Structural basis of N‐end rule substrate recognition in Escherichia coli by the ClpAP adaptor protein ClpS

In Escherichia coli, the ClpAP protease, together with the adaptor protein ClpS, is responsible for the degradation of proteins bearing an amino‐terminal destabilizing amino acid (N‐degron). Here, we determined the three‐dimensional structures of ClpS in complex with three peptides, each having a different destabilizing residue—Leu, Phe or Trp—at its N terminus. All peptides, regardless of the identity of their N‐terminal residue, are bound in a surface pocket on ClpS in a stereo‐specific manner. Several highly conserved residues in this binding pocket interact directly with the backbone of the N‐degron peptide and hence are crucial for the binding of all N‐degrons. By contrast, two hydrophobic residues define the volume of the binding pocket and influence the specificity of ClpS. Taken together, our data suggest that ClpS has been optimized for the binding and delivery of N‐degrons containing an N‐terminal Phe or Leu.     

Does N‐Terminal Protein Acetylation Lead to Protein Degradation?

The N‐end rule denotes the relationship between the identity of the amino‐terminal residue of a protein and its in vivo half‐life. Since its discovery in 1986, the N‐end rule has generally been described by a defined set of rules for determining whether an amino‐terminal residue is stabilizing or not. However, recent studies are revealing that this N‐end rule (or N‐degron concept) is less straightforward than previously appreciated. For instance, it is unveiled that N‐terminal acetylation of N‐terminal residues may create a degradation signal (Ac‐degron) that promotes the degradation of target proteins. A recent high‐throughput dissection of degrons in yeast proteins amino termini intriguingly suggested that the hydrophobicity of amino‐terminal residues—but not the N‐terminal acetylation status—may be the indispensable feature of amino‐terminal degrons. Herein, these recent advances in N‐terminal acetylation and the complexity of N‐terminal degradation signals in the context of the N‐degron pathway are analyzed.     

Structure of a putative ClpS N‐end rule adaptor protein from the malaria pathogen Plasmodium falciparum

The N‐end rule pathway uses an evolutionarily conserved mechanism in bacteria and eukaryotes that marks proteins for degradation by ATP‐dependent chaperones and proteases such as the Clp chaperones and proteases. Specific N‐terminal amino acids (N‐degrons) are sufficient to target substrates for degradation. In bacteria, the ClpS adaptor binds and delivers N‐end rule substrates for their degradation upon association with the ClpA/P chaperone/protease. Here, we report the first crystal structure, solved at 2.7 Å resolution, of a eukaryotic homolog of bacterial ClpS from the malaria apicomplexan parasite Plasmodium falciparum (Pfal). Despite limited sequence identity, Plasmodium ClpS is very similar to bacterial ClpS. Akin to its bacterial orthologs, plasmodial ClpS harbors a preformed hydrophobic pocket whose geometry and chemical properties are compatible with the binding of N‐degrons. However, while the N‐degron binding pocket in bacterial ClpS structures is open and accessible, the corresponding pocket in Plasmodium ClpS is occluded by a conserved surface loop that acts as a latch. Despite the closed conformation observed in the crystal, we show that, in solution, Pfal‐ClpS binds and discriminates peptides mimicking bona fide N‐end rule substrates. The presence of an apicoplast targeting peptide suggests that Pfal‐ClpS localizes to this plastid‐like organelle characteristic of all Apicomplexa and hosting most of its Clp machinery. By analogy with the related ClpS1 from plant chloroplasts and cyanobacteria, Plasmodium ClpS likely functions in association with ClpC in the apicoplast. Our findings open new venues for the design of novel anti‐malarial drugs aimed at disrupting parasite‐specific protein quality control pathways.     

