Evolutionary conservation of DNA sequences expressed in sea urchin eggs and early embryos

Summary DNA sequence divergence measurements indicate thatStrongylocentrotus franciscanus is more distinct fromS. purpuratus andS. drobachiensis than these two species are from each other, in agreement with paleontological and morphological evidence. The evolutionary divergence of several classes of expressed DNA sequences was compared with that of total single-copy DNA. BetweenS. franciscanus andS. purpuratus the divergence of cDNA made from gastrula cytoplasmic poly(A)⁺ RNA is about half that of total single-copy DNA. Similar results were obtained for cDNA made from unfertilized egg poly(A)⁺ RNA. In contrast, sequences expressed in gastrula nuclear RNA have diverged almost as much as total single-copy DNA.     

Single copy DNA and structural gene sequence relationships among four sea urchin species

Measurements of the divergence of single copy DNA sequences among four sea urchin species are presented. At a standard criterion for reassociation (0.12 M phosphate buffer, 60° C, hydroxyapatite binding) we observe the following extents of reaction and reductions in thermal stability for single copy DNA reassociation between Strongylocentrotus purpuratus tracer and heterologous driver DNA: S. dröbachiensis 68% and 2.5°C; S. franciscanus 51% and 3.5° C; Lytechinus pictus 12% and 7.5° C. The implied extents of sequence relatedness are consistent with the phylogenetic relationships of these species. The rate of single copy sequence divergence in the evolutionary lines leading to the Strongylocentrotus species is estimated to be 0.06–0.35% per million years. The rate of divergence of total single copy sequence has been compared to that of structural gene sequences represented in S. purpuratus gastrula polysomal messenger RNA. When closely related species, S. purpuratus and S. franciscanus, are compared, these polysomal sequences are found to diverge at a lower rate than does the total single copy sequence. For two very distantly related species, S. purpuratus and L. pictus, a small fraction of the single copy DNA sequence is probably conserved. These conserved sequences are not enriched in their content of structural gene sequences.Also staff member, Carnegie Institution of Washington, Washington, D.C. 20015     

Absence of short period interspersion of repetitive and non-repetitive sequences in the DNA of Drosophila melanogaster

A sensitive search has been made in Drosophila melanogaster DNA for short repetitive sequences interspersed with single copy sequences. Five kinds of measurements all yield the conclusion that there are few short repetitive sequences in this genome: 1) Comparison of the kinetics of reassociation of short (360 nucleotide) and long (1,830 nucleotide) fragments of DNA; 2) reassociation kinetics of long fragments (2,200 nucleotide) with an excess of short (390 short nucleotide) fragments; 3) measurement of the size of S1 nuclease resistant reassociated repeated sequences; 4) measurement of the hyperchromicity of reassociated repetitive fragments as a function of length; 5) direct assay by kinetics of reassociation of the amount of single copy sequence present on 1,200 nucleotide long fragments which also contain repetitive sequences.     

Evolutionary divergence and length of repetitive sequences in sea urchin DNA

Summary The organization of repetitive and single copy DNA sequences in sea urchin DNA has been examined with the single strand specific nuclease Sl fromAspergillus. Conditions and levels of enzyme were established so that single strand DNA was effectively digested while reassociated divergent repetitive duplexes remained enzyme resistant. About 25% of sea urchin DNA reassociates with repetitive kinetics to form Sl resistant duplexes of two distinct size classes derived from long and short repetitive sequences in the sea urchin genome. Fragments 2,000 nucleotides long were reassociated to Cot 20 and subjected to controlled digestion with Sl nuclease. About half of the resistant duplexes (13% of the DNA) are short, with a mode size of about 300 nucleotide pairs. This class exhibits significant sequence divergence, and principally consists of repetitive sequences which were interspersed with single copy sequences. About one-third of the long duplexes (4% of the DNA) are reduced in size after extensive Sl nuclease digestion to about 300 nucleotide pairs. About two-thirds of the long resistant duplexes (8% of the DNA) remains long after extensive SI nuclease digestion. These long reassociated duplexes are precisely base paired. The short duplexes are imprecisely paired with a melting temperature about 9°C below that of precisely paired duplexes of the same length. The relationship between length of repetitive duplex and precision of repetition is confirmed by an independent method and has been observed in the DNA of a number of species over a wide phylogenetic area.Also Staff Member, Carnegie Institution of Washington     

