day cultures of the 8.5-day-old materials, and then decreased. Concomitant with the decrease of CAT-activity, δ-crystallin became detectable and increased thereafter. CAT-activity changed in parallel with the increase in the number of small neuroblast-like cells in cultures. The results demonstrate that the neuronal specificity identified by the appearance of acetylcholine and GABA and of the enzyme for the synthesis of acetylcholine is expressed in the early period of transdifferentiating cultures, which would later differentiate into lens and pigment cells. The possible mechanisms of the transition from neuronal to non-neuroretinal specificities of the transdifferentiating cultures are discussed.     

A DEMONSTRATION OF LENS FORMING-CELLS IN NEURAL RETINA IN CLONAL CELL CULTURE

Clonal cultures with 1,000–3,000 cells were prepared from cells harvested from high density cultures of neural retina of 8-day-old chick embryos. About 1.14% and 0.31% of inoculated cells developed into recogniziable colonies in Eagle's MEM and in Ham's F-12 supplemented with fetal calf serum respectively. Of these colonies, lentoid bodies of authentic lens nature were differentiated in 10% and 33.52% in MEM and F-12 respectively. Cells harvested from high density cultures of the anterior and posterior portions of the neural retina were clonally cultured. Plating efficiency was much higher in the anterior cells than in the posterior ones and clonies with lentoid differentiation were developed only in clonal cultures of the anterior cells.     

Pathways of differentiation in chick embryo neuroretinal cultures

Markers of neuronal cell differentiation (GABA accumulation, choline acetyltransferase activity) are shown to increase initially and then decline sharply in monolayer cultures of 9 day embryo neuroretinal (NR) cells. A glial marker (glutamine synthetase, GSase) is precociously inducible by hydrocortisone (HC) in dens "monolayer' NR cultures (containing aggregates of neuronal cells overlying the glian sheet) as well as in chick embryo retinal explants. The induced level of GSase activity is not maintained in the continued presence of HC, but rather declines by 20 days in vitro. Choline acetyltransferase (CAT) activity is higher in HC-treated cultures than in controls only during the period when induced GSase activity is detectable. Furthermore, the subsequent transdifferentiation of lens cells (monitored as delta crystalline content) in these cultures is delayed by 10 days and much reduced in extent when HC is present throughout the culture period. We suggest a simple model to account for these results, on the basis of recent evidence that lens cells are derived mainly from the retinal epithelial cells (immature Müller glia) of 9-day embryonic NR, and that transdifferentiation results from a change in cell determination during the early stages of "monolayers' culture. In outline, our model proposes that early determination of the retinal glia is associated with a decline of neuronal cell markers (dedifferentiation) followed eventually by loss of the neuronal cells. Hydrocortisone, by inducing transient glial cell differentiation (GSase activity), both prolongs the expression of a neuronal marker (CAT) and also reduces later transdifferentiation into lens.     

Pathways of Differentiation in Chick Embryo Neuroretinal Cultures

Markers of neuronal cell differentiation (GABA accumulation, choline acetyltransferase activity) are shown to increase initially and then decline sharply in monolayer cultures of 9 day embryo neuroretinal (NR) cells. A glial marker (glutamine synthetase, GSase) is precociously inducible by hydrocortisone (HC) in dense'monolayer' NR cultures (containing aggregates of neuronal cells overlying the glial sheet) as well as in chick embryo retinal explants. The induced level of GSase activity is not maintained in the continued presence of HC, but rather declines by 20 days in vitro. Choline acetyltransferase (CAT) activity is higher in HC-treated cultures than in controls only during the period when induced GSase activity is detectable. Furthermore, the subsequent transdifferentiation of lens cells (monitored as δ crystallin content) in these cultures is delayed by 10 days and much reduced in extent when HC is present throughout the culture period.
We suggest a simple model to account for these results, on the basis of recent evidence that lens cells are derived mainly from the retinal epithelial cells (immature Müller glia) of 9-day embryonic NR, and that transdifferentiation results from a change in cell determination during the early stages of'monolayer' culture. In outline, our model proposes that early dedetermination of the retinal glia is associated with a decline of neuronal cell markers (dedifferentiation) followed eventually by loss of the neuronal cells. Hydrocortisone, by inducing transient glial cell differentiation (GSase activity), both prolongs the expression of a neuronal marker (CAT) and also reduces later transdifferentiation into lens.     

Crystallin synthesis in lens differentiation in cultures of neural retinal cells of chick embryos.