The N-end rule pathway and regulation by proteolysis

The N‐end rule relates the regulation of the in vivo half‐life of a protein to the identity of its N‐terminal residue. Degradation signals (degrons) that are targeted by the N‐end rule pathway include a set called N‐degrons. The main determinant of an N‐degron is a destabilizing N‐terminal residue of a protein. In eukaryotes, the N‐end rule pathway is a part of the ubiquitin system and consists of two branches, the Ac/N‐end rule and the Arg/N‐end rule pathways. The Ac/N‐end rule pathway targets proteins containing N^α‐terminally acetylated (Nt‐acetylated) residues. The Arg/N‐end rule pathway recognizes unacetylated N‐terminal residues and involves N‐terminal arginylation. Together, these branches target for degradation a majority of cellular proteins. For example, more than 80% of human proteins are cotranslationally Nt‐acetylated. Thus, most proteins harbor a specific degradation signal, termed ^AcN‐degron, from the moment of their birth. Specific N‐end rule pathways are also present in prokaryotes and in mitochondria. Enzymes that produce N‐degrons include methionine‐aminopeptidases, caspases, calpains, Nt‐acetylases, Nt‐amidases, arginyl‐transferases, and leucyl‐transferases. Regulated degradation of specific proteins by the N‐end rule pathway mediates a legion of physiological functions, including the sensing of heme, oxygen, and nitric oxide; selective elimination of misfolded proteins; the regulation of DNA repair, segregation, and condensation; the signaling by G proteins; the regulation of peptide import, fat metabolism, viral and bacterial infections, apoptosis, meiosis, spermatogenesis, neurogenesis, and cardiovascular development; and the functioning of adult organs, including the pancreas and the brain. Discovered 25 years ago, this pathway continues to be a fount of biological insights.     

Structure and evolutionary conservation of the plant N‐end rule pathway

The N‐end rule relates the in vivo half‐life of a protein to the identity of its N‐terminal amino acid residue. While some N‐terminal residues result in metabolically stable proteins, other, so‐called destabilizing residues, lead to rapid protein turnover. The N‐end rule pathway, which mediates the recognition and degradation of proteins with N‐terminal destabilizing residues, is present in all organisms examined, including prokaryotes. This protein degradation pathway has a hierarchical organization in which some N‐terminal residues, called primary destabilizing residues, are directly recognized by specific ubiquitin ligases. Other destabilizing residues, termed secondary and tertiary destabilizing residues, require modifications before the corresponding proteins can be targeted for degradation by ubiquitin ligases. In eukaryotes, the N‐end rule pathway is a part of the ubiquitin/proteasome system and is known to play essential roles in a broad range of biological processes in fungi, animals and plants. While the structure of the N‐end rule pathway has been extensively studied in yeast and mammals, knowledge of its organization in plants is limited. Using both tobacco and Arabidopsis, we identified the complete sets destabilizing and stabilizing N‐terminal residues. We also characterized the hierarchical organization of the plant N‐end rule by identifying and determining the specificity of two distinct N‐terminal amidohydrolases (Nt‐amidases) of Arabidopsis that are essential for the destabilizing activity of the tertiary destabilizing residues Asn and Gln. Our results indicate that both the N‐end rule itself and mechanistic aspects of the N‐end rule pathway in angiosperms are very similar to those of mammals.     

Efficient protein depletion by genetically controlled deprotection of a dormant N‐degron

Methods that allow for the manipulation of genes or their products have been highly fruitful for biomedical research. Here, we describe a method that allows the control of protein abundance by a genetically encoded regulatory system. We developed a dormant N‐degron that can be attached to the N‐terminus of a protein of interest. Upon expression of a site‐specific protease, the dormant N‐degron becomes deprotected. The N‐degron then targets itself and the attached protein for rapid proteasomal degradation through the N‐end rule pathway. We use an optimized tobacco etch virus (TEV) protease variant combined with selective target binding to achieve complete and rapid deprotection of the N‐degron‐tagged proteins. This method, termed TEV protease induced protein inactivation (TIPI) of TIPI‐degron (TDeg) modified target proteins is fast, reversible, and applicable to a broad range of proteins. TIPI of yeast proteins essential for vegetative growth causes phenotypes that are close to deletion mutants. The features of the TIPI system make it a versatile tool to study protein function in eukaryotes and to create new modules for synthetic or systems biology.     

The bacterial N‐end rule pathway: expect the unexpected

The N‐end rule pathway is a highly conserved process that operates in many different organisms. It relates the metabolic stability of a protein to its N‐terminal amino acid. Consequently, amino acids are described as either ‘stabilizing’ or ‘destabilizing’. Destabilizing residues are organized into three hierarchical levels: primary, secondary, and in eukaryotes – tertiary. Secondary and tertiary destabilizing residues act as signals for the post‐translational modification of the target protein, ultimately resulting in the attachment of a primary destabilizing residue to the N‐terminus of the protein. Regardless of their origin, proteins containing N‐terminal primary destabilizing residues are recognized by a key component of the pathway. In prokaryotes, the recognition component is a specialized adaptor protein, known as ClpS, which delivers target proteins directly to the ClpAP protease for degradation. In contrast, eukaryotes use a family of E3 ligases, known as UBRs, to recognize and ubiquitylate their substrates resulting in their turnover by the 26S proteasome. While the physiological role of the N‐end rule pathway is largely understood in eukaryotes, progress on the bacterial pathway has been slow. However, new interest in this area of research has invigorated several recent advances, unlocking some of the secrets of this unique proteolytic pathway in prokaryotes.     

ClpS is the recognition component for Escherichia coli substrates of the N-end rule degradation pathway

The N-end rule degradation pathway states that the half-life of a protein is determined by the nature of its N-terminal residue. In Escherichia coli the adaptor protein ClpS directly interacts with destabilizing N-terminal residues and transfers them to the ClpA/ClpP proteolytic complex for degradation. The crucial role of ClpS in N-end rule degradation is currently under debate, since ClpA/ClpP was shown to process selected N-terminal degrons harbouring destabilizing residues in the absence of ClpS. Here, we investigated the contribution of ClpS to N-end rule degradation by two approaches. First, we performed a systematic mutagenesis of selected N-degron model substrates, demonstrating that ClpS but not ClpA specifically senses the nature of N-terminal residues. Second, we identified two natural N-end rule substrates of E. coli : Dps and PATase (YgjG). The in vivo degradation of both proteins strictly relied on ClpS, thereby establishing the function of ClpS as the essential discriminator of the E. coli N-end rule pathway.     

Structural basis for the N‐degron specificity of ClpS1 from Arabidopsis thaliana

The N‐degron pathway determines the half‐life of proteins in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes by precisely recognizing the N‐terminal residue (N‐degron) of substrates. ClpS proteins from bacteria bind to substrates containing hydrophobic N‐degrons (Leu, Phe, Tyr, and Trp) and deliver them to the caseinolytic protease system ClpAP. This mechanism is preserved in organelles such as mitochondria and chloroplasts. Bacterial ClpS adaptors bind preferentially to Leu and Phe N‐degrons; however, ClpS1 from Arabidopsis thaliana (AtClpS1) shows a difference in that it binds strongly to Phe and Trp N‐degrons and only weakly to Leu. This difference in behavior cannot be explained without structural information due to the high sequence homology between bacterial and plant ClpS proteins. Here, we report the structure of AtClpS1 at 2.0 Å resolution in the presence of a bound N‐degron. The key determinants for α‐amino group recognition are conserved among all ClpS proteins, but the α3‐helix of eukaryotic AtClpS1 is significantly shortened, and consequently, a loop forming a pocket for the N‐degron is moved slightly outward to enlarge the pocket. In addition, amino acid replacement from Val to Ala causes a reduction in hydrophobic interactions with Leu N‐degron. A combination of the fine‐tuned hydrophobic residues in the pocket and the basic gatekeeper at the entrance of the pocket controls the N‐degron selectivity of the plant ClpS protein.     

Recognition of gluconeogenic enzymes; Icl1, Fbp1, and Mdh2 by Gid4 ligase: A molecular docking study

The pro/N‐degron pathway is an evolved protein degradation pathway through the ubiquitin‐proteasome system. It is a vital pathway to attain protein homeostasis inside the liver cells with varying glucose levels. N‐terminal proline exists in more than 300 proteins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, but only three of them are the gluconeogenic enzymes; isocitrate lyase (Icl1), fructose‐1,6‐bisphosphatase (Fbp1), and malate dehydrogenase (Mdh2). The present in silico study aims to structurally illustrate the binding of Icl1 enzyme to Gid4 ligase concerning its peers; Fbp1 and Mdh2. Based on the molecular docking scores and interactions, one can attribute the binding stability of Gid4 with degrons, to peptides of length six up to eight from the N‐terminal. Moreover, the percent change in the docking score provides a rationale for the unique Gid4‐Icl1^1‐4 interaction. The present study provides insights on the binding attitude of Gid4 ligase to degrons of different lengths, so one will consider in designing peptidomimetics to target Gid4 ligase.     

A cleavable self‐assembling tag strategy for preparing proteins and peptides with an authentic N‐terminus

Recombinant protein expression and purification remains a central need for biotechnology. Herein, the authors report a streamlined protein and peptide purification strategy using short self‐assembling peptides and a C‐terminal cleavage intein. In this strategy, the fusion protein is first expressed as an aggregate induced by the self‐assembling peptide. Upon simple separation, the target protein or peptide with an authentic N‐terminus is then released in the solution by intein‐mediated cleavage. Different combinations of four self‐assembling peptides (ELK16, L₆KD, FK and FR) with three inteins (Sce VMA, Mtu ΔI‐CM and Ssp DnaB) were explored. One protein and two peptides were used as model polypeptides to test the strategy. The intein Mtu ΔI‐CM, which has pH‐shift inducible cleavage, was found to work well with three self‐assembling peptides (L₆KD, FR, FK). Using this intein gave a yield of protein or peptide comparable with that from other more established strategies, such as the Trx‐strategy, but in a simpler and more economical way. This strategy provides a simple and efficient method by which to prepare proteins and peptides with an authentic N‐terminus, which is especially effective for peptides of 30‐100 amino acids in length that are typically unstable and susceptible to degradation in Escherichia coli.     

An Approach to Incorporate Multi‐Enzyme Digestion into C‐TAILS for C‐Terminomics Studies

Protein C‐termini study is still a challenging task and far behind its counterpart, N‐termini study. MS based C‐terminomics study is often hampered by the low ionization efficiency of C‐terminal peptides and the lack of efficient enrichment methods. We previously optimized the C‐terminal amine‐based isotope labeling of substrates (C‐TAILS) method and identified 369 genuine protein C‐termini in Escherichia coli. A key limitation of C‐TAILS is that the prior protection of amines and carboxylic groups at protein level makes Arg‐C as the only specific enzyme in practice. Herein, we report an approach combining multi‐enzyme digestion and C‐TAILS, which significantly increases the identification rate of C‐terminal peptides and consequently improves the applicability of C‐TAILS in biological studies. We carry out a systematic study and confirm that the omission of the prior amine protection at protein level has a negligible influence and allows the application of multi‐enzyme digestion. We successfully apply five different enzyme digestions to C‐TAILS, including trypsin, Arg‐C, Lys‐C, Lys‐N, and Lysarginase. As a result, we identify a total of 722 protein C‐termini in E. coli, which is at least 66% more than the results using any single enzyme. Moreover, the favored enzyme and enzyme combination are discovered. Data are available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD004275.     

Mining mammalian genomes for folding competent proteins using Tat‐dependent genetic selection in Escherichia coli

Recombinant expression of eukaryotic proteins in Escherichia coli is often limited by poor folding and solubility. To address this problem, we employed a recently developed genetic selection for protein folding and solubility based on the bacterial twin‐arginine translocation (Tat) pathway to rapidly identify properly folded recombinant proteins or soluble protein domains of mammalian origin. The coding sequences for 29 different mammalian polypeptides were cloned as sandwich fusions between an N‐terminal Tat export signal and a C‐terminal selectable marker, namely β‐lactamase. Hence, expression of the selectable marker and survival on selective media was linked to Tat export of the target mammalian protein. Since the folding quality control feature of the Tat pathway prevents export of misfolded proteins, only correctly folded fusion proteins reached the periplasm and conferred cell survival. In general, the ability to confer growth was found to relate closely to the solubility profile and molecular weight of the protein, although other features such as number of contiguous hydrophobic amino acids and cysteine content may also be important. These results highlight the capacity of Tat selection to reveal the folding potential of mammalian proteins and protein domains without the need for structural or functional information about the target protein.     

Deciphering proteolysis pathways for the error-prone DNA polymerase in cyanobacteria

Protein quality control pathways require AAA+ proteases, such as Clp and Lon. Lon protease maintains UmuD, an important component of the error-prone DNA repair polymerase (Pol V), at very low levels in E. coli. Most members of the phylum Cyanobacteria lack Lon (including the model cyanobacterium, Synechocystis sp. PCC6803), so maintenance of UmuD at low levels must employ different proteases. We demonstrate that the first 19 residues from the N-terminus of UmuD (Sug^1-19) fused to a reporter protein are adequate to trigger complete proteolysis and that mutation of a single leucine residue (L6) to aspartic acid inhibits proteolysis. This process appears to follow the N-end rule and is mediated by ClpA/P protease and the ClpS adaptor. Additionally, mutations of arginine residues in the Sug^1-19 tag suggest that the ClpX/P pathway also plays a role in proteolysis. We propose that there is a dual degron at the N-terminus of the UmuD protein in Synechocystis sp. PCC6803, which is distinct from the degron required for degradation of UmuD in E. coli. The use of two proteolysis pathways to tune levels of UmuD might reflect how a photosynthetic organism responds to multiple environmental stressors.     

Identification of protein stability determinants in chloroplasts

Although chloroplast protein stability has long been recognised as a major level of post‐translational regulation in photosynthesis and gene expression, the factors determining protein stability in plastids are largely unknown. Here, we have identified stability determinants in vivo by producing plants with transgenic chloroplasts that express a reporter protein whose N‐ and C‐termini were systematically modified. We found that major stability determinants are located in the N‐terminus. Moreover, testing of all 20 amino acids in the position after the initiator methionine revealed strong differences in protein stability and indicated an important role of the penultimate N‐terminal amino acid residue in determining the protein half life. We propose that the stability of plastid proteins is largely determined by three factors: (i) the action of methionine aminopeptidase (the enzyme that removes the initiator methionine and exposes the penultimate N‐terminal amino acid residue), (ii) an N‐end rule‐like protein degradation pathway, and (iii) additional sequence determinants in the N‐terminal region.     

Crystal structure of the Legionella pneumophila Lpg2936 in complex with the cofactor S‐adenosyl‐L‐methionine reveals novel insights into the mechanism of RsmE family methyltransferases

The methylation of U1498 located in the 16S ribosomal RNA of Escherichia coli is an important modification affecting ribosomal activity. RsmE methyltransferases methylate specifically this position in a mechanism that requires an S‐adenosyl‐L‐methionine (AdoMet) molecule as cofactor. Here we report the structure of Apo and AdoMet‐bound Lpg2936 from Legionella pneumophila at 1.5 and 2.3 Å, respectively. The protein comprises an N‐terminal PUA domain and a C‐terminal SPOUT domain. The latter is responsible for protein dimerization and cofactor binding. Comparison with similar structures suggests that Lpg2936 is an RsmE‐like enzyme that can target the equivalent of U1498 in the L. pneumophila ribosomal RNA, thereby potentially enhancing ribosomal activity during infection‐mediated effector production. The multiple copies of the enzyme found in both structures reveal a flexible conformation of the bound AdoMet ligand. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements suggest an asymmetric two site binding mode. Our results therefore also provide unprecedented insights into AdoMet/RsmE interaction, furthering our understanding of the RsmE catalytic mechanism.     

New roles for old modifications: Emerging roles of N‐terminal post‐translational modifications in development and disease

The importance of internal post‐translational modification (PTM) in protein signaling and function has long been known and appreciated. However, the significance of the same PTMs on the alpha amino group of N‐terminal amino acids has been comparatively understudied. Historically considered static regulators of protein stability, additional functional roles for N‐terminal PTMs are now beginning to be elucidated. New findings show that N‐terminal methylation, along with N‐terminal acetylation, is an important regulatory modification with significant roles in development and disease progression. There are also emerging studies on the enzymology and functional roles of N‐terminal ubiquitylation and N‐terminal propionylation. Here, will discuss the recent advances in the functional studies of N‐terminal PTMs, recount the new N‐terminal PTMs being identified, and briefly examine the possibility of dynamic N‐terminal PTM exchange.