Functional analysis of cloned macrophage hybridomas. IV. Induction and inhibition of mixed lymphocyte responses

A series of macrophage (M phi) hybridomas were generated by fusion of drug-marked P388D1 (H-2d) tumor cells with CKB (H-2k) splenic adherent cells. The ability of this panel of cloned M phi hybridomas expressing various levels of surface Ia antigens to induce allogeneic mixed lymphocytes responses (MLR) was examined. All MLR stimulatory M phi hybridomas expressed surface Ia antigens. However, some Ia+ and all Ia- M phi hybridomas were unable to induce vigorous MLR responses. Furthermore, even after induction of surface Ia antigen expression with Con A supernatants (Con A Sn) or purified interferon-gamma, the nonstimulatory M phi hybridomas remained ineffective at inducing strong MLR proliferative responses. Furthermore, addition of the latter M phi hybridoma clones (both with and without Con A Sn treatment) to conventional MLR cultures resulted in inhibition of MLR responses. The series of inhibitory M phi hybridomas secreted normal levels of IL 1 upon stimulation with lipopolysaccharide. After surface Ia induction with Con A Sn, the inhibitory M phi hybridomas could stimulate secretion of IL 2 and expression of IL 2 receptors. Moreover, although they inhibited conventional MLR responses, IL 2 production and IL 2 receptor expression were not significantly inhibited. Addition of these M phi hybridomas 24 to 48 hr after initiation of MLR response also inhibited MLR proliferation. The results indicated that the group of inhibitory M phi hybridomas can inhibit MLR responses after IL 2 secretion and acquisition of IL 2 receptors. Finally, this inhibitory activity has been maintained during 1 yr of continuous in vitro culture, and the hybridomas represent a stable "homogeneous" subpopulation of inhibitory macrophages. Thus, the inhibitory phenotype appears to reflect arrest at a distinct differentiation stage.     

Analysis of IgG glycopeptides by alkaline borate gel filtration chromatography

A protocol for the characterization of IgG glycopeptides is described. Central to this scheme is the novel application of an alkaline borate buffer to gel filtration chromatography. The use of this buffer significantly enhances the resolution of glycopeptides. Furthermore, it results in the separation of a unique size class of glycopeptides derived from IgG secreted by murine hybridomas. Although predominantly neutral, these glycopeptides differ both qualitatively and quantitatively by lectin affinity chromatography from the other glycopeptides which are presumably derived from the Fc portion of IgG.     

Regulatory effects of human IgE-binding factors on the IgE response of rat lymphocytes

Normal human peripheral blood T cells were propagated in the presence of human interleukin 2, and activated cells were incubated with human IgE-dimer to induce IgE binding factor formation. The cells were then fused with a mutant of the human T cell line CEM. Five of the T cell hybridomas formed IgE binding factors upon incubation with human IgE-dimer. Because IgE binding factors formed by the human T cell hybridomas had affinity not only for human IgE but also for rat IgE, the biologic activities of the factors were evaluated by using antigen-primed rat mesenteric lymph node (MLN) cells. When parent T cells were propagated with crude IL 2, which contained glycosylation enhancing factor (GEF), IgE binding factors formed by all of the five hybridomas had affinity for Con A, but only a fraction of the factors bound to lentil lectin. The 60,000 and 15,000 IgE binding factors formed by two representative hybridomas, i.e., 166A2 and 166G11, selectively potentiated the IgE-forming cell response of rat MLN cells. When parent T cells were obtained by propagation with purified IL 2, which did not contain GEF, and the cells were incubated with IgE-dimer in the presence of glycosylation inhibiting factor (GIF), T cell hybridomas constructed from the cells formed IgE binding factors that lacked affinity for Con A but bound to peanut agglutinin (PNA). The 30,000 IgE binding factors formed by two of such hybridomas, 398A3 and 400G2, selectively suppressed the IgE response of rat MLN cells. It was also found that the biologic activities and carbohydrate moieties of human IgE binding factors could be switched by changing the culture conditions of the hybridomas. When the 166A2 hybridoma was cultured with human IgE in the presence of bradykinin, essentially all of the IgE binding factors that were formed by the cells bound to lentil lectin, and the factors that were formed in the presence of bradykinin exerted higher potentiating activity than those obtained in the absence of bradykinin. On the other hand, IgE binding factors formed by the same cells in the presence of GIF had affinity for PNA, and selectively suppressed the IgE response of rat MLN cells.     

