Computational mechanics of Nitinol stent grafts

A finite element analysis of tubular, diamond-shaped stent grafts under representative cyclic loading conditions for abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) repair is presented. Commercial software was employed to study the mechanical behavior and fatigue performance of different materials found in commercially available stent-graft systems. Specifically, the effects of crimping, deployment, and cyclic pressure loading on stent-graft fatigue life, radial force, and wall compliances were simulated and analyzed for two types of realistic but different Nitinol materials (NITI-1 and NITI-2) and grafts (expanded polytetrafluoroethylene-ePTFE and polyethylene therephthalate-PET). The results show that NITI-1 stent has a better crimping performance than NITI-2. Under representative cyclic pressure loading, both NITI-1 and NITI-2 sealing stents are located in the safe zone of the fatigue-life diagram; however, the fatigue resistance of an NITI-1 stent is better than that of an NITI-2 stent. It was found that the two types of sealing stents do not damage a healthy neck artery. In the aneurysm section, the NITI-1&ePTFE, NITI-1&PET, and NITI-2&PET combinations were free of fatigue fracture when subjected to conditions of radial stress between 50 and 150mmHg. In contrast, the safety factor for the NITI-2&ePFTE combination was only 0.67, which is not acceptable for proper AAA stent-graft design. In summary, a Nitinol stent with PET graft may greatly improve fatigue life, while its compliance is much lower than the NITI-ePTFE combination.     

Effects of stent design parameters on normal artery wall mechanics

A stent is a device designed to restore flow through constricted arteries. These tubular scaffold devices are delivered to the afflicted region and deployed using minimally invasive techniques. Stents must have sufficient radial strength to prop the diseased artery open. The presence of a stent can subject the artery to abnormally high stresses that can trigger adverse biologic responses culminating in restenosis. The primary aim of this investigation was to investigate the effects of varying stent "design parameters" on the stress field induced in the normal artery wall and the radial displacement achieved by the stent. The generic stent models were designed to represent a sample of the attributes incorporated in present commercially available stents. Each stent was deployed in a homogeneous, nonlinear hyperelastic artery model and evaluated using commercially available finite element analysis software. Of the designs investigated herein, those employing large axial strut spacing, blunted corners, and higher amplitudes in the ring segments induced high circumferential stresses over smaller areas of the artery's inner surface than all other configurations. Axial strut spacing was the dominant parameter in this study, i.e., all designs employing a small stent strut spacing induced higher stresses over larger areas than designs employing the large strut spacing. Increasing either radius of curvature or strut amplitude generally resulted in smaller areas exposed to high stresses. At larger strut spacing, sensitivity to radius of curvature was increased in comparison to the small strut spacing. With the larger strut spacing designs, the effects of varying amplitude could be offset by varying the radius of curvature and vice versa. The range of minimum radial displacements from the unstented diastolic radius observed among all designs was less than 90 microm. Evidence presented herein suggests that stent designs incorporating large axial strut spacing, blunted corners at bends, and higher amplitudes exposed smaller regions of the artery to high stresses, while maintaining a radial displacement that should be sufficient to restore adequate flow.     

Flow-tissue interaction with compliance mismatch in a model stented artery

The insertion of an endovascular prosthesis is known to have a thrombogenic effect that is also a consequence of the interaction between the flowing blood and the stented arterial segment; in fact the prosthesis induces a compliance mismatch and a possible small expansion along the vessel that eventually gives rise to an anomalous distribution of wall shear stresses. The fluid dynamics inside a rectilinear elastic vessel with compliance and section variation is studied here numerically. A recently introduced perturbative approach is employed to model the interaction between the fluid and the elastic tissue; this approximate technique is first validated by comparison with a complete solution within a simple one-dimensional model of the same system. Then it is applied to an axisymmetric model in order to evaluate the flow dynamics and the distribution of wall shear stress in the stented vessel. Compliance mismatch is shown to produce more intense negative wall shear stresses in the stented segment while rapid variations of wall shear stress are found at the stent ends. These effects are enhanced when the prosthesis is accompanied by a small increase of the vessel lumen.     

