The restriction of the heart morphogenetic field in Xenopus laevis

We have examined the spatial restriction of heart-forming potency in Xenopus laevis embryos, using an assay system in which explants or explant recombinates are cultured in hanging drops and scored for the formation of a beating heart. At the end of neurulation at stage 20, the heart morphogenetic field, i.e., the area that is capable of heart formation when cultured in isolation, includes anterior ventral and ventrolateral mesoderm. This area of developmental potency does not extend into more posterior regions. Between postneurula stage 23 and the onset of heart morphogenesis at stage 28, the heart morphogenetic field becomes spatially restricted to the anterior ventral region. The restriction of the heart morphogenetic field during postneurula stages results from a loss of developmental potency in the lateral mesoderm, rather than from ventrally directed morphogenetic movements of the lateral mesoderm. This loss of potency is not due to the inhibition of heart formation by migrating neural crest cells. During postneurula stages, tissue interactions between the lateral mesoderm and the underlying anterior endoderm support the heart-forming potency in the lateral mesoderm. The lateral mesoderm loses the ability to respond to this tissue interaction by stages 27-28. We speculate that either formation of the third pharyngeal pouch during stages 23-27 or lateral inhibition by ventral mesoderm may contribute to the spatial restriction of the heart morphogenetic field.     

The role of the dorsal lip in the induction of heart mesoderm in Xenopus laevis

We have examined the tissue interactions responsible for the expression of heart-forming potency during gastrulation. By comparing the specification of different regions of the marginal zone, we show that heart-forming potency is expressed only in explants containing both the dorsal lip of the blastopore and deep mesoderm between 30 degrees and 45 degrees lateral to the dorsal midline. Embryos from which both of these 30 degrees-45 degrees dorsolateral regions have been removed undergo heart formation in two thirds of cases, as long as the dorsal lip is left intact. If the dorsal lip is removed along with the 30 degrees-45 degrees regions, heart formation does not occur. These results indicate that the dorsolateral deep mesoderm must interact with the dorsal lip in order to express heart-forming potency. Transplantation of the dorsal lip into the ventral marginal zone of host embryos results in the formation of a secondary axis; in over half of cases, this secondary axis includes a heart derived from the host mesoderm. These findings suggest that the establishment of heart mesoderm is initiated by a dorsalizing signal from the dorsal lip of the blastopore.     

Heart formative factor(s) is localized in the anterior endoderm of early Xenopus neurula

To elucidate the mechanisms of early heart morphogenesis in Xenopus laevis, we examined the effect of endoderm on heart morphogenesis in the early Xenopus neurula. Explants of anterior ventral (presumptive heart) mesoderm from early neurula were cultured alone or in combination with endoderm dissected from various regions. Heart formation was scored by an original heart index based on morphology. These explant studies revealed that anterior ventral endoderm plays a critical role in heart morphogenesis. Furthermore, we found that it was possible to confer this heart-forming ability on posterior ventral endoderm by the injection of poly(A)⁺ RNA from stage 13 anterior endoderm. These results imply that the heart formative factor(s) is localized in the anterior endoderm of the early neurula and that at least part of this activity is encoded by mRNA(s).     

The outflow tract of the heart is recruited from a novel heart-forming field.

As classically described, the precardiac mesoderm of the paired heart-forming fields migrate and fuse anteriomedially in the ventral midline to form the first segment of the straight heart tube. This segment ultimately forms the right trabeculated ventricle. Additional segments are added to the caudal end of the first in a sequential fashion from the posteriolateral heart-forming field mesoderm. In this study we report that the final major heart segment, which forms the cardiac outflow tract, does not follow this pattern of embryonic development. The cardiac outlet, consisting of the conus and truncus, does not derive from the paired heart-forming fields, but originates separately from a previously unrecognized source of mesoderm located anterior to the initial primitive heart tube segment. Fate-mapping results show that cells labeled in the mesoderm surrounding the aortic sac and anterior to the primitive right ventricle are incorporated into both the conus and the truncus. Conversely, if cells are labeled in the existing right ventricle no incorporation into the cardiac outlet is observed. Tissue explants microdissected from this anterior mesoderm region are capable of forming beating cardiac muscle in vitro when cocultured with explants of the primitive right ventricle. These findings establish the presence of another heart-forming field. This anterior heart-forming field (AHF) consists of mesoderm surrounding the aortic sac immediately anterior to the existing heart tube. This new concept of the heart outlet's embryonic origin provides a new basis for explaining a variety of gene-expression patterns and cardiac defects described in both transgenic animals and human congenital heart disease.     