Comparison of the N-linked glycopeptides of DQw1 and DR1 molecules

HLA class II molecules have been isolated from a [3H]mannose-labeled GM3104 B lymphoblastoid cell line with the phenotype DQw1, DR1. The DQw1 molecules were purified by affinity to 77-34 IgG specifically reactive with the DQw1 specificity. The DR1 molecules were separated into two subsets, DR1a (70 to 80%) and DR1b (20 to 30%), by sequential affinity to 21r5-IgG and 21w4-IgG Sepharose. The alpha- and beta-chains of [3H]mannose-labeled DQw1, DR1a, and DR1b molecules were separated by SDS-PAGE and were recovered by electrophoretic elution. The isolated chains were digested with pronase and the glycopeptides were fractionated by sequential lectin chromatography on immobilized concanavalin A (Con A), Lens culinaris (Lens), and Ricinus communis agglutinin type I (RCA). The N-linked glycopeptides derived from the alpha-chains of DQw1, DR1a, or DR1b showed similar profiles on Con A Sepharose: 45% unbound (ConA I), 25% weakly bound (ConA II), and 30% tightly bound (ConA III). The glycopeptides derived from the beta-chains of DQw1 or DR1 molecules were found almost exclusively (80%) in the fraction unbound to Con A Sepharose, with only 11% and 9% in ConA II and ConA III fractions, respectively. The observation that most of the binding to Con A is associated with the alpha-chain glycopeptides suggests that binding of membrane-associated class II molecules to that lectin must be mediated by the alpha-chains. Binding to Lens Sepharose was higher for beta-(50%) than for alpha-(15%) chain glycopeptides, suggesting that within the intact glycoproteins, the beta-chains are responsible for the interaction with Lens. The ConA I fractions derived from the alpha-chain glycopeptides of either DQw1 or DR1 molecules were separated on RCA-agarose as follows: 60% unbound, 17% retarded, and 20% bound and eluted with 0.1 M galactose. The ConA I fractions derived from the beta-chain glycopeptides of either subset of class II molecules also had a similar profile on RCA-agarose: 70% unbound, 16% retarded, and 10% bound and eluted specifically. After removal of sialic acid residues, all of the ConA I fractions of alpha- and beta-chains bound to RCA-agarose. A high degree of similarity was observed between the corresponding glycopeptides of the three subsets of class II molecules and between the complex N-linked structures of alpha- and beta-chains. Minor variations were observed between DR1a and DR1b glycopeptides which appear greater than those observed between DR1 and DQw1 glycopeptides.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

The polypeptide of immunoglobulin G influences its galactosylation in vivo

To examine the nature of the factors influencing the galactosylation pattern of the heavy chain of murine immunoglobulin G (IgG), cell fusion was performed between a myeloma (P3x63Ag8) and a hybridoma (Sp2HL/Bu) cell line which secrete different IgGs possessing structurally distinct CH2-linked oligosaccharide moieties. The glycosylation patterns of the IgGs of the parental and fused cells were studied. Pronase digestion of the purified heavy chains and subsequent end labeling with fluorescein isothiocyanate produced fluoresceinated glycopeptides which were detected and purified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Structural information was obtained by enzymatic digestion, lectin affinity chromatography, and methylation analysis. IgGs from both parental lines possessed oligosaccharide units displaying microheterogeneity based upon a common symmetrical biantennary structure terminating in beta-GlcNAc. The structures of both IgGs, however, differed in the pattern of the mono- and digalactosylated components. Clones, selected following the fusion of the parental cells, were expanded; and the individual IgGs were purified. All clones produced homodimeric IgG1 and IgG2b as well as heterodimeric IgG possessing both the gamma 1 and gamma 2b heavy chains. Analysis of the carbohydrate moieties of the gamma 1 chain from the homodimeric and heterodimeric IgGs and of the gamma 2b chain from the heterodimeric molecule demonstrates that the polypeptide structure of the heavy chain influences the terminal galactosylation of the glycan unit at the conserved site of glycosylation of IgGs.     

