Structural basis of pyrimidine specificity in the MS2 RNA hairpin-coat-protein complex.

We have determined the X-ray structures of six MS2 RNA hairpin-coat-protein complexes having five different substitutions at the hairpin loop base -5. This is a uracil in the wild-type hairpin and contacts the coat protein both by stacking on to a tyrosine side chain and by hydrogen bonding to an asparagine side chain. The RNA consensus sequence derived from coat protein binding studies with natural sequence variants suggested that the -5 base needs to be a pyrimidine for strong binding. The five -5 substituents used in this study were 5-bromouracil, pyrimidin-2-one, 2-thiouracil, adenine, and guanine. The structure of the 5-bromouracil complex was determined to 2.2 A resolution, which is the highest to date for any MS2 RNA-protein complex. All the complexes presented here show very similar conformations, despite variation in affinity in solution. The results suggest that the stacking of the -5 base on to the tyrosine side chain is the most important driving force for complex formation. A number of hydrogen bonds that are present in the wild-type complex are not crucial for binding, as they are missing in one or more of the complexes. The results also reveal the flexibility of this RNA-protein interface, with respect to functional group variation, and may be generally applicable to other RNA-protein complexes.     

Mutagenesis of a stacking contact in the MS2 coat protein-RNA complex.

The thermodynamic contribution of a stacking interaction between Tyr85 in MS2 coat protein and a single-stranded pyrimidine in its RNA binding site has been examined. Mutation of Tyr85 to Phe, His, Cys, Ser and Ala decreased the RNA affinity by 1-3 kcal/mol under standard binding conditions. Since the Phe, His and Cys 85 proteins formed UV photocrosslinks with iodouracil-containing RNA at the same rate as the wild-type protein, the mutant proteins interact with RNA in a similar manner. The pH dependence of KD for the Phe and His proteins differs substantially from the wild-type protein, suggesting that the titration of position 85 contributes substantially to the binding properties. Experiments with specifically substituted phosphorothioate RNAs confirm a hydrogen bond between the hydroxyl group of tyrosine and a phosphate predicted by the crystal structure.     

Investigating the structural basis of purine specificity in the structures of MS2 coat protein RNA translational operator hairpins

We have determined the structures of complexes between the phage MS2 coat protein and variants of the replicase translational operator in order to explore the sequence specificity of the RNA–protein interaction. The 19-nt RNA hairpins studied have substitutions at two positions that have been shown to be important for specific binding. At one of these positions, –10, which is a bulged adenosine (A) in the stem of the wild-type operator hairpin, substitutions were made with guanosine (G), cytidine (C) and two non-native bases, 2-aminopurine (2AP) and inosine (I). At the other position, –7 in the hairpin loop, the native adenine was substituted with a cytidine. Of these, only the G-10, C-10 and C-7 variants showed interpretable density for the RNA hairpin. In spite of large differences in binding affinities, the structures of the variant complexes are very similar to the wild-type operator complex. For G-10 substitutions in hairpin variants that can form bulges at alternative places in the stem, the binding affinity is low and a partly disordered conformation is seen in the electron density maps. The affinity is similar to that of wild-type when the base pairs adjacent to the bulged nucleotide are selected to avoid alternative conformations. Both purines bind in a very similar way in a pocket in the protein. In the C-10 variant, which has very low affinity, the cytidine is partly inserted in the protein pocket rather than intercalated in the RNA stem. Substitution of the wild-type adenosine at position –7 by pyrimidines gives strongly reduced affinities, but the structure of the C-7 complex shows that the base occupies the same position as the A-7 in the wild-type RNA. It is stacked in the RNA and makes no direct contact with the protein.     