Design and evaluation of the crimping of a hooked self-expandable caval valve stent for the treatment of tricuspid regurgitation

To design a hooked self-expandable caval valve stent and determine the best crimping scenario for its percutaneous implantation in the Superior and Inferior Vena Cava (SVC & IVC) for the treatment of tricuspid regurgitation (TR). A hooked, Nitinol based stent design was modeled using SOLIDWORKS and finite element analysis (FEA) was carried out using ABAQUS. The Nitinol material used in this study was modeled in ABAQUS as superelastic-plastic. Two cases were simulated. In case A, the stent model was crimped to 18?F by compressing the stent main body and then: (i) bending both the proximal and distal hooks; (ii) straightening the proximal hooks and bending the distal hooks. In case B, the stent model was crimped to 18?F by: (i) bending the proximal and distal hooks and then compressing the stent main body; (ii) straightening the proximal hooks and bending the distal hooks and then compressing the stent main body. The maximum strain after crimping was used to evaluate the best crimping scenario. Hook straightening produced strains of 10.7% and 10.96% as opposed to 12.6% and 13.0% produced by hook bending. From comparison of results of both cases simulated, it was found that straightening the hooks gave lower strain and thus was the best crimping procedure. The analysis performed in this paper may help understand the critical issue of crimpability of the new stent design. The best crimping scenario can be found based on finite element modeling and simulation. Identifying the best crimping way will also help the design team to optimize the delivery system that will eventually be used to deploy this caval valve stent.     

Mechanical behaviour modelling of balloon-expandable stents

Endoprostheses are small struts placed by intravascular way to restore the vascular lumen and flow conditions. The purpose of this work is to provide models for evaluation and characterisation of some mechanical properties of a balloon-expandable stent by using the finite element method. Here we present the results for a metallic tubular peripheral prosthesis: the P308 Palmaz stent. We focus on the mechanisms linked to the structure expansion and its long-term behaviour. Several models are constructed in order to determine the stent shape after dilation and to assess the stress and strain fields in its wall due to this transformation. They inform us about the shortening percentage on expansion, degrees of radial and longitudinal recoil, and weaknesses of the structure. Various methods, differing in their levels of complexity, are then attempted to exhibit the predominant factors responsible for the crushing of a stent under external pressure. Moreover, the sensitivity of this critical pressure to geometric imperfections is studied. Lastly, since this kind of material is implanted for a lifetime, we test the stent with regard to fatigue life. Beyond safety considerations, this type of characterisation provides mechanical properties that are often difficult to obtain by experiments. If it was available for various stents, such information could be used to choose the appropriate prosthesis for specific applications. Moreover, confronted with observations from practitioners, they might lead to a better understanding of the failure or success of a particular design and to work on the product optimisation.     

Simulation of a balloon expandable stent in a realistic coronary artery—Determination of the optimum modelling strategy

Computational models of stent deployment in arteries have been widely used to shed light on various aspects of stent design and optimisation. In this context, modelling of balloon expandable stents has proved challenging due to the complex mechanics of balloon–stent interaction and the difficulties involved in creating folded balloon geometries. In this study, a method to create a folded balloon model is presented and utilised to numerically model the accurate deployment of a stent in a realistic geometry of an atherosclerotic human coronary artery. Stent deployment is, however, commonly modelled by applying an increasing pressure to the stent, thereby neglecting the balloon. This method is compared to the realistic balloon expansion simulation to fully elucidate the limitations of this procedure. The results illustrate that inclusion of a realistic balloon model is essential for accurate modelling of stent deformation and stent stresses. An alternative balloon simulation procedure is presented however, which overcomes many of the limitations of the applied pressure approach by using elements which restrain the stent as the desired diameter is achieved. This study shows that direct application of pressure to the stent inner surface may be used as an optimal modelling strategy to estimate the stresses in the vessel wall using these restraining elements and hence offer a very efficient alternative approach to numerically modelling stent deployment within complex arterial geometries. The method is limited however, in that it can only predict final stresses in the stented vessel and not those occurring during stent expansion, in which case the balloon expansion model is required.     