Mouse models of fukutin-related protein mutations show a wide range of disease phenotypes

Dystroglycanopathies are characterized by a reduction in the glycosylation of alpha-dystroglycan (α-DG). A common cause for this subset of muscular dystrophies is mutations in the gene of fukutin-related protein (FKRP). FKRP mutations have been associated with a wide spectrum of clinical severity from severe Walker–Warburg syndrome and muscle–eye–brain disease with brain and eye defects to mild limb–girdle muscular dystrophy 2I with myopathy only. To examine the affects of FKRP mutations on the severity of the disease, we have generated homozygous and compound heterozygous mouse models with human mutations in the murine FKRP gene. P448Lneo+ and E310delneo+ mutations result in severe dystrophic and embryonic lethal phenotypes, respectively. P448Lneo+/E310delneo+ compound heterozygotes exhibit brain defects and severe muscular dystrophies with near absence of α-DG glycosylation. Removal of the Neo^r cassette from the P448Lneo+ homozygous mice eliminates overt brain and eye defects, and reduces severity of dystrophic phenotypes. Furthermore, introduction of the common L276I mutation to generate transgenic L276Ineo+ homozygous and L276Ineo+/P448Lneo+ and L276Ineo+/E310delneo+ compound heterozygotes results in mice displaying milder dystrophies with reduced α-DG glycosylation and no apparent brain defects. Limited sampling and variation in functionally glycosylated α-DG levels between and within muscles may explain the difficulties in correlating FKRP expression levels with phenotype in clinics. The nature of individual mutations, expression levels and status of muscle differentiation all contribute to the phenotypic manifestation. These mutant FKRP mice are useful models for the study of disease mechanism(s) and experimental therapies.     

Presence of an antigen-specific T cell subset that forms IgE-suppressive factor and IgG-suppressive factor on antigenic stimulation

B6D2F1 mice were given three i.v. injections of ovalbumin (OA), and antigen-specific T cell clones were established from their spleen cells. One of the FcR+ T cell clones formed IgE-binding factors on incubation with OA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages. Neither soluble antigen nor macrophages alone induced factor formation. T cell hybridomas were constructed by fusion of the antigen-specific T cell clone with BW 5147 cells. Among 11 T cell hybridomas established, six clones produced IgE-binding factors on incubation with OA-pulsed BDF1 macrophages. Mouse IgE also induced the same hybridoma to form IgE-binding factors. The majority of IgE-binding factors formed by two T hybridomas and by those produced by the parent T cell clone had affinity for peanut agglutinin but for neither lentil lectin nor Con A. These hybridomas and the original T cell clone spontaneously released glycosylation-inhibiting factor, which inhibits the assembly of N-linked oligosaccharide(s) on IgE-binding factors. On antigenic stimulation, the T cell hybridomas produced both IgE-binding factors and IgG-binding factors. The IgE-binding factors consisted of three species with m.w. of 60,000, 30,000, and 15,000. Both the 60K and 15K IgE-binding factors selectively suppressed the IgE response of DNP-OA-primed rat mesenteric lymph node cells, whereas IgG-binding factors selectively suppressed the IgG response. The results indicate that antigen-primed FcR+ T cells produced IgE-suppressive factors and IgG-suppressive factors on antigenic stimulation. However, the T cell hybridomas were not committed to suppressive activity. When the hybridomas were stimulated by antigen in the presence of glycosylation-enhancing factor (GEF), the 60K, 30K, and 15K IgE-binding factors formed by the cells selectively potentiated the IgE response. IgG-binding factors formed by the cells in the presence of GEF failed to suppress the IgG response. It appears that antigen-specific FcR+ T cells regulate the antibody response through the formation of Ig-binding factors, but that the function of the cells could be switched from suppression to enhancement, depending on the environment of the cells.     

