A hydrophobic gate in an ion channel: the closed state of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) is the prototypic member of the 'Cys-loop' superfamily of ligand-gated ion channels which mediate synaptic neurotransmission, and whose other members include receptors for glycine, gamma-aminobutyric acid and serotonin. Cryo-electron microscopy has yielded a three-dimensional structure of the nAChR in its closed state. However, the exact nature and location of the channel gate remains uncertain. Although the transmembrane pore is constricted close to its center, it is not completely occluded. Rather, the pore has a central hydrophobic zone of radius about 3 A. Model calculations suggest that such a constriction may form a hydrophobic gate, preventing movement of ions through a channel. We present a detailed and quantitative simulation study of the hydrophobic gating model of the nicotinic receptor, in order to fully evaluate this hypothesis. We demonstrate that the hydrophobic constriction of the nAChR pore indeed forms a closed gate. Potential of mean force (PMF) calculations reveal that the constriction presents a barrier of height about 10 kT to the permeation of sodium ions, placing an upper bound on the closed channel conductance of 0.3 pS. Thus, a 3 A radius hydrophobic pore can form a functional barrier to the permeation of a 1 A radius Na+ ion. Using a united-atom force field for the protein instead of an all-atom one retains the qualitative features but results in differing conductances, showing that the PMF is sensitive to the detailed molecular interactions.     

Time-resolved photolabeling by quinacrine azide of a noncompetitive inhibitor site of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in a transient, agonist-induced state

Local anesthetics and other noncompetitive inhibitors (NCIs) of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor, acting at sites other than the acetylcholine-binding sites, block channel opening and/or cation translation through the open channel. In order to characterize the NCI sites and to decide among possible mechanisms of NCI action, we have photolabeled the receptor in membrane from Torpedo electric tissue with the photolyzable NCI [3H]quinacrine azide ([3H]QA), using a continuous-flow, rapid-mixing device and millisecond-duration irradiation. Membrane, [3H]QA, and effectors were mixed, and, after delay times of 20 ms or greater, the mixture was irradiated for 2 ms, quenched, and collected. Brief exposure of the receptor to acetylcholine, but not to hexamethonium or d-tubocurarine, induced a state particularly susceptible to photoincorporation of [3H]QA. This acetylcholine-induced photoincorporation was exclusively into the alpha and beta chains of the receptor, peaked at 100-ms delay time, declined to 15% of maximum after delay times of minutes, and was blocked by the NCIs proadifen and histrionicotoxin. At 20-ms delay, the dependence of labeling by 2 microM [3H]QA on acetylcholine concentration was characterized by an apparent dissociation constant of about 15 microM and a Hill coefficient of 1. The kinetics of the development of susceptibility to photolabeling and the apparent lack of positive cooperativity in the effect of acetylcholine on this development suggest that the preferentially photolabeled state is a transient, rapidly developing, desensitized state, rather than an open-channel state.     

Examining the noncompetitive antagonist-binding site in the ion channel of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor in the resting state

3-Trifluoromethyl-3-(m-[(125)I]iodophenyl)diazirine ([(125)I]TID) has been shown to be a potent noncompetitive antagonist (NCA) of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Amino acids that contribute to the binding site for [(125)I]TID in the ion channel have been identified in both the resting and desensitized state of the AChR (White, B.H., and Cohen, J.B. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 15770-15783). To characterize further the structure of the NCA-binding site in the resting state channel, we have employed structural analogs of TID. The TID analogs were assessed by the following: 1) their ability to inhibit [(125)I]TID photoincorporation into the resting state channel; 2) the pattern, agonist sensitivity, and NCA inhibition of [(125)I]TID analog photoincorporation into AChR subunits. The addition of a primary alcohol group to TID has no demonstrable effect on the interaction of the compound with the resting state channel. However, conversion of the alcohol function to acetate, isobutyl acetate (TIDBIBA), or to trimethyl acetate leads to rightward shifts in the concentration-response curves for inhibition of [(125)I]TID photoincorporation into the AChR channel and a progressive reduction in the agonist sensitivity of [(125)I]TID analog photoincorporation into AChR subunits. Inhibition of [(125)I]TID analog photoincorporation by NCAs (e.g. tetracaine) as well as identification of the sites of [(125)I]TIDBIBA photoincorporation in the deltaM2 segment indicate a common binding locus for each TID analog. We conclude that relatively small additions to TID progressively reduce its ability to interact with the NCA site in the resting state channel. A model of the NCA site and resting state channel is presented.     