Dissociated cells of neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos differentiated into “lentoid bodies” within about 10–12 days when cultured in vitro. Protein synthesis of these cultured cells was studied with the use of SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, affinity chromatography, and autoradiography combined with immunological techniques. Incorporation of [¹⁴C]leucine into total proteins, α-crystallin, and δ-crystallin was estimated after increasing times of culture up to about 30 days. Isotope incorporation into δ-crystallin was detected at 9 days, and it increased sevenfold after another 17 days. α-Crystallin was also first detected at 9 days, but its relative content reached a maximum at 12 days and then decreased gradually. The ratio of δ-crystallin synthesis to total protein synthesis increased up to 40% at 26 days, while that of α-crystallin synthesis remained 3% throughout the culture period. These results show that lens differentiation from neural retinal cells is associated with the preferential synthesis of lens crystallins, particularly of δ-crystallin.     

Isolation and cell-free translation of chick lens crystallin mRNA during normal development and transdifferentiation of neural retina

Messenger RNA has been isolated from day-old chick lens. Size characterization and heterologous cell-free translation demonstrate that the predominant species of mRNA present code for α-, β- and δ-crystallins. Total polysomal RNA and polysomal RNA which did not bind to oligo (dT)-cellulose translate in the cell-free system to give a crystallin profile qualitatively similar to that of poly(A)⁺ mRNA. RNA from postribosomal supernatant which binds to oligo(dT)-cellulose also translates to give crystallins, but the products are enriched for β-crystallins. Messenger RNAs isolated from 15-day embryo lens fiber and lens epithelium cells give products on translation which reflect the different protein compositions of these two cell types, as do mRNAs isolated from chick lenses at various developmental stages. Messenger RNAs were isolated from freshly excised 8-day embryo neural retina and from this tissue undergoing transdifferentiation into lens cells in cell culture. Cell-free translation demonstrates no detectable crystallin mRNAs in the freshly excised material, but by 42 days in cell culture, crystallin mRNAs are the most prominent species.     

Delta-crystallin mRNA in chick lens cells: mRNA accumulates during differential stimulation of delta-crystallin synthesis in cultured cells.

Increasing specialization for δ-crystallin synthesis is a prominent feature of the differentiation of chick lens epithelial cells into lens fiber cells and can be studied in cultured embryonic lens epithelia. Quantitation of δ-crystallin mRNA by molecular hybridizaton to a [³H]DNA complementary to δ-crystallin mRNA demonstrates that differentiation, both in ovo and in tissue culture, is associated with the accumulation of δ-crystallin mRNA. In the cultures, there is an overall stimulation of protein synthesis, including δ-crystallin mRNA during the first 5 hr in vitro. Between 5 and 24 hr in vitro there is a differential stimulation of δ-crystallin synthesis and an accumulation of δ-crystallin mRNA that can quantitatively account for this stimulation.     

Differentiation of lens and pigment cells in cultures of neural retinal cells of early chick embryos

Dissociated cells of neural retinas of 3.5-day-old chick embryos (stages 20–21) were cultured as a monolayer in order to examine their differentiation in vitro. These cells started to grow actively soon after inoculation and formed a confluent sheet within which neuroblast-like cells with long cytoplasmic processes were differentiated by 8 days. At about 16 days the differentiation of both lentoid bodies and foci of pigment cells was observed, while neuronal structure disappeared. The numbers of lentoid bodies and foci of pigmented cells continued to increase up to 30 days, when primary cultures were terminated. The increase in δ-crystallin content, as measured by quantitative immunoelectrophoresis assay using rabbit antiserum against δ-crystallin, was consistent with the increase in the number of lentoid bodies in cultures. The amount of α-crystallin per culture, estimated by the same technique as above, reached a maximum at 16 days and decreased slightly during further culture. The differentiation of both lentoid bodies and pigment cells was observed also in cultures of the second generation. The results demonstrate that cells of the undifferentiated neuroepithelium of 3.5-day-old embryonic retinas can achieve at least three differentiations, neuronal, lens, and pigment cells, in vitro. We discuss several differences between the present results and the previous ones from in vitro cultures of 8- to 9-day-old embryonic neural retinas.     

An attempt to assay the state of determination by using transfected genes as probes in transdifferentiation of neural retina into lens

Hybrid genes coding for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) with a non-specific retroviral, lens-specific delta-crystallin or lens-specific alpha-crystallin promoters were constructed to transfect the transdifferentiating (lentoidogenic) and non-transdifferentiating (non-lentoidogenic) cultures of chicken embryonic neural retina for assaying the state of determination towards lens differentiation. The expression occurred only when CAT genes with lens-specific promoters were transfected to the cultures maintained in the conditions permissive to lentoidogenesis. The expression of these exogenous, lens-specific CAT genes began at stages of culturing that were earlier than the expression of endogenous crystallin. Presumably, there are two steps in the transdifferentiation of neural retina into lens; acquisition of capacity to express crystallin genes and derepression of the endogenous crystallin genes.     

