Equilibrium studies of the cyclic AMP receptor protein-DNA interaction

The binding of the Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) to restriction fragments containing the lac promoter-operator region has been investigated as a function of cAMP concentration, using a sensitive gel electrophoresis assay. Under standard conditions (13 mM ionic strength), the equilibrium constant for CAP binding to its primary site on a 203 base-pair lac promoter fragment is 6.3 X 10(8) M-1 at 0.2 microM-cAMP, and increases to 8.4 X 10(10) M-1 at 5.0 microM-cAMP. The latter is about 10(5) times larger than the equilibrium constant for binding to an isolated, non-specific site. The L8 mutation, which renders the lac promoter unresponsive to CAP in vivo, lowers this binding affinity by five- to tenfold. Analysis of the cAMP dependency of binding over the concentration range of 0.2 microM to 10 microM reveals that uptake of a single equivalent of cAMP is required for site-specific binding. Similarly, the transfer of CAP from a non-specific DNA site to a specific site requires the net uptake of a single molecule of cAMP. In contrast, co-operative non-specific binding to DNA was found to be independent of cAMP concentration with an equilibrium binding constant of 6 X 10(6) M-1. We conclude that the cAMP affinity of the two CAP subunits in the specific promoter complex is not equal, and that the complex structure therefore deviates significantly from twofold symmetry. A model for the regulation of the lac promoter by the intracellular cAMP concentration is proposed on the basis of the equilibrium binding results.     

Solution conformations of DNAs containing binding sites of the catabolite gene activator protein and lac repressor protein: characterization by Raman spectroscopy

Raman spectra from three subfragments of the Escherichia coli lactose promoter region were obtained in 0.1 M NaCl. The three DNAs are 21, 40, and 62 bp in length. The 21 and 62 bp DNAs contain the binding site for the catabolite gene activator protein (CAP). The 40 bp DNA contains the binding site for the lac repressor. A quantitative analysis of Raman band characteristics indicates an overall B-type conformation for these gene regulatory sites. Bands which correspond to A-family (807 cm-1) and B-family (834 cm-1) deoxyribose phosphate vibrations have the same intensities as bands found in heterogeneous DNAs. The spectra of the 21 bp CAP site have, however, a small band at 867 cm-1 and several other small differences similar to some characteristics observed in C-DNA spectra. Several dG nucleosides in the CAP site appear to be altered from the conventional C2'-endo/anti conformation. At 45 degrees C, well below the melting region of these DNAs, small changes occur in the spectra of the 40 bp lac repressor site which are not observed in the other DNAs. A weak band occurs at 705 cm-1, and intensity changes are observed at 497, 682, and 792 cm-1. The changes suggest that the conformations of several dG nucleosides are altered and that a small region may exist with characteristics of an A-family backbone. This conformational change at 45 degrees C coincides with previous NMR observations indicating an enhanced imino proton exchange rate at a GTG sequence within the lac operator site.     

Specific binding of the cAMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli to the lactose operon promoter

The nitrocellulose filter binding assay has been used to study effects of pH, temperature, ionic strength and magnesium ions on the specific binding of the cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cAMP) receptor protein (CAP) to the promoter of the lactose (lac) operon of Escherichia coli. The pH has a significant effect on binding with the greatest amount of specific binding appearing at pHs near 7 with a gradual decrease in binding as the pH is increased to 8. Specific binding was observed at temperatures of 22 degrees C and 37 degrees C but not at 4 degrees C. The specific binding was also found to be a function of the concentration of magnesium acetate and potassium chloride, being dependent on the specific cation present, the total ionic strength, and the concentration of the CAP protein. All binding decreases as the ionic strength, increases, but this decrease occurs at a lower ionic strength in magnesium acetate than in potassium chloride. In a double label experiment the filter assay demonstrates that the cAMP-CAP complex preferentially binds to the wild-type lac promoter in the presence of a lac promoter mutated at the CAP binding site. Based on these results and comparisons with other experiments reported in the literature, buffer conditions that approximate the physiological state of a cell appear to be best for studying the interaction between CAP and the lactose promoter in vitro.     

CAP binding to B and Z forms of DNA.