A conformational intermediate between the resting and desensitized states of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The structural changes induced in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor by two noncompetitive channel blockers, proadifen and phencyclidine, have been studied by infrared difference spectroscopy and using the conformationally sensitive photoreactive noncompetitive antagonist 3-(trifluoromethyl)-3-m-([(125)I]iodophenyl)diazirine. Simultaneous binding of proadifen to both the ion channel pore and neurotransmitter sites leads to the loss of positive markers near 1663, 1655, 1547, 1430, and 1059 cm(-)(1) in carbamylcholine difference spectra, suggesting the stabilization of a desensitized conformation. In contrast, only the positive markers near 1663 and 1059 cm(-)(1) are maximally affected by the binding of either blocker to the ion channel pore suggesting that the conformationally sensitive residues vibrating at these two frequencies are stabilized in a desensitized-like conformation, whereas those vibrating near 1655 and 1430 cm(-)(1) remain in a resting-like state. The vibrations at 1547 cm(-)(1) are coupled to those at both 1663 and 1655 cm(-)(1) and thus exhibit an intermediate pattern of band intensity change. The formation of a structural intermediate between the resting and desensitized states in the presence of phencyclidine is further supported by the pattern of 3-(trifluoromethyl)-3-m-([(125)I]iodophenyl)diazirine photoincorporation. In the presence of phencyclidine, the subunit labeling pattern is distinct from that observed in either the resting or desensitized conformations; specifically, there is a concentration-dependent increase in the extent of photoincorporation into the delta-subunit. Our data show that domains of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor interconvert between the resting and desensitized states independently of each other and suggest a revised model of channel blocker action that involves both low and high affinity agonist binding conformational intermediates.     

Desensitization of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor by diisopropylfluorophosphate

The interaction of diisopropylfluorophosphate (DFP) with the nicotinic acetylcholine (ACh) receptor of Torpedo electric organ was studied, using [³H]-phencyclidine ([³H]-PCP) as a reporter probe. Phencyclidine binds with different kinetics to resting, activated, and desensitized receptor conformations. Although DFP did not inhibit binding of [³H]-ACh or ¹²⁵I-α-bungarotoxin (BGT) to the receptor recognition sites and potentiated in a time-dependent manner [³H]-PCP binding to the receptor's high-affinity allosteric site, it inhibited the ACh or carbamylcholine-stimulated [³H]-PCP binding. This suggested that DFP bound to a third kind of site on the receptor and affected receptor conformation. Preincubation of the membranes with DFP increased the receptor's affinity for carbamylcholine by eightfold and raised the pseudo-first-order rate of [³H]-PCP binding to that of an agonist-desensitized receptor. Accordingly, it is suggested that DFP induces receptor desensitization by binding to a site that is distinct from the recognition or high-affinity noncompetitive sites.     

Modulation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor conformational state by free fatty acids and steroids

Steroids and free fatty acids (FFA) are noncompetitive antagonists of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR). Their site of action is purportedly located at the lipid-AChR interface, but their exact mechanism of action is still unknown. Here we studied the effect of structurally different FFA and steroids on the conformational equilibrium of the AChR in Torpedo californica receptor-rich membranes. We took advantage of the higher affinity of the fluorescent AChR open channel blocker, crystal violet, for the desensitized state than for the resting state. Increasing concentrations of steroids and FFA decreased the K(D) of crystal violet in the absence of agonist; however, only cis-unsaturated FFA caused an increase in K(D) in the presence of agonist. This latter effect was also observed with treatments that caused the opposite effects on membrane polarity, such as phospholipase A(2) treatment or temperature increase (decreasing or increasing membrane polarity, respectively). Quenching by spin-labeled fatty acids of pyrene-labeled AChR reconstituted into model membranes, with the label located at the gammaM4 transmembrane segment, disclosed the occurrence of conformational changes induced by steroids and cis-unsaturated FFA. The present work is a step forward in understanding the mechanism of action of this type of molecules, suggesting that the direct contact between exogenous lipids and the AChR transmembrane segments removes the AChR from its resting state and that membrane polarity modulates the AChR activation equilibrium by an independent mechanism.     

Activation of a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor.

