Suppression of temperature-sensitive chromosome replication of an Escherichia coli dnaX(Ts) mutant by reduction of initiation efficiency

Temperature sensitivity of DNA polymerization and growth of a dnaX(Ts) mutant is suppressible at 39 to 40 degrees C by mutations in the initiator gene, dnaA. These suppressor mutations concomitantly cause initiation inhibition at 20 degrees C and have been designated Cs,Sx to indicate both phenotypic characteristics of cold-sensitive initiation and suppression of dnaX(Ts). One dnaA(Cs,Sx) mutant, A213D, has reduced affinity for ATP, and two mutants, R432L and T435K, have eliminated detectable DnaA box binding in vitro. Two models have explained dnaA(Cs,Sx) suppression of dnaX, which codes for both the tau and gamma subunits of DNA polymerase III. The initiation deficiency model assumes that reducing initiation efficiency allows survival of the dnaX(Ts) mutant at the somewhat intermediate temperature of 39 to 40 degrees C by reducing chromosome content per cell, thus allowing partially active DNA polymerase III to complete replication of enough chromosomes for the organism to survive. The stabilization model is based on the idea that DnaA interacts, directly or indirectly, with polymerization factors during replication. We present five lines of evidence consistent with the initiation deficiency model. First, a dnaA(Cs,Sx) mutation reduced initiation frequency and chromosome content (measured by flow cytometry) and origin/terminus ratios (measured by real-time PCR) in both wild-type and dnaX(Ts) strains growing at 39 and 34 degrees C. These effects were shown to result specifically from the Cs,Sx mutations, because the dnaX(Ts) mutant is not defective in initiation. Second, reduction of the number of origins and chromosome content per cell was common to all three known suppressor mutations. Third, growing the dnaA(Cs,Sx) dnaX(Ts) strain on glycerol-containing medium reduced its chromosome content to one per cell and eliminated suppression at 39 degrees C, as would be expected if the combination of poor carbon source, the Cs,Sx mutation, the Ts mutation, and the 39 degrees C incubation reduced replication to the point that growth (and, therefore, suppression) was not possible. However, suppression was possible on glycerol medium at 38 degrees C. Fourth, the dnaX(Ts) mutation can be suppressed also by introduction of oriC mutations, which reduced initiation efficiency and chromosome number per cell, and the degree of suppression was proportional to the level of initiation defect. Fifth, introducing a dnaA(Cos) allele, which causes overinitiation, into the dnaX(Ts) mutant exacerbated its temperature sensitivity.     

Cloning and characterization of dnaA(Cs), a mutation which leads to overinitiation of DNA replication in Escherichia coli K-12.

The product of the dnaA gene is essential for the initiation of chromosomal DNA replication in Escherichia coli K-12. A cold-sensitive mutation, dnaA(Cs), was originally isolated as a putative intragenic suppressor of the temperature sensitivity of a dnaA46 mutant (G. Kellenberger-Gujer, A. J. Podhajska, and L. Caro, Mol. Gen. Genet. 162:9-16, 1978). The cold sensitivity of the dnaA(Cs) mutant was attributed to a loss of replication control resulting in overinitiation of DNA replication. We cloned and sequenced the dnaA gene from the dnaA(Cs) mutant and showed that it contains three point mutations in addition to the original dnaA46(Ts) mutation. The dnaA(Cs) mutation was dominant to the wild-type allele. Overproduction of the DnaA(Cs) protein blocked cell growth. In contrast, overproduction of wild-type DnaA protein reduced the growth rate of cells but did not stop cell growth. Thus, the effect of elevated levels of the DnaA(Cs) protein was quite different from that of the wild-type protein under the same conditions.     

Interactions of DNA replication factors in vivo as detected by introduction of suppressor alleles of dnaA into other temperature-sensitive dna mutants.

