Defective B cell tolerance induction in New Zealand black mice. I. Macrophage independence and comparison with other autoimmune strains

B cell unresponsiveness was examined in vitro by using spleen cells from autoimmune NZB, BXSB/Mp male, MRL/Mp-Ipr/Ipr (MRL/l), and control mice, and the tolerogen trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP-HGG). The B cell subset responsive to TNP-Brucella abortus in each autoimmune and control strain that was tested was highly susceptible to tolerance induction with the use of high epitope density conjugates (TNP30HGG and TNP32HGG). When a tolerogen with a lower epitope density was used (TNP7HGG), several control strains were all rendered tolerant in a thymic-independent and hapten-specific manner. NZB B cells were resistant to all concentrations of TNP7HGG tested, whereas B cells from BXSB/Mp male and MRL/1 mice were resistant to low concentrations of this tolerogen. NZB mice were resistant in addition to tolerance induction with TNP9HGG, TNP10HGG, and TNP12.7HGG. Experiments were performed to determine whether splenic macrophages played a role in resistance to tolerance in NZB mice. The mixing of NZB and control DBA/2J T cell-depleted splenocytes revealed no modulatory effects by the accessory cells in culture. Moreover, B cells rigorously depleted of macrophages by double Sephadex G-10 column passage exhibited characteristic patterns of resistance or susceptibility in NZB and control strains, respectively. These findings support the conclusion that resistance to tolerance in NZB mice is determined at the B cell level and are consistent with the hypothesis that diverse immunoregulatory disturbances contribute in varying degrees to the development of systemic lupus erythematosus in different inbred strains of mice.     

Specific suppression of the immune response by HGG tolerant spleen cells. I. Parameters affecting the level of suppression.

After adoptive transfer, the spleen cells from mice made tolerant to human gamma-globulin (HGG) specifically suppress the immune response of normal spleen cells. However, this suppressive activity in the spleen cells of tolerant mice is only present for a brief period after treatment with tolerogen. Spleen cells from animals injected 10 days earlier with tolerogen reduce the immune response of an equal number of normal spleen cells by 75%. Spleen cells from mice made tolerant 40 days previously are, however, no longer suppressive, even though they remain completely unresponsive. These data suggest that active suppression of antigen-reactive cells is not the mechanism responsible for maintaining tolerance to HGG, but rather is only transiently associated with the tolerant state. Further evidence in favor of the separation of the tolerant state from suppressive activity is that complete suppression of the normal spleen cell response requires either a high ratio of tolerant to immune competent cells or a delay in the antigenic challenge of the reconstituted recipients. By contrast, such manipulations are not required to demonstrate the complete unresponsiveness of the tolerant cells after adoptive transfer.     

Membrane defects of the tolerant B cell. I. Failure of antigen-induced capping.

In order to study the membrane function of tolerant B antigen-binding cells, tolerance to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) determinant was induced in mice by injecting the reactive form of the hapten, trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS). By appropriate transfer experiments, Fidler and Golub (J. Immunol.112, 1891, 1974) had previously shown that this form of tolerance is a B-cell property, induced and expressed in the absence of T cells. Hapten inhibition demonstrated the TNP-specificity of receptors on TNP-donkey erythrocyte(TNP-D)-binding cells in tolerant and nontolerant mice. About 88% of these cells were B cells by immunofluorescence, and the remainder were T cells. In the tolerant mice, challenge with TNP-sheep erythrocytes failed to expand the TNP-binding population, but sheep erythrocyte binders and anti-sheep plaque-forming cells expanded normally. Despite little or no change in TNP-binding cell numbers after tolerance induction, the TNP-binding cells of tolerant animals could not cap their receptors, in contrast to the sheep erythrocyte-binding cells from the same animals which capped normally. Although there is no anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response when tolerogen and immunogen are given simultaneously, capping failure is not evident until 2–4 days after tolerogen exposure. By Day 7, substantial recovery of immune responsiveness had occurred, yet even 12 months after a single dose of tolerogen there was no restoration of capping. Thus despite the association of both capping failure and unresponsiveness with tolerogen exposure, these lymphocyte functional defects appeared not to be causally related.     

The induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. V. Evidence for b-cell deletion in vitro with serum from tolerant mice.

The serum from mice that had been rendered specifically tolerant (TolS) to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) hapten by the injection of trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) is effective in the in vitro induction of immunological unresponsiveness in murine spleen cells. This tolerance system was investigated with particular emphasis upon the mode of induction. The observed inhibition by TolS of responses to the thymic-independent (TI) antigen TNP-lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS) was stable following adoptive transfer to lethally irradiated recipients and was due neither to the delay of in vitro responsiveness nor to effector cell blockade at the level of the antibody-forming cell. Neither suppressor cells nor cell-bound tolerogen carry-over were responsible for the tolerance induced by TolS. TNP-LPS doses, including a wide range of polyclonal activating concentrations, were ineffective in reversing the unresponsive state induced by cocultivation with TolS. Additionally, unconjugated LPS in either fetal calf serum (FCS)-containing or FCS-free cultures did not break tolerance. This failure of polyclonal activating substances to reverse the unresponsive state suggests that blockade of TNP-specific receptors is not the mechanism of tolerogenesis, since such compounds trigger cells polyclonally through nonimmunoglobulin receptors. Tolerance induced by incubation of spleen cells with TolS for 24 hr followed by extensive washing was stable whether the immunogenic stimulus was the TI antigen TNP-LPS or the thymic-dependent (TD) form of the hapten, TNP-sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRC). Washing spleen cells at elevated temperatures after preculturing with TolS to avoid possible reassociation of surface Ig (sIg)-bound TNP conjugates did not lead to escape from tolerance. Antigen-free incubation for 24 hr following cultivation with TolS was equally unsuccessful in reversing the unresponsive state. Thus, extensive washing following tolerance induction and antigen-free cultivation where unblocking or turnover and resynthesis of sIg receptors should have taken place provided no support for receptor blockade as the mode of in vitro induction and maintenance of tolerance by TolS. Treatment with the proteolytic enzyme pronase with the intention of removing potential tolerogen from the cell surface revealed a stable tolerant state. Incubation with anti-Ig or anti-TNP antisera under conditions designed to allow capping and removal of sIg-bound tolerogen or surface-bound TNP conjugates also failed to reverse the tolerance induced by incubation with TolS. The results presented here and previously lend no support to active or passive suppression or blockade of reactive cells as the mechanism of tolerance induction in vitro by TolS. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that TolS-induced unresponsiveness is due to a functional deletion of TNP-specific B lymphocytes. Furthermore, the similarities observed between the induction of tolerance by TNBS injection and TolS-induced unresponsiveness are consistent with the suggestion that TNBS-induced tolerance in vivo is mediated by a component of TolS which is active as a tolerogen in vitro.     

The role of macrophages in B cell tolerance. I. Antigen-specific failure of Thy-1, Ly-2 negative adherent cells from tolerant mice to reconstitute immunocompetence in adherent cell deficient spleen cells

T-Cell-independent B-cell tolerance to the hapten derivatives of carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) or methyl cellulose (MC) appears to be controlled by Thy-1-, Ly-2- adherent (A) cells contained in the spleen or peritoneal fluid. Immunocompetence in nonadherent (NA) normal spleen cells could be restored in vitro by irradiated A cells from normal mice. However, NA cells reconstituted with irradiated A cells derived from hapten specifically tolerant mice failed to respond to the same hapten, but responded normally to an immunogenic challenge with another unrelated antigen. A cells that had been preincubated at 4 degrees C with hapten derivatized MC also failed to restore immunocompetence. While preincubation of unfractionated spleen cells with the tolerogen under the same conditions resulted in B-cell unresponsiveness, such treatment of NA cells failed to render B cells tolerant. Treatment of A cells from tolerant mice with the reducing agent potassium iodide (KI) in vitro restored their capacity to render cultures of NA cells immunocompetent to the relevant hapten. Moreover, treatment with KI of spleen cells from mice injected with the tolerogen was shown to render them responsive. We suggest that B-cell tolerance induced by hapten derivatives of CMC and MC is mediated by suppressive macrophages contained among A cells. Certain subpopulations of macrophages are known to exert cytotoxic effects upon target cells by the release at close range of oxidating agents. We postulate that hapten derivatized CMC and MC, through unique properties of the carrier, bind to and possibly activate macrophages rendering them specifically suppressive for hapten binding B cells.     

