Issues associated with residual cell-substrate DNA in viral vaccines

The presence of some residual cellular DNA derived from the production-cell substrate in viral vaccines is inevitable. Whether this DNA represents a safety concern, particularly if the cell substrate is derived from a tumor or is tumorigenic, is unknown. DNA has two biological activities that need to be considered. First, DNA can be oncogenic; second, DNA can be infectious. As part of our studies to assess the risk of residual cell-substrate DNA in viral vaccines, we have established assays that can quantify the biological activities of DNA. From data obtained using these assays, we have estimated the risk of an oncogenic or an infectious event from DNA. Because these estimates were derived from the most sensitive assays identified so far, they likely represent worst-case estimates. In addition, methods that inactivate the biological activities of DNA can be assessed and estimations of risk reduction by these treatments can be made. In this paper, we discuss our approaches to address potential safety issues associated with residual cellular DNA from neoplastic cell substrates in viral vaccines, summarize the development of assays to quantify the oncogenic and infectivity activities of DNA, and discuss methods to reduce the biological activities of DNA.     

Safety of Viral DNA in Biological Products

Data from studies of the infectivity of DNA injected directly into laboratory animals are used to estimate the potential infectivity risk of residual DNA in biological products. The potential for some novel products to contain infectious quantities of residual cellular DNA is discussed, and further study of this subject is suggested.     

DNA methylation affecting the expression of murine leukemia proviruses.

The endogenous, vertically transmitted proviral DNAs of the ecotropic murine leukemia virus in AKR embryo fibroblasts were found to be hypermethylated relative to exogenous AKR murine leukemia virus proviral DNAs acquired by infection of the same cells. The hypermethylated state of the endogenous AKR murine leukemia virus proviruses in these cells correlated with the failure to express AKR murine leukemia virus and the lack of infectivity of cellular DNA. Induction of the endogenous AKR murine leukemia virus proviruses with the methylation antagonist 5-azacytidine suggested a causal connection between DNA methylation and provirus expression. Also found to be relatively hypermethylated and noninfectious were three of six Moloney murine leukemia virus proviral DNAs in an unusual clone of infected rat cells. Recombinant DNA clones which derived from a methylated, noninfectious Moloney provirus of this cell line were found to be highly active upon transfection, suggesting that a potentially active proviral genome can be rendered inactive by cellular DNA methylation. In contrast, in vitro methylation with the bacterial methylases MHpaII and MHhaI only slightly reduced the infectivity of the biologically active cloned proviral DNA. Recombinant DNA clones which derived from a second Moloney provirus of this cell line were noninfectious. An in vitro recombination method was utilized in mapping studies to show that this lack of infectivity was governed by mechanisms other than methylation.     

Formation and structure of infectious DNA of spleen necrosis virus.

The kinetics of formation and the structure of infectious DNA of spleen necrosis virus were determined. Nonintegrated infectious viral DNA first appeared 18 to 24 h after infection of dividing cells and persisted for more than 14 days. The nonintegrated infectious viral DNA was in the form of either a double-stranded linear DNA with a molecular weight of 6 X 10(6), detected in both the cytoplasm and nucleus, or a closed circular DNA of the same molecular weight, detected primarily in the nucleus. Integrated infectious viral DNA appeared soon after the nonintegrated infectious viral DNA and was the predominant form of infectious viral DNA late after infection. Integration of the spleen necrosis virus DNA into the chicken cell genome was demonstrated by three independent criteria. Nucleic acid hybridization indicated that the linear infectious viral DNA had a 5- to 10-fold higher specific infectivity than either the closed circular or integrated infectious viral DNA. Infectious viral DNA did not appear in infected stationary cells, indicating some cellular influence on the formation of infectious viral DNA.     

