Genetic analysis of mutagenesis in aging Escherichia coli colonies

Bacteria live in unstructured and structured environments, experiencing feast and famine lifestyles. Bacterial colonies can be viewed as model structured environments. SOS induction and mutagenesis have been observed in aging Escherichia coli colonies, in the absence of exogenous sources of DNA damage. This cAMP-dependent mutagenesis occurring in Resting Organisms in a Structured Environment (ROSE) is unaffected by a umuC mutation and therefore differs from both targeted UV mutagenesis and recA730 (SOS constitutive) untargeted mutagenesis. As a recB mutation has only a minor effect on ROSE mutagenesis it also differs from both adaptive reversion of the lacI33 allele and from iSDR (inducible Stable DNA Replication) mutagenesis. Besides its recA and lexA dependence, ROSE mutagenesis is also uvrB and polA dependent. These genetic requirements are reminiscent of the untargeted mutagenesis in λ phage observed when unirradiated λ infects UV-irradiated E. coli. These mutations, which are not observed in aging liquid cultures, accumulate linearly with the age of the colonies. ROSE mutagenesis might offer a good model for bacterial mutagenesis in structured environments such as biofilms and for mutagenesis of quiescent eukaryotic cells. Received: 30 April 1997 / Accepted: 1 July 1997     

Involvement of DNA polymerase III in UV-induced mutagenesis of bacteriophage lambda

Summary It has been proposed that the mutation fixation processes stimulated by SOS induction result from an induced infidelity of DNA replication (Radman 1974). The aim of this study was to determine if mutator mutations in the E. coli DNA polymerase III might affect UV-induced mutagenesis.Using a phage mutation assay which can discriminate between targeted and untargeted mutations, we show that the polC74 mutator mutation (Sevastopoulos and Glaser 1977) primarily affects untargeted mutagenesis, which occurs in a recA1 genetic background and is amplified in the recA ⁺ genetic background. The polC74 mutation also increases the UV-induced mutagenesis of the bacterial chromosome. These results suggest that DNA polymerase III is involved in the process of UV-induced mutagenesis in E. coli.     

Nature of the SOS mutator activity: genetic characterization of untargeted mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Summary In Escherichia coli, induction of the SOS functions by UV irradiation or by mutation in the recA gene promotes an SOS mutator activity which generates mutations in undamaged DNA. Activation of RecA protein by the recA730 mutation increases the level of spontaneous mutation in the bacterial DNA. The number of recA730-induced mutations is greatly increased in mismatch repair deficient strains in which replication errors are not corrected. This suggests that the majority of recA730-induced mutations (90%) arise through correctable, i.e. non-targeted, replication errors. This recA730 mutator effect is suppressed by a mutation in the umuC gene. We also found that dam recA730 double mutants are unstable, segregating clones that have lost the dam or the recA mutations or that have acquired a new mutation, probably in one of the genes involved in mismatch repair. We suggest that the genetic instability of the dam recA730 mutants is provoked by the high level of replication errors induced by the recA730 mutation, generating killing by coincident mismatch repair on the two unmethylated DNA strands. The recA730 mutation increases spontaneous mutagenesis of phage poorly. UV irradiation of recA730 host bacteria increases phage untargeted mutagenesis to the level observed in UV-irradiated recA ⁺ strains. This UV-induced mutator effect in recA730 mutants is not suppressed by a umuC mutation. Therefore UV and the recA730 mutation seem to induce different SOS mutator activities, both generating untargeted mutations.     

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA,which is responsible for inhibition of SOS functions

A new mutation inEscherichia coli K12,isfA, is described, which causes inhibition of SOS functions. The mutation, discovered in a ΔpolA ⁺ mutant, is responsible for inhibition of several phenomena related to the SOS response inpolA ⁺ strains: UV- and methyl methanesulfonate-induced mutagenesis, resumption of DNA replication in UV-irradiated cells, cell filamentation, prophage induction and increase in UV sensitivity. TheisfA mutation also significantly reduces UV-induced expression of β-galactosidase fromrecA::lacZ andumuC′::lacZ fusions. The results suggest that theisfA gene product may affect RecA^* coprotease activity and may be involved in the regulation of the termination of the SOS response after completion of DNA repair. TheisfA mutation was localized at 85 min on theE. coli chromosome, and preliminary experiments suggest that it may be dominant to the wild-type allele.     

