Comparison of fertility results after vaginal insemination using different thawing procedures and packages for frozen ram semen

Background  

The effect of different thawing procedures for ram semen frozen in minitubes and mini straws on the fertility of sheep was tested in a field trial.     

Survival and fertility of ram spermatozoa frozen in pellets, straws and minitubes

The post-thaw survival and fertility of ram spermatozoa frozen in pellets, 0.25- and 0.5-ml PVC straws, and 0.25-ml minitubes were examined. In 5 experiments, a freezing height of 6 cm above the level of liquid nitrogen was optimal for 0.25- and 0.5-ml straws, whereas 4 cm was best for the 0.25-ml minitubes. Post-thaw motility of spermatozoa was lower for semen frozen in straws and minitubes than in pellets (Experiment 1: 43.7 vs 53.4%, P < 0.001), but after freezing was better in 0.5-ml straws and 0.25-ml minitubes than in 0.25-ml straws (Experiment 1: 44.9 vs 41.3%, P < 0.05; Experiment 2: 49.6 vs 46.8%, P < 0.01). Sperm motility was also better for 1:8 (semen:diluent) pre-freezing dilution rate (50.5%) than for 1:4 (45.6%, P < 0.01) and 1:2 (39.8%, P < 0.001) but not the 1:16 (49.5%) dilution rate. Dry ice was a better freezing medium than liquid nitrogen vapor (49.2 vs 46.9% motile spermatozoa, P < 0.001). The post-thaw motility of spermatozoa was similar for the three freezing packages if the semen was loaded at 5 degrees C, but motility was poorer for semen loaded into 0.25-ml straws than 0.25-ml minitubes at 30 degrees C (P < 0.05). In a fertility test, pregnancy rates were influenced by rams (3 rams, P < 0.05) and freezing package (pellets vs 0.25-ml minitube vs 0.25-ml straw vs 0.5-ml straw, P < 0.05) but not freezing medium (liquid nitrogen vapor vs dry ice). More ewes were pregnant after insemination with pellet-frozen semen (106/150, 71%) than with semen frozen in 0.25-ml straws (85/150, 57%; P < 0.05) and in 0.5-ml straws (83/150, 55%; P < 0.01) but not minitubes (98/150, 65%). It was concluded that minitubes provide a useful alternative to pellets as a storage package for ram spermatozoa, allowing for individual dose identification and easier storage while maintaining a fertility rate indistinguishable from that obtained with pellet-frozen semen.     

A new method for thawing frozen ram semen

The purpose of this work was to facilitate the on-farm use of frozen semen by initially thawing the straws in laboratory treated sperm (TS) rather than on-farm control sperm (CS), as is usually done. After thawing, TS was diluted, centrifuged, and extended in skim milk for storage at +15° C until utilized 3 to 6 hours later. $\text{In}$$\text{vitro}$: immediately after preparation and addition of skim milk for TS and thawing for CS, the percentage of stained cells and abnormal cells was higher (P < 0.01) in TS than in CS. In contrast, following a 3 hour incubation, TS and CS had the same proportion of motile cells. $\text{In}$$\text{vivo}$: fertility and prolificacy of FGA + PMSG-treated ewes were slightly higher following AI (1 AI/female) with TS than with CS: 52.4% $\text{vs}$ 44.2% and 155.0% $\text{vs}$ 148.0%, respectively. Fertility was also higher (P < 0.01) with fresh semen than with TS, but the difference was only 9.2 points (70.3% $\text{vs}$ 61.1% for the respective 798 and 242 ewes inseminated once). Prolificacy rates were similar (164.3% $\text{vs}$ 167.6%).     

Fertility of ram semen frozen in Bioexcell and used for cervical artificial insemination

The current use of ingredients of animal origin, such as egg yolk, in semen extenders presents a risk of microbial contamination, and has led to the search for alternatives. Such an extender is commercially available for bull semen (Bioexcell), IMV, L'Aigle, France), and it has previously been tested in vitro for freezing ram semen, with satisfactory results. The aim of the present study was to compare the fertility results of ewes in Uruguay, after cervical insemination with ram semen that was frozen in Bioexcell versus semen frozen in a conventional milk-egg yolk extender (control). Semen from five Corriedale rams was frozen, using a split sample design, in either milk-egg yolk or Bioexcell extender, using a two-step extension method. The sperm parameters assessed after thawing were subjective motility, membrane integrity (SYBR-14/PI), and capacitation status (CTC). Thawed semen was inseminated intracervically once during spontaneous estrus in 970 Corriedale ewes that grazed in natural pastures, under extensive management conditions. Fertility was recorded as nonreturn rates at 21 days (NRR-21) and 36 days (NRR-36) after artificial insemination (AI), as well as pregnancy rate (PR-US, diagnosed ultrasonographically 50 days after AI of the last ewe). Subjective motility was slightly higher in Bioexcell than in the milk extender (47 vs. 46.5%; NS), as was membrane integrity (38 vs. 37.7%; NS) and the percentage of uncapacitated spermatozoa (28.5 vs. 26.3%; NS). There were no statistically significant differences in fertility rates found between Bioexcell and the control extender: NRR-21 (35.9 vs. 33.2%), NRR-36 (34.8 vs. 32.6%), and PR-US (28.4 vs. 27.2%). In conclusion, Bioexcell appears to be an alternative to the conventional milk-egg yolk extender for freezing ram semen, and provides similar fertility results after cervical AI under extensive management conditions. Thus, Bioexcell, containing no additives of animal origin, can offer a safer alternative when frozen semen is used for introducing new genetic material into a flock or a country.     