Establishment of unresponsiveness in primed B lymphocytes in vivo

As an approach to examine the influence of the state of cellular activation on the ability to tolerize B cells, the induction of unresponsiveness in human gamma-globulin-(HGG) primed B lymphocytes was studied in an adoptive transfer system. In contrast to transferred normal spleen cells, spleen cells from HGG-primed mice are not readily rendered unresponsive when exposed to the tolerogen, deaggregated HGG (DHGG), in irradiated recipients. A kinetic study showed that unfractionated primed spleen cells do not respond to an antigenic challenge given between 6 and 10 days after cell transfer and injection of DHGG, indicating that they are transiently depressed. In contrast, isolated primed B cells are tolerized when transferred to recipients and treated with DHGG in the absence of T cells. Furthermore, primed B cells exposed to tolerogen in the recipients do not recover the ability to respond to HGG either after a secondary challenge with AHGG given up to 14 days after transfer, or after 2 consecutive challenges given on days 14 and 24 after transfer. The presence of primed T cells at the time of tolerization interferes with the induction of unresponsiveness in these primed B cells. These studies suggest that the presence of primed T cells is responsible for the inability to tolerize unfractionated primed spleen cells populations and that primed B cells themselves are not intrinsically resistant to the induction of unresponsiveness.     

B cell tolerance. I. Analysis of hapten-specific unresponsiveness induced in vitro in adult and neonatal murine spleen cell populations.

The cellular mechanisms and tolerogen dose requirements of hapten-specific unresponsiveness induced in vitro by using 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl human gamma-globulin (TNP17HgG) were analyzed in adult and neonatal murine splenocytes. Tolerance induction in both cell populations was found to be independent of non-B cell effects including BAtheta-positive cells, Ly 2.2-positive cells, adding or reducing the number of macrophages, and large excesses of HgG. The tolerance induced was specific and not "infectious", further excluding a role for suppressor T cells. Neonatal splenic B cells were rendered tolerant by doses of TNP17HgG 1000-fold less than those required to produce similar tolerance in splenic B cells from adults. These findings support the concept of functional clonal abortion as a mechanism for producing tolerance to self antigens.     

Defective B-cell tolerance in New Zealand black mice. Fc receptor-independence of resistance to low-epitope-density tolerogens

Trinitrophenyl (TNP) human gamma-globulin with low-epitope-density tolerizes B cells from normal BDF1 mice in a Fc gamma receptor-dependent manner but does not tolerize B cells from preautoimmune NZB mice. In order to investigate the relationships between tolerance induction and epitope density independently of Fc gamma receptor function in these two strains, TNP conjugates of two additional thymic-independent tolerogenic carriers, D-glutamic acid-D-lysine (D-GL) and carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC), were tested. A brief pulse with low-epitope-density conjugates such as TNP4.4-D-GL rendered unfractionated or T-cell-depleted spleen cells from BDF1 but not NZB mice tolerant in a hapten-specific manner. Spleen cells from NZB mice, however, were susceptible to tolerization with TNP13.5-D-GL. NZB mice were also resistant to tolerance induction in vivo with TNP5.5-D-GL, TNP3-CMC, and TNP6-CMC, all of which tolerize BDF1 mice in vivo. Both strains were tolerized with TNP13.5-D-GL and TNP13-CMC in vivo. NZB mice were also significantly less susceptible to tolerance induction with TNP3-CMC when TNP-Ficoll was substituted for TNP Brucella abortus as the challenge antigen. These findings militate against the possibility that an Fc gamma receptor defect is the principal mechanism of resistance of NZB B cells to tolerance induction with-low-epitope density conjugates.     