Crystal Structure of the Bacteriophage Qβ Coat Protein in Complex with the RNA Operator of the Replicase Gene

The coat proteins of single-stranded RNA bacteriophages specifically recognize and bind to a hairpin structure in their genome at the beginning of the replicase gene. The interaction serves to repress the synthesis of the replicase enzyme late in infection and contributes to the specific encapsidation of phage RNA. While this mechanism is conserved throughout the Leviviridae family, the coat protein and operator sequences from different phages show remarkable variation, serving as prime examples for the co-evolution of protein and RNA structure. To better understand the protein–RNA interactions in this virus family, we have determined the three-dimensional structure of the coat protein from bacteriophage Qβ bound to its cognate translational operator. The RNA binding mode of Qβ coat protein shares several features with that of the widely studied phage MS2, but only one nucleotide base in the hairpin loop makes sequence-specific contacts with the protein. Unlike in other RNA phages, the Qβ coat protein does not utilize an adenine-recognition pocket for binding a bulged adenine base in the hairpin stem but instead uses a stacking interaction with a tyrosine side chain to accommodate the base. The extended loop between β strands E and F of Qβ coat protein makes contacts with the lower part of the RNA stem, explaining the greater length dependence of the RNA helix for optimal binding to the protein. Consequently, the complex structure allows the proposal of a mechanism by which the Qβ coat protein recognizes and discriminates in favor of its cognate RNA.     

Using phosphorothioate-substituted RNA to investigate the thermodynamic role of phosphates in a sequence specific RNA-protein complex

Part of the binding affinity and specificity in RNA-protein complexes is often contributed by contacts between the protein and backbone phosphates that are held in position by the RNA structure. This study focuses on the well-characterized interaction between a dimer of the MS2 coat protein and a small RNA hairpin. Using a short oligoribonucleotide which contains all the necessary sequence elements required for tight protein binding, a single phosphorothioate linkage was introduced at 13 different positions. In each case, the R(P) and S(P) stereoisomers were separated and their affinities to the MS2 coat protein were determined. Comparison of these biochemical data with the crystal structure of the protein-hairpin complex indicates that introduction of a phosphorothioate only affects binding at sites where a protein-phosphate contact is observed in the crystal structure. This means that phosphorothioate-containing oligoribonucleotides should also be useful for mapping phosphate contacts in RNA-protein complexes for which no crystal structure is available.     

StreptoTag: a novel method for the isolation of RNA-binding proteins

We describe a fast and simple one-step affinity-purification method for the isolation of specific RNA-binding proteins. An in vitro-transcribed hybrid RNA consisting of an aptamer sequence with high binding specificity to the antibiotic streptomycin and a putative protein-binding RNA sequence is incubated with crude extract. After complex formation, the sample is applied to an affinity column containing streptomycin immobilized to Sepharose. The binding of the in vitro-assembled RNA-protein complex to streptomycin-Sepharose is mediated by the aptamer RNA and the specifically bound proteins are recovered from the affinity matrix by elution with the antibiotic. Employing two well-characterized RNA-protein interactions, we tested the performance of this new method. The spliceosomal U1A protein and the bacteriophage MS2 coat protein could be isolated via their appropriate RNA motif containing hybrid RNA from crude yeast extracts in high yield and purity after only one round of affinity purification. As the purification principle is independent of the extract source, this new affinity chromatography strategy that makes use of an in vitro-selected antibiotic-binding RNA as a tag, "StreptoTag," should be applicable to extracts from other organisms as well. Therefore, we propose StreptoTag to be a versatile tool for the isolation of unknown RNA-binding proteins.     

Modifying the specificity of an RNA backbone contact.

The interaction between the MS2 bacteriophage coat protein homodimer and its cognate RNA hairpin is facilitated by 21 different RNA-protein contacts. In one of these contacts, the 2'-hydroxyl group at ribose -5 of the RNA acts as a hydrogen bond donor to Glu63 in one subunit of the protein. Previous experiments showed that substitution of ribose -5 with deoxyribose resulted in a 24-fold decrease in binding affinity between RNA and protein. Using a protein where the two MS2 monomers were fused to increase stability, the contribution of this contact to the overall binding affinity was investigated by site-directed mutagenesis. When Glu63 was substituted with glutamine, aspartate, or alanine, the binding affinity of the hairpin for the protein was weakened by 12 to 100-fold, similar to that observed with deoxyribose at position -5. However, the specificity of the three mutant proteins for RNAs with various modifications at the 2'-position of ribose -5 differed dramatically. While the Glu63Asp protein resembled the wild-type protein in preferring the 2'-hydroxyl group over a proton or a bulky 2'-substituent, both the Glu63Ala and Glu63Gln proteins preferred bulky 2'-substituents over the 2'-hydroxyl group by more than 100-fold. These experiments emphasize the ease with which the specificity of a protein-nucleic acid interaction can be changed at thermodynamically important sites.     