Distinct interactions of αA-crystallin with homologous substrate proteins, δ-crystallin and argininosuccinate lyase, under thermal stress

δ-Crystallin is a taxon-specific eye lens protein that was recruited from argininosuccinate lyase (ASL) through gene sharing. ASL is a metabolic enzyme that catalyzes the reversible conversion of argininosuccinate into arginine and fumarate and shares about 70% sequence identity and similar overall topology with δ-crystallin. ASL has a lower thermal stability than δ-crystallin. In this study, we show that the small heat shock protein, αA-crystallin, functions as a molecular chaperone, and enhanced thermal stability of both δ-crystallin and ASL. The stoichiometry for efficient protection of the two substrate proteins by αA-crystallin was determined by slowly increasing the temperature. N- or C-terminal truncated mutants of δ-crystallin co-incubated with αA-crystallin showed higher thermal stability than wild-type enzyme, and the stoichiometry for efficient protection was the same. Thermal unfolding of δ-crystallin or ASL in the presence of αA-crystallin followed a similar three-state model, as determined by circular dichroism analyses. A stable intermediate which retained about 30% α-helical structure was observed. Protection from thermal denaturation by αA-crystallin was by interaction with partly unfolded ASL or δ-crystallin to form high molecular weight heteroligomers, as judged by size-exclusive chromatography and SDS-PAGE analyses. Aggregate formation of ASL was significantly reduced in the presence of αA-crystallin. The extent of protection of ASL and δ-crystallin at different ratios of αA-crystallin were described by hyperbolic and sigmoidal curves, respectively. These results suggest the preferential recognition of partly unfolded ASL by αA-crystallin. In contrast, unstable δ-crystallin might trigger a cooperative interaction by higher stoichiometries of αA-crystallin leading to fuller protection. The different interactions of αA-crystallin with the two homologous but functionally different substrate proteins show its behavior as a chaperone is variable.     

pp60c-src expression in transdifferentiating cultures of embryonic chick neural retina cells

Chick embryo neural retinal cells transdifferentiate extensively into lens cells when cultured in Eagle's MEM containing horse and fetal calf sera (FHMEM). Such cultures express elevated levels of pp60c-src-associated tyrosine kinase activity relative to parallel cultures prevented from transdifferentiating by the addition of supplementary glucose (FHGMEM) or replacement of MEM by medium 199 (F199). Northern blotting and in vitro translation studies suggest that c-src mRNA levels are only slightly higher in late transdifferentiating (FHMEM) cultures as compared to parallel blocked (FHGMEM or F199) cultures. By immunocytochemical staining, we show that pp60c-src protein is largely localized in cell groups undergoing conversion into lens (i.e. expressing delta crystallin) in late FHMEM cultures. Initial studies of pp60c-src in chick lens tissues during development indicate that higher kinase activity is found in the epithelial cells relative to mature lens fibres. Thus pp60c-src may be expressed both during the differentiation of lens cells in vivo and during the transdifferentiation of neural retina cells into lens in vitro.     

Transdifferentiation of putative neuronal cells of neural retina into lens: A demonstration by chick-quail chimeric cultures

Summary To elucidate the cell-type origin of lens cells, which differentiate in stationary cultures of neural retina, chimeric cultures between chick and quail cells were made to recombine xenoplastically the different cell fractions separated from 8- to 9-day cultures of 3.5-day-old embryonic neural retinal cells by means of centrifugation in Percoll. Extensive lentoidogenesis occurred in the recombination of the N2-fraction (consisting mostly of small round cells) with the E-fraction (containing a number of flattened epithelial cells). Taking advantage of the difference in electrophoretic mobility of chick and quail -crystallin, it was shown that this lens-specific protein, synthesized in the chimeric cultures, was mostly of the species-specificity of N2. Microscopic observations of histological sections of cell sheets of quail N2- and chick E-fraction chimeric cultures revealed that most cells with -crystallin, as identified by means of immunohistological detection, are provided with a nuclear marker characteristic of quail. By determining the level of activity of choline acetyltransferase and by examining the stainability with a fluorescent dye (Merocyanine-540), it was suggested that cells in the N2-fraction are primitive neuroblast-like cells. Thus, we can conclude that putative neuronal cells in early cultures of avian embryonic neural retina can transdifferentiate into lens cells.     

