Embedding carotenoids of spheroidene-branch biosynthesis into antenna complexes of sulfur photosynthetic bacteria

The possibility of embedding the carotenoids of spheroidene-branch biosynthesis (spheroidene and spheroidenone) from non-sulfur bacteria into the diphenylamine antenna complexes (DPA-complexes) from the sulfur bacteria Allochromatium minutissimum and Ectothiorhodospira haloalkaliphila with carotenoid synthesis inhibited by diphenylamine (DPA) was studied for the first time. It was found that spheroidene was embedded into the DPA-complexes from these bacteria at a level of 75–87%, with spheroidene embedding efficiency being 41–68% for the LH1-RC DPA-complexes and 71–89% for the LH2 DPA-complexes. The energy transfer efficiency from carotenoids to bacteriochlorophyll was shown to depend not only on the type of carotenoid but also on the very structure on the antenna complex.     

The spirilloxanthine-pathway carotenoid incorporation into light-harvesting complexes of Ectothiorhodospira haloalkaliphila in vitro

Carotenoidless light-harvesting complexes (DPA-complexes) LH1-RC and LH2 were isolated from the purple sulfur bacterium Ectothiorhodospira haloalkaliphila in which carotenoid biosynthesis was suppressed with diphenylamine (DPA). Carotenoids of the spirilloxanthine series, which were isolated from the same bacterium, were incorporated into the DPA-complexes in vitro with an efficiency of 95–100%. The comparison of characteristics of the complexes with the incorporated carotenoids and the control complexes showed that the LH2 complexes with the incorporated carotenoids restored their absorption spectra, circular dichroism signals, and energy transfer from carotenoids to bacteriochlorophyll, which indicates that carotenoids were correctly incorporated into the structure of this complex.     

Formation of a subunit form of the core light-harvesting complex from sulfur purple bacteria <Emphasis Type="Italic">Ectothiorhodospira haloalkaliphila</Emphasis> with different carotenoid composition

B820 subunits from a purple sulfur bacterium Ectothiorhodospira haloalkaliphila strain ATCC 51935^T were obtained by treatment of carotenoid free LH1-RC complexes of this bacterium with ß-octylglucopyranoside (ß-OG). The same complexes with 100% carotenoid content were unable to dißsociate to B820 subunits, but disintegrated to monomeric bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) regardless of their carotenoid composition. The degree of dissociation of the LH1-RC complexes with an intermediate content of carotenoids (the B820 formation) was directly dependent on the quantity of carotenoids in the samples. The resulting B820 subunits did not contain carotenoids. B820 subunits easily aggregated to form a complex with an absorption peak at 880 nm at decreased ß-OG concentration. Analysis of the spectra of the LH1-RC complexes isolated from the cells with different levels of carotenogenesis inhibition led to the conclusion of the heterogeneity of the samples with a predominance of them in (a) the fraction with 100% of carotenoids and (b) the fraction of carotenoid-free complexes.     

Formation of Bacteriochlorophyll Form B820 in Light Harvesting 2 Complexes from Purple Sulfur Bacteria Treated with Dioxane

Treatment of some sulfur bacteria (Allochromatium minutissimum, Thiorhodospira sibirica, and Ectothiorhodospira halovacuolata WN22) with dioxane results in formation of the bacteriochlorophyll form B820 in the light harvesting complex LH2. This form characterized by absorption maximum at 820 nm has the same absorption spectrum as B820 subcomplex from LH1 complex. Appearance of the B820 form was accompanied by a sharp decrease in absorption in the carotenoid region. This phenomenon observed in all LH2 complexes investigated may be attributed to formation of colorless carotenoid aggregates. This is very similar to the previously reported dissociation of the LH1 complex with carotenoids into B820 subcomplexes. Although the B820 form corresponded the bacteriochlorophyll dimer, its circular dichroism spectrum showed that pigment molecules in this dimer exhibit different interaction than those in the B820 subcomplex. The dioxane treatment of LH2 complexes isolated from Rhodopseudomonas palustris bacteria grown under normal or low intensity illumination did not result in formation of such dimers. It is suggested that bacteriochlorophyll B820 formation is related to unique structure of LH2 complexes from the sulfur bacteria.     