Interaction of the adenoviral IVa2 protein with a truncated viral DNA packaging sequence

Adenoviral (Ad) infection typically poses little health risk for immunosufficient individuals. However, for immunocompromised individuals, such as AIDS patients and organ transplant recipients, especially pediatric heart transplant recipients, Ad infection is common and can be lethal. Ad DNA packaging is the process whereby the Ad genome becomes encapsulated by the viral capsid. Specific packaging is dependent upon the packaging sequence (PS), which is composed of seven repeated elements called A repeats. The Ad protein, IVa2, which is required for viral DNA packaging, has been shown to bind specifically to synthetic DNA probes containing A repeats I and II, however, the molecular details of this interaction have not been investigated. In this work we have studied the binding of a truncated form of the IVa2 protein, that has previously been shown to be sufficient for virus viability, to a DNA probe containing A repeats I and II. We find that the IVa2 protein exists as a monomer in solution, and that a single IVa2 monomer binds to this DNA with high affinity (K_d <  10 nM), and moderate specificity, and that the trIVa2 protein interacts in a fundamentally different way with DNA containing A repeats than it does with non-specific DNA. We also find that at elevated IVa2 concentrations, additional binding, beyond the singly ligated complex, is observed. When this reaction is modeled as representing the binding of a second IVa2 monomer to the singly ligated complex, the K_d is 1.4 ± 0.7 µM, implying a large degree of negative cooperativity exists for placing two IVa2 monomers on a DNA with adjacent A repeats.     

Cloning of Two Genetically Transmitted Moloney Leukemia Proviral Genomes: Correlation Between Biological Activity of the Cloned DNA and Viral Genome Activation in the Animal

The Mov-7 and Mov-9 substrains of mice, carrying Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) in their germ line at the Mov-7 locus and Mov-9 locus, respectively, are different with respect to virus activation. Infectious virus appears in all mice carrying the Mov-9 locus but is not activated in animals carrying the Mov-7 locus. Consequently, only Mov-9 mice develop viremia and subsequent leukemia. The endogenous M-MuLV provirus with flanking mouse sequences corresponding to the Mov-7 and Mov-9 loci was molecularly cloned. Detailed restriction maps obtained from the cloned DNAs revealed no detectable differences in the proviral genomes. The flanking mouse sequences, however, were different, confirming that the Mov-7 and Mov-9 loci represent different integration sites of M-MuLV. Both clones induced XC plaques in a transfection assay. The specific infectivity of the clones, however, was different. A total of 10⁻⁵ XC plaques per genome equivalent were induced by the Mov-9 clone, whereas only 10⁻⁹ XC plaques per genome equivalent were induced by the Mov-7 clone. Moreover, NIH 3T3 cells transfected with the Mov-9 clone produced NB-tropic M-MuLV, whereas cells transfected with the Mov-7 clone did not produce infectious virus. The results suggest that M-MuLV integrated at the Mov-7 locus carries a mutation which prevents synthesis of infectious virus but permits XC plaque induction by partial genome expression or synthesis of noninfectious particles. Thus, the pattern of virus expression in Mov-7 and Mov-9 mice correlates with the biological properties of the respective clones. Genomic DNA from Mov-9 mice was not infectious in the transfection assay (specific infectivity < 10⁻⁷ PFU per genome equivalent). As the only difference between the genomic and the cloned Mov-9 DNA appears to be the presence of 5-methylcytosine in CpG sequences, our results suggest that removal of methyl groups by molecular cloning in procaryotes permits genome expression in transfected eucaryotic cells. Our results support the hypothesis that DNA methylation is relevant not only in genome expression in the animal but also in expression of genes transfected into eucaryotic cells.     

Replication of single-stranded porcine circovirus DNA by DNA polymerases α and δ

Porcine circovirus is the only mammalian DNA virus so far known to contain a single-stranded circular genome (Tischer et al. (1982) Nature 295, 64–66). Replication of its small viral DNA (1.76 kb) appears to be dependent on cellular enzymes expressed during S-phase of the cell cycle (Tischer et al. (1987) Arch. Virol. 96, 39–57). In this paper we have exploited the porcine circovirus genome to probe for in vitro initiation and elongation of DNA replication by different preparations of calf thymus DNA polymerase α and δ as well as by a partially purified preparation from pig thymus. The results indicated that three different purification fractions of calf thymus DNA polymerase α and one from pig thymus initiate DNA synthesis at several sites on the porcine circovirus DNA. It appears that the sites at which DNA primase synthesizes primers are not entirely random. Subsequent DNA elongation by a highly purified DNA polymerase α holoenzyme which had been isolated by the criterion of replicating single-stranded M13 DNA (Ottiger et al. (1987) Nucleic Acids Res. 15, 4789–4807) is very efficient. Complete conversion to the double-stranded form is obtained in less than 1 min. When the DNA synthesis by DNA polymerase α is blocked with the DNA polymerase α specific monoclonal antibody SJK 132-20 after initiation by DNA primase, DNA polymerase δ can efficiently replicate from the primers. This in vitro DNA replication system may be used in analogy to the bacteriophage systems in E. coli to study initiation and elongation of DNA replication.     