Relationship between T cell receptors and antigen-binding factors. I. Specificity of functional T cell receptors on mouse T cell hybridomas that produce antigen-binding T cell factors

Upon antigenic stimulation with OVA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages, the mouse T cell hybridoma 231F1 produced glycosylation inhibiting factor (GIF) having affinity for OVA and IgE-suppressive factors, whereas another T cell hybridoma, 12H5, cells produced OVA-binding glycosylation enhancing factor (GEF) and IgE-potentiating factor. The OVA-binding GIF from the 231F1 cells is an Ag-specific Ts cell factor, whereas OVA-binding GEF from the 12H5 cells is an Ag-specific augmenting factor. Both hybridomas express CD3 complex and functional TCR-alpha beta. Cross-linking of TCR-alpha beta or CD3 molecules on the hybridomas by anti-TCR-alpha beta mAb or anti-CD3 mAb and protein A resulted in the formation of the same factors as those obtained by the stimulation of the cells with OVA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages. It was also found that both the 231F1 cells and 12H5 cells formed IgE-binding factors upon incubation with H-2d and H-2b APC, respectively, with a synthetic peptide corresponding to residues 307-317 in the OVA molecules (P307-317). Six other synthetic peptides, including those containing the major immunogenic epitope, i.e., P323-339, failed to stimulate the hybridomas in the presence of APC. Indeed, all of the 10 T cell hybridoma clones, which could produce either OVA-binding GIF or OVA-binding GEF, responded to P307-317 and APC for the formation of IgE-binding factors. In contrast, GIF/GEF derived from six other hybridoma clones, whose TCR recognized P323-339 in the context of a MHC product, failed to bind to OVA-coupled Sepharose. The results indicate the correlation between the fine specificity of TCR and the affinity of GIF/GEF to the nominal Ag. The amino acid sequence of P307-317 suggested that TCR on the cell sources of Ag-binding factors are specific for an external structure of the Ag molecules.     

Monoclonal antibodies reacting with isotypic and/or allotypic determinants of human IgG

Mice were immunized with purified human IgG myeloma proteins and hybridomas were prepared using their spleen cells. 1817 of the hybridomas secreted anti-Ig antibodies. Several of them detected subclass-associated determinants. Eight different specificities could be distinguished. The number of hybridomas in each category were the following: 3 anti-IgG1 (1.8% of all anti-Ig clones) 5 anti-IgG2 (0.3% of all anti-Ig clones) 2 anti-IgG3 (2.5% of all anti-Ig clones) 3 anti-IgG4 (12% of all anti-Ig clones) 12 anti-IgG1, IgG2, IgG3 70 anti-IgG1, IgG2, IgG4 2 anti-IgG2, IgG4 7 anti-IgG2, IgG4 (one out of five myelomas).     

Wall mannoproteins in cells from colonial phenotypic variants of Candida albicans

Candida albicans ATCC 26555 switched at high frequency (10(-1) to 10(-3)) between several phenotypes identified by colony morphology on a defined mineral amino-acid-containing agar medium supplemented with arginine and zinc (LAZ medium). When cells taken from colonies exhibiting distinct morphologies were plated directly onto LAZ agar, spontaneous conversion to all the variant phenotypes occurred at combined frequencies of 2.1 x 10(-1) to 9.5 x 10(-3). However, when cells taken from the different colonial phenotypes were plated directly onto an undefined medium (yeast extract/peptone/dextrose; YPD medium), or first incubated in liquid YPD medium and then cloned on YPD agar, all colonies observed exhibited the same phenotype (smooth-white). When cells from the smooth-white colonies were plated as clones on LAZ agar, the original switch phenotype reappeared. These results suggest that environmental conditions such as the growth medium (and possibly the temperature) influence switching by suppressing phenotype expression, but have no effect on genotype. The variant colony morphologies also appeared to be associated with differences in the relative proportions of yeast and mycelial cells. Zymolyase digests of wall preparations obtained from cells belonging to different colonial phenotypes were analysed by SDS-PAGE. After blotting to nitrocellulose paper, the mannoproteins were stained with Concanavalin A, with a polyclonal antiserum enriched in antibodies against mycelium-specific wall components, and with a monoclonal antibody raised against a high-molecular-mass mannoprotein band (260 kDa) specific to the walls of mycelial cells. The results suggest that phenotypic switching might be associated with changes in the degree of glycosylation in high-molecular-mass mannoproteins, or in the way these mannoproteins are bound to other cell wall components.     

