Two mutations of basic residues within the N-terminus of HMG-1 B domain with different effects on DNA supercoiling and binding to bent DNA

High mobility group (HMG) 1 protein and its two homologous DNA-binding domains, A and B ("HMG-boxes"), can bend and supercoil DNA in the presence of topoisomerase I, as well as recognize differently bent and distorted DNA structures, including four-way DNA junctions, supercoiled DNA and DNA modified with anticancer drug cisplatin. Here we show that the lysine-rich part of the linker region between A and B domains of HMG-1, the (85)TKKKFKD(91) sequence that is attached to the N-terminus of the B domain within HMG-1, is a prerequisite for a preferential binding of the B domain to supercoiled DNA. The above sequence is also essential for a high-affinity binding of the B domain to DNA containing a site-specific major 1,2-d(GpG) intrastrand DNA adduct of cisplatin. Mutation of Arg(97), but not Lys(90) [Lys(90) forms a specific cross-link with platinum(II) in major groove of cisplatin-modified DNA; Kane, S. A., and Lippard, S. J. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 2180--2188], to alanine significantly (>40-fold) reduces affinity of the B domain to cisplatin-modified DNA, inhibits the ability of the B domain to bend (ligase-mediated circularization) or supercoil DNA, and results in a loss of the preferential binding of the B domain to supercoiled DNA without affecting the structural-specificity of the HMG-box for four-way DNA junctions. Some of the reported activities of the B domain are enhanced when the B domain is covalently linked to the A domain. We propose that binding of the A/B linker region within the major DNA groove helps the two HMG-1 domains to anchor to the minor DNA groove to facilitate their DNA binding and other activities.     

Crystal structures of Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase: inferences for the mechanism of positive DNA supercoiling

Reverse gyrase is an ATP-dependent topoisomerase that is unique to hyperthermophilic archaea and eubacteria. The only reverse gyrase structure determined to date has revealed the arrangement of the N-terminal helicase domain and the C-terminal topoisomerase domain that intimately cooperate to generate the unique function of positive DNA supercoiling. Although the structure has elicited hypotheses as to how supercoiling may be achieved, it lacks structural elements important for supercoiling and the molecular mechanism of positive supercoiling is still not clear. We present five structures of authentic Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase that reveal a first view of two interacting zinc fingers that are crucial for positive DNA supercoiling. The so-called latch domain, which connects the helicase and the topoisomerase domains is required for their functional cooperation and presents a novel fold. Structural comparison defines mobile regions in parts of the helicase domain, including a helical insert and the latch that are likely important for DNA binding during catalysis. We show that the latch, the helical insert and the zinc fingers contribute to the binding of DNA to reverse gyrase and are uniquely placed within the reverse gyrase structure to bind and guide DNA during strand passage. A possible mechanism for positive supercoiling by reverse gyrases is presented.     

Probing the role of the ATP-operated clamp in the strand-passage reaction of DNA gyrase.

The high-resolution structure of the 43 kDa N-terminal fragment of the DNA gyrase B protein shows a large cavity within the protein dimer. The approximate size of this cavity is 20 A, suggesting it could accommodate a DNA helix. Computer-modelling studies of this cavity suggest that it contains a constriction, reducing the width to approximately 13 A, principally caused by the side chain of Arg286. We have used site-directed mutagenesis to alter this residue to Gln. Gyrase bearing this mutation shows virtually no supercoiling activity and near-normal relaxation and DNA cleavage activities. The mutated protein has ATPase activity which cannot be stimulated by DNA. These data support the proposed role of the 43 kDa domain as an ATP-operated clamp which binds DNA during the supercoiling cycle. The lack of DNA-dependent ATPase of the mutant may indicate that binding of DNA within the clamp is a prerequisite for stimulation of the ATPase activity.     