Suppressor mutations located within dnaA can suppress the temperature sensitivity of a dnaZ polymerization mutant, indicating in vivo interaction of the products of these genes. The suppressor allele of dnaA [designated dnaA(SUZ, Cs)] could not be introduced, even at the permissive temperature, by transduction into temperature-sensitive (Ts) dnaC or dnaG recipients; it was transduced into dnaB(Ts) and dnaE(Ts) strains but at very low frequency. Recipient cells which were dnaA+ dnaE(Ts) were killed by the incoming dnaA(SUZ, Cs) allele, and it is presumed that combinations of dnaA(SUZ, Cs) with dnaB(Ts), dnaC(Ts), or dnaG(Ts) are lethal also. In one specific case, the lethality required the presence of three alleles: the incoming dnaA suppressor mutation, the resident dnaA+ gene, and the dnaB(Ts) gene. This was shown by the fact that dnaB(Ts) could readily be introduced into a dnaA(SUZ, Cs) dnaB+ recipient. That is, in the absence of dnaA+, the dnaA suppressor and dnaB(Ts) double mutant was stable. One model to explain these results proposes that the dnaA protein functions not only in initiation but also in the replication complex which contains multiple copies of dnaA and other replication factors.     

Cooperation of the prs and dnaA gene products for initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli.

A new Escherichia coli mutant allele, named dnaR, that causes thermosensitive initiation of chromosome replication has been identified to be an allele of the prs gene, the gene for phosphoribosylpyrophosphate synthetase (Y. Sakakibara, J. Mol. Biol. 226:979-987, 1992; Y. Sakakibara, J. Mol. Biol. 226:989-996, 1992). The dnaR mutant became temperature resistant by acquisition of a mutation in the dnaA gene that did not affect the intrinsic activity for the initiation of replication. The suppressor mutant was capable of initiating replication from oriC at a high temperature restrictive for the dnaR single mutant. The thermoresistant DNA synthesis was inhibited by the presence of the wild-type dnaA allele at a high but not a low copy number. The synthesis was also inhibited by an elevated dose of a mutant dnaR allele retaining dnaR activity. Therefore, thermoresistant DNA synthesis in the suppressor mutant was dependent on both the dnaA and the dnaR functions. On the basis of these results, I conclude that the initiation of chromosome replication requires cooperation of the prs and dnaA products.     

Initiation of chromosome replication in dnaA and dnaC mutants of Escherichia coli B/r F.

Regulatory aspects of chromosome replication were investigated in dnaA5 and dnaC2 mutants of the Escherichia coli B/r F. When cultures growing at 25 degrees C were shifted to 41 degrees C for extended periods and then returned to 25 degrees C, the subsequent synchronous initiations of chromosome replication were spaced at fixed intervals. When chloramphenicol was added coincident with the temperature downshift, the extend of chromosome replication in the dnaA mutant was greater than that in the dnaC mutant, but the time intervals between initiations were the same in both mutants. Furthermore, the time interval between the first two initiation events was unaffected by alterations in the rate of rifampin-sensitive RNA synthesis or cell mass increase. In the dnaC2 mutant, the capacities for both initiations were achieved in the absence of extensive DNA replication at 25 degrees C as long as protein synthesis was permitted, but the cells did not progress toward the second initiation at 25 degrees C when both protein synthesis and DNA replication were prevented. Cells of the dnaA5 mutant did not achieve the capacity for the second initiation event in the absence of extensive chromosome replication, although delayed initiation may have taken place. A plausible hypothesis to explain the data is that the minimum interval is determined by the time required for formation of a supercoiled, membrane-attached structure in the vicinity of oriC which is required for initiation of DNA synthesis.     

Involvement of the ribulosephosphate epimerase gene in the dnaA and dnaR functions for initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli

Initiation of replication of the Escherichia coli chromosome is rendered temperature-sensitive by the dnaR130 mutation in the prs gene that encodes phosphoribosylpyrophosphate synthetase. The thermosensitivity of the dnaR mutant is suppressed by a spontaneous mutation in rpe , the gene encoding ribulosephosphate epimerase. Disruption of the rpe gene reverses the thermosensitive growth of the dnaR mutant. The rpe -disrupted dnaR mutant exhibits extensive DNA synthesis at low and high temperatures, as does the dnaR  ⁺ rpe disruptant and the dnaR  ⁺ rpe ⁺ strain. The thermoresistant DNA synthesis in the rpe dnaR double mutant is dnaA dependent, because the dnaA167 mutation renders the synthesis thermosensitive. The rpe -knockout mutation abolishes the ability of the dnaA115 allele to complement the defect of the dnaA167 mutant with or without the dnaR mutation and diminishes the dnaR -complementing ability of the dnaR224 allele. These results show that the rpe product is involved in the functions of the products of both dnaA and dnaR for initiation of replication of the bacterial chromosome.     

