Delineation of spontaneous erythrocyte autoantibody responses of NZB and other strains of mice.

Four anti-erythrocyte autoantibody responses (anti-X, anti-HB, anti-HOL, and anti-I) that occur spontaneously in mice have been characterized with regard to antigenic specificities, predominant immunoglobulin class, and pathogenetic importance. Each autoantibody response exhibits specificity for an independent erythrocyte membrane autoantigen (X, HB, HOL, or I) or a soluble analogue (SEA-X or SEA-HB) present in the plasma. The anti-X response, unique to NZB mice, is directed to a normally exposed murine erythrocyte autoantigen, whereas the anti-HB response is directed to a cryptic erythrocyte autoantigen exposed by limited enzymatic cleavage of the membrane. The anti-I response also is directed to a cryptic but distinct autoantigen, and anti-HOL autoantibodies react with an erythrocyte autoantigen located at the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane. Analysis of the predominant immunoglobulin class of each of the autoantibodies has demonstrated that anti-HB and anti-I antibodies are predominantly of IgM class, whereas anti-X and anti-HOL antibodies are IgG immunoblobulins. Only anti-X and anti-HB autoantibodies are recovered from Coombs' positive erythrocytes from NZB mice and erythrocytes with surface C3 are detected only in NZB mice greater than 9 months of age. These data suggest that only the anti-X and anti-HB responses are pathogenetically implicated in the autoimmune hemolytic anemia of NZB mice.     

The presence of autoantibodies specific for NZB serum factors in adult NZB mice and the establishment of monoclonal autoantibodies against these humoral factors

Humoral factors in serum of young NZB mice enhance maturation of B-lymphocyte precursors in vitro. A blot ELISA assay identified autoantibodies against the serum factors. NZB-SFs (designated NZB-SF alpha, pI 3.5-4.0, and NZB-SF beta, pI 7.8) were purified by sequential steps. Both had a molecular weight (MW) of approximately 23,000 in SDS-PAGE. NZB mice develop autoantibodies against NZB-SFs by 2 months of age; titers increased progressively with age. Non-autoimmune-prone mice did not produce autoantibodies against NZB-SFs. We then developed two hybridoma clones, IIC1C1 and IIC1M4, which produce monoclonal autoantibodies against NZB-SF alpha and NZB-SF beta, respectively. Both IgM autoantibodies could be affinity purified with a column of CNBr-Sepharose 4B gel conjugated with anti-mouse IgM antibody. Neither IIC1C1 nor IIC1M4 abolished bioactivity of recombinant mouse IL-1 alpha, human IL-1, mouse, rat, or human IL-2, mouse IL-3, or colony-stimulating factor. Neither antibody reacted to recombinant mouse IL-1 alpha, IL-4, TNF alpha, or IFN gamma in blot ELISA assays. Monoclonal autoantibodies IIC1C1 and IIC1M4 were used to purify NZB-SFs. SDS-PAGE of the affinity-purified NZB-SFs revealed bands of 23 and 60 kDa, and proteins extracted from the bands were reactive to our monoclonal autoantibodies.     

Natural thymocytotoxic autoantibodies in autoimmune and normal mice.

Natural thymocytotoxic autoantibodies (NTA) were found in all mouse strains. Among those strains that show autoimmune syndromes resembling human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), the NZB and NZBxNZW had high levels of NTA, the BXSB had moderate levels, and the MRL/1 and MRL/n had very low levels. In addition, some normal strains had high levels, sometimes even higher than the autoimmune strains. The NTA were mostly IgM and were present, but not concentrated, in the cryoprecipitates of teh autoimmune mouse strains. In most strains, they were directed toward an antigen shared by thymocytes and brain. The failure to find high levels of NTA in all autoimmune mouse strains, as well as the finding of very high levels in some normal strains, make it unlikely that such auto-antibodies are a fundametnal etiologic factor in all murine SLE.     

V region sequences of anti-DNA and anti-RNA autoantibodies from NZB/NZW F1 mice

The V region sequences of two anti-DNA (A52, D42) and two anti-RNA (D44, D444) autoantibodies, derived from lupus prone NZB/NZW F1 female mice, were determined by mRNA sequencing. The sequences had the following features: 1) there was no clear sequence relationship between anti-DNA and anti-RNA antibodies; 2) there were no major similarities between any of the L chain sequences and each VL gene segment belonged to a different mouse VK subgroup; 3) the H chains of the two anti-RNA antibodies showed closely related sequences of VH gene segments and very similar third complementarity determining regions (CDR3); 4) the H chains of the two anti-DNA antibodies had VH segments belonging to different VH gene families but had a unique and similar combination of D segments and junctional sequences, suggesting a common recognition element for Ag and/or for idiotypic regulation in the H chain CDR3; and 5) the VH gene segment of one anti-DNA antibody (D42) was found to be very similar to the VH gene segment of a CBA mouse hybridoma antibody (6G6) which binds to the environmental Ag phosphocholine. The three-dimensional structure of the Fv-region of the anti-DNA antibody (D42) was modeled by computer and a stretch of poly(dT), ssDNA was docked to a cleft in the antibody combining site, formed by the three H chain CDR and by CDR1 and CDR3 of the L chain. The cleft is characterized by a preponderance of arginine and tyrosine residues, lining both the walls and base of the cleft.     

