Multiple covalent modifications of Trg, a sensory transducer of Escherichia coli

The sensory transducers of Escherichia coli are integral membrane proteins that mediate the tactic response of cells to chemical stimuli. Adaptation to environmental stimuli is correlated with methylation of the transducer proteins. Two transducer genes, tsr and tar, exhibit extensive homologies while no homology has been detected between a third transducer, trg, and those genes. The Tsr and Tar proteins have been shown to contain multiple sites for methylation as well as two sites for another modification that requires an active cheB gene product and is designated the CheB-dependent modification. In this study, covalent modifications of the Trg protein were characterized by analysis of tryptic peptides. We found that methylation occurred at several sites on the Trg protein and that the protein contained at least three sites for CheB-dependent modification, two of which were located on a tryptic peptide that contains both methionine and lysine. This tryptic peptide is analogous to the methionine- and lysine-containing methyl-accepting peptides isolated from the Tsr and Tar proteins and like those peptides may contain several methyl-accepting sites. We estimated the pKa of the group created by the CheB-dependent modification on the methionine- and lysine-containing peptide of Trg to be between pH 2.2 and 5.8. This result supports the idea that the CheB-dependent modification is an enzymatic deamidation of glutamine to glutamic acid.     

Limited homology between trg and the other transducer proteins of Escherichia coli.

Transducers are transmembrane proteins that are central to the chemotactic system of Escherichia coli. The proteins transduce ligand recognition into an excitatory signal and function in adaptation as methyl-accepting proteins. The transducer genes tsr, tar, and tap have extensive homology with each other. However, previous studies revealed little indication of homology between those three transducer genes and a fourth gene, trg. We investigated the relationship between trg and the other genes by blot-hybridization experiments and the relationship between Trg and the other transducer proteins by immune precipitation and experiments with an antiserum raised to purified Trg protein. In experiments in which 35% mismatch would be tolerated, weak hybridization of trg was detected to a DNA fragment containing tar and tap but not to a fragment containing tsr. In experiments in which only 30% mismatch would be tolerated, no trg hybridization was apparent either to total chromosomal DNA or to DNA from hybrid plasmids carrying the other transducer genes. An anti-Trg serum formed immune precipitates with the Tsr and Tar proteins as well as with the Trg protein to which it was raised. We conclude that there is homology between Trg and the other transducer, but the homology is more limited than that shared among the other transducers. Furthermore, we found no indication of additional transducer genes closely related to trg. Thus, the trg gene is a somewhat distant cousin within a single transducer gene family of E. coli.     

Purification of receptor protein Trg by exploiting a property common to chemotactic transducers of Escherichia coli

The methyl-accepting chemotactic transducers of Escherichia coli were found to bind strongly to Cibacron blue-Sepharose. Among potential elutants tested, only S-adenosylmethionine at moderate concentrations and NaCl at concentrations greater than 1.5 M caused dissociation of these detergent-solubilized transmembrane proteins from the dye. Release by S-adenosylmethionine may be a generalized effect rather than the result of a specific binding site for that compound on transducers. A truncated trg gene was created that coded for the carboxyl-terminal three-fifths of the transducer, which constitutes the cytoplasmic domain common to all four transducers in E. coli. This domain bound to Cibacron blue-Sepharose and was eluted in a pattern similar to that exhibited by intact Trg, indicating that interaction with the dye occurred in this conserved domain. Adherence to Cibacron blue and elution by high salt formed the core of an efficient purification scheme, developed for Trg but applicable to all transducers in E. coli and perhaps to methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins in other species. Determination of the amino acid sequence at the beginning of purified Trg confirmed that it contained a longer hydrophilic segment at its amino terminus than other transducers of E. coli. The initial methionine of Trg is neither cleaved nor modified, in contrast to the Tar transducer in which the amino terminus was found previously to be blocked. Circular dichroic measurements of purified Trg indicated that the secondary structural organization of the protein is predominantly alpha-helix.     

Inversion of aerotactic response in Escherichia coli deficient in cheB protein methylesterase.