The 5S RNA genes inPinus radiata and the spacer region as a probe for relationships betweenPinus species

The 5S RNA genes inPinus radiata occur in two size classes of about 850 and 525 bp in length. Representatives from both the long and short size classes were cloned and sequenced. The primary difference in the two size classes was shown to be a 330 bp insertion in the spacer region of the long units. Within an individual breeding clone ofP. radiata there was some sequence heterogeneity between representatives of the short class. The 5S RNA genes in thirty pine species were characterised using either a clone of the short size class or a subclone of the 330 bp insertion characterizing the long size class. Eleven species of subg.Strobus were examined and all lacked the long type of unit of radiata pine. The New World species of subg.Pinus all had both short and long units whereas the Old World species had long units. The implications of these results for the evolution of the 5S DNA sequences and the phylogenetic relationships withinPinus are discussed.     

Genome structure and divergence of nucleotide sequences in echinodermata

The arrangement of repetitive and single-copy DNA sequences has been studied in DNA of some species of Echinodermata — sea urchin, starfishes and sea-cucumber. Comparison of the reassociation kinetics of short and long DNA fragments indicates that the pattern of DNA sequence organization of all these species is similar to the so called Xenopus pattern characteristic of the genomes of most animals and plants. However, substantional variations have been found in the amount of repetitive nucleotide sequences in DNA of different species and in the length of DNA regions containing adjacent single-copy and repetitive sequences. Measurements of the size of S₁-nuclease resistant reassociated repetitive DNA sequences show a variability of ratios between long and short repetitive DNA sequences of different species. — The degree of divergence of short and long repetitive DNA sequences and single-copy DNA was studied by molecular hybridization of the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus intermedius ³H-DNA with the DNA of other species and by determination of the thermostability of the hybridized molecules so obtained. All three fractions of S. intermedius DNA contain sequences homologous to DNA of the other echinoderm species studied. The results obtained suggest that short repetitive DNA sequences are those which have been most highly conserved throughout the evolution of Echinodermata. A new hypothesis is proposed to explain the nature of the evolutionary changes in DNA sequence interspersion patterns.     

Evolutionary change in the repetition frequency of sea urchin DNA sequences

The frequency of occurrence of particular repetitive sequence families has been estimated in the DNA of the three sea urchin species Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, Strongylocentrotus franciscanus and Lytechinus pictus using individual cloned S. purpuratus repetitive sequence elements. Cloned repetitive sequence elements as described by Scheller et al. (1977a) were prepared by reassociation of S. purpuratus DNA fragments to repetitive Cot, digestion with single-strand-specific nuclease S1 and ligation of synthetic restriction sites to their ends. The sequences were cloned by insertion at the Eco RI site of plasmid RSF2124, labeled, strand-separated and reassociated with 800–900 nucleotide long unlabeled DNA. Both kinetic (genomic DNA excess) and saturation (cloned DNA excess) estimates of frequencies were made. For nine cloned fragments, the ratio of the repetition frequency in S. purpuratus DNA to that in S. franciscanus DNA ranges from about 20 to about 1. In the four cases examined, only a few copies were detected in the DNA of L. pictus. Estimates have also been made of frequency changes in many repetitive families by measuring the reassociation of labeled repetitive DNA fractions of each species with total DNA from other species. In each reciprocal comparison, the labeled repetitive sequences reassociate more slowly with DNA of other species than with DNA of the species from which they were prepared. Thus it appears that the dominant repetitive sequence families in the DNA of each species are present at lower frequencies in the DNA of closely related species. Measurements of thermal stability have been made of S. purpuratus cloned repetitive sequences reassociated with S. franciscanus DNA or S. purpuratus DNA. Most families have changed both in frequency and sequence, although some have changed little in sequence but show great changes in frequency.     

Formation of the genome of the alligator gar Lepisosteus osseus (Ganoidomorpha) genome

Genome structure of the alligator gar was studied by means of a comparison of reassociation kinetics of short and long DNA fragments, an estimation of hyperchromicity of reassociated repetitive DNA as a function of fragments length, and length estimation of S1-resistant duplexes by gel filtration. It was shown that most of the repeated sequences in the alligator gar DNA are no less than 2000 b.p. long and weakly divergent. Little or no interspersion of unique and short repeated sequences were observed in this genome. No highly divergent repeats were found in the alligator gar genome.     