Neonatally induced tolerance to soluble protein antigens. II. A role for the thymus in prolonging tolerance

Mice were rendered tolerant to bovine serum albumin (BSA) or fowl γ-globulin (FGG) by neonatal injection. Spleen and thymus cells from tolerant mice were able to suppress responsiveness of normal adult spleen cells, but only if tolerant donor mice were between the ages of 6 weeks and the age at which mice were no longer tolerant (10 weeks for BSA tolerance and 20 weeks for FGG tolerance). To determine whether T-cell-dependent suppression was obligatory for the maintenance of tolerance, neonatal nude and euthymic littermate mice were injected with tolerizing doses of FGG. FGG-specific B-cell tolerance in nude mice lasted until the mice were 8 weeks of age. In sharp contrast, B-cell tolerance in euthymic littermates lasted until 22 weeks of age. These results are consistent with a “fail-safe” role of T-cell-dependent immune suppression in the maintenance of tolerance.     

Membrane defects in the tolerant B cell. II. Mechanism of capping failure and reversal by antigen exposure.

The demonstration that TNP-binding B lymphocytes from animals whose B cells have been rendered tolerant to TNP by trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid cannot undergo antigen-induced capping of their TNP receptors for at least a year despite recovery of immune responsiveness has led to a search for the mechanism of the capping failure. Microtubule-dependent membrane “locking” analogous to that induced by concanavalin A appears to afflict the tolerant B cells, in that capping TNP receptors is restored after exposure to 10^?4M colchicine or overnight incubation at 4 °C. Assignment of the defect to the cytoskeleton rather than the receptors themselves is also supported by the observations that enzymatic stripping and regrowth of receptors does not unlock the cell and that non-Ig membrane molecules recognized by antilymphocyte serum also cannot be capped on the tolerant cells. Cells which have remained locked for 4 days to 8 months after a single tolerogen exposure become unlocked 4 days after immunogen is given. Four days after immunogen, tolerogen fails to lock the membranes of TNP-binding cells. These results suggest that tolerogen contact interferes in a much broader range of functions in the TNP-binding cell than those which affect the immune response. Among these effects is a remarkably stable “locked” configuration of the cytoskeleton which is independent of immune responsiveness or receptor turnover, but which can be reversed by exposure to immunogen whether or not an immune response ensues.     

Induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. VII. Correlation between trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid administration, serum trinitrophenyl content, and level of tolerance

The induction of immunological tolerance with trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) was studied by a comparison of the concentration of trinitrophenyl (TNP) in the serum of tolerant mice (TolS) and the degree of unresponsiveness induced as the dose and time of tolerogen injection were varied. The concentration of TNP in TolS was greater with a larger dose of TNBS, as expected, and decreased with time after tolerogen injection in a biphasic manner. The rapid initial decline followed on Day 10 by a more gradual decrease in TNP concentration suggests that there were two classes of TNP conjugates produced by TNBS injection. The serum TNP concentration appeared to correlate to the in vivo response of TNBS-treated mice to thymic-dependent and thymic-independent antigenic challenge while little correlation was evident with the in vitro response.     

Tolerance induced by TNP-derivatized syngeneic erythrocytes: evidence for cooperation between hapten-specific T and hapten-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response.

Tolerance to the DNP haptenic determinant was induced with a single i.v. injection of trinitrophenylated syngeneic red blood cells. The tolerant state lasted 1 month and was stable on transfer to irradiated thymectomized syngeneic recipients. Suppressor activity was found soon after injection of tolerogen but was lost before the termination of tolerance. The unresponsive state could be reversed by adding normal thymus cells to tolerant spleen cells but not by normal bone marrow cells. LPS when given with immunogen restored the normal immune response in tolerant mice. Thus the injection of TNP-MRBC induced partial immune unresponsiveness which was characterized by the induction of T cell suppressor activity and by a hapten-specific helper T cells tolerance. Finally, these studies suggest a cooperative interaction between DNP-specific T lymphocytes and DNP-specific B lymphocytes in the immune response to DNP-BGG.     