The anterior heart-forming field: voyage to the arterial pole of the heart

Studies of vertebrate heart development have identified key genes and signalling molecules involved in the formation of a myocardial tube from paired heart-forming fields in splanchnic mesoderm. The posterior region of the paired heart-forming fields subsequently contributes myocardial precursor cells to the inflow region or venous pole of the heart. Recently, a population of myocardial precursor cells in chick and mouse embryos has been identified in pharyngeal mesoderm anterior to the early heart tube. This anterior heart-forming field gives rise to myocardium of the outflow region or arterial pole of the heart. The amniote heart is therefore derived from two myocardial precursor cell populations, which appear to be regulated by distinct genetic programmes. Discovery of the anterior heart-forming field has important implications for the interpretation of cardiac defects in mouse mutants and for the study of human congenital heart disease.     

Precardiac cell migration: fibronectin localization at mesoderm-endoderm interface during directional movement

The pathway of directional movement of chick precardiac mesoderm cells was studied by indirect immunofluorescence and by scanning electron microscopy. Directional movement of the precardiac cells begins at stage 6 from the lateral sides of the embryo at the level of Hensen's node. The cells move anteriorly in an arc to the embryo's midline. By stage 8 the cells arrive at the lateral sides of the anterior intestinal portal and movement ceases. The interval of this directional movement is approximately 10 hr. During migration the precardiac cells are in close association with the underlying endoderm. As migration proceeds, the cells encounter increasing amounts of fibrils in the substratum at the mesoderm-endoderm interface. Concomitant with increasing fibril formation there is an increase in fibronectin (FN) in the heart-forming region. During stage 5 FN first appears in the lateral heart-forming regions and increases in amount during the period of cell migration. By stage 7 a concentration difference of FN is apparent in the lateral regions with more FN cephalad and decreasing amounts caudad. At stages 7 and 8 large amounts of extracellular FN-associated fibrils are observed at the lateral sides of the anterior intestinal portal where the cells stop moving. The precardiac cells moving into this region are oriented perpendicular to the anterior intestinal portal and in close association with these fibrils. There is no evidence that the fibrillar meshwork forming the substratum of the precardiac mesoderm cells is physically oriented as a guide for directional movement. The correlations between FN distribution at the mesoderm-endoderm interface and directional cell movement suggest that the precardiac cells may migrate by haptotaxis, i.e., by moving along the substratum toward areas of greater adhesiveness.     

The effects of retinoic acid on heart formation in the early chick embryo.

The vitamin A derivative retinoic acid has previously been shown to have teratogenic effects on heart development in mammalian embryos. The craniomedial migration of the precardiac mesoderm during the early stages of heart formation is thought to depend on a gradient of extracellular fibronectin associated with the underlying endoderm. Here, the effects of retinoic acid on migration of the precardiac mesoderm have been investigated in the early chick embryo. When applied to the whole embryo in culture, the retinoid inhibits the craniomedial migration of the precardiac mesoderm resulting in a heart tube that is stunted cranially, while normal or enlarged caudally. Similarly, a local application of retinoic acid to the heart-forming area disrupts the formation of the cardiogenic crescent and the subsequent development of a single mid-line heart tube. This effect is analogous to removing a segment of endoderm and mesoderm across the heart-forming area and results in various degrees of cardia bifida. At higher concentrations of retinoic acid and earlier developmental stages, two completely separate hearts are produced, while at lower concentrations and later stages there are partial bifurcations. The controls, in which the identical operation is carried out except that dimethyl sulphoxide (DMSO) is used instead of the retinoid, are almost all normal. We propose that one of the teratogenic effects of retinoic acid on the heart is to disrupt the interaction between precardiac cells and the extracellular matrix thus inhibiting their directed migration on the endodermal substratum.     