Deletion of a single hydrogen bonding atom from the MS2 RNA operator leads to dramatic rearrangements at the RNA-coat protein interface

The MS2 coat protein binds specifically to an RNA hairpin formed within the viral genome. By soaking different RNA fragments into crystals of MS2 coat protein capsids it is possible to determine the X-ray structure of the RNA–protein complexes formed. Here we present the structure to 2.85 Å resolution of a complex between a chemically modified RNA hairpin variant and the MS2 coat protein. This RNA variant has a substitution at the –5 base position, which has been shown previously to be pyrimidine-specific and is a uracil in the wild-type RNA. The modified RNA hairpin contains a pyridin-4-one base (4one) at this position that lacks the exocyclic 2-oxygen eliminating the possibility of forming a hydrogen bond to asparagine A87 in the protein. The 4one complex structure shows an unprecedented major conformational change in the loop region of the RNA, whereas there is almost no change in the conformation of the protein.     

Crystal structure of the coat protein from the GA bacteriophage: model of the unassembled dimer.

There are four groups of RNA bacteriophages with distinct antigenic and physicochemical properties due to differences in surface residues of the viral coat proteins. Coat proteins also play a role as translational repressor during the viral life cycle, binding an RNA hairpin within the genome. In this study, the first crystal structure of the coat protein from a Group II phage GA is reported and compared to the Group I MS2 coat protein. The structure of the GA dimer was determined at 2.8 A resolution (R-factor = 0.20). The overall folding pattern of the coat protein is similar to the Group I MS2 coat protein in the intact virus (Golmohammadi R, Valegård K, Fridborg K, Liljas L. 1993, J Mol Biol 234:620-639) or as an unassembled dimer (Ni Cz, Syed R, Kodandapani R. Wickersham J, Peabody DS, Ely KR, 1995, Structure 3:255-263). The structures differ in the FG loops and in the first turn of the alpha A helix. GA and MS2 coat proteins differ in sequence at 49 of 129 amino acid residues. Sequence differences that contribute to distinct immunological and physical properties of the proteins are found at the surface of the intact virus in the AB and FG loops. There are six differences in potential RNA contact residues within the RNA-binding site located in an antiparallel beta-sheet across the dimer interface. Three differences involve residues in the center of this concave site: Lys/Arg 83, Ser/Asn 87, and Asp/Glu 89. Residue 87 was shown by molecular genetics to define RNA-binding specificity by GA or MS2 coat protein (Lim F. Spingola M, Peabody DS, 1994, J Biol Chem 269:9006-9010). This sequence difference reflects recognition of the nucleotide at position -5 in the unpaired loop of the translational operators bound by these coat proteins. In GA, the nucleotide at this position is a purine whereas in MS2, it is a pyrimidine.     

Asymmetric contributions to RNA binding by the Thr(45) residues of the MS2 coat protein dimer.

A prominent feature of the interaction of MS2 coat protein with RNA is the quasi-symmetric insertion of a bulged adenine (A-10) and a loop adenine (A-4) into conserved pockets on each subunit of the coat protein dimer. Because of its presence in both of these adenine-binding pockets, Thr(45) is thought to play an important role in interaction with RNA on both subunits of the dimer. To test the significance of Thr(45), we introduced all 19 amino acid substitutions. However, we were initially unable to determine the effects of the mutations on RNA binding because every substitution compromised the ability of coat protein to fold correctly. Genetic fusion of coat protein subunits reverted these protein structural defects, allowing us to show that the RNA binding activity of coat protein tolerates substitution of Thr(45), but only on one or the other subunit of the dimer. Single-chain heterodimer complementation experiments suggest that the primary site of Thr(45) interaction with RNA is with A-4 in the translational operator. Either contact of Thr(45) with A-10 makes little contribution to stability of the RNA-protein complex, or the effects of Thr(45) substitution are offset by conformational adjustments that introduce new, favorable contacts at nearby sites.     