DinB Upregulation Is the Sole Role of the SOS Response in Stress-Induced Mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Stress-induced mutagenesis is a collection of mechanisms observed in bacterial, yeast, and human cells in which adverse conditions provoke mutagenesis, often under the control of stress responses. Control of mutagenesis by stress responses may accelerate evolution specifically when cells are maladapted to their environments, i.e., are stressed. It is therefore important to understand how stress responses increase mutagenesis. In the Escherichia coli Lac assay, stress-induced point mutagenesis requires induction of at least two stress responses: the RpoS-controlled general/starvation stress response and the SOS DNA-damage response, both of which upregulate DinB error-prone DNA polymerase, among other genes required for Lac mutagenesis. We show that upregulation of DinB is the only aspect of the SOS response needed for stress-induced mutagenesis. We constructed two dinB(o^c) (operator-constitutive) mutants. Both produce SOS-induced levels of DinB constitutively. We find that both dinB(o^c) alleles fully suppress the phenotype of constitutively SOS-“off” lexA(Ind⁻) mutant cells, restoring normal levels of stress-induced mutagenesis. Thus, dinB is the only SOS gene required at induced levels for stress-induced point mutagenesis. Furthermore, although spontaneous SOS induction has been observed to occur in only a small fraction of cells, upregulation of dinB by the dinB(o^c) alleles in all cells does not promote a further increase in mutagenesis, implying that SOS induction of DinB, although necessary, is insufficient to differentiate cells into a hypermutable condition.     

SOS repair of 8-methoxypsoralene monoadducts in DNA of lambda bacteriophage and plasmids is mediated by MucA 2 ′ B, but not UmuD 2 ′ C (PolV) polymerase

The light-induced action of 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) on λ phage and plasmids yields monoadducts and interstrand crosslinks. The survival and clear plaque mutation frequency in the phage photosensitized with 8-MOP and irradiated with UV at wavelength >320 nm are increased when the wild-type host (Escherichia coli uvr ⁺) is subjected to UV irradiation (wavelength = 254 nm) prior to phage inoculation. These phenomena are known as “W reactivation” and “W mutagenesis.” It is shown that 8-MOP monoadducts in λ DNA induce clear mutations in the phage inoculated to UV-irradiated excision repair mutants of E. coli only when the error-prone repair is performed by MucA ₂ ^′ B, but not PolV (UmuD ₂ ^′ C) polymerase. The efficiency of the SOS repair (W reactivation) of 8-MOP monoadducts in plasmid and λ phage DNA also only increases with the presence of pKM101 plasmid muc ⁺ in E. coli uvr ^?.     

60 years of SOS repair

This review integrates 60 years of research on SOS repair and SOS mutagenesis in prokaryotes and eukaryotes, from Jean Weigle’s experiment in 1953 (mutagenesis of lambda bacteriophage in UV-irradiated bacteria) to the latest achievements in studying SOS mutagenesis on all living organisms, i.e., Eukarya, Archaea and Bacteria. A key role in establishing of a biochemical basis for SOS mutagenesis belongs to the finding in 1998–1999 that specific error-prone DNA polymerases (PolV and others) catalyzed translesion synthesis on damaged DNA. This review focuses on recent studies that address new models for SOS-induced mutagenesis in Escherichia coli and Homo sapiens cells.     

Induction of only one SOS operon,umuDC, is required for SOS mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

The actions of UmuDC and RecA proteins, respectively in SOS mutagenesis are studied here with the following experimental strategy. We used lexAl (Ind^?) bacteria to maintain all SOS proteins at their basal concentrations and then selectively increased the concentration of either UmuDC or RecA protein. For this purpose, we isolated operator-constitutive mutations o ^c in the umuDC and umuD'C operons and also used the o ₉₈ ^c -recA mutation. The o ₁ ^c -umuDC mutation prevents LexA repressor from binding to the operator and improves the Pribnow box consensus sequence. As a result, 5000 UmuD and 500 UmuC molecules per cell were produced in lexAl bacteria. This concentration is sufficient to restore SOS mutagenesis. The level of RecA protein present in the repressed state promoted full UmuD cleavage. Overproduction of RecA alone did not promote SOS mutagenesis. Increasing the level of RecA in the presence of high concentrations of UmuDC proteins has no further effect on SOS mutgenesis. We conclude that, after DNA damage, umuDC is the only SOS operon that must be induced in Escherichia coli to promote SOS mutagenesis.     