We studied activation of the nicotinic acetylcholine (ACh) receptor on cells of a mouse clonal muscle cell line (BC3H1). We analyzed single-channel currents through outside-out patches elicited with various concentrations of acetylcholine (ACh), carbamylcholine (Carb) and suberyldicholine (Sub). Our goal is to determine a likely reaction scheme for receptor activation by agonist and to determine values of rate constants for transitions in that scheme. Over a wide range of agonist concentrations the open-time duration histograms are not described by single exponential functions, but are well-described by the sum of two exponentials, a brief-duration and a long-duration component. At high concentration, channel openings occur in groups and these groups contain an excess number of brief openings. We conclude that there are two open states of the ACh receptor with different mean open times and that a single receptor may open to either open state. The concentration dependence of the numbers of brief and long openings indicates that brief openings do not result from the opening of channels of receptors which have only one agonist molecule bound to them. Closed-time duration histograms exhibit a major brief component at low concentrations. We have used the method proposed by Colquhoun and Sakmann (1981) to analyze these brief closings and to extract estimates for the rates of channel opening (beta) and agonist dissociation (k-2). We find that this estimate of beta does not predict our closed-time histograms at high agonist concentration (ACh: 30-300 microM; Carb: 300-1,000 microM). We conclude that brief closings at low agonist concentrations do not result solely from transitions between the doubly-liganded open and the doubly-liganded closed states. Instead, we postulate the existence of a second closed-channel state coupled to the open state.     

Allosterically linked noncompetitive antagonist binding sites in the resting nicotinic acetylcholine receptor ion channel

Previous studies have established the presence of overlapping binding sites for the noncompetitive antagonists (NCAs) amobarbital, tetracaine, and 3-trifluoromethyl-3-(m-[(125)I]iodophenyl) diazirine ([(125)I]TID) within the ion channel of the Torpedo nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) in the resting state. These well-characterized NCAs and competitive radioligand binding and photolabeling experiments were employed to better characterize the interaction of the dissociative anesthetics ketamine and thienylcycloexylpiperidine (TCP) with the resting AChR. Our experiments yielded what appear to be conflicting results: (i) both ketamine and TCP potentiated [(125)I]TID photoincorporation into AChR subunits; and (ii) ketamine and TCP had very little effect on [(14)C]amobarbital binding. Nevertheless, (iii) both ketamine and TCP completely displaced [(3)H]tetracaine binding (K(i)s approximately 20.9 and 2.0 microM, respectively) by a mutually exclusive mechanism. To reconcile these results we propose that, in the resting ion channel, TCP and ketamine bind to a site that is spatially distinct from the TID and barbiturate locus, while tetracaine bridges both binding sites.     

Site specificity of agonist-induced opening and desensitization of the Torpedo californica nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Agonist-binding kinetics to the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) from Torpedo californica were measured using sequential-mixing stopped-flow fluorescence methods to determine the contribution of each individual site to agonist-induced opening and desensitization. Timed dansyl-C6-choline (DC6C) binding followed by its dissociation upon mixing with high, competing agonist concentrations revealed four kinetic components: an initial, fast fluorescence decay, followed by a transient increase, and then two characteristic decays that reflect dissociation from the desensitized agonist sites. The transient increase resulted from DC6C binding to the open-channel based on its prevention by proadifen, a noncompetitive antagonist. Further characterization of DC6C channel binding by the inhibition of [3H]phencyclidine binding and by equilibrium measurements of DC6C fluorescence yielded KD values of 2-4 microM for the desensitized AChR and approximately 600 microM for the closed state. At this site, DC6C displayed a strongly blue-shifted emission spectrum, higher intrinsic fluorescence, and weaker energy transfer from tryptophans than when bound to either agonist site. The initial, fast fluorescence decay was assigned to DC6C dissociation from the alphadelta site of the AChR in its closed conformation, on the basis of inhibition with the site-selective antagonists d-tubocurarine and alpha-conotoxin MI. Fast decay amplitude data indicated an apparent affinity of 0.9 microM for the closed-state alphadelta site; the closed-state alphagamma-site affinity is inferred to be near 100 microM. These values and the known affinities for the desensitized conformation show that the alphagamma site drives AChR desensitization to a approximately 40-fold greater extent than the alphadelta site, undergoes energetically larger conformational changes, and is the primary determinant of agonist potency.     