Phenotypic Diversity among Alleles at the PER-1 Locus of NEUROSPORA CRASSA

Comparison of 11 perithecial color mutants suggested that all were alleles at the per-1 locus but nonetheless separable into two groups because of phenotypic differences. Three of the mutant strains produced orange perithecia and black ascospores, and eight produced paler, yellow perithecia and white ascospores. Perithecial phenotype was dependent upon the genotype of the protoperithecial parent; ascospore phenotype, upon the genotype of the individual ascospore. No evidence was found that the white ascospores were due to chromosomal rearrangements. No separation of the perithecial and ascospore phenotypes by recombination was observed in a cross between one of the mutants and a per-1+ strain. However, apparent low levels of recombination in crosses between some of the mutants indicated possible genetic complexity at the per-1 locus. The phase specificity of the per-1 mutations and the possible nature and mode of expression of the orange and yellow perithecial pigments are discussed.     

N-glycosylation site mapping of human serotransferrin by serial lectin affinity chromatography, fast atom bombardment-mass spectrometry, and 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.

This report describes the N-glycosylation site mapping of human serotransferrin (h-STF). Reduced and S-carboxymethylated h-STF was digested with trypsin or chymotrypsin. Glycopeptides in the proteolytic digests were isolated by serial concanavalin A (Con A), Sambucus nigra agglutinin (SNA), and Phaseolus vulgaris leukoagglutinin (LPHA) affinity chromatography and subjected to preliminary analysis by 1H NMR spectroscopy. The glycopeptide fractions were then individually digested with N-glycanase. One part of the digest of each fraction was analyzed by fast atom bombardment-mass spectrometry (FAB-MS) to identify the peptide sequences of the glycosylation sites. The other part was used to isolate the oligosaccharide by the corresponding lectin affinity chromatography and to characterize the structures of the isolated oligosaccharides by 1H NMR spectroscopy and FAB-MS. The oligosaccharides in the Con A-bound fraction were shown to have bi-alpha(2-->6)-sialyl, diantennary structures. The SNA-bound fraction was shown to contain trisialyl, triantennary structures. Di- and triantennary oligosaccharides were found to occur on each of the two N-glycosylation sites of h-STF (Asn413 and Asn611) in the ratio of approximately 85:15. The SNA-bound glycopeptides were further fractionated by LPHA affinity chromatography. Two different oligosaccharides were characterized, namely, a trisialyl 2,4-triantennary and a trisialyl 2,6-triantennary glycan. The ratio of 2,4-triantennary vs 2,6-triantennary oligosaccharides attached to glycosylation site Asn413 was found to be approximately 5:1, whereas the two isomeric triantennary oligosaccharides were found to be attached to glycosylation site Asn611 in the ratio approximately 1:1.     