Localization of the lampbrush loop pair Nooses on the Y chromosome of Drosophila hydei by fluorescence in situ hybridization

We have used fluorescence in situ hybridization to map the positions of the different repetitive DNA sequences from the region forming the lampbrush loop pair Nooses on the Y chromosome of Drosophila hydei. This region harbours a megabase cluster of tandemly organized repeats of the Y-specific ay1 family and a megabase cluster of tandem repeats of the related Y-specific YsI family. In addition, ay1 repeats also occur in short blocks that are interspersed by other repetitive DNA sequences that we call Y-associated, since they have additional copies on other chromosomes. Using specific probes for ay1, YsI and Y-associated DNA sequences, we show that there is one large proximal cluster of YsI repeats and one, more distally located, large cluster of ay1 repeats. The Y-chromosomal copies of the Y-associated sequences are located in the most distal part of the ay1 cluster. This is consistent with the juxtaposition of ay1 and Y-associated sequences in more than 300 kb of cloned genomic DNA. Since both ay1 and Y-associated sequences have been shown to be transcribed in the Nooses, the lampbrush loop is formed in a distal region of the short arm of the Y chromosome, adjacent to the terminally located nucleolus organizer region. The clusters of homogeneous ay1 and YsI repeats are of no functional significance for the formation of the lampbrush loop.     

Contrasting patterns of DNA sequence arrangement in Apis mellifera (Honeybee) and Musca domestica (housefly)

We have examined the organization of the repeated and single copy DNA sequences in the genomes of two insects, the honeybee (Apis mellifera) and the housefly (Musca domestica). Analysis of the reassociation kinetics of honeybee DNA fragments 330 and 2,200 nucleotides long shows that approximately 90% of both size fragments is composed entirely of non-repeated sequences. Thus honeybee DNA contains few or no repeated sequences interspersed with nonrepeated sequences at a distance of less than a few thousand nucleotides. On the other hand, the reassociation kinetics of housefly DNA fragments 250 and 2,000 nucleotides long indicates that less than 15% of the longer fragments are composed entirely of single copy sequences. A large fraction of the housefly DNA therefore contains repeated sequences spaced less than a few thousand nucleotides apart. Reassociated repetitive DNA from the housefly was treated with S1 nuclease and sized on agarose A-50. The S1 resistant sequences have a bimodal distribution of lengths. Thirty-three percent is greater than 1,500 nucleotide pairs, and 67% has an average size about 300 nucleotide pairs. The genome of the housefly appears to have at least 70% of its DNA arranged as short repeats interspersed with single copy sequences in a pattern qualitatively similar to that of most eukaryotic genomes.     

A 21 kilobase-pair deletion/addition difference in the inverted repeat sequence of chloroplast DNA from Chlamydomonas eugametos and C. moewusii

Summary Our recent physical mapping of chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) from Chlamydomonas moewusii, a unicellular green alga which is interfertile with Chlamydomonas eugametos, has revealed a two-fold size difference between the inverted repeat sequences of these algae. With a size of 42 kbp, the inverted repeat of C. moewusii is the largest yet identified in any chloroplast genome. Here we have compared the arrangement of conserved sequences within the two algal inverted repeats by hybridizing cloned restriction fragments representing over 90% of these repeats to Southern blots of cpDNA digests from the two algae. We found that the size difference between the two algal inverted repeats is due to the presence of an extra DNA segment of 21 kilobase pairs (kbp) in C. moewusii. Except for this sequence, the C. moewusii inverted repeat is highly homologous to the entire C. eugametos repeat and the arrangement of conserved sequences in the two repeats is identical. Southern hybridizations with specific gene probes revealed that the conserved sequences include the rDNA region and the genes coding for the large subunit of ribulose 1,5 bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase (rbcL) and for the 32 kilodalton thylakoid membrane protein (psbA). With respect to the conserved sequences, the extra 21 kbp DNA segment of C. moewusii lies in the region of psbA, most probably slightly downstream from this gene.     