Assessment of ram sperm membrane integrity following different thawing procedures

Semen from five 2.5-yr-old rams selected for use in an AI program was collected over 3 consecutive days using an artificial vagina. The semen was diluted with a skim milk extender containing 7% glycerol (v/v), packed in French mini-straws (approx. 100 mill/straw), and frozen in a programmable freezer. Three freezing operations were carried out per ram. Three straws per freezing operation were subjected to the following thawing procedures: 1) 70 degrees C, 5 sec; 2) 50 degrees C, 9 sec and 3) 35 degrees C, 12 sec. Post-thaw sperm motility was subjectively assessed using a phase contrast microscope; while the combined fluorochromes carboxyfluorescein diacetate and propidium iodide (CFDA/PI), the hypo-osmotic swelling test (HOS) and the presence of normal apical ridges (NAR's) were used to determine the degree of sperm membrane integrity. Significant differences between thawing treatments were found for post-thaw motility (P < .05) and membrane integrity (P < 0.01), and variation among rams was statistically significant. Post-thaw sperm motility as well as the percentage of spermatozoa showing intact membranes were significantly higher (P < 0.01) for straws thawed at 70 degrees C than for those thawed at 35 degrees C (67.0 +/- 1.1 and 63.0 +/- 1.1%, and 50.5 +/- 1.5 and 41.7 +/- 1.5%, respectively). However, no corresponding statistically significant difference could be found for these parameters when 70 degrees C and 50 degrees C thawing were compared. It was concluded that sperm can be thawed at 50 degrees C for 9 sec instead of 70 degrees C for 5 sec without further reducing sperm motility or membrane integrity. This lower thawing temperature would facilitate the widespread use of frozen/thawed ram semen under farm conditions in Sweden.     

Cryopreservation and post-thawed fertility of ram semen frozen in different trehalose concentrations

We evaluated freeze-thawing tolerance of heterospermic ram spermatozoa (Pampinta breed) in a base diluent (Tris, citric acid, fructose, egg yolk, glycerol) with the addition of different trehalose concentrations (0-400 mOsm). We chose sperm motility, acrosome integrity and hypo-osmotic swelling test as parameters to evaluate cryopreservation capacity. We obtained the best results for 50 and 100 mOsm trehalose-supplemented extenders, with values (referred to fresh semen values) of 65% for motility, 75% for acrosome integrity and 50% for hypo-osmotic swelling test, while freeze-thawing tolerance diminished significantly for 200 and 400 mOsm of the disaccharide. Fertility values measured at lambing were 47.1 and 44.6% (2 consecutive years), using semen cryopreserved in 100 mOsm trehalose-containing diluent, which is 2.5 times greater than those obtained with the base diluent (18.5 and 14.5%). We conclude that the membrane-protecting disaccharide trehalose confers a greater cryoprotective capacity to the base extender, when added up to 100 mOsm. This action is reflected in the different sperm membranes, the motile activity and in vivo fertility.     