A critical role in structure-specific DNA binding for the acetylatable lysine residues in HMGB1

The structure-specific DNA-binding protein HMGB1 (high-mobility group protein B1) which comprises two tandem HMG boxes (A and B) and an acidic C-terminal tail, is acetylated in vivo at Lys(2) and Lys(11) in the A box. Mutation to alanine of both residues in the isolated A domain, which has a strong preference for pre-bent DNA, abolishes binding to four-way junctions and 88 bp DNA minicircles. The same mutations in full-length HMGB1 also abolish its binding to four-way junctions, and binding to minicircles is substantially impaired. In contrast, when the acidic tail is absent (AB di-domain) there is little effect of the double mutation on four-way junction binding, although binding to minicircles is reduced approximately 15-fold. Therefore it appears that in AB the B domain is able to substitute for the non-functional A domain, whereas in full-length HMGB1 the B domain is masked by the acidic tail. In no case does single substitution of Lys(2) or Lys(11) abolish DNA binding. The double mutation does not significantly perturb the structure of the A domain. We conclude that Lys(2) and Lys(11) are critical for binding of the isolated A domain and HMGB1 to distorted DNA substrates.     

Flexibility at Gly-194 is required for DNA cleavage and relaxation activity of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

The proposed mechanism of type IA DNA topoisomerase I includes conformational changes by the single enzyme polypeptide to allow binding of the G strand of the DNA substrate at the active site, and the opening or closing of the "gate" created on the G strand of DNA to the passing single or double DNA strand(s) through the cleaved G strand DNA. The shifting of an alpha helix upon G strand DNA binding has been observed from the comparison of the type IA DNA topoisomerase crystal structures. Site-directed mutagenesis of the strictly conserved Gly-194 at the N terminus of this alpha helix in Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I showed that flexibility around this glycine residue is required for DNA cleavage and relaxation activity and supports a functional role for this hinge region in the enzyme conformational change.     

DNA looping by the HMG-box domains of HMG1 and modulation of DNA binding by the acidic C-terminal domain.

We have compared HMG1 with the product of tryptic removal of its acidic C-terminal domain termed HMG3, which contains two 'HMG-box' DNA-binding domains. (i) HMG3 has a higher affinity for DNA than HMG1. (ii) Both HMG1 and HMG3 supercoil circular DNA in the presence of topoisomerase I. Supercoiling by HMG3 is the same at approximately 50 mM and approximately 150 mM ionic strength, as is its affinity for DNA, whereas supercoiling by HMG1 is less at 150 mM than at 50 mM ionic strength although its affinity for DNA is unchanged, showing that the acidic C-terminal tail represses supercoiling at the higher ionic strength. (iii) Electron microscopy shows that HMG3 at a low protein:DNA input ratio (1:1 w/w; r = 1), and HMG1 at a 6-fold higher ratio, cause looping of relaxed circular DNA at 150 mM ionic strength. Oligomeric protein 'beads' are apparent at the bases of the loops and at cross-overs of DNA duplexes. (iv) HMG3 at high input ratios (r = 6), but not HMG1, causes DNA compaction without distortion of the B-form. The two HMG-box domains of HMG1 are thus capable of manipulating DNA by looping, compaction and changes in topology. The acidic C-tail down-regulates these effects by modulation of the DNA-binding properties.     

Experimental and computational investigations of Ser10 and Lys13 in the binding and cleavage of DNA substrates by Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

Ser10 and Lys13 found near the active site tyrosine of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I are conserved among the type IA topoisomerases. Site-directed mutagenesis of these two residues to Ala reduced the relaxation and DNA cleavage activity, with a more severe effect from the Lys13 mutation. Changing Ser10 to Thr or Lys13 to Arg also resulted in loss of DNA cleavage and relaxation activity of the enzyme. In simulations of the open form of the topoisomerase–DNA complex, Lys13 interacts directly with Glu9 (proposed to be important in the catalytic mechanism). This interaction is removed in the K13A mutant, suggesting the importance of lysine as either a proton donor or a stabilizing cation during strand cleavage, while the Lys to Arg mutation significantly distorts catalytic residues. Ser10 forms a direct hydrogen bond with a phosphate group near the active site and is involved in direct binding of the DNA substrate; this interaction is disturbed in the S10A and S10T mutants. This combination of a lysine and a serine residue conserved in the active site of type IA topoisomerases may be required for correct positioning of the scissile phosphate and coordination of catalytic residues relative to each other so that DNA cleavage and subsequent strand passage can take place.     