Association between the Herpes Simplex Virus-1 DNA Polymerase and Uracil DNA Glycosylase

Herpes simplex virus-1 (HSV-1) is a large dsDNA virus that encodes its own DNA replication machinery and other enzymes involved in DNA transactions. We recently reported that the HSV-1 DNA polymerase catalytic subunit (UL30) exhibits apurinic/apyrimidinic and 5′-deoxyribose phosphate lyase activities. Moreover, UL30, in conjunction with the viral uracil DNA glycosylase (UL2), cellular apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease, and DNA ligase IIIα-XRCC1, performs uracil-initiated base excision repair. Base excision repair is required to maintain genome stability as a means to counter the accumulation of unusual bases and to protect from the loss of DNA bases. Here we show that the HSV-1 UL2 associates with the viral replisome. We identified UL2 as a protein that co-purifies with the DNA polymerase through numerous chromatographic steps, an interaction that was verified by co-immunoprecipitation and direct binding studies. The interaction between UL2 and the DNA polymerase is mediated through the UL30 subunit. Moreover, UL2 co-localizes with UL30 to nuclear viral prereplicative sites. The functional consequence of this interaction is that replication of uracil-containing templates stalls at positions −1 and −2 relative to the template uracil because of the fact that these are converted into non-instructional abasic sites. These findings support the existence of a viral repair complex that may be capable of replication-coupled base excision repair and further highlight the role of DNA repair in the maintenance of the HSV-1 genome.     

Infectivity of Proviral DNA from Avian Sarcoma Virus-Transformed Mammalian Cells

The number of Rous viral genomes in the cellular DNA from two subclones (RS2/3, RS2/6) derived from the same clone of hamster BHK-21 cells transformed by Rous sarcoma virus was determined by hybridization with viral complementary DNA made in vitro, and the capacity of the cellular DNA to infect (transfect) chicken embryo fibroblasts was compared before and after shearing this DNA to about the size of the provirus (6 x 10(6) to 7 x 10(6) daltons). The two subclones differed widely both in their capacity to give rise to virus (inducibility) after fusion with chicken embryo fibroblasts and in level of expression of viral proteins. It was shown that cells of both subclones contain a single copy of Rous DNA and yield infectious DNA. However, whereas transfection of chicken embryo fibroblasts was successful with both unsheared (>/=18 x 10(6) daltons) and sheared DNA from the most inducible subclone (RS2/3 subclone), which also expresses viral proteins to an appreciable amount, transfection with DNA from the least inducible subclone (RS2/6 subclone), in which viral proteins are not expressed, succeeded only with sheared DNA. It was then about as successful as with sheared or unsheared RS2/3 DNA. The lack of infectivity of unsheared RS2/6 DNA may be explained by the hypothesis proposed by Cooper and Temin (G. M. Cooper and H. T. Temin, J. Virol. 17:422-430, 1976) to explain the lack of infectivity of DNA from certain chicken cells producing spontaneously low amounts of RAV-0 and resistant to exogenous RAV-0 infection, that is, that the viral genome (proviral DNA) is linked to a cis-acting control element which blocks its expression. This linkage might originate, in RS2/6 cells, from translocation of cellular DNA containing the single proviral copy.     

