A pH-dependent conformational change, rather than the chemical step, appears to be rate-limiting in the hammerhead ribozyme cleavage reaction.

We have investigated the chemical basis for a previously observed 7.8 A conformational change in the hammerhead ribozyme that positions the substrate for in-line attack. We have found that the conformational change can only be observed at or above pH 8.5 (in the presence of Co(2+)) and requires the presence of an ionizable 2'-OH at the cleavage site, and note that this observed apparent pK(a) of 8.5 for the conformational change is within experimental error (+/-0.5) of the previously reported apparent kinetic pK(a) of 8.5 for the hammerhead ribozyme in the presence of Co(2+). We have solved two crystal structures of hammerhead ribozymes having 2'-OCH(3) or 2'-F substitutions at the cleavage site and have found that these will not undergo a conformational change equivalent to that observed for the hammerhead ribozyme having an unmodified attacking nucleophile under otherwise identical conditions. We have also characterized the kinetics of cleavage in the crystal. In addition to verifying that the particular sequence of RNA that we crystallized cleaves faster in the crystal than in solution, we also find that the extent of cleavage in the crystal is complete, unlike in solution where this and most other hammerhead ribozyme substrates are cleaved only to about 70 % completion. The initial cleavage rate in the crystal obeys the expected log-linear relation between cleavage-rate and pH with a slope of 0.7, as has been observed for other hammerhead ribozyme sequences in solution, indicating that in both the crystal and in solution the pH-dependent step is rate-limiting. However, the cleavage rate in the crystal is biphasic, with the most dramatic distinction between initial (slower) and final (faster) phases appearing at pH 6.0. The initial phase corresponds to the pH-dependent cleavage rate observed in solution, but the second, faster phase is roughly pH-independent and closely parallels the cleavage rate observed at pH 8 (0.4/minute). This result is particularly remarkable because it entails that the rapidly cleaving phase at pH 6 is comparable to the cleavage rate for the fastest cleaving hammerhead ribozymes at pH 6. Based upon these observations, we conclude that the pH-dependent conformational change is the rate-determining step under standard conditions for the hammerhead ribozyme self-cleavage reaction, and that an ionizable 2'-proton at cleavage site is required for this conformational change. We further hypothesize that deprotonation of the cleavage-site 2'-oxygen drives this conformational change.     

The Global Conformation of an Active Hammerhead RNA during the Process of Self-cleavage

The RNA “hammerhead” domain is a small element of secondary structure found in the genomes of certain plant pathogens. It possesses a core of conserved sequence at the conjunction of three helix stems, and is capable of undergoing self-cleavage in the presence of divalent cations. Both crystallographic and solution studies suggest that the domain is highly structured, with the three stems assuming a Y-shaped global conformation; however, such studies have employed either RNA analogues that were catalytically inactive, or conditions of temperature and pH for which rates of self-cleavage are slow. Thus, it was unknown whether such species represented the principal conformers during the cleavage process itself. In order to address this issue, a series of time- resolved, transient electric birefringence measurements was conducted in an effort to define the global conformation of an RNA hammerhead in real time throughout the process of self-cleavage. The current study demonstrates that the angular relationship between the two helices that flank the cleavage center is essentially unchanged between the pre-cleavage and post-cleavage forms. Moreover, despite the fact that at least one kinetic intermediate is formed during the self-cleavage reaction, there is no evidence for the existence of a significant population of intermediates with altered global conformation during cleavage. Thus, any conformational isomerism that may occur is likely to be relatively localized to the active center. Finally, it was observed that sequence elements lying outside of the conserved region, at the base of stem I, influence interhelix geometry. The current results are consistent with a structural model in which the active center possesses similar conformations pre-cleavage and post-cleavage. Such a model would help to explain the significant rate of reversal of the cleavage reaction (self-ligation).     

Design, characterization and testing of tRNA3Lys-based hammerhead ribozymes

A hammerhead ribozyme targeted against the HIV-1 env coding region was expressed as part of the anticodon loop of human tRNA3Lys without sacrificing tRNA stability or ribozyme catalytic activity. These tRNA-ribozymes were isolated from a library which was designed to contain linkers (sequences connecting the ribozyme to the anticodon loop) of random sequence and variable length. The ribozyme target site was provided in cis during selection and in trans during subsequent characterization. tRNA-ribozymes that possessed ideal combinations of linkers were expected to recognize the cis target site more freely and undergo cleavage. The cleaved molecules were isolated, cloned and characterized. Active tRNA-ribozymes were identified and the structural features conducive to cleavage were defined. The selected tRNA-ribozymes were stable, possessed cleavage rates lower or similar to the linear hammerhead ribozyme, and could be transcribed by an extract containing RNA polymerase III. Retroviral vectors expressing tRNA-ribozymes were tested in a human CD4+ T cell line and were shown to inhibit HIV-1 replication. These tRNA3Lys-based hammerhead ribozymes should therefore prove to be valuable for both basic and applied research. Special application is sought in HIV-1 or HIV-2 gene therapy.     