Trapping of an assembly intermediate of photosynthetic LH1 antenna beyond B820 subunit. Significance for the assembly of photosynthetic LH1 antenna

Most photosynthetic LH1 antennae undergo dissociation into B820 subunits, suggesting their universal character as structural modules. However, dissociation into subunits seems to occur reversibly only in the absence of carotenoids and the subunits were never found to bind carotenoids. The interactions of carotenoids with B820 have been studied in a newly developed reconstitution assay of the LH1 antenna from Rhodospirillum rubrum (Fiedor, L., Akahane, J., and Koyama, Y. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 16487-16496). These model studies show that B820 subunits strongly interact with carotenoids and spontaneously form stable LH1-like complexes with substoichiometric carotenoid content. This is the first experimental evidence that B820 may occur as a short-lived intermediate in the assembly of LH1 in vivo. The resulting complex of B820 subunits with carotenoid, termed iB873, is homogeneous, according to ion exchange chromatography and reproducible pigment composition. The iB873-bound carotenoid is as efficient in energy transfer to bacteriochlorophyll as the one in native antenna. To our knowledge, iB873 is the first complex binding functional carotenoid, with the spectral and biochemical properties intermediate between that of B820 and the fully assembled LH1.     

Two-photon excitation spectrum of fluorescence of the light-harvesting complex B800–850 from Allochromatium minutissimum within 1200–1500 (600–750) nm spectral range is not carotenoid mediated

Two types of peripheral light-harvesting complexes LH2 (B800–850) from photosynthetic purple bacterium Allochromatium minutissimum were studied. First type containing carotenoids was prepared from wild type cells. The other one was obtained from carotenoid depleted cells grown with diphenylamine. We have shown that under laser femtosecond excitation within absorption 1200–1500 nm wavelength range the two-photon excitation of LH2 complexes takes place. This can be observed as fluorescence of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) spectral form B850 (BChl molecules of circular aggregate with strong exciton interaction in 850 nm spectral domain). LH2 fluorescence excitation spectra under two-photon excitation are the same for carotenoid-containing and carotenoidless preparations. In both cases the broad band with peak near 1350 (675) nm (FWHM ～ 240 (120) nm) was found. It is concluded that the broad band with peak near 1350 (675) nm in two-photon excitation spectra of LH2 complexes from Allochromatium minutissimum cannot be interpreted as two-photon excitation band of the optically forbidden S₀ → S₁ transition of carotenoids (rhodopin). Possible nature of this band is discussed.     

X-ray scattering and electron cryomicroscopy study on the effect of carotenoid biosynthesis to the structure of Chlorobium tepidum chlorosomes

Chlorosomes, the main antenna complexes of green photosynthetic bacteria, were isolated from null mutants of Chlorobium tepidum, each of which lacked one enzyme involved in the biosynthesis of carotenoids. The effects of the altered carotenoid composition on the structure of the chlorosomes were studied by means of x-ray scattering and electron cryomicroscopy. The chlorosomes from each mutant strain exhibited a lamellar arrangement of the bacteriochlorophyll c aggregates, which are the major constituents of the chlorosome interior. However, the carotenoid content and composition had a pronounced effect on chlorosome biogenesis and structure. The results indicate that carotenoids with a sufficiently long conjugated system are important for the biogenesis of the chlorosome baseplate. Defects in the baseplate structure affected the shape of the chlorosomes and were correlated with differences in the arrangement of lamellae and spacing between the lamellar planes of bacteriochlorophyll aggregates. In addition, comparisons among the various mutants enabled refinement of the assignments of the x-ray scattering peaks. While the main scattering peaks come from the lamellar structure of bacteriochlorophyll c aggregates, some minor peaks may originate from the paracrystalline arrangement of CsmA in the baseplate.     