Mutants of Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium that were deficient in protein methylesterase activity encoded by cheB had an inverted response to oxygen; they were repelled by concentrations of oxygen that attract wild-type bacteria. Normal responses to oxygen and phosphotransferase substrates were observed in mutants that were deficient in protein methyltransferase (CheR) and the methyl-accepting transducing proteins (Tsr, Tar, Trg). However, the methylation-independent response to oxygen was modified by the loss of esterase activity. The inversion was apparently effected by the amidated Tsr protein present in cheB tsr+ mutants because aerotaxis was normal in cheB tsr strains. Chemotaxis to phosphotransferase sugars was normal in cheB mutants provided the extreme clockwise bias of the flagellar motors was modified to increase the probability of counterclockwise rotation.     

Evolution of chemotactic-signal transducers in enteric bacteria.

The methyl-accepting chemotactic-signal transducers of the enteric bacteria are transmembrane proteins that consist of a periplasmic receptor domain and a cytoplasmic signaling domain. To study their evolution, transducer genes from Enterobacter aerogenes and Klebsiella pneumoniae were compared with transducer genes from Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. There are at least two functional transducer genes in the nonmotile species K. pneumoniae, one of which complements the defect in serine taxis of an E. coli tsr mutant. The tse (taxis to serine) gene of E. aerogenes also complements an E. coli tsr mutant; the tas (taxis to aspartate) gene of E. aerogenes complements the defect in aspartate taxis, but not the defect in maltose taxis, of an E. coli tar mutant. The sequence was determined for 5 kilobases of E. aerogenes DNA containing a 3' fragment of the cheA gene, cheW, tse, tas, and a 5' fragment of the cheR gene. The tse and tas genes are in one operon, unlike tsr and tar. The cytoplasmic domains of Tse and Tas are very similar to those of E. coli and S. typhimurium transducers. The periplasmic domain of Tse is homologous to that of Tsr, but Tas and Tar are much less similar in this region. However, several short sequences are conserved in the periplasmic domains of Tsr, Tar, Tse, and Tas but not of Tap and Trg, transducers that do not bind amino acids. These conserved regions include residues implicated in amino-acid binding.     

Effects of glutamines and glutamates at sites of covalent modification of a methyl-accepting transducer.

Chemotactic transducer proteins of Escherichia coli contain four or five methyl-accepting glutamates that are crucial for sensory adaptation and gradient sensing. Two residues arise from posttranslational deamidation of glutamines to yield methyl-accepting glutamates. We addressed the significance of this arrangement by creating two mutated trg genes: trg(5E), coding for a transducer in which all five modification sites were synthesized as glutamates, and trg(5Q), in which all five were glutamines. We found that the normal (3E,2Q) configuration was not an absolute requirement for synthesis, assembly, or stable maintenance of transducers. Both mutant proteins were methylated, although Trg(5Q) had a reduced number of methyl-accepting sites because two glutamines at adjacent residues were blocked for deamidation and thus could not become methyl-accepting glutamates. The glutamine-glutamate balance had striking effects on signaling state. Trg(5E) was in a strong counterclockwise signaling configuration, and Trg(5Q) was in a strong clockwise signaling induced by ligand binding, and alanines substituted at modification sites had an intermediate effect. Chemotactic migration by growing cells containing trg(5E) or trg(5Q) exhibited reduced effectiveness, probably reflecting perturbations of the counterclockwise/clockwise ratio caused by newly synthesized transducers not modified rapidly enough to produce a balanced signaling state during growth. These defects were evident for cells in which other transducers were not available to contribute to balanced signaling or were present at lower levels than the mutant proteins.     