The Mechanism of σ-Crystallin Gene Regulation: Cooperation of Lens-Specific and Non-Specific Elements1

Employing δ-crystallin gene as a model, we have investigated tissue-specific gene regulation. Our approach was to analyze regulatory elements associated with the gene utilizing gene transfer techniques. Introduction of the chicken δ1-crystallin gene into the genome of developing mouse embryos resulted in lens-specific expression, indicating that the elements governing the tissue specificity are located in the DNA sequence introduced. Through analysis of various regions of the δ1-crystallin gene and the associated DNA sequences, we identified a lens-specific enhancer in the third intron of the gene. It was demonstrated that this enhancer alone is sufficient to account for lens specificity of the δ1-crystallin gene. Dissection of the δ1-crystallin enhancer and functional assessment by multiplication of enhancer fragments demonstrated the cooperative interaction of lens-specific and nonspecific elements in the enhancer. The mechanism by which heterologous elements cooperate in generating enhancer activity unquestionably provides great flexibility to the regulatory system, and may account for developmental modulation of gene activity superimposed on tissue specificity.     

THE INFLUENCE OF GROWTH-INHIBITING AND GROWTH-PROMOTING MEDIUM CONDITIONS ON CRYSTALLIN ACCUMULATION IN TRANSDIFFERENTIATING CULTURES OF EMBRYONIC CHICK NEURAL RETINA

The effects of media containing undialysed serum (controls) or dialysed serum with or without ascorbic acid, were compared during the second half of the 41-day culture period in embryonic chick neural retina cultures, which had all been grown in control medium prior to 19 days. Conditions permitting greatest culture growth (controls) showed earlier and more extensive development of lentoids, greater accumulation of total crystallin and a higher proportion of δ relative to α+β crystallins. Conditions allowing least culture growth (dialysed serum) gave converse results throughout. Thus changes in culture growth rate apparently affect δ crystallin production more than α or β crystallin production. Insulin promotes growth in neural retina cultures, whether present throughout the culture period (in this case 31 days), or only from 18 days onwards. The frequency and survival of putative neuronal cell aggregates are both increased by insulin during the first 18 days of culture. Delta crystallin production during subsequent transdifferentiation is selectively promoted by insulin when present throughout, but this effect is largely obviated when insulin is present only from 18 days onwards. This anomaly could arise through percursor cell selection during the earlier phases of culture, since it is possible that some (not all) lentoids may be derived from aggregates of neuronal-like cells in neural retina cultures. Thus precursor cell selection as well as culture growth rate may influence the pattern of crystallin production during transdifferentiation.     

The control of δ-crystallin gene expression during lens cell development: Dissociation of cell elongation,cell division, δ-crystallin synthesis,and δ-crystallin mRNA accumulation

Previous studies have shown that freshly explanted 6-day-old embryonic chick lens epithelial cells elongate, differentially increase their synthesis of δ-crystallin, and accumulate δ-crystallin mRNA when cultured with fetal calf serum; in contrast, precultured serum-starved 6-day-old and freshly explanted 19-day-old embryonic epithelial cells divide when treated with fetal calf serum. We have explored whether the stimulation of δ-crystallin gene expression (as measured by δ-crystallin synthesis and δ-crystallin mRNA accumulation) is affected by inhibiting lens cell elongation with colchicine, and whether δ-crystallin gene expression is increased in lens epithelial cells stimulated to divide by treatment with fetal calf serum, as it is in those stimulated to elongate by treatment with serum. Three new findings were made in this study. First, the stimulation of δ-crystallin gene expression does not require elongation of the cultured lens cells. Second, a decreased proportion of δ-crystallin synthesis is observed in lens epithelial cells during normal development and during serum starvation; in neither case is this decrease associated with a reduction in the number of δ-crystallin mRNA sequences per cell. Finally, serum stimulation of lens cell division does not increase the proportion of δ-crystallin synthesis, but can promote the accumulation of δ-crystallin mRNA. Thus, the relative proportion of δ-crystallin synthesized during chick lens development is not solely a function of the number of δ-crystallin mRNA sequences in the lens cells.     

Degradation of δ-crystallin mRNA in the lens fiber cells of the chicken

δ-Crystallin is the principal protein synthesized in the embryonic chicken lens. After hatching δ-crystallin synthesis decreases and eventually ceases. We have determined when the δ-crystallin messenger RNA (mRNA) disappears from the lens fiber cells during the first year of age by cell-free translation of lens RNA in a reticulocyte lysate, RNA blot (Northern) hybridization, and in situ hybridization. The hybridization was performed with a nick-translated, cloned δ-crystallin cDNA (pδCr2). δ-Crystallin mRNA was present in the lens until 3 months of age and disappeared between the third and fifth month after hatching. The in situ hybridization experiments indicated that the δ-crystallin mRNA was present throughout the lens fiber mass until 1 month after hatching and was greatly reduced in the cortical fiber cells thereafter. In contrast to earlier stages, then, the cortical fiber cells differentiating at the lens equator after about 1 month of age do not accumulate δ-crystallin mRNA. The data also indicate that the maximal half-life of functional δ-crystallin mRNA in the posthatched chicken lens is about 2 months.