Lack of regulation in the heart forming region of avian embryos

The ability to regenerate a heart after ablation of cardiogenic mesoderm has been demonstrated in early stage fish and amphibian embryos but this type of regulation of the heart field has not been seen in avians or mammals. The regulative potential of the cardiogenic mesoderm was examined in avian embryos and related to the spatial expression of genes implicated in early cardiogenesis. With the identification of early cardiac regulators such as bmp-2 and nkx-2.5, it is now possible to reconcile classical embryological studies with molecular mechanisms of cardiac lineage determination in vivo. The most anterior lateral embryonic cells were identified as the region that becomes the heart and removal of all or any subset of these cells resulted in the loss of corresponding cardiac structures. In addition, removal of the lateral heart forming mesoderm while leaving the lateral endoderm intact also results in loss of cardiac structures. Thus the medial anterior mesoderm cannot be recruited into the heart lineage in vivo even in the presence of potentially cardiac inducing endoderm. In situ analysis demonstrated that genes involved in early events of cardiogenesis such as bone morphogenetic protein 2 (bmp-2) and nkx-2.5 are expressed coincidentally with the mapped far lateral heart forming region. The activin type IIa receptor (actR-IIa) is a potential mediator of BMP signaling since it is expressed throughout the anterior mesoderm with the highest level of expression occurring in the lateral prospective heart cells. The posterior boundary of actR-IIa is consistent with the posterior boundary of nkx-2.5 expression, supporting a model whereby ActR-IIa is involved in restricting the heart forming region to an anterior subset of lateral cells exposed to BMP-2. Analysis of the cardiogenic potential of the lateral plate mesoderm posterior to nkx-2.5 and actR-IIa expression demonstrated that these cells are not cardiogenic in vitro and that removal of these cells from the embryo does not result in loss of heart tissue in vivo. Thus, the region of the avian embryo that will become the heart is defined medially, laterally, and posteriorly by nkx-2.5 gene expression. Removal of all or part of the nkx-2.5 expressing region results in the loss of corresponding heart structures, demonstrating the inability of the chick embryo to regenerate cardiac tissue in vivo at stages after nkx-2.5 expression is initiated.     

The specification of heart mesoderm occurs during gastrulation in Xenopus laevis

The establishment of heart mesoderm during Xenopus development has been examined using an assay for heart differentiation in explants and explant combinations in culture. Previous studies using urodele embryos have shown that the heart mesoderm is induced by the prospective pharyngeal endoderm during neurula and postneurula stages. In this study, we find that the specification of heart mesoderm must begin well before the end of gastrulation in Xenopus embryos. Explants of prospective heart mesoderm isolated from mid- or late neurula stages were capable of heart formation in nearly 100% of cases, indicating that the specification of heart mesoderm is complete by midneurula stages. Moreover, inclusion of pharyngeal endoderm had no statistically significant effect upon either the frequency of heart formation or the timing of the initiation of heartbeat in explants of prospective heart mesoderm isolated after the end of gastrulation. When the superficial pharyngeal endoderm was removed at the beginning of gastrulation, experimental embryos formed hearts, as did explants of prospective heart mesoderm from such embryos. These results indicate that the inductive interactions responsible for the establishment of heart mesoderm occur prior to the end of gastrulation and do not require the participation of the superficial pharyngeal endoderm.     

Transgenic zebrafish reveal stage-specific roles for Bmp signaling in ventral and posterior mesoderm development

Bone morphogenetic protein (Bmp) signaling is crucial for the formation and patterning of zebrafish ventral and posterior mesoderm. Mutants defective in the Bmp pathway have expanded trunk muscle, abnormal tails and severely impaired development of ventral mesodermal derivatives such as vasculature, blood and pronephros. As Bmps continue to be expressed in the ventral and posterior mesoderm after gastrulation, it is likely that Bmp signaling continues to play an important developmental role during outgrowth of the posterior body. However, because Bmp signaling plays an essential role during the gastrula stages, it has not been possible with mutants or standard disruption techniques to determine the later functions of the Bmp pathway. To study the role of Bmp signaling in the ventral and posterior mesoderm during trunk and tail outgrowth, we generated a transgenic zebrafish line containing a heatshock-inducible dominant-negative Bmp receptor-GFP fusion. Our data show that Bmps are important for tail organizer formation and for patterning the ventral mesoderm during early gastrulation. However, from mid-gastrulation to the early somitogenesis stages, Bmp signaling is important for ventral tail fin development and for preventing secondary tail formation. We conclude that the role of Bmp signaling in the ventral and posterior mesoderm changes as gastrulation proceeds.     