Characterization of long and short repetitive sequences in the sea urchin genome

Long and short repetitive sequences were purified from the DNA of Paracentrotus lividus under conditions designed to optimize the yield of complete, end to end sequences. Double-stranded long repeat DNA prepared in this manner ranged in length from approximately 3000 to 15 000 nucleotide pairs with average sizes of approximately 6000 base pairs. In the electron microscope, long repeat DNA was observed to possess continuous sequences that often appeared to be terminated by one or more loops and/or fold backs. Long repeat DNA sequences, resheared to 300 base pairs, were found to have an average melting point identical to that for sheared native DNA. Thus, the reassociated duplexes of long repetitive DNA seem to possess very few mismatched base pairs. Reassociation kinetic analyses indicate that the majority of the long repeat sequences are reiterated only 4--7 times per haploid amount of DNA. Melt-reassociation analyses of short repetitive DNA, at several criteria, support the previously held concept that these sequences belong the sets or families of sequences which are inexact copies of one another. Our studies also support hypotheses suggesting that short repetitive sequences belong to families which may have arisen via distinct salttatory events. The relationships between long and short repetitive DNA sequences are considered with respect to widely held concepts of their sequence organization, evolution, and possible functions within eucaryotic genomes. A model for the possible organization of short repeats within long repetitive DNA sequences is also presented.     

Evolution of sea urchin non-repetitive DNA

Summary New methods have been applied to the determination of single copy DNA sequence differences between the sea urchin speciesStrongylocentrotus purpuratus, S. franciscanus, S. drobachiensis, andLytechinus pictus. The thermal stability of interspecies DNA duplexes was measured in a solvent (2.4 M tetraethylammonium chloride) that suppresses the effect of base composition on melting temperature. The lengths of duplexes were measured after digestion with S1 nuclease and correction made for the effect of length on thermal stability. The degree of base substitution that has occurred in the single copy DNA during sea urchin evolution is significantly larger than indicated by earlier measurements. We estimate that 19% of the nucleotides of the single copy DNA are different in the genomes of the two sea urchin congeners,S. purpuratus, andS. franciscanus, which apparently diverged only 15 to 20 million years ago.     

An experimental analysis of sea urchin dynamics and community interactions on a rock jetty

Density-dependent effects of sea urchins have been investigated in Mission Bay, San Diego, California. During 1972–1973, the biomasses of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus (Stimpson) and S. franciscanus (A. Ag.) were manipulated in 21 experimental cells (each with an area of ≈ 15 m²)constructed on the rocks of the entrance channel breakwater. Biomasses were 0, 100, 1000, and 10,000 g (wet wt) of urchins/m². Cells were set up with S. purpuratus only, with S. franciscanus only, and with half of the biomass of each species. The rate of change of biomass was positively correlated with original density. Because barriers were not totally effective in restricting movement, the correlation is possibly best interpreted as one of diffusion rather than density-dependent mortality. Difference in the rate of loss between cells with single urchin species and with mixed species may indicate that intraspecific is more intense than interspecific competition. Individual growth rates were determined and step-wise multiple regression analysis was used to examine the relationships between growth increment and initial size, total biomass, interaction of biomass and initial size, and position along the jetty. Only original size and total urchin biomass were significant. The parameter K of the Brody-Bertalanffy growth equation was 0.61 for S. purpuratus and 0.72 for S. franciscanus.The relationship between algal biomass (kg wet wt/0.1 m²) and urchin biomass (kg wet wt/0.25 m²) was: In (algae + 1) = 1.225 In (S.p. + 1)?0.534 In (S.f. + l)+0.009 (position along jetty). Total barrenness would require 42 S. purpuratus or 41 S. franciscanus m². These values are higher than others in the literature.The density of certain marine invertebrates was found to be correlated with urchin biomass. The hard-shelled sessile molluscs Hinnites multirugosus (Gage) and Serpulorbis squamigerus (Carpenter) were positively correlated, whereas the soft-bodied tunicates Ciona intestinalis (L.) and Styela spp. were negatively correlated.     

Arrangement and size distribution of repeat and single copy DNA sequences in four species ofCucurbitaceae

DNA sequence organization patterns have been studied in fourCucurbitaceae plant species, namely,Luffa cylindrica (sponge gourd),L. acutangula (ridge gourd),Benincasa hispida (ash gourd) andCoccinia indica (ivy gourd). Extensive interspersion of repeat and single copy sequences has been observed in sponge gourd and ridge gourd. In ash gourd and ivy gourd, however, there is a limited interspersion of these sequences and a large portion of the single copy DNA remains uninterspersed. The interspersed repetitive sequences are composed of a major class (75–80%) of short repeats (300 base pairs long) and a minor class (15–20%) of long repeats (2 000–4 000 base pairs) in all the four species. The average length of single copy sequences dispersed among repeats is 1 800–2 900 base pairs. In spite of these gross similarities in the genome organization in the four species, the fraction of repeats and single copy sequences involved in short and long period interspersion patterns, and fraction of single copy sequences remaining uninterrupted by repeats are vastly different. The probable implications of these differences with respect to speciation events and rates of genome evolution are discussed.Molecular Analysis ofCucurbitaceae Genomes, III. — NCL Communication No.: 3595.     