Effect of glenoid prosthesis design on glenoid bone remodeling: Adaptive finite element based simulation

Glenoid prosthesis loosening is the most common cause for revision total shoulder arthroplasty. Improved glenoid prosthesis design requires looking beyond initial post-implantation static stress analyses. Adaptive bone remodeling simulations based on Wolff’s law are needed for predicting long-term glenoid prosthesis results. This study demonstrates the capability of predicting glenoid bone remodeling produced by changing prosthesis design features. Twelve glenoid prostheses were designed to fit each of six donor human glenoids, using combinations of three peg types and four backing-peg material combinations (polyethylene and or metal). The twelve FE prosthesis models were individually combined, simulating surgical implantation, with the glenoid models. Remodeling simulations, using a validated adaptive bone remodeling simulation, commenced with homogeneous glenoid bone density. To produce bone remodeling, center, posterior-offset, and anterior-offset physiologic loads were consecutively applied to the bone–prosthesis FE models for 300 iterations. Upon completion, region-specific mean predicted bone apparent densities were compared between bone–prosthesis and intact glenoid FE models. Metal fixations significantly increased proximal-center bone density. Polyethylene fixations resulted in bone density approximately equal to intact. Two angled polyethylene peg designs with longer-anterior and shorter-posterior pegs, reflecting natural glenoid shape, best maintained mid and distal glenoid bone density. While these initial results were not validated, they demonstrate the capability and potential of adaptive glenoid bone remodeling simulation. We expect FE glenoid bone remodeling simulations to become powerful and robust tools in the design and evaluation of glenoid prostheses.     

Experimental study of laminar blood flow through an artery treated by a stent implantation: characterisation of intra-stent wall shear stress

The stimulation of endothelial cells by arterial wall shear stress (WSS) plays a central role in restenosis. The fluid-structure interaction between stent wire and blood flow alters the WSS, particularly between stent struts. We have designed an in vitro model of struts of an intra-vascular prosthesis to study blood flow through a 'stented' section. The experimental artery consisted of a transparent square section test vein, which reproduced the strut design (100x magnifying power). A programmable pump was used to maintain a steady blood flow. Particle image velocimetry method was used to measure the flow between and over the stent branches, and to quantify WSS. Several prosthesis patterns that were representative of the total stent strut geometry were studied in a greater detail. We obtained WSS values of between -1.5 and 1.5Pa in a weak SS area which provided a source of endothelial stimulation propitious to restenosis. We also compared two similar patterns located in two different flow areas (one at the entry of the stent and one further downstream). We only detected a slight difference between the weakest SS levels at these two sites. As the endothelial proliferation is greatly influenced by the SS, knowledge of the SS modification induced by the stent implantation could be of importance for intra-vascular prostheses design optimisation and thus can help to reduce the restenosis incidence rate.     

Fabrication and in vitro deployment of a laser-activated shape memory polymer vascular stent

Background

Vascular stents are small tubular scaffolds used in the treatment of arterial stenosis (narrowing of the vessel). Most vascular stents are metallic and are deployed either by balloon expansion or by self-expansion. A shape memory polymer (SMP) stent may enhance flexibility, compliance, and drug elution compared to its current metallic counterparts. The purpose of this study was to describe the fabrication of a laser-activated SMP stent and demonstrate photothermal expansion of the stent in an in vitro artery model.

Methods

A novel SMP stent was fabricated from thermoplastic polyurethane. A solid SMP tube formed by dip coating a stainless steel pin was laser-etched to create the mesh pattern of the finished stent. The stent was crimped over a fiber-optic cylindrical light diffuser coupled to an infrared diode laser. Photothermal actuation of the stent was performed in a water-filled mock artery.

Results

At a physiological flow rate, the stent did not fully expand at the maximum laser power (8.6 W) due to convective cooling. However, under zero flow, simulating the technique of endovascular flow occlusion, complete laser actuation was achieved in the mock artery at a laser power of ~8 W.

Conclusion

We have shown the design and fabrication of an SMP stent and a means of light delivery for photothermal actuation. Though further studies are required to optimize the device and assess thermal tissue damage, photothermal actuation of the SMP stent was demonstrated.     

Mechanical behavior of coronary stents investigated through the finite element method

