Enhanced monomer–monomer interactions can suppress the recombination deficiency of the recA142 allele

The RecA142 protein, in which valine is substituted for isoleucine-225, is defective for genetic recombination in vivo and for DNA strand exchange activity in vitro under conventional growth and reaction conditions respectively. However, we show that mildly acidic conditions restore both the in vitro DNA strand exchange activity and the in vivo function of RecA142 protein, suggesting that recombination function can be restored by a slight change in protein structure elicited by protonation. Indeed, we identified an intragenic suppressor of the recombination deficiency of the recA142 allele. This suppressor mutation is a substitution of leucine for glutamine at position 124. Based on the three-dimensional structure, the Q-124L substitution is predicted to make a new monomer-monomer contact with residue phenylalanine-21 of the adjacent RecA monomer. The Q-124L mutation is not allele specific, because it also suppresses the recombination deficiency of a recA deletion (Delta9), lacking nine amino acids at the amino-terminus, presumably by reinforcing the monomer-monomer interactions that are attenuated by the Delta9 deletion. Expression of RecA(Q-124L) protein is toxic to Escherichia coli, presumably because of enhanced affinity for DNA. We speculate as to how enhanced monomer-monomer interactions and acidic pH conditions can restore the recombination activity of some defective recA alleles.     

DNA polymerase V and RecA protein, a minimal mutasome

A hallmark of the Escherichia coli SOS response is the large increase in mutations caused by translesion synthesis (TLS). TLS requires DNA polymerase V (UmuD'2C) and RecA. Here, we show that pol V and RecA interact by two distinct mechanisms. First, pol V binds to RecA in the absence of DNA and ATP and second, through its UmuD' subunit, requiring DNA and ATP without ATP hydrolysis. TLS occurs in the absence of a RecA nucleoprotein filament but is inhibited in its presence. Therefore, a RecA nucleoprotein filament is unlikely to be required for SOS mutagenesis. Pol V activity is severely diminished in the absence of RecA or in the presence of RecA1730, a mutant defective for pol V mutagenesis in vivo. Pol V activity is strongly enhanced with RecA mutants constitutive for mutagenesis in vivo, suggesting that RecA is an obligate accessory factor that activates pol V for SOS mutagenesis.     

Crystals of TELSAM–target protein fusions that exhibit minimal crystal contacts and lack direct inter-TELSAM contacts

While conducting pilot studies into the usefulness of fusion to TELSAM polymers as a potential protein crystallization strategy, we observed novel properties in crystals of two TELSAM–target protein fusions, as follows. (i) A TELSAM–target protein fusion can crystallize more rapidly and with greater propensity than the same target protein alone. (ii) TELSAM–target protein fusions can be crystallized at low protein concentrations. This unprecedented observation suggests a route to crystallize proteins that can only be produced in microgram amounts. (iii) The TELSAM polymers themselves need not directly contact one another in the crystal lattice in order to form well-diffracting crystals. This novel observation is important because it suggests that TELSAM may be able to crystallize target proteins too large to allow direct inter-polymer contacts. (iv) Flexible TELSAM–target protein linkers can allow target proteins to find productive binding modes against the TELSAM polymer. (v) TELSAM polymers can adjust their helical rise to allow fused target proteins to make productive crystal contacts. (vi). Fusion to TELSAM polymers can stabilize weak inter-target protein crystal contacts. We report features of these TELSAM–target protein crystal structures and outline future work needed to validate TELSAM as a crystallization chaperone and determine best practices for its use.     

Observation of RecA protein monomer by small angle X-ray scattering with synchrotron radiation

RecA protein is capable of forming homo-oligomers in solution. The oligomeric and monomeric states of Thermus thermophilus RecA protein were studied by small angle X-ray scattering, a direct method used to measure the overall dimensions of a macromolecule. In the presence of 3 M urea or 0.2 M lithium perchlorate, RecA dissociates from higher oligomeric states to form a hexamer with a radius of gyration (R(g)) of 52 A. The value of R(g) decreased to 36 A at a higher lithium perchlorate concentration (1.0 M). The zero angle intensity, I(0), was consistent with the identification of the former state as a hexamer and the latter as a monomer.     