Identification of N-glycosylated proteins from the central nervous system of Drosophila melanogaster

Although the function of many glycoproteins in the nervous system of fruit flies is well understood, information about the glycosylation profile and glycan attachment sites for such proteins is scarce. In order to fill this gap and to facilitate the analysis of N-linked glycosylation in the nervous system, we have performed an extensive survey of membrane-associated glycoproteins and their N-glycosylation sites isolated from the adult Drosophila brain. Following subcellular fractionation and trypsin digestion, we used different lectin affinity chromatography steps to isolate N-glycosylated glycopeptides. We identified a total of 205 glycoproteins carrying N-linked glycans and revealed their 307 N-glycan attachment sites. The size of the resulting dataset furthermore allowed the statistical characterization of amino acid distribution around the N-linked glycosylation sites. Glycan profiles were analyzed separately for glycopeptides that were strongly and weakly bound to Concanavalin A (Con A), or that failed to bind Concanavalin A, but did bind to wheat germ agglutinin (WGA). High- or paucimannosidic glycans dominated each of the profiles, although the wheat germ agglutinin-bound glycan population was enriched in more extensively processed structures. A sialylated glycan structure was unambiguously detected in the wheat germ agglutinin-bound fraction. Despite the large amount of starting material, insufficient amount of glycopeptides was retained by the Wisteria floribunda (WFA) and Sambucus nigra columns to allow glycan or glycoprotein identification, providing further evidence that the vast majority of glycoproteins in the adult Drosophila brain carry primarily high-mannose, paucimannose, and hybrid glycans. The obtained results should facilitate future genetic and molecular approaches addressing the role of N-glycosylation in the central nervous system (CNS) of Drosophila.     

Selection and characterization of Chinese hamster ovary cells resistant to the cytotoxicity of lectins.

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells selected in a single step for resistance to the cytotoxicity of the lectin from red kidney beans (PHA) behave as authentic somatic cell mutants. The PHA-resistant (Phar) phenotype is stable in the absence of selection; its frequency in a sensitive-population is increased several-fold by mutagenesis; and it behaves recessively in somatic cell hybrids. The activity of a specific glycosyl transferase which transfers N-acetylglucosamine (GlcNAc) to terminal alpha-mannose residues is dramatically reduced (less than or equal to 5% of the activity detected in wild-type CHO cells) in several independent PhaR clones. These clones also exhibit (a) a decreased ability to bind [125I]-PHA; (b) a marked resistance to the cytotoxicity of wheat germ agglutinin (WGA), Ricin (RIC) and Lens culinaris agglutinin (LCA); (c) a 4- to 5-fold increased sensitivity to the cytoxocity of concanavalin A (Con A); (d) an increased ability to bind 125I-Con A; and (e) decreased surface galactose residues - all properties consistent with the specific loss of the GlcNAc transferase activity. The lectins WGA, RIC, LCA and Con A have also been used to select, in a single step, resistance closes from each of two complementary CHO auxitrophic lines. These lectin-resistant clones have been characterized by their ability to survive cytotoxic doses of PHA, Con A, WGA, RIC, or LCA, and 4-5 "lectin-resistance" phenotypes have been demonstrated. Complementation data is being sought by somatic cell hybridization. Preliminary results show that two phenotypically-distinct Con AR mutants are complementary in that hybrid cells formed between them exhibit wild-type sensitivity to Con A.     

Effect of transgenic expression of human alpha 1-acid glycoprotein (AGP) on the glycosylation of human and mouse AGP in various transgenic mouse sera.

The occurrence and the glycosylation of human alpha 1-acid glycoprotein (AGP) was studied in two classes of transgenic mice expressing either the A, B and B' genes (ABB'-mice) or only the A gene of human AGP (A-mice). The glycosylation of the human AGP molecules in the transgenic mouse sera was compared with the glycosylation of mouse AGP in the same animal and with human AGP in normal human serum by studying their heterogeneity in binding to concanavalin A (Con A), using crossed affino immunoelectrophoresis (CAIE) with Con A as the affinocomponent in the first dimension gel. Three to four different glycosylated fractions of human as well as mouse AGP were revealed by this method in all the transgenic mouse sera. A close relationship was apparent between the heterogeneities in Con A binding of human and mouse AGP in the same transgenic mouse. The magnitude of this so-called Con A reactivity was, however, strongly dependent on the transgenic mouse studied. Especially within the group of ABB'-mice dramatic changes in Con A reactivity were found when the human AGP genes were expressed. This indicates in the first place that the oligosaccharide chains of the human AGP molecules expressed also mouse-specific features. Secondly, and more importantly, these findings indicate that the expression of the human AGP genes affected the glycosylation process of the transgenic mouse liver. This organ is the source of the AGP forms occurring in serum. We do not know whether this effect has been caused by the introduction or the expression of the human gene(s) or by the presence of human AGP in the Golgi system or in serum.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Glycosylation profiling of immunoglobulin G (IgG) subclasses from human serum