Interference with tolerance induction in vivo by inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis

Prostaglandins (PG) have been implicated as modulators of both humoral and cellular immune responses. In order to evaluate a possible role for PG in tolerance, the effect of inhibitors of prostaglandin synthesis on tolerance induction and circumvention has been investigated. Injection of deaggregated human gamma-globulin (DHGG) into A/J mice leads to unresponsiveness to a subsequent challenge with immunogenic aggregated human gamma-globulin (AHGG). Administration of indomethacin (IM) or acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) shortly before and after DHGG injection prevents tolerance induction. PGE2 reverses the tolerance overriding effect provided by IM. IM is not able to overcome unresponsiveness when given 10 and 20 days after tolerance induction, at a time point when both T and B lymphocytes are tolerant. As previously shown, lipopolysaccharide (LPS) both inhibits the induction of tolerance to HGG and circumvents tolerant T helper cells late in tolerance when competent B cells are present. In contrast, IM is unable to circumvent T-helper cell tolerance when given at Day 60 after tolerogen, when B cells (but not T cells) are responsive. Furthermore, LPS acts as an adjuvant, B-cell mitogens, inducer of polyclonal Ig secretion, and primes mice when given with tolerogen, while IM has none of these properties. These results indicate a difference between the effects of IM and LPS on tolerance and a possible role of PG in DHGG-mediated tolerance induction.     

Characterization of cytotoxic cells in mice rendered neonatally tolerant of MHC alloantigens: evidence for repertoire modification

A common prediction of clonal deletion/inactivation hypotheses is that cells with high avidity for tolerogen are preferentially eliminated, with low avidity cells being most likely to escape the tolerance induction mechanism. Thus it would be expected that the tolerogen-specific cells in tolerant mice would have a different repertoire than those in normal mice. To find evidence in favor of this prediction, neonatal B10.A mice were rendered tolerant to B10 by the injection of 15 X 10(6) (B10.A X B10)F1 spleen and bone marrow cells, and tolerance was assessed by the acceptance of B10 skin grafts for greater than 50 days. Mice rendered tolerant in this manner contain severely reduced (to less than 10% of normal) but detectable numbers of tolerogen-specific cytotoxic cell precursors that can be activated in the presence, but not absence, of exogenous interleukin 2. Spleen cells from the tolerant animals were compared with those of normal B10.A mice with respect to the expression of differentiation markers on the surface of B10-specific cytotoxic cells and their precursors, and the relative strength of the anti-B10 response toward Kb and Db as a measure of the repertoire of the cytotoxic cell populations. The T cell nature of the tolerogen-specific cytotoxic cells in both normal and tolerant mice was confirmed by their susceptibility to lysis by anti-Thy-1 or Lyt-2 antibody and complement. More importantly, cold target inhibition experiments showed that cytotoxic T cells from tolerant mice were inhibited to a greater degree by B10.A(2R) (KkDb) cold targets than B10.A(5R) (KbDd), suggesting that the response was preferentially directed at the D end of H-2, in direct contrast to normal B10.A spleen cells, which show a preferential response against Kb. Measurement of the frequency of anti-Kb and anti-Db cytotoxic T cell precursors in the spleens of normal and tolerant mice confirmed the differential specificities seen in the cold target experiments. The data suggest that neonatal tolerance induction results in repertoire modification of the anti-tolerogen response rather than a uniform decrease in anti-tolerogen reactivity. Possible mechanisms to explain the alteration in the repertoire of tolerant mice are discussed.     

Cellular events in tolerance. VI. Neonatal vs adult B cell tolerance: differences in antigen-binding cell patterns and lipopolysaccharide stimulation.