Real-time observation of RecA filament dynamics with single monomer resolution

RecA and its homologs help maintain genomic integrity through recombination. Using single-molecule fluorescence assays and hidden Markov modeling, we show the most direct evidence that a RecA filament grows and shrinks primarily one monomer at a time and only at the extremities. Both ends grow and shrink, contrary to expectation, but a higher binding rate at one end is responsible for directional filament growth. Quantitative rate determination also provides insights into how RecA might control DNA accessibility in vivo. We find that about five monomers are sufficient for filament nucleation. Although ordinarily single-stranded DNA binding protein (SSB) prevents filament nucleation, single RecA monomers can easily be added to an existing filament and displace SSB from DNA at the rate of filament extension. This supports the proposal for a passive role of RecA-loading machineries in SSB removal.     

Affinity chromatography of RecA protein and RecA nucleoprotein complexes on RecA protein-agarose columns

We have analyzed the nature of RecA protein-RecA protein interactions using an affinity column prepared by coupling RecA protein to an agarose support. When radiolabeled soluble proteins from Escherichia coli are applied to this column, only the labeled RecA protein from the extract was selectively retained and bound tightly to the affinity column. Efficient binding of purified 35S-labeled RecA protein required Mg2+, and high salt did not interfere with the binding of RecA protein to the column. Complete removal of the bound enzyme from the affinity column required treatment with guanidine HCl (5 M) or urea (8 M). These and other properties suggest that hydrophobic interactions contribute significantly to RecA protein subunit recognition in solution. Using a series of truncated RecA proteins synthesized in vitro, we have obtained evidence that at least some of the sequences involved in protein recognition are localized within the first 90 amino-terminal residues of the protein. Based on the observation that RecA proteins from three heterologous bacteria are specifically retained on the E. coli RecA affinity column, it is likely that this binding domain is highly conserved and is required for interaction and association of RecA protein monomers. Stable ternary complexes of RecA protein and single-stranded DNA were formed in the presence of the nonhydrolyzable ATP analog adenosine 5'-O-(thiotriphosphate) and applied to the affinity columns. Most of the complexes formed with M13 DNA could be eluted in high salt, whereas a substantial fraction of those formed with the oligonucleotide (dT)25-30 remained bound in high salt and were quantitatively eluted with guanidine HCl (5 M). The different binding properties of these RecA protein-DNA complexes likely reflect differences in the availability of a hydrophobic surface on RecA protein when it is bound to long polynucleotides compared to short oligonucleotides.     

Biochemical events essential to the recombination activity of Escherichia coli RecA protein. II. Co-dominant effects of RecA142 protein on wild-type RecA protein function

In the accompanying paper, RecA142 protein was found to be completely defective in DNA heteroduplex formation. Here, we show that RecA142 protein not only is defective in this activity but also is inhibitory for certain activities of wild-type RecA protein. Under appropriate conditions, RecA142 protein substantially inhibits the DNA strand exchange reaction catalyzed by wild-type RecA protein; at equimolar concentrations of each protein, formation of full-length gapped duplex DNA product molecules is less than 7% of the amount produced by wild-type protein alone. Inhibition by RecA142 protein is also evident in S1 nuclease assays of DNA heteroduplex formation, although the extent of inhibition is less than is observed for the complete DNA strand exchange process; at equimolar concentrations of wild-type and mutant proteins, the extent of DNA heteroduplex formation is 36% of the wild-type protein level. This difference implies that RecA142 protein prevents, at minimum, the branch migration normally observed during DNA strand exchange. RecA142 protein does not inhibit either the single-strand (ss) DNA-dependent ATPase activity or the coaggregation activities of wild-type RecA protein. This suggests that these reactions are not responsible for the inhibition of wild-type protein DNA strand exchange activity by RecA142 protein. However, under conditions where RecA142 protein inhibits DNA strand exchange activity, RecA142 protein renders the M13 ssDNA-dependent ATPase activity of wild-type protein sensitive to inhibition by single-strand DNA-binding protein, and it inhibits the double-strand DNA-dependent ATPase activity of wild-type RecA protein. These results imply that these two activities are important components of the overall DNA strand exchange process. These experiments also demonstrate the applicability of using defective mutant RecA proteins as specific codominant inhibitors of wild-type protein activities in vitro and should be of general utility for mechanistic analysis of RecA protein function both in vitro and in vivo.     