Fertility of ram semen after storage at 5°C

In five experiments, fertilization, early (18–19-day) pregnancy, and lambing were examined after insemination with semen stored at 5°C in tris-fructose-egg yolk diluent.After deposition into uterine horns by surgical insemination of semen stored for 0 (control), 2, 4, 6, 8, 9 or 10 days, fertilized eggs were recovered in $\text{32}\text{34}\text{,}\text{16}\text{16}\text{,}\text{21}\text{22}\text{,}\text{15}\text{20}$, $\text{9}\text{17}\text{,}\text{2}\text{18}$ and $\text{1}\text{15}$ ewes; the 18–19-day pregnancy rates determined by progesterone assay were $\text{32}\text{48}\text{,}\text{15}\text{28}\text{,}\text{11}\text{20}\text{,}\text{12}\text{20}\text{,}\text{9}\text{20}$, $\text{2}\text{20}$ and $\text{1}\text{21}$ for the respective storage periods. There was a linear decrease in fertilization rates beyond 4 days of storage and in early pregnancy rates after 6 days of storage (P<0.001). The decline with time of storage in the fertilization rate was not associated with an increase in early embryonic loss. Surgical insemination with semen stored for 0, 4, 6, 8, 9 and 10 days resulted in 53, 35, 40, 25, 5, and 0% lambing.Single cervical (normal) insemination of a total of 281 ewes with 0, 1, 2 or 3-day-old semen, using within each semen treatment 90 × 10⁶ and 180 × 10⁶ spermatozoa, yielded mean lambing rates of 60.0, 34.3, 33.8, and 17.1%; and after using 150 × 10⁶ and 300 × 10⁶ spermatozoa in a total of 393 ewes the mean lambing rates for the above semen treatments were 69.0, 46.4, 36.1, and 24.2% (linear, P < 0.001). In both tests the lambing results were better after insemination of the higher number of spermatozoa, but the slope of decline in fertility with age of semen was not affected by the sperm dose.When single and double cervical inseminations were performed in a total of 411 ewes, with 150 × 10⁶ and 300 × 10⁶ spermatozoa per inseminate, the lambing rates for semen stored for 0, 1, 2 and 3 days were 57.7, 30.4, 26.8, and 4.7% after single insemination, and 66.7, 56.8, 46.4, and 41.5% after double inseminations. The sperm dose within method of insemination and semen treatment had no effect. The lambing rate was better after double than single insemination (P<0.001), but the slope of decline in fertility with age of semen was not significantly affected by number of inseminations.In the final experiment, involving 408 ewes, 300 μg of prostaglandin F₂α added to the inseminate did not improve the fertility of fresh semen or semen stored for 1 day.     

Fertility of ewes following artificial insemination with semen frozen in pellets or straws, a preliminary report

In two trials involving the artificial insemination of 194 ewes, the fertility of ram semen was examined following freezing, either in pellet form or in straws, and after storage in a chilled state (15 degrees C) for up to 16 hours. Estrus was synchronized in ewes by intravaginal sponge (MAP) treatment for 14 days. At sponge removal 600 IU PMSG was injected and the ewes received two inseminations 50 and 60 hours later. Fertility was assessed at lambing. In trial 1, the mean lambing rate of 52% (16 31 ) for semen frozen in pellets was higher than 29% (9 31 ) for semen frozen in straws but this difference was not significant. In trial 2, ewes inseminated with chilled semen and semen frozen in pellets had lambing rates of 83% (44 53 ) and 55% (44 79 ) respectively (P<0.001).     

The effect of thawing velocity on survival and acrosomal integrity of ram spermatozoa frozen at optimal and suboptimal rates in straws

The effect of various thawing velocities on the motility and acrosomal maintenance of ram spermatozoa frozen at 20 degrees C/min (optimal) or 2 degrees C/min (suboptimal) was studied. The freeze-thaw motility and the percentage of intact acrosomes of spermatozoa frozen at 20 degrees C/min increased progressively with the thawing velocity. In semen frozen at 2 degrees C/min, motility of spermatozoa and the percentage of intact acrosomes declined drastically when the thawing velocity obtained in air at 20 degrees C was increased by thawing in water at 20 degrees C. Thawing at higher temperatures markedly increased both motility and acrosomal preservation, but the best results with semen frozen at 2 degrees C/min were lower than those obtained with semen frozen at 20 degrees C/min. The optimal freeze-thaw conditions for semen protected by 4% glycerol were freezing at 20 degrees C/min and thawing in water at 60 or 80 degrees C for 8 or 5 sec, respectively. Semen collected from rams exposed to a decreasing photoperiod exhibited higher motility after freezing and thawing than those exposed to an increasing photoperiod. However, there was no effect on acrosomal preservation after freezing at 20 degrees C/min.     

Evaluation of a new diluent and different processing procedures for cryopreservation of ram semen

Ram semen was processed for freezing after initial dilution with a modified Tris-fructose diluent. Two aliquots were processed by cooling gradually to 5 degrees C, further dilution, equilibration and freezing in 0.5 ml straws either in pressurized liquid nitrogen (LN(2)) vapor (Method A) or on a block of dry ice (Method B). A third aliquot was cooled rapidly to 16 degrees C and then slowly to 5 degrees C, diluted further, equilibrated and frozen in straws in pressurized LN(2) vapor (Method C). The second dilution was carried out using a new diluent based on dextran-lactose. The diluted semen was equilibrated for 2 h before freezing. Semen was evaluated by artificial insemination (AI). The fertility of ewes bred by a double insemination with frozen-thawed semen processed by Methods A, B and C was 73% (n = 33), 67% (n = 30) and 80% (n = 30), respectively. In comparison, the fertility of ewes inseminated with fresh semen was 93% (n = 31). These preliminary data indicate an acceptable fertility can be achieved by AI with frozen-thawed semen processed using improved procedures.     