The numbers and fate of antigen-binding cells (ABC) in neonatal and adult mice rendered tolerant to fluorescein (FL)-labeled heterologous gamma-globulins were studied. Similar numbers of FL-ABC were observed 1 day after tolerogen in both adult and neonatal mouse spleens: by 7 days after tolerization, no FL-ABC were observed in either case. Reinjection with FL-tolerogen at 7 days led to the detection of normal numbers of ABC in adult mice but significantly reduced numbers in neonates. This suggests that neonatal ABC either have been deleted or have failed to resynthesize surface receptors. Two weeks after tolerance induction, spleen cells from these tolerant mice were cultured with Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide (LPS), a polyclonal B cell mitogen, or with specific antigen. Tolerant adult spleen cells made an equivalent anti-FL response to that of the uninjected controls when stimulated with LPS, but were unresponsive to specific antigenic triggering. In contrast, spleen cells from neonatally tolerized mice were unresponsive to either specific or nonspecific (LPS) stimulation. Thus, these neonatally tolerized spleen cells lose sensitivity to polyclonal-stimulating agents (along with their receptors), or more simply, are deleted.     

Suppressors of the graft vs graft reaction in tolerance to alloantigens

Immune response and suppressor cell activity of CBA (H-2k) mice made tolerant to allogeneic C57B1/6 (H-2b) heart graft were studied in graft-versus-graft reaction (GvGR). Intact CBA spleen cells inhibited response of (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 cells to antigenic stimulus (sheep red blood cells--SRBC), when injected together into lethally irradiated (CBA X C57B1/6)F1 mice. Spleen cells of tolerant mice were unable to decrease immune response of (CBA X C57B1/6F1 lymphocytes to SRBC and suppressed specifically the inhibition induced by intact CBA spleen cells. Spleen cells from tolerant mice were also capable of suppressing GvGR induced by CBA lymphocytes immune to C57B1/6 cells. Pretreatment of tolerant spleen cells with rabbit antithymocyte globulin and complement before adoptive transfer diminished markedly the suppression. The results obtained in the study suggest that suppression of transplantation immunity in this model is mostly due to T suppressor cells.     

Studies on the resistance to tolerance induction against human IgG in DDD mice. III. Development of the resistance with age and cellular events.

Three-week-old DDD mice were easily rendered tolerant to human IgG while 12-week-old mice were tolerized only partially. Mechanisms of the development of the resistance with age were investigated. It was shown by the cell transfer experiments that spleen T cells, purified on a Tetron wool column, from older mice were responsible for the resistance, which was not associated with the loss of suppressor cells with age. To elucidate the possibility of whether tolerogen-sensitive spleen T cells differentiate into resistant ones, cell transfer experiments were carried out in which thymectomized, lethally irradiated mice were reconstituted with spleen cells from 3-week-old mice and then treated with the tolerogen on various days afterward. The results indicated that tolerance was inducible in these hosts to the same degree, irrespective of the timing of the tolerogen injection, while age-matched intact mice gradually acquired the resistance. Then the possibility of whether age of thymus affected tolerance inducibility of the hosts or not was examined. The tolerogen was injected into irradiated, bone-marrow-reconstituted mice which bore either 4- or 7-week-old thymus. It was shown that helper T cells newly generated under younger thymus acquired higher susceptibility to the tolerogen. There was no difference in tolerance inducibility irrespective as to whether bone marrow cells were prepared from younger or older mice. From these observations it was suggested that the resistance to tolerance induction in DDD mice is acquired through the appearance of resistant T cells which are generated from T-cell precursors in bone marrow under the influence of a radioresistant thymic constitution and predominantly located in the spleen.     

The use of haptenated-immunoglobulin molecules to induce tolerance in B cells from neonatal mice

The role of the Fc region of trinitrophenylated (TNP)-immunoglobulins (Ig) in their ability to induce tolerance in immature B cells was examined. With the use of B cells from neonatal mice, tolerogens that could or could not bind to Fc receptors were assessed for their ability to induce tolerance. This was accomplished by tolerizing spleen cells in bulk culture and assessing the degree of tolerance by challenging the cells with the thymus-independent antigen TNP-Brucella abortus (TNP-BA) in limiting dilution cultures. It was found that by using tolerogens containing 10 to 11 haptens per Ig molecule, immature B cells were very susceptible to tolerance induction. Mature B cells were not as susceptible. This increased susceptibility was independent of the Fc portion of the tolerogen, because TNP11-HGG and a TNP10-F(ab')2 induced equivalent degrees of unresponsiveness. When the TNP density was lowered to approximately five haptens per Ig molecule, those Ig molecules that contained Fc portions were superior tolerogens with the use of B cells from 6-day-old mice. Thus, a TNP4-HGG, TNP7-mouse IgG1, and TNP6-mouse IgG2a were more effective tolerogens than either TNP5-F(ab')2 or TNP6-mouse IgG3. These results confirm previous findings that immature B cells are inherently more susceptible to tolerance induction than mature B cells. They also suggest that very lightly haptenated Ig molecules may depend on Fc receptor-binding for effective tolerance induction. Finally, by means of a cytofluorograph, the surface IgD (sIgD) and sIgM phenotypes of splenic B cells from neonates of increasing age were determined. When comparing the phenotype of maturing cells with their tolerance susceptibilities, a correlation between the appearance of sIgD and the acquisition of resistance to tolerance was observed.     