Evidence for a four-strand exchange catalyzed by the RecA protein

Strand exchange between two duplexes is usually initiated as a three-strand event that requires the presence of a single-stranded overhang or gap in one of the two molecules. Here we show that the RecA protein can catalyze a four-strand exchange. Specifically, it can recombine short hairpin substrates with homologous stems provided that one of the hairpins possesses a chimeric DNA/RNA backbone. This four-strand exchange reaction goes to completion in the presence of ATPgammaS and releases a stable heteroduplex upon removal of the RecA protein. Under identical conditions, strand exchange between two DNA hairpins is incomplete and generates a nascent heteroduplex that rapidly dissociates when the RecA protein is denatured. Since presynaptic filament formation does not appear to melt either type of hairpin, we propose that exchange occurs between homologously aligned duplexes that are extended and unwound within a RecA filament. The first reaction provides a mechanism for gene targeting by chimeric double-hairpin oligonucleotides while the second reaction explains the ability of the RecA protein to transiently align double-stranded DNA molecules.     

Regulation of RecA protein binding to DNA by opposing effects of ATP and ADP on inter-domain contacts: analysis by urea-induced unfolding of wild-type and C-terminal truncated RecA

RecA protein requires ATP and its hydrolysis to ADP to complete the DNA strand-exchange reaction. We investigated how the nucleotides activate RecA by examining their effect on urea-induced unfolding, which could reflect domain-domain contact of protein. RecA is folded into three continuous domains: the N-terminal, central and C-terminal domains. The fluorescence of tyrosine residues, which lie mainly in the central domain, was modified in 1-3 M urea, while the red shift of fluorescence peak of the tryptophan residues located in the C-terminal domain occurred only in 3-6 M urea. Thus, the C-terminal domain of RecA is unfolded after the central part unfolds. The change in intensity of tryptophan fluorescence without a large shift in the peak at low concentrations of urea suggests that there are weak interactions between the central and C-terminal domains. This is supported by our observation that RecA protein lacking the C-terminal tail unfolded at lower concentrations of urea than the entire RecA, and with clear transitions, unlike the entire RecA. ATP and its unhydrolyzable analog (ATPgammaS), which enhance the binding of RecA to DNA, facilitated the urea-induced change in RecA tryptophan fluorescence, while ADP, an antagonist of ATP, prevented the change. ATP probably weakens the domain-domain contact and facilitates the DNA binding, while ADP stabilizes the contact and inhibits it. Supporting this conclusion, the binding of RecA lacking the C-terminal tail to DNA was not inhibited by ADP, while that of the intact RecA was.     

Regulation of bacterial RecA protein function

The RecA protein is a recombinase functioning in recombinational DNA repair in bacteria. RecA is regulated at many levels. The expression of the recA gene is regulated within the SOS response. The activity of the RecA protein itself is autoregulated by its own C-terminus. RecA is also regulated by the action of other proteins. To date, these include the RecF, RecO, RecR, DinI, RecX, RdgC, PsiB, and UvrD proteins. The SSB protein also indirectly affects RecA function by competing for ssDNA binding sites. The RecO and RecR, and possibly the RecF proteins, all facilitate RecA loading onto SSB-coated ssDNA. The RecX protein blocks RecA filament extension, and may have other effects on RecA activity. The DinI protein stabilizes RecA filaments. The RdgC protein binds to dsDNA and blocks RecA access to dsDNA. The PsiB protein, encoded by F plasmids, is uncharacterized, but may inhibit RecA in some manner. The UvrD helicase removes RecA filaments from RecA. All of these proteins function in a network that determines where and how RecA functions. Additional regulatory proteins may remain to be discovered. The elaborate regulatory pattern is likely to be reprised for RecA homologues in archaeans and eukaryotes.     