We have examined the interaction between the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) and a small DNA fragment containing its specific recognition sequence by circular dichroism spectroscopy. The binding of CAP to this fragment induces a B to "C-like" change in the CD spectrum, which is different from that observed for non-specific binding. A one-to-one (CAP dimer to DNA) binding stoichiometry was deduced from spectroscopic titration data, as was a non-specific binding site size of 17 bp/dimer. In addition, we have compared the non-specific binding affinity of CAP for the B and Z forms of synthetic DNA copolymers. A slight preference for the B form was found. These results do not support the recent specific suggestion that CAP binds to a left-handed form of DNA (1), but indicate more generally that an optically detectable conformational change takes place in DNA on binding CAP.     

NMR study of the structural changes induced in the E. coli lac promoter by the specific binding of the CAP protein.

We have studied the binding of the CAP protein to an 18 base pair lac promoter sequence comprising the core of the CAP recognition sequence. Specific binding of this sequence was established by competition binding assays and comparison of the relative affinities of a number of lac promoter, lac operator, and unspecific sequences of different lengths. The effect of the binding of CAP to the 18 base pair promoter sequence and, for comparison, to an 18 base pair symmetric operator and an oligonucleotide of unrelated sequence have been studied by 1H NMR. Binding of CAP does not bring about any changes in the chemical shift values of the imino proton resonances of the DNA, but causes the selective line broadening of two of the resonances. The comparison of these data with results of gel retardation assays published previously (1) allows the identification and localization of a kink induced in the DNA by the CAP binding to its specific site on the lac promoter.     

Cloning DNA restriction endonuclease fragments with protruding single-stranded ends

A new method of in vitro recombination was employed to construct plasmids containing lac promoter fragments 64 bp and 144 bp long. The 64 bp HpaII-HhaI fragment contains the binding site for the catabolite activator protein (CAP). The HpaII-HaeIII 144 bp fragment includes the binding sites for RNA polymerase, the lac repressor and CAP. The method utilizes the ability of T4 DNA polymerase to make flush-ended DNA either by filling in a recessed 3'-end or by exonucleolytic removal of a protruding 3'-end. The treated fragments were then blunt-end ligated to the filled-in EcoRI cloning sites of the plasmids pVH51 and pBR322 using T4 ligase. In this process, the EcoRI sites were regenerated on the fragment ends thus facilitating the subsequent isolation of the fragments from their cloning vectors.     

Specific DNA binding of the cAMP receptor protein within the lac operon stabilizes double-stranded DNA in the presence of cAMP

The effects of varying amounts of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) in the presence and absence of cAMP on the melting and differential melting curves of a 301-bp fragment containing the lac control region in 5 mM Na+ have been investigated. The native 301-bp fragment consists of three cooperatively melting thermalites. At 5 mM Na+, thermalite I (155 bp) has a Tm of 66.4 degrees C and the melting transitions of thermalites II (81 bp) and III (65 bp) are superimposed with a Tm of 61.9 degrees C. The specific DNA target site for CRP and the lac promotor are located within thermalite II. CRP alone exerts no specific effects on the melting of the 301-bp fragment, non-specific DNA binding of CRP resulting in a progressive stabilization of the double-stranded DNA by increasing the number of base pairs melting at a higher Tm in a non-cooperative transition. The cAMP-CRP complex, however, exerts a specific effect with a region of approximately 36 bp, comprising the specific CRP binding site and a neighbouring region of DNA, being stabilized. The appearance of this new cooperatively melting region, known as thermalite IV, is associated with a corresponding decrease in the area of thermalites II/III. The Tm of thermalite IV is 64.4 degrees C, 2.5 degrees C higher than that of thermalites II/III. With two or more cAMP-CRP complexes bound per 301-bp fragment, the stabilization also affects the remaining 110 bp now making up thermalites II/III whose Tm is increased by 1 degrees C to 62.9 degrees C. The implications of these findings for various models of the mode of action of the cAMP-CRP complex are discussed.     