Effect of different thawing temperatures on the viability, in vitro fertilizing capacity and chromatin condensation of frozen boar semen packaged in 5 ml straws

The effect of two different thawing temperatures on frozen boar semen viability, in vitro fertilizing capacity and chromatin condensation and stability was studied. Freeze-thaw motility, normal apical ridge (NAR), in vitro fertilizing (IVF) capacity and chromatin condensation and stability were evaluated after thawing at 42 degrees C, 40s and 50 degrees C, 40s. Chromatin condensation degree was determined by flow cytometry, using propidium iodide as fluorochrome intercalating agent, and chromatin stability was evaluated by the same procedure after inducing sperm chromatin decondensation with ethylene diamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA) and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS). The results showed that thawing straws at 42 degrees C, 40s significantly reduced motility compared to straws thawed at 50 degrees C, 40s. NAR, penetration, monospermy and polyspermy were not different between the two groups of samples thawed at different temperatures. Chromatin was significantly more compact when thawing was performed at 50 degrees C, but its stability did not show any difference relative to thawing at 42 degrees C. It is suggested that the interactions involved in chromatin overcondensation had a non-covalent nature.     

Fertility of frozen-thawed porcine semen following controlled-rate freezing in straws

A method was developed for freezing large batches of porcine semen in straws at a controlled rate in a liquid nitrogen programmable freezer. The fertilizing potential of spermatozoa frozen by this method was examined by inseminating 220 sows with a mixture of semen from two boars. Estrus was synchronized using one of two regimens and sows were inseminated once at 34 h after human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) treatment. The average pregnancy rate at 60 d of gestation, farrowing rate and litter size were 60.9%, 51.4% and 8.8, respectively. The fertilizing potential of spermatozoa frozen by this method appeared to be similar to that reported for other methods of freezing porcine semen.     

Cryoprotectant effect of trehalose and low-density lipoprotein in extenders for frozen ram semen

This study tested trehalose and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) as cryoprotectants in extenders for frozen ram semen. In the first experiment, the extenders were Tris, with 20% egg yolk (E1-1); E1-1 with 5% glycerol (E1-2); E1-1 with 100 mM trehalose (E1-3); and E1-1 with 100 mM trehalose and 5% glycerol (E1-4). Sperm motility and membrane integrity of the E1-2, E1-3 and E1-4 extenders were greater than for E1-1 (P < 0.05), but acrosome integrity following cryopreservation did not differ. In the second experiment, the extenders were Tris, with 20% egg yolk and 100 mM trehalose (E2-1); Tris with 8% LDL and 5% glycerol (E2-2); Tris with 8% LDL and 100 mM trehalose (E2-3); and Tris with 8% LDL, 100 mM trehalose and 5% glycerol (E2-4). Sperm membrane integrity was lowest for the E2-1 extender (P < 0.05), but similar for extenders including LDL. Sperm motility post-thawing was highest for E2-2 and E2-3 extenders (P < 0.05), but acrosome integrity did not differ. Thus, extenders including trehalose and LDL as cryoprotectants recorded a post-thawing ram sperm quality similar to that achieved when using conventional cryoprotectants.     

Thawing time and nonreturn rate of bovine semen frozen in fine French straws

Bovine semen packaged in fine French straws was thawed for 8 or 25 s in warm water baths (38 +/- 2 degrees C). During 12 months, 43 inseminators performed alternately 87,486 first inseminations. The nonreturn rate was highly and significantly affected by month of first service, region, inseminator within region, herd with our without contract for progeny testing, parity group and the bull. When the semen was thawed for 25 s, the 75-day nonreturn rate was 0.54% and the 120-day nonreturn rate 0.45% higher than for 8 s. Though these differences were barely significant (P<.08, P<.16, resp.), they confirm nevertheless the observations of other authors. No significant interaction was found between thawing time and inseminator. According to the results of this trial, the semen temperature should be brought to the temperature of the water bath (38 +/- 2 degrees C) when thawed. A thawing time of 25 s is recommended.     

Fertility test for ram semen preserved at ambient temperatures by discontinuous flow dialysis

The effect of two insemination doses (250 vs 500 x 10(6) spermatozoa) and three storage periods (0,1 or 2d) on the fertility of ram semen preserved at ambient temperatures by discontinuous flow dialysis were investigated in sheep (n=54). The 21-d nonreturn rates were 55.6, 44.4 and 27.8% for the three storage periods, and 44.4 and 40% for the two insemination doses, respectively. The corresponding lambing rates were 38.9, 16.7 and 11.1% for the three storage periods, and 25.9 and 18.5% for the two insemination doses, respectively. There were no significant differences between any of the treatments (P>0.05).