Reversibility of DnaA protein activity in the'irreversible'dnaA204 mutant of Escherichia coli

The dnaA204 mutant, one of the so-called irreversible dnaA mutants which cannot reinitiate chromosome replication upon a shift from non-permissive to permissive growth temperature in the absence of protein synthesis, was reinvestigated using flow cytometry and marker frequency analysis. In a temperature downshift experiment and in the presence of protein synthesis the dnaA204 mutant reinitiates chromosome replication very fast. Using a lac promoter-controlled wild type or a dnaA204 mutant gene carried on a plasmid, we have observed instantaneous initiation of replication when synthesis of DnaA protein is induced in the dnaA204 mutant at 42δC. The data indicate that the dnaA204 mutant after a shift to 42δC still contains functional DnaA protein, but that the activity level is below the initiation threshold. Thus, after synthesis of very small amounts of additional DnaA protein, initiation occurs very fast both after a shift to 30δC, and after induction of DnaA protein synthesis at 42 C. A model describing the processing of DnaA protein in mutants and in the wild type Is presented.     

Genetic mapping of the chromosomal replication origin of Salmonella typhimurium.

Two hundred strains of Escherichia coli harboring Filv+ plasmids which carry a segment of the Salmonella typhimurium chromosome were isolated independently. Among them, two strains were found to harbor F' plasmids that are able to replicate in Hfr cells of E. coli; i.e., they carry a site designated poh (permissive on Hfr) of the S. typhimurium chromosome. The poh site is presumably identical with the replication origin (oriC) of the bacterial chromosome. These two plasmids carry the dnaA-uncA-rbs-ilv-cya-metE region of the chromosome of S. typhimurium. Other F' plasmids which only carried the ilv-cya-metE region were unable to be maintained in Hfr cells. The poh site (= oriC) of S. typhimurium thus is located in the uhp-ilv region of the chromosome. The two plasmids carrying the poh site of S. typhimurium can suppress the temperature-sensitive character of an E. coli mutant that carries the temperature-sensitive dnaA46 allele, when the plasmids exist in the mutant cells. This suggests that the dnaA chromosome in place of the dnaA gene product of E. coli itself. The ability of the plasmids carrying the poh site of S. typhimurium to replicate in Hfr cells of E. coli suggests that the replication system of E. coli can recognize the Salmonella replication origin.     

Requirement of DNA Gyrase for the initiation of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli K-12

Summary It has been found that strains carrying mutations in the dnaA gene are unusually sensitive to COU, NAL or NOV, which are known to inhibit DNA gyrase activities. The delay in the initiation of chromosome replication after COU treatment has been observed in cells with chromosomes synchronized by amino acid starvation or by temperature shift-up (dnaA46). The unusual sensitivity of growth to COU of the initiation mutant runs parallel to a higher sensitivity to the drug of the initiation of chromosome replication.The double mutant, dnaA46 cou-110 has been isolated and mutation cou-110 conferring resistance of growth, initiation and elongation of chromosome replication to COU was mapped in the gene coding for the subunit of DNA gyrase. The reduced frequency of appearance of the mutants resistant to COU, NAL or NOV in the initiation mutant suggests that some mutations in genes coding for DNA gyrase subunits cannot coexist with the dnaA46 mutation. The possible mechanisms of the requirement of DNA gyrase for dnaA-dependent initiation of E. coli chromosome are discussed.Abbreviations used COU coumermycin A₁ - NAL nalidixic acid - NOV novobiocin     

Mutations in Escherichia coli dnaA which suppress a dnaX(Ts) polymerization mutation and are dominant when located in the chromosomal allele and recessive on plasmids.