Kinetics and mechanism in the reaction of gene regulatory proteins with DNA

We have measured the kinetic properties of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein (CAP) and lac repressor interacting with lac promoter restriction fragments. Under our reaction conditions (10 mM-Tris X HCl (pH 8.0 at 21 degrees C), 1 mM-EDTA, 10 microM-cAMP, 50 micrograms bovine serum albumin/ml, 5% glycerol), the association of CAP is at least a two-step process, with an initial, unstable complex formed with rate constant kappa a = 5(+/- 2.5) X 10(7) M-1 s-1. Subsequent formation of a stable complex occurs with an apparent bimolecular rate constant kappa a = 6.7 X 10(6) M-1 s-1. At low total DNA concentration, the dissociation rate constant for the specific CAP-DNA complex is 1.2 X 10(-4) s-1. The ratio of formation and dissociation rate constants yields an estimate of the equilibrium constant, Keq = 5 X 10(10) M-1, in good agreement with static results. We observed that the dissociation rate constant of both CAP-DNA and repressor-DNA complexes is increased by adding non-specific "catalytic" DNA to the reaction mixture. CAP dissociation by the concentration-dependent pathway is second-order in added non-specific DNA, consistent with either the simultaneous or the sequential participation of two DNA molecules in the reaction mechanism. The results imply a role for distal DNA in assembly-disassembly of specific CAP-DNA complexes, and are consistent with a model in which the subunits in the CAP dimer separate in the assembly-disassembly process. The dissociation of lac repressor-operator complexes was found to be DNA concentration-dependent as well, although in contrast to CAP, the reaction is first-order in catalytic DNA. Added excess operator-rich DNA gave more rapid dissociation than equivalent concentrations of non-specific DNA, indicating that the sequence content of the competing DNA influences the rate of repressor dissociation. The simplest interpretation of these observations is that lac repressor can be transferred directly from one DNA molecule to another. A comparison of the translocation rates calculated for direct transfer with those predicted by the one-dimensional sliding model indicates that direct transfer may play a role in the binding site search of lac repressor.     

High resolution experimental and theoretical thermal denaturation studies on small overlapping restriction fragments containing the Escherichia coli lactose genetic control region

The distribution of thermal stability in the Escherichia coli lac control region is evaluated from the melting behavior of 5 short (80-219 base pairs (bp)) sequenced DNA restriction fragments containing various parts of this sequence. The thermal denaturation of these fragments was measured at 3 salt concentrations. The previous notion that the melting curves for small fragments are sharp and asymmetric in 0.01 M Na+ and broadened and less asymmetric at 0.105 and 0.505 M Na+ is confirmed and the possible explanations are discussed. The existence of two thermodynamic boundaries in this region is also confirmed. The exact location of the boundary upstream of the cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) binding site is accurately determined from melting experiments at 260 and 282 nm. The secondary boundary located between the promoter and operator sequence is apparent at the two higher salt concentrations and begins to disappear at the lower salt concentration. The physical interpretation of the melting experiments is compared to the results of theoretical predictions derived from the known sequence of the fragments.     

TET repressor.tet operator complex formation induces conformational changes in the tet operator DNA.

The structural changes of the tet operator DNA upon binding of the TET repressor protein are examined by circular dichroism. For this purpose a 70 bp DNA fragment was prepared which contains both tet operators. About 67% of the base pairs of this DNA are involved in specific interaction with the TET repressor. A rather large change in the CD of the DNA is induced by binding of the TET repressor. The shape of the CD difference spectrum is similar to the respective difference found for the lac operator DNA upon complex formation with the lac repressor. However, the effect induced by the TET repressor on tet operator DNA seems to comprise both the specific and non-specific effect of the lac repressor on the structure of DNA [Culard, F. and Maurizot, J.C. (1981) Nucl. Acids Res. 9, 5157-5184]. Specificity of binding is confirmed by the lack of any effect of the TET repressor on the CD of a 95 bp lac operator containing DNA fragment, by the reduced mobility of TET repressor.tet operator complexes on polyacrylamide gels under CD conditions, and by a titration experiment of tet operator DNA with TET repressor employing the CD change. The latter experiment reveals a stoichiometry of four TET repressors per tet operon control region.     

Mutants of the lac promoter with large insertions and deletions between the CAP binding site and the -35 region

A set of the lac promoter mutants that have varying lengths of the spacer between the CAP binding site and the -35 region was constructed. The mutants have the spacer length increased by five (I5 mutant), or eleven (I11) residues or decreased by eleven residues (D11). We also present a construction of the hybrid between the gal and lac promoters in which the CAP binding site and the -35 region of the gal promoter are fused to the lac -10 region. The promoter fragments were assembled through ligations of chemically synthesized oligodeoxynucleotides and cloned into a pBR322-derivative vector. The results of the in vivo assays of promoter activity show that the I11 mutation results in an active but weak promoter that can be stimulated by CAP, though to a lesser degree than the wild-type lac promoter. The other mutants exhibit no promoter activity. Since the insertion of 11-bp preserves the location of the CAP binding site on the same side on the DNA helix, the data demonstrate the importance of spatial alignment between the CAP binding site and the promoter. The fact that the gal::lac hybrid is inactive as a promoter indicates also that catabolite activation is a highly complex process in which the -35 and -10 regions cannot be easily exchanged between promoters.     