Phenol sensing by Escherichia coli chemoreceptors: a nonclassical mechanism

The four transmembrane chemoreceptors of Escherichia coli sense phenol as either an attractant (Tar) or a repellent (Tap, Trg, and Tsr). In this study, we investigated the Tar determinants that mediate its attractant response to phenol and the Tsr determinants that mediate its repellent response to phenol. Tar molecules with lesions in the aspartate-binding pocket of the periplasmic domain, with a foreign periplasmic domain (from Tsr or from several Pseudomonas chemoreceptors), or lacking nearly the entire periplasmic domain still mediated attractant responses to phenol. Similarly, Tar molecules with the cytoplasmic methylation and kinase control domains of Tsr still sensed phenol as an attractant. Additional hybrid receptors with signaling elements from both Tar and Tsr indicated that the transmembrane (TM) helices and HAMP domain determined the sign of the phenol-sensing response. Several amino acid replacements in the HAMP domain of Tsr, particularly attractant-mimic signaling lesions at residue E248, converted Tsr to an attractant sensor of phenol. These findings suggest that phenol may elicit chemotactic responses by diffusing into the cytoplasmic membrane and perturbing the structural stability or position of the TM bundle helices, in conjunction with structural input from the HAMP domain. We conclude that behavioral responses to phenol, and perhaps to temperature, cytoplasmic pH, and glycerol, as well, occur through a general sensing mechanism in chemoreceptors that detects changes in the structural stability or dynamic behavior of a receptor signaling element. The structurally sensitive target for phenol is probably the TM bundle, but other behaviors could target other receptor elements.     

Sites of covalent modification in Trg, a sensory transducer of Escherichia coli

The Trg protein mediates chemotactic response of Escherichia coli to the attractants ribose and galactose. Like other transducers, Trg is a transmembrane protein that undergoes post-translational covalent modification. The modifications are hydrolysis (deamidation) of certain glutamine side chains to create glutamate residues and methylation of specific glutamates to form carboxyl methyl esters. Analysis of radiolabeled, tryptic peptides by high performance liquid chromatography and gas-phase sequencing allowed direct identification of the modified residues of Trg. The protein has 5 methyl-accepting residues. Four, at positions 304, 310, 311, and 318, are contained in a 23-residue tryptic peptide ending in lysine. The fifth, at position 500, is within a 25-residue tryptic peptide ending in arginine. At two sites, 311 and 318, glutamines are deamidated to create methyl-accepting glutamates. There is not a required order of modification among the sites. However, there is a substantial preference for methylation on the arginine peptide and, among sites on the lysine peptide, for the middle pair. Comparison of sequences surrounding modified residues identified in this work for Trg and previously for Tsr and Tar suggests a consensus sequence for methyl-accepting sites of Ala/Ser-Xaa-Xaa-Glu-Glu*-Xaa-Ala/OH-Ala-OH/Ala, where OH signifies Ser or Thr and the asterick marks the site of modification.     

Multiple electrophoretic forms of methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins generated by stimulus-elicited methylation in Escherichia coli.

The tsr and tar genetic loci of Escherichia coli determine the presence in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins (MCPs) I and II, respectively, each of which consists of a distinct group of multiple bands. Synthesis of the tsr and tar products was directed in ultraviolet-irradiated bacteria by lambda transducing phages. The addition of appropriate chemotactic stimuli to these cells resulted in the appearance of additional, faster migrating electrophoretic forms of the Tsr and Tar polypeptides which disappeared upon removal of the stimulus. The stimulus-elicited forms comigrated with component bands of the corresponding MCPs. These results indicate that methylation itself caused shifts in electrophoretic mobility and hence led to the observed MCP band patterns. The number of Tsr species suggested that there were at least three methylated sites on the Tsr polypeptide. The conclusion that methylation generates multiplicity was supported by the results of experiments in which the tsr product was synthesized in mutant bacteria defective in specific chemotaxis functions concerned with methylation or demethylation of MCPs. Thus, the presence of a cheX defect blocked the stimulus-elicited appearance of faster migrating forms of the tsr product; conversely, the presence of a cheB defect resulted in a pronounced shift toward these forms in the absence of a chemotactic stimulus.     

Chemotactic Adaptation Is Altered by Changes in the Carboxy-Terminal Sequence Conserved among the Major Methyl-Accepting Chemoreceptors

In Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium, methylation and demethylation of receptors are responsible for chemotactic adaptation and are catalyzed by the methyltransferase CheR and the methylesterase CheB, respectively. Among the chemoreceptors of these species, Tsr, Tar, and Tcp have a well-conserved carboxy-terminal motif (NWET/SF) that is absent in Trg and Tap. When they are expressed as sole chemoreceptors, Tsr, Tar, and Tcp support good adaptation, but Trg and Tap are poorly methylated and supported only weak adaptation. It was recently discovered that CheR binds to the NWETF sequence of Tsr in vitro. To examine the physiological significance of this binding, we characterized mutant receptors in which this pentapeptide sequence was altered. C-terminally-mutated Tar and Tcp expressed in a receptorless E. coli strain mediated responses to aspartate and citrate, respectively, but their adaptation abilities were severely impaired. Their expression levels and attractant-sensing abilities were similar to those of the wild-type receptors, but the methylation levels of the mutant receptors increased only slightly upon addition of attractants. When CheR was overproduced, both the adaptation and methylation profiles of the mutant Tar receptor became comparable to those of wild-type Tar. Furthermore, overproduction of CheR also enhanced adaptive methylation of wild-type Trg, which lacks the NWETF sequence, in the absence of any other chemoreceptor. These results suggest that the pentapeptide sequence facilitates effective adaptation and methylation by recruiting CheR.     

Uropathogenic Escherichia coli strains generally lack functional Trg and Tap chemoreceptors found in the majority of E. coli strains strictly residing in the gut

The prevalence and function of four chemoreceptors, Tsr, Tar, Trg, and Tap, were determined for a collection of uropathogenic, fecal-commensal, and diarrheagenic Escherichia coli strains. tar and tsr were present or functional in nearly all isolates. However, trg and tap were significantly less prevalent or functional among the uropathogenic E. coli strains (both in 6% of strains) than among fecal-commensal strains (both in > or =50% of strains) or diarrheal strains (both in > or =75% of strains) (P < 0.02).     

Genetics of methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins in Escherichia coli: cheD mutations affect the structure and function of the Tsr transducer

The tsr gene specifies a methyl-accepting membrane protein involved in chemotaxis to serine and several repellent compounds. We have characterized a special class of tsr mutations designated cheD which alter the signaling properties of the Tsr transducer. Unlike tsr null mutants, cheD strains are generally nonchemotactic, dominant in complementation tests, and exhibit a pronounced counterclockwise bias in flagellar rotation. Several lines of evidence showed that cheD mutations were alleles of the tsr gene. First, cheD mutations were mapped into the same deletion segments as conventional tsr mutations. Second, restriction site analysis of the transducing phage deletions used to construct the genetic map demonstrated that the endpoints of the deletion segments fell within the tsr coding sequence. Third, a number of the cheD mutants synthesized Tsr proteins with slight changes in electrophoretic mobility, consistent with alterations in Tsr primary structure. These mutant proteins were able to undergo posttranslational deamidation and methylation reactions in the same manner as wild-type Tsr protein; however, the steady-state level of Tsr methylation in cheD strains was very high. The methylation state of the Tar protein, another species of methyl-accepting protein in Escherichia coli, was also higher than normal in cheD strains, suggesting that the aberrant Tsr transducer in cheD mutants has a generalized effect on the sensory adaptation system of the cell. These properties are consistent with the notion that the Tsr protein of cheD mutants is locked in an excitatory signaling mode that both activates the sensory adaptation system and drowns out chemotactic signals generated by other transducer species. Further study of cheD mutations thus promises to reveal valuable information about the functional architecture of the Tsr protein and how this transducer controls flagellar behavior.     

Thermosensing ability of Trg and Tap chemoreceptors in Escherichia coli.

The thermosensing ability of the Trg and Tap chemoreceptors in Escherichia coli was investigated after amplifying these receptors in a host strain lacking all four known chemoreceptors (Tar, Tsr, Trg, and Tap). Cells with an increased amount of either Trg or Tap showed mostly smooth swimming and no response to thermal stimuli. However, when the smooth-swimming bias of the cells was reduced by adding Trg- or Tap-mediated repellents, the cells showed clear changes in the swimming pattern upon temperature changes; Trg-containing cells showed tumbling at 23 degrees C but mostly smooth swimming at 32 degrees C, while Tap-containing cells showed smooth swimming at 20 degrees C but tumbling at 32 degrees C. These results indicate that although both Trg and Tap have the ability to sense thermal stimuli, Trg functions as a warm receptor, as reported previously for Tar and Tsr, while Tap functions as a cold receptor.     