Preferential reactivity of autoantibodies in murine lupus NZB mice to neuraminidase-treated monosialogangliosides on B cells of mouse spleen

When analyzed by flow cytometry, reactivity of IgM autoantibodies in sera from NZB mice to spleen B cells, but not to T cells, from BALB/c mice was remarkably increased after treatment of the cells with Vibrio cholerae neuraminidase. By TLC immunostaining with the antibodies, neither neutral nor acidic glycosphingolipids from both BALB/c and NZB mouse spleens were found to be reactive, but after neuraminidase treatment of the TLC plate, prior to the immunostaining, three components became reactive. All of the reactive glycosphingolipids were found to carry a single sialic acid residue and were at a concentration less than 1.3% of the total lipid-bound sialic acids. Their mobilities on TLC plate were close to those of IV3 NeuAcnLc4Cer, IV3 NeuAcII3 NeuAcGg4Cer, and IV3 NeuAcII3 NeuAc2Gg4Cer. In addition, the monosialogangliosides, which became reactive with the autoantibodies after neuraminidase treatment, were found to be predominantly distributed on B cells from BALB/c mice spleen, but not on T cells by TLC immunostaining. These studies demonstrate that the majority of IgM autoantibodies to spleen lymphocytes in sera from NZB mice might react preferentially to terminal sugar residues of three new glycosphingolipids masked by a single sialic acid on B cells, but not on T cells.     

Splenocytes from NZB mice exhibit spontaneously high rates of fusion compared to control strains

A previous report (G. E. Woloschak and D. Senitzer, submitted for publication) has demonstrated that mitogen-stimulated splenocytes fuse at a much higher frequency than untreated splenocytes as measured by the fusion index (a calculation of the number of nuclei in fused cells vs the total number of nuclei). A measurement of the fusion indices of NZB spleen cells provides results markedly different from those observed with splenocytes from control strains of mice—NZB spleen cells exhibit a spontaneously high fusion index. In this assay, they spontaneously display the same fusing capacity as that observed in cultures of mitogen-treated spleen cells from control strains of mice. This elevated fusion index is not affected by treatment with anti-Thy-1.2 and complement, but is abrogated by treatment with anti-immunoglobulin serum and complement. This suggests that a B cell is responsible for the high fusion index of NZB splenocytes. This high fusion index is present when using splenocytes from both male and female mice in the fusion assay, and can be observed using spleen cells from NZB mice as young as 12 days. This appears to be the result of a spontaneous polyclonal B-cell activation in NZB mice.     

Genetic studies in NZB mice. II. Hyperdiploidy in the spleen of NZB mice and their hybrids.

The presence of hyperdiploidy was studied in New Zealand black (NZB) mice and the progeny of NZB X DBA/2 crosses and backcrosses. Hyperdiploidy was observed in the spleens of a majority of NZB mice but not in DBA/2 mice at 1 year of age. In crosses of NZB with the DBA/2 strain, hyperploidy was observed only in backcrosses to NZB. Hyperdiploidy appeared to be determined by a recessivley inherited trait and was not related to the presence of other immunological abnormalities, including splenomegaly, hypergammaglobulinemia, and spontaneous antibodies cytotoxic for T cells and reactive with single-stranded DNA. Abnormal cells were not present in Concanavalin A-stimulated 48-h spleen cultures. There was no difference in the in vitro sister chromatid exchange rate between the autoimmune NZB strain and the non-autoimmune DBA/2 strain. Identification of NZB chromosomes by banding analysis showed that chromosomes 15 and 17 were frequently present in more than two copies in hyperdiploid spleen cells. NZB chromsomes also had reduced C-banding in an autosomal pair. These studies indicate that chromosomal abnormalities which occur in NZB mice may be useful as genetic and cytogenetic markers.     

A pathogenic monoclonal antibody, G8, is characteristic of antierythrocyte autoantibodies from Coombs'-positive NZB mice.