Distance between the agonist and noncompetitive inhibitor sites on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor possesses an agonist binding site on each of the two alpha-subunits and an allosterically coupled noncompetitive inhibitor (NCI) site. The spatial relationships between these sites have been determined by fluorescence energy transfer employing lifetime and steady-state techniques with two donor-acceptor pairs. 6-(5-Dimethylaminonaphthalene-1-sulfonamido)hexanoic acid-beta-(N-trimethylammonium)ethyl ester (dansyl-C6-choline, an agonist) and bis(choline)-N-(4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa-1,3-diazol-7-yl)-iminodiprop rionate (BCNI, a competitive antagonist) were employed as energy donors bound to the agonist sites. Ethidium was employed as a specific probe of the NCI site and served as the energy acceptor for both donors. Under steady-state conditions, energy transfer was measured by monitoring BCNI fluorescence as a function of occupancy of ethidium. Changes in acceptor occupancy were achieved by titrating acetylcholine receptor-donor-acceptor complexes with phencyclidine, a nonfluorescent NCI ligand. Extrapolation of the data to 100% acceptor occupancy yielded a transfer efficiency of 38% for the BCNI-ethidium pair. In the second method, the transfer efficiency of the dansyl-C6-choline-ethidium pair was determined by analysis of the reduction of the donor-excited state fluorescence lifetime. The nanosecond decay rates for dansyl-C6-choline measured in the presence of phencyclidine are characterized by two lifetimes (tau 1 = 6.7; tau 2 = 17.1 ns) with an amplitude ratio, alpha 1/alpha 2 = 2.3. In the presence of ethidium, the two lifetimes were proportionally diminished while retaining a comparable ratio of amplitudes. Displacement of ethidium from the NCI site by phencyclidine restored the two lifetimes to their original values. These data indicate that the donors bound to the two agonist sites transferred energy with similar efficiencies to the acceptor. Thus, the lifetime data suggest that the NCI site is approximately equidistant from each of the agonist sites. The corrected efficiency of donor quenching by this method was 34%, a value in close accord with the steady-state measurements. The distance between the agonist sites and the NCI site was calculated to be between 21-35 A for the BCNI/ethidium pair and 22-40 A for the dansyl-C6-choline/ethidium pair. Consideration of these distances with respect to the molecular dimensions of the receptor and location of the agonist sites suggests a location for the NCI site near the ion channel at the extracellular surface of the membrane bilayer.     

The activation of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor by the transmitter

Experimental evidence has been published from isolated guinea pig muscle in vitro, and from direct ligand binding to receptors from T. californica, indicating that two agonist ions react with the nicotinic receptor by exchanging for one magnesium ion. It is the basis of the ion exchange receptor pair model, in which two acetylcholine ions exchange for one magnesium ion in contact with and between a pair of negatively charged receptor groups about 4 A apart. In the resting state the electrostatic attraction between the negatively charged receptor groups and the Mg2+ ion exerts a binding force. This binding force is opposed by the quantum mechanical repulsions of the electron clouds of the charged groups and ions in contact, together with the mutual repulsion of the pair of receptor oxyanions. When the Mg2+ ion is replaced by two acetylcholine ions the quaternary heads of the latter are positioned so that they form two mutually repelling ACh+ receptor group dipoles. As the Mg2+ ion leaves, its rehydration energy contributes to the sum of the electron cloud repulsions and the ACh+ receptor group dipole repulsions, causing the receptor groups to be forced apart activating the receptor macromolecule. The subsequent decrease in ACh+ concentration results in the reestablishment of the resting state. The coulombic electrostatic energy, the Born repulsion energy, the London attraction energy and the oxyanion ACh+ dipole repulsion energies have been calculated and shown to be consistent with the model. The displacement of the Mg2+ by two ACh+ ions makes several hundred kcals of energy available for receptor group separation and receptor activation.     

Mapping the alpha-subunit site photolabeled by the noncompetitive inhibitor [3H]quinacrine azide in the active state of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

We have characterized the time-resolved labeling of a site on the Torpedo californica electrocyte acetylcholine receptor (ACHR) by the photoreactive noncompetitive inhibitor derivative quinacrine azide (QA). The dependence of [3H]QA labeling on acetylcholine (ACH) concentration and on time is consistent with the preferential labeling by [3H]QA of ACHR in the open state. The ACH-dependent [3H]QA labeling, which was associated predominantly with the alpha-subunit, was blocked by other noncompetitive inhibitors including quinacrine, chlorpromazine, proadifen, histrionicotoxin, and bupivacaine. alpha-Subunit from ACHR labeled with [3H]QA 20 ms after the addition of ACH was cleaved with CNBr, and the fragments were separated by high pressure liquid chromatography. A peptide containing a major site of specific labeling was purified on two different reverse-phase columns. By N-terminal sequencing, amino acid composition, binding to mercurial-agarose, and apparent molecular weight, this [3H]QA-labeled peptide was identified as alpha-208-243, a CNBr fragment containing the putative membrane-spanning helix M1.     