Sensory transducers of E. coli are composed of discrete structural and functional domains

The tar and tsr genes of E. coli encode functionally analogous transducer proteins that mediate two distinct classes of chemotactic response. The tap gene lies adjacent to tar, and is thought to encode another transducer protein. We present here the complete nucleotide sequence of the tar-tap region of the E. coli genome, together with a comparative analysis of the sequences of the Tar, Tap, and Tsr proteins. The proteins appear to have a simple transmembrane structure consisting of an extracytoplasmic amino-terminal domain, a membrane-spanning domain, and an intracellular carboxy-terminal domain. The carboxy-terminal domains of three proteins possess highly homologous sequences and contain sites of methylation involved in sensory adaptation, while the amino-terminal sequences are only distantly related to one another, consistent with their serving as chemoreceptor domains that have diverged functionally.     

Aberrant regulation of methylesterase activity in cheD chemotaxis mutants of Escherichia coli

The adaptation process in several cheD chemotaxis mutants, which carry defects in tsr, the serine transducer gene, was examined. cheD mutants are smooth swimming and generally nonchemotactic; the defect is dominant to the wild-type tsr gene (J. S. Parkinson, J. Bacteriol. 142:953-961, 1980). All classes of methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins synthesized in unstimulated cheD strains are overmethylated relative to the wild type. We found that the steady-state rate of demethylation in cheD mutants was low; this may explain their overmethylated phenotype. In addition, all cheD mutants showed diminished responsiveness of methylesterase activity to attractant and repellent stimuli transduced by either the Tsr or Tar protein, and they did not adapt. These results suggest that the dominant nature of the cheD mutations is manifested as a general defect in the regulation of demethylation. Some of these altered properties of methylesterase activity in cheD mutants were exhibited in wild-type cells that were treated with saturating concentrations of serine. The mutant Tsr protein thus seems to be locked into a signaling mode that suppresses tumbling and inhibits methylesterase activity in a global fashion. We found that the Tar and mutant Tsr proteins synthesized in cheD strains were methylated and deamidated at the correct sites and that the mutations were not located in the methylated peptides. Thus, the signaling properties of the transducers may be controlled at sites distinct from the methyl-accepting sites.     

Repellent response functions of the Trg and Tap chemoreceptors of Escherichia coli.

The chemoreceptors responsible for the repellent response of Escherichia coli to phenol were investigated. In the absence of all four known methyl-accepting chemoreceptors (Tar, Tsr, Trg, and Tap), cells showed no response to phenol. However, when Trg, which mediates the attractant response to ribose and galactose, was introduced via a plasmid, the cells acquired a repellent response to phenol. About 1 mM phenol induced a clear repellent response; this response was suppressed by 1 mM ribose. Thus, Trg mediates the repellent response to phenol. Mutant Trg proteins with altered sensing for ribose and galactose showed a normal response to phenol, indicating that the interaction site for phenol differs from that for the ribose- and galactose-binding proteins. Tap, which mediates the attractant response to dipeptides, mediated a weaker repellent response to phenol. Tsr, which mediates the attractant response to serine, mediated an even weaker response to phenol. Trg and Tap were also found to function as intracellular pH sensors. Upon a pH decrease, Trg mediated an attractant response, whereas Tap mediated a repellent response. These results indicate that all the receptors in E. coli have dual functions, mediating both attractant and repellent responses.     

A gene coding for a periplasmic protein is located near the locus for termination of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli

Hybrid plasmids carrying trg, the genetic locus in closest proximity to terC, coded for several polypeptides in addition to the Trg protein. Polypeptides of 59,000 and 61,000 apparent molecular weight were the most prominent products synthesized in minicells containing the hybrid plasmids. Analysis of the effects of deletions generated by a restriction endonuclease identified a region of DNA immediately adjacent to trg as the putative gene coding for the two polypeptides. Studies with whole cells and minicells showed that the 59,000-dalton polypeptide is a periplasmic protein. Analysis by limited proteolysis indicated that the two polypeptides are related, and a number of observations support the notion that the 61,000-dalton protein is a precursor form of the 59,000-dalton mature exported protein. The identification and characterization of a protein, in addition to Trg, which is produced by a gene in close proximity to terC emphasizes the fact that the region does contain intact and active genes.     

Mutations specifically affecting ligand interaction of the Trg chemosensory transducer.