Probing the kinetics of formation of the bacteriophage MS2 translational operator complex: identification of a protein conformer unable to bind RNA

We have investigated the kinetics of complex formation between bacteriophage MS2 coat protein subunits and synthetic RNA fragments encompassing the natural translational operator site, or the consensus sequences of three distinct RNA aptamer families, which are known to bind to the same site on the protein. Reactions were assayed using stopped-flow fluorescence spectroscopy and either the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of the protein or the signals from RNA fragments site-specifically substituted with the fluorescent adenosine analogue 2'-deoxy, 2-aminopurine. The kinetics observed were independent of the fluorophore being monitored or its position within the complex, indicating that the data report global events occurring during complex formation. Competition assays show that the complex being formed consists of a single coat protein dimer and one RNA molecule. The binding reaction is at least biphasic. The faster phase, constituting 80-85 % of the amplitude, is a largely diffusion driven RNA-protein interaction (k1 approximately 2x10(9) M(-1) s(-1)). The salt dependence of the forward reaction and the similarities of the on-rates of lower-affinity RNA fragments are consistent with a diffusion-controlled step dominated by electrostatic steering. The slower phase is independent of reactant concentration, and appears to correspond to isomerisation of the coat protein subunit(s) prior to RNA binding (k(iso) approximately 0.23 s(-1)). Measurements with a coat protein mutant (Pro78Asn) show that this phase is not due to cis-trans isomerisation at this residue. The conformational changes in the protein ligand during formation of an RNA-protein complex might play a role in the triggering of capsid self-assembly and a model for this is discussed.     

Use of synthetic oligoribonucleotides to probe RNA-protein interactions in the MS2 translational operator complex.

Synthetic oligoribonucleotides have been used to probe the interaction of MS2 coat protein with the translational operator of the MS2 replicase gene. We have investigated the possible formation of a transient covalent bond between the single-stranded uridine residue, at position -5, and a cysteine side-chain on the coat protein, by the incorporation of a chemically modified residue (5-BrU) at this position. This chemically synthesised operator variant has a binding constant of between 10 and 50 times greater than that of the wild type and is therefore comparable with the tight binding variant having a cytidine substituted at the -5 position. Dissociation kinetics show that the complex with the 5-BrU operator is more stable than the -5C variant; a result which is consistent with the formation of a Michael adduct at the -5 position. In addition, a number of other chemical variants of the operator have been analysed. These include operators incorporating deoxyadenine residues at each of the important single-stranded adenine sites. Recently the Michael adduct proposal has been challenged on the basis of mutagenesis of the coat protein cysteine residues. These results are discussed in the light of our data in support of Michael adduct formation.     

Sequence determinants for the recognition of the fork junction DNA containing the -10 region of promoter DNA by E. coli RNA polymerase

It has been recently suggested that E. coli RNA polymerase can specifically recognize a fork junction DNA structure, suggesting a possible role for such interaction in promoter DNA melting [Guo, Y., and Gralla, J. D. (1998) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 95, 11655-11660]. We have determined here quantitatively, using a site-specific binding assay, the effects of base substitutions within the conserved -10 hexamer in the context of a short fork junction DNA on binding to RNA polymerase. Adenine at position -11 and thymine at position -7 were found to be critical for sequence-specific recognition of the DNA. The identities of bases at positions -9 and -8 were found to be not important for the binding whereas replacement of bases at positions -12 and -10 had a mild negative effect on the binding affinity. It was found that for the binding of fork DNA to RNA polymerase, specific sequence recognition was more important than specific recognition of fork junction DNA structure. The pattern of relative importance of bases in the -10 region for binding RNA polymerase was generally consistent with the sequence conservation pattern observed in nature where positions -11 and -7 are the most conserved. Binding experiments with a series of adenine analogues at position -11 revealed that the N1 nitrogen of adenine was a critical determinant for the preference of the adenine at this position, suggesting a mechanism for the nucleation of promoter DNA melting initiation in which RNA polymerase destabilizes duplex DNA by directly competing with the thymine of the A-T base pair for hydrogen bonding to the N1 position of the -11 nontemplate strand adenine.     