Intravascular stents are small tube-like structures expanded into stenotic arteries to restore blood flow perfusion to the downstream tissues. The stent is mounted on a balloon catheter and delivered to the site of blockage. When the balloon is inflated, the stent expands and is pressed against the inner wall of the coronary artery. After the balloon is deflated and removed, the stent remains in place, keeping the artery open. Hence, the stent expansion defines the effectiveness of the surgical procedure: it depends on the stent geometry, it includes large displacements and deformations and material non-linearity.In this paper, the finite element method is applied (i) to understand the effects of different geometrical parameters (thickness, metal-to-artery surface ratio, longitudinal and radial cut lengths) of a typical diamond-shaped coronary stent on the device mechanical performance, (ii) to compare the response of different actual stent models when loaded by internal pressure and (iii) to collect suggestions for optimizing the device shape and performance.The stent expansion and partial recoil under balloon inflation and deflation were simulated. Results showed the influence of the geometry on the stent behavior: a stent with a low metal-to-artery surface ratio has a higher radial and longitudinal recoil, but a lower dogboning. The thickness influences the stent performance in terms of foreshortening, longitudinal recoil and dogboning.In conclusion, a finite element analysis similar to the one herewith proposed could help in designing new stents or analyzing actual stents to ensure ideal expansion and structural integrity, substituting in vitro experiments often difficult and unpractical.     

Shape optimization of stress concentration-free lattice for self-expandable Nitinol stent-grafts

In a mechanical component, stress-concentration is one of the factors contributing to reduce fatigue life. This paper presents a design methodology based on shape optimization to improve the fatigue safety factor and increase the radial stiffness of Nitinol self-expandable stent-grafts. A planar lattice free of stress concentrators is proposed for the synthesis of a stent with smooth cell shapes. Design optimization is systematically applied to minimize the curvature and reduce the bending strain of the elements defining the lattice cells. A novel cell geometry with improved fatigue life and radial supportive force is introduced for Nitinol self-expandable stent-grafts used for treating abdominal aortic aneurism. A parametric study comparing the optimized stent-graft to recent stent designs demonstrates that the former exhibits a superior anchoring performance and a reduction of the risk of fatigue failure.     

Mechanical and hydrodynamic effects of stent expansion in tapered coronary vessels

Percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) has become the primary treatment for patients with coronary heart disease because of its minimally invasive nature and high efficiency. Anatomical studies have shown that most coronary vessels gradually shrink, and the vessels gradually become thinner from the proximal to the distal end. In this paper, the effects of different stent expansion methods on the mechanical and hemodynamic behaviors of coronary vessels and stents were studied. To perform a structural-mechanical analysis of stent implantation, the coronary vessels with branching vessels and the coronary vessels with large bending curvature are selected. The two characteristic structures are implanted in equal diameter expansion mode and conical expansion mode, and the stress and mechanical behaviors of the coronary vessels and stents are analyzed. The results of the structural-mechanical analysis showed that the mechanical behaviors and fatigue performance of the cobalt-chromium alloy stent were good, and the different expansion modes of the stent had little effect on the fatigue performance of the stent. However, the equal diameter expansion mode increased distal coronary artery stress and the risk of vascular injury. The computational fluid dynamics analysis results showed that different stent expansion methods had varied effects on coronary vessel hemodynamics and that the wall shear stress distribution of conical stent expansion is more uniform compared with equal diameter expansion. Additionally, the vortex phenomenon is not apparent, the blood flow velocity is slightly increased, the hydrodynamic environment is more reasonable, and the risk of coronary artery injury is reduced.

     

Mechanistic evaluation of long-term in-stent restenosis based on models of tissue damage and growth

Development and application of advanced mechanical models of soft tissues and their growth represent one of the main directions in modern mechanics of solids. Such models are increasingly used to deal with complex biomedical problems. Prediction of in-stent restenosis for patients treated with coronary stents remains a highly challenging task. Using a finite element method, this paper presents a mechanistic approach to evaluate the development of in-stent restenosis in an artery following stent implantation. Hyperelastic models with damage, verified with experimental results, are used to describe the level of tissue damage in arterial layers and plaque caused by such intervention. A tissue-growth model, associated with vessel damage, is adopted to describe the growth behaviour of a media layer after stent implantation. Narrowing of lumen diameter with time is used to quantify the development of in-stent restenosis in the vessel after stenting. It is demonstrated that stent designs and materials strongly affect the stenting-induced damage in the media layer and the subsequent development of in-stent restenosis. The larger the artery expansion achieved during balloon inflation, the higher the damage introduced to the media layer, leading to an increased level of in-stent restenosis. In addition, the development of in-stent restenosis is directly correlated with the artery expansion during the stent deployment. The correlation is further used to predict the effect of a complex clinical procedure, such as stent overlapping, on the level of in-stent restenosis developed after percutaneous coronary intervention.