With age, NZB mice develop anti-RBC autoantibodies resulting in the development of autoimmune hemolytic anemia. We now have evidence that this spontaneous autoantibody response consists of antibodies that are similar in specificity and Id expression to a pathogenic autoantibody (G8) that was cloned from an autoimmune NZB mouse. Similar to autoantibodies eluted from Coombs'-positive mouse E (MRBC), the G8 mAb recognizes native (unmodified) MRBC but not RBC from other species. Interestingly, G8 and four additional mAb bind with a higher titer to bromelain-treated MRBC than to native MRBC. Nucleotide sequence analysis reveals, however, that unlike "natural" antibodies that react solely with bromelain-MRBC, G8 is encoded by a J558 VH gene and a V kappa 12,13 L-chain gene. Thus G8 is clearly distinct from antibodies to bromelain-MRBC which are encoded by unrelated V genes. Instead, the sequence of the G8 VH chain was found to be nearly identical to that of an anti-DNA mAb derived from an MRL-lpr/lpr mouse. The results suggest Coombs'-positive autoantibodies from NZB mice are not derived from "natural" antibodies, but rather, consist of a restricted set of autoantibodies expressing the G8 IdX.     

Culture and characterization of thymic epithelium from autoimmune NZB and NZB/W mice

Autoimmune NZB and NZB/W mice display early abnormalities in thymus histology, T cell development, and mature T cell function. Abnormalities in the subcapsular/medullary thymic epithelium (TE) can also be inferred from the early disappearance of thymulin from NZB. It has also been reported that NZB thymic epithelial cells do not grow in culture conditions that support the growth of these cells from other strains of mice. In order to study the contribution of TE to the abnormal T cell development and function in NZB and NZB/W mice, we have devised a culture system which supports the growth of TE cells from these mice. The method involves the use of culture vessels coated with extracellular matrix produced by a rat thymic epithelial cell line. TEA3A1, and selective low-calcium, low-serum medium. In addition TEA3A1 cells have been used as an antigen to generate monoclonal antibodies specific for subcapsular/medullary TE. These antibodies, as well as others already available, have been used to show that the culture conditions described here select for cells displaying subcapsular/medullary TE markers, whereas markers for cortical TE and macrophages are absent.     

Specificity of antierythrocyte autoantibodies secreted by a NZB-derived hybridoma and NZB peritoneal cells

The specificity of monoclonal IgM antierythrocyte autoantibody produced by a NZB-derived hybridoma and the specificity of autoantibodies produced by uninduced NZB peritoneal cells in culture were determined. Supernatant fluids from cultures of hybridoma and peritoneal cells reacted in direct hemagglutination assays with bromelin-treated mouse erythrocytes, and, to a lesser extent, with sheep red blood cells; no agglutination was observed with intact mouse red blood cells or human O⁺ erythrocytes. These results suggest the presence of previously characterized anti-HB, but not anti-X or cold reactive autoantibodies, with a cross-reaction between antigenic constituents on sheep and bromelin-treated mouse erythrocytes. Specificity was affirmed by neutralization of agglutination or of direct hemolysis of bromelin-treated mouse erythrocytes with partially purified SEA-HB, the soluble plasma analog of the erythrocyte-bound HB autoantigen. Plaque formation in direct plaque-forming cell assays by both hybridoma and peritoneal cells was specifically inhibited by SEA-HB. These results demonstrate that NZB-derived hybridoma as well as NZB peritoneal cells secrete anti-HB autoantibody, an autoantibody that spontaneously appears in the serum of NZB as well as other strains of mice.     

Lupus prone (SWR x NZB)F1 mice produce potentially nephritogenic autoantibodies inherited from the normal SWR parent

The incidence of nephritis in autoimmune NZB mice is low, but when they are crossed with normal SWR mice, almost 100% of the female F1 hybrids (SNF1) develop lethal glomerulonephritis. To define the contribution of the normal SWR strain to the development of nephritis, we analyzed 65 monoclonal anti-DNA autoantibodies derived from SNF1 mice and compared them with those obtained from the NZB parent. The majority of the SNF1-derived anti-DNA antibodies were IgG and cationic in charge. By contrast, 77% of the NZB-derived antibodies were IgM. Moreover, all three NZB-derived IgG anti-DNA antibodies were anionic. The cationic property of the SNF1-derived IgG autoantibodies was not restricted to any particular antigenic specificity pattern or IgG subclass, nor was there a preference for the allotype of either parent. However, we identified a set of highly cationic (pI at 8.2 to 8.8 pH) IgG2b anti-DNA antibodies from SNF1 hybrids that had the SWR allotype. Isoelectric focusing of intact antibodies and isolated heavy and light chains showed that the highly cationic charge of these antibodies was determined by the variable regions of their heavy chains. Because IgG anti-DNA antibodies with cationic charge are especially pathogenic, those antibodies bearing the allotype of the normal SWR parent may account for the high incidence of severe nephritis in the F1 hybrids. The results indicate that pathogenic autoantibodies, which are encoded by genes of the nonautoimmune SWR parent, are expressed in the SNF1 mice due to some cellular and genetic regulatory influence of the NZB parent.     