Folding of the SAM aptamer is determined by the formation of a K-turn-dependent pseudoknot

The S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) riboswitch is one of the most recurrent riboswitches found in bacteria and has three known different natural aptamers. The Bacillus subtilis yitJ SAM riboswitch aptamer is organized around a four-way junction which is characterized by the presence of a pseudoknot and a K-turn motif. By replacing the adenine involved in a Watson-Crick base pair at position 138 in the core region of the aptamer with the fluorescent analogue 2-aminopurine (2AP), we show that the ligand-induced reorganization of the aptamer strongly attenuates 2AP fluorescence. The fluorescence quenching process is specific to SAM on the basis of the observation that the structural analogue S-adenosylhomocysteine does not promote a similar effect. We find that the pseudoknot is important for the reorganization of the core domain and that the K-turn motif also has a marked influence on the core domain reorganization, most probably through its important role in pseudoknot formation. Finally, we show that SAM riboswitch ligand binding is facilitated by the L7Ae K-turn binding protein, which suggests that K-turn motifs may be protein anchor sites used by riboswitches to promote RNA folding.     

RNA Recognition by the MS2 Phage Coat Protein

The interaction of MS2 coat protein and its translational operator hairpin is a very well-characterized RNA–protein complex. The recent high-resolution cocrystal structure successfully explains many biochemical experiments measuring the affinity of the protein–RNA interaction for mutant proteins and chemically modified RNAs. However, an analysis of a tight binding variant of the RNA suggests that the conformation of the free RNA is also an important determinant of the affinity.     

Structural basis of the highly efficient trapping of the HIV Tat protein by an RNA aptamer

An RNA aptamer containing two binding sites exhibits extremely high affinity to the HIV Tat protein. We have determined the structure of the aptamer complexed with two argininamide molecules. Two adjacent U:A:U base triples were formed, which widens the major groove to make space for the two argininamide molecules. The argininamide molecules bind to the G bases through hydrogen bonds. The binding is stabilized through stacking interactions. The structure of the aptamer complexed with a Tat-derived arginine-rich peptide was also characterized. It was suggested that the aptamer structure is similar for both complexes and that the aptamer interacts with two different arginine residues of the peptide simultaneously at the two binding sites, which could explain the high affinity to Tat.     

Conformational plasticity of RNA for target recognition as revealed by the 2.15?? crystal structure of a human IgG–aptamer complex

Aptamers are short single-stranded nucleic acids with high affinity to target molecules and are applicable to therapeutics and diagnostics. Regardless of an increasing number of reported aptamers, the structural basis of the interaction of RNA aptamer with proteins is poorly understood. Here, we determined the 2.15 Å crystal structure of the Fc fragment of human IgG1 (hFc1) complexed with an anti-Fc RNA aptamer. The aptamer adopts a characteristic structure fit to hFc1 that is stabilized by a calcium ion, and the binding activity of the aptamer can be controlled many times by calcium chelation and addition. Importantly, the aptamer–hFc1 interaction involves mainly van der Waals contacts and hydrogen bonds rather than electrostatic forces, in contrast to other known aptamer–protein complexes. Moreover, the aptamer–hFc1 interaction involves human IgG-specific amino acids, rendering the aptamer specific to human IgGs, and not crossreactive to other species IgGs. Hence, the aptamer is a potent alternative for protein A affinity purification of Fc-fusion proteins and therapeutic antibodies. These results demonstrate, from a structural viewpoint, that conformational plasticity and selectivity of an RNA aptamer is achieved by multiple interactions other than electrostatic forces, which is applicable to many protein targets of low or no affinity to nucleic acids.     

Core requirements of the adenine riboswitch aptamer for ligand binding

The adenine riboswitch aptamer, the A box, positively regulates gene expression upon adenine binding. To provide insight into structure-function relationships, important for the adenine riboswitch aptamer, we have created alignments for six aptamer sequences that reveal the core requirements. In addition, 2-aminopurine (2AP) binding studies have been used to test the consensus sequence derived from the alignment. Overall, the consensus secondary structure is consistent with 2AP binding studies. However, a position in the core, previously identified as variable, shows restriction in nucleotide sequence. Furthermore, this restriction is found to be related with the ligand specificity of the riboswitch. The implications of this relationship for the riboswitch gene regulation mechanism are discussed.