Satellite cereal yellow dwarf virus-RPV (satRPV) RNA requires a douXble hammerhead for self-cleavage and an alternative structure for replication.

The 110 nt hammerhead ribozyme in the satellite RNA of cereal yellow dwarf virus-RPV (satRPV RNA) folds into an alternative conformation that inhibits self-cleavage. This alternative structure comprises a pseudoknot with base-pairing between loop (L1) and a single-stranded bulge (L2a), which are located in hammerhead stems I and II, respectively. Mutations that disrupt this base-pairing, or otherwise cause the ribozyme to more closely resemble a canonical hammerhead, greatly increase self-cleavage. In a more natural multimeric sequence context containing the full-length satRPV RNA and two copies of the hammerhead, wild-type RNA cleaves much more efficiently than in the 110 nt context. Mutations in the upstream hammerhead, including a knock-out in the catalytic core, affect cleavage at the downstream cleavage site, indicating that multimers of satRPV RNA cleave via a double hammerhead. The double hammerhead includes base-pairing between two copies of the L1 sequence which extends stem I. Disruption of L1-L1 base-pairing slows cleavage of the multimer. L1-L2a base-pairing is required for efficient replication of satRPV RNA in oat protoplasts. Mutations that affect self-cleavage of the multimer do not correlate with replication efficiency, indicating that the ability to self-cleave is not a primary determinant of replication. We present a replication model in which multimeric satRPV RNA folds into alternative conformations that cannot form in the monomer. One potential metastable intermediate conformation involves L1-L2a base-pairing that may facilitate formation of the double hammerhead. However, we conclude that L1-L2a also performs some other essential function in the satRPV RNA replication cycle, because the L1-L2a base-pairing is more important than efficient self-cleavage for replication.     

In vitro selection of RNAs that undergo autolytic cleavage with Pb2+.

An in vitro selection method has been developed to obtain RNA molecules that specifically undergo autolytic cleavage reactions by Pb2+ ion. The method utilizes a circular RNA intermediate which is regenerated following the cleavage reaction to allow amplification and multiple cycles of selection. Pb2+ is known to catalyze a specific cleavage reaction between U17 and G18 of yeast tRNA(Phe). Starting from pools of RNA molecules which have a random distribution of sequences at nine or ten selected positions in the sequence of yeast tRNA(Phe), we have isolated many RNA molecules that undergo rapid and specific self-cleavage with Pb2+ at a variety of different sites. Terminal truncation experiments suggest that most of these self-cleaving RNA molecules do not fold like tRNA. However, two of the variants are cleaved rapidly with Pb2+ at U17 even though they lack the highly conserved nucleotides G18 and G19. Both specific mutations and terminal truncation experiments suggest that the D and T loops of these two variants interact in a manner similar to that of tRNA(Phe) despite the absence of the G18U55 and G19C56 tertiary interactions. A model for an alternate tertiary interaction involving a U17U55 pair is presented. This model may be relevant to the structure of about 100 mitochondrial tRNAs that also lack G18 and G19. The selection method presented here can be directly applied to isolate catalytic RNAs that undergo cleavage in the presence of other metal ions, modified nucleotides, or sequence-specific nucleases.     

Autoproteolytic cleavage and activation of human acid ceramidase

Herein we report the mechanism of human acid ceramidase (AC; N-acylsphingosine deacylase) cleavage and activation. A highly purified, recombinant human AC precursor underwent self-cleavage into alpha and beta subunits, similar to other members of the N-terminal nucleophile hydrolase superfamily. This reaction proceeded with first order kinetics, characteristic of self-cleavage. AC self-cleavage occurred most rapidly at acidic pH, but also at neutral pH. Site-directed mutagenesis and expression studies demonstrated that Cys-143 was an essential nucleophile that was required at the cleavage site. Other amino acids participating in AC cleavage included Arg-159 and Asp-162. Mutations at these three amino acids prevented AC cleavage and activity, the latter assessed using BODIPY-conjugated ceramide. We propose the following mechanism for AC self-cleavage and activation. Asp-162 likely forms a hydrogen bond with Cys-143, initiating a conformational change that allows Arg-159 to act as a proton acceptor. This, in turn, facilitates an intermediate thioether bond between Cys-143 and Ile-142, the site of AC cleavage. Hydrolysis of this bond is catalyzed by water. Treatment of recombinant AC with the cysteine protease inhibitor, methyl methanethiosulfonate, inhibited both cleavage and enzymatic activity, further indicating that cysteine-mediated self-cleavage is required for ceramide hydrolysis.     