Clonal analysis of helper and effector T-Cell function in neonatal transplantation tolerance: Clonal deletion of helper cells determines lack of in vitro responsiveness

Mice rendered tolerant at birth of H-2 alloantigens display concordant in vivo and in vitro phenotypes: they fail to reject skin grafts bearing the tolerated antigens, and their lymphoid cells fail to participate in tolerogen-specific mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLRs) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML). Tolerant animals normally reject third-party skin allografts and develop positive MLRs and CML to third-party antigens. It has been suggested that clonal deletion of antigen reactive cells is the basis for this spectrum of responses. To investigate further the basis for the lack of in vitro alloreactivity, we conducted limiting dilution studies with lymph node cells from adult mice tolerant of various H-2 disparities. When the frequencies of (a) cells responding to the tolerogen in MLR and (b) interleukin-2-producing cells against the tolerogen were determined, it appeared that both types of cells were functionally deleted, that is, the frequency of cells responding to tolerogen-bearing stimulator cells was identical with that of cells stimulated with syngeneic cells. On the assumption that cells from H-2 tolerant mice are deficient in helper cell activity toward the tolerogen, we performed CML cultures under conditions in which exogenous help was provided in the form of supernatants derived from concanavalin A stimulated rat spleen cell cultures. Lymphoid cells from H-2 tolerant mice generated significant cytotoxicity toward the tolerogen under these conditions, although the absolute level of killing was reduced compared with that of cells from normal mice. Limiting dilution assays confirmed that T_c precursors were present in tolerant mice, and that they were reduced to less than 10% of normal numbers; however, tolerogen-specific T_c precursors were present in frequencies significantly greater than self-reactive T_c precursors. These data indicate that a deletion mechanism operates in neonatal transplantation     

Membrane defects of the tolerant B cell. IV. Failure to accelerate antigen receptor loss

Mechanisms of immunologic tolerance affecting antibody responses include conditions extrinsic to the B cell such as dominant suppression by T cells (1), regulation by anti-idiotype (2), and tolerance in T helper cell populations (3). But tolerance can also result from changes in the antigen-reactive B cells such as their deletion (4), or that mysterious process by which they become "intrinsically tolerant", i.e., refractory to stimulation (5). One approach to learning more about the mechanism of intrinsic tolerance at the level of cell physiology is to determine which of the activation events that normally follow antigen contact occur or fail to occur in such cells. An established model of intrinsic B cell tolerance previously exploited in such studies in the trinitrophenyl (TNP)-self-induced tolerance model of Fidler and Golub (6). Having established that BDF1 mice injected with 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS) become tolerant to TNP, they showed by appropriate transfer experiments that the tolerance could be not induce antibody to TNP in such mice (8). cells (7). They also showed that lipopolysaccharide could not induce antibody to TNP in such mice (8). Together, these data indicated that in this example, tolerance is intrinsic to the B cells. B cells with receptors for TNP remain in these mice (9), providing an opportunity to study activation events in intrinsically tolerant B cells. This paper is part of an ongoing series of studies of activation events in TNP-antibody-binding cells (ABC)2 using this tolerance model (9-11). It shows that a TNP-antigen that normally induces rapid loss of antigen receptors on TNP-ABC cannot do so in mice rendered tolerant to TNP.