The early formation of the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodospirillum rubrum

The time dependent assembly of the photosynthetic apparatus was studied in Rhodospirillum rubrum after transfer of cells growing aerobically in the dark to low aeration. While bacteriochlorophyll (Bchl) cellular levels increase continuously levels of soluble cytochrome c ₂do not change significantly. Absorption spectra of membranes isolated at different times after transfer reveal that incorporation of carotenoids lags behind incorporation of Bchl. However, a carotenoid fraction exhibiting spectral properties of spirilloxanthin isomers was isolated apart from membranes. This carotenoid fraction even was present in homogenates from Bchl-free, aerobically grown cells. Incorporation of U-¹⁴C-proteinhydrolyzate into membrane proteins showed that proteins are mainly formed which are specific for photosynthetic membranes. Although the proportion of reaction center (RC) Bchl per light harvesting (LH) Bchl does not change the proportions of membrane proteins present in RC and LH preparations change initially. But later on the proportions of the different proteins also reach constant values. Concerning proteins characteristic for cytoplasmic membranes a differential incorporation of label can be observed. The data indicate that the photosynthetic apparatus in Rhodospirillum rubrum is assembled through a sequential mechanism.Abbreviations Bchl bacteriochlorophyll - LH light harvesting - RC reaction center - R. Rhodospirillum - R. Rhodopseudomonas     

The Influence of the Number of Conjugated Double Bonds in Carotenoid Molecules on the Energy Transfer Efficiency to Bacteriochlorophyll in Light-Harvesting Complexes LH2 from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Allochromatium vinosum</Emphasis> Strain MSU

Seven different carotenoids with the number of conjugated double bonds (N) from 5 to 11 were incorporated in vitro into carotenoidless complexes LH2 of the sulfur bacterium Allochromatium vinosum strain MSU. The efficiency of their incorporation varied from 4 to 99%. The influence of N in the carotenoid molecules on the energy transfer efficiency from these pigments to bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) in the modified LH2 complexes was studied for the first time. The highest level of energy transfer was recorded for rhodopin (N = 11) and neurosporene (N = 7) (37 and 51%, respectively). In the other carotenoids, this parameter ranged from 11 to 33%. In the LH2 complexes studied, we found no direct correlation between the decrease in N in carotenoids and increase in the energy transfer efficiency from these pigments to BChl.     

Triplet states of bacteriochlorophyll and carotenoids in chromatophores of photosynthetic bacteria

Chromatophores from photosynthetic bacteria were excited with flashes lasting approx. 15 ns. Transient optical absorbance changes not associated with the photochemical electron-transfer reactions were interpreted as reflecting the conversion of bacteriochlorophyll or carotenoids into triplet states. Triplet states of various carotenoids were detected in five strains of bacteria; triplet states of bacteriochlorophyll, in two strains that lack carotenoids. Triplet states of antenna pigments could be distinguished from those of pigments specifically associated with the photochemical reaction centers. Antenna pigments were converted into their triplet states if the photochemical apparatus was oversaturated with light, if the primary photochemical reaction was blocked by prior chemical oxidation of P-870 or reduction of the primary electron acceptor, or if the bacteria were genetically devoid of reaction centers. Only the reduction of the electron acceptor appeared to lead to the formation of triplet states in the reaction centers.In the antenna bacteriochlorophyll, triplet states probably arise from excited singlet states by intersystem crossing. The antenna carotenoid triplets probably are formed by energy transfer from triplet antenna bacteriochlorophyll. The energy transfer process has a half time of approx. 20 ns, and is about 1 × 10³ times more rapid than the reaction of the bacteriochlorophyll triplet states with O₂. This is consistent with a role of carotenoids in preventing the formation of singlet O₂ in vivo. In the absence of carotenoids and O₂, the decay half times of the triplet states are 70 μs for the antenna bacteriochlorophyll and 6–10 μs for the reaction center bacteriochlorophyll. The carotenoid triplets decay with half times of 2–8 μs.With weak flashes, the quantum yields of the antenna triplet states are in the order of 0.02. The quantum yields decline severely after approximately one triplet state is formed per photosynthetic unit, so that even extremely strong flashes convert only a very small fraction of the antenna pigments into triplet states. The yield of fluorescence from the antenna bacteriochlorophyll declines similarly. These observations can be explained by the proposal that singlet-triplet fusion causes rapid quenching of excited singlet states in the antenna bacteriochlorophyll.     