High-pressure analysis of a hammerhead ribozyme from Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid reveals two different populations of self-cleaving molecule

The activity of the full-length hammerhead ribozyme requires a tertiary interaction between its distal loops leading to the closure of the molecule and its stabilization in the active conformation. In this study, the conformational changes accompanying the cis-cleavage reaction of Chrysanthemum chlorotic mottle viroid hammerhead ribozyme were investigated by high-pressure experiments on the complete cleavage reaction. Two activation volumes (ΔV(≠)) were measured, pointing to the presence of two different populations of molecules corresponding to fast-cleaving and slow-cleaving ribozymes in the reaction mixture. The fast population, with a small ΔV(≠) of 2.6 mL·mol(-1), most likely represents molecules in the near-active conformation, whereas the slow population, with a larger ΔV(≠) of 11.6 mL·mol(-1 , represents molecules that need a larger conformational change to induce activity. In addition, pH-dependence experiments suggest that the group whose deprotonation is required for activity intervenes in the formation of the transition state or in the chemistry of the reaction, but not in the conformational change that precedes it.     

Probing the hammerhead ribozyme structure with ribonucleases.

Susceptibility to RNase digestion has been used to probe the conformation of the hammerhead ribozyme structure prepared from chemically synthesised RNAs. Less than about 1.5% of the total sample was digested to obtain a profile of RNase digestion sites. The observed digestion profiles confirmed the predicted base-paired secondary structure for the hammerhead. Digestion profiles of both cis and trans hammerhead structures were nearly identical which indicated that the structural interactions leading to self-cleavage were similar for both systems. Furthermore, the presence or absence of Mg2+ did not affect the RNase digestion profiles, thus indicating that Mg2+ did not modify the hammerhead structure significantly to induce self-cleavage. The base-paired stems I and II in the hammerhead structure were stable whereas stem III, which was susceptible to digestion, appeared to be an unstable region. The single strand domains separating the stems were susceptible to digestion with the exception of sites adjacent to guanosines; GL2.1 in the stem II loop and G12 in the conserved GAAAC sequence, which separates stems II and III. The absence of digestion at GL2.1 in the stem II hairpin loop of the hammerhead complex was maintained in uncomplexed ribozyme and in short oligonucleotides containing only the stem II hairpin region. In contrast, the G12 site became susceptible when the ribozyme was not complexed with its substrate. Overall the results are consistent with the role of Mg2+ in the hammerhead self-cleavage reaction being catalytic and not structural.     

Engineering a ribozyme cleavage-induced split fluorescent aptamer complementation assay

Hammerhead ribozymes are self-cleaving RNA molecules capable of regulating gene expression in living cells. Their cleavage performance is strongly influenced by intra-molecular loop–loop interactions, a feature not readily accessible through modern prediction algorithms. Ribozyme engineering and efficient implementation of ribozyme-based genetic switches requires detailed knowledge of individual self-cleavage performances. By rational design, we devised fluorescent aptamer-ribozyme RNA architectures that allow for the real-time measurement of ribozyme self-cleavage activity in vitro. The engineered nucleic acid molecules implement a split Spinach aptamer sequence that is made accessible for strand displacement upon ribozyme self-cleavage, thereby complementing the fluorescent Spinach aptamer. This fully RNA-based ribozyme performance assay correlates ribozyme cleavage activity with Spinach fluorescence to provide a rapid and straightforward technology for the validation of loop–loop interactions in hammerhead ribozymes.     

Artificial self-cleaving molecules consisting of a tRNA precursor and the catalytic RNA of RNase P.

We synthesized two types of chimeric RNAs between the catalytic RNA subunit of RNase P from Escherichia coli (M1 RNA) and a tRNA precursor (pre-tRNA); one had pre-tRNA at the 3' side to the M1 RNA (M1 RNA-pre-tRNA). The second had pre-tRNA at the 5' side of the M1 RNA (pre-tRNA-M1 RNA). Both molecules were self-cleaving RNAs. The self-cleavage of M1 RNA-pre-tRNA occurred at the normal site (5'-end of mature tRNA sequence) and proceeded under the condition of 10 mM Mg2+ concentration. This reaction at 10 mM Mg2+ was an intramolecular reaction (cis-cleavage), while, at 40 mM and 80 mM Mg2+, trans-cleavage partially occurred. The self-cleavage rate was strictly affected by the distance between the M1 RNA and the pre-tRNA in the molecule. The self-cleavage of pre-tRNA-M1 RNA occurred mainly at three sites within the mature tRNA sequence. This cleavage did not occur at 10 mM Mg2+. Use of M1 RNA-pre-tRNA molecule for the in vitro evolution of M1 RNA is discussed.     