     

Influence of shape-memory stent grafts on local aortic compliance

The effect of repair techniques on the biomechanics of the aorta is poorly understood, resulting in significant levels of postoperative complications for patients worldwide. This study presents a computational analysis of the influence of Nitinol-based devices on the biomechanical performance of a healthy patient-specific human aorta. Simulations reveal that Nitinol stent-grafts stretch the artery wall so that collagen is stretched to a straightened high-stiffness configuration. The high-compliance regime (HCR) associated with low diastolic lumen pressure is eliminated, and the artery operates in a low-compliance regime (LCR) throughout the entire cardiac cycle. The slope of the lumen pressure–area curve for the LCR post-implantation is almost identical to that of the native vessel during systole. This negligible change from the native LCR slope occurs because the stent-graft increases its diameter from the crimped configuration during deployment so that it reaches a low-stiffness unloading plateau. The effective radial stiffness of the implant along this unloading plateau is negligible compared to the stiffness of the artery wall. Provided the Nitinol device unloads sufficiently during deployment to the unloading plateau, the degree of oversizing has a negligible effect on the pressure–area response of the vessel, as each device exerts approximately the same radial force, the slope of which is negligible compared to the LCR slope of the native artery. We show that 10% oversizing based on the observed diastolic diameter in the mid descending thoracic aorta results in a complete loss of contact between the device and the wall during systole, which could lead to an endoleak and stent migration. 20% oversizing reaches the Dacron enforced area limit (DEAL) during the pulse pressure and results in an effective zero-compliance in the later portion of systole.

     

Finite-element Analysis of a Stenotic Artery Revascularization Through a Stent Insertion

Short-term and long-term clinical follow-up data clearly indicate the superiority of stenting techniques within the family of mechanical treatments for percutaneous coronary revascularizations. However, restenosis phenomena are in general still present, representing the major drawback for this innovative non-invasive approach.

Experimental evidence indicates the mechanical interaction between the stent and the artery as a significant cause for the activation of stent-related restenosis. At the same time, the literature shows a significant lack of computational investigations within this field, possibly as consequence of the complexity of the problem.

According to these considerations, the aim of the present work is to study the bio-mechanical interaction between a balloon-expandable stent and a stenotic artery, highlighting considerations able to improve the general understanding of the problem.

In particular, given an initial stent design (J&J Palmaz-Schatz like), we show the presence of possible areas of artery injury during the stent deployment and areas of non-uniform contact pressure after the stent apposition, due to a non-uniform stent expansion. Since these concentrated mechanical actions can play an important role in the activation of restenosis mechanisms, we propose a modified stent design, which shows a more uniform expansion and for which typical stenting parameters (i.e., residual stenosis, elastic recoil, foreshortening) are computed and presented.     

Endovascular Repair of Arterial Iliac Vessel Wall Lesions with a Self-Expandable Nitinol Stent Graft System

Objective

To assess the therapeutic outcome after endovascular repair of iliac arterial lesions (IALs) using a self-expandable Nitinol stent graft system.

Methods

Between July 2006 and March 2013, 16 patients (13 males, mean age: 68 years) with a self-expandable Nitinol stent graft. A total of 19 lesions were treated: nine true aneurysms, two anastomotic aneurysms, two dissections, one arteriovenous fistula, two type 1B endoleaks after endovascular aneurysm repair, one pseudoaneurysm, and two perforations after angioplasty. Pre-, intra-, and postinterventional imaging studies and the medical records were analyzed for technical and clinical success and postinterventional complications.

Results

The primary technical and clinical success rate was 81.3% (13/16 patients) and 75.0% (12/16), respectively. Two patients had technical failure due to persistent type 1A endoleak and another patient due to acute stent graft thrombosis. One patient showed severe stent graft kinking on the first postinterventional day. In two patients, a second intervention was performed. The secondary technical and clinical success rate was 87.5% (14/16) and 93.8% (15/16). The minor complication rate was 6.3% (patient with painful hematoma at the access site). The major complication rate was 6.3% (patient with ipsilateral deep vein thrombosis). During median follow-up of 22.4 months, an infection of the aneurysm sac in one patient and a stent graft thrombosis in another patient were observed.

Conclusion

Endovascular repair of various IALs with a self-expandable Nitinol stent graft is safe and effective.     