Egg size and the evolution of phenotypic plasticity in larvae of the echinoid genus Strongylocentrotus

Planktotrophic larvae grow by utilizing energy obtained from food gathered in the plankton. Morphological plasticity of feeding structures has been demonstrated in multiple phyla, in which food-limited larvae increase feeding structure size to increase feeding rates. However, before larvae can feed exogenously they depend largely on material contained within the egg to build larval structures and to fuel larval metabolism. Thus, the capacity for plasticity of feeding structures early in development may depend on egg size. Using the congeneric sea urchins Strongylocentrotus franciscanus and S. purpuratus, which differ in egg volume by 5-fold, I tested whether the degree of expression of feeding structure (larval arm length) plasticity is correlated with differences in the size of the egg. I experimentally manipulated egg size of S. franciscanus (the larger-egged species) by separating blastomeres at the 2-cell stage to produce half-sized larvae. I reared half-size and normal-size larvae under high and low food treatments for 20 days. I measured arm and body lengths at multiple ages during development and calculated the degree of plasticity expressed by larvae from all treatments. Control and unmanipulated S. franciscanus larvae (from ∼ 1.0 nl eggs) had significantly longer arms relative to body size and a significantly greater degree of plasticity than half-sized S. franciscanus larvae (from < 0.18 nl eggs), which in turn expressed a significantly greater degree of plasticity than S. purpuratus larvae (from ∼ 0.3 nl eggs). These results indicate that egg size affects larval arm length plasticity in the genus Strongylocentrotus; larger eggs produce more-plastic larvae both in an experimental and a comparative context. However, changes in egg size alone are not sufficient to account for evolved differences in the pattern of plasticity expressed by each species over time and may not be sufficient for the evolutionary transition from feeding to non-feeding.     

Evolving sea urchin histone genes-nucleotide polymorphisms in the H4 gene and spacers ofStrongylocentrotus purpuratus

Summary We present a comparison of spacer and coding sequences of histone gene repeats from fourStronglycocentrotus purpuratus individuals. Sequences of two previously cloned units (pCO2 and pSp2) were compared with three new histone gene clones, two of them from a single individual. Within a 1.7-kb region, 59 polymorphic sites were found in spacers, in mRNA nontranslated stretches, and at silent sites in codons of the H4 gene. The permitted silent-site changes were as frequent as in any other region studied. The most abundant polymorphisms were single-base substitutions. The ratio of transitions: tranversions: single-base-pair insertions/deletions was 322. A number of larger insertions/deletions were found, as well as differences in the length of (CTA)_n and (CT)_n runs. Two of the five cloned repeats contained an insertion of a 195-bp element that is also present at many other sites in the genomes of everyS. purpuratus individual studied. Pairwise comparisons of the different clones indicate that the variation is not uniformly divergent, but ranges from a difference of 0.34% to 3.0% of all nucleotide sites. A parsimonious tree of ancestry constructed from the pariwise comparisons indicates that recombination between the most distantly related repeats has not occurred in the 1–2 million years necessary for accumulation of the variation. The level of sequence variation found within theS. purpuratus population, for both tandemly repeated and single-copy genes, is 25%–50% of that found betweenS. purpuratus andS. drobachiensis.     

Prefeeding larval development time is not correlated with egg size in regular echinoids (Strongylocentrotus species)

Summary

We compared prefeeding development times, from fertilized egg to prism larva, for Strongylocentrotus embryos from four clutches of eggs (each from a different species) differing in size. Development times did not vary consistently with egg diameter, and trends among eggs of different sizes varied with stage of development. In some cases, development times for eggs of intermediate diameter (S. franciscanus) were longer than those for larger or smaller eggs. Although mean egg diameters in clutches ranged from 84 μm (S. purpuratus) to 162 μm (S. pallidus), differences in development time to the last embryonic stage (prism) were very small. We conclude that the inverse relationship between parental investment in offspring and premetamorphic development time in echinoids depends only on the functional consequences of reduced size of feeding larval stages: effects of egg size on prefeeding development time are not evident.