The Trg transducer mediates chemotactic response to galactose and ribose by interacting, respectively, with sugar-occupied galactose- and ribose-binding proteins. Adaptation is linked to methylation of specific glutamyl residues of the Trg protein. This study characterized two trg mutations that affect interaction with binding protein ligands but do not affect methylation or adaptation. The mutant phenotypes indicated that the steady-state activity of methyl-accepting sites is independent of ligand-binding activity. The mutation trg-8 changed arginine 85 to histidine, and trg-19 changed glycine 151 to aspartate. The locations of the mutational changes provided direct evidence for functioning of the amino-terminal domain of Trg in ligand recognition. Cross-inhibition of tactic sensitivity by the two Trg-linked attractants implies competition for a common site on Trg. However, the single amino acid substitution caused by trg-19 greatly reduced the response to galactose but left unperturbed the response to ribose. Thus Trg must recognize the two sugar-binding proteins at nonidentical sites, and the complementary sites on the respective binding proteins should differ. trg-8 mutants were substantially defective in the response to both galactose and ribose. An increase in cellular content of Trg-8 protein improved the response to galactose but not to ribose. It appears that Trg-8 protein is defective in the generation of the putative conformational change induced by ligand interaction. The asymmetry of the mutational defect implies that functional separation of interaction sites could persist beyond the initial stage of ligand binding.     

Conditional inversion of the thermoresponse in Escherichia coli.

Mutants in Escherichia coli having defects in one of the methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins, Tsr protein, which is the chemoreceptor and transducer for L-serine, showed a reduced but similar type of thermoresponse compared with wild-type strains; the cells showed smooth swimming upon temperature increase and tumbling upon temperature decrease. However, when the mutant cells were adapted to attractants such as L-aspartate and maltose, which are specific to another methyl-accepting chemotaxis protein, Tar protein, the direction of the thermoresponse was found to be inverted; a temperature increase induced tumbling and a temperature decrease induced smooth swimming. Consistent with this, the mutant cells showed inverted changes in the methylation level of Tar protein upon temperature changes. Wild-type strains but not Tar protein-deficient mutants exhibited the inverted thermoresponse when the cells were simultaneously adapted to L-aspartate and L-serine, indicating that Tar protein has a key role in the inversion of the thermoresponse. Thus, besides Tsr protein, Tar protein has a certain role in thermoreception. A simple model for thermoreception and inversion of the thermoresponse is also discussed.     

Chimeric Chemoreceptors in Escherichia coli: Signaling Properties of Tar-Tap and Tap-Tar Hybrids

The Tap (taxis toward peptides) receptor and the periplasmic dipeptide-binding protein (DBP) of Escherichia coli together mediate chemotactic responses to dipeptides. Tap is a low-abundance receptor. It is present in 5- to 10-fold-fewer copies than high-abundance receptors like Tar and Tsr. Cells expressing Tap as the sole receptor, even from a multicopy plasmid at 5- to 10-fold-overexpressed levels, do not generate sufficient clockwise (CW) signal to tumble and thus swim exclusively smoothly (run). To study the signaling properties of Tap in detail, we constructed reciprocal hybrids between Tap and Tar fused in the linker region between the periplasmic and cytoplasmic domains. The Tapr hybrid senses dipeptides and is a good CW-signal generator, whereas the Tarp hybrid senses aspartate but is a poor CW-signal generator. Thus, the poor CW signaling of Tap is a property of its cytoplasmic domain. Eighteen residues at the carboxyl terminus of high-abundance receptors, including the NWETF sequence that binds the CheR methylesterase, are missing in Tap. The Tart protein, created by removing these 18 residues from Tar, has diminished CW-signaling ability. The Tapl protein, made by adding the last 18 residues of Tar to the carboxyl terminus of Tap, also does not support CW flagellar rotation. However, Tart and Tapl cross-react well with antibody directed against the conserved cytoplasmic region of Tsr, whereas Tap does not cross-react with this antibody. Tap does cross-react, however, with antibody directed against the low-abundance chemoreceptor Trg. The hybrid, truncated, and extended receptors exhibit various levels of methylation. However, Tar and Tapl, which contain a consensus CheR-binding motif (NWETF) at their carboxyl termini, exhibit the highest basal levels of methylation, as expected. We conclude that no simple correlation exists between the abundance of a receptor, its methylation level, and its CW-signaling ability.