Long-distance dispersal vs vicariance: the origin and genetic diversity of alpine plants in the Spanish Sierra Nevada

Here, we investigated the origin and genetic diversity of four alpine plant species co-occurring in the Spanish Sierra Nevada and other high mountains in south-western Europe by analysis of amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLPs). In Kernera saxatilis, Silene rupestris and Gentiana alpina we found intraspecific phylogroups corresponding to mountain regions as predicted by the vicariance hypothesis. Moreover, genetic distances between Sierra Nevada and Pyrenees populations were always higher than those between populations from the Pyrenees and the south-western Alps/Massif Central. This suggests successive disruption of gene exchange between mountain ranges as postglacial climatic warming proceeded from south to north. In Papaver alpinum, our data indicate that a central Pyrenean population arose via long-distance dispersal from the Sierra Nevada, and that vicariant separation events between the Sierra Nevada and the Pyrenees and between the Pyrenees and the south-western Alps occurred simultaneously. Overall, Sierra Nevada populations of all species investigated here preserve unexpectedly high (or not exceptionally reduced) genetic diversity. This testifies to the important influence of long-term isolation, i.e. vicariance, on genetic diversity through fostering the accumulation of new mutations and/or the fixation of ancestral ones.     

An AFLP clock for absolute dating of shallow‐time evolutionary history – too good to be true?

A major drawback of Amplified Fragment Length Polymorphisms (AFLP) as genetic makers for phylogeographic studies is their lack of a temporal dimension. In a recent publication in Molecular Ecology, Kropf et al. (2009) proposed a molecular clock for AFLP. In this comment we evaluate the proposed approach both theoretically and empirically. A linear increase with time is a prerequisite to use a genetic distance as molecular clock. Testing the relationship between genetic distance and time in the data of Kropf et al. (2009) for linearity revealed that the relationship was in fact not linear for their pooled data, as well as for one of the three species analyzed. Also, the relationship was not linear in two new species, where divergence times could be inferred from macrofossils. When applying the proposed molecular clock to data from eight species, dates obtained were plausible in some cases, but very improbable in others. The suggested genetic distance was also influenced by intrapopulation genetic diversity, leading to a potential bias. In the future, investigations of AFLP mutation rates combined with phylogeographic modelling may contribute to adding a time scale to the understanding of AFLP data.     

Insights into the evolutionary history of Cervus (Cervidae,tribe Cervini) based on Bayesian analysis of mitochondrial marker sequences,with first indications for a new species

Molecular phylogeny and evolutionary history of Cervus, the most successful and widespread cervid genus, have been extensively addressed in Europe, fairly in eastern Asia, but scarcely in central Asia, where some populations have never been phylogenetically investigated with DNA‐based methods. Here, we applied a coalescent Bayesian approach to most Cervus taxa using complete mitochondrial cytochrome b gene and control region to provide a temporal framework for species differentiation and dispersal, with special emphasis on the central Asian populations from the Tarim Basin (C. elaphus bactrianus, C. elaphus yarkandensis) and Indian Kashmir (C. elaphus hanglu) aiming at assessing their phylogenetic and phylogeographic patterns. Red deer (C. elaphus), wapiti (C. canadensis) and sika deer (C. nippon) are confirmed as highly differentiated taxa, with genetic distances, divergence times and phylogenetic positions compatible with the rank of species. Similarly, the red deer of the Tarim group, hitherto considered as subspecies of C. elaphus, showed a comparable pattern of genetic distinction in the phylogeny and, according to our results, are thus worthy of being raised to the species level. The systematic position of the endangered red deer from Indian Kashmir is assessed here for the first time, and implications for its conservation are also outlined. Based on phylogeny and divergence time estimates, we propose a novel evolutionary pattern for the genus Cervus during the Mio/Pliocene, in the light of palaeo‐climatological information.