Extragenic suppressor mutations which had the ability to suppress a dnaX2016(Ts) DNA polymerization defect and which concomitantly caused cold sensitivity have been characterized within the dnaA initiation gene. When these alleles (designated Cs, Sx) were moved into dnaX+ strains, the new mutants became cold sensitive and phenotypically were initiation defective at 20 degrees C (J.R. Walker, J.A. Ramsey, and W.G. Haldenwang, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79:3340-3344, 1982). Detailed localization by marker rescue and DNA sequencing are reported here. One mutation changed codon 213 from Ala to Asp, the second changed Arg-432 to Leu, and the third changed codon 435 from Thr to Lys. It is striking that two of the three spontaneous mutations occurred in codons 432 and 435; these codons are within a very highly conserved, 12-residue region (K. Skarstad and E. Boye, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1217:111-130, 1994; W. Messer and C. Weigel, submitted for publication) which must be critical for one of the DnaA activities. The dominance of wild-type and mutant alleles in both initiation and suppression activities was studied. First, in initiation function, the wild-type allele was dominant over the Cs, Sx alleles, and this dominance was independent of location. That is, the dnaA+ allele restored growth to dnaA (Cs, Sx) strains at 20 degrees C independently of which allele was present on the plasmid. The dnaA (Cs, Sx) alleles provided initiator function at 39 degrees C and were dominant in a dnaA(Ts) host at that temperature. On the other hand, suppression was dominant when the suppressor allele was chromosomal but recessive when it was plasmid borne. Furthermore, suppression was not observed when the suppressor allele was present on a plasmid and the chromosomal dnaA was a null allele. These data suggest that the suppressor allele must be integrated into the chromosome, perhaps at the normal dnaA location. Suppression by dnaA (Cs, Sx) did not require initiation at oriC; it was observed in strains deleted of oriC and which initiated at an integrated plasmid origin.     

Two types of cold sensitivity associated with the A184-->V change in the DnaA protein

Multicopy dnaA(Ts) strains carrying the dnaA5 or dnaA46 allele are high-temperature resistant but are cold sensitive for colony formation. The DnaA5 and DnaA46 proteins both have an A184-->V change in the ATP binding motif of the protein, but they also have one additional mutation. The mutations were separated, and it was found that a plasmid carrying exclusively the A184-->V mutation conferred a phenotype virtually identical to that of the dnaA5 plasmid. Strains carrying plasmids with either of the additional mutations behaved like a strain carrying the dnaA+ plasmid. In temperature downshifts from 42 degrees C to 30 degrees C, chromosome replication was stimulated in the multicopy dnaA46 strain. The DNA per mass ratio increased threefold, and exponential growth was maintained for more than four mass doublings. Strains carrying plasmids with the dnaA(A184-->V) or the dnaA5 gene behaved differently. The temperature downshift resulted in run out of DNA synthesis and the strains eventually ceased growth. The arrest of DNA synthesis was not due to the inability to initiate chromosome replication because marker frequency analysis showed high initiation activity after temperature downshift. However, the marker frequencies indicated that most, if not all, of the newly initiated replication forks were stalled soon after the onset of chromosome replication. Thus, it appears that the multicopy dnaA(A184-->V) strains are cold sensitive because of an inability to elongate replication at low temperature. The multicopy dnaA46 strains, on the contrary, exhibit productive initiation and normal fork movement. In this case, the cold-sensitive phenotype may be due to DNA overproduction.     

A novel class of mutations that affect DNA replication in E. coli

Over-initiation of DNA replication in cells containing the cold-sensitive dnaA(cos) allele has been shown to lead to extensive DNA damage, potentially due to head-to-tail replication fork collisions that ultimately lead to replication fork collapse, growth stasis and/or cell death. Based on the assumption that suppressors of the cold-sensitive phenotype of the cos mutant should include mutations that affect the efficiency and/or regulation of DNA replication, we subjected a dnaA(cos) mutant strain to transposon mutagenesis and selected mutant derivatives that could form colonies at 30 degrees C. Four suppressors of the dnaA(cos)-mediated cold sensitivity were identified and further characterized. Based on origin to terminus ratios, chromosome content per cell, measured by flow cytometry, and sensitivity to the replication fork inhibitor hydroxyurea, the suppressors fell into two distinct categories: those that directly inhibit over-initiation of DNA replication and those that act independently of initiation. Mutations that decrease the cellular level of HolC, the chi subunit of DNA polymerase, or loss of ndk (nucleoside diphosphate kinase) function fall into the latter category. We propose that these novel suppressor mutations function by decreasing the efficiency of replication fork movement in vivo, either by decreasing the dynamic exchange of DNA polymerase subunits in the case of HolC, or by altering the balance between DNA replication and deoxynucleoside triphosphate synthesis in the case of ndk. Additionally, our results indicate a direct correlation between over-initiation and sensitivity to replication fork inhibition by hydroxyurea, supporting a model of increased head-to-tail replication fork collisions due to over-initiation.     