General mechanism for RecA protein binding to duplex DNA

RecA protein binding to duplex DNA occurs by a multi-step process. The tau analysis, originally developed to examine the binding of RNA polymerase to promoter DNA, is adapted here to study two kinetically distinguishable reaction segments of RecA-double stranded (ds) DNA complex formation in greater detail. One, which is probably a rapid preequilibrium in which RecA protein binds weakly to native dsDNA, is found to have the following properties: (1) a sensitivity to pH, involving a net release of approximately one proton; (2) a sensitivity to salts; (3) little or no dependence on temperature; (4) little or no dependence on DNA length. The second reaction segment, the rate-limiting nucleation of nucleoprotein filament formation accompanied by partial DNA unwinding, is found to have the following properties: (1) a sensitivity to pH, involving a net uptake of approximately three protons; (2) a sensitivity to salts; (3) a relatively large dependence on temperature, with an Arrhenius activation energy of 39 kcal mol(-1); (4) a sensitivity to DNA topology; (5) a dependence on DNA length. These results contribute to a general mechanism for RecA protein binding to duplex DNA, which can provide a rationale for the apparent preferential binding to altered DNA structures such as pyrimidine dimers and Z-DNA.     

Interaction of RecA protein with acidic phospholipids inhibits DNA-binding activity of RecA.

The RecA protein of Escherichia coli binds specifically to acidic phospholipids such as cardiolipin and phosphatidylglycerol. This binding appears to be affected by the presence of divalent cations such as Ca2+ and Mg2+. The interaction leads to the inhibition of RecA binding to at least two different conformations of DNA, single-stranded DNA and left-handed Z-DNA, thus suggesting that the phospholipids interact at the DNA-binding site of the RecA protein. Inclusion of a nucleotide cofactor [adenosine 5'-O-(gamma-thiotriphosphate)] in the reactions did not prevent the inhibition of DNA-binding activities of RecA protein by the phospholipids. The interaction of RecA protein with cardiolipin and phosphatidylglycerol, which represent two of the three major phospholipids of the E. coli membrane, may be physiologically important, as it provides a possible mechanism for the RecA-membrane association during the SOS response. These observations raise the possibility that the Z-DNA-binding activity of RecA protein is merely a manifestation of its phospholipid-binding property.     

Protein–protein interaction at crystal contacts

Packing contacts are crystal artifacts, yet they make use of the same forces that govern specific recognition in protein-protein complexes and oligomeric proteins. They provide examples of a nonspecific protein-protein interaction which can be compared to biologically relevant ones. We evaluate the number and size of pairwise interfaces in 152 crystal forms where the asymmetric unit contains a monomeric protein. In those crystal forms that have no element of 2-fold symmetry, we find that molecules form 8 to 10 pairwise interfaces. The total area of the surface buried on each molecule is large, up to 4400 Ų. Pairwise interfaces bury 200–1200 Ų, like interfaces generated at random in a computer simulation, and less than interfaces in protease-inhibitor or antigen-antibody complexes, which bury 1500 Ų or more. Thus, specific contacts occurring in such complexes extend over a larger surface than nonspecific ones. In crystal forms with 2-fold symmetry, pairwise interfaces are fewer and larger on average than in the absence of 2-fold symmetry. Some bury 1500–2500 Ų, like interfaces in oligomeric proteins, and create “crystal oligomers” which may have formed in the solution before crystallizing. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Inhibition of RecA protein by the Escherichia coli RecX protein: modulation by the RecA C terminus and filament functional state

The RecX protein is a potent inhibitor of RecA activities. We identified several factors that affect RecX-RecA interaction. The interaction is enhanced by the RecA C terminus and by significant concentrations of free Mg(2+) ion. The interaction is also enhanced by an N-terminal His(6) tag on the RecX protein. We conclude that RecX protein interacts most effectively with a RecA functional state designated A(o) and that the RecA C terminus has a role in modulating the interaction. We further identified a C-terminal point mutation in RecA protein (E343K) that significantly alters the interaction between RecA and RecX proteins.     

Studies of the interaction of RecA protein with DNA

Ethidium fluorescence assays were adapted for the rapid and sensitive detection of precA; in addition, fluorescence measurements on binding precA to linear, OC and CCC PM2 DNAs have enabled the stoichiometry of precA binding as well as the precA-induced unwinding angle of DNA to be determined. The stoichiometry of binding was independently confirmed by sedimentation analysis to be one precA molecule per 3 bp. The unwinding angle was also independently confirmed by measurements of fluorescence changes induced by the binding of precA to CCC DNA which was relaxed by topoisomerase to give a precA-induced unwinding angle of 51 degrees. Electron microscopy of OC DNA molecules which bound nonsaturating amounts of precA revealed that the length increase in DNA due to precA was approximately 55%. Finally, examination of negatively stained precA complexes with a variety of linear DNAs showed that the minor groove is the primary site of interaction for this protein.     