Human DNA polymerase kappa synthesizes DNA with extraordinarily low fidelity

Escherichia coli DNA polymerase IV encoded by the dinB gene is involved in untargeted mutagenesis. Its human homologue is DNA polymerase κ (Polκ) encoded by the DINB1 gene. Our recent studies have indicated that human Polκ is capable of both error-free and error-prone translesion DNA synthesis in vitro. However, it is not known whether human Polκ also plays a role in untargeted mutagenesis. To examine this possibility, we have measured the fidelity of human Polκ during DNA synthesis from undamaged templates. Using kinetic measurements of nucleotide incorporations and a fidelity assay with gapped M13mp2 DNA, we show that human Polκ synthesizes DNA with extraordinarily low fidelity. At the lacZα target gene, human Polκ made on average one error for every 200 nucleotides synthesized, with a predominant T→G transversion mutation at a rate of 1/147. The overall error rate of human Polκ is 1.7-fold lower than human Polη, but 33-fold higher than human Polβ, a DNA polymerase with very low fidelity. Thus, human Polκ is one of the most inaccurate DNA polymerases known. These results support a role for human Polκ in untargeted mutagenesis surrounding a DNA lesion and in DNA regions without damage.     

Expression of ultraviolet-induced restriction alleviation in Escherichia coli K-12. Detection of a λ phage fraction with a retarded mode of DNA injection

Ultraviolet-induced restriction alleviation is an SOS function which partially relieves the K-12-specific DNA restriction in Escherichia coli. Restriction alleviation is determined by observing elevated survival of unmodified phage λ in cells irradiated with ultraviolet prior to infection. We demonstrate that restriction of λ is also relieved when log-phase cells are irradiated as late as 50 min after adsorption of λ. At this time more than 60% of the λ DNA is already released as acid-soluble material from the cells. Experiments involving reextraction of λ DNA from infected cells and a mild detergent treatment removing adsorbed phages from the cellular surface showed that only a small specific fraction of all λ infections is destined to escape restriction due to restriction alleviation. This fraction (10–20%) has a retarded mode of DNA injection (60 min or longer) after adsorption which allows the expression of the restriction alleviation function before the phage DNA is exposed to restriction endonucleases. This behaviour of a fraction of λ phages explains why the SOS function restriction alleviation could initially be discovered. We show that the retarded mode of DNA injection is not required for another SOS function acting on λ DNA, the increased repair of ultraviolet-irradiated DNA (Weigle reactivation).     

Elevated Mutagenesis Does Not Explain the Increased Frequency of Antibiotic Resistant Mutants in Starved Aging Colonies

The frequency of mutants resistant to the antibiotic rifampicin has been shown to increase in aging (starved), compared to young colonies of Eschierchia coli. These increases in resistance frequency occur in the absence of any antibiotic exposure, and similar increases have also been observed in response to additional growth limiting conditions. Understanding the causes of such increases in the frequency of resistance is important for understanding the dynamics of antibiotic resistance emergence and spread. Increased frequency of rifampicin resistant mutants in aging colonies is cited widely as evidence of stress-induced mutagenesis (SIM), a mechanism thought to allow bacteria to increase mutation rates upon exposure to growth-limiting stresses. At the same time it has been demonstrated that some rifampicin resistant mutants are relatively fitter in aging compared to young colonies, indicating that natural selection may also contribute to increased frequency of rifampicin resistance in aging colonies. Here, we demonstrate that the frequency of mutants resistant to both rifampicin and an additional antibiotic (nalidixic-acid) significantly increases in aging compared to young colonies of a lab strain of Escherichia coli. We then use whole genome sequencing to demonstrate conclusively that SIM cannot explain the observed magnitude of increased frequency of resistance to these two antibiotics. We further demonstrate that, as was previously shown for rifampicin resistance mutations, mutations conferring nalidixic acid resistance can also increase fitness in aging compared to young colonies. Our results show that increases in the frequency of antibiotic resistant mutants in aging colonies cannot be seen as evidence of SIM. Furthermore, they demonstrate that natural selection likely contributes to increases in the frequency of certain antibiotic resistance mutations, even when no selection is exerted due to the presence of antibiotics.     