Distribution of anti-histone-antibody-secreting cells in NZB/NZW mice

Using a histone-specific plaque assay, we examined anti-histone-antibody (AHA) production at the organ level in the autoimmune NZB/NZW strain. The spleen had the highest absolute numbers of AHA-secreting cells. High percentages of immunoglobulin-secreting cells producing AHA were characteristic of spleen and bone marrow but not lymph node. AHA-secreting cells were detected in NZB/NZW mice with elevated serum activity but not in mice with normal serum levels. Serum AHA activity correlated with the number of AHA-secreting cells in the spleen but not with the total number of immunoglobulin-secreting cells in the spleen nor with the total serum immunoglobulin level. These findings concerning the organ distribution of AHA-secreting cells contrast with results of other investigators studying autoantibodies of other specificities. Furthermore, our results suggest that AHA production does not solely result from a generalized increase in total immunoglobulin synthesis present in NZB/NZW mice.     

Genetic control of the natural killer cell activity in SJL and other strains of mice

Murine natural killer (NK) cell activity against lymphoma targets can be classified into three major functional phenotypes, i.e., low, inducible, and high, according to the levels of endogeneous activity and the extent of augmentation by interferon (IFN) or IFN inducers, as previously described. The prototype strains identifying these three phenotypes are SJL, A.SW, and B10.S, respectively, all bearing the H-2s haplotype. In the present study, the genetic basis of the low phenotype of SJL mice was examined further. F1 hybrid offspring of crosses between SJL and a strain with the high NK phenotype (B10.S, B10.D2, B10, C3H/HeN, or D1.LP) invariably expressed the high NK phenotype, indicating recessiveness of the low phenotype. Crosses between SJL and another low NK strain, such as A/J, A/HeN, or I/St, resulted in offspring of either the inducible or the high NK phenotype. Such genetic complementation between the low NK pairs indicates that the low phenotype of SJL and that of the other strains have different genetic bases. F1 hybrid mice between SJL and an inducible strain, A/WySn, were inducible, but those between SJL and the second inducible strain, A.SW, had the high NK phenotype. Thus, the congenic A/WySn and A.SW have distinct genotypes resulting in the same inducible phenotype. According to analyses of the segregating offspring from backcrosses of (SJL X B10.S)F1 mice to SJL, a single gene difference is responsible for the low endogenous level of NK activity in SJL as opposed to the high endogenous level in B10.S, and that the difference in three genes accounts for the poor responsiveness of NK cells to IFN in SJL mice. Studies of the two congenic lines of SJL, i.e., SJL-Igha and SJL-nu, indicated that the Igh locus is irrelevant for the low NK phenotype of SJL, but the nu locus clearly is relevant; SJL mice homozygous for the nu allele were phenotypically inducible in contrast to the nu/+ or +/+ mice which are low. The nu gene homozygosity rendered SJL mice responsive to IFN, not only in NK activity against lymphomas but also in ADCC activity against antibody-coated lymphoma cells.     

Comparison between autoantibodies arising during Trypanosoma cruzi infection in mice and natural autoantibodies

The autoantibodies induced in (C57BL/6 x BALB/c)F1 mice during Trypanosoma cruzi (CL strain) infection were analyzed and compared with natural autoantibodies present in healthy mice. Mice were killed at intervals after infection and their sera were tested by enzyme immunoassay against a panel of self- and non-self-Ag: actin, myoglobin, myosin, tubulin, DNA, and TNP-OVA. The level of IgM and IgG autoantibodies against all Ag started to increase from day 15 until 6 wk after the parasite infection. The high level of all autoantibodies persisted 3 mo postinfection, and 1 yr later, half of the mice still had elevated levels of IgM and IgG autoantibodies, particularly antitubulin IgG antibodies. IgM and IgG were isolated from pools of normal and infected mouse sera and their binding capacity to all Ag was compared. The titers of infected mouse sera were increased and the slopes of both IgM and IgG binding curves of autoantibodies to actin, myosin, and tubulin were greater than those of control mouse sera, indicating higher affinities. The average dissociation constant of the IgG2a autoantibody to mouse tubulin was 5 times lower than that of natural antitubulin IgG2a antibodies. Furthermore, absorption of the IgG from infected mouse sera onto a tubulin immunoadsorbent removed half the reactivity with tubulin and also with myosin, actin and parasite extracts. The eluted antibodies bound the same Ag. When IgG were further analyzed by Western blot on proteolytic fragments of tubulin, we found that antibodies from both groups bound to the same broad spectrum of polypeptide bands. However, additional fragments were recognized by antibodies from infected mice. All these results indicate that the autoantibodies naturally present in mice are significantly affected after infection with T. cruzi, in quantity as well as in specificity and affinity.