Efficient ligation of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme from Schistosoma mansoni is the best characterized of the natural hammerhead ribozymes. Biophysical, biochemical, and structural studies have shown that the formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction between stems I and II alters the global folding, cleavage kinetics, and conformation of the catalytic core of this hammerhead, leading to a ribozyme that is readily cleaved under physiological conditions. This study investigates the ligation kinetics and the internal equilibrium between cleavage and ligation for the Schistosoma hammerhead. Single turnover kinetic studies on a construct where the ribozyme cleaves and ligates substrate(s) in trans showed up to 23% ligation when starting from fully cleaved products. This was achieved by an approximately 2000-fold increase in the rate of ligation compared to a minimal hammerhead without the loop-loop tertiary interaction, yielding an internal equilibrium that ranges from 2 to 3 at physiological Mg2+ ion concentrations (0.1-1 mM). Thus, the natural Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme is almost as efficient at ligation as it is at cleavage. The results here are consistent with a model where formation of the loop-loop tertiary interaction leads to a higher population of catalytically active molecules and where formation of this tertiary interaction has a much larger effect on the ligation than the cleavage activity of the Schistosoma hammerhead ribozyme.     

A catalytic 13-mer ribozyme.

A 13-mer oligoribonucleotide can act as a ribozyme for the specific self-cleavage of a 41-mer oligoribonucleotide substrate in the presence of Mg2+. The two sequences involved correspond to the self-cleavage hammerhead structure of the virusoid of lucerne transient streak virus. The Michaelis-menten kinetic parameters for the reaction were; Km 1.3 microM, Vmax 0.012 microM min-1, kcat 0.5 min-1. The 13-mer RNA is the smallest ribozyme so far reported. A DNA analogue of the 13-mer can not substitute for the RNA in the reaction.     

A kinetic model of the cleavage of permutational variants of the antigenomic HDV-ribozyme

The kinetic characteristics have been studied for noncircularly permuted variants of the human hepatitis delta virus (HDV) antigenomic ribozyme to find out the cause of the two-phase kinetics of the self-cleavage reaction. Different ways of reaction initiation, suboptimal conditions, and jumpwise changes of reaction conditions have been used, and the temperature dependences have been studied. A correlation has been shown between the apparent kinetic constant of the first reaction phase and the portion of the ribozyme molecules that self-cleaved during the first phase. Partial restoration of the initial reaction characteristics has been shown by the reinitiation of reaction being stopped after completing the first phase. On the basis of all the data obtained, a scheme of the self-cleavage reaction has been proposed including: (i) activation of the ribozyme with energy of 40-50 kcal/mol and a characteristic time of several deciminutes under optimal reaction conditions; (ii) fast and reversible reaction of the phosphodiester bond cleavage; (iii) reaction leading to isomerization of the 3',5'-phosphodiester bond to the 2',5' bond in the self-cleavage site with a characteristic activation time of tens of minutes; and (iv) practically irreversible conformational change leading to fixation of the cleavage by immobilization of the 5'-terminal nucleotide of the product in the center of the formed structure and displacement of the 3'-terminal nucleotide to the periphery. The latter process has a characteristic time of tens of minutes and a low activation energy.     

Alternative tertiary structure attenuates self-cleavage of the ribozyme in the satellite RNA of barley yellow dwarf virus.

A self-cleaving satellite RNA associated with barley yellow dwarf virus (sBYDV) contains a sequence predicted to form a secondary structure similar to catalytic RNA molecules (ribozymes) of the 'hammerhead' class (Miller et al., 1991, Virology 183, 711-720). However, this RNA differs from other naturally occurring hammerheads both in its very slow cleavage rate, and in some aspects of its structure. One striking structural difference is that an additional helix is predicted that may be part of an unusual pseudoknot containing three stacked helices. Nucleotide substitutions that prevent formation of the additional helix and favor the hammerhead increased the self-cleavage rate up to 400-fold. Compensatory substitutions, predicted to restore the additional helix, reduced the self-cleavage rate by an extent proportional to the calculated stability of the helix. Partial digestion of the RNA with structure-sensitive nucleases supported the existence of the proposed alternative structure in the wildtype sequence, and formation of the hammerhead in the rapidly-cleaving mutants. This tertiary interaction may serve as a molecular switch that controls the rate of self-cleavage and possibly other functions of the satellite RNA.     