Reinitiation kinetics in eight dnaA(Ts) mutants of Escherichia coli: rifampicin-resistant Initiation of chromosome replication

The kinetics of reinitiation of chromosome replication of eight dnaA(Ts) mutants was investigated in an isogenic set of strains. Five mutants (167, 46, 601, 606 and 5) are classified as reversible, since they can reinitiate at 30 C without protein synthesis, whereas the other three (508, 205, 204) require protein synthesis. In the presence of protein synthesis, reversible mutants initiate one round of replication rapidly after a shift to 30δC, indicating that they contain active or renaturable DnaA protein. The dnaA508 and dnaA204 mutants also reinitiate chromosome replication rapidly, whereas reinitiation is delayed 15–20min in dnaA205. The dnaA508 and dnaA204 mutants might contain active DnaA protein just below the threshold level at 42δC and only require synthesis of small amounts of new DnaA protein before initiation at 30δC, whereas dnaA205 accumulates DnaA protein for some time at 30δC before reaching the initiation threshold. Three of the reversible mutants (5, 601, and 606) exhibited, in addition to the protein synthesis-independent initiation capacity, an RNA synthesis-independent initiation capacity. The thermal stability of these initiation capacities is the same as for mutant DnaA protein, strongly suggesting that mutant DnaA protein is responsible for both.     

DNA replication studies with coliphage 186: the involvement of the Escherichia coli DnaA protein in 186 replication is indirect.

The inability of coliphage 186 to infect productively a dnaA(Ts) mutant at a restrictive temperature was confirmed. However, the requirement by 186 for DnaA is indirect, since 186 can successfully infect suppressed dnaA (null) strains. The block to 186 infection of a dnaA(Ts) strain at a restrictive temperature is at the level of replication but incompletely so, since some 20% of the phage specific replication seen with infection of a dnaA+ host does occur. A mutant screen, to isolate host mutants blocked in 186-specific replication but not in the replication of the close relative coliphage P2, which has no DnaA requirement, yielded a mutant whose locus we mapped to the rep gene. A 186 mutant able to infect this rep mutant was isolated, and the mutation was located in the phage replication initiation endonuclease gene A, suggesting direct interaction between the Rep helicase and phage endonuclease during replication. DNA sequencing indicated a glutamic acid-to-valine change at residue 155 of the 694-residue product of gene A. In the discussion, we speculate that the indirect need of DnaA function is at the level of lagging-strand synthesis in the rolling circle replication of 186.     

Novel Escherichia coli mutant, dnaR, thermosensitive in initiation of chromosome replication.

A newly isolated Escherichia coli mutant thermosensitive in DNA synthesis had an allele named dnaR130, which was located at 26.3 minutes on the genetic map. The mutant was defective in initiation of chromosome replication but not in propagation at a high temperature. This mutant was capable of growing in the absence of the rnh function at the high temperature by means of a dnaA-independent replication mechanism. In the mutant exposed to the high temperature, an oriC plasmid was able to replicate, although at a lower rate than at the low temperature. The plasmid replication at the high temperature depended on the dnaA function essential for the initiation of replication from oriC. The mutant lacking the rnh function persistently maintained the oriC plasmid at the high temperature in a dnaA-dependent manner. Thus, the dnaR function was required for initiation of replication of the bacterial chromosome from oriC but not the oriC plasmid. This result reveals that a dnaR-dependent initiation mechanism that is dispensable for oriC plasmid replication operates in the bacterial chromosome replication.     

Requirement of the Escherichia coli dnaA gene function for ori-2-dependent mini-F plasmid replication.