A Distinct Triplex DNA Unwinding Activity of ChlR1 Helicase

Mutations in the human ChlR1 (DDX11) gene are associated with a unique genetic disorder known as Warsaw breakage syndrome characterized by cellular defects in genome maintenance. The DNA triplex helix structures that form by Hoogsteen or reverse Hoogsteen hydrogen bonding are examples of alternate DNA structures that can be a source of genomic instability. In this study, we have examined the ability of human ChlR1 helicase to destabilize DNA triplexes. Biochemical studies demonstrated that ChlR1 efficiently melted both intermolecular and intramolecular DNA triplex substrates in an ATP-dependent manner. Compared with other substrates such as replication fork and G-quadruplex DNA, triplex DNA was a preferred substrate for ChlR1. Also, compared with FANCJ, a helicase of the same family, the triplex resolving activity of ChlR1 is unique. On the other hand, the mutant protein from a Warsaw breakage syndrome patient failed to unwind these triplexes. A previously characterized triplex DNA-specific antibody (Jel 466) bound triplex DNA structures and inhibited ChlR1 unwinding activity. Moreover, cellular assays demonstrated that there were increased triplex DNA content and double-stranded breaks in ChlR1-depleted cells, but not in FANCJ^−/− cells, when cells were treated with a triplex stabilizing compound benzoquinoquinoxaline, suggesting that ChlR1 melting of triple-helix structures is distinctive and physiologically important to defend genome integrity. On the basis of our results, we conclude that the abundance of ChlR1 known to exist in vivo is likely to be a strong deterrent to the stability of triplexes that can potentially form in the human genome.     

Agroinfection and nucleotide sequence of cloned wheat dwarf virus DNA

Cloned DNA of the geminivirus wheat dwarf virus (WDV) was successfully used to infect seedling wheat plants. The clone was derived from circular double-stranded viral DNA isolated from naturally infected tissue. The initiation of infection was mediated by Agrobacterium tumefaciens using cloned dimeric WDV genomes in a binary Agrobacterium vector. The WDV DNA which comprised the infectious clone was sequenced and is compared with the published sequence of a Swedish isolate of the same virus. The results confirm that the single WDV genome component of 2.75 kb carries all the information necessary for production of viral symptoms, virus particles and viral double- and single-stranded DNA forms.     

Infectious mutants of cassava latent virus generated in vivo from intact recombinant DNA clones containing single copies of the genome.

Intact recombinant DNAs containing single copies of either component of the cassava latent virus genome can elicit infection when mechanically inoculated to host plants in the presence of the appropriate second component. Characterisation of infectious mutant progeny viruses, by analysis of virus-specific supercoiled DNA intermediates, indicates that most if not all of the cloning vector has been deleted, achieved at least in some cases by intermolecular recombination in vivo between DNAs 1 and 2. Significant rearrangements within the intergenic region of DNA 2, predominantly external to the common region, can be tolerated without loss of infectivity suggesting a somewhat passive role in virus multiplication for the sequences in question. Although packaging constraints might impose limits on the amount of DNA within geminate particles, isolation of an infectious coat protein mutant defective in virion production suggests that packaging is not essential for systemic spread of the viral DNA.     

DNA Genome Size Affects the Stability of the Adenovirus Virion

Replication-defective adenovirus (Ad) vectors can vary considerably in genome length, but whether this affects virion stability has not been investigated. Helper-dependent Ad vectors with a genome size of ~30 kb were 100-fold more sensitive to heat inactivation than their parental helper virus (>36 kb), and increasing the genome size of the vector significantly improved heat stability. A similar relationship between genome size and stability existed for Ad with early region 1 deleted. Loss of infectivity was due to release of vertex proteins, followed by disintegration of the capsid. Thus, not only does the viral DNA encode all of the heritable information essential for virus replication, it also plays a critical role in maintaining capsid strength and integrity.     

A replication-defective variant of Moloney murine leukemia virus. I. Biological characterization.

