The β clamp is an essential replication sliding clamp required for processive DNA synthesis. The β clamp is also critical for several additional aspects of DNA metabolism, including DNA mismatch repair (MMR). The
dnaN5 allele of
Bacillus subtilis encodes a mutant form of β clamp containing the G73R substitution. Cells with the
dnaN5 allele are temperature sensitive for growth due to a defect in DNA replication at 49°C, and they show an increase in mutation frequency caused by a partial defect in MMR at permissive temperatures. We selected for intragenic suppressors of
dnaN5 that rescued viability at 49°C to determine if the DNA replication defect could be separated from the MMR defect. We isolated three intragenic suppressors of
dnaN5 that restored growth at the nonpermissive temperature while maintaining an increase in mutation frequency. All three
dnaN alleles encoded the G73R substitution along with one of three novel missense mutations. The missense mutations isolated were S22P, S181G, and E346K. Of these, S181G and E346K are located near the hydrophobic cleft of the β clamp, a common site occupied by proteins that bind the β clamp. Using several methods, we show that the increase in mutation frequency resulting from each
dnaN allele is linked to a defect in MMR. Moreover, we found that S181G and E346K allowed growth at elevated temperatures and did not have an appreciable effect on mutation frequency when separated from G73R. Thus, we found that specific residue changes in the
B. subtilis β clamp separate the role of the β clamp in DNA replication from its role in MMR.Replication sliding clamps are essential cellular proteins imparting a spectacular degree of processivity to DNA polymerases during genome replication (
24,
39-
41). Encoded by the
dnaN gene, the β clamp is a highly conserved bacterial sliding clamp found in virtually all eubacterial species (reviewed in reference
7). The β clamp is a head-to-tail, ring-shaped homodimer that encircles double-stranded DNA (
1,
39). In eukaryotes and archaea, the analog of the β clamp is proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) (
15,
28,
40,
41). Eukaryotic PCNA is a ring-shaped homotrimer that also acts to encircle DNA, increasing the processivity of the replicative DNA polymerases (
40,
41). Although the primary structures of the β clamp and PCNA are not conserved, the tertiary structures of these proteins are very similar, demonstrating structural conservation among bacterial, archaeal, and eukaryotic replication sliding clamps (
28,
39-
41; reviewed in reference
6).The function of the β clamp is not limited to its well-defined role in genome replication. The
Escherichia coli β clamp binds Hda, which also binds the replication initiation protein DnaA, regulating the active form of DnaA complexed with ATP (
19,
37,
43). This allows the β clamp to regulate replication initiation through the amount of available DnaA-ATP. In
Bacillus subtilis, the β clamp binds YabA, a negative regulator of DNA replication initiation (
12,
29,
52). It has also been suggested that the
B. subtilis β clamp sequesters DnaA from the replication origin during the cell cycle through the binding of DnaA to YabA and the binding of YabA to the β clamp (
70). Thus, it is hypothesized that in
E. coli and
B. subtilis, the β clamp influences the frequency of replication initiation through interactions with Hda and YabA, respectively.The
E. coli and
B. subtilis β clamp has an important role in translesion DNA synthesis during the replicative bypass of noncoding bases by specialized DNA polymerases belonging to the Y family (
20,
33). The roles of the
E. coli β clamp in translesion synthesis are well established (
5,
8,
30,
31). Binding sites on the
E. coli β clamp that accommodate translesion polymerases pol IV (DinB) and pol V (UmuD
2′C) have been identified, and the consequence of disrupting their association with the β clamp has illustrated the critical importance of the β clamp to the activity of both of these polymerases (
4,
5,
8,
26,
30,
31,
48,
49).In addition to the involvement of the β clamp in replication initiation, DNA replication, and translesion synthesis, the
E. coli and
B. subtilis β clamp also functions in DNA mismatch repair (MMR) (
45,
46,
64). The MMR pathway recognizes and repairs DNA polymerase errors, contributing to the overall fidelity of the DNA replication pathway (reviewed in references
42 and
60). In both
E. coli and
B. subtilis, deletion of the genes
mutS and
mutL increases the spontaneous mutation frequency several hundredfold (
13,
25,
63). In
E. coli, MutS recognizes and binds mismatches, while MutL functions as a “matchmaker,” coordinating the actions of other proteins in the MMR pathway, allowing the removal of the mismatch and resynthesis of the resulting gap (reviewed in references
42 and
60). MutS and MutL of
E. coli and
B. subtilis physically interact with the β clamp (
45,
46,
51,
64). Interaction between the
B. subtilis β clamp and MutS is important for efficient MMR and organization of MutS-green fluorescent protein (GFP) into foci in response to replication errors, while the function of MutL binding to the β clamp is unknown (
64).These studies show that the β clamp is critical for several aspects of DNA metabolism in
E. coli and
B. subtilis. In
E. coli, many
dnaN alleles have been examined and used to define the mechanistic roles of the β clamp
in vivo (
5,
18,
24,
30,
31,
48,
49,
73). A limitation in studying the mechanistic roles of the
B. subtilis β clamp is that only two
dnaN alleles (β clamp) are available,
dnaN5 and
dnaN34 (
36) (
www.bgsc.org/), and both of these alleles do not support growth at temperatures above 49°C, suggesting that they may cause similar defects (
36) (
www.bgsc.org/). Of these two
dnaN alleles, only
dnaN5 has been investigated in any detail (
36,
53,
64). The mutant β clamp encoded by
dnaN5 contains a G73R substitution [
dnaN5(
G73R)] in a surface-exposed residue located on the outside rim of the β clamp (
53,
64). Our previous studies with this allele showed that
dnaN5(
G73R) confers an increase in mutation frequency at 30°C and 37°C (
64). Further characterization of
dnaN5(
G73R) showed that the increased mutation frequency is caused by a partial defect in MMR (
64). Additionally,
dnaN5(
G73R)-containing cells have a reduced ability to support MutS-GFP focus formation in response to mismatches (
64). These results support the hypothesis that G73R in the β clamp causes a defect in DNA replication at 49°C (
36) and impaired MMR manifested by a defect in establishing the assembly of MutS-GFP foci in response to replication errors (
64).To understand the roles of the
B. subtilis β clamp in MMR and DNA replication, we examined the
dnaN5 and
dnaN34 alleles. We found that the nucleotide sequences of
dnaN5 and
dnaN34 and the phenotypes they produce were identical, both producing the G73R missense mutation. We analyzed
in vivo β clamp
G73R protein levels and found that the β clamp
G73R protein accumulated to wild-type levels at elevated temperatures. To identify amino acid residues that would restore DNA replication at elevated temperatures, we isolated three intragenic suppressors of
dnaN5(
G73R) that conferred growth of
B. subtilis cells at 49°C. Epistasis analysis and determination of the mutation spectrum showed that each
dnaN allele isolated in this study caused an MMR-dependent increase in mutation frequency. Additionally, we found that the β clamp binding protein YabA can reduce the efficiency of MMR
in vivo when
yabA expression is induced. Thus, we have identified residues in the β clamp that are critical for DNA replication and MMR in
B. subtilis. We also found that a β clamp binding protein, YabA, can reduce the efficiency of MMR
in vivo.
相似文献