The mini-F plasmids pSC138, pKP1013, and pKV513 were unable to transform Escherichia coli cells with a dnaA-defective mutation under nonpermissive conditions. The dnaA defect was suppressed for host chromosome replication either by the simultaneous presence of the rnh-199 (amber) mutation or by prophage P2 sig5 integrated at the attP2II locus on the chromosome, both providing new origins for replication independent of dnaA function. The dnaA mutations tested were dnaA17, dnaA5, and dnaA46. dnaA5 and dnaA46 are missense mutations. dnaA17 is an amber mutation whose activity is controlled by the temperature-sensitive amber suppressor supF6. Under permissive conditions in which active DnaA protein was available, the mini-F plasmids efficiently transformed the cells. However, the transformants lost the plasmid as the cells multiplied under conditions in which DnaA protein was inactivated or its synthesis was arrested. As controls, plasmids pSC101 and pBR322 were examined along with mini-F; pSC101 behaved in the same manner as mini-F, showing complete dependence on dnaA for stable maintenance, whereas pBR322 was indifferent to the dnaA defect. Thus, ori-2-dependent mini-F plasmid replication seems to require active dnaA gene function. This notion was strengthened by the results of deletion analysis which revealed that integrity of at least one of the two DnaA boxes present as a tandem repeat in ori-2 was required for the origin activity of mini-F replication.     

Two separate DNA sequences within oriC participate in accurate chromosome segregation in Bacillus subtilis

Current views of bacterial chromosome segregation vary in respect of the likely presence or absence of an active segregation mechanism involving a mitotic-like apparatus. Furthermore, little is known about cis-acting elements for chromosome segregation in bacteria. In this report, we show that two separate DNA regions, a 3' coding region of dnaA and the AT-rich sequence between dnaA and dnaN (the initial opening site of duplex DNA during replication), are necessary for efficient segregation of the chromosome in Bacillus subtilis. When a plasmid replicon was integrated into argG, far from oriC, on the chromosome and then the oriC function was disrupted, the oriC-deleted mutant formed anucleate cells at 5% possibly because of defects in chromosome segregation. However, when the two DNA sequences were added near oriN, frequency of anucleate cells decreased to 1%. In these cells, the origin (argG) regions were localized near cell poles, whereas they were randomly distributed in cells without the two DNA sequences. These results suggest that the two DNA sequences in and downstream of the dnaA gene participate in correct positioning of the replication origin region within the cell and that this function is associated with accurate chromosome segregation in B. subtilis.     

Isolation of a temperature-sensitive dnaA mutant of Staphylococcus aureus

Of 750 temperature-sensitive mutants of Gram-positive Staphylococcus aureus, one was complemented by the dnaA gene. This mutant had a single base transition in the dnaA gene causing the amino-acid substitution mutation, Ala40Thr. Phage transduction experiments showed that this temperature-sensitive phenotype was linked with a drug-resistant marker inserted near the dnaA gene, suggesting the dnaA mutation is responsible for the phenotype. Flow cytometric analysis revealed that the dnaA mutant was unable to initiate DNA replication at a restrictive temperature and exhibited asynchrony in the replication initiation at a permissive temperature. This is the first report of a temperature-sensitive dnaA mutant in S. aureus, and the results show that DnaA is required for the initiation of chromosomal replication and for the regulation of synchrony in the bacterial cells.     

Kinetics of minichromosome replication in Escherichia coli B/r.

Replication control of the minichromosome pAL2 was found to differ from that of the chromosome in synchronously dividing populations of Escherichia coli B/r. Initiation of minichromosome replication took place at an increasing rate throughout synchronous growth. No coupling to initiation of chromosome replication was detected. Minichromosome replication was further examined in a dnaA5(Ts) temperature-sensitive initiation mutant. When cultures held at nonpermissive temperature (41 degrees C) for 60 min were shifted to permissive temperature (25 degrees C), initiation of both pAL2 and chromosome replication ensued in two waves spaced 25 to 35 min apart. Evidence is presented that minichromosomes terminate replication by passing slowly through a series of dimeric intermediate forms before reaching the closed circular monomeric form. The consequence of this slow passage as a rate-limiting step in the initiation reaction is discussed.