All four subclasses of human serum IgG contain a single N-glycosylation site in the constant region of their heavy chain, which is occupied by biantennary, largely core-fucosylated and partially truncated oligosaccharides, that may carry a bisecting N-acetylglucosamine and sialic acid residues. IgG glycosylation has been shown to be altered under various physiological and pathological circumstances. IgG N-glycan profiles vary with age, and galactosylation for example is enhanced during pregnancy. Several diseases including rheumatoid arthritis are associated with a reduction in galactosylation of the IgG N-glycans. Here, we describe a robust method for the isolation of IgG subclasses using protein A (binds IgG1, IgG2, and IgG4) and protein G (binds additionally IgG3) at the 96-well plate level, which is suitable for automation. Isolated IgGs were digested with trypsin, and obtained glycopeptides were analyzed by nano-LC-MS. Glycopeptides were characterized by CID as well as electron transfer dissociation (ETD). The method provided glycosylation profiles for IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, and IgG4 and revealed distinct differences in N-glycosylation between the four IgG subclasses. The changes in galactosylation associated with rheumatoid arthritis could readily be monitored. This method is suitable for the subclass-specific analysis of IgG glycosylation from clinical samples.     

Evolvability and robustness in a complex signalling circuit

Biological systems at various levels of organisation exhibit robustness, as well as phenotypic variability or evolvability, the ability to evolve novel phenotypes. We still know very little about the relationship between robustness and phenotypic variability at levels of organisation beyond individual macromolecules, and especially for signalling circuits. Here, we examine multiple alternate topologies of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae target-of-rapamycin (TOR) signalling circuit, in order to understand the circuit's robustness and phenotypic variability. We consider each of the topological variants a genotype, a set of alternative interactions between TOR circuit components. Two genotypes are neighbours in genotype space if they can be reached from each other by a single small genetic change. Each genotype (topology) has a signalling phenotype, which we define via the concentration trajectories of key signalling molecules. We find that the circuits we study can produce almost 300 different phenotypes. The number of genotypes with a given phenotype varies very widely among these phenotypes. Some phenotypes have few associated genotypes. Others have many genotypes that form genotype networks extending far through genotype space. A minority of phenotypes accounts for the vast majority of genotypes. Importantly, we find that these phenotypes tend to have large genotype networks, greater robustness and a greater ability to produce novel phenotypes. Thus, over a broad range of phenotypic robustness, robustness facilitates phenotypic variability in our study system. Our observations show parallels to studies on macromolecules, suggesting that similar principles might govern robustness and phenotypic variability in biological systems. Our approach points a way towards mapping genotype spaces in complex circuitry, and it exposes some challenges such mapping faces.     

Production of interleukin 2, interleukin 3, and interferon by mouse T lymphocyte clones of Lyt-2+ and -2- phenotype

T lymphocyte clones were derived by stimulation of positively selected Lyt-2+ and Lyt-2- lymphocytes with Con A in an Interleukin 2 (IL 2)-enriched medium under conditions of limiting dilution. Forty clones were expanded and tested, after activation by Con A, for the production of IL 2, IL 3, and interferon (IFN). Thirteen Lyt-2- clones were all co-producers of IL 2 and IL 3, and 10/13 were also producers of IFN. Twenty-seven Lyt-2+ clones were much more heterogeneous, 13 being IL 2 and IL 3 nonproducers, whereas 14 produced variable and poorly correlated amounts of IL 2 and IL 3. Three Lyt-2+ clones were observed to produce IL 2 or IL 3 alone. The majority of the Lyt-2- (10/13) and of the Lyt 2+ (21/27) clones were also producers of IFN. Exogenous IL 2 added during the activation of the Lyt-2+ by Con A did not enhance IL 3 production, whereas it did enhance IFN production by some but not all Lyt-2+ clones. Thus, among the T lymphocytes of the Lyt-2+ and -2- phenotypes there are cells capable of releasing IL 2, IL 3, and IFN. This supports the concept that these phenotypes are associated with antigen recognition rather than with cell functions, but it is apparent that the functional capacities of individual T cells, if accurately represented by their clonal progeny, are far from uniform.     