RpoS Plays a Central Role in the SOS Induction by Sub-Lethal Aminoglycoside Concentrations in Vibrio cholerae

Bacteria encounter sub-inhibitory concentrations of antibiotics in various niches, where these low doses play a key role for antibiotic resistance selection. However, the physiological effects of these sub-lethal concentrations and their observed connection to the cellular mechanisms generating genetic diversification are still poorly understood. It is known that, unlike for the model bacterium Escherichia coli, sub-minimal inhibitory concentrations (sub-MIC) of aminoglycosides (AGs) induce the SOS response in Vibrio cholerae. SOS is induced upon DNA damage, and since AGs do not directly target DNA, we addressed two issues in this study: how sub-MIC AGs induce SOS in V. cholerae and why they do not do so in E. coli. We found that when bacteria are grown with tobramycin at a concentration 100-fold below the MIC, intracellular reactive oxygen species strongly increase in V. cholerae but not in E. coli. Using flow cytometry and gfp fusions with the SOS regulated promoter of intIA, we followed AG-dependent SOS induction. Testing the different mutation repair pathways, we found that over-expression of the base excision repair (BER) pathway protein MutY relieved this SOS induction in V. cholerae, suggesting a role for oxidized guanine in AG-mediated indirect DNA damage. As a corollary, we established that a BER pathway deficient E. coli strain induces SOS in response to sub-MIC AGs. We finally demonstrate that the RpoS general stress regulator prevents oxidative stress-mediated DNA damage formation in E. coli. We further show that AG-mediated SOS induction is conserved among the distantly related Gram negative pathogens Klebsiella pneumoniae and Photorhabdus luminescens, suggesting that E. coli is more of an exception than a paradigm for the physiological response to antibiotics sub-MIC.     

Growth‐dependent heterogeneity in the DNA damage response in Escherichia coli

In natural environments, bacteria are frequently exposed to sub‐lethal levels of DNA damage, which leads to the induction of a stress response (the SOS response in Escherichia coli). Natural environments also vary in nutrient availability, resulting in distinct physiological changes in bacteria, which may have direct implications on their capacity to repair their chromosomes. Here, we evaluated the impact of varying the nutrient availability on the expression of the SOS response induced by chronic sub‐lethal DNA damage in E. coli. We found heterogeneous expression of the SOS regulon at the single‐cell level in all growth conditions. Surprisingly, we observed a larger fraction of high SOS‐induced cells in slow growth as compared with fast growth, despite a higher rate of SOS induction in fast growth. The result can be explained by the dynamic balance between the rate of SOS induction and the division rates of cells exposed to DNA damage. Taken together, our data illustrate how cell division and physiology come together to produce growth‐dependent heterogeneity in the DNA damage response.     

Adducts formed by the food mutagen 2-amino-3-methylimidazo(4, 5-f ) quinoline induce frameshift mutations at hot spots through an SOS-independent pathway

The potency of 2-amino-3-methylimidazo(4, 5-f)quinoline (IQ) adducts to induce ?2, ?1 and +1 frameshift mutations has been determined on specific target DNA sequences, namely short runs of alternating GpC sequences and short runs of guanines. The genetic control of the mutational processes has been analyzed using different Escherichia coli mutants, affected either in the control or in the mutagenesis pathway of the SOS system. We have shown that IQ adducts induce very efficiently both ?1 and ?2 frameshift mutations in E. coli. Both types of deletion mutations are induced in bacteria without the need of SOS induction, indicating that no LexA-controlled functions, in particular the UmuDC proteins, are required for mutation fixation. We have also shown that the frequency of IQ-induced ?2 frameshift mutations in alternating GC sequences increases with the length of the repetition. The efficiency of IQ adducts to induce ?1 and ?2 frameshift mutations is similar to that of N‐2-acetylaminofluorene (AAF) adducts. Both chemicals are potent carcinogens which form covalent adducts at the C8 position of guanines. We suggest that in both cases the adduct-induced DNA structure allows the replication complex to perform a mutagenic bypass of the lesion by a slippage mechanism. However, in contrast to AAF-induced frameshift mutagenesis, IQ-induced frameshift mutagenesis is SOS-independent.     

The σE stress response is required for stress‐induced mutation and amplification in Escherichia coli

Pathways of mutagenesis are induced in microbes under adverse conditions controlled by stress responses. Control of mutagenesis by stress responses may accelerate evolution specifically when cells are maladapted to their environments, i.e. are stressed. Stress‐induced mutagenesis in the Escherichia coli Lac assay occurs either by ‘point’ mutation or gene amplification. Point mutagenesis is associated with DNA double‐strand‐break (DSB) repair and requires DinB error‐prone DNA polymerase and the SOS DNA‐damage‐ and RpoS general‐stress responses. We report that the RpoE envelope‐protein‐stress response is also required. In a screen for mutagenesis‐defective mutants, we isolated a transposon insertion in the rpoE P2 promoter. The insertion prevents rpoE induction during stress, but leaves constitutive expression intact, and allows cell viability. rpoE insertion and suppressed null mutants display reduced point mutagenesis and maintenance of amplified DNA. Furthermore, σ^E acts independently of stress responses previously implicated: SOS/DinB and RpoS, and of σ³², which was postulated to affect mutagenesis. I‐SceI‐induced DSBs alleviated much of the rpoE phenotype, implying that σ^E promoted DSB formation. Thus, a third stress response and stress input regulate DSB‐repair‐associated stress‐induced mutagenesis. This provides the first report of mutagenesis promoted by σ^E, and implies that extracytoplasmic stressors may affect genome integrity and, potentially, the ability to evolve.     