Heart induction in wild-type and cardiac mutant axolotls (Ambystoma mexicanum).

We have re-examined some of the factors affecting the induction of heart-forming mesoderm in the axolotl. The formation of functional, rhythmically contracting myocardial tissue was used as an assay. We have found that heart-forming mesoderm is fully induced and capable of completing its developmental repertoire by the end of neurulation. As has been previously reported, pharyngeal endoderm appears to be the major inductor of heart mesoderm. Unlike previous workers, we have found that the inducing activity appears to be highly localized in the mid-ventral pharyngeal endoderm. The endoderm retains its inductive properties, and the mesoderm retains at least some capacity to respond, long after the heart-forming mesoderm is apparently fully induced. We have also found that RNA extracts from pharyngeal endoderm, which are capable of causing cardiac-lethal (c/c) mutant axolotl hearts to begin beating, are not capable of inducing early wild-type heart-forming mesoderm. Based on these results, we speculate that induction of heart-forming mesoderm is a two-step process. The first signal, occurring during neurulation, directs the mesoderm to begin differentiating into cardiomyocytes, and the second, beginning in mid- to late neurulation and continuing until just prior to the onset of heartbeat, causes myofibrillogenesis and the initiation of rhythmic contractions. The latter signal, which is lacking in c/c mutant embryos, appears to be necessary to override an inhibition present in the embryonic milieu.     

Retinoic acid signaling in heart development

Retinoic acid (RA) is a vitamin A metabolite that acts as a morphogen and teratogen. Excess or defective RA signaling causes developmental defects including in the heart. The heart develops from the anterior lateral plate mesoderm. Cardiogenesis involves successive steps, including formation of the primitive heart tube, cardiac looping, septation, chamber development, coronary vascularization, and completion of the four‐chambered heart. RA is dispensable for primitive heart tube formation. Before looping, RA is required to define the anterior/posterior boundaries of the heart‐forming mesoderm as well as to form the atrium and sinus venosus. In outflow tract elongation and septation, RA signaling is required to maintain/differentiate cardiogenic progenitors in the second heart field at the posterior pharyngeal arches level. Epicardium‐secreted insulin‐like growth factor, the expression of which is regulated by hepatic mesoderm‐derived erythropoietin under the control of RA, promotes myocardial proliferation of the ventricular wall. Epicardium‐derived RA induces the expression of angiogenic factors in the myocardium to form the coronary vasculature. In cardiogenic events at different stages, properly controlled RA signaling is required to establish the functional heart.     

Avian vasculogenesis and the distribution of collagens I, IV, laminin, and fibronectin in the heart primordia

The heart-forming regions of the early embryo are composed of splanchnic mesoderm, endoderm, and the associated ECM. The ECM of the heart-forming regions in stage 7-9 chicken embryos was examined using immunofluorescence. Affinity purified antibodies to chicken collagens type I and IV, chicken fibronectin, and mouse laminin were used as probes. We report that (1) the basement membrane of the endoderm contains immunoreactive laminin and collagen IV; (2) the nascent basement membrane of the heart splanchnic mesoderm contains immunoreactive laminin, but not type IV collagen, and (3) the prominent ECM between the splanchnic mesoderm and the endoderm (the primitive-heart ECM) contains collagen IV, collagen I, fibronectin, but not laminin. In addition, we describe microscopic observations on the spatial relationship of cardiogenic cells to the primitive-heart ECM and the endodermal basement membrane.     