Specific and non-specific interactions of integration host factor with DNA: thermodynamic evidence for disruption of multiple IHF surface salt-bridges coupled to DNA binding.

Site-specific DNA binding of architectural protein integration host factor (IHF) is involved in formation of functional multiprotein-DNA assemblies in Escherichia coli, while non-specific binding of IHF and other histone-like proteins serves to structure the nucleoid. Here, we report an isothermal titration calorimetry study of the thermodynamics of binding IHF to a 34 bp fragment composed entirely of the specific H' site from lambda-phage DNA. At low to moderate [K(+)] (60-100 mM), strong competition is observed between specific and non-specific binding as a result of a low specificity ratio (approximately 10(2)) and a very small non-specific site size. In this [K(+)] range, both specific and non-specific binding are enthalpy-driven, with large negative enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity changes and binding constants that are insensitive to [K(+)]. Above 100 mM K(+), only specific binding is observed, and both the binding constant and the magnitudes of enthalpy, entropy and heat capacity changes all decrease strongly with increasing [K(+)]. When interpreted in the context of the structure of the specific complex, the thermodynamics provide compelling evidence for a previously unrecognized design principle by which proteins that form extensive binding interfaces with nucleic acids control binding constants, binding site sizes and effects of temperature and ion concentrations on stability and specificity. We propose that up to 22 of the 23 IHF cationic side-chains that are located within 6 A of DNA phosphate oxygen atoms in the complex, are masked in the absence of DNA by pairing with anionic carboxylate groups in intramolecular salt-bridges (dehydrated ion-pairs). These salt-bridges increase in stability with increasing temperature and decreasing [K(+)]. To explain the unusual thermodynamics of IHF-DNA interactions, we propose that both specific and non-specific binding at low [K(+)] require disruption of salt-bridges (as many as 18 for specific binding) whereupon many of the unmasked charged groups hydrate and the cationic groups interact with DNA. From structural or thermodynamic parallels with IHF, we propose that large-scale coupling of disruption of protein salt-bridges to DNA binding is significant for other large-interface DNA wrapping proteins including the nucleosome, lac repressor core tetramer, RNA polymerase core protein, HU and SSB.     

The interaction of RNA polymerase and lac repressor with the lac control region.

We have examined the interactions of lac repressor and RNA polymerase with the DNA of the lac control region, using a method for direct visualization of the regions of DNA protected by proteins from DNAase attack. The repressor protects the operator essentially as reported by Gilbert and Maxam (1) with some small modifications. However, the evidence reported here concerning the binding of RNA polymerase to the DNA of the promoter mutant UV5 indicates that : 1) the RNA polymerase molecule binds asymmetrically to the promoter DNA, 2) RNA polymerase protects DNA sequences to within a few bases of the CAP binding site, suggesting direct interaction between polymerase and the CAP protein at this site, 3) RNA polymerase still binds to the promoter when repressor is bound to the operator, but fails to form the same extensive complex.     

CAP and RNA polymerase interactions with the lac promoter: binding stoichiometry and long range effects.

The binding stoichiometries of the complexes formed when the E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CAP) binds to 203 bp lac promoter-operator restriction fragments have been determined. Under quantitative binding conditions, a single dimer of CAP occupies each of two sites in the promoter. Different electrophoretic mobilities are observed for 1:1 complexes formed with L8-UV5 mutant, L305 mutant, and wild type promoter fragments, indicating sequence-specific structural differences between the complexes. The differences in gel mobility between L8-UV5 and wild type complexes disappear when the promoter fragments are cleaved with Hpa II restriction endonuclease. Models in which CAP alters DNA conformation or in which CAP forms a transient intramolecular bridge between two domains of a DNA molecule could account for these observations. The selective binding of RNA polymerase to CAP-promoter complexes is demonstrated: the binding of a single CAP dimer to the promoter is sufficient to stimulate subsequent polymerase binding. Functional CAP molecules are not released from the promoter on polymerase binding.