Comparative study of the coupling between topoisomerase I activity and high-mobility group proteins in E. coli and mammalian cells

It is now well established that the HMG box DNA-binding motif can alter the topology of double-stranded DNA in several ways. Using the spermatid-specific tsHMG as a model protein of the HMG-1/-2 family, we have demonstrated that its expression in E. coli produces an increase in plasmid supercoiling density that is likely a consequence of its ability to constrain free supercoils in vivo. As demonstrated in vitro, stabilization of free DNA supercoils by tsHMG prevents topoisomerase I from gaining access to the template and could represent a mechanism for the apparent inhibition of topoisomerase I in bacteria. A similar modulation of eukaryotic topoisomerase I activity was not detected after expression of the tsHMG in mammalian cells. This differential response is discussed in terms of the marked difference in DNA packaging and accessibility of free supercoils in prokaryotic vs. eukaryotic cells.     

Interactions between HMG boxes.

Many proteins consist of subdomains that can fold and function independently. We investigate here the interaction between the two high mobility group (HMG) box subdomains of the nuclear protein rHMG1. An HMG box is a conserved amino acid sequence of approximately 80 amino acids rich in basic, aromatic and proline side chains that is active in binding DNA in a sequence or structure-specific manner. In the case of HMG1, each box can bind structural DNA substrates including four-way junctions (4WJs) and branched or kinked DNA duplexes. Since proteins containing up to six HMG boxes are known, the question arises whether linking subdomains together influences the folding or function of individual boxes. In an effort to understand interactions between individual DNA-binding domains in HMG1, we created new fusion proteins: one is an inversion of the order of the AB di-domain in HMG1 (BA); in the second, we added a third A domain C-terminal to the AB di-domain (ABA). Pairs of boxes, AB or BA, behave similarly and are functionally active. By contrast, the ABA triple subdomain construct is partially unfolded and is less active than individual boxes or di-domains. Thus, long-range inter-domain effects can influence the activity of HMG boxes.     

Hindering the strand passage reaction of human topoisomerase IIalpha without disturbing DNA cleavage, ATP hydrolysis, or the operation of the N-terminal clamp

DNA topoisomerase II is an essential enzyme that releases a topological strain in DNA by introduction of transient breaks in one DNA helix through which another helix is passed. While changing DNA topology, ATP is required to drive the enzyme through a series of conformational changes dependent on interdomain communication. We have characterized a human topoisomerase IIalpha enzyme with a two-amino acid insertion at position 351 in the transducer domain. The mutation specifically abolishes the DNA strand passage event of the enzyme, probably because of a sterical hindrance of T-segment transport. Thus, the enzyme fails to decatenate and relax DNA, even though it is fully capable of ATP hydrolysis, closure of the N-terminal clamp, and DNA cleavage. The cleavage activity is increased, suggesting that the transducer domain has a role in regulating DNA cleavage. Furthermore, the enzyme has retained a tendency to increase DNA cleavage upon nucleotide binding and also responds to DNA with elevated ATP hydrolysis. However, the DNA-mediated increase in ATP hydrolysis is lower than that obtained with the wild-type enzyme but similar to that of a cleavage-deficient topoisomerase IIalpha enzyme. Our results strongly suggest that the strand passage event is required for efficient DNA stimulation of topoisomerase II-mediated ATP hydrolysis, whereas the stimulation occurs independent of the DNA cleavage reaction per se. A comparison of the strand passage deficient-enzyme described here and the cleavage-deficient enzyme may have applications in other studies where a clear distinction between strand passage and topoisomerase II-mediated DNA cleavage is desirable.     

Localization of von willebrand factor-binding sites for platelet glycoprotein Ib and botrocetin by charged-to-alanine scanning mutagenesis