Proteolipid protein 2 mRNA is expressed in the rabbit embryo during gastrulation

The expression pattern of the receptor tyrosine kinase gene EphB3 was examined during the early stages of chick embryogenesis, and is described in this report. In the gastrula, EphB3 is expressed in epiblast cells adjacent to and entering the anterior portion of the primitive streak; expression is extinguished once cells have ingressed. At headfold stages, EphB3 is strongly transcribed in the floor of the foregut and in anterior lateral endoderm, and is expressed in the subjacent cardiogenic mesoderm. EphB3 is transiently expressed in the lateral ectoderm, neural tube, and neural crest during these stages. Later neural expression is localized to the mesencephalon. In the somitic mesoderm, EphB3 is initially expressed in the sclerotome, but later is expressed predominantly in the dermatome. Prominent expression is also detected in the developing heart, liver, posterior ventral limb bud mesenchyme, pharyngeal arches, and head mesenchyme.     

Diversification of Cardiomyogenic Cell Lineages in Vitro

The ability of undifferentiated cardiogenic mesoderm to generate diversified myogenic phenotypes was assayed in a minimal culture system. During cardiogenesis in vivo, the anterior and posterior segments of the avian heart have distinct patterns of contractile protein gene expression when they first differentiate. To assess the potential of undifferentiated cardiogenic tissue to diversify into distinct anterior and posterior lineages prior to heart formation, cardiogenic mesoderm and endoderm were removed together from the embryo at Hamburger and Hamilton stages 4-8. Explants from each of these stages differentiated in defined medium as indicated by the expression of muscle-specific genes. However, the ability to express the atrial-specific myosin heavy chain (AMHC1) mRNA was confined to posterior cardiac progenitors. Diversification was not dependent on anterior endoderm, suggesting that inductive interactions between the mesoderm and endoderm are not necessary to maintain diversified cardiac lineages after stage 4. The diversified potential of explanted cardiogenic tissue was altered with retinoic acid treatment, resulting in the activation of AMHC1 gene expression in the anterior progenitors. Anterior cardiogenic cells removed from the embryo at stage 8, when the heart begins to differentiate in vivo, are not susceptible to the alteration of diversified phenotype by retinoic acid treatment. Therefore, the potential to form distinct cardiomyogenic cell lineages is present in the anterior lateral plate mesoderm soon after gastrulation and the maturation of these lineages in a positionally dependent manner is maintained in a simple defined culture system in vitro.     

A gradient of homeodomain protein in developing forelimbs of Xenopus and mouse embryos

The expression of the homeodomain protein XIHbox 1 in developing Xenopus limbs was analyzed using specific antibodies. In the forelimb bud mesoderm XIHbox 1 shows a clear antero-posterior gradient that is strongest in the anterior and proximal region of the forelimb. Hindlimb bud mesoderm is devoid of XIHbox 1, indicating an early molecular difference between arm and leg. The innermost ectodermal cell layer is positive throughout the forelimb and hindlimb bud ectoderm, but no other areas of the skin. Similar results are obtained in developing mouse limbs, suggesting that XIHbox 1 participates in forelimb development in a variety of tetrapods. In early tadpoles analyzed at stages preceding limb bud formation, the lateral plate mesoderm is positive in the region corresponding to the earliest "field" of forelimb information, but not in the hindlimb field. These results suggest a molecular link between morphogenetic fields, gradients, and homeobox genes in vertebrate development.     

The preservation of the ability of cultured quail wing bud mesoderm to elicit a position-related differentiative response

A previous study showed that grafting wedges of fresh anterior quail wing mesoderm into posterior slits of chick wing buds resulted in the formation of rods and nodules of cartilage in a high percentage of cases (B. Carlson, 1983, Dev. Biol. 101, 97-105). The purpose of the present study was to determine if a similar response could be elicited by grafting pieces of mesoderm that had been cultured in vitro. When pieces of 1-day cultured anterior mesoderm from stage 17-24 donors were grafted into standard posterior slits of chick wing buds, the percentages of supernumerary structures differed little from those which formed after the grafting of pieces of fresh mesoderm. In a time series, grafts of stage 22-23 anterior mesoderm which had been cultured for 1-4 days retained the ability to form cartilage after being grafted into posterior locations. A time series showed that the duration of this retention was longer in cultured mesoderm than it was in mesoderm that remains in the donor wing bud.