Modeling noncompetitive antagonism of a nicotinic acetylcholine receptor

Models of closed and open channel pores of a muscle-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) channel comprising M1 and M2 segments are presented. A model of the closed channel is proposed in which hydrophobic residues of the Equatorial Leucine ring screen the oxygen domain formed by the Serine ring, thereby preventing ion flux without completely occluding the pore. This model demonstrates a high similarity with the structure derived from a recent electron microscopy study. We propose that hydrophobic residues of the Equatorial Leucine ring are retracted when the pore is open. Our models provide a possible resolution of the nAChR gate controversy. We have also obtained explanations for the complex mechanisms underlying inhibition of nAChR by philanthotoxins (PhTXs). PhTX-343, containing a spermine moiety with a charge of +3, binds deep in the pore near the Serine ring where classical open channel blockers of nAChR bind. In contrast, PhTX-(12), which has a single charged amino group is unable to reach deeply located rings because of steric restrictions. Both philanthotoxins may bind to a hydrophobic site located close to the external entrance of the pore in a region that includes residues associated with the regulation of desensitization.     

Functional equivalence of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor transmitter binding sites in the open state

The subunits of the muscle-type nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AChR) are not uniformly oriented in the resting closed conformation: the two α subunits are rotated relative to its non-α subunits. In contrast, all the subunits overlay well with one another when agonist is bound to the AChR, suggesting that they are uniformly oriented in the open receptor. This gating-dependent increase in orientational uniformity due to rotation of the α subunits might affect the relative affinities of the two transmitter binding sites, making the two affinities dissimilar (functionally non-equivalent) in the initial ligand-bound closed state but similar (functionally equivalent) in the open state. To test this hypothesis, we measured single-channel activity of the αG153S gain-of-function mutant receptor evoked by choline, and estimated the resting closed-state and open-state affinities of the two transmitter binding sites. Both model-independent analyses and maximum-likelihood estimation of microscopic rate constants indicate that channel opening makes the binding sites' affinities more similar to each other. These results support the hypothesis that open-state affinities to the transmitter binding sites are primarily determined by the α subunits.     

Regulation of nicotinic acetylcholine receptor function by adenine nucleotides

1. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChR)4 from BC3H1 cells (which express a skeletal muscle-type receptor) and from Torpedo californica electric organ were expressed in Xenopus laevis oocytes and studied with a voltage-clamp technique. 2. We found that bath application of ATP in the micromolar to millimolar range increased the ACh-elicited current in both muscle and electrocyte receptors. The effect of ATP increased with successive applications. This "use-dependent" increase in potentiation was Ca2+ dependent, while the potentiation itself was not. 3. Four other nucleotides were tested on muscle nAChR: ADP, AMP, adenosine, and GTP. Of these, only ADP was a potentiator, but its effect was not use dependent. Neither ATP nor ADP affected the resting potential of the oocyte membrane. 4. ADP potentiated the response to suberyldicholine and nicotine, as well as ACh. 5. Finally, ADP reversed the phencyclidine-induced block of ACh currents in oocytes expressing muscle nAChR.     

Mutations in the M1 region of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor alter the sensitivity to inhibition by quinacrine

Summary 1. Site directed mutagenesis was used to alter the structure ofTorpedo californica nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) and to identify amino acid residues which contribute to noncompetitive inhibition by quinacrine. Mutant receptors were expressed inXenopus laevis oocytes injected within vitro synthesized mRNA and the whole cell currents induced by acetylcholine (ACh) were recorded by two electrode voltage clamp.2. A series of mutations of a highly conserved Arg at position 209 of the subunit ofTorpedo californica nAChR revealed that positively charged amino acids are required for functional receptor expression. Mutation of Arg to Lys (R209K) or His (R209H) at position 209 shifted the EC₅₀ for ACh slightly from 5µM to 12µM and increased the normalized maximal channel activity 8.5-and 3.2-fold, respectively.3. These mutations altered the sensitivity of nAChR to noncompetitive inhibition by quinacrine. The extent of inhibition of ion channel function by quinacrine was decreased as pH increased in both wild type and mutant nAChR suggesting that the doubly charged form of quinacrine was responsible for the inhibition.4. Further mutations at different positions of the subunit suggest the contribution of Pro and Tyr residues at positions 211 and 213 to quinacrine inhibition whereas mutationsI210A andL212A did not have any effects. None of these mutations changed the sensitivity of nAChR to inhibition by a different noncompetitive inhibitor, chlorpromazine.5. These findings support a hypothesis that the quinacrine binding site is located in the lumen of the ion channel. In addition, the quantitative effect of point mutations at alternate positions on the sensitivity of quinacrine inhibition suggests that the secondary structure at the beginning of M1 region might be sheet structure.