At sites of vascular injury, von Willebrand factor (VWF) mediates platelet adhesion through binding to platelet glycoprotein Ib (GPIb). Previous studies identified clusters of charged residues within VWF domain A1 that were involved in binding GPIb or botrocetin. The contribution of 28 specific residues within these clusters was analyzed by mutating single amino acids to alanine. Binding to a panel of six conformation-dependent monoclonal antibodies was decreased by mutations at Asp(514), Asp(520), Arg(552), and Arg(611) (numbered from the N-terminal Ser of the mature processed VWF), suggesting that these residues are necessary for domain A1 folding. Binding of (125)I-botrocetin was decreased by mutations at Arg(629), Arg(632), Arg(636), and Lys(667). Ristocetin-induced and botrocetin-induced binding to GPIb both were decreased by mutations at Lys(599), Arg(629), and Arg(632); among this group the K599A mutant was unique because (125)I-botrocetin binding was normal, suggesting that Lys(599) interacts directly with GPIb. Ristocetin and botrocetin actions on VWF were dissociated readily by mutagenesis. Ristocetin-induced binding to GPIb was reduced selectively by substitutions at positions Lys(534), Arg(571), Lys(572), Glu(596), Glu(613), Arg(616), Glu(626), and Lys(642), whereas botrocetin-induced binding to GPIb was decreased selectively by mutations at Arg(636) and Lys(667). The binding of monoclonal antibody B724 involved Lys(660) and Arg(663), and this antibody inhibits (125)I-botrocetin binding to VWF. The crystal structure of the A1 domain suggests that the botrocetin-binding site overlaps the monoclonal antibody B724 epitope on helix 5 and spans helices 4 and 5. The binding of botrocetin also activates the nearby VWF-binding site for GPIb that involves Lys(599) on helix 3.     

The DNA sequence specificity of HMG boxes lies in the minor wing of the structure.

To establish the basis of sequence-specific DNA recognition by HMG boxes we separately transferred the minor and major wings from the sequence-specific HMG box of TCF1 alpha into their equivalent position in the non-sequence-specific box 2 of HMG1. Thus chimera THT1 contains the minor wing (of 11 N-terminal and 25 C-terminal residues) from the HMG box of TCF1 alpha and the major wing (the 45 residue central section) from HMG1 box 2, whilst the situation is reversed in chimera HTH1. The structural integrity of the two chimeric proteins was established by CD, NMR and their binding to four-way junction DNA. Gel retardation and circular permutation assays showed that only chimera THT1, containing the TCF1 alpha minor wing, formed a sequence-specific complex and bent the DNA. The bend angle was estimated to be 59 degrees for chimera THT1 and 52 degrees for the HMG box of TCF1 alpha. Our results, in combination with mutagenesis and other data, suggests a model for the DNA binding of HMG boxes in which the N-terminal residues and part of helix 1 contact the minor groove on the outside of a bent DNA duplex.     

Structure-specific binding of the two tandem HMG boxes of HMG1 to four-way junction DNA is mediated by the A domain

We have investigated the nature of the "structure-specific" binding of the tandem A and B HMG boxes of high mobility group protein 1 (HMG1) to four-way junction DNA. AB didomain binding favours the open, planar form of the junction, as shown by reaction with potassium permanganate. Site-directed cleavage of the DNA by a 1, 10-phenanthroline-copper moiety attached to unique natural or engineered cysteine residues in the A or B domain shows that the two linked HMG boxes are not functionally equivalent in four-way junction binding. The A domain of the didomain binds to the centre of the junction, mediating structure-specific binding; the concave surface of the domain interacts with the widened minor groove at the centre, contacting one of the four strands of the junction, and the short arm comprising helices I and II and the connecting loop protrudes into the central hole. The B domain makes contacts along one of the arms, presumably stabilising the binding of the didomain through additional non-sequence-specific interactions. The isolated B domain can, however, bind to the centre of the junction. The preferential binding of the A domain of the AB didomain to the centre correlates with our previous finding of a higher preference of the isolated A domain than of the B domain for this structurally distinct DNA ligand. It is probably at least partly due to the higher positive surface potential in the DNA-binding region of the A domain (in particular to an array of positively charged side-chains suitably positioned to interact with the negatively charged phosphates surrounding the central hole of the junction) and partly to differences in residues corresponding to those that intercalate between bases in other HMG box/DNA complexes.     

Studies of a positive supercoiling machine. Nucleotide hydrolysis and a multifunctional "latch" in the mechanism of reverse gyrase

Reverse gyrase, the only topoisomerase known to positively supercoil DNA, has an N-terminal ATPase domain that drives the activity of a topoisomerase domain. This study shows that the N-terminal domain represses topoisomerase activity in the absence of nucleotide, and nucleotide binding is sufficient to relieve the repression. A "latch" region in the N-terminal part was observed to close over the topoisomerase domain in the reverse gyrase crystal structure. Mutants lacking all or part of the latch relax DNA in the absence of nucleotide, indicating that this region mediates topoisomerase repression. The mutants also show altered DNA-dependent ATPase activity, suggesting that the latch may be involved in coupling nucleotide hydrolysis to supercoiling. It is not required for this process, however, because the mutants can still positively supercoil DNA. Nucleotide hydrolysis is essential to the specificity of reverse gyrase for increasing the linking number of DNA. Although with ATP the enzyme performs strand passage always toward increasing linking number, it can increase or decrease the linking number in the presence of a nonhydrolyzable ATP analog. This suggests that the mechanism of reverse gyrase is best described by a combination of recently proposed models.     