Spectroscopic studies of two spectral variants of light-harvesting complex 2 (LH2) from the photosynthetic purple sulfur bacterium Allochromatium vinosum

Two spectral forms of the peripheral light-harvesting complex (LH2) from the purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium Allochromatium vinosum were purified and their photophysical properties characterized. The complexes contain bacteriochlorophyll a (BChl a) and multiple species of carotenoids. The composition of carotenoids depends on the light conditions applied during growth of the cultures. In addition, LH2 grown under high light has a noticeable split of the B800 absorption band. The influence of the change of carotenoid distribution as well as the spectral change of the excitonic absorption of the bacteriochlorophylls on the light-harvesting ability was studied using steady-state absorption, fluorescence and femtosecond time-resolved absorption at 77K. The results demonstrate that the change of the distribution of the carotenoids when cells were grown at low light adapts the absorptive properties of the complex to the light conditions and maintains maximum photon-capture performance. In addition, an explanation for the origin of the enigmatic split of the B800 absorption band is provided. This spectral splitting is also observed in LH2 complexes from other photosynthetic sulfur purple bacterial species. According to results obtained from transient absorption spectroscopy, the B800 band split originates from two spectral forms of the associated BChl a monomeric molecules bound within the same complex.     

Characterisation of the LH2 spectral variants produced by the photosynthetic purple sulphur bacterium Allochromatium vinosum

This study systematically investigated the different types of LH2 produced by Allochromatium (Alc.) vinosum, a photosynthetic purple sulphur bacterium, in response to variations in growth conditions. Three different spectral forms of LH2 were isolated and purified, the B800-820, B800-840 and B800-850 LH2 types, all of which exhibit an unusual split 800 peak in their low temperature absorption spectra. However, it is likely that more forms are also present. Relatively more B800-820 and B800-840 are produced under low light conditions, while relatively more B800-850 is produced under high light conditions. Polypeptide compositions of the three different LH2 types were determined by a combination of HPLC and TOF/MS. The B800-820, B800-840 and B800-850 LH2 types all have a heterogeneous polypeptide composition, containing multiple types of both α and β polypeptides, and differ in their precise polypeptide composition. They all have a mixed carotenoid composition, containing carotenoids of the spirilloxanthin series. In all cases the most abundant carotenoid is rhodopin; however, there is a shift towards carotenoids with a higher conjugation number in LH2 complexes produced under low light conditions. CD spectroscopy, together with the polypeptide analysis, demonstrates that these Alc. vinosum LH2 complexes are more closely related to the LH2 complex from Phs. molischianum than they are to the LH2 complexes from Rps. acidophila.     

Femtosecond spectroscopy of native and carotenoidless purple-bacterial LH2 clarifies functions of carotenoids

EET between the two circular bacteriochlorophyll compartments B800 and B850 in native (containing the carotenoid rhodopin) and carotenoidless LH2 isolated from the photosynthetic purple sulfur bacterium Allochromatium minutissimum was investigated by femtosecond time-resolved transient absorption spectroscopy. Both samples were excited with 120-fs laser pulses at 800 nm, and spectral evolution was followed in the 720-955 nm range at different delay times. No dependence of transient absorption in the B800 band on the presence of the carotenoid rhodopin was found. Together with the likewise virtually unchanged absorption spectra in the bacteriochlorophyll Q_y region, these observations suggest that absence of rhodopin does not significantly alter the structure of the pigment-protein complex including interactions between bacteriochlorophylls. Apparently, rhodopin does also not accelerate B800 to B850 EET in LH2, contrary to what has been suggested previously. Moreover, “carotenoid-catalyzed internal conversion” can also be excluded for the bacteriochlorophylls in LH2 of A. minutissimum. Together with previous results obtained with two-photon fluorescence excitation spectroscopy, it can also be concluded that there is neither EET from rhodopin to B800 nor (back-)EET from B800 to rhodopin.     

Reconstitution of Okenone into Light Harvesting Complexes from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Allochromatium minutissimum</Emphasis>

Okenone was reconstituted into light harvesting (LH) complexes of the purple photosynthetic bacterium Allochromatium minutissimum possessing the spirilloxanthin pathway for carotenoid biosynthesis. Suppression of this pathway by diphenylamine, an inhibitor of carotenogenesis, yielded nearly carotenoidless complexes preserving their native spectral properties. Using a previously developed technique, okenone was readily reconstituted into LH1 complex (>90%) whereas its reconstitution into LH2 complex was of low efficacy (10-20%). The absorption band of the reconstituted okenone was shifted to shorter wavelength compared with its position in vivo. This is typical for other reconstituted carotenoids. The reconstitution of okenone was confirmed by Li-DS electrophoresis (in contrast to free okenone the reconstituted okenone migrated with complexes), circular dichroism spectra (reconstituted okenone exhibited optical activity), and fluorescence excitation spectrum (energy transfer from okenone to bacteriochlorophyll was at the control level).     