On the effects of different strategies in modelling balloon-expandable stenting by means of finite element method

In recent years, computational structural analyses have emerged as important tools to investigate the mechanical response of stent placement into arterial walls. Although most coronary stents are expanded by inflating a polymeric balloon, realistic computational balloon models have been introduced only recently. In the present study, the finite element method is applied to simulate three different approaches to evaluate stent-free expansion and stent expansion inside an artery. Three different stent expansion modelling techniques were analysed by: (i) imposing a uniform pressure on the stent internal surface, (ii) a rigid cylindrical surface expanded with displacement control and (iii) modelling a polymeric deformable balloon. The computational results showed differences in the free and confined-stent expansions due to different expansion techniques. The modelling technique of the balloon seems essential to estimate the level of injury caused on arterial walls during stent expansion.     

Finite element analysis of the biomechanical interaction between coronary sinus and proximal anchoring stent in coronary sinus annuloplasty

Recent clinical studies of the percutaneous transvenous mitral annuloplasty (PTMA) devices have shown a short-term reduction of mitral regurgitation after implantation. However, adverse events associated with the devices such as compression and perforation of vessel branches, device migration and fracture were reported. In this study, a finite element analysis was carried out to investigate the biomechanical interaction between the proximal anchor stent of a PTMA device and the coronary sinus (CS) vessel in three steps including: (i) the stent release and contact with the CS wall, (ii) the axial pull t the stent connector and (iii) the pressure inflation of the vessel wall. To investigate the impact of the material properties of tissues and stents on the interactive responses, the CS vessel was modelled with human and porcine material properties, and the proximal stent was modelled with two different Nitinol materials with one being stiffer than the other. The results indicated that the vessel wall stresses and contact forces imposed by the stents were much higher in the human model than the porcine model. However, the mechanical differences induced by the two stent types were relatively small. The softer stent exhibited a better fatigue safety factor when deployed in the human model than in the porcine model. These results underscored the importance of the CS tissue mechanical properties. Vessel wall stress and stent radial force obtained in the human model were higher than those obtained in the porcine model, which also brought up questions as to the validity of using the porcine model to assess device mechanical function. The quantification of these biomechanical interactions can offer scientific insight into the development and optimisation of the PTMA device design.     

Factors that affect mass transport from drug eluting stents into the artery wall

Coronary artery disease can be treated by implanting a stent into the blocked region of an artery, thus enabling blood perfusion to distal vessels. Minimally invasive procedures of this nature often result in damage to the arterial tissue culminating in the re-blocking of the vessel. In an effort to alleviate this phenomenon, known as restenosis, drug eluting stents were developed. They are similar in composition to a bare metal stent but encompass a coating with therapeutic agents designed to reduce the overly aggressive healing response that contributes to restenosis. There are many variables that can influence the effectiveness of these therapeutic drugs being transported from the stent coating to and within the artery wall, many of which have been analysed and documented by researchers. However, the physical deformation of the artery substructure due to stent expansion, and its influence on a drugs ability to diffuse evenly within the artery wall have been lacking in published work to date. The paper highlights previous approaches adopted by researchers and proposes the addition of porous artery wall deformation to increase model accuracy.     

Finite element simulation of early creep and wear in total hip arthroplasty

Polyethylene wear particulate has been implicated in osteolytic lesion development and may lead to implant loosening and revision surgery. Wear in total hip arthroplasty is frequently estimated from patient radiographs by measurement of penetration of the femoral head into the polyethylene liner. Penetration, however, is multi-factorial, and includes components of wear and deformation due to creep. From a clinical perspective, it is of great interest to separate these elements to better evaluate true wear rates in vivo. Thus, the aim of this study was to determine polyethylene creep and wear penetration and volumetric wear during simulated gait loading conditions for variables of head size, liner thickness, and head–liner clearance. A finite element model of hip replacement articulation was developed, and creep and wear simulation was performed to 1 million gait cycles. Creep of the liner occurred quickly and increased the predicted contact areas by up to 56%, subsequently reducing contact pressures by up to 41%. Greater creep penetration was found with smaller heads, thicker liners, and larger clearance. The least volumetric wear but the most linear penetration was found with the smallest head size. Although polyethylene thickness increases from 4 to 16 mm produced only slight increases in volumetric wear and modest effects on total penetration, the fraction of creep in total penetration varied with thickness from 10% to over 50%. With thicker liners and smaller heads, creep will comprise a significant fraction of early penetration. These results will aid an understanding of the complex interaction of creep and wear.