Production of T-T hybrids from T cell clones. Direct comparison between cloned T cells and T hybridoma cells derived from them

It has been assumed, without direct evidence, that T cell hybridomas and non-transformed T cell clones are both good models of normal Ag-specific T cells. To compare directly the difference in activation of cloned normal T cells and T hybridoma cells with the same TCR, cloned T hybridoma cells were obtained by fusing pre-established, myoglobin-specific, Iad-restricted T cell clones (14.5 and 9.27) with BW5147 cells. T cell clones were pre-activated with IL-2 as well as specific Ag before fusion. Cloned T hybridoma A3.4C6 was derived from Lys 140-specific and I-Ed-restricted clone 14.5. The other cloned T hybridoma, C7R14, was a fusion product of Glu 109-specific and I-Ad-restricted clone 9.27. Both T hybridomas showed the same Ag specificity and Ia restriction as the parental cloned T cells. However, C7R14 showed higher apparent affinity and broader cross-reactivity than 9.27. Clone 14.5, but not hybridoma A3.4C6, appeared to stimulate splenic cells to secrete cytokines inhibiting HT-2A cell proliferation. The most striking difference between the clones and hybridomas was that both clones, but neither of the matched hybridomas, were induced to synthesize IL-1 on stimulation with Ag. Finally, both cloned T cells and T hybridomas killed Ag-pulsed Iad-bearing B lymphoma target cells. This evidence suggests that killing function can be inherited from clones to hybridomas. However, the clones were much more efficient at killing than the hybridomas, and the hybridomas were more efficient at IL-2 production than the clones. Thus, matched pairs of clones and hybridomas differ in their capacity to mediate the two functions or may tend to be selected differently during cloning. Thus, although our results generally support the validity of T cell hybridomas as faithful models of the corresponding T cell clones, a number of subtle and not-so-subtle differences indicate that caution must be used in such an extrapolation.     

Dissecting the anti-desmoglein autoreactive B cell repertoire in pemphigus vulgaris patients

Pemphigus vulgaris (PV) encompasses two clinical phenotypes, one producing mucosal blisters and the other mucosal and skin lesions (mcPV). The mucosal blister-producing PV variant is characterized by autoantibodies against desmoglein (Dsg)3, whereas mucosal and skin lesion-producing PV is characterized by autoantibodies to Dsg3 and Dsg1. The present study was aimed at disclosing the diversity and clonality of the anti-Dsg3 response, as well as whether anti-Dsg3 B cells are Ag selected. Human-mouse heterohybridomas were generated by fusion of EBV-transformed or freshly isolated PBLs from six PV patients with mouse myeloma cells. A total of 73 anti-Dsg hybridomas (47 IgM and 26 IgG) were isolated. Over 90% are specific for both Dsg1 and Dsg3 indicating extensive cross-reactivity between these responses. V(H) gene segment use by IgM hybridomas is diverse, but is restricted among IgG hybridomas, where the majority uses one of two V(H) genes. V(L) gene segment use was diverse even among IgG hybridomas suggesting that the V(L) is less critical to defining desmoglein specificity. Additionally, the IgG hybridomas were extensively mutated and the distribution and nature of the mutations suggested that they had been Ag selected. We conclude that the potentially pathogenic IgG anti-Dsg response is restricted in V(H) use, is somatically mutated, and is Ag selected.