Spirilloxanthin incorporation into the LH2 and LH1-RC pigment-protein complexes from a purple sulfur bacterium <Emphasis Type="Italic">Allochromatium minutissimum</Emphasis>

Incorporation of spirilloxanthin into carotenoidless LH2 and LH1-RC complexes from a purple sulfur bacterium Allochromatium (Alc.) minutissimum was studied. Carotenoidless cells of Alc. minutissimum were obtained using diphenylamine, a carotenoid biosynthesis inhibitor. In the course of incorporation of the carotenoid mixture, the composition of which corresponded to that of Alc. minutissimum control photosynthetic membranes, no selective incorporation of spirilloxanthin into the LH1-RC complex was detected. It is assumed that in vivo carotenoids are not incorporated into the LH2 and LH1-RC complexes from a common pool. Pure spirilloxanthin destroys both the LH2 and LH1-RC complexes. Within the concentration range of spirilloxanthin in the incorporated mixture from 27% to 52%, it was found to be incorporated into the LH2 and LH1-RC complexes with the efficiency of 13% and 33%, respectively. The possible existence of different sites of assembly for the LH2 and LH1-RC complexes is discussed, as well as of two fractions of LH2 complexes, in one of which rhodopin may be integrated, and in the other (minor) one, spirilloxanthin.     

Hexacoordination of bacteriochlorophyll in photosynthetic antenna LH1

The ability of chlorophylls to coordinate ligands is of fundamental structural importance for photosynthetic pigment-protein complexes, where in virtually all cases the pigment is thought to be in a pentacoordinated state. In this study, the correlation of the Q(X) transition energy with the coordination state of the central metal in bacteriochlorophyll is applied in investigating the pigment coordination state in bacterial photosynthetic antenna LH1. To facilitate a detailed spectral analysis in the Q(X) region, carotenoid-depleted forms of LH1 are prepared and model LH1 are constructed with non-native carotenoids having blue-shifted absorption. The deconvolution of the Q(X) envelope in LH1 reveals that the band is the sum of two transitions, which peak near 590 and 607 nm, showing that a significant fraction (up to 25%) of hexacoordinated bacteriochlorophyll is present in the complex. The hexacoordination can be seen also in LH1 antennae from other species of purple photosynthetic bacteria. It seems correlated with the LH1 aggregation state and probably is a consequence of the structural flexibility of the assembled complex. The sixth ligand probably originates from the apoprotein and seems not to affect the chromophore core size. These findings show that in light-harvesting complexes a hexacoordinated state of bacteriochlorophyll is not uncommon. Its presence may be relevant to a correct assembly of the antenna and have functional consequences, as it results in a splitting of the pigment S2 excited state (Q(X)), i.e., the carotenoid excitation acceptor state, what might affect intracomplex carotenoid-to-bacteriochlorophyll energy transfer.     

3-Acetyl-chlorophyll formation in light-harvesting complexes of purple bacteria by chemical oxidation

Oxidation of bacteriochlorophyll (BChl) with potassium ferricyanide in membranes and LH2 complexes (carotenoid-less and control samples) from the purple bacteria Allochromatium minutissimum and Rhodobacter sphaeroides as well as BChl photobleaching in a model system have been studied. The oxidation of BChl depended on the type of bacteria. BChl850 was rapidly oxidized in samples from Alc. minutissimum, and BChl800 and BChl850 were slowly oxidized in samples from Rb. sphaeroides. The carotenoids were not involved in protecting BChl from chemical oxidation in the lightharvesting complexes. The appearance of BChl oxidation product was registered in the absorption spectra (absorption maximum about 700 nm) and by HPLC analysis. The oxidized BChl was identified as 3-acetyl-chlorophyll. It differed from BChl by the presence of a double bond in pyrrole ring II at the 7-8 position. The extinction coefficient of 3-acetyl-chlorophyll was about 10 times less than that of BChl850 in the LH2 complex from Alc. minutissimum. In the BChl → 3-acetylchlorophyll transition, the binding constant of the latter with LH2 complex as compared with that of BChl did not change dramatically, as indicated by: (i) preserved electrophoretic mobility of the complex; (ii) the presence of 3-acetyl-chlorophyll in the complex after separation; (iii) the presence of a 3-acetyl-chlorophyll CD signal that was proportional to its absorption spectrum.     