Recombinogenic flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I

Aberration of eukaryotic topoisomerase I catalysis leads to potentially recombinogenic pathways by allowing the joining of heterologous DNA strands. Recently, a new ligation pathway (flap ligation) was presented for vaccinia virus topoisomerase I, in which blunt end cleavage complexes ligate the recessed end of duplex acceptors having a single-stranded 3'-tail. This reaction was suggested to play an important role in the repair of topoisomerase I-induced DNA double-strand breaks. Here, we characterize flap ligation mediated by human topoisomerase I. We demonstrate that cleavage complexes containing the enzyme at a blunt end allow invasion of a 3'-acceptor tail matching the scissile strand of the donor, which facilitates ligation of the recessed 5'-hydroxyl end. However, the reaction was strictly dependent on the length of double-stranded DNA of the donor complexes, and longer stretches of base-pairing inhibited strand invasion. The stabilization of the DNA helix was most probably provided by the covalently bound enzyme itself, since deleting the N-terminal domain of human topoisomerase I stimulated flap ligation. We suggest that stabilization of the DNA duplex upon enzyme binding may play an important role during normal topoisomerase I catalysis by preventing undesired strand transfer reactions. For flap ligation to function in a repair pathway, factors other than topoisomerase I, such as helicases, would be necessary to unwind the DNA duplex and allow strand invasion.     

Dissection of reverse gyrase activities: insight into the evolution of a thermostable molecular machine

Reverse gyrase is a peculiar DNA topoisomerase, specific of thermophilic microorganisms, which induces positive supercoiling into DNA molecules in an ATP-dependent reaction. It is a modular enzyme and comprises an N-terminal helicase-like module fused to a C-terminal topoisomerase IA-like domain. The exact molecular mechanism of this unique reaction is not understood, and a fundamental mechanistic question is how its distinct steps are coordinated. We studied the cross-talk between the components of this molecular motor and probed communication between the DNA-binding sites and the different activities (DNA relaxation, ATP hydrolysis and positive supercoiling). We show that the isolated ATPase and topoisomerase domains of reverse gyrase form specific physical interactions, retain their own DNA binding and enzymatic activities, and when combined cooperate to achieve the unique ATP-dependent positive supercoiling activity. Our results indicate a mutual effect of both domains on all individual steps of the reaction. The C-terminal domain shows ATP-independent topoisomerase activity, which is repressed by the N-terminal domain in the full-length enzyme; experiments with the isolated domains showed that the C-terminal domain has stimulatory influence on the ATPase activity of the N-terminal domain. In addition, the two domains showed a striking reciprocal thermostabilization effect.     

The latch modulates nucleotide and DNA binding to the helicase-like domain of Thermotoga maritima reverse gyrase and is required for positive DNA supercoiling

Reverse gyrase is the only topoisomerase that can introduce positive supercoils into DNA in an ATP-dependent process. It has a modular structure and harnesses a helicase-like domain to support a topoisomerase activity, thereby creating the unique function of positive DNA supercoiling. The isolated topoisomerase domain can relax negatively supercoiled DNA, an activity that is suppressed in reverse gyrase. The isolated helicase-like domain is a nucleotide-dependent switch that is attenuated by the topoisomerase domain. Inter-domain communication thus appears central for the functional cooperation of the two domains. The latch, an insertion into the helicase-like domain, has been suggested as an important element in coordinating their activities. Here, we have dissected the influence of the latch on nucleotide and DNA binding to the helicase-like domain, and on DNA supercoiling by reverse gyrase. We find that the latch is required for positive DNA supercoiling. It is crucial for the cooperativity of DNA and nucleotide binding to the helicase-like domain. The latch contributes to DNA binding, and affects the preference of reverse gyrase for ssDNA. Thus, the latch coordinates the individual domain activities by modulating the helicase-like domain, and by communicating changes in the nucleotide state to the topoisomerase domain.