New recA mutations that dissociate the various RecA protein activities in Escherichia coli provide evidence for an additional role for RecA protein in UV mutagenesis.

To isolate strains with new recA mutations that differentially affect RecA protein functions, we mutagenized in vitro the recA gene carried by plasmid mini-F and then introduced the mini-F-recA plasmid into a delta recA host that was lysogenic for prophage phi 80 and carried a lac duplication. By scoring prophage induction and recombination of the lac duplication, we isolated new recA mutations. A strain carrying mutation recA1734 (Arg-243 changed to Leu) was found to be deficient in phi 80 induction but proficient in recombination. The mutation rendered the host not mutable by UV, even in a lexA(Def) background. Yet, the recA1734 host became mutable upon introduction of a plasmid encoding UmuD*, the active carboxyl-terminal fragment of UmuD. Although the recA1734 mutation permits cleavage of lambda and LexA repressors, it renders the host deficient in the cleavage of phi 80 repressor and UmuD protein. Another strain carrying mutation recA1730 (Ser-117 changed to Phe) was found to be proficient in phi 80 induction but deficient in recombination. The recombination defect conferred by the mutation was partly alleviated in a cell devoid of LexA repressor, suggesting that, when amplified, RecA1730 protein is active in recombination. Since LexA protein was poorly cleaved in the recA1730 strain while phage lambda was induced, we conclude that RecA1730 protein cannot specifically mediate LexA protein cleavage. Our results show that the recA1734 and recA1730 mutations differentially affect cleavage of various substrates. The recA1730 mutation prevented UV mutagenesis, even upon introduction into the host of a plasmid encoding UmuD* and was dominant over recA+. With respect to other RecA functions, recA1730 was recessive to recA+. This demonstrates that RecA protein has an additional role in mutagenesis beside mediating the cleavage of LexA and UmuD proteins.     

Intein-mediated affinity-fusion purification of the Escherichia coli RecA protein

The RecA protein of Escherichia coli plays important roles in homologous recombination, recombinational DNA repair, and SOS induction. Because its functions are conserved among the phylogenetic kingdoms, RecA investigations have provided a paradigm for understanding these biological processes. The RecA protein has been overproduced in E. coli and purified using a variety of purification schemes requiring multiple, time-intensive steps. The purification schemes share a dependence on appropriate RecA structure and/or function at one or more steps. In this report, we used a modified protein splicing element (intein) and a chitin-binding domain, fused to the C-terminus of RecA, to facilitate a one-step affinity purification of RecA protein without modification of the native protein sequence. Following the single chromatographic step, RecA protein that is greater than 95% physical purity at a concentration of greater than microM was obtained. The protein displays in vitro activities that are identical to those of protein isolated using classical procedures. The purification strategy described here promises to yield mutant RecA proteins in sufficient quantity for rigorous biophysical characterization without dependence on intrinsic RecA function.     

Epitopes and active sites of the RecA protein.

The RecA protein is indispensable for homologous genetic recombination in Escherichia coli. This protein alone promotes the ATP-dependent formation of homologous joint molecules and their processing in vitro. Through the use of a set of anti-RecA protein mouse monoclonal IgGs, we have been attempting to divide the whole process into elementary steps to determine the basic functions of the protein. In order to correlate the basic functions with the active sites on the recA polypeptide, we located the epitopes for the anti-RecA protein-IgGs on the recA polypeptide by means of immunoblotting experiments and an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay involving isolated proteolytic polypeptides or synthetic ones derived from various regions of the recA polypeptide. The epitopes for anti-RecA protein-IgGs ARM321 and ARM414, both of which are shown to inhibit the DNA-dependent ATP hydrolysis and the formation of homologous joints by the RecA protein, were found to be located between Thr89 and Glu127 and between Glu233 and Lys256, respectively, on the RecA polypeptide. IgG ARM193 had been shown to interfere with the protein-protein interaction between two RecA protein molecules, and ARM191 had been suggested to inhibit the binding of double-stranded DNA to the RecA protein. The epitopes for ARM193 and ARM191 were found to be located in a approximately 90-amino acid region at the C terminus. These results suggest the locations of the active sites and a functional core on the RecA polypeptide.