Distribution of rhodopin and spirilloxanthin between LH1 and LH2 complexes when incorporating carotenoid mixture into the membrane of purple sulfur bacterium <Emphasis Type="Italic">Allochromatium minutissimum</Emphasis> in vitro

Carotenoid mixture enriched by rhodopin and spirilloxanthin was incorporated in LH2 and LH1 complexes from Allochromatium (Alc.) minutissimum in vitro. The maximum incorporating level was ~95%. Rhodopin (56.4%) and spirilloxanthin (13.8%) were incorporated into the LH1 complex, in contrast to the control complex, which contained primarily spirilloxanthin (66.8%). After incorporating, the LH2 complex contained rhodopin (66.7%) and didehydrorhodopin (14.6%), which was close to their content in the control (67.4 and 20.5%, respectively). Thus, it was shown that carotenoids from the total pool are not selectively incorporated into LH2 and LH1 complexes in vitro in the proportion corresponding to the carotenoid content in the complexes in vivo.     

Singlet-triplet excitation fission in light-harvesting complexes of photosynthetic bacteria and in isolated carotenoids

Time-resolved electron paramagnetic resonance was used to study the properties of carotenoid triplet states populated in LH2 light-harvesting complexes of phototrophic bacteria Allochromatium minutissimum, Rhodopseudomonas palustris, and in carotenoid films free of bacteriochlorophyll. The study was performed on purified LH2 preparations not contaminated by reaction centers, and under selective pigment excitation. The obtained results enable a conclusion that the carotenoid triplet states, both in LH2 complexes and films, are populated in the process of homofission of singlet excitation into two triplets, which involves only carotenoid molecules. It is observed that the fission process in magnetic field leads to predominant population of the T₀ spin sublevel of the triplet. One molecular spin sublevel of the triplet is demonstrated to possess an increased probability of intersystem crossing to the ground state, independent of the carotenoid configuration. Pigment composition of the LH2 protein heterodimers is discussed, and a conclusion of the possible presence of two interacting carotenoid molecules is made.     

Dynamics of energy transfer from lycopene to bacteriochlorophyll in genetically-modified LH2 complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

LH2 complexes from Rb. sphaeroides were modified genetically so that lycopene, with 11 saturated double bonds, replaced the native carotenoids which contain 10 saturated double bonds. Tuning the S1 level of the carotenoid in LH2 in this way affected the dynamics of energy transfer within LH2, which were investigated using both steady-state and time-resolved techniques. The S1 energy of lycopene in n-hexane was determined to be approximately 12 500 +/- 150 cm(-1), by direct measurement of the S1-S2 transient absorption spectrum using a femtosecond IR-probing technique, thus placing an upper limit on the S1 energy of lycopene in the LH2 complex. Fluorescence emission and excitation spectra demonstrated that energy can be transferred from lycopene to the bacteriochlorophyll molecules within this LH2 complex. The energy-transfer dynamics within the mutant complex were compared to wild-type LH2 from Rb. sphaeroides containing the carotenoid spheroidene and from Rs. molischianum, in which lycopene is the native carotenoid. The results show that the overall efficiency for Crt --> B850 energy transfer is approximately 80% in lyco-LH2 and approximately 95% in WT-LH2 of Rb. sphaeroides. The difference in overall Crt --> BChl transfer efficiency of lyco-LH2 and WT-LH2 mainly relates to the low efficiency of the Crt S(1) --> BChl pathway for complexes containing lycopene, which was 20% in lyco-LH2. These results show that in an LH2 complex where the Crt S1 energy is sufficiently high to provide efficient spectral overlap with both B800 and B850 Q(y) states, energy transfer via the Crt S1 state occurs to both pigments. However, the introduction of lycopene into the Rb. sphaeroides LH2 complex lowers the S1 level of the carotenoid sufficiently to prevent efficient transfer of energy to the B800 Q(y) state, leaving only the Crt S1 --> B850 channel, strongly suggesting that Crt S1 --> BChl energy transfer is controlled by the relative Crt S1 and BChl Q(y) energies.