Kinetic Self-Cleavage Models for Permuted Variants of the Antigenomic HDV Ribozyme

The kinetic characteristics have been studied for noncircularly permuted variants of the human hepatitis delta virus antigenomic ribozyme to find out the cause of the two-phase kinetics of the self-cleavage reaction. Different ways of reaction initiation, suboptimal conditions, and jumpwise changes of reaction conditions have been used, and the temperature dependences have been studied. A correlation has been shown between the apparent kinetic constant of the first reaction phase and the portion of the ribozyme molecules that self-cleaved during the first phase. Partial restoration of the initial reaction characteristics has been shown by the reinitiation of reaction being stopped after completing the first phase. On the basis of all the data obtained, a scheme of the self-cleavage reaction has been proposed including: (i) activation of the ribozyme with energy of 40–50 kcal/mol and a characteristic time of several deciminutes under optimal reaction conditions; (ii) fast and reversible reaction of the phosphodiester bond cleavage; (iii) reaction leading to isomerization of the 3",5"-phosphodiester bond to the 2",5" bond in the self-cleavage site with a characteristic activation time of tens of minutes; and (iv) practically irreversible conformational change leading to fixation of the cleavage by immobilization of the 5"-terminal nucleotide of the product in the center of the formed structure and displacement of the 3"-terminal nucleotide to the periphery. The latter process has a characteristic time of tens of minutes and a low activation energy.     

Evaluation of uranyl photocleavage as a probe to monitor ion binding and flexibility in RNAs

In order to evaluate uranyl photocleavage as a tool to identify and characterize structural and dynamic properties in RNA, we compared uranyl cleavage sites in five RNA molecules with known X-ray structures, namely the hammerhead and hepatitis delta virus ribozymes, the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron, as well as tRNA(Phe) and tRNA(Asp) from yeast. Uranyl photocleavage was observed at specific positions in all molecules investigated. In order to characterize the sites, photocleavage was performed in the absence and in increasing amounts of MgCl(2). Uranyl photocleavage correlates well with sites of low calculated accessibility, suggesting that uranyl ions bind in tight RNA pockets formed by close approach of phosphate groups. RNA foldings require ion binding, usually magnesium ions. Thus, upon the adoption of the native structure, uranyl ions can no longer bind well except in flexible and open to the solvent regions that can undergo induced-fit without disrupting the native fold. Uranyl photocleavage was compared to N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea and lead-induced cleavages in the context of the three-dimensional X-ray structures. Overall, the regions protected from ENU attack are sites of uranyl cleavage, indicating sites of low accessibility which can form ion binding sites. On the contrary, lead cleavages occur at flexible and accessible sites and correlate with the unspecific cleavages prevalent in dynamic and open regions. Applied in a magnesium-dependent manner, and only in combination with other backbone probing agents such as N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea, lead and Fenton cleavage, uranyl probing has the potential to reveal high-affinity metal ion environments, as well as regions involved in conformational transitions.     

Interaction between RNA molecules of a two-component trans analog of antigenomic HDV ribozyme

A study was made of the association of the RNA components forming a B:LS two-component rans analog of the antigenomic HDV ribozyme. The B:LS ribozyme differed from known trans ribozymes in the sizes and nucleotide sequences of its components (33 and 34 nt, respectively), the topology of its functional parts, and the lack of a very short cleavage product. Compared to the cis ribozyme, B:LS showed similar dependences on the reaction conditions (Mg²⁺ concentration, pH, temperature) and a similar biphasic kinetic curve of self-cleavage. The kinetic model of B:LS self-cleavage (available at www.cardio.ru/labgen/RZ_e.html) describes a possible cause of the biphasic kinetic curve as a change in the rate-limiting step of consecutive conformational transitions accompanying self-cleavage. Another possible cause is an interaction between the molecules involved in cleavage, i.e., multimerization of whole ribozyme molecules with their components or the reaction products. B:LS provides a convenient model for studying such interactions, since the mode of component binding allows generation of 1B:2LS and 2B:1LS complexes as well as complexes with the cleavage products. Nondenaturing PAGE was used to study the factors affecting association and dissociation of the ribozyme components. The possibility of interactions between the RNA components of the cis and trans ribozymes was demonstrated experimentally. It was shown that the ribozyme is capable of multimerization when LS is in excess over B and that the cleavage products are not significantly involved in this process. The results suggest intermolecular interactions for the cleavage of the natural cis ribozyme.