SOS-inducible DNA polymerases and adaptive mutagenesis

Stability of genomes of living organisms is maintained by various mechanisms that ensure high fidelity of DNA replication. However, cells can reversibly enhance the level of replication errors in response to external factors. As mutable states are potentially involved in carcinogenesis, aging, and resistance for pathogenic agents, the existence of these states is of great importance for human health. A well-known system of inducible mutation is SOS response, whose key component is replication of damaged DNA regions. Inducible mutation implies a contribution of SOS response to the adaptation of a bacterial population to adverse environments. There is ample evidence indicating the primary role of SOS response genes in the phenomenon of adaptive mutation. The involvement of the SOS system in adaptive mutagenesis is discussed.     

Comparison of Responses to Double-Strand Breaks between Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis Reveals Different Requirements for SOS Induction

DNA double-strand breaks are particularly deleterious lesions that can lead to genomic instability and cell death. We investigated the SOS response to double-strand breaks in both Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. In E. coli, double-strand breaks induced by ionizing radiation resulted in SOS induction in virtually every cell. E. coli strains incapable of SOS induction were sensitive to ionizing radiation. In striking contrast, we found that in B. subtilis both ionizing radiation and a site-specific double-strand break causes induction of prophage PBSX and SOS gene expression in only a small subpopulation of cells. These results show that double-strand breaks provoke global SOS induction in E. coli but not in B. subtilis. Remarkably, RecA-GFP focus formation was nearly identical following ionizing radiation challenge in both E. coli and B. subtilis, demonstrating that formation of RecA-GFP foci occurs in response to double-strand breaks but does not require or result in SOS induction in B. subtilis. Furthermore, we found that B. subtilis cells incapable of inducing SOS had near wild-type levels of survival in response to ionizing radiation. Moreover, B. subtilis RecN contributes to maintaining low levels of SOS induction during double-strand break repair. Thus, we found that the contribution of SOS induction to double-strand break repair differs substantially between E. coli and B. subtilis.     

SOS-Inducible DNA Polymerases and Adaptive Mutagenesis

Stability of genomes of living organisms is maintained by various mechanisms that ensure high fidelity of DNA replication. However, cells can reversibly enhance the level of replication errors in response to external factors. As mutable states are potentially involved in carcinogenesis, aging, and resistance for pathogenic agents, the existence of these states is of great importance for human health. A well-known system of inducible mutation is SOS response, whose key component is replication of damaged DNA regions. Inducible mutation implies a contribution of SOS response to the adaptation of a bacterial population to adverse environments. There is ample evidence indicating the primary role of SOS response genes in the phenomenon of adaptive mutation. The involvement of the SOS system in adaptive mutagenesis is discussed.     

Mutagenic SOS repair of site-specific psoralen damage in plasmid pBR322

The mutagenic repair of psoralen damage was examined by transforming Escherichia coli with psoralen-treated pBR322. Plasmid DNA randomly reacted with psoralen was repaired only when the E. coli was uvrA⁺ and recA⁺, and only when the cells were pre-irradiated with far-ultraviolet light. The recA dependence and requirement for pre-irradiation are characteristics of SOS repair.Psoralens were placed specifically near the BamHI site, in the tetracycline-resistance gene of pBR322, using a sulfhydryl-containing psoralen derivative. Repair of this damage also required pre-irradiation of the host cells. This repair was accompanied by a 4% frequency of mutagenesis to a tetraeycline-sensitive phenotype. Sequence analysis of these mutant plasmids revealed that 75% had mutations within the targeted region, while 25% had no sequence changes within 100 bases of the BamHI site. In up to five independent isolates only one kind of mutation was observed at each site, suggesting that mutagenic SOS repair is influenced by DNA structure at the site of the psoralen. Most mutations were transitions, primarily G-C to A-T changes. Some transitions occurred at sites where psoralen crosslinks could not have formed, and these may have arisen from the repair of psoralen monoadducts.