We have studied the virus produced by a clone, termed 8A, that was isolated from a culture of murine sarcoma virus-transformed mouse cells after superinfection with Moloney murine leukemia virus (MuLV-M). Clone 8A produced high levels of type C virus particles, but only a low titer of infectious murine sarcoma virus and almost no infectious MuLV. When fresh cultures of mouse cells were infected with undiluted clone 8A culture fluids, they released no detectable pogeny virus for several weeks after infection. Fully infectious MuLV was then produced in these cultures. This virus was indistinguishable from MuLV-M by nucleic acid hybridization tests and in its insensitivity to Fv-1 restriction. It also induced thymic lymphomas in BALB/c mice. To explain these results, we propose that cone 8A is infected with a replication-defective variant of MuLV-M. Particles produced by clone 8A, containing this defective genome, can establish an infection in fresh cells but cannot produce progency virus at detectable levels. Several weeks after infection, the defect in the viral genome is corrected by back-mutation or by recombination with endogenous viral genomes, resulting in the formation of fully infectious progeny MuLV. The progeny MuLV'S that arose in two different experiments were found to be genetically different from each other. This is consistent with the hypothesis that, in each experiment, the progeny virus is formed clone 8A cells and assayed for infectivity by the calcium phosphate transfection technique. No detectable MuLV was produced by cells treated with this DNA. This finding, along with positive results obtained in control experiments, indicates that clone 8A cells do not contain a normal MuLV provirus.     

Infectious and noninfectious recombinant clones of the provirus of SNV differ in cellular DNA and are apparently the same in viral DNA

Ten clones of Charon 4A containing proviruses of spleen necrosis virus, an avian retrovirus, and flanking chicken DNA sequences were isolated and characterized. Some clones gave rise to progeny with viral DNA sequences deleted or duplicated, probably as a result of crossing-over in the 600 bp terminal redundancy in viral DNA. The cellular sequences are different in each clone, indicating that all the proviruses are integrated in different sites in cellular DNA. Six clones are infectious and four are not. All the infectious molecules containing a provirus are of a similar size and are smaller than the noninfectious molecules containing a provirus. The viral DNA is not apparently different in eight clones, but two clones, one infectious and one noninfectious, lack two restriction sites each. Large changes in proviral DNA therefore do not seem responsible for the lack of infectivity of some clones. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that neighboring cellular DNA sequences control proviral expression (infectivity).     

DNA Ejection from an Archaeal Virus—A Single-Molecule Approach

The translocation of genetic material from the viral capsid to the cell is an essential part of the viral infection process. Whether the energetics of this process is driven by the energy stored within the confined nucleic acid or cellular processes pull the genome into the cell has been the subject of discussion. However, in vitro studies of genome ejection have been limited to a few head-tailed bacteriophages with a double-stranded DNA genome. Here we describe a DNA release system that operates in an archaeal virus. This virus infects an archaeon Haloarcula hispanica that was isolated from a hypersaline environment. The DNA-ejection velocity of His1, determined by single-molecule experiments, is comparable to that of bacterial viruses. We found that the ejection process is modulated by the external osmotic pressure (polyethylene glycol (PEG)) and by increased ion (Mg²⁺ and Na⁺) concentration. The observed ejection was unidirectional, randomly paused, and incomplete, which suggests that cellular processes are required to complete the DNA transfer.     

Prevention of Contamination by Xenotropic Murine Leukemia Virus-Related Virus: Susceptibility to Alcohol-Based Disinfectants and Environmental Stability

Xenotropic murine leukemia virus-related virus (XMRV) represents a novel γ-retrovirus that is capable of infecting human cells and has been classified as a biosafety level 2 (BSL-2) organism. Hence, XMRV represents a potential risk for personnel in laboratories worldwide. Here, we measured the stability of XMRV and its susceptibility to alcohol-based disinfectants. To this end, we exposed an infectious XMRV reporter virus encoding a secretable luciferase to different temperatures, pH values, and disinfectants and infected XMRV-permissive Raji B cells to measure residual viral infectivity. We found that 1 min treatment of XMRV particles at 60°C is sufficient to reduce infectivity by 99.9%. XMRV infectivity was maximal at a neutral pH but was reduced by 86% at pH 4 and 99.9% at pH 10. The common hand and surface disinfectants ethanol and isopropanol as well as the cell fixation reagent paraformaldehyde abrogated XMRV infectivity entirely, as indicated by a reduction of infectivity exceeding 99.99%. Our findings provide evidence of specific means to inactivate XMRV. Their application will help to prevent unintended XMRV contamination of cell cultures in laboratories and minimize the risk for laboratory personnel and health care